Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 456 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Cus.Appeal Nos.9/2022 to 15/2022; WP(C) Nos.9058/2022 & 27835/2021

Ashwin Gold Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Preventive)

This is a consolidated judgment of the Kerala High Court (Division Bench) delivering the common judgment on Cus.Appeal Nos. 9/2022 to 15/2022 and WP(C) Nos. 9058/2022 and 27835/2021, decided on 22 December 2022. The core issue is the legality and correctness of the CESTAT order dated 17.02.2022 in Final Order No.20057/2002 and related orders, which had quashed or modified several actions by the Revenue under the Customs Act, 1962 and the SEZ Act, 2005. The court examined the jurisdictional interface between the SEZ regime (Development Commissioner, Cochin SEZ) and the Customs Act where gold moved from SEZ to the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA), leading to seizures, confiscations, and penalties. The CESTAT’s approach treated SEZ actions as subsuming or limiting the powers of Customs authorities in DTA, which the High Court reversed on a jurisdictional overreach basis. It held that the Customs authorities retain jurisdiction in offences detected in DTA and that SEZ actions seek to cancel permissions and impose penalties independently. The judgment remits the relevant matters to the CESTAT for fresh consideration, sets aside several appellate orders, and directs appropriate relief including provisional release of 4 kg of gold after due process, with Bill of Entry and duty considerations to be addressed. The decision clarifies the split between SEZ enforcement and Customs enforcement in cross-border-like movements involving SEZs and DTAs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases v. State of Kerala & Others (High Court of Kerala, Raja Vijayaraghavan V)

These writ petitions, filed by Managers of private aided higher secondary schools, challenge Government Order GO(MS) No.121/2022 dated 07.07.2022 and the accompanying prospectus for Plus One admission for 2022-23. The core dispute concerns the division of seats in PAHS between management quota, community quota and open merit, and specifically the Government’s 20% management quota and the directive that management declare the community to which the school belongs, with a 10% community quota reserved for that community. Petitioners contend the GO and prospectus violate constitutional guarantees, particularly Articles 14 and 15, by creating an impermissible community-based reservation and by undermining the autonomy of secular educational institutions. They argue there is no vested right to a 30% management quota, and the 10% community quota is arbitrary and discriminatory. Respondents defend the policy as a rational, uniform correction of historical anomalies in admissions, aimed at merit-based selection and transparency via the Centralized Admission Process (CAP). The court undertakes a detailed historical and constitutional analysis, upholding the 20% management quota but striking down the 10% community quota as unconstitutional, directing that such seats be treated as open merit seats to be allotted via CAP, and noting admissions already made shall not be disturbed. The petitions are disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.Appeal (C) No.8 of 2021

VIDHYA MUNDEKKAT vs AKHILESH JAYARAM

This intra-court transfer appeal under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958 challenges a 01.07.2021 order of a Single Judge dismissing a CPC Section 24 transfer petition. The appellant, wife of the respondent, sought to transfer ongoing Family Court proceedings (O.P. Nos. 354/2019 for restitution of conjugal rights and 749/2020 for dissolution of marriage) from Kozhikode to the Family Court at Chavara. The appellant asserts that her permanent residence has shifted to Karunagappally, Kollam, making the 330-km travel to Kozhikode unduly burdensome and that the Family Court, Chavara would be a more convenient forum. The respondent counters that the appellant’s permanent residence remains in Kozhikode and that the transfer would prejudice his rights, including visitation. The court reminds that Section 5(i) appeals should be exercised with caution, citing Balan v. Sivagiri Sree Narayana Dharma Sanghom Trust, and notes that each petition should be decided on its merits, not on automatic convenience for one party. The bench considers relevant authorities on transfer petitions and the use of video conferencing under pandemic-era guidelines, ultimately upholding the Single Judge’s jurisdictional finding and dismissing the transfer appeal, while endorsing use of video linkage to minimize travel burdens.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 35613 of 2019 & WP(C) No. 14191 of 2021

Fr. A. V. Varghese v. State of Kerala and Others (WP(C) Nos. 35613 of 2019 & 14191 of 2021)

This common judgment deals with a protracted church dispute involving St. Marthasmooni Church, Thiruvarppu, and factions of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church (Orthodox and Jacobite). The petitioner, Fr. A. V. Varghese, claims to be the Vicar of the 7th respondent church, appointed under the Malankara Church Constitution of 1934. Respondents challenge this position, contending that certain priests/personalities (respondents 8–15) align with a parallel 2002 constitution adopted by a faction known as the Yacobaya Suriyani Christiani Sabha, and thus dispute the authority of the petitioner’s appointment. The suit before the Munsiff Court (O.S.654/2017) sought a permanent injunction vis‑à‑vis the 8–13 defendants, with interim orders restricting non‑1934 appointments from administering sacraments in the church. Aggressive inter‑factional actions and non‑compliance with civil court orders led to police protection orders (Ext P3 and Ext P5), which the District Administration and Police failed to implement for two years, triggering the writ petitions. The Kerala High Court emphasizes that court orders must be obeyed and that the rule of law requires immediate compliance with Ext P3 and its affirmations by higher authorities. It holds that the 1934 Constitution continues to govern Malankara Church matters and directs the District Collector, District Police Chief, and State Police Chief to ensure implementation, reopen the church, and provide police protection to allow lawful religious services under the 1934 framework, while preserving the right to challenge in court if aggrieved.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases - Judgment of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The judgment of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, delivered by Justice T.R. Ravi on 26 March 2024, consolidates WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and a large batch of connected petitions challenging police/Cyber Crime Department and National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal freezes of bank accounts. Petitioners alleged unlawful or disproportionate freezing of accounts in metrics ranging from bonafide personal or business transactions to suspected cybercrime proceeds. The court scrutinized interim freezes and directed banks to confine freezes strictly to the amounts mentioned in police requisitions, relying on established jurisprudence including Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and related orders. The order requires police to inform Banks about continuation of freezes, and if continuation is necessary, not beyond a period of eight months from the judgment copy. The court observed the need to balance anti-crime objectives with the petitioners’ right to access their funds, especially where transactions may be bona fide. The petitions are disposed of with directions to limit freezes to the disputed sums and to enable petitioners to operate accounts beyond those sums, while preserving the authorities’ right to pursue the case. The decision reaffirms a proportionality approach to freezing powers in cybercrime-related financial cases.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos.77/2021 & 78/2021

Imperial Spirits Ltd. v. State of Kerala (OT.Rev Nos. 77/2021 & 78/2021)

The two connected O.T.Revisions (Nos. 77/2021 and 78/2021) were heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court (S. V. Bhatti, J., and Basant Balaji, J.) arising from common orders dated 03.02.2021 of the KVAT Appellate Tribunal, Kozhikode, in two assessments for the year 2011-12. Imperial Spirits Ltd challenged the Tribunal’s tax decisions, including the imposition of tax on the estimated value of de-mineralized water and the inclusion of interest receipts (Rs. 1,86,74,437/-) in turnover. The petitioner contended that taxation of interest income and its inclusion as turnover is illegal under the KVAT Act, 2003. The State defended the revisions, arguing that Section 63 permits the High Court to entertain revisions only when the Appellate Tribunal or Commissioner has decided erroneously or failed to decide a question of law, and that such grounds should have been raised before the Tribunal. While the petitioner argued that the ground is a pure question of law and should be entertainable due to remittance, the Court examined the relevant authorities, notably the binding principle established in Kerala Distilleries & Allied Products (P) Ltd, and related precedents, and held that revisions cannot be entertained for questions not raised before the Tribunal. Consequently, the revisions were dismissed. The order reflects a cautionary stance on revisiting questions of law outside the Tribunal’s record, reinforcing the limited revisional jurisdiction under KVAT.

High Court of Kerala
A.S. Nos.490 & 530 of 1990

Radha (Chalil Parambath Radha) v. Sreejith alias Abhilash and others

This is a common judgment of the Kerala High Court delivering on A.S. Nos. 490 and 530 of 1990, arising from a 1988 partition suit (O.S. No. 3 of 1988) in Tellicherry. The plaintiff, Radha, widow of the deceased Radhakrishnan, claimed a share in ancestral ( plaint A schedule items 1 and 2 ) and self‑acquired ( plaint A schedule items 3 and 4 ) properties. The 9th defendant, Sreejith alias Abhilash (a minor represented by his mother Leela), claimed a share under Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act, asserting that the late Radhakrishnan and Leela had a marriage/relationship that produced him. The trial court decreed partition in favour of Radha but the appellate bench found issues because several defendants had died and their heirs needed impleading, remitting the matter for reconsolidation. The High Court, after addressing the death of several parties and the proper impleadment of legal heirs, examined the central question: whether the 9th defendant can claim rights under Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act for a child born in a void/voidable marriage scenario, and how those rights attach to the properties. The Court drew on Shyamalavalli Amma v. Kavalam Jisha and Jayachandran v. Valsala to hold that solemnisation/relationship may suffice for purposes of Section 16, and that the illegitimate child can obtain a right against the parents’ property in certain contexts, while distinguishing between ancestral and self‑acquired property. The judgment ultimately sets aside the trial court decree, allows partition, and recognizes one share to the 9th defendant, with detailed distribution among other heirs and costs.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 6152 OF 2024

Deva Harshan v. State of Kerala

Deva Harshan, the fifth accused in Crime No.565/2024 of Kodakara Police Station, Thrissur, petitions for bail under Section 483 of BNSS before the Kerala High Court. The FIR dated 01.07.2024 relates to alleged offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 294(b), 506 and 307 r/w 34, arising from an incident on 30.06.2024 around 19:00 hours, where the accused, in furtherance of a common intention, allegedly formed an unlawful assembly; the 1st accused allegedly inflicted a cut with a sword, the 2nd a head injury with a chopper, the 3rd a blow to the left eye with a knuckle duster, with others aiding. The petitioner asserts innocence, contends no material ties him to the 307 act, and notes he has been in judicial custody for 30 days with investigation practically complete and recovery effected; he also asserts no criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing risk of witness intimidation and tampering, given the brutal nature and the 46 antecedents of the 1st accused. The court cites the presumption of innocence (Sanjay Chandra), the rule that bail is the general rule and jail the exception (Dataram Singh), and the protective force of Article 21. After weighing circumstances—30 days in custody, completed investigation, recovery, lack of antecedents—the court grants bail, with Rs 50,000 bond and two sureties, and imposes conditions on appearance, non-interference, non-offence, passport surrender, and potential cancellation for violations, citing Sushila Aggarwal as to bail on conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 13607 OF 2022

Moideen Kutty Kannayilkkal v. National Highways Authority of India and Others

This writ petition challenges Ext. P4 Award under the National Highways Act (NH Act) regarding land acquired for the National Highway project. The petitioner alleges that 6% salvage was unfairly deducted from compensation and that, despite informing CALA that he would not remove the remnants of the building, the Salvage deduction was maintained in the award. He seeks setting aside of the impugned portion of Ext. P4 and directs CALA to include salvage in the final compensation. The respondents argue that once CALA issues an Award, its role is functus officio, with the remedy lying in Section 3G(5) of the NH Act before the Statutory Arbitrator; this position is anchored in Usman Arif v. Project Director (2022(1) KLT 35). The court agrees that CALA cannot reconsider the award in a writ petition, but notes that the petitioner seeks modification, not a fresh challenge, and therefore should be directed to pursue the Statutory Arbitrator under 3G(5). The judge directs that the petitioner be given liberty to file before the Statutory Arbitrator within one month, with the Arbitrator to afford hearing to the NHAI officials if required, and to consider the matter expeditiously. The judgment also references Mohammad Salahuddin and another vs. Special Deputy Collector for guidance on salvage and timelines. The court leaves room for the petitioner to raise valuation concerns at the time of such reference, and to approach the Court again after eight months if no final orders are issued.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No.6091 of 2024

Bail Application No. 6091 of 2024 (Crime No. 540/2024, Venjaramoodu PS) v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, on 2 August 2024, in B.A. No. 6091 of 2024, allowed bail to the sole accused in Crime No. 540/2024 of Venjaramoodu Police Station under the POCSO Act. The applicant, the cousin of a 9-year-old victim, faced charges under sections 8 r/w 7 and 10 r/w 9(1)(l)(m)(n) of the POCSO Act; the accused was arrested on 14.04.2024 and remanded. The prosecution alleges aggravated sexual assault between May and December 2023 and contends that release could lead to intimidation or tampering with witnesses. The court noted that Section 29 of the POCSO Act does not allow a presumption of innocence to be drawn in favour of the accused, but also highlighted that the investigation is complete, the final report is filed (11.05.2024), and the accused has no prior criminal record, with custody totaling about 110–120 days. Relying on Dataram Singh, State v. Raneef, Hussainara Khatoon and Sushila Aggarwal, the court reaffirmed the bail principle under Article 21, and granted bail with stringent conditions: bond of Rs 1 lakh with two solvent sureties, appearance before the Investigating Officer on alternate Saturdays, restrictions on contacting witnesses, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, territorial limits, and potential for cancellation on breach. The order stresses it does not decide merits.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal Nos. 221/2018; 222/2018; 224/2018; 225/2018

Sreejith v. Sudhina (Mat.Appeal Nos. 221/2018; 222/2018; 224/2018; 225/2018)

These four matrimonial appeals, heard together by a division bench of the Kerala High Court, arise from OP Nos. 412–415 of 2017, filed in Family Court, Ottappalam and Kannur. The central issue across the four matters was the validity and terms of matrimonial relief—restitution of conjugal rights in OP 414/2017; return of gold ornaments and money in OPs 413 and 415/2017; and divorce on the ground of cruelty in OP 412/2017. The Family Court’s orders dated 08 January 2018 were challenged under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984. In the course of proceedings, the matter was placed before mediation; on 09 November 2022 the parties entered into a memorandum of settlement, which included a mutual consent divorce, waiving the cooling period under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and leaving the MOA terms to form part of the judgment. The High Court, noting that the disputes had been genuinely settled and the parties had been living apart since 2017, held that the six-month cooling period could be dispensed with in these circumstances, and proceeded to grant a decree of divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B. The appeals are disposed of in terms of the memorandum of agreement.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).6752/2023

W.P.(C).6752/2023 & connected matters (Hartals in Kerala) - In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, Division Bench of Dr. Justice A.K. Jayasankaran Nambiar and Mr. Justice Mohammed Nias C.P.

This flagship Kerala High Court judgment deals with petitions challenging the legality and handling of hartals (including flash hartals) and the attendant state measures in Kerala, culminating in a comprehensive set of interim and final directions. The court recalls that while the right to protest is safeguarded under the Constitution, a hartal must not infringe others’ fundamental rights. It emphasizes a balancing of rights under Article 19(1)(a) and Article 21, citing Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India to justify prioritizing collective public interest when conflicts arise. The judgment notes that calls for flash hartals, particularly on 23.09.2022 by the Popular Front of India, led to widespread violence and destruction of public/private property, including KSRTC losses, and that the State must take measures to protect non-participants. Interim orders direct the state to deposit Rs.5.2 crores within two weeks, attach assets of the 12th and 13th respondents and related office bearers under the Revenue Recovery Act, and empower a Claims Commissioner to quantify damages. It also directs release of any wrongly attached properties and mandates safeguarding arrangements for the Claims Commissioner, while ordering no sale of attached properties until adjudication is complete. The petitions 222/244 of 2019 receive ongoing interim treatment, and other connected writ petitions are disposed subject to these directions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.35456 of 2023

Ajithkumar P and others v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation and others

The petitioners are former employees of the Kerala State Road Transport Corporation who retired in 2022 and 2023. They seek immediate disbursement of Provident Fund (PF) closure amounts and the Staff Welfare Fund that were deducted from their salaries during service but have not been paid on retirement. They argue these funds are employee contributions and their non-disbursement causes severe financial hardship, including medical expenses, and leaves them dependent on private loans in retirement. They anchor their claim on constitutional rights and on precedents such as Soman v. K.S.R.T.C and D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, contending that withholding terminal benefits undermines pensioners’ financial stability and dignified life after retirement. The petition references a Division Bench directive in W.A. No. 289 of 2001, which ordered earmarking 10% of daily collections for retirement benefits, maintaining a separate fund, and regular reporting to the court, among other safeguards. The respondents contend the KSRTC faces financial constraints and is implementing directions already issued by the Court for retirees, with further disbursement subject to readiness of funds. Upon consideration, the Court emphasizes the pensioners’ reliance on terminal benefits and holds that disbursement is owed. It directs the respondents to disburse PF closure with statutory interest and the Staff Welfare Fund within four months from receipt of the judgment, disposing of the petition.”

High Court of Kerala
DBP No.17 of 2024 & W.P.(C)No.2783 of 2024

Travancore Devaswom Board - Thrikkaviyoor Mahadeva Temple – Suo Motu Proceedings regarding Temple Advisory Committee, DBP No.17 of 2024 & WP(C) No.2783 of 2024

This combined DBP 17/2024 and WP(C) 2783/2024 concerns the Thrikkaviyoor Mahadeva Temple and alleged irregularities in the Temple Advisory Committee (TAC), a body constituted under Section 31A of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, and its bye-laws approved by the Court. Suo motu proceedings were initiated on 06.02.2024 based on complaints dated 02.02.2024 and 03.02.2024 by temple devotees. WP(C)2783/2024 seeks mandamus against respondents to take action under Clause 18 of the bye-laws against the TAC and to consider representations dated 23.11.2023. The State and Travancore Devaswom Board justify the governance framework, citing an ongoing police complaint against TAC, the absconding TAC president with Rs.4.5 lakh, resignation of seven members, and a Board-ordered detailed enquiry by the Chief Vigilance and Security Officer. The court analyzes Sections 31A(1)-(3) and the bye-laws, including Clauses 2 (objectives), 3 (membership), 9 (officers), 12 (Board’s powers), and 18 (prohibitions), alongside Sunil Kumar C. and others v. Travancore Devaswom Board (2022 (4) KHC 663). It directs the convening of a new TAC within three weeks, places temple activities under the ADCS and Group Officer pending audit, and requires action under the rules with Ombudsman oversight within three months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 73 of 2020; 126 of 2020; 97 of 2020; 100 of 2020

M.A. Latheef v Pallikkere Islamic Education Society & Others (WP(C) Nos. 73/2020; 126/2020; 97/2020; 100/2020), High Court of Kerala

The four writ petitions filed by M.A. Latheef, Secretary of Pallikkere Islamic Education Society, challenge the orders of the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, which had held that teachers of Pallikkere School were employees and that the Society was the employer, directing payment of gratuity on the last drawn wages for periods of service. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeals on the ground that they were filed beyond the statutory period under Section 7(7) of the Act. A previous common judgment dated 22.03.2019 in WP(C) No. 2198/2019 and connected cases directed disposal of the appeals within a time frame, a direction the petitioners later sought to invoke. The petitioner argued that the orders were per se without application of mind, and that teachers cannot be treated as employees under the Act, especially since evidence such as attendance registers and verification of continuous service (240 days) had not been adequately produced. The respondents argued that teaching staff fall within the definition of ‘Employee’ under Section 2(e) and that the school constitutes the ‘Employer’ under Section 2(f), with reliance on the welfare purpose of the Act and material on record. The Court ultimately held no grounds to interfere, dismissing the petitions with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
RP 1256 of 2022 in WA 267 of 2022

RP No.1256 of 2022 in WA No.267 of 2022

This review petition challenges the Kerala High Court’s 23 August 2022 judgment in WA No.267 of 2022, which held that appointments in private colleges under the State Direct Payment Scheme can only be sanctioned from the date of government sanction, i.e., 30 December 2020, even though workload existed earlier. The petitioners—Poornima C.C. and Kavitha V. Rajan—were appointed as Assistant Professors (Not Approved) in Malayalam and Hindi at Cochin College and joined on 24 January 2018. The college sought sanction of posts from 2018, but the University insisted that posts could be sanctioned only with effect from 30 December 2020, leading to refusal to regard earlier appointments as valid salary-bearing posts. The petitioners argued that the University should backdate approval to their join date given sufficient workload, and that UGC Regulations 2010 require contract appointments only when absolutely necessary and when student–teacher ratios justify it; they contended UGC norms should prevail over conflicting statutory provisions. The State supported the WA judgment, and the Single Judge’s view was reversed, dismissing the writ petition. The present review petitions argue that Section 59(1) of the Mahatma Gandhi University Act and UGC Regulations are not in conflict, but the court rejects this, reaffirming the State’s prerogative to sanction posts and to protect public funds. The petition is ultimately dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. NO. 9053 OF 2023

Bala Devan v. State of Kerala & Others

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case challenges Annexure-X, an order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur, dismissing the petitioner’s petition under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. The petitioner is Charge Witness No.1 in C.C. No.121/2012 and sought reinvestigation to include additional accused, since earlier orders directed further investigation but the main culprits were not included in the supplementary charge sheet. The learned Magistrate relied on a Supreme Court decision in Vinubhai Haribhai Malaviya and Others v. State of Gujarat & Another (2019 KLJ 429), and held that, with trial already commenced, a Section 173(8) petition is not maintainable before the Magistrate. The High Court notes that the trial has begun and, on that basis, finds no reason to interfere with Annexure-X. However, it offers a practical route: the petitioner may submit a representation narrating the additional materials to include other accused within ten days from receipt of a certified copy of this order; the Investigating Officer will consider and decide within one month and communicate the result. Until final orders are passed, the trial in CC-121/2012 shall be deferred; the IO’s decision will also be communicated to the Magistrate. The order thereby channels the process for adding accused through the IO rather than further magistrate proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2953 OF 2008; CO NO. 53 OF 2021

MACA 2953/2008 and C.O. 53/2021

This common judgment disposed of an appeal (MACA No.2953/2008) filed by the Tamil Nadu State Road Transport Corporation Ltd. against an award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda, in O.P.(MV) No.1027/2001, and the connected cross-objection (C.O. No.53/2021) filed by the claimants-turned-cross objectors. The accident occurred on 5 March 2001, killing the breadwinner aged about 43; dependents claimed Rs.6,81,000 in compensation. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition, awarding Rs.2,85,000 against the corporation and insurer, while holding the petitioners 4 and 5 (the deceased’s parents) not to be dependents. The appellant contended lack of opportunity to contest on merits due to an ex parte order and argued excessive compensation. The cross objectors sought enhanced compensation, challenging the Tribunal’s notional income, multiplier, and heads of damages under Pranay Sethi, Sarala Verma, and other authorities. The High Court upheld the principle of just compensation, applying established precedents to recompute the loss of dependency as Rs.4,72,500, adjust future prospects, deduct personal living expenses, and revise conventional heads. It also disallowed love-and-affection under the changed facts. Ultimately, MACA is dismissed and CO is allowed, with a further enhanced compensation of Rs.3,49,000 and conditions for deposit and costs.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.REV.NO.99 OF 2021

Prasanth K.P. v. Kunhabdulla and Dr. Jamsheer Abdulla P.K.

This Rent Control Revision arises from eviction petitions under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The petitioner-tenant, Prasanth K.P., challenges the Rent Control Appellate Authority’s order dated 26 February 2021, which dismissed I.A.1/2020 seeking condonation of delay of 245 days in filing R.C.A. No. 91/2020, thereby denying the appeal as time-barred. The underlying Rent Control Court had, by its order dated 03 January 2020, allowed R.C.P. No. 13 of 2019 filed by landlords seeking eviction of the petition schedule shop room on grounds including a rent deed dated 05 October 2017 fixing rent at Rs. 36,000 per month. The Appellate Authority’s cryptic order failed to consider the tenant’s explanation for delay or the landlords’ objections, labeling the petitioner a defaulter in rent payment and holding the long delay cannot be condoned. The High Court, invoking liberal yet reasonable interpretation of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, emphasizes that while delay can be condoned for sufficient cause, it cannot be abused. Citing Katiji, Esha Bhattacharjee, Shukla and Brothers, Woolcombers, English v. Emery Reimbold, and related authorities, the Court holds that reasons must accompany orders and that a revisional court’s jurisdiction cannot be rendered nugatory by cryptic orders. The revision is allowed, with remand to the Appellate Authority for fresh, reasoned consideration of I.A.1/2020 in R.C.A.No.91/2020 within a specified period (by 22.09.2021).

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. 8367 of 2023

Tomy Abraham v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No. 8367 of 2023) concerns Tomy Abraham, the applicant, challenging an Annexure-III order that dismissed his Cr.P.C. Section 451 application for interim custody of a seized Honda Jazz (Reg. No. KL-30-G-1071) linked to Crime No. 24/2023 of the Excise Range Office, Pala, under offences under the NDPS Act (sections 20(b)(ii)(A), 29 and 60(3)). The Magistrate’s dismissal rested on the premise that the NDPS Act prescribes the disposal of the article and the vehicle, leaving no jurisdiction to entertain such interim custody. The High Court examines the issue through stare decisis, citing Shanil v. State of Kerala (2023) (2) KHC 88) and the Division Bench decision in Shajahan v. Inspector of Excise and Others (2019 (4) KLT 507). It elaborates that the jurisdictional courts have power to grant interim custody under Cr.P.C. 457, even where NDPS disposal procedures are concerned, with inventory under S.52A not restricting such custody. The Court also relies on Wilson C.C. v. State of Kerala and Sainaba v. State of Kerala to illustrate circumstances where vehicles linked to contraband can be treated in light of interim custody or release to owners. Consequently, the petition is allowed; Annexure-III is set aside and the matter is remitted to reconsider CMP 1638/2023 in light of these authorities.