Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 504 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.167 of 2023

Jaseeba v. Noushad

This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by a Division Bench comprising Justices Anil K. Narendran and P. G. Ajithkumar, reviews an O.P.(FC) No.167 of 2023 filed by Jaseeba challenging Ext.P3, the Family Court, Kunnamkulam’s interim custody order in I.A.8/2022 in GOP No.846/2023, which granted the respondent father interim custody of the child, Fasalur Farisa, aged about five years. The matter was heard after notice and counselling directives; both parties and the child were interviewed by the bench, and the Family Counselling Centre report was considered. The petitioner contended that granting overnight or extended custody to the respondent would jeopardize the child’s health and education, pointing to alleged superstitions, black-magic associations, and threats of criminal action; she argued such custody would lead to harm to the child’s welfare. The respondent argued the child requires parental care and interaction, especially from the father, and highlighted the child’s comfort with him in counselling. The bench relied on Rosy Jacob v. Jacob A. Chakramakkal, Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan, and Vasudha Sethi v. Kiran Bhaskar to emphasize welfare of the child as paramount and the need to preserve contact with both parents. Observing lack of substantiation for superstition claims, the court modified Ext.P3 and ordered interim custody to the father on specified days (Onam/Christmas holidays and certain weeks) with visitation rights, disposing of the petition accordingly, while safeguarding the counselling report.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 3526 of 2015

M.A.C.A No. 3526 of 2015

M.A.C.A No.3526 of 2015 concerns an appeal by the legal heirs of Ratheesh challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kollam's award in O.P.(M.V) No.1157/2007 arising from a motor accident dated 04.04.2007. The incident involved a KSRTC bus and an ambulance; following initial treatment, the deceased Ratheesh, a 28-year-old police constable, died on 05.04.2007. The Tribunal held negligence on both the KSRTC bus driver and the ambulance driver, imposing liability equally and awarding Rs.6,14,000 as compensation, with the appellants seeking enhancement. The appellants argued that post‑death pay revisions should be reflected in the income basis for dependency calculations, citing Annexure A1 showing a salary of Rs.33,382 in 2016, and asking for the standard 50% addition for future prospects to be applied, rather than the deceased’s actual pre‑death salary. The respondents urged adherence to established guidelines (Sarla Verma and Pranay Sethi), and maintained that pay revisions after death cannot be used to derive the deceased’s earnings. The High Court, while acknowledging the principles in Sarla Verma, Pranay Sethi, and Simi v. Brothers Carriers Pvt. Ltd., rejected the Annexure A1 argument as posthumous, declining to rely on pay revisions occurring after death. It recalculated compensation with a 50% future prospects addition, a 17-year multiplier, and 50% deduction for personal expenses, resulting in an additional Rs.5,89,960 and adjusting losses of consortium, funeral expenses, and related heads; the appeal is allowed and the award modified accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.P NO.1741 OF 2013

Mohanan v. State of Kerala

Mohanan, the revision petitioner, was convicted under Sections 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act for possession and sale of four litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor on 05.08.2007 at Nediyavila, Kollam. The trial court awarded sentences of one year imprisonment and Rs 1,00,000 fine under 55(a) with a default term, and one year imprisonment and Rs 1,00,000 fine under 55(i) with a default term. The Appellate Court (Adhoc-II Kollam) partly set aside the 55(a) conviction but upheld the 55(i) conviction, prompting this revision petition. The defense contends that the accused ran a provision store and reared cows; there is no credible proof of sale to customers; PW1 and PW2 admitted not witnessing actual sale, and the entire prosecution case is tainted by enmity. The petitioner asserts procedural defects—Ext P1 seizure mahazar does not specify the seal’s nature; Ext P11 inventory under Section 53A was not certified by an authorized officer; countersignature lacks date; the certification by a Judicial Magistrate rather than an Executive Magistrate; and unexplained delays in chemical analysis and investigation under Section 50 Abkari Act. The High Court, noting these irregularities and doubts, follows Bhaskaran K. v. State of Kerala (2020 KHC 5296) and related authorities, finds the evidence insufficient to sustain a conviction under 55(i), and accordingly sets aside the conviction and acquits the petitioner, with bail cancelled and liberty granted.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P. No. 3684 of 2008

Kusan, S/o Kuttan Amalloor Kara

This is a criminal revision petition by Kusan, the accused in S.C. No. 249 of 2001, challenging a conviction under Section 8(1) and (2) of the Abkari Act. On 25 June 1999, CW1 and his party on patrol observed the accused transporting 2 litres of illicit arrack in contravention of the Abkari Act and thus charged him with the offence. The trial court convicted him and imposed two years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with an additional six months’ imprisonment in default of payment; set-off was allowed. An appeal before the Addl. Sessions Judge, Pathanamthitta, was dismissed, upholding the conviction and sentence. The revision petitioner contends, among other things, that Ext.P2 (seizure mahazar) does not show a specimen seal or its description, and Ext.P6 forwarding note omits the specimen seal and the guard’s name, casting doubt on the tamper-proof chain of custody. The court reviews strict statutory formalities under the Abkari Act, citing Baburaj v. State of Kerala and Sathi v. State of Kerala to emphasize that regularity of official acts cannot be presumed if the necessary safeguards are not shown. In light of the accumulated precedents, including Vijayan, Nadarajan, Gopalan, Prakasan, Ramachandran, Mookedath Sivadasan and Kumaran, the court finds a failure to establish a tamper-proof link from seizure to laboratory analysis, acquitting the petitioner. The revision petition is allowed, the conviction and sentence set aside, and the accused acquitted; bail bonds are cancelled and the accused is discharged forthwith with refunds as applicable.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12142 of 2023

Aswin P P v Sub Registrar, Chelannur; District Registrar, Kozhikode; Inspector General of Registration; State of Kerala

The petition, filed by Indian citizen Aswin P P, seeks to compel registration of his proposed marriage to Estrella Joy Guadalupe Poblador, a Philippine national, under the Special Marriage Act, 1954. The petitioner contends that the foreign national’s lack of a bachelorhood/single status certificate should not bar registration, and that the couple has complied with all applicable formalities, including certificates from the Philippines. The respondents contend that registration of marriages with foreign nationals requires a bachelorhood certificate or equivalent status proof from the foreign embassy, and rely on circulars to insist upon an NOC and bachelorhood certificate from the foreign country before solemnisation. The court recalls Joel K Yoyakkim v. Sub Registrar (Marriage Officer) Pampady and others, which discussed single-status proof when embassies do not issue certificates, and notes that the foreign partner’s lack of an embassy certificate can be mitigated by declarations or apostilled documents. It finds that the embassy may not issue such certificates in this case, and that refusing registration would amount to grave injustice. Accordingly, Ext.P12 is quashed, and the court directs the first respondent to register the marriage under the Special Marriage Act upon receipt of Exts. P8, P9 declarations and upon other conditions being satisfied, including an affidavit asserting no disqualification and other formalities.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No.575 of 2017 (H)

M.V.Geetha and others v. M.V.Shery and others

This Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 575 of 2017) arises from a partition dispute in which a preliminary decree directed partition of 6.5 acres into seven equal shares by metes and bounds. The final decree allegedly granted an owelty amount of Rs. 27 lakhs to the mother from her due share, instead of distributing the land itself. The appellants challenge the trial court’s approach, contending that substituting money for property in a partition contradicts the basic concept of partition by metes and bounds, except where owelty or moiety is allowed. The judgment clarifies that, generally, money cannot replace landed property in partition, and owelty is a practical mechanism to compensate a co-sharer when equal division is not feasible while preserving the intrinsic value of the land. Owelty must reflect the actual value and should not simply be the cash equivalent of a share; it is intended to adjust inequality without destroying the property’s value. The court discusses Sections 2 and 3 of The Partition Act, 1893, highlighting that sale under Section 2 requires specific preconditions and that moiety or owelty are circumstances bounded by those sections. A reference is made to Badri Narain Prasad Choudhary v. Nil Ratan Sarkar to emphasize the sine qua non for sale (public sale) under Section 2. The High Court sets aside the final decree, remands the matter to the trial court for a proper decree under the law, and notes potential injustice in the Rs.27 lakh owelty. Instructions for appearance are issued for 12/10/2021.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C).1171/21

Anoop Unnikrishnan & M/s Innovus Energies & Anupama Balaram & Rajesh S. Nair v. Johnson Stephen & M/s MCEES Trading and other corporate respondents (KSEB? Kerala High Court, OP(C).1171/21)

The petition challenges Exhibit P5, an interim order of the Principal Sub Court (Commercial Court), Ernakulam, freezing bank accounts of the petitioners and directing them to maintain status quo pending arbitration. The 1st petitioner and respondents were partners in the firm MCEES Trading; dissolution notices and a dispute led the 1st respondent to file CMA (Arb) No. 766 of 2020 under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which was dismissed. The High Court’s interim order directed inaction to preserve assets; Arbitration proceedings were later initiated with Justice (Retd.) Thomas P. Joseph as arbitrator. On 11 July 2021, the 1st respondent filed CMA (Arb) No. 321 of 2021 under Section 9 seeking interim relief and freezing of accounts, which led to Exhibit P5 granting the injunction. The petition argues that after the Arbitral Tribunal’s constitution, Section 9(1) relief requires showing that Section 17 remedy is not efficacious, a proposition supported by Ashraf M. v. Kasim V.K.; and that freezing the 2nd petitioner’s benami interests is improper and beyond the 9(1) remedy. The respondents defend maintainability under Section 9 and the necessity to safeguard assets amid arbitration; the High Court ultimately refrains from interfering with the order and dismisses the petition, upholding the status quo until final arbitration.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev.No.41 of 2016

State of Kerala v. M/s. Minar Alloys & Forgings (P) Ltd

This is an intra-State VAT revision under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act challenging the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal’s order dated 30-09-2015 in TA (VAT) No.37 of 2015. The petitioner, Deputy Commissioner (Law), Commercial Taxes, Ernakulam, on behalf of the State, challenges the inclusion of Rs. 3,01,69,858/- as part of the respondent-dealer’s sales turnover on account of a sundry creditor written off shown as Other Income in the Profit & Loss account. The assessing officer had treated this amount as suppression/escapement of turnover under Section 8 read with Section 25(1) of KVAT Act, but the Appellate Tribunal allowed the respondent to exclude this entry from turnover, holding that the Department had not discharged its onus to prove that the entry represented sales. The Tribunal relied on a Supreme Court decision (Giridharilal Nannelal v. Sales Tax Commissioner) and applied the ratio therein that the burden to prove suppression lies on the Department. The petition contends that the Tribunal’s interpretation is erroneous, that remand would be futile or merely statistical, and that the Department’s evidence was inadequate. The High Court ultimately holds that the onus lies with the Department; the Tribunal’s approach is maintained and the revision petition is dismissed, affirming the Tribunal’s order.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 2650 of 2010

Ajikumar G v Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

Ajikumar G v Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., MACA No. 2650 of 2010, is a motor accident claims appeal arising from an award under OP(MV) No.730/2006 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kollam. The appellant, a headload worker who rode as a pillion on a motorcycle, sustained serious injuries when a Mini Lorry allegedly driven rashly struck him on 14 August 2005. The Tribunal held liability against the owner and insurer and awarded Rs. 77,006 with interest at 7.5% per annum. The respondents 1, 2, 4 and 5 did not contest the proceedings and were ex-parte; respondents 3 and 6 admitted the policy but disputed negligence concerning the driver. The High Court, while scrutinising quantum, relies on the Ramachandrappa principle on notional income and fixes the appellant’s monthly earnings at Rs. 5,000 rather than the claimed Rs. 7,000. It increases compensation only for two heads: loss of earnings (enhanced by Rs. 25,000 to Rs. 30,000) and bystander expenses (enhanced to Rs. 7,000 in total). The overall enhancement amounts to Rs. 28,500, with interest at 7.5% from the petition date and costs. The insurer is directed to deposit the enhanced amount within two months, and the Tribunal is to disburse the funds in accordance with law.

High Court
BAIL APPL. NO. 5214 OF 2021

Oommen K. John v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 5214 OF 2021) before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam concerning Crime No. 834 of 2021 registered with Maradu Police Station. The sole accused, Oommen K. John, is charged originally under sections 279 and 304A IPC, later altered to section 304 IPC and section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act after evidence was collected. The prosecution's case alleges that on 08.06.2021, around 12.50 p.m., the petitioner drove his car at excessive speed on National Highway, struck a scooter rider, who died shortly after, raising the possibility of culpable homicide not amounting to murder. The defense contends the incident was an accident and not a crime; seeks pre-arrest bail, arguing that custodial interrogation is not essential and that much of the investigation has already been completed (vehicle seized, preliminary materials gathered). The wife of the deceased opposes bail, claiming the driver was racing at 140 km/h, with lockdown conditions and potential influence due to his family background. The court, noting that this is a bail matter, declines to engage in a detailed fact-evaluation for trial and emphasizes the sufficiency of non-custodial investigation at this stage. It directs the petitioner to surrender on 13.10.2021, at 11 a.m., and, upon interrogation and arrest, to be released on bail subject to conditions: bond, two sureties, appearance, no tampering, surrender of license, and safety against committing offences while on bail.

High Court of Kerala
R.CREV. NO. 148 OF 2016

NABEESU and FOUSIYA v MEYANA SHEEJA and KARUNNANTAVIDA SEKHARAN

This is a Kerala High Court Rent Control Revision (R.C.Rev. No.148 of 2016) arising from eviction petitions under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The revision petitioners, Nabeesu and Fousiya (landladies), challenged the orders of the Rent Control Court, Vadakara (R.C.P. No.63 of 2010, dated 30.06.2012) and the Rent Control Appellate Authority (R.C.A. No.191 of 2012, dated 21.10.2015) disallowing eviction under Section 11(3) and 11(4)(i). They allege that the first respondent-tenant sublet to the second respondent and that the tenant does not conduct any business in the petition schedule room; the husband of the first petitioner intends to run a grocery shop thereon. The tenant contends she runs a tailoring business with her father-in-law, and cites difficulty in obtaining a local license due to lack of consent from the landladies. Evidence consisted of PWs and Exts A1–A7 for landladies and RW1 with Exts B1–B4 for the tenant; the court relies on the long-pending nature of proceedings and statutory mechanisms to reassess. The apex issues are whether the first proviso to 11(3) bars eviction, and whether the second proviso shield is met. The court remands to determine the applicability of the first proviso, while upholding the genuine need and denying the tenant’s second-proviso defense. The matter is directed to be heard again with admissible evidence within three months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.2643OF2023

Ashwanth N., Vivek U., and Sujay A. v. State of Kerala, Station House Officer, Mayyil Police Station, Kannur, and Sanjay K.

This criminal miscellaneous petition under section 482 CrPC seeks quashing of Crime No.211/2023 at Mayyil Police Station, Kannur. The petitioners—accused Nos. 1 to 3—are charged under IPC sections 341, 323, 324, 326 read with 34. The prosecution alleges that on 04.03.2023, at about 11:30 hours, the accused intercepted the de facto complainant and assaulted him on the allegation that the informant was maintaining a relationship with the sister of the first accused, in furtherance of their common intention. The petition contends that the parties have arrived at an amicable settlement, supported by Annexure-A2, and they are not desirous of pursuing the prosecution; recording the settlement would allow them to move forward peacefully. The court directed the investigating officer to record the informant’s statement and verify the genuineness of the settlement and whether the petitioners have any criminal antecedents that would impede termination. The Public Prosecutor raised concerns about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but noted no other transgressions against the petitioners. Relying on a line of Supreme Court precedents (e.g., State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Shambhu Kewat; Deepak; Manish; Ramesh Kamath; Rajveer Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; Kalyan Singh; Dhruv Gurjar), the court held that CrPC 482 powers may be exercised where the offence is of a predominantly civil/private character and the dispute is resolved, with exceptions for heinous/serious offences or offences under special statutes. After weighing gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the nature of the relationship, the court concluded that quashing would not harm society and would serve ends of justice. Resultantly, the petition was allowed and the FIR and all further proceedings were quashed.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos. 945 of 2012; 1047 of 2012; 1079 of 2012

MACA Nos. 945 of 2012; 1047 of 2012; and 1079 of 2012 (National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Leelamma John; LiJu John Mathew; Liji Rachel John; Suresh Babu; Madhu)

These consolidated Motor Accident Claims Appeals arise from a 2002 road accident in Pathanamthitta involving a Tata Sumo. The Tribunal awarded compensation for Liju John Mathew (OP(MV) No.331/2003) for injuries and for the legal heirs of Mathai John (OP(MV) No.332/2003) for death. The National Insurance Company Limited (NIC) challenged the awards, while the appellants challenged the quantum for disability and death. The High Court, with consent of parties, admits the appeals and disposes of them together, noting the事故's common facts. The court scrutinizes heads of compensation: notional income, disability percentage, multiplier, future prospects, and various heads like Pain and Suffering, Loss of Amenities, Bystander Expenses, Funeral Expenses, and Loss of Estate. It relies on established precedents, particularly Ramachandrappa for baseline notional income, Sarla Verma for multiplier guidance, and Pranay Sethi for ancillary heads such as Loss of Consortium and Funeral/Loss of Estate, while referencing Rajani for robust assessment in technical avocations. The court increases certain awards, revises income and multiplier, and directs payment with 7.5% interest, while also deleting Loss of Love and Affection as per United India Insurance Co. v. Satinder Kaur. The result is a partial allowed, with substantial enhancements to several heads of compensation.

High Court of Kerala
OP (FC) No. 166 of 2023

Jyothi K.R. v. Sukumaran, Devaky & Malayappan

This is a petition filed under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDV Act), read with the Family Courts Act, 1984, challenging an order (Ext.P5) dated 23 February 2023 passed by the Family Court, Thrissur, in IA No.3 of 2022 in OP No.1149 of 2018. The petitioner-wife sought reliefs under Sections 18-22 (and related reliefs) and attempted to incorporate a compensatory relief under Section 22 via amendment under Order VI Rule 7(d) CPC, arguing that the Family Court has concurrent jurisdiction to grant comprehensive relief in proceedings under the PWDV Act. The Family Court rejected the amendment, holding that Section 26 of the Act bars such reliefs in that forum, and that the Act contemplates that proceedings under the Act be governed by CPC in some respects, thus limiting the Family Court’s jurisdiction to certain reliefs. The petitioner argues, relying on Vaishali Abhimanyu Joshi v. Nanasaheb Joshi (2017 KHC 6434) and other precedents, that Section 26 must be interpreted to promote the Act’s object and permit the aggrieved person to claim relief under Sections 18-22 in appropriate forums without multiplicity of proceedings, and that there is a doctrine of election between remedies. The court ultimately holds that the plain reading of Sections 12, 18-22, and 26 allows an aggrieved person to seek such reliefs within the existing proceedings, and that the Family Court retains jurisdiction to grant reliefs under Sections 18-22 where appropriate. It quashes the Ext.P5 order, allows the amendment, and directs the petitioner to file the amendment within three weeks; the petition is thus allowed.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 51 of 2012

MACA 51 of 2012

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA 51 of 2012) filed by Ratheesh, the claimant in OP(MV) No. 8 of 2007, challenging an award of dismissal by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Tirur. The accident occurred on 20 May 2006 at about 9:30 p.m. when the KL-10/X-567 motorcycle, ridden by the first respondent in rash and negligent manner, dashed against the rear of an auto rickshaw and then knocked down the appellant who was standing by the roadside waiting for a bus. He sustained a head injury and was hospitalised for about 13 days. He claimed Rs. 1,60,000 in compensation. The Tribunal dismissed the claim, citing delay in registering the FIR and discrepancies about the place of incident, and found that the rash driving could not be established. On appeal, the High Court held that the delay in FIR, given the head injury, cannot bar the claim, and that the charge sheet constitutes prima facie evidence of negligence under S.166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The Court re-evaluates the evidence, including PW1, Exts. A1–A13, C1, C2, and police records, and finds the incident occurred at KG Padi rather than Thazhepalam, supported by robust corroboration. It recalculates compensation using notional income (Rs.5,500/month for 2006), a 3% disability, a multiplier of 18, and includes loss of earnings, transport, nourishment, clothing, bystander expenses, treatment, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities, totaling Rs.91,300. The insurer is held liable and directed to deposit the amount with interest; the appeal is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 5558 OF 2022

Sanalkumar v. State of Kerala and Others

This High Court of Kerala, in CRL.MC 5558 of 2022, heard Sanalkumar’s challenge to the continuation of proceedings in Crime No.1195/2017 (Paravoor) now CC 14/2018 (JFMC Paravur). The accused is charged with offences under IPC Sections 279, 337 and 338 and under Sections 146 read with 196 of the Motor Vehicles Act for a 27.04.2017 motor vehicle accident that allegedly injured CW1 and caused damages to CW3/CW4. The prosecution relies on the FIR (A1) and final report (A2). The petition argues that the dispute between the petitioner and respondents has been settled, supported by affidavits A3 (CW2), A4 and A5 (CW3 and CW4), with no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. The State and respondents confirm the settlement; the SHO verifies it. The court cites Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another (2012(4) KLT 108) to endorse exercise of 482 CrPC to quash private-dispute prosecutions. It distinguishes MV Act offence 146/196 by noting such offences affect the public at large and cannot be nullified solely by private settlement. Nevertheless, the court ultimately holds that continuing the prosecution would be futile, and the entire proceedings (including CC 14/2018) are quashed. The order is pronounced by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No. 2787 of 2023

Shahul Hameed v. State of Kerala

Shahul Hameed v. State of Kerala: This is a regular bail application by Shahul Hameed, the sixth accused in Crime No.1015/2022 of Infopark Police Station, Ernakulam. The prosecution alleges that on 23 December 2022, the accused criminally trespassed into the defacto complainant’s office (operating as a clinic/studio), beat staff with a hammer and a wooden stick, and forcibly obtained a signed cheque. They allegedly looted files, a laptop, treatment equipment, an i20 car (KL-40-L 3141), ATM card, gold, clothing, and other valuables to the tune of about Rs.14.8 lakh, and poured salt to misrepresent the office as MDMA-related. They allegedly photographed the defacto complainant with the seized items to intimidate him into appearing as a narcotics seller. The defacto complainant sustained peri-orbital injuries; CT scans indicated possible undisplaced fractures of the roof-medial wall of the right orbit and pneumo-orbit. The crime was registered on 25.12.2022 under IPC Sections 452, 324, 328, 395, 427 and 506(ii) read with 212. The petitioner, detained since 23.01.2023, argues that the investigation is practically over and points out that 8th accused has been granted regular bail (BA No.2121/2023). The State opposes bail, contending the offences are serious and the investigation is at an early stage. The court, after scrutiny of the records and hearing, grants regular bail with conditions: bond Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties, non-intimidation of witnesses, cooperation with investigation, appearance before the IO on Mondays for two months, no inducement or leaving India without permission, and prohibition from committing any other offence during the bail period; violation may lead to cancellation of bail.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 14171 of 2021

Shyam Raj P. v. State of Kerala and Kerala Mineral and Metals Limited and The Managing Director, Kerala Mineral and Metals Limited and B. Sundaran

This writ petition concerns a Government tender issued by KMML for mechanized collection, loading, transportation and supply of mineral sand. The petitioner Shyam Raj P. and the fourth respondent submitted e-tenders in response to the tender notice. The petitioner alleges that the fourth respondent did not affix his signature on the declaration form uploaded with the tender, a defect that, in the petitioner’s submission, should have led to rejection at the threshold. The petitioner also compares quoted amounts: his bid of Rs. 3,29,00,000 plus 18% GST versus the fourth respondent’s Rs. 3,29,90,000 with 9% GST, arguing that the 18% GST was applicable and that the lower present value of the fourth respondent’s bid is a misrepresentation intended to secure the contract. The fourth respondent counters that the omission to sign was inadvertent and that the tender, otherwise complete, should not be rejected; he also contends that even with 18% GST his price would be lower due to a 9% discount. The second respondent accepted the petitioner’s cure of the declaration form while not granting a similar cure to the fourth respondent. The court discusses two categories of tender conditions (essential vs ancillary) and examines whether the signature on all pages is an essential term. Relying on Poddar Steel, Birla International Marketing Corporation, and other authorities, the court concludes that minor, inadvertent defects may be cured and that there was no illegality in the second respondent’s conduct. The writ petition is dismissed on merits, and the Court emphasizes judicial restraint in interference with public procurement decisions under Article 226 of the Constitution.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P.No.629 of 2008

Subramanyan v. State of Kerala

On 19 October 1999, Subramanyan, the accused, was allegedly found with about 7½ litres of illicit arrack and a glass for sale near the riverbank at Thottuva Kadavu, Kodanadu village. He was charged under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The trial court convicted him and sentenced four years’ simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1,00,000, with default imprisonment for six months. The appellate court affirmed the conviction but modified the sentence to one year and Rs 1 lakh fine. In revisional jurisdiction, the Kerala High Court set aside the conviction and acquitted the accused. The court found fatal deficiencies: a 20-day unexplained delay in producing the seizure Ext.P2, absence of a specimen seal on the seizure mahazar and no forwarding note, and lack of independent chain of custody evidence showing the sample reached the laboratory in tamper-proof condition. Citing several precedents (Baburaj; Sathi; Ramachandran; Vijayan; Nadarajan; Sasidharan; State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram; Vijay Pandey; Udayan; Gopalan; Prakasan; Ramachandran 2021; Moothedath Sivadasan), the judge held that strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities and proper link between seizure, sample analysis, and accused is essential. Since these links were not established, there is reasonable doubt, and the revision petition is allowed, acquitting Subramanyan.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2541 OF 2019

Latheesh Babu P.T. and Others v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 2541 of 2019) filed by three accused (Latheesh Babu P.T., Mridula, and Sherly) challenging FIR No. 38/2019 of Thondarnadu Police Station, Waynad, and seeking quashing of all further proceedings. The de facto complainant is T.K. Thressia, who filed a complaint that led to investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. The alleged offence is under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC, based on an agreement for the sale of land (6 cents) and possession transfer. The accused received multiple instalments from the complainant but allegedly refused to execute the sale deed on the agreed date, which the complainant contends amounts to cheating. Counsel for the petitioners argued that even accepting the allegations, no offence under 420 IPC is attracted, suggesting breach of contract rather than cheating. The respondents argued that failing to execute the sale deed constitutes cheating/breach of trust. The court examined the elements of Section 420, emphasizing mens rea as an essential ingredient and noting the possession transfer prior to the alleged breach. Relying on State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (1992 Supp. (1) 335) and related jurisprudence, the court held that the FIR does not disclose an offence prima facie and that continuance of proceedings would be an abuse of process. Accordingly, the petition was allowed and the FIR and proceedings were quashed.