Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 499 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020

Hillwood Imports and Exports Pvt. Ltd.; Hillwood Furniture Pvt. Ltd.; Hillwood Timbers Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Kochi (ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020)

This batch judgment of the High Court of Kerala (Division Bench) deals with a cluster of connected ITA appeals filed by Hillwood entities challenging block assessments under the Income Tax Act framed on the basis of material seized during searches and surveys conducted in 2013–2014. The court recites the sequence: searches on 04.12.2013 at the assessee’s business premises and the MD’s residence, followed by a survey on 14.07.2014 at Riyaz’s premises, and the data recovered via three pen drives. The department relied on the data and a Hash Value Report to determine suppressed turnover and income; the Assessing Officer’s 2016-2018 orders were challenged, including the Tribunal’s dismissal of additional grounds and the admissibility of electronic records under Sections 65A/65B. The appellants argued that survey at a residence, the pen drives, and the Hash Value report were inadmissible; they sought admission of expert opinion and additional grounds. The court examines substantial questions of law concerning the legality of the survey, admissibility of evidence, and the Tribunal’s powers, ultimately upholding the Tribunal’s approach and dismissing all connected appeals with no costs order.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C.No.6371/2021

Chinnu Darwin @ Chinnu v. State of Kerala

This criminal miscellaneous case arises from an anticipatory bail order issued by the First Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam, in Cr.M.C. No.2551/2021, granting bail to the 3rd and 4th respondents in Crime No. 1384/2021 of Infopark Police Station. The de facto complainant, CHINNU DARWIN aka CHINNU, challenged the order under section 482 Cr.P.C. on 15 June 2022. The underlying crime, registered on a private complaint, alleges theft of gold ornaments valued at 20 sovereigns and other household articles from a flat leased by the 3rd respondent in Kakkanad, during 7 November 2021, while the petitioner and the 3rd respondent resided there. The case involves matrimonial discord; the petitioner questioned the ownership and custody of the items and contended the bail order would jeopardize investigation. The court below found no reason to deny anticipatory bail and granted relief, prompting this challenge. The High Court reaffirmed that its inherent 482 powers intervene only to prevent miscarriage of justice or illegal, perverse orders based on irrelevant materials, citing Puran v. Rambilas and xxxx v. State of Kerala. It concludes that the High Court can set aside perverse bail orders, but in this case the order is not perverse, and there are cogent grounds to uphold the court below’s discretion. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed and the bail order stands.

High Court of Kerala
RP Nos. 147/2023 and 155/2023

M/s Vinayaka Timber and Wood Crafts v. State of Kerala (RP Nos. 147/2023 & 155/2023)

This is a Kerala High Court review petition in two connected matters filed by M/s Vinayaka Timber and Wood Crafts, challenging orders in ST Revision Nos. 33/2019 and 34/2019 and the Amnesty-driven settlement under the Kerala Finance Act 2008. The petitioners sought to continuation of proceedings under Section 23B(7) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, arguing that ex post facto continuation of cases settled under the Amnesty scheme could preserve their rights to pursue disputes already initiated. The State opposed this, advocating adherence to the statutory framework, particularly Section 41(7)(b) of the GST Act, and contending that the Amnesty-based settlement should bar further litigation, since the essential condition is that the settled amount must have been subject matter of appeal or revision. The court undertook a careful statutory interpretation of Section 23B(7), applying the literal rule and the golden rule of interpretation, and ultimately held that the dealer cannot re-open issues settled under the Amnesty Order. The review petitions were dismissed, and the court affirmed its earlier judgment dated 22.09.2022 in ST Revision Nos.33 and 34 of 2019. The decision emphasizes that Amnesty provisions, once invoked, foreclose subsequent challenges to settled disputes, distinguishing prior precedents relied upon by the petitioner. The matter involved tax years 2000-2001 and 2001-02, with the tribunal and FAA orders set aside by earlier review but not re-opened on merits in this round.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O.No.16 of 2011

Kunjuraman Pillai and Gopinathan Pillai v. Thalavoor Thrikkanamarkode Devaswom and others

This is an appeal (F.A.O. No.16 of 2011) from an order dated 30.10.2010 passed in O.P.245 of 2010 on the file of the III Additional District Court, Kollam. The appellants, Kunjuraman Pillai and Gopinathan Pillai, challenged the district court’s dismissal of leave to institute a fresh suit seeking leave under Section 92 CPC to (i) settle or modify the scheme of the NSS Karayogams Trust, (ii) remove certain trustees, (iii) appoint new trustees, and (iv) conduct accounts from 01.01.1983. The appellants claim to be members of NSS Karayogams and beneficiaries of the Trust, and contended that the existing scheme lacks a provision enabling beneficiaries to approach the District Court for amendments, necessitating a fresh suit. Respondents argued that Ext.A1 already provides remedies and that leave to file a fresh suit is unwarranted; they urged approaching O.S.No.1 of 1976 through interlocutory petitions in the original suit to address grievances and mismanagement. The district court upheld this view, noting the scheme contains provisions to redress grievances and to prevent multiplicity of proceedings. The appellants relied on Jamia Masjid v. Sri K.V. Rudrappa (D) by LRs. (2022) 9 SCC 225 to emphasize the representative character of Section 92 suits; the High Court, however, affirmed the district court, holding there is no requirement for a fresh suit and that leave under Section 92 should be refused. The appeal is therefore dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 2433 OF 2022

OP(C) NO. 2433 OF 2022

This original petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenges Ext.P7 in E.P. No.132/2017 in O.S. No.350/2013 arising from a Lok Adalath settlement on 12.11.2015. The decree holder sought execution of a money decree; the judgment debtor (Devassykutty) contends that the attachment and subsequent sale were improper because only a portion of the 15.50 cents of property in Chowara Village needs to be sold to satisfy the award debt, given its substantial market value (claimed Rs. 5,00,000 per cent) and building value (over Rs. 60 lakhs). Ext.P7 directed the sale of the entire property, without fixing an upset price, and without addressing Ext.P3 and Ext.P6 objections. The petitioner argues that Order 21 Rule 64 CPC requires evaluating whether partial sale is feasible and that sale beyond the decretal amount is impermissible. The High Court relies on Fathima Beevi v. Joly John (2022) and Nedungadi Bank Ltd. v. Ezhimala Agrl. Products (2003) to require limiting the sale and fixing an upset price, and cites Rahul S Shah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi to emphasize disclosure of third-party interests. The court sets aside Ext.P7, directs reassessment of the extent to be sold, fixation of an upset price, and disclosure of third-party interests, with a deadline of 31.01.2023 for expeditious compliance.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.P (C) No. 806 of 2021

Tr.P (C) No. 806 of 2021

This Transfer Petition (Civil) arises from a dispute over copyright rights in Malayalam films and seeks to transfer CS 683/2021 from the Commercial Court, Kozhikode, to the Additional District Judge‑V, Ernakulam for consolidation with O.S. 41/2021 pending in Ernakulam. The petitioner, A. M. Raju, asserts that he is the plaintiff in O.S. 41/2021 and that Annexure 1 involves a prior assignment of rights in three films (Mudra, Thaniyavarthanam, Sooryamanasam) by the second respondent. Annexure 3 in CS 683/2021 is filed by the first respondent against the second respondent and others for infringement of rights, and Annexure 4 seeks interim relief. The petitioner contends that consolidation in a single forum would avoid multiplicity of proceedings and delay, as the suits involve common questions and related rights. The respondents oppose the transfer, arguing lack of balance of convenience, that the two suits arise from independent assignment agreements with different parties, and that the mere convenience of moving to Ernakulam cannot justify transfer under Sec. 24 CPC. After detailed consideration, including evidence of the Annexures and independent causes of action, the Court concludes that the suits are distinct and not amenable to consolidation. Relying on Indian Overseas Bank and TV Eachara Warrier, the Court declines the transfer and dismisses the petition. Judge: C. S. Dias, 20 June 2022.

High Court of Kerala
WA 1867 of 2022

Ahammed Shafi v. Assistant Motor Vehicle Inspector, Sub-Regional Transport Office, Thripunithura; Joint Regional Transport Office, Chembra, Tirur; State Transport Authority, represented by the Secretary, Trans Bhavan

This writ appeal challenges a government colour-code policy for contract carriages in Kerala, challenging Exhibits P5 and P6 directing compliance with a uniform colour code, and Exhibits P7 and P8 outlining the staged implementation. The appellant, Ahammed Shafi, is the registered owner of two contract carriages KL-38/H-9003 and KL-38/H-8200 with fitness certificates valid into 2024. On 29.11.2022, officers issued a CFX (Suspension of Fitness Certificate) notice for non-compliance with the colour code. Exhibit P7 (and P8) describe the colour-code regime, with implementation to commence from 01.01.2022 but to be given effect in stages, including a primary effective date of 01.06.2022. The appellant contends that colour-code enforcement should await renewal of fitness certificates, arguing the certificates are valid until 16.02.2024 and 09.01.2024 respectively, and asserts Exhibit P5/P6 are illegal. The respondents defend the policy as a reasoned, good-faith measure by the State Transport Authority to standardize vehicle aesthetics and safety, citing Covid-era concerns and a stage-wise rollout. The court references Jijith & Others v. State of Kerala (2019 (1) KHC 463) for compliance expectations and WA 1502/2022 for non-interference in similar cases, and dismisses the appeal, upholding the colour-code regime as implemented. The writ petition is thus dismissed and the impugned judgment stands.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 39229 OF 2022

P. GOPAKUMARAN NAIR v. State of Kerala and Others

P. GOPAKUMARAN NAIR, a retired Superintendent of Police, filed a public interest writ petition seeking mandamus against the State of Kerala and several State authorities, and Union of India, to take action against protesters at the Vizhinjam Port project site and to involve the National Investigation Agency (NIA) for the violence surrounding the Adani Vizhinjam Port project on 27-28 November 2022. He contends that the agitation led by the Latin Archdiocese of Thiruvananthapuram disrupted construction, attacked police, and caused extensive public property damage, while FIRs against thousands of protesters were registered without proportionate action. He sought (i) action against instigators, (ii) use of Central forces if needed, and (iii) transfer of the investigation to the NIA. The respondents argued that FIRs (Exts. P1–P3) have been registered, investigations are underway, and the Kerala Police have taken all necessary steps; invoking the NIA would be premature and unwarranted. The High Court dismissed the petition, noting that the cases involve multiple actors and that police investigations should proceed; it held that the NIA should not be invoked and that it is premature to direct action against all involved. The court stressed that identifiable offenders are being investigated and that existing High Court directions to ensure progress in construction were not to be undermined. The petition was therefore dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 2797 OF 2011

Shelvi v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition challenging the legality of a conviction for offences under sections 448 (house-trespass) and 324 (voluntary hurt) IPC, and the accompanying sentences recorded against Shelvi in the trial court, confirmed in appeal. The trial court found the accused had injured his brother during a dispute over property/title on 26.07.2002 when Panchayat officials visited to allot a house number; the appellant was convicted and sentenced to simple imprisonment with fines, and the appellate court partly upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence. During admission of the revision petition, both sides presented that the subject dispute between the revision petitioner and the de facto complainant (his brother) had been amicably settled, with the second respondent filing a notarized affidavit affirming the settlement and stating no objection to acquittal. The State did not oppose acquittal, and the matter was urged to be resolved in the interests of justice. Relying on Soban v. State of Kerala and Supreme Court precedents such as Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, along with Renjith and Bitan Singh Gupta, the High Court held that if the requirements of Section 482 Cr.P.C are satisfied, criminal proceedings involving non-compoundable offences can be quashed to prevent abuse of process and to secure ends of justice. The Court therefore exercised its plenary power, set aside the conviction and sentence, quashed all related proceedings (Crime No. 183/2002), cancelled bail bonds, and directed the release of any remitted fines to the petitioner, thereby restoring amity between the brothers.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 38724/2022

P. V. Jeevesh v Union of India and Others

This Public Interest Writ Petition (WP(C) 38724/2022) filed by advocate P. V. Jeevesh challenges the Governor of Kerala’s indefinite withholding of bills passed by the Kerala Legislative Assembly. The petitioner contends that the Governor must exercise his discretionary powers under Article 200 of the Constitution within a reasonable time and in accordance with the advice tendered by the Council of Ministers; withholding assent indeterminately disrupts democratic governance, federalism, and the functioning of the Cabinet system. The petition seeks several declarations, including striking down the phrase withholds assent therefrom, creating a time-bound framework (two months from presentation) for exercising assent, and mandamus or constitutional amendments to Articles 111/200 recommending time limits, in line with commissions such as Sarkaria, Punchhi, and the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution. The State argues Article 200 does not prescribe a fixed time for decision and the Governor may act with reasonable time, considering the solemn duty to uphold constitutionalism. The court analyzes Articles 200, 163, and 201, and cites prior Supreme Court decisions (Nabam Rebia, Shamsher Singh, Rameshwar Prasad, Indra Sawhney, A. G. Perarivalan, S. R. Bommai, etc.) to discuss the Governor’s discretion, aid-and-advice, and the limits of judicial scrutiny. Ultimately, the court declines to interfere and holds that the Governor’s discretion cannot be bound by a court-ordered time frame; the petition is dismissed. This reinforces judicial deference to constitutional processes within a federal framework.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C No. 8862 of 2022

Crl.M.C No. 8862 of 2022

This High Court of Kerala, before a single judge, deals with a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash proceedings in SC 1011/2021, arising from Crime No.780/2019 of Viyyur Police Station. Accused Nos. 1 to 24 petition for quashing the further proceedings. The petition is grounded on a private settlement between the parties, with injured victims (Nos. 2–9) swearing affidavits indicating no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, corroborates the settlement’s genuineness after verification by the SHO, who confirms that the injured parties reiterate no objection. The offences alleged include IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 308 and 506 read with Section 149, and the occurrence took place inside a college campus; none of the victims sustained serious injuries, and there are no notable criminal antecedents among the petitioners. The court faces a private dispute where continued prosecution would have bleak prospects of success, and invokes the principle articulated in Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another (2012) to exercise its 482 CrPC powers. Consequently, the petition is allowed; Annexure-1 Final Report and all further proceedings in SC 1011/2021 against the petitioners are quashed. The order notes the settlement’s validity and the lack of subsisting grievance by the injured parties.

High Court of Kerala
RP 1172/2022; RP 1196/2022

Central Board of Anglo-Indian Education v. Dalbin D'Cunha & Others; Review Petitions RP 1172/2022 & RP 1196/2022 against WP(C) 1133/2019, Kerala High Court

Two review petitions (RP 1172/2022 by the Central Board of Anglo-Indian Education and RP 1196/2022 by Patrick Livera) arise from WP(C) 1133/2019 concerning the election of office bearers of the Central Board of Anglo-Indian Education. On 13 December 2022, the Kerala High Court, presided by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V, dismissed the reviews challenging the 21 November 2022 order that directed steps to finalize the voters’ list and conduct a General Meeting for electing the Board’s Administrative Committee. The petitions argued that the Commissioner Advocate’s final voters’ list did not conform with the Board’s bye-laws (Ext.C17), as amended without Board/Registrar approval, and that the last election occurred in 2017; thus the voters’ list lacked sanctity and needed reconsideration. Respondents contended that the Court sought to give finality to the dispute and ensure elections in accordance with bye-laws, and that review petitions are not appeals and must be tightly circumscribed. Citing authorities on the scope and limits of review (Northern India Caterers, Meera Bhanja, Shivdeo Singh, Lily Thomas), the court held no valid ground for review, rejected the challenges, and upheld directions to complete the election process by 27.12.2022.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.8063 of 2019

Ratheesh V.R. v. Sujitha Jacob and State of Kerala

This is a criminal miscellane­ous case (CRL.MC No.8063 of 2019) arising from SC No.241/2010 before the IIIrd Addl. Sessions Judge, Thrissur, and Crime No.136/2019 of Viyyur Police Station, registered for offences under Sections 306 and 420 IPC. The petitioner, Ratheesh V.R., the de facto complainant, challenges an order dated 13.07.2018 in CRL.M.P.687/2017 that refused permission for further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. The prosecution contends that certain bank account printouts (CW10 and CW13) lack proper 65B certification under the Evidence Act, and seeks to obtain certification via further investigation to render the documents admissible. The respondent 1st accused had allegedly cheated the deceased, the petitioner’s brother, under the pretext of a love affair, collecting Rs.19 lakhs; the deceased allegedly committed suicide later, leaving a note implicating the accused. The High Court, after detailed discussion of authorities (Ram Lal Narang, Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi, CBI v. Pai, Rama Chaudhary, A.S. Peter, Vinay Tyagi, Arjun Khotkar, Gopalakrishnan @ Dileep, etc.), holds that: (a) 173(8) can be invoked even after charge-sheet; (b) absence of 65B certification can be cured via court-permitted further investigation; (c) the prosecution’s motive is to reach truth and ensure justice; (d) no prejudice to the accused in allowing such investigation; and (e) the Annexure-B order is set aside with directions for expeditious supplementary reporting and abeyance of further trial proceedings pending the report.

High Court of Kerala
RP 1172/2022; RP 1196/2022

Central Board of Anglo-Indian Education v Dalbin D'Cunha & Others

This is a pair of review petitions (RP Nos. 1172/2022 and 1196/2022) filed in the Kerala High Court challenging the order dated 21 November 2022 in W.P.(C.) No.1133/2019. The petitioners sought to review the Court’s directions to elect office-bearers of the Central Board of Anglo-Indian Education in terms of its bye-laws. The court had directed the Commissioner Advocate to publish the final voters list (in accordance with Ext.C17), and to convene a General Meeting with 15 days’ notice to elect board members; the entire process was to be completed by 27 December 2022. The petitioners argued that the final voters list was not in accord with the bye-laws because amendments to Ext.C17 had not been approved by the Board or Registrar of Societies; they asserted that the last election was in 2017 and the incumbent office-bearers’ term had expired, thus challenging the electorate’s validity. The respondents contended that the Court’s exercise was to settle disputes and secure elections per the bye-laws. Relying on established review principles (Order 47 Rule 1 CPC) and authorities like Lily Thomas and Shivdeo Singh, the Court found no sufficient error apparent on the record or new matter warranting review. Accordingly, both review petitions were dismissed, with directions to complete the process as ordered.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P. No.709 of 2022

K. Rafeeque v. The State of Kerala and Devassia E.K.

This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by K. Rafeeque challenging concurrent convictions for an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) arising from two dishonoured cheques issued to the complainant in relation to a ginger purchase. The trial court convicted Rafeeque and sentenced simple imprisonment till rising of the Court along with a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000 to the complainant. The Sessions Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the conviction and sentence. Rafeeque contended before the Kerala High Court that the presumption under Section 139 NI Act had been rebutted and that Ext. P1 (the cheque) was not issued for consideration; he argued that Ext. P8 (an agreement) was the sole basis for the instrument’s issuance and that the lower courts improperly re-evaluated evidence in revision. The High Court refrained from re-appreciating evidence, reiterating that revisional jurisdiction is supervisory and not appellate, citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and subsequent Supreme Court precedents (Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan, Kishan Rao, Rangappa, Bir Singh, Kalamani Tex). It affirmed the conviction and dissolution of Rafeeque’s revision but granted two months to pay the compensation, deferment of execution until 29.12.2022, and directed Rafeeque to appear on 30.12.2022 to comply, with further directions if non-compliance occurred.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 33322 OF 2016

V.ANJU v Union of India & Others (WP(C) 33322 of 2016) and connected cases

This batch of writ petitions challenges the upper age limit of 20 years introduced for admission to the Integrated Five-Year LLB Course in Kerala through Clause 28(a) of the Legal Education Rules, 2008, and the 2016 notification issued by the Commissioner of Entrance Examinations. Petitioners, including V. Anju and others across WP(C) Nos 33905/2016, 34226/2016, 34227/2016, 34233/2016, 34234/2016, 34237/2016, 34258/2016, 34261/2016, etc., had applied for admission based on prospectus provisions that did not originally impose an upper age limit. They contend that the 20-year cap was introduced after they appeared for the entrance examination and were provisionally ranked, and that altering the rules post hoc is arbitrary and violates their rights. They rely on authorities like Madras High Court’s Santhosh Antony Vareed (upholding Clause 28 in some fora) and Punjab & Haryana High Court’s Rajan Sharma line showing constitutional challenges to Clause 28, while other courts have differed. The respondents argue Clause 28 is a valid regulatory measure to standardize admissions, supported by government orders and Bar Council directions. The Court, noting conflicting authorities, stayed the government notification and permitted all candidates to participate in the selection process. It ultimately made the interim order absolute, closed the petitions, and ordered that petitioners receive certificates on successful completion, balancing equity with the course years already undertaken.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 33322 OF 2016 & Conn. cases

WP(C) NO. 33322 OF 2016 & Connected Cases

The batch of writ petitions (WP(C) 33322/2016 and connected cases) challenges the 2016 admission process for the integrated five-year LL.B course in Kerala on grounds that Clause 28(a) of the Legal Education Rules, 2008, imposes an upper age limit of 20 years for admission. Petitioners, who had appeared in the entrance examination under the notification dated 28 July 2016 and were included in the provisional rank list, contend that this upper age limit was imposed after the examination and after provisional results, rendering the change arbitrary and retroactive. They point to provisions indicating there was no upper age limit in the notification and prospectus, and allege that Bar Council of India had previously withdrawn Clause 28 in 2013, implying a change in rules after the process had started. They rely on judgments from other High Courts (Punjab & Haryana and Allahabad) declaring Clause 28 unconstitutional, contrasted with Madras High Court upholding it, and note the Supreme Court’s dismissal of related SLPs. The Kerala High Court, while acknowledging the conflicting views, stayed the Government Order dated 21 October 2016 and permitted all candidates to participate, extending a window for DOB documents. The judgment ultimately makes the interim order absolute, directing issuance of certificates upon successful completion of the course and closing the writ petitions in the interest of justice.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 39979 OF 2022

Anjana M.M v. Central Board of Secondary Education

This writ petition concerns a correction of the petitioner’s date of birth recorded in the CBSE-affiliated Nazareth School, Manjeri. The petitioner’s school records show a birth date of 25.05.1992, while the Birth Certificate issued by the Registrar of Births and Deaths (Adoor) and the Aadhar card record 19.01.1991. The petitioner approached the 1st respondent CBSE with an application for correction on 25.10.2022 (Ext.P4). The petitioner contends that Jigya Yadav v. CBSE (2021 (3) KLT 711(SC)) laid down that the Board can consider changes made to public documents to align them with public records and that the Board may impose reasonable conditions (affidavit, indemnity, fee, public notice, surrender of certificates, and possible disclaimer). Counsel for the petitioner submitted that limitation under Regulation 69.3 of the CBSE Byelaws (five years) should not bar entertainability in light of Jigya Yadav and related judicial directions, which this Court previously acknowledged but noted the byelaw amendment remains pending. The 1st respondent argued the five-year limit applies, though it did not dispute Jigya Yadav’s directions. The Court held there is merit in entertaining the petitioner's request and directed the petitioner to file a fresh application within one week, after which the 1st respondent must consider it within 30 days, in terms of Jigya Yadav and Ananthu Ashok’s guidance, with all actions to be undertaken under the Court’s order in W.P(C) 29182/2021. The petition is disposed with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.680 of 2022

O.P.(FC) No.680 of 2022: Midhun Kumar, Mohanan Pillai & Indira v. RadhaKrishnan Nair & Vijaya Lekshmi

This is an Article 227 challenge to an interim custody order in a Family Court proceeding. The petitioners – father and paternal grandparents – sought to challenge an order which granted interim custody of minor Hrithik (born 19.08.2020) to the respondents, the maternal grandparents, under a compromise recorded in IA 1/2021 in O.P.(G&W) No.1321/2021. The mother of the child had died on 29.04.2021. The Family Court, after hearing, disposed of several interlocutory applications (IA 1/21, IA 6/22, IA 7/22) by Ext. P7, which (a) set aside the compromise, and (b) granted interim custody to the respondents from 10 a.m. on Saturdays to 5 p.m. on Sundays starting 03.09.2022, with the child to be picked up/dropped at each party’s residence. The petitioners argued that a two-year-old child with pneumonia and on treatment requires stable care and that such long weekend custody is not in the child’s welfare. Citing Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan and Vasudha Sethi, the court reiterates that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration and visitation rights should be ensured when custody is altered. The High Court, noting the child’s tender age and the proximity of the respondents, finds no merit in the petition and dismisses the Original Petition, upholding Ext. P7 and the interim arrangement.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.39910 of 2022

Mohammed Musthafa v. State of Kerala

This writ petition (Civil) filed by Mohammed Musthafa challenges Ext.P8, the Tahsildar’s rejection of his Form-A application under the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961, seeking reassessment of Basic Tax in light of a Kerala Land Utilisation Order (KLU) 1957 permission to use land for non‑agricultural purposes. The petitioner owns land in Angadippuram Village, Perinthalmanna Taluk, Malappuram District (6.19 ares in Re-Survey No. 6/4-8 and 17.41 ares in Re-Survey No. 6/4-9). The predecessor had obtained permission from the Revenue Divisional Officer under Ext.P2 (Order No. K.DIS 1643/2004/M, dated 12.03.2004) to convert the land for non‑agricultural use, enabling the petitioner to secure a Building Permit and commence construction. When renewal of the permit was sought, authorities argued that revenue records still described the land as paddy land, so renewal could not be granted. The petitioner filed Form-A to reassess Basic Tax in view of Ext.P2, but Ext.P8 denied this relief. The petitioner relies on this Court’s decision in Sealand Builders Private Limited v. Revenue Divisional Officer (2020 (4) KLJ 329), which held that lands with pre‑30.12.2017 permission under the KLU Order must be treated under Clause 6(2) rather than the Paddy Land Rules, to permit tax reassessment under the Kerala Land Tax Act. The respondents emphasized the lack of authority in the KLU Order to alter land nature. Relying on Sealand Builders and Tahsildar v. Renjith George (2020 (1) KLJ 908), the court held Ext.P8 to be invalid, directed the Tahsildar (LR) to reconsider Form-A and finalize, within a month, appropriate orders reflecting the land’s current status. The petition is thus allowed.