Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 488 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 10 of 2017

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Kochi-I v Cochin International Airport Ltd

This Kerala High Court judgment concerns ITA No. 10 of 2017 (assessment year 2006-07) filed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Kochi-I, challenging an ITAT order in ITA 463/Coch/2014. The dispute centers on whether reassessment under section 147, read with section 143(3), was validly initiated by the Assessing Officer on the basis of internal audit objections and whether the required ‘reason to believe’ was properly recorded. The CIT (A) held that initiation under section 147 did not comply with the requirement; the Tribunal affirmed, and the Revenue’s appeal was dismissed by the High Court. The judgment emphasises that section 147 is a machinery provision whose precondition is a reason to believe that income has escaped assessment. While the amended section broadens its scope, the reason must reflect a subjective belief supported by rational grounds, not merely a change of opinion or a submission based solely on audit recommendations. The Court reiterates the jurisprudence that mere audit objections cannot automatically constitute a valid reason to reopen; it also notes that where the AO acted under compulsion of audit findings, or merely abundant caution, the reopening is vulnerable. The High Court ultimately agrees with the assessee’s position, holding that substantial question of law framed in favor of the respondent; the Revenue’s appeal is dismissed, upholding the quashing of the reassessment.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.782/2012

B.K. Sreekumar v. Geetha and Others

This Kerala High Court MACA appeal arises from a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in OP(MV) No.1065 of 2004. On 12.02.2004, the appellant, a pillion rider on KL-7A-919, was injured when the motorcycle collided with another bike and was subsequently run over by a lorry, resulting in bilateral leg amputations. The Tribunal held 90% liability on the insurer of the lorry and 10% on the rider’s insurer, awarding Rs.4,97,985 with interest. The appellant challenges both liability apportionment and quantum, arguing composite negligence and urging that insurer liability should be for the entire compensation. The respondents contend that the accident involved contributory negligence by the motorcyclist and that the Tribunal’s award reflects fair compensation. In a detailed analysis of expert evidence, income, disability, medical treatment, and future needs, the High Court enhances compensation across several heads, considers the permanent disability as 88%, and adopts the principle of joint and several liability for tortfeasors. Citing Sajad Saheer and Khenyei, the Court rejects the 25% deduction from the insurer and holds the liability to be joint and several, directing payment by the Additional 6th respondent (New India Assurance Co. Ltd.) with liberty to recover 10% from the 4th respondent. The appeal is allowed with substantial enhancement in total compensation.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Appeal No. 2314 of 2008

Biju v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal arises from a judgment convicting the accused, Biju, under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 6500 ml of arrack in 65 plastic covers along a roadside on 14 November 2001. The trial court sentenced six months’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000. The prosecution’s case was that the contraband was seized by excise officials and the samples were sent for chemical examination. On appeal, the appellant challenged the conviction mainly on two grounds: (i) unexplained delay in producing the seized sample and other articles before the court; and (ii) failure to establish that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner in tamper-proof condition, i.e., a valid chain of custody. The judgment analyzes the seizure report, the property list, and the evidence about forwarding the sample, noting contradictions about the dates and the absence of examination of two excise guards who handled the sample. Relying on judicial pronouncements such as Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi and others, the court emphasizes strict compliance with sampling/sealing formalities and the necessity of proving a tamper-proof link to the laboratory. Ultimately, the court finds the link to the laboratory unreliable and acquits the appellant, setting aside the conviction and allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 392 OF 2012

Ranjesh Kumar v. Director General of Police & others

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, arising from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Punalur, in OP(MV) 987/2005. The appellant, Ranjesh Kumar, was injured on 5 March 2005 when his car KL-9A-4536 was struck by a jeep KL-01 B/5204 driven negligently by the 2nd respondent. He received treatment at the Government Medical College Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram, including an operation on 23 May 2005. The jeep owner was insured with the 3rd respondent; additional respondents were subsequent purchasers, and after the 5th respondent's death, his legal representatives were impleaded. The Tribunal allowed a portion of the petition and awarded Rs. 85,010 with interest and costs to be recovered from the insurer. The appellant challenges the quantum, contending that the Tribunal erred in fixing the notional income at Rs. 2,250 per month and in the calculation of losses for losing earnings and disability. He relies on Ramachandrappa (2011) to justify a higher notional income and on Sarla Verma (2009) to apply the correct multiplier and disability compensation. The respondents largely supported the Tribunal’s determination; the 3rd respondent admitted the policy coverage. The High Court, while upholding insurer liability, re-assessed the figures, increasing the notional income to Rs. 4,500 per month and the loss of earnings to Rs. 18,000, and, applying Sarla Verma, fixed disability at Rs. 86,400. The appeal was allowed in part, with an enhanced total of Rs. 49,500, 7.5% interest, and Rs. 5,000 costs, to be deposited within two months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.3944 OF 2023

Dee Pu v. State of Kerala and Amal

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC 3944/2023) filed in the Kerala High Court by accused Nos.1 to 3 in CC No.266/2020 (Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Nedumangadu, Forest Offences) seeking to invoke the inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC to quash criminal proceedings arising from Crime No.120/2020 of Palode Police Station, in which the petitioners were charged under IPC sections 341, 294(b), 323, and 324 read with 34. The record reveals that on 08.02.2020, the petitioners allegedly restrained and inflicted injuries on the de facto complainant, with the facts argued under private dispute. The petition asserts that the parties have amicably settled their disputes (Annexure B) and no longer wish to pursue prosecution, and requests termination of proceedings after recording the settlement. The investigating officer was directed to verify the genuineness of the settlement and to check for any antecedents or impediments to termination. While the Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, he acknowledged no other ongoing transgressions. The High Court, after considering the gravity of offenses, injuries, and the amicable settlement, held that quashing would not adversely affect society, aligns with ends of justice, and is appropriate where the dispute is private and the offenses are non-heinous. It allowed the petition, quashing the Final Report (Annexure-A) and all further proceedings in CC 266/2020.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2547 of 2008

Ouseph v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Appeal (CRL.A No. 2547 of 2008) arising from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing 3.5 litres of arrack on 04.02.2005 near Chalakudy–Palappilly road. The trial court, after trial, convicted the sole accused and imposed three years’ simple imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The High Court, however, examined the chain of custody and the reliability of the sample sent for Chemical Analysis. The prosecution failed to establish a tamper‑proof chain: the name of the official who forwarded the sample to the laboratory was not identified; Ext. P3 forwarding note lacked that information and the dates; the property clerk and the Excise guard who delivered the sample were not examined; the sample reportedly remained in the Court’s custody from 05.02.2005 to 17.02.2005, and the lab analysis (Ext. P12) post‑dated to 21.07.2006, with no satisfactory linkage showing that the seized contraband and the tested sample were one and the same. The court invoked Sasidharan, Sathi, Kumaran, Rajamma, Ravi, Krishnadas and related precedents to emphasize strict compliance with sampling/sealing and the necessity of showing the chain of custody. It held that the prosecution failed to prove the link between the contraband and the sample tested and that the unexplained delay undermined reliability. Result: benefit of doubt to the accused; conviction set aside; the accused acquitted; appeal allowed.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No.264 of 2015

K.C. HAMSA v. V.V. ABDULLA

This appeal arises from an order in O.S.383 of 2010 on the file of the Sub Court, Tirur, where a cheque for Rs.3,00,000 formed the basis of the plaintiff’s suit. The appellant, K.C. Hamsa, was previously noted as ex parte in 2014, and again, after deadlines were not met in 2015, an ex parte decree was passed on 08.06.2015. The respondent-plaintiff sought realisation of the debt by that decree. The appellant filed I.A.1132/2015 under Order IX Rule 13 CPC within the statutory period to set aside the ex parte decree, contending that his absence was not mala fide and that the court should exercise its discretion in his favour given the timely filing and the prior ex parte default. The Sub Court dismissed the application on 07.10.2015, finding the absence to be an attempt to protract the matter. The Kerala High Court, in allowing the appeal, held that the rule governing setting aside ex parte decrees under Order IX Rule 13 CPC must be liberally construed to do complete justice where no mala fides or intentional conduct is shown, especially when the application is within time, citing G.P. Srivastava, Peeves Enterprises, and Shivananda M. The court imposed a Rs.3,000 cost and directed the Sub Court to proceed with the suit expeditiously within four months, with appearance fixed for 03.07.2023.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO.639 OF 2019

Prathiba A. v. Niburaj B.R. and KSFE, Enathu Branch

This is a matrimonial appeal from Mat.Appeal No.639/2019 arising from a Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, which dissolved the marriage between the appellant-wife and the respondent-husband. The parties wed in 2014 under Hindu Ezhava rites. The husband filed for divorce in 2016 alleging cruelty; the Family Court granted a decree of dissolution. The appellant-wife challenged the decree in this High Court appeal, seeking not only dissolution but also the return of gold ornaments pledged by the husband with KSFE, Enathu Branch to secure a loan. KSFE was suo motu impleaded as an additional respondent to address the ornament dispute. The husband asserted that he had discharged the liability to KSFE, and that the ornaments could be released to the wife. The court noted that prolonged disputes over monetary claims can impede mutual separation, and it relied on Beena M.S. v. Shino G. Babu to emphasize that withholding consent for mutual separation under incompatible circumstances can itself constitute cruelty. The High Court, while upholding the Family Court’s dissolution, held that withholding consent, in the light of incompatibility, can constitute cruelty. It directed that the gold ornaments be released to the appellant-wife within a set timeframe and directed the Family Court to close related proceedings (OP No. 1660/2018), with no costs.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 12756 OF 2020

C.R. Badhran v. Radhakrishna Pillai P.K. and Kerala State Human Rights Commission

The petitioner, C.R. Badhran, challenges an order of the Kerala State Human Rights Commission (HRCP) in HRMP No. 4730/2018/TVM dated 27.02.2020 directing the District Police Chief to take steps to register an FIR and proceed with legal action against the petitioner for alleged dumping of sewage waste from a manhole in front of the complainant’s residence, and to conduct an enquiry into the matter. The writ petition contends that the HR Commission, by Ext. P4, acted without jurisdiction and that the remedy for police inaction lies in the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) under Section 156 or other CrPC provisions, not in a human-rights proceeding. The petitioner argues that the 1st respondent had alternative remedies under CrPC, and that Ext. P4 did not properly scrutinize Ext. P3, which showed the SHO recorded statements and found no cognizable offense. The respondents maintain that the HR Act, 1993, authorizes the Commission to inquire into violations of human rights and to issue directions, including directing FIRs, where cognizable offenses appear prima facie, citing Lalithakumari and Anandawardhan. The High Court analyzes the protections and powers conferred by the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, notes the relevant CrPC provisions cited in the pleadings, and concludes there is no patent illegality or arbitrariness in Ext. P4. The petition is dismissed, and the HR Commission’s order is upheld as valid and enforceable.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 2824 of 2023

: null

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. No. 2824 of 2023) before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam concerns eight petitioners/accused in Crime No. 1140 of 2022 registered at Pandalam Police Station, for offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324 read with Section 149 IPC. The petition, filed under Section 482 CrPC, seeks to quash the proceedings on the ground that the dispute between the accused and the defacto complainant/respondents has been amicably settled and that continued proceedings would be unnecessary and counterproductive to peace and justice. The Prosecution, via the Public Prosecutor, expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, noting the gravity of the alleged offences and the need to consider public interest. The High Court, after analyzing the governing law (State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh v. State of Punjab; Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab), held that quashing under 482 CrPC is permissible for non‑compoundable offences with predominantly civil characteristics where the entire dispute between parties is settled, provided concerns like antecedents, the nature of the injuries, and the overall impact on society are weighed. Relying on these authorities, the court concluded that the amicable settlement would not adversely affect society and that continuation of prosecution was unwarranted. Accordingly, the petition is allowed and Annexure-A1 FIR and all further proceedings against the petitioners are quashed, bringing peace and closure to the matter.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1826 of 2012

Shamil A. et al. v. Kuncheria George Proprietor, Prima Fuels, Antony K.M., Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.

This is an appeal under MACA No.1826 of 2012 before the Kerala High Court arising from an award of the First Additional MACT, Kollam, in O.P.(M.V)No.191/2007, concerning the death of Shajahan in a motor vehicle collision on 29.12.2006 between his autorickshaw (KL-2F-6573) and a container lorry (KL-43/2975). The Tribunal held the second respondent negligent and vicariously liable on behalf of the first respondent owner; the insurer was directed to indemnify. The claimants, the wife, five dependants, and parents, sought Rs.7,00,000 in total compensation. The tribunal awarded Rs.4,58,000 with 7.5% interest. On appeal, the appellants argued that the deceased’s monthly income was Rs.4,500 instead of Rs.3,000 used by the Tribunal, and urged 40% future prospects (in line with Pranay Sethi) for a younger deceased, with multiplication by a suitable multiplier. They also pressed for enhanced conventional heads (funeral, loss of estate, love and affection, and especially loss of consortium) consistent with evolving Supreme Court guidance, including the Magma line of expansion for consortium. The High Court, applying Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq for income and Sarla Verma/Pranay Sethi for compensation, computed a higher monthly income (6,300 after 40% future prospects) and applied a 17 multiplier, revising the loss of dependency and conventional heads. The court ultimately enhanced the total compensation to Rs.7,73,900 with 6% interest, directing the insurer to pay within two months and to deposit a portion for the minor until majority, with costs to be borne by parties.

High Court of Kerala
RCRev Nos.190 of 2018 and 196 of 2018

Zakkir Hussain v. Vijayamohan; Shameela Zakkir Hussain v. Vijayamohan (RC Rev. Nos.190/2018 and 196/2018)

This is a consolidated set of rent-control revision petitions under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 arising from eviction petitions (R.C.P. Nos. 14 and 15 of 2014) before the Rent Control Court, Kayamkulam, and consolidated for adjudication with the appellate order in RCA Nos. 8 and 9 of 2016. The landlord sought eviction on the ground of bona fide need to start a supermarket in the four premises comprising a commercial complex in Kayamkulam, with the adjoining space intended for a bakery. The tenants argued that the need was not bona fide, noting inconsistent pleadings (initially joint venture with the landlord’s wife, later a proprietary supermarket), and contended that vacant spaces in the complex could accommodate their business, thus undermining the bona fides. They also pressed the second proviso to Section 11(3) on the ground that they did not depend solely on income from the tenanted premises, and that other jewelleries in the locality were operated under the same name by others. The Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority found the need bona fide and dismissed the petitions on that ground. The High Court upheld those findings under Section 20, rejected the tenant’s contentions, and dismissed the revisions, but granted a one-year time to vacate with an unconditional undertakings and a staged rent schedule (1.25x in the later months). The judgment emphasizes that Section 20 review is confined to correcting illegality, irregularity, or perverse findings, and not reappreciation of evidence.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.4084 OF 2023

JIBIN, AJAY, ARUN, ANANTHU, VISHNU, SAVIN v. State of Kerala and Dinil Kumar

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC 4084/2023) filed under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash proceedings in CC No.3268/2017 (Ollur Police Station), Thrissur, arising from an FIR registered on 05.09.2017 under IPC sections 143, 147, 341, 323, 427, 294(b) read with Section 149. Accused Nos.2-7 (petitioners) contend that the matter has been amicably settled with the complainant; the 1st accused having expired. Annexure A3 (affidavit of the 2nd respondent) supports the settlement, and the Investigating Officer’s report was sought to verify genuineness and absence of impediments to terminating the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing solely on settlement and emphasized the need to consider whether the case involves disqualifying elements for exercise of inherent jurisdiction. The High Court relied on three-judge decisions culminating in settled principles: quashing under 482 is permissible where the offences are of civil/private nature, the dispute is resolved, and the offences are not heinous; yet not permissible for grave offences or public-serving crimes. After evaluating gravity, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the court held that quashing would not adversely affect society, and continued proceedings would be a waste of time. The petition was allowed; Annexure-A2 Final Report and proceedings in CC 3268/2017 were quashed, under 482 CrPC.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 2478 of 2023

MUHAMMED LUKHMAN, MAHAMOODKOTTAYI AND UNais P. v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC filed in the High Court of Kerala by three accused (petitioners) challenging the order in C.C. No. 61 of 2021, Judicial Magistrate of First Class-II, Hosdurg, for offences punishable under Section 341 and 324 read with Section 34 IPC. The petition states that the parties have settled all disputes amicably, and the injured has no ongoing grievance, supported by Annexure A4 affidavit. The court had earlier directed the investigating officer to record the victim’s statement and verify the genuineness of the settlement and the absence of any criminal antecedents among the petitioners. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing the proceedings solely on the basis of a settlement. Relying on the settled law (State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and pari materia cases such as Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and others), the court explains that Section 482 powers can quash non‑compoundable offences with predominantly civil character when the disputes are settled, except for heinous or societal crimes, and not for offences under special statutes. Weighing gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and private nature of the dispute, the court concludes that quashing would not harm society and would promote ends of justice. Consequently, Annexure A3 (Final Report) and all further proceedings in C.C. 61/2021 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.11825 of 2021

Joshy A. Chempparathy v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Muvattupuzha; Tahsildar (Land Records), Muvattupuzha; Village Officer, Manjalloor Village

In this Kerala High Court writ petition (W.P.(C) No.11825 of 2021) the petitioner, Joshy A. Chempparathy, challenges a notice under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, seeking payment for land classified as 'dry land' in the past. The land, measuring 13.59 ares in Sy.No.22/1-2-2-2 of Manjalloor Village, was historically converted from agricultural land via a Kerala Land Utilisation Order (KLU) Clause 6(2) order dated 27.11.1992, tied to a larger 16.19 ares that originated with Rajamma and later Suja Xavier. The petitioner argues that the land was dry long before the 2008 Act and that the KLU order dated 27.11.1992 effectively pre-dates the Act; he asserts that the file showing the order existed (Exts.P2 and P8), even though the file itself was destroyed, and that reassessment under Section 6A of the Land Tax Act, 1961 treating the land as dry land is appropriate. The respondents contend the KLU file is destroyed and that payment of a conversion fee (Rs. 4,23,360) is required; Ext.P9 shows the difficulty in determining genuineness of the KLU order. The court relies on decisions that fresh assessment under Section 6A is warranted when land is converted prior to the 2008 Act, and holds that the petition is maintainable. The petition is allowed, Ext.P9 is quashed, and the R2 and R3 authorities are directed to reassess and reclassify the land as 'purayidam' and correct revenue records, within two months of certified copy."

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.12267 of 2021

Green Pepper Resorts Pvt. Ltd. v. District Collector, Collectorate, Painavu, Idukki; Revenue Divisional Officer, Devikulam; Tahsildar, Devikulam; Village Officer, Pallivasal; Deputy Chief Engineer, Kerala State Electricity Board Limited; Assistant Engineer Electrical Sub Division, KSEB Ltd.

Green Pepper Resorts Pvt. Ltd., a hotel operator at Chithirapuram near Munnar, challenged the denial of converting its LT electricity supply to HT. The petitioner had constructed a hotel on Re-Sy No. 229/1/2 in Pallivasal village after obtaining a building permit in 2014. The contention is that the building permit and construction are distinct from obtaining an HT electrical connection, and that a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from revenue authorities is not a mandatory precondition for conversion; the decision should hinge on compliance with the Electricity Supply Code. The petitioner relied on Exts. P12 and P13 judgments showing similarly situated parties were granted HT conversion despite lacking NOC. The respondents argued the building was constructed without NOC and thus the petitioner has no right to service connection or conversion; the land is cultivated land and construction is prohibited by law, a position supported by Haridas R. v. State of Kerala and Others (2016 (5) KHC 615). The Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) indicated willingness to grant conversion subject to Court orders and completion certificates, and compliance with the electricity supply code. The court held that the petitioner could be entitled to HT conversion if the statutory requirements are met and directed the authorities to process the application within a time-bound period, while denying any equities on the basis of the judgment. The petition was disposed of accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.17021 of 2022

The Corporate Manager, T.D. Schools, Thuravoor, Alappuzha v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition questions Ext.P9, a Regional Deputy Director of Higher Secondary Education (RDD) order rejecting the petitioners’ request to appoint Maya G as Principal of the T.D. Higher Secondary School, Thuravoor. The1st petitioner, corporate manager of TD Schools, argues that the school is a linguistic minority institution under Article 30(1) of the Constitution, and thus the management has the right to nominate a qualified person as Principal, subject to standard qualifications. The petitioners contend Ext.P7 (1999) and Ext.P8 (1974) Government orders recognized the Konkani linguistic minority’s rights to select staff for institutions they run and that the government’s Ext.P9 cannot defeat those rights. They seek quashing Ext.P9 and mandamus to approve the 2nd petitioner’s appointment from 01.04.2020 on a regular basis with back wages, and to grant consequential service benefits. The respondents urge that minority status for Konkani language is not automatic in Kerala; Tamil and Kannada are the recognized minority languages there, and the 2004 Act (National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions) may require formal declaration. The court surveys authorities such as TM A Pai, Manager Corporate Educational Agency, N. Ammad, Azeez Basha, Bal Patil, P.A. Inamdar, St. Paul’s and others to uphold the core protection of Article 30(1): the management’s right to appoint a Principal is a fundamental facet of administration and cannot be invalidated by mere executive fiat. The court quashes Ext.P9 and directs approval of the 2nd petitioner as Principal with effect from 01.04.2020, treating the school as a minority institution, with back benefits and three-month compliance.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos.225/2015 & 2/2018

Lekshmi Traders ABKARI Contractors v. Commissioner of Income Tax

This Kerala High Court judgment relates to two connected ITA appeals filed by Lekshmi Traders ABKARI Contractors challenging block assessments and notices issued under Section 158BD for the block period 01.04.1988 to 23.02.1999, following a search under Section 132 at the premises of one R. Prasad (a partner in the assessee entity treated as an AOP). The appeals were heard together (ITA 225/2015 and ITA 2/2018). The core issue is whether the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) could consider an additional ground and whether the assessment framed under 158BD was valid in the absence of a recorded “satisfaction” by the assessing officer who conducted the search. The High Court relied on Calcutta Knitwears and AR Enterprises to emphasize that the statute’s machinery provisions must be interpreted to effectuate the object of the law, and that recording of satisfaction under Section 158BD is a sine qua non for initiating proceedings. CBDT Circular No. 24/2015 was cited to underscore strict compliance. The court found the non-recording of satisfaction to render the 158BD notice and block assessment illegal and set aside the assessment order in ITA 225/2015, while closing the accompanying petition in ITA 2/2018. The decision stresses strict adherence to the satisfaction requirement and the jurisdictional limits of the Tribunal, with preservation of the core remedies for the assessee.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No.1119 of 2015

Mary Margret v. Jos P Thomas

Mary Margret, a Christian wife, challenged a Family Court dissolution of marriage granted to her husband Jos P Thomas under the Divorce Act, 1869, in O.P.1339 of 2009. The Kerala High Court hears Mat.Appeal No.1119 of 2015 on 22 December 2021, delivering judgment on 21 January 2022. The Family Court found cruelty and desertion to be established and decreed divorce in 2015. The appellant contends that the evidence does not prove sustained mental cruelty or desertion; she asserts that the allegations of impulse control disorder came from a treating psychiatrist and that she was willing to undergo counselling and to reconcile. She claims long-standing cruelty by the husband and his mother and that she left the matrimonial home in 2005 due to coercive acts and injunction suits rather than a voluntary desertion. The respondent argues that the appellant subjected him to repeated abusive and violent conduct, including threats to kill, and that she deserted in 2005 and never returned. The High Court reconsiders the factual matrix, applying well-known authorities on mental cruelty (Samar Ghosh), and notes the long separation from 2005 onward, with the children staying with the husband. It concludes that there was no error in the Family Court’s findings and dismisses the appeal, affirming the divorce and costs to be borne by the parties.

High Court of Kerala
M.A.C.A.No.1909-2012

Job Thaddeus K.A. v. Aliyar, V.K. Krishnan, The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.

Job Thaddeus K.A., the claimant in OP(MV) No.75/2007 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, appeals the Tribunal’s quantum of compensation for injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident on 02 January 2006. The auto-rickshaw involved, owned by Respondent 1 and insured by Respondent 3, collided with the claimant’s motorcycle driven by the second respondent; the driver and insurer are the key respondents in the appeal. The Tribunal held the second respondent negligent and awarded Rs. 2,54,284 together with interest and costs. The appellant contends that the compensation is inadequate, and that the Tribunal erred in not applying the correct notional income and multiplier. The appellant claimed a monthly income of Rs 4,500 as a landscaper; the Tribunal fixed a notional income of Rs 3,500. Relying on Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram, the court re-fixes the notional monthly income at Rs 4,500, consistent with the year 2006. It then recalculates loss of earnings, bystander expenses, extra nourishment, pain and sufferings, loss of amenities, and disability, resulting in a total enhanced award of Rs 3,04,859. The court adopts the Sarla Verma multiplier of 15. All other heads are reassessed in line with the established precedents. The appeal is allowed; enhanced compensation of Rs 50,575, with interest at 6% p.a. from the date of petition to deposit, plus Rs 1,000 costs, and the third respondent to deposit the enhanced sum within 60 days for disbursement to the appellant.”,