Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 455 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 6063 OF 2024

FARZIN P P v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Farzin P P, the third accused in Crime No.697/2024 of Kannur Town Police Station, Kannur, pending before the Special Court (NDPS Act Cases), Vadakara. The accused were arrested on 20.06.2024 for allegedly possessing 3.72 grams of ganja and 5.60 grams of MDMA in a hotel room, with the contraband recovered on the spot. The offences alleged are under NDPS Act sections 20(b)(ii)(A) and 22(b) read with Section 29. The petitioner contends innocence, false implication, and asserts that he has no criminal antecedents and has already remained in judicial custody since 20.06.2024. He argues that the contraband constitutes an intermediate quantity and that the investigation is practically complete, with the recovery already effected; therefore, further detention is unnecessary. The State opposes bail, noting ongoing investigation and asserting concerns about reoffending, though conceding absence of antecedents and the intermediate quantity. After careful consideration of these factors—intermediate quantity, lack of antecedents, lengthy custody, and near-completion of the investigation—the High Court grants bail. The court directs bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, and imposes conditions including weekly appearances before the IO, prohibition on inducement or tampering with evidence, non-commission of any offence, passport surrender, and potential cancellation for violation. The order cites a Supreme Court principle from Sushila Aggarwal regarding police powers to investigate and recover even during bail.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 26473 OF 2012

M.S. Raveendranathan v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd and others

This writ petition by M.S. Raveendranathan, an erstwhile Assistant Manager of Indian Oil Corporation, challenges the enquiry report, the disciplinary proceedings and the dismissal following an internal investigation into a truck load operation at Kochi. On 29 August 2009, while on second shift duty, a tank truck loaded with motor spirit and High Speed Diesel was found to have excess quantities, leading to his suspension and a charge sheet dated 05.10.2009 for misconduct including dishonesty, acting in a manner prejudicial to the corporation, and acts subversive of discipline. An Enquiry Officer, after recording evidence from two IOCL witnesses and the petitioner’s driver, held the charges proved. The Disciplinary Authority issued a show cause, rejected the petitioner’s explanation, and imposed dismissal; the statutory appeal also upheld the dismissal. The petitioner contends that dismissal stigmatizes him and is disproportionate; at most a minor penalty (stoppage of increments with cumulative effect) or compulsory retirement would have been appropriate given his age (52). He argues that losses were not established, cross-examination was inadequately afforded, and automation fault at the filling station undermined the finding of extra fuel. The court, citing Union of India v. Sunil Kumar and Rajasthan Heem Singh, reiterates that judicial review in disciplinary matters is restrained and interference is warranted only where findings are based on no evidence or are perversely disproportionate. On merits, the court finds no perversity and disposes of the petition by upholding the dismissal, dismissing the writ petition as devoid of merit.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1705 of 2022

Writ Appeal No.1705 of 2022

This writ appeal challenges a Kerala High Court order regarding gratuity payable to two former employees of the Muliyar Service Co-operative Bank. The appellants contended they were entitled to gratuity beyond the cap fixed in Section 4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, arguing a higher amount had been paid by LIC in respect of gratuity for the policy taken by the Society and, under Rule 59 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, better terms may apply. They relied on the Full Bench decision Chandrasekharan Nair G. v. Kerala State Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. (2017) to claim entitlement to higher amounts released by LIC, seeking to override the statutory cap. The 3rd respondent contended there must be a separate agreement or instrument providing a better term for Section 4(5) to apply; otherwise the statutory cap prevails, and LIC’s payments reflect the actual disbursed amounts. The Court analysed Rule 59 and its provisos, noting that Rule 59 can yield higher gratuity than the cap where the Act’s overriding provisions permit, as per the Full Bench decision, and concluded that the 1st appellant is entitled only to Rs.3,50,000 (as per the Act at retirement) while the 2nd appellant is entitled to Rs.10,43,955 (last drawn pay x 15 months, capped at 15 months). The Court ordered payment of an additional Rs.43,955 with statutory interest and directed disbursement within a month.

High Court of Kerala
OP(CRL.) NO. 662 OF 2022

Suresh K v Vasantha K and Akshay S

This is an Original Petition (Criminal) under Article 227 of the Constitution of India filed by Suresh K challenging Exts.P12 to P15 orders of the Family Court, Palakkad, in MC No.330/2011. The Family Court had dealt with maintenance arrears arising from OP No.590/2015 and MC No.330/2011, granting past and future maintenance to the respondents and ordering adjustments in execution. As on 22.12.2022, the petitioner claimed a balance of Rs.42,700 (Rs.10,000 deposited), while counsel for the respondents contended, based on nine CMPs filed to execute the MC, that the outstanding balance was Rs.3,40,000. The petitioner asserted that the sale of his property was used to offset past maintenance and that the balance after such adjustments should be payable only as future maintenance up to a specified date; he also claimed that the decree in OP No.590/2015 and MC No.330/2011 had effectively become final, so adjustments required a proper legal route. The respondents argued the adjustment was improper because the decree had finality and the remedy was to set aside the decree itself. The High Court directs that the adjustment issue be decided in light of settled law, citing Rajnesh v. Neha, and remands to the Family Court for afresh adjudication. It sets a two-week deadline for the petitioner to clear Rs.41,720 and directs appearance on 02.02.2023, with a copy of the order to the Family Court for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos.747/2019, 1061/2019, 1146/2019

WA Nos. 747/2019, 1061/2019 and 1146/2019; Sheen Golden Jewels (India) Pvt Ltd; Bhima Boutique Private Limited; Alappat Gold Den Private Limited v State of Kerala

These three writ appeals challenge Section 174(2) of the Kerala Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (KSGST Act) and the saving provisions enacted to preserve pre-GST liabilities under the KVAT regime during the transition to GST. The batch arises in the wake of the constitutional amendments introducing GST (One Nation, One Tax) via the 101st Amendment Act and the Central–State amendments in the Constitution, notably Article 246A. The Kerala legislature repealed KVAT Act and related acts, while Section 19 of the Constitution (One Hundred and First) Amendment Act, 2016 (CAA 2016) introduced a sunset/saving framework to permit continuance of laws inconsistent with the amended Constitution for a limited period and, optionally, their repeal or amendment thereafter. The High Court examines (i) whether Section 174(2) is ultra vires, (ii) whether the saving provision enables revival of rights accrued before 16.09.2016, and (iii) whether Section 19 permits the State Legislature to enact saving clauses. After a detailed survey of constitutional and statutory provisions, and comparing precedents, the court holds that Section 174(2) is within the competence of the State Legislature under Section 19 of CAA 2016, and that saving clauses may preserve pre-GST rights and ongoing proceedings. The appeals are dismissed, with liberty to dealers to pursue remedies within eight weeks; no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WA 437 OF 2025

P.A. ABRAHAM AND OTHERS v. B.N. SHYAMKUMAR AND OTHERS

This judgment of a Division Bench (Amit Rawal, J. and K. V. Jayakumar, J.) delivers a common adjudication in WA No. 437 of 2025 and connected WP(C) Nos. 1307/2025, 2902/2025, and 3398/2025 arising from a dispute in the Katttakkada Primary Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. The core dispute concerns a no-confidence motion passed on 8 January 2025 against the Bank’s President, B.N. Shyamkumar, and how actions taken by the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies—especially notices dated 16 January 2025 (appointing an officer to convene a meeting) and 18 January 2025 (disqualification notices) — intersect with resignations submitted by some directors. The petitioners/appellants (P.A. Abraham and others) challenge these notices, alleging fabrication of resignation letters, lack of quorum due to defaults and resignations, and procedural irregularities. The respondents defend the registrar’s actions as statutory and necessary to address no-confidence and governance issues. The Court identifies a common controversy across the matters and notes disputes about the genuineness of resignations and the quorum; it emphasizes that the writ court cannot act as an expert to adjudicate fabrication, and should rely on an expert body. The Court directs the Registrar Co-operative Society, Thiruvananthapuram, to conduct an inquiry into the resignations, the no-confidence motion, and related default issues with hearing, and decide within two months from the certified copy of the judgment. The interim orders remain in place pending final resolution. Four matters are disposed of by this common judgment.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos.306 & 302 of 2022

Sneha S v. Kerala Gramin Bank (WA Nos. 306 of 2022 & 302 of 2022)

Two writ appeals by Sneha S., a Kerala Gramin Bank employee, challenge a common High Court judgment that quashed a transfer cancellation and upheld a general transfer order. Sneha S. was posted at the Kunnikode Branch, Kollam, and, pregnant with health complications, proceeded on sabbatical and sought to be transferred back to Kollam in view of hardship and vacancies. Ext.P1 transferred her from Kollam to Manjeri; Ext.P2–P5 show representations highlighting pregnancy-related difficulties and health conditions; Ext.P3 later transferred her back within Kollam district, but Ext.P4 cancelled that transfer. Ext.P7, the Appellate Authority’s order, upheld Ext.P4. The learned Single Judge disposed of W.P.(C) Nos.18208/2021 and 22642/2021 on 10.01.2022 without disturbing the general transfer policy. The petitions emphasized guidelines in Annexure-A2 and Ext.P9 (Union Government transfer guidance for female employees) and relied on observations from the Supreme Court in SK Nousad Rahaman v. Union of India & Ors. (2022) about compassionate, family-life aware policy-making and substantive equality. The High Court held Ext.P4 and Ext.P7 unsustainable, quashed them, and remitted the matter to the 2nd respondent Chairman for fresh consideration, directing temporary accommodation in Kollam until a final decision. The appeals were disposed of by a Division Bench.

High Court of Kerala
M.F.A.(Forest) 115/2006

C. Sundaran v. State of Kerala & The Custodian of Vested Forests

The appellant, C. Sundaran, challenges the Forest Tribunal Kozhikode’s 2003 decision in OA 37/2003, which held the scheduled property to be a private forest vested in the Government as of 10.05.1971 and denied exemptions under Sections 3(2) and 3(3) of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971. The Land Tribunal record shows an oral lease in 1957, certificate of purchase in 1976 in the name of the appellant’s father, and subsequent partition in 2001. The property was cultivated with pepper, rubber, jack, cashew and coconut, with seasonal cultivation; the Tribunal found the property vested and rejected relief. The appellant sought to adduce additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, presenting a genuine purchase certificate (Ext A1) issued by the Sreekrishnapuram Land Tribunal. The respondent Government relied on earlier Supreme Court decisions (Kunjanam Antony; Popular Estates) to argue that a purchase certificate is only evidence, not conclusive proof. The Kerala High Court, applying the Supreme Court’s Mohammed Basheer decision (2019) 4 SCC 260, held that a Section 72K certificate of purchase is conclusive proof of title and exemption from vesting, and allowed the additional document on remand while keeping the Tribunal’s finding on exclusion undisturbed. The appeal is thus allowed with remand to the Forest Tribunal for fresh consideration on exemption under the Vesting Act, with costs against the appellant and respondents.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. NO. 8847 OF 2023

Vishnuraj and Athul v. State of Kerala and Sreejith

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case arises from C.C. No.1414/2022 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Adoor, in respect of Crime No.236/2022 of the Adoor Police Station, Pathanamthitta. Petitioners VishnuraJ and Athul challenge the continuation of the proceedings on the ground that the parties have amicably settled the dispute and the victim has filed an affidavit stating there is no objection to quashing the prosecution. The matter involves offences under Sections 294(b), 341, 451, 323, and 324 read with Section 34 IPC. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, initially expressed reservations but conceded the settlement. The Court undertook a detailed review of the legal framework governing the exercise of inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences where the civil/private character of the dispute is predominant and the parties have resolved all disputes, as laid down by the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan and Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019) 5 SCC 688, with reference to Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab. The Court emphasized that such power is not available for heinous crimes, cases under special statutes, or offences like section 307 IPC/Arms Act, where public interest is paramount. Applying these principles to the facts, the court found the dispute to be private and the settlement acceptable, and accordingly allowed the Cr.M.C., quashing all further proceedings in C.C. No.1414/2022.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 4 of 2015

Manager, Nirmala Public School v. Bulkis @ Shaila, George @ Joy & Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

This MACA (MACA No. 4 of 2015) arises from an award under the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thodupuzha, where the appellant (the Manager of Nirmala Public School) challenges a direction that the insurer pay the awarded compensation at first instance and then recover from the owner and the driver. The core issue is whether the driver’s driving license, not renewal within the statutory 30 days, renders the owner liable to reimburse the insurer when the accident occurred on 19 August 2010, and the Ext.B1 license was valid only up to 18 March 2010 with renewal on 27 August 2010. The High Court, per Justice C. Jayachandran, upholds the tribunal’s recovery direction, holding that a driver not duly licensed at the time of the accident constitutes a breach of policy conditions, and the insurer can be made to satisfy the decree first and recover from the owner if such breach is fundamental and contributed to the accident. The court notes Swaran Singh and a series of subsequent decisions (including Jisha, Shaji) to support the insurer’s recoverability, but distinguishes Lehru and Rishi Pal Singh as factually different. It emphasizes that reasonable care in verification does not erase the breach where license validity lapsed before the accident, and concludes that the appeal fails and is dismissed. The decision reinforces the social welfare aim of motor insurance and the insurer’s right to recover sums paid.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 13256 of 2022

K.A. Hassan v. State of Kerala & Ors

Petitioner, K.A. Hassan, a retired Meter Inspector of the Kerala Water Authority, seeks certiorari to quash Exhibits P6 and P7 and mandamus to sanction and disburse retirement benefits, including monthly pension with arrears, DCRG, and commuted value, leave surrender, and provident fund (PF) interest, along with other related entitlements. He retired on 30 November 2021, but alleges non-release of gratuity and PF closure amounts. He was served with Exhibit P6 (notice) and Exhibit P7 (pension payment order) alleging liability for a past erroneous fixation of pay and promotion, linked to pay revisions from 1992 onward, implying a huge liability for recovery. Respondents contend that past service was counted from 20.07.1987 instead of 19.09.1991, leading to erroneous 1st–4th time-bound higher grade promotions; the liability to recover excess draws was computed at Rs. 16,29,999, and the GPF closure payment was issued but delayed due to revenue constraints. The court notes no prior notice of error was served before retirement; the fixation error dates back to 1992 and only came to light during pension verification post-retirement. Relying on the Supreme Court’s Rafiq Masih (White Washer) doctrine, it held that no liability can be imposed for an old fixation error without pre-retirement notice. Accordingly, P6 and the fixation liability in P7 are set aside; the court directs release of retirement benefits within six months and payment of LEAVE surrender and PF interest within two months, factoring seniority.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 209 of 2013

SMITHA and others v Nazar P.M. and National Insurance Company Ltd.

This appeal arises from MACA No.209 of 2013 challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam’s dismissal of the claim petition following a fatal motorcycle accident that occurred on 20 May 2010 and resulted in the death on 18 June 2010. The appellants—Smitha (the wife of the deceased) and her minor children Poornima Rajesh and Abinmanue Rajesh, represented by their mother, and Kunjamma K.B.— contend that the final report (Ext. A4) establishes that the death was caused by an accident involving another vehicle, and that the driver of the offending vehicle was charge-sheeted. They submit that, per New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Pazhaniammal, the final report can serve as prima facie evidence of negligence in the absence of contrary evidence, and that the Tribunal’s conclusion that no other vehicle was involved was based on presumptions rather than proper evaluation of Ext. A4. The insurer’s argument, based on Ext. A9 AMVI, contends there was no damage to the offending vehicle, suggesting non-involvement. The appellants counter that the absence of a driving licence does not automatically prove contributory negligence, citing Muhammed Noufal v. Majeed & Ors. The High Court holds the final report can function as evidence of negligence and that the Tribunal’s reasoning was flawed. On quantum, the court assesses income, future prospects, and various heads of damages, awarding ₹18,26,564 with 9% interest from filing and directing deposit by the insurer, while condoning 136 days of delay subject to conditions. A detailed disbursement plan follows.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.65 of 2022

THEMBRAYIL T.V.KURIAKOSE v. K.R.THANKAPPAN

The case arises from a revision petition under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging eviction proceedings initiated by the landlord under Section 11(3). The Rent Control Court (Munsiff) at Sulthan Bathery issued an eviction order on 29.02.2020, which was upheld by the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-I), Kalpetta, on appeal under Section 18(1)(b). The petitioner tenant contends lack of bona fide need and raises issues about the landlord’s reliance on the two sons’ prospective hardware business, the elder son’s separate enterprise, and the wife’s possession of other rooms, alongside the absence of evidence showing vacancy of suitable rooms in the locality. The Courts below examined oral evidence (PW1, RW1) and documentary Exts. A1, A2, B1 and concluded that the landlord’s need was bona fide and that the second proviso to Section 11(3) did not apply, given absence of proof that the tenant depends primarily on rental income from the subject premises or lack of a suitable alternative. The petitioner’s arguments regarding deviance from pleadings and alleged malafide were considered but were not found sufficient to negate bona fides. The High Court ultimately upheld the concurrent findings, while exercising Revisional jurisdiction, and dismissed the revision petition, granting six months’ time to vacate on specified conditions.

High Court of Kerala
OS No.219/2024; BAIl APPL. Nos. 6396/2024 and 6399/2024

Sathis Kumar Sadanandan and Roshan Kumar Linganathan v. The Assistant Commissioner of Customs, Air Customs, Cochin International Airport, Nedumbassery

This Kerala High Court bail judgment, delivered on 6 August 2024 by Justice C.S. Dias, concerns two connected bail applications filed under BNSS 2023 (Section 483) arising from OS No. 219/2024 of Air Customs, Cochin International Airport. The petitioners, Malaysian citizens Sathis Kumar Sadanandan and Roshan Kumar Linganathan, were arrested on 04.06.2024 and found in conscious possession of five capsules each containing gold paste totaling 1,875.91 grams, making them accused under Sections 132 and 135 of the Customs Act, 1962. They sought bail under CrPC 167(2) alleging innocence, lack of material, 61 days in custody, ongoing investigation, and no complaint yet filed. The Respondent, represented by the Special Public Prosecutor, opposed bail citing ongoing investigation and risk of flight. The court analyzed CrPC 167(1) and (2) and BNSS Section 483, noting that the offences carry up to ten years' imprisonment, and the petitioners have been in custody for 61 days without a filed complaint. Relying on Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (2001) 5 SCC 453 and supportive precedents (including Sushila Aggarwal), the court held that default bail accrues when investigation remains incomplete beyond the statutory periods, constituting an indefeasible right. Accordingly, it allowed bail on bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties each, subject to conditions such as weekly reporting, non-tampering, passport surrender, and non-removal from jurisdiction, while allowing investigation to continue.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 10612/2024 & connected cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This judgment consolidates WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and several connected writ petitions arising from bank account freezes invoked by cybercrime investigations, police authorities, and notices from the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (NCCRP). The petitioners, a mix of individuals and corporate entities across Kerala and other states, challenge freezing of their bank accounts and, in many cases, partial/complete blocking of operations, arguing infringement of rights to access lawful monies and undue hardship on business and daily life. Banks and police authorities defend the freezes as protective measures designed to preserve proceeds of crime and to facilitate ongoing investigations, relying on requisitions from police and directives from NCCRP and RBI guidelines. The Kerala High Court, presided by Justice T. R. Ravi, examined the scope of such freezes, the need to balance enforcement objectives with fundamental rights, and the proper invocation of police requisitions. The court directs that freezing must be strictly confined to the amounts specified in police requisitions and requires police to inform banks whether continued freezing is necessary and for what duration. Banks must comply with these constraints; petitioners may approach the court again if information is not provided. The judgment cites Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and adopts its directions to regulate freezes and ensure proportional relief while the criminal process proceeds.

High Court of Kerala
BA 1225/2023; BA 1345/2023

M.K. Anil Kumar v. State of Kerala (BA 1225/2023) and Nikhil Jagadeeshan v. State of Kerala (BA 1345/2023)

Two anticipatory bail petitions under section 438 CrPC were heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court in respect of crime No. 216/2022 of Kannavam Police Station, Kannur. The petitioners, M.K. Anil Kumar (BA 1225/2023) and Nikhil Jagadeeshan (BA 1345/2023), were accused along with a bank official in the related proceedings for offences including criminal breach of trust, forgery, cheating and criminal conspiracy (sections 406, 468, 471, 420, 120B read with 34 IPC). The prosecution alleged transfer of Rs. 2,50,000 via cheque 10236495 and a subsequent withdrawal of Rs. 50,00,000 using the same firm account, raising forgery allegations. The court noted that the forgery substratum appeared shaky after forensic findings and that most evidence was documentary; arbitration proceedings between partners were pending, and the petitioners were previously in custody-related contact with the investigating officer. Bank communications suggested that the second transfer used the first unused cheque. The court held custodial interrogation unnecessary and granted anticipatory bail with standard conditions, including appearance before the IO, bonds on arrest, restrictions on travel, and regular reporting until the final report. The order cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) to acknowledge police power to investigate even after grant of bail. The decision reflects a careful balance between investigative needs and the accused’s liberty pending trial.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P No.144/23

Snoby Sourabhan v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a Criminal Revision Petition filed under section 397 Cr.P.C. by the second accused, Snoby Sourabhan, challenging an order discharging her in SC No.241/2020 pending before the Principal Assistant Sessions Court, Thiruvananthapuram. The case arises from Crime No.621/2011 (Pettah Police Station) arising out of an incident on 16.07.2011 during the subsisting marriage between the accused (second) and CW2, wherein the defacto complainant alleged trespass with a chopper, injuries to CW2 and his son, and other offences including 308 IPC; the FIR initially named only the first accused, but, after further investigation, the revision petitioner was added as accused with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution contends that the accused acted with a common intention to commit offences under sections 447, 294(b), 323, 324 and 308 read with 34 IPC. Importantly, the wound certificate for CW2 shows only minor injuries, no bite mark or tile recovered, and ocular witness statements prior to further investigation did not implicate the revision petitioner. The Supreme Court had earlier dismissed the SLP but permitted discharge consideration by the trial court. The Kerala High Court, applying the Sajjan Kumar framework, found no grave suspicion against the petitioner, concluded a lack of materials to establish any offence against her, and discharged her. The petition is allowed and the petitioner is discharged.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1262 OF 2023

Jinith Baby v. The State of Kerala and Kuruppumpady Police Station

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by Jinith Baby, the first accused in Kuruppumpady PS Crime No. 69/2023 for an offence under Section 395 IPC. The prosecution case, as per the charge diary, is that on 05 February 2023 at about 19.30 hours, the first accused and his associates attacked the defacto complainant and his friend at Nedungapara Shappumpady junction, in a Swift car, robbed the complainant of a mobile phone worth Rs. 16,000 and cash Rs. 1,800, on the pretext of the first accused’ non-payment of Rs. 5,000 for paint goods purchased on credit. The prosecution contains that the third and fourth accused are habitual offenders, with the third accused having a history of various offences and the fourth accused having offences including IPC 279 and related acts; however, no antecedents were shown against the petitioner. During hearing, the petitioner’s counsel contended that the allegations are false, the petitioner is a first-time offender, and the entire case arose merely because of non-payment of Rs.5,000, warranting regular bail. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, arguing that the materials prima facie support a case and the petitioner has been in custody since 06.02.2023. The court, after evaluating the case diary and investigation progress, grants regular bail on conditions balancing crime seriousness with absence of personal antecedents.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.4686/2023

Ajo Anto v. State of Kerala & Others

This writ petition by Ajo Anto, a person with benchmark disability under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (41% low vision), challenges the denial of his appointment as Lab Assistant in Holy Cross Higher Secondary School, Mapranam, while respondents 6 and 7 were appointed to the post. The petitioner had been included in Ext.P7 rank list and participated in the interview; he contends qualification and disability-based entitlement justify his appointment, and that the appointment of respondents 6 and 7 violates the dictum laid down by this Court in W.P.(C) No.19808/2021 and in Renjith v. State of Kerala. He petitions for certiorari to quash Exts.P13 and P14 and for mandamus directing appointment with salary and benefits from 28/3/2022, and interest on salary from that date. The court notes the petitioner’s disability status under Act 2016 and the need to consider his representations (Exts.P9 and P11) with notice to respondents 4–7, in light of the cited precedents. The bench directs the 3rd respondent to decide on Exts.P9 and P11, before any approval of the appointments of respondents 6 and 7, and to complete the exercise within two months, with certified copies of the judgment produced for compliance. The petition is disposed of with these directions, clarifying the process to ensure conformity with disability rights precedents.

High Court of Kerala
WPC.No.12944/2011

Anvar Sadath Ibrahimkutty and Subaida Beevi v. Chief Registrar General of Marriages (Common) and Others

This writ petition, filed through the power of attorney holder of the first petitioner, challenges cancellation of the marriage registration Ext. P1 under the Kerala Rules for Common Marriages. The first petitioner, Anvar Sadath Ibrahimkutty, married Khadeeja K. S. on 26 November 2009; the 4th respondent, the father of the petitioner and father-in-law of the wife, lodged a complaint with the Local Registrar alleging that the marriage was not solemnized according to Muslim law. The Local Registrar initially rejected the complaint (Ext. P2); however, the Registrar General of Marriages (Common) set aside the order by Ext. P3, cancelling Ext. P1. The order was challenged by the petitioners through revision and ultimately by this writ petition. The core issues are whether the 4th respondent has authority to file under Rule 13, and whether the Registrar or the Chief Registrar General has power to decide the validity of a marriage. The Court held that Rule 13(1) contemplates entries corrections or cancellation only on application by the parties to the marriage; a third party cannot be treated as a “party” to the marriage. Consequently, the impugned orders cancelling Ext. P1, based on a third‑party complaint, are unsustainable. Citing Abdul Samad, Rajesh Rajan and Lakshmi S.S., the Court concluded that such validity can be adjudicated only by a competent Civil Court, not by Registrar. The petition is allowed and Exts.P3 to P6 are quashed, preserving the rights of the spouses to pursue any necessary remedies in accordance with law.