This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No.478/2013, hears an appeal by the claimant in OP(MV) No.1429/2005 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta, challenging the Tribunal’s award of compensation for injuries suffered in a road traffic accident on 11.07.2005. The accident involved KL-05/Q-2077 motorcycle owned by the 2nd respondent and insured by the 3rd respondent. The appellant, a vegetable vendor aged around 38, contends the Tribunal erred in several heads of compensation: it fixed an artificially low notional income of Rs.3,000 per month, contrary to the principle in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. (AIR 2011 SC 2951), which should yield Rs.5,000 per month for notional income. The Medical Board rated disability at 30% (Traumatic Optic Neuropathy of the left eye), but the Tribunal awarded no permanent disablement compensation. The appellant asks for enhancement across heads: loss of earning (Rs.12,000 balance from Rs.30,000 notional loss), transportation (Rs.2,000), extra diet (Rs.1,500), bystander expenses (Rs.1,950), pain and suffering (Rs.25,000), and permanent disability (Rs.1,80,000) using a notional income of Rs.5,000, multiplier 15 and 20% whole-body disability. He relies on Rs.5,000 notional income and 20% disability for computation. The High Court recalculates and awards enhanced compensation totaling Rs.2,04,400, directs the insurer to deposit the amount with 9% interest within two months, and allows the appeal, with no costs ordered.
This Kerala High Court MACA article concerns an appeal from the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, arising out of the death of A.K. Muraleedharan in a motor vehicle collision on 31.10.2005. The petitioners, as dependants, claimed compensation under section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, alleging negligence by the driver of the car (registration KL-7/AY 6444). The Tribunal granted Rs. 10,20,000 in total relief against the insurer (Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd.) with proportionate costs, determining income based on Saral forms and applying a notional framework that underestimated the deceased’s earning capacity. The High Court re-evaluates several core components: it accepts the deceased as promoter of M/s. Pooja Milk Foods (P) Ltd., overturns the Tribunal’s income figure, and adopts the multiplier of 11 from Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation. It applies 10% future prospects (per Pranay Sethi) and adjusts for personal living expenses, reducing dependency to a higher figure of Rs.17,64,180 for loss of dependency. Conventional heads (funeral expenses, loss of estate, loss of consortium) are recalibrated, and the court removes “loss of love and affection” to avoid duplication per Somwati. The appeal is allowed in part, with a total enhanced compensation of Rs.19,49,180, to be deposited by the insurer within 60 days, and disbursed among the appellants in a 50:25:25 ratio, plus interest and costs.
The appellant, Unnikrishnan @ Kannan, filed O.P(MV) No.2437/2003 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for compensation for injuries sustained on 12-04-2003 when a trailer lorry, driven negligently by the 2nd respondent, struck a parked lorry on NH-47. The Tribunal, Thrissur, allowed the petition in part and awarded Rs.1,40,000 plus costs and interest against the 3rd respondent insurer. The appellant contends that the compensation is inadequate and that notional income should be Rs.4,000 per month, supported by Ext.A7 disability certificate showing 22% permanent disability to the right lower limb and 11.55% to the whole body, though the Tribunal had fixed 5% due to lack of medical board. The Tribunal had relied on Ext.A7 but appeared to discount it for not being issued by a Medical Board. The High Court, applying the principles from Ramachandrappa (notional income) and Sarla Verma (multiplier), re-fixated the notional income at Rs.4,000, increased the disability to 10%, and recalculated several heads of loss: loss of earnings, bystander expenses, extra nourishment, and loss of amenities, culminating in a total of Rs.2,15,064 (rounded to Rs.2,15,000). The appeal was allowed in part, enhancing compensation by Rs.75,064 with 8% interest and Rs.10,000 costs, with deposit and disbursement requirements to be fulfilled by the Tribunal within the stated timeframe.
CRL.MC Nos.3965 of 2023 & connected cases (including 3977/2023, 3979/2023, 3986/2023, 3991/2023, 4003/2023, 4005/2023, 4017/2023) This is a consolidated High Court of Kerala decision by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V in Criminal Misc. Cases Nos. 3965 of 2023 and connected matters. The petitions challenge identical orders under Sections 111 and 107 CrPC issued by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Fort Kochi, directing eight petitioners to show cause why they should not be ordered to execute a cash bond for Rs. 1,00,000 with two sureties for keeping the peace for one year. The petitioners contend that the magistrate did not apply his mind, relied on police information without disclosing the substance of the information or the grounds for a probable breach of peace, and that the orders violate the mandatory procedure under CrPC. The State contends that a report from the North Paravur Police Station established a real threat to public peace and tranquility, and that Section 107 is preventive, not punitive, justifying action taken. The court, after considering authorities such as Moidu v. State of Kerala, Peethambaran v. State of Kerala, Madhu Limaye, Santhosh M.V., and Bejoy K.V., held the orders were identically worded and devoid of cogent grounds or the substance of information required under Sections 107 and 111 CrPC, constituting an abuse of power. The petitions are allowed, and all further proceedings under Section 107 CrPC against the petitioners are quashed, affirming that the object of Section 107 is prevention, not punishment and must be exercised with strict adherence to lawful procedure.
This is an appeal under Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging the order dated 24.02.2020 in I.A.49 of 2018 in O.S.96 of 2016 (as clarified by the court’s corrigendum) on the file of the Sub Court, Chavakkad, in a suit for partition. The appellant, Velayudhan, contends that the ex parte decree dated 23.09.2017 was passed only because the defendants failed to file written statements; the appellant could not meet his counsel due to unavoidable circumstances. He filed I.A.49 of 2018 within the prescribed period seeking to set aside the ex parte decree, arguing there was no negligence or mala fide and that restoration would allow adjudication on merits. The Sub Judge held that there was no bona fides in filing the application and dismissed the request to set aside. The High Court, citing Robin Thapa v. Rohit Dora, Peeves Enterprises v. Muhammed Ashraf, and Shivananda M. v. M. Susheela, held that when there is no negligence or inaction and the application is within time, the court should ordinarily restore the case to merits. The court concluded that sufficient cause existed for setting aside the ex parte decree and that justice requires restoration of the suit for adjudication on merits. The appeal is allowed, and the impugned order is set aside with directions to restore the suit on file and proceed accordingly.
This writ appeal arises from an interim order of a learned Single Judge in WP(C) 13123/2021 denying a stay of enforcement of orders under the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. The appellant, a super-specialty hospital, contends that its trainees and apprentices, engaged under certified standing orders, are learners and not “employees” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the EPF Act, and hence should not be brought within the ambit of provident fund contributions. The 1st respondent EPFO, by Ext. P-7, determined that the hospital is liable to remit contributions for trainees, holding that the standing orders did not automatically exempt them, while the 2nd respondent, the Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court, upheld the EPFO’s posture. The petitioner relies on decisions including Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Mangalore v Central Arecanut & Cocoa Marketing and Processing Co-op. Society Ltd., Mangalore (2006) 2 SCC 381, and Sivagiri Sreenarayana Medical Mission Hospital v RPFC (2018) 4 KLT 352, arguing trainees are primarily learners and not employees, and that no adverse materials were elicited to prove that trainees were engaged to extract work. The court, after hearing, directs that the main writ petition be disposed by a Single Judge within three months, and that Exts. P-7 and P-10 be kept in abeyance for three months, given Covid-19 constraints, thereby modifying the interim stay posture and expediting resolution.
This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC filed by BaburaJ challenging the Family Court, Palakkad, order in M.C. No. 236/2014 directing him to pay monthly maintenance of Rs. 4,500 to Kumari, his wife whom he married in 2011 and with whom there are no children. Kumari alleged matrimonial cruelty, including threats to strangulate and kill, which compelled her to leave the matrimonial home and seek shelter at her parental home. She claimed she is employed in VM Politex Limited, earning about Rs. 13,500 per month. BaburaJ, a coolie worker with parental responsibilities for three children from a previous marriage, contended that he has to maintain his dependants and that Kumari left without sufficient cause, claiming he has insufficient means to pay the maintenance. The Family Court, after evaluating the pleadings and evidence (PW1 and CPWs 1-2), partly allowed the application, directing maintenance of Rs. 4,500 per month. The revision petition argues illegality in that order, asserting the respondent’s alleged earnings and his own limited means. The High Court, relying on Rajnesh v. Neha and Anr., Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal, and Bhuwan Mohan Singh, treats maintenance as a social-justice measure and permits court-led estimation of notional income. It fixes the petitioner’s notional income at Rs. 25,000 per month, finds no illegality, and dismisses the revision petition while allowing arrears to be paid in three installments, with adjustment for any interim deposits.
This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal arising from a common award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottapalam, in O.P. (MV) No. 382/2008 and connected petitions. The appellant Thomas, a tailor, sustained multiple injuries in an accident on 02.02.2008 involving a lorry driven negligently by the first respondent. The lorry was owned by the second respondent and insured with the third respondent. The Tribunal consolidated several petitions, allowing the claim in part and directing the insurer to pay Rs. 25,450 with costs. On appeal, the High Court reassessed quantum: it re-fixed the notional monthly income to Rs. 5,000 (instead of Rs. 3,000 as per the Tribunal, following Ramachandrappa) and held the appellant’s disability at 5% (accepting Exhibit A8 on its face value—per Raj Kumar). The court also determined loss of earnings, loss of earning capacity (Rs. 45,000), and revised heads of compensation: pain and suffering (Rs. 20,000), loss of amenities (Rs. 10,000), along with other heads, culminating in a total enhanced compensation of Rs. 1,01,500 (rounded). The appeal is allowed in part; the insurer must deposit the enhanced compensation with interest (6% p.a.) and costs within 60 days, and disbursement follows on deposit. The judgment relies on Sarla Verma for multiplier (15) and cites Raj Kumar and Ramachandrappa as supportive precedents.
N. Vishnu Namboothiri Vishnu Nilayam, petitioner, sought selection as Melsanthi for Sabarimala Sree Dharma Sastha Temple for the year 1197 M.E. (2021-22) under Ext.P1 notification. The board rejected his application by Ext.P2 (02.09.2021) and Ext.P9 (20.09.2021) after a personal hearing, contending that the applicant did not meet the prescribed experience and qualification criteria and had suppressed material facts, including past disciplinary actions. The petitioner claimed eligibility based on experience evidenced by Ext.P3 (08.09.2021) and Ext.P11 (07.06.2021), and relied on precedents such as Mohandas Embranthiri v. Travancore Devaswom Board, Rajesh J. Potty v. Travancore Devaswom Board, and Krishnan Namboothiri S. v. Travancore Devaswom Board, arguing that the selection process must be guided by the terms of the settlement for Sabarimala and Malikappuram temples and that the courts should not automatically bar consideration on the basis of prior records. The court, noting that Ext.P11 did not satisfy Clause 4 and that Ext.P3 did not demonstrate the requisite experience, held that the matter falls within the policy framework established by the earlier decisions and that the Supreme Court guidance in SLP No.8017/03 and other authorities does not compel interference. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs, upholding Ext.P2 and Ext.P9.” ,
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No.2262 of 2023) filed by an under-trial accused challenging an order of the Fast Track Special Court (SC 314/2022) Nadapuram dated 01.03.2023 that declined to recall four prosecution witnesses. The petitioner faces grave offences under IPC sections 376-AB, 376(2)(f) and 354-A(1)(i) and under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, including sections 6(1), 6(2), 5(l), 5(m), 5(n), 8 read with 7 and 12 read with 11(iii). The trial record shows the accused, in judicial custody, was represented by a legal aid counsel who cross-examined witnesses allegedly without his instructions, prejudicing his defence. After engaging private counsel, the petitioner sought to reopen the evidence and recall PWs 1, 2, 5 and 6, a prayer partly allowed by the trial court to recall only PW19 (investigation officer). The High Court held that the order refusing recall of PWs 1, 2, 5 and 6 could prejudice the fair trial and should be set aside, invoking Section 311 Cr.P.C. and Section 33(5) of the POCSO Act, while warning against capricious use of power. Citing Zahira, Mohanlal Soni, Mina Lalita Baruwa, Rajaram Yadav, Natasha Singh and Ranchod Wasawa, the Court remitted with directions to recall the witnesses for further examination to secure truth and a just decision.
R.C.Rev No.352 of 2019 arises from eviction proceedings under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The petitioners, Mahmood Stores and associates, contend they own the land on which the building stands, derived from Asmabi via a chain of transfers, and that the government has no right to divest them. The Rent Control Court ordered eviction on the ground of bona fide need (to establish a jewellery shop) and the Appellate Authority affirmed. The revision petition before the High Court contends that the respondents’ denial of the petitioners' title is not bona fide and that the petitioners are entitled to protections under the provisos to Section 11(3). The respondents counter that the land belongs to the Government and that the petitioners have not proven title, and that the alleged rent receipts do not establish a landlord-tenant relationship. The court undertook a detailed review of documentary evidence, including Exts A1–A5 title deeds, Exts A6–A13 revenue records showing Asmabi as owner, Exts A14–A18 and A21–A25 property tax receipts, and Ext A19, a carbon copy rent receipt. It held Ext A26 judgment in W.P.(C) 20734/2005 establishing title in the petitioners and that the government does not retain a right over the land; accordingly, the denial of title was not bona fide and the petition was dismissed, preserving the eviction order.
Rajula, the wife of detenu Shamsudheen, challenges a detention order under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAP Act) issued against her husband. The writ petition (criminal) seeks habeas corpus and quashing of Ext.P2 (dated 17.05.2022) on grounds that the detaining authority’s subjective satisfaction is vitiated, and the link between the last prejudicial activity and detention is broken by unexplained delay. The detenu faced three NDPS Act-related cases at Pudunagaram and Kollengode: (i) 975/2020 with 1.1 kg ganja; (ii) 701/2021 with 30 g ganja; (iii) 40/2022 with 4.060 kg ganja. The District Police Chief advised preventive detention; the District Collector issued Ext.P2; Government approved Ext.P3; the Advisory Board submitted its report (Ext.P5) and recommended detention be upheld. The petitioner contends (a) delay of about 3 months 26 days (22.01.2022 last act to 17.05.2022) breaks the live link and is unexplained; (b) the bail-order in the third case was inadequately considered, undermining the detaining authority’s subjective satisfaction. The court examines these submissions, finds the delay reasonably explained by the authorities’ bona fides, and ultimately upholds the detention, distinguishing other cases and holding that the judicial review of subjective satisfaction cannot be based on challenging reasons alone, thereby dismissing the petition.
This writ petition challenges the Kerala Lok Ayukta's 1 September 2016 order in Complaint No.943/2014 directing payment of arrears to Smt. R. Pankajakshy, a part‑time sweeper who served at the Mannoorkara Village Office from 2006 to 2009 but was never paid. The petitioners—senior state officials led by the Chief Secretary and supported by the Government Pleader—contend that the Lok Ayukta exceeded its jurisdiction by entertaining a service matter, specifically arrears of salary, which falls under executive decisions and pension/retirement issues, excluded by Section 8(1) and the Second Schedule of the Kerala Lok Ayukta Act, 1999. The respondent seeks enforcement of the wage claim arising from government orders raising remuneration for casual sweepers (G.O. 145/06; 154/08) and asserts the grievance concerns pay and conditions of service. The High Court examines the statutory framework: Section 8 of the Lok Ayukta Act and the Second Schedule, plus precedents in Kamal v. State of Kerala, Kerala State Civil Supplies Corp. v. Lok Ayukta, and Commissioner of Police v. Abida Beevi, which collectively indicate that jurisdiction over such service/pay matters does not lie with the Lok Ayukta. The Court, while acknowledging the Government’s power to grant enhanced wages, ultimately holds that the Lok Ayukta had no jurisdiction to entertain the complaint and quashes Ext.P5, directing discharge of arrears as per G.O.154/08 within one month.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 4109 OF 2007 This is a criminal revision petition arising from a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act), where the 2nd accused, V.K. Prabhakaran, was the Managing Partner of M/s Soccer Polymers. The trial court convicted the 2nd accused and sentenced him to six months’ imprisonment and hefty compensation, while the first accused (the firm) was acquitted. The appellate court affirmed the conviction but reduced the substantive sentence to one day’s imprisonment till the rising of the court and reduced the compensation to Rs. 1,50,000 with a two-month default sentence. The revision challenges the court’s reasoning, arguing that the cheque was issued by the firm from its account and signed by the Managing Partner in that capacity, so there is no personal liability under Sec. 138 NI Act. The core issue is whether, when a firm is acquitted of the offence, the Managing Partner can be held liable under Sec. 141 NI Act as a person in charge of the firm. The High Court widens the legal view, citing Siby Thomas v. Somany Ceramics Ltd and Ashok Shewakramani, and Pramod v. Velayudhan, to hold that where the juristic person commits no offence, the persons in charge cannot be held liable. The court sets aside the lower court judgments and acquits the revision petitioner, with bail cancelled and liberty granted.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition (CRL.R.P No.2878 of 2008) arising from a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The first accused, a contractor, was found in possession of 5495 litres of rectified spirit and 3234 litres of arrack in a godown leased by him, during 1995-96, and he also held a toddy licence for 1996-97. The trial court convicted A1 and sentenced him to two years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine; A2 and A3 were acquitted. On appeal, the II Additional Sessions Judge, Kollam, upheld the conviction. The High Court intervened, scrutinizing procedural irregularities in the seizure process, including lack of a specimen-seal impression on the seizure list (Ext.P1), absence of a forwarding note, discrepancies in the number of seized bottles (Ext.P1 vs Ext.P10), and a significant delay in forwarding samples to the Chemical Examiner. It also highlighted the absence of a property list and unexplained delays in investigation and filing the final report. Relying on several Kerala High Court precedents—Moothedath Sivadasan v. State of Kerala; Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala; Krishnadas v. State of Kerala; Krishnan H v. State; Chandran v. State—the court held that such defects undermine the prosecution’s case. Consequently, the court acquitted the petitioner and allowed the revision petition, setting aside conviction and sentence and ordering release.
Rejitha, a nurse working in Saudi Arabia, filed O.P. No. 1380 of 2021 in the Family Court, Attingal, seeking permanent custody of her minor son Abel Pereira. The child is presently with his maternal grandparents. She also moved I.A. No. 3 of 2022 seeking permission to take the child to Saudi Arabia, which was dismissed by order dated 12.05.2022 for lack of specific pleadings and missing passport/visa details. Aggrieved, she approached the Kerala High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution, challenging the Family Court order. The High Court dispensed with notice and examined the Family Court’s order in light of the broad, yet limited, supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227. Relying on decisions including Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil, Jai Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi, K.V.S. Ram v. Bangalore Metropolitan Transport Corporation, and Sobhana Nair K.N. v. Shaji S.G. Nair, the Court emphasired that Article 227 relief is not an appellate remedy but a supervisory mechanism to ensure efficiency and adherence to fundamental legal principles. It held that the Family Court’s order dated 12.05.2022 was not perverse or illegal. The petition was dismissed, with liberty to file a fresh application before the Family Court with specific pleadings (passport/visa details). The Court also noted that service on the respondent was dispensed with for the interim relief requested.
The petitioner, Biju Mathew, filed OP (MAC) No.86/2022 seeking compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for a motor accident that occurred on 10 December 2021 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta. The MACT dismissed the petition on 17 June 2022, holding it barred by the six-month limitation reintroduced by Act 32 of 2019 (effective 1 April 2022). The petitioner contends that under the old regime, no rigid time limit existed for filing a no-fault liability claim and that the amendment would deprive him of a right accrued prior to 1 April 2022; he argues that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 saves existing rights and that there is no express savings clause in the repealing provision. The respondent’s counsel argued the amendment should bar such petitions filed after the new six-month limit. The High Court, after hearing, notes that the old no-fault regime allowed filing at any time up to 1994 and that Act 32/2019 reintroduced the six-month period without a specific saving clause. Relying on the Bhajan Kaur decision and the General Clauses Act, the court holds that the amendment has prospective effect; existing rights are saved, so the petition deserves to be entertained. The impugned order is set aside and the MACT is directed to hear the petition on merits, with parties to appear on 26 September 2022.
The petitioner, a Class VII Co-operative Bank with only three employees (Secretary, Clerk, and Peon), challenged orders directing it to enroll a fourth employee in the Kerala State Co-operative Employees’ Pension Scheme, transfer the balance in his Contributory Provident Fund (CPF) to the pension fund, and grant him promotional benefits including a second higher grade. After a prior writ petition, Ext. P4 directed the Joint Registrar (General) to hear the employee and the Bank, resulting in Ext. P5 directing enrollment and payment of contributions. The Bank appealed, arguing that its current severe financial stringency and a circular prohibiting use of funds for salaries, plus a letter (Ext. P9) warning of a potential financial crisis, show that enrollment would impose an unsustainable burden and that Exts. P5 and P8 were issued without considering present financial realities. The employee contends pension rights are vested and that the Bank must transfer CPF amounts already credited to the pension fund, with Service benefits including higher grade not being denied. The Court refused to interfere with Exts. P5 and P8, noting welfare statutes protect employee benefits and that financial difficulties cannot nullify statutory obligations; the Bank is not exempt from the Pension Scheme and, if conditions improve, may reconsider participation.
WP(C) Nos. 33820/2022, 33821/2022, 33822/2022, 33823/2022, 33824/2022, 33825/2022, 33826/2022, 33828/2022 In a consolidated batch of writ petitions, eight Vice Chancellors of Kerala’s universities challenge an analogously worded communication dated 23.10.2022 from the Chancellor (Governor) informing them that they are ceased to be Vice Chancellors with effect from 21.10.2022 and inviting them to submit their resignations by 11:30 a.m. on 24.10.2022. The petitioners contend that the Chancellor acted without jurisdiction, outside the scope of the parent Acts, and in derogation of due process and natural justice, thereby purporting to remove them or declare their appointments void ab initio. They dispute the reliance on Supreme Court judgments invoked by the Chancellor to justify removal or non-renewal, arguing that the 2018 UGC Regulations under which they were appointed differ from the 2010/2013 regime cited in those decisions. The respondents (Chancellor, the State, and the Universities) maintain the communications were issued bona fide in light of binding judicial precedents and with a view to ensure fair process in line with the jurisprudence. The High Court, after hearing, finds prima facie that forcing resignations within a few hours and declaring cessation without due process is improper, and that the notices to show cause may not be a substitute for a valid process. Ultimately, the court sets aside the impugned communications and allows the petitions, directing adherence to lawful procedures and directions consistent with the judgments cited.
This Civil Revision Petition (CRP No. 110 of 2017) in the Kerala High Court challenges the scope of an enquiry under Rule 15 of Order XXXII CPC in a suit filed by a mentally unsound person through a next friend. During the suit, the alleged plaintiff expressed unwillingness to proceed, and the trial court conducted an in-court enquiry, recording questions and the plaintiff’s responses, and concluded the plaintiff was incapable of managing his affairs due to mental infirmity, dismissing the application I.A.2245/2014. The petitioner contends that, in the absence of a judicial adjudication, the matter falls under the second limb of Rule 15 which requires a full inquiry into incapacity, including medical evidence or a Medical Board assessment; mere questioning and non-rational answers cannot suffice. The court jurisprudence cited includes Sharda v. Dharmpal, which authorizes expert evaluation and even Section 151 CPC directions to ascertain truth, and Kasturibai v. Anguri Chaudhary, which the court distinguishes as applicable only to the first limb (adjudication) and not to the second limb. The High Court holds that the trial court’s approach was premature and non-compliant with Rule 15, and directs a proper enquiry with medical input to protect the person’s interests. It notes that the authority to proceed through a next friend may terminate on death of the original plaintiff unless a substitute steps in. The revision petition is allowed accordingly.