Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 500 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 1315 of 2019

Nandhini P. and Thankam P. v. Poroli Sadanandhan and Others

This Regular Second Appeal before the Kerala High Court arises from the dismissal of O.S. No. 364/2015 by the Principal Munsiff’s Court, Kozhikode, which was affirmed on appeal by the 1st Additional District Judge, Kozhikode for non-payment of the balance court fee. The appellants, Nandhini P. and Thankam P., challenge the appellate order, claiming they had tendered the court fee but failed to file an application for enlargement of time, a bonafide omission rather than intentional default. They contend that the court should have extended the time to enable payment, especially given that one-third of the fee is payable at admission while the balance may be due within a specified period. The respondents submit that the balance fee was not paid within the fixed time and no enlargement petition was filed, justifying the dismissal. The High Court analyzes the interplay of Section 52 of the Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act, 1959 (Kerala) with Sections 148 and 149 of the CPC and Order VII Rule 11, emphasizing that court-fee matters are procedural and that courts have inherent power to extend time and cure deficiencies. Relying on State of Kerala v. Umesh Rao, KCM Ltd v. Padmanabha Pillai, and Elizabeth v. Francis, the court finds fault with the impugned order for not clarifying whether time for payment was fixed and whether enlargement could be permitted. Consequently, the appeal is allowed, the impugned order is set aside, and the case is remanded to the 1st Additional District Court, Kozhikode for fresh consideration, with directions to entertain proper enlargement applications if applicable.

High Court of Kerala
FAO NO. 148 OF 2022

Sri Beeran Kutty Moozhikkal v. Nimil K.K

This appeal from an order of injunction concerns an underwater glass tunnel aquarium designed for exhibition. The plaintiff, Nimil K.K., owner of M/S NIEL Entertainment, claims the defendant Beeron Kutty Moozhikkal infringed a design and possibly copyright by constructing a glass tunnel filled with water, fish and weeds in an identical format. The trial court had granted an interim injunction restraining the defendant from using the tunnel, prompting the present FAO before the Kerala High Court. The crucial questions centered on what constitutes a ‘design’ under the Designs Act, what amounts to copyright or infringement, the overlap between the two regimes, and which court has jurisdiction. The court examined Section 22 of the Designs Act (piracy of registered design) and Section 15 of the Copyright Act (special provisions regarding copyright in designs capable of registration), along with Sections 14 and 19, to delineate the scope of protection. It relied on prior decisions, including FAO No.151/2019, Microfibres Inc. v. Girdhar & Co., and Bharat Glass Tube Ltd. v. Gopal Glass Works Ltd, to discuss, but ultimately found these authorities insufficient to sustain a conclusion that the present case involves an artistic work or a protectable copyright. The High Court remanded the matter to the trial court for fresh consideration, held that the injunction should stand vacated till then, and allowed the appeal with no costs, noting the need for cautious use of interim relief in IP matters.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 37464 OF 2018

Jayan P.K v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation and Others

Jayan P.K., employed as a driver with KSRTC since 2000, sought a lighter-duty assignment on medical grounds after developing spondylosis and later non-Hodgkins lymphoma. He initially accepted a lighter-duty posting (as per Ext. P2) and appeared before the District Medical Board (Ext. P3). When his condition worsened, he filed Ext. P5 seeking a change of category in 2005; he subsequently fell seriously ill and could not report for duty. Despite these medical developments, KSRTC issued Ext. P6 in 2016 requiring him to rejoin, and disciplinary action was initiated when he could not report. He submitted representations (Exts. P7–P9) and produced medical evidence (Ext. P8). The petitioner contends that Ext. P12, dated 12/03/2018, terminating his services, was vitiated for failing to consider his extenuating medical condition, Ext. P11 explanation, and his long illness. He also argued for invalid pension or reinstatement. The court notes hazy facts, including lack of clear medical-leave records and ad hoc absence from 29.03.2003 onward, while acknowledging the severe health issues. Ultimately, the court does not quash Ext. P12 but directs the KSRTC’s Disciplinary Authority to reassess the case and consider limited relief, including possibly invalid pension, after providing due process and within three months, taking into account relevant Supreme Court declarations and disability provisions."

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.30355 of 2022

Karrikode Bhagavathy Temple Advisory Committee v. Travancore Devaswom Board and The Chief Engineer (General), Travancore Devaswom Board

The petitioner, Karikkode Bhagavathy Temple Advisory Committee, is a temple under the management of the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB). It filed this writ petition under Article 226 seeking mandamus to (i) prepare a revised estimate for the construction of Prasada Oottupura-cum-Tantrimadom as referred in the Court’s Ext.P3 judgment in W.P.(C) No. 54 of 2013, and (ii) entrust the proposed construction on the revised estimate rate to the petitioner in the absence of any contractors, with a view to completing the construction within a time frame fixed by the Court. It also sought an extension of the Temple Advisory Committee’s term by one year. The respondents submitted that the revised administrative sanction had been accorded in 2013, tenders were invited in 2016, and a contractor was selected, but execution stalled due to floods, the Covid-19 pandemic, and financial constraints. They contended that Section 31A of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 and Clause (11) of the Board’s Rules cap the Committee’s term at two years, with limited extensions. The judgment relies on Chandu K. v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Sunil Kumar C. v. Travancore Devaswom Board to enforce statutory term limits and restrict extensions, and ultimately directs the Board to finalize the revised estimate and obtain administrative sanction within three months, placing the matter before the Ombudsman, while denying other reliefs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P. No. 768 of 2022

Nasimudeen v. State of Kerala and Haritha Syndicate

Nasimudeen, aged 74, challenges a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act that followed a complaint by Haritha Syndicate (represented by its power of attorney holder). The Trial Court, Kollam, upon examining PW1 (the complainant’s power of attorney holder) and Exts. P1–P9, held that the complainant discharged the initial burden and that the accused’s liability was established through the presumption under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act. The accused was convicted and sentenced to pay Rs. 1,30,000 as compensation and to imprisonment till rising of the court, with default imprisonment for two months. The Sessions Court (Crl.Appeal No. 10/2020) affirmed the conviction and sentence. In the revision, Nasimudeen contended that the complainant failed to prove passing of consideration and execution of Ext. P1; that the power of attorney holder had no personal knowledge; and that the courts below reappraised the evidence in contravention of the limited revisional remit. The Kerala High Court, however, held that PW1 had cognizable knowledge, and that revisional jurisdiction does not permit reweighing of evidence except in glaring miscarriages of justice. Relying on various Supreme Court authorities on revisional power and NI Act presumptions, the court dismissed the revision, while granting one month to pay the fine and directing appearance for sentence, with execution deferred to a later date.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 40197 OF 2022

Vinod Kumar K. vs The Secretary, Regional Transport Authority, Civil Station Ayyanthole, Thrissur District; Joint Regional Transport Officer, Sub Regional Transport Office, Triprayar; M/S HDFC Bank

The petitioner, Vinod Kumar K., challenges the refusal to renew the contract carriage permit of Bus KL-08BN-1617, which was valid till 28.08.2022. The vehicle is financed by M/s HDFC Bank and hypothecated to the financier, as noted in the registration certificate. Renewal of a permit under Section 51(6) of the Motor Vehicles Act requires the financier’s No Objection Certificate (NOC). The petitioner asserted on 22.07.2022 that the financier should issue the NOC. The financier did not issue or refuse the NOC, and the petitioner invoked Section 51(7) deeming provision, arguing that the absence of action should be treated as a deemed NOC, while a writ petition directed the matter for consideration. The 2nd respondent later rejected renewal via Ext. P9, citing arrears and ongoing arbitration with the financier. The court relied on Shabu Sukumaran v. RTO and Jayamon v. RTA to explain the discretionary power vested in the registering authority under sub-section (9) of Section 51, and observed that Ext. P9 lacked independent consideration. Consequently, the court disposed of the petition by setting aside Ext. P9 and directing the 2nd respondent to reconsider the matter after giving both petitioner and financier an opportunity of hearing, within ten days, with further appearance scheduled for 27.12.2022. The petition is disposed of accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.APPEAL NOS.507 OF 2020; 600 OF 2020; 607 OF 2020; 958 OF 2020; 263 OF 2021; 752 OF 2021

Crl.Appeal Nos.507, 600, 607 & 958 of 2020 and 263 & 752 of 2021

These appeals arise from the Palakkad Sessions Court’s judgment in SC No.382 of 2014, delivered on 27 May 2020, in which nine accused were tried for the murder of Raghu, a taxi driver. The prosecution advanced a conspiracy theory: accused 1–4 planned to hijack Raghu’s taxi to steal smuggled gold; cyanide was intended to be administered to Raghu, who was killed, and the perpetrators disposed of the body. Accused 4 turned approver during trial. On 27 May 2020, convictions were recorded against several accused under IPC sections 120B, 201, 302, and 397 read with 34, and others under 118 and 120B read with 34. The High Court, in a common judgment dated 20 October 2023, allowed three appeals (Crl.A. Nos.507, 600, 607 of 2020) and acquitted accused Nos.6–8, while dismissing the other three appeals (Crl.A. Nos.958 of 2020, 263 of 2021, 752 of 2021), thereby upholding the convictions of accused Nos.2, 3, and 5. A key issue was whether accused No.2, who claimed juvenility on the date of offence (06.12.2012), was above 18; the court relied on Rule 12 of the Juvenile Justice Rules, 2007 and Ext.P24 (birth certificate) to hold that he was an adult. The court also evaluated the credibility of PW59, the approver, and examined the admissibility of confessions to him in light of prior co-accused confession jurisprudence. The ultimate disposition is that accused Nos.6–8 are acquitted and set at liberty; accused Nos.2, 3, and 5 are affirmed in conviction and sentence; the remaining appeals are dismissed or allowed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P No. 664 of 2016

Binu v. State of Kerala and Sugamya Chits (P) Ltd.

This is a criminal revision petition filed by Binu challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, and the accompanying sentence, recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kodungallur, and upheld by the Additional Sessions Court. The prosecution alleged that a cheque for Rs. 2,40,000 dated 15.05.2010, drawn in favor of the complainant by the accused as Managing Partner of a firm, was dishonored for “exceeds arrangement.” The case traversed trial and appellate courts, with the trial court convicting and sentencing, and the conviction being affirmed on appeal. The central issue concerns whether a partnership firm (Ganga Marbles and Granites), represented by a managing partner, can be prosecuted under Section 138 NI Act without the firm being arrayed as an accused, and whether individuals can be held liable under Section 141 NI Act on the basis of vicarious liability without explicit averments in the complaint. The petitioner relies on Apex Court precedents and Kerala decisions (notably P.I. Moideen kutty and Aneeta Hada) to argue that arraignment of the firm is imperative and that mere vicarious liability cannot sustain conviction. The High Court analyzes several authorities, including S.P. Mani and Mohan Dairy, and ultimately holds that the prosecution is vitiated for failure to array the firm as an accused, thus setting aside the concurrent conviction and sentence and acquitting the petitioner, with bail, if any, canceled.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2737 OF 2008

Suresh @ Suresh Kumar v. M/S Siva Sakthi Earth Movers & Others

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal before the Kerala High Court arising from an MACT award at Irinjalakkuda in OPMV 1382/2004. The appellant, Suresh Kumar, claimed Rs 3,00,000 as compensation for injuries sustained in a 16 March 2004 accident when his motorcycle was struck by a jeep. The Tribunal found the jeep owner liable and the insurer liable to indemnify, awarding Rs 54,300 with interest and costs. On appeal, the High Court undertook a re-evaluation of quantum. It rejected the Tribunal’s method of computing income but ultimately fixed the appellant’s monthly income at Rs 3,000 in light of his driver’s profession and the accident year, applying the Ramachandrappa doctrine. It corrected the multiplier from 18 to 17 in line with Sarla Verma. The Court held the appellant’s functional disability at 20% (per Raj Kumar), recognizing his functional impairment in using his left foot. Loss of earnings was recalculated for six months at Rs 3,000/month, increasing from Rs 6,000 to Rs 18,000. Medical expenses were not awarded due to lack of bills. Pain and suffering head was increased from Rs 15,000 to Rs 25,000. Overall compensation heads were recalculated; the appeal was allowed in part, with an additional Rs 1,18,400 awarded as enhanced compensation, plus interest at 7% and costs, to be deposited before the Tribunal. The Tribunal shall disburse the enhanced amount in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2658 OF 2009

Krishna Kumar v. Pankajakshan, Manikan and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

Krishna Kumar, a driver, filed a motor vehicle claim petition under Section 166 of the MV Act, 1988, seeking compensation for injuries sustained on 7 February 2002 in a highway collision involving a lorry owned by the 1st respondent and insured by the 3rd respondent. The Tribunal (M.A.C.T., Thrissur) allowed the petition in part, awarding Rs. 94,140 with 7% interest and costs. The appellant contended that the Tribunal wrongly fixed the notional monthly income (Rs. 2,000) and did not adequately account for his actual earnings and occupation as a driver; he relied on judicial authorities to recalibrate income and other heads. The Respondents mostly resisted liability and contested quantum, with the 3rd respondent arguing the accident was due to the appellant’s negligence and praying for dismissal. The High Court, while confirming liability, undertook its own reassessment of several heads of compensation: increasing notional income to Rs. 3,500 per month, fixing disability at 12%, applying a multiplier of 17 (per Sarla Verma), and re-calculating losses including loss of earnings, loss due to disability, loss of amenities, bystander and nourishment expenses. The Court enhanced the total compensation to Rs. 1,56,980, directing deposit and disbursement through the Tribunal with costs and interest at 7% on the enhanced amount.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.343 of 2013

Madhavi, Padmini and Rajani v. Sankaran

This is a Rent Control Revision (R.C.Rev.No.343 of 2013) filed before the Kerala High Court by Madhavi, Padmini and Rajani, landlords of a petition schedule shop room in Vadakara, challenging two lower court orders under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Vadakara, had dismissed a petition for eviction under sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3), holding Ext.A2 to be an invalid notice under 11(2)(b) but that the landlords’ need for the premises was bona fide under 11(3); however, the court refused eviction under 11(3) because the tenant was found to be protected by the second proviso since his livelihood depended on the shop’s income and there was no other suitable building. The Appellate Authority (RCA 97 of 2010) confirmed this. The revision before this Court raises the correctness of the Appellate Authority’s approach, especially its failure to make a clear finding on whether the need under 11(3) is true and genuine. The judgment cites Smitha v. Krishnan (2017) to emphasize that when bona fides under 11(3) (and 11(4)(iv)) are proved, there is no need for further proof under 11(10). The High Court allows the revision and remands to the Appellate Authority to reconsider entitlement under 11(3) and pass fresh orders expeditiously, within two months, while returning records.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 3052 OF 2009

Ajithkumar S/o Nepolean v. Ullasan Vishnu Nivas, P. M. Rajappan, and United India Insurance Company Ltd.

The appellant, Ajithkumar S/o Nepolean, sustained serious injuries in a motor vehicle accident on 12.03.2002 when a tempo van (KRA-5971) driven rashly by the first respondent struck his scooter near a petrol pump at Kuthiathode. He was hospitalized in 2002 for extended periods, including three spells totalling 18 days, and suffered a compound fracture of both bones of the right leg. He claimed compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking Rs. 2,09,800, against the owner and insurer of the van; the Tribunal granted Rs. 41,750 with 6% interest. The appeal contends that the notional income used by the Tribunal was far too low and undercompensated him for loss of earnings, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities, especially given his occupation as a driver. The respondents did not contest the proceedings (except the insurer, who denied liability beyond the policy terms). The High Court reconsiders the quantum, noting medical evidence and the applicant’s status as a driver, and, relying on a Supreme Court decision (Chandra v. Mukesh Kumar Yadav), fixes the notional monthly income at Rs. 5,000 for the relevant period and enhances compensation accordingly. The Court finalizes an enhanced award and directs deposit of the amount with costs and interest, to be disbursed to the appellant upon deposit.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.12864 OF 2019(G)

Rajalekshmi L. and others v. State of Kerala and others

The writ petition challenges the Kerala Public Service Commission’s district-wise rank lists prepared for appointment to the post of Confidential Assistants (Gr. II) in various Government Departments, seeking to fill existing vacancies caused by deputation to government-controlled Companies and Corporations from the 2016 district-wise rank list. The petitioners argued that the rank list, though expired, should permit appointments from it, citing State of Haryana v. Mahabir Prasad Sharma (AIR 1994 SC 1804) to justify recruitment from an outdated list. The PSC contended that the district-wise ranking was not designed for Corporations (which operate on state-wise lists) and that the rank list had already expired, making further appointments from it impossible. The LBS Centre for Science and Technology argued no prayer lay against them since they did not requisition the PSC to prepare the list. The learned judge observed that the rank list has indeed expired and, given district-wise implementation for departments and not for Corporations, it cannot be used for filling vacancies in the latter. Citing Vimala Kumari v. State (1994 (2) KLT 47), the court noted that the expired list cannot be used to grant appointments. Consequently, the petition was dismissed. The judgment emphasizes that appointments must follow valid, current rank lists appropriate to the specific recruitment bodies and sectors involved.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A.No.915 of 2008; CRL.A.No.1021 of 2008

M. Karunakaran v. State of Kerala

The appellants, M. Karunakaran and another, were convicted by the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kozhikode, under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, for demanding and accepting a bribe of Rs 2,000 from PW1, a toddy shop salesman, in March 2001. A trap was arranged on 24 March 2001 after PW1 gave a statement (Ext.P1) and the MO1 series of tainted notes were recovered during the operation. Despite the recovery, the High Court found deficiencies in the prosecution case: PW1’s testimony was solitary and uncorroborated, PW2 did not witness the handing over of the money, and the police constable who purportedly observed the incident was not examined. Crucially, the tainted notes were not recovered from the possession of the accused, and PW1 had not stated a proper demand or a complete payment of Rs 2,000. The court also noted inconsistent conduct by PW1, failure to inform the shop owner DW1 of the alleged demand, and the absence of independent corroboration. Relying on Mukhtiar Singh and Jayaraj B., the court held that proof of demand and acceptance was not established, and that the mere recovery of tainted notes could not sustain conviction. The appeals were allowed, convictions and sentences set aside, and the appellants acquitted with bail bonds discharged.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1107 OF 2017

Shanavas P. v. Babin Technologies Pvt. Ltd. and State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal revision petition concerns Shanavas P., the 2nd accused, challenging the conviction under Section 138 NI Act arising from a private complaint by M/s. Babin Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (the complainant) against Fortis Marketing (A1) and its managing partner (A2). The trial court convicted both, with the 1st accused (the firm) receiving vicarious liability and the 2nd accused (A2) personally sentenced, a conviction upheld by the Sessions Court though the sentence was partially reduced to a mere day’s imprisonment pending payment of a substantial fine. The revision petition contends the complaint’s filing was defective due to lack of proper authorisation; PW1, the company’s PRO, filed and testified under Ext.P1 (Power of Attorney) without demonstrable authorisation from a board resolution. In its analysis, the court surveys leading authorities on who may file, testify and represent a company in NI Act proceedings, including Narayanan A.C., Popular Motor Corporation, TRL Krosaki Refractories and Pramod v. Velayudhan, to determine the legitimacy of POA-based filings and the de jure/de facto distinction for complainants. The court ultimately holds that a POA holder can file and depose if properly authorised, but notes that once the firm’s conviction is final, the managing partner cannot rely on fresh defences. The revision petition is dismissed, and the sentence is to be executed with directions to produce the petitioner for sentencing.

High Court of Kerala
RP 382/2022 in I.A. 1/2021 in R.F.A. No. 241 of 2020

Basheer Malikayil v. K.U. Jayaprakash

This is a Kerala High Court review petition (RP 382 of 2022) arising from an appeal in R.F.A. No. 241 of 2020. The petition, filed by Basheer Malikayil (the 3rd respondent in the appeal), challenges the order dated 10 December 2021 passed in I.A. No. 1 of 2021 in R.F.A. No. 241 of 2020, which granted a temporary injunction restraining him from transferring, alienating or creating any interest in the plaint schedule property and from inducting any stranger. The respondent/applicant in the review, Jayaprakash, contends that the injunction was misapplied and that consideration of injury, balance of convenience, and the property’s utility warranted a different view. The court anchors its analysis in well-known Supreme Court jurisprudence: Meera Bhanja, Parsion Devi, Lily Thomas, Anantha Reddy, and S. Madhusudhan Reddy, to emphasize the restricted, non-merit-based nature of review under Order XLVII, Rule 1 CPC. It reiterates that review cannot function as an appeal, nor permit rehearing on merits; only errors apparent on the record or new material may justify review, and even then narrowly. The court ultimately holds that none of the grounds suffices to invoke review and dismisses the petition. The matter is directed for LC R and notes SLP withdrawal in 2022. Appendix references annexures.

High Court of Kerala
Bail Appl.No.252 of 2018

Raveendran P.A. v. State of Kerala & The Station House Officer, Bekkal Police Station, Kasaragod District

This is a bail application (Bail Appl. No.252 of 2018) by Raveendran P.A., the first accused in Crime No.734/2017 of Bekkal Police Station, Kasaragod, alleging offences under sections 143, 147, 148, 452, 427, 323, 324 and 506(1) read with 34 IPC. The petitioner seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. The prosecution alleges that on 15.11.2017, the petitioner and eight accomplices entered the de facto complainant’s house armed with a stick, assaulted him, and threatened to kill him and his son, causing damage by throwing stones. The case diary indicates the possibility of deleting certain offences and complicity of others; eventually, the petitioner became the sole accused. The court notes that the only non-bailable offense is 452 IPC (house trespass with intent to cause hurt) but finds no evidence of injury to vital parts or previous criminal antecedents, and sees no necessity for custodial interrogation or fear of absconding. Citing Anthru v. Sub Inspector of Police, the court rejects directions to surrender before police or courts during investigation and grants anticipatory bail. The order imposes standard conditions—bond, sureties, appearance before IO, no witness tampering, and restriction on travel. The petition is allowed and pre-arrest bail is granted.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O. 322 of 2010

Dr. Gracy Abraham v. Joseph (dead) and others

The plaintiff, Dr. Gracy Abraham, filed O.S.592 of 2006 for specific performance of an agreement of sale dated 14.03.2006. The suit was dismissed for default on 04.03.2008 when the plaintiff failed to appear on the trial date. She moved for restoration via I.A.3005/2008 under Order IX, Rule 9 CPC and a separate I.A.3006/2008 for condonation of delay of 48 days in filing the restoration petitions. The Sub Court rejected both petitions by an order dated 10.07.2009. The appellant contends the suit was inadvertently dismissed due to a clerical posting error and that there were subsequent amicable settlement efforts; hence the restoration petition and delay were bona fide. The High Court notes a three-day appeal delay which it condoned and observes that additional respondents, impleaded as 4–11 during the appeal, did not participate. It relies on established authority—Collector, Land Acquisition v. Katiji; Esha Bhattacharjee v. Raghunathpur Nafar Academy; and Rafeek v. K. Kamarudeen—to emphasize that “sufficient cause” is elastic and a liberal, reasoned approach should be adopted, balancing justice with prejudice. Ultimately, the court holds that a 48-day delay is condonable and restores the suit, directing expeditious disposal within four months from appearance. The appeal is allowed and the impugned orders are set aside.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos.51/2018, 52/2018, 53/2018

M/S Kuttukkaran Trading Ventures v. State of Kerala

This is a triplet of tax revision petitions (OT.Rev Nos. 51/2018, 52/2018, 53/2018) before the Kerala High Court challenging the common order of the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal (TA (VAT) Nos. 471/14, 472/14 and 473/2014). The petitioner, M/s Kuttukkaran Trading Ventures, contends that license fees paid by a third party for operating service centres under a license agreement should not be included in its taxable turnover under the KVAT Act, arguing primarily that the arrangement constitutes a transfer of the right to use immovable property and thus a service, not a sale of goods. The Department contends that the license arrangement constitutes a transfer of the right to use, constituting a taxable turnover under KVAT, and that the Tribunal correctly upheld the assessment. The petition relies on Article 366(29A) of the Constitution and the 46th Amendment to contend that composite contracts (including works contracts, hire purchase, and catering contracts) are contemplated as deemed sales only in specific categories; the petitioner urges that the present license agreement does not fall within those categories. The High Court recognizes the need to re-examine the facts, discusses the license agreement and Annexures, and ultimately sets aside the three orders and remits the matter to the Assessing Officer for disposal afresh, allowing the petitioner to place the license agreement on record. No costs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos.151 & 1002 of 2012

MACA Nos.151 & 1002 of 2012

These concurrent Motor Accidents Claims Appeals arise from the award in OP(MV) No.100 of 2005 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri, concerning the death of Panali Basheer in 2004. The appellants (1-10), being the wife, minor children, and other dependents, challenged the Tribunal’s compensation of Rs.40,28,000 as inadequate, while the insurer challenged it as excessive in MACA No.151/2012 and 1002/2012, respectively. The High Court re-evaluates the decedent’s income, rejecting reliance on uncertain Gulf earnings for a non-permanent employee and applying Indian standards (per Sarla Verma) for loss of dependency. It notes that the deceased earned through Saudi business under a sponsor, with disputed, unauthenticated salary affidavits, and that Gulf income cannot be safely used for Indian compensation calculations. Relying on Pranay Sethi and National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi and United India Insurance Co. v. Satinder Kaur, the Court adds 25% for future prospects and deducts 50% for personal and living expenses. The court ultimately increases the loss of dependency to Rs.63 lakh (from Rs.40 lakh) and enhances other heads (love and affection, estate, funeral) while limiting eligibility to appellants 1-5 as dependents. The result: MACA No.1002/2012 dismissed; MACA No.151/2012 allowed to the extent stated, with a deposit directive and no costs order.