USAIBA BEEVI, the claimant in O.P.(M.V.) No. 1213 of 2006 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kollam, challenges an award that exonerated the insurer on the premise that the driver of the offending vehicle was a minor at the time of the accident. The High Court, hearing MACA No. 918 of 2012, addresses whether the insurer should be held liable in the first instance and whether recovery against the owner and driver can be pursued when the driver reportedly lacked a valid license. The appellant argues that liability should lie with the insurer, with a clause for recovery from the owner and driver since the vehicle’s driver did not hold a valid license, and objects to the Tribunal’s finding of 10% contributory negligence against the claimant, which she contends is not supported by the evidence (Ext. A2 scene mahazar and Ext. A4 wound certificate). She maintains that the compensation awarded under various heads was insufficient; seeks higher notional income (Rs.3,500/month in 2006, per Ramachandrappa) and bystander-expenses (Rs.200/day for 8 days), plus enhanced damages for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities. The respondents contend the vehicle was insured, and liability could be drawn to the insurer; the driver’s lack of license and claimant’s own negligence are argued as grounds for reduction. The Court partially allows the appeal, directing the insurer to pay the fixed amount with a recovery right against the owner and driver, sets aside the contributory-negligence finding, and enhances several heads of compensation.
The petitioner, Ebrahim V.K.C., seeks to quash Ext.P7, an order rejecting his Form-5 application for 12.95 acres in Re-Survey No.30/18 of Nochad Village. He asserts ownership and possession over the land and seeks to construct a building on the property. He contends that the land has been wrongly included in Ext.P3 data bank, which appears to reflect that only 40 cents of the land qualifies as paddy land; Ext.P5 notes the land has been converted and is not suitable for paddy cultivation, and Ext.P6 (KSREC report) lacks 2008 data, rendering it unhelpful for decision-making. The petitioner argues that the LLMC data-bank reasoning cannot be the sole basis to deny Form-5, and relies on several precedents holding that the data bank should consist of cultivable paddy land or wetlands as of the relevant date (12.08.2008) and that independent scientific data should be used if necessary. The court cites Salim C.K., Lalu P.S., Joy, Arthasasthra Ventures, Muraleedharan Nair, and Aparna Sasi Menon to emphasize that the decisive factor is whether the land was cultivable for paddy as of 2008. The Court ultimately sets aside Ext.P7 and directs the 1st respondent to reconsider the Form-5 application, taking into account the Ext.P3 entry and Ext.P5 report, with fresh orders within one month.
The petitioner Rahul Raj, a bank account holder with Axis Bank Ltd, seeks a writ of mandamus to lift a debit-freeze on his account (No. 924020042337862) allegedly placed by the 8th respondent bank on police requisition. The petition asserts that the freezing is arbitrary and overbroad, hindering normal banking transactions. The bank contends that the freeze concerns a disputed sum of Rs. 1,66,273 and has been imposed pursuant to police directions. The High Court, after hearing arguments, relies on a trilogy of Supreme Court and High Court authorities to shape its approach to banking freezes in the context of police seizures. It cites Dr. Sajeer v. RBI and Nazeer K.T. v. Federal Bank Ltd to narrow freezes to the amount involved and to require banks to seek or obtain police information for continued freezes. The court also invokes State of Maharashtra v. Tapas D. Neogy, Teesta Atul Setalvad v. State of Gujarat, and Shento Varghese v. Julfikar Husen to emphasize timely reporting under Section 102 CrPC and to forge a practical framework requiring police to inform banks of reporting status. The judgment ultimately disposes of the petition by directing the bank to confine the freeze to the specified amount and mandating procedural communications between police and banks, with a contingency for lift if no information is provided within set periods.
TR.P(C) Nos. 228, 464 & 474 of 2022 These transfer petitions arise from the petitioner-wife Treesa Sebastian seeking transfer under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure of three matrimonial proceedings from the Family Courts at Alappuzha (O.P. 348/2022) and at Thiruvananthapuram (O.P. 1968/2022) to the Family Court, Ernakulam, so that all disputes between the couple—maintenance for children, custody, divorce and past maintenance—may be consolidated and tried together. The petitioner contends that marital estrangement persists, there are three children, and she and the children reside within the Ernakulam jurisdiction; two cases are already pending before the Ernakulam Family Court (O.P. 220/2022 and MC 29/2022), while the respondent contests the proceedings in Ernakulam. The respondent, according to the record, does not object to the transfers. The court notes established law by the Supreme Court in Sumithra Sing v. Kumar Sanjay and others, Mona Aresh Goel v. Aresh Satya Goel, Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap v. Shridhar Vishwanath Jagtap, Santhini V. Vijaya Venkatesh, and Aiswarya N.C.V. v. A.S. Saravana Karthik Sha, holding that convenience of the wife and children governs the transfer of matrimonial disputes, not rigid territorial rules. On consideration of pleadings, background, and the respondent's lack of objection, the court exercises its discretionary power under Section 24 CPC and orders the transfer of O.P. 348/2022 (Alappuzha to Ernakulam), O.P. 806/2022 (Alappuzha to Ernakulam), and O.P.(G&W) 1968/2022 (Thiruvananthapuram to Ernakulam). The parties are at liberty to seek consolidation before Ernakulam; registry shall transmit records; Ernakulam Court shall post the matter with O.P. 220/2022 for consolidation.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6099 OF 2024 The bail petition was filed by Vishnu A.S., the sole accused in Crime No.513/2024 (Pallikkathode Police Station, Kottayam) under Sections 363, 354, 354D IPC and Sections 7 and 8 of the POCSO Act, and under Section 483 BNSS 2023. The accused, aged 20, is alleged to have abducted a 17-year-old girl on 25 May 2024, dragged her to his home, kissed her and demanded sexual intercourse. He has been in judicial custody since 06 July 2024. The petitioner’s counsel contends complete innocence, false implication, and that the parties are in love; the FIR and statements do not establish the offences; the investigation is complete, and the accused has no prior criminal record. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, arguing ongoing investigation and risk of intimidation and witness tampering. The court cited Supreme Court principles from Dataram Singh, Raneef, and Hussainara Khatoon to emphasize bail as a rule and the right to liberty under Article 21; it noted the length of custody (about 30 days) and lack of antecedents. The judge concluded that further detention is unnecessary and granted bail subject to stringent conditions (bond, two sureties, regular appearances, no contact with victims/witnesses, restrictions on travel, and potential for cancellation for violations), while clarifying that observations do not decide merits.
This is a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging the order under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008 (Data Bank). The petitioner, Raju Thomas, owns 33.20 ares in Bharananganam village, Meenachil Taluk, Kottayam, and filed Form-5 on 10.04.2023 seeking removal of the land from the Data Bank on the ground that it is not suitable for paddy cultivation and that there are no nearby paddy lands. The Agricultural Officer inspected the land with the Local Level Monitoring Committee (LLMC) and the 2nd respondent (RDO) rejected the application, maintaining the land in the Data Bank (Exhibit P5). The petitioner contends that Ext.P5 is not a speaking order, that the decision relied on the LLMC report without an independent assessment, and that KSREC’s scientific data was not adequately considered. The court examines whether the RDO must independently assess the land’s status and whether the 2008 Act requires a reasoned order. Relying on Muraleedharan Nair and Aparna Sasi Menon, the court holds Ext.P5 to be non-speaking and directs reconsideration with KSREC input and independent verification. The judgment ultimately sets aside Ext.P5 and directs timely reconsideration with specified timelines and proper consideration of KSREC data, while allowing the petitioner to obtain KSREC report if needed.
Jayakumar R., a farmer in Palakkad, challenges Ext.P10 order of the Debts Recovery Tribunal-I, Ernakulam in IA 1633/2023 in SA No.242/2023 seeking to appoint an Advocate Commissioner to inspect the secured asset described by Exts.P2 and P8. The Bank sanctioned an agricultural loan of ₹25,50,000 in 2015 for agricultural development on the land; floods in 2018 and the Covid-19 pandemic led to EMI defaults, and OA No.200/2022 was filed to realise ₹34,63,312.49, with Ext.P2 auction notice issued on 10.04.2023 and Ext.P8 on 17.07.2023 for ₹37,16,813. The petitioner asserts the secured asset is agricultural land and thus exempt from SARFAESI under Section 31(1) and particularly Section 31(i); Exts.P3 and P4 (Village Officer and Agricultural Officer certificates) and Ext.P5 photographs allegedly support agricultural use. The Tribunal rejected IA 1633/2023, finding no material proving agricultural use at the time of mortgage and relied on a Supreme Court view that land classification in revenue records is not dispositive of SARFAESI applicability. The petitioner contends local inspection would produce best evidence about the land’s status, including age of coconut trees. The High Court finds Ext.P10 illegal, sets it aside, and directs the Tribunal to reconsider IA 1633/2023 with further proceedings on Exts.P2 and P8 deferred until fresh orders, noting the possible need to establish agricultural status at the time of mortgage for exemption.
The CSB Bank Ltd (formerly Catholic Syrian Bank Ltd) filed a writ petition seeking to erase post-mortgage attachments entered in the encumbrance certificate (Ext.P4) and to register Ext.P5 draft sale deed in favour of the 3rd respondent after a sale under the SARFAESI Act. The borrower executed an equitable mortgage on 02.02.2011; when the borrower defaulted, the bank initiated SARFAESI proceedings, culminating in Ext.P3 sale certificate dated 24.03.2022, conveying the property to the 3rd respondent. The Sub Registrar demanded that encumbrances arising from Civil Court attachments be lifted before registration of Ext.P5, arguing such entries post-date the mortgage and cannot be effaced by the bank. The petition relied on Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar, Kollam and subsequent decisions (e.g., Ali Asharaf, Keechery Bank cases) to argue that attachments created after the mortgage do not survive against the SARFAESI sale and must be effaced to preserve marketability and title. The court noted several authorities and ultimately held that post-mortgage attachments have no effect on the SARFAESI sale and directed the Sub Registrar to efface those entries after 02.02.2011 and to register Ext.P5 as presented, while keeping civil proceedings intact. The petition is thus disposed of with directions to effect the encumbrance removal and register the sale.
This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA 1891 of 2021) filed by United India Insurance Company Ltd. (the sixth respondent and insurer of the Mini lorry) challenging a MACT award in OPMV No. 314/2016 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta. The petitioners claimed compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for the death of Sujith, a 22-year-old welder who died on 18 February 2016 on the Adoor-Pathanapuram road when a tipper lorry (driven by the second respondent) collided with his motorcycle and a Mini lorry (driven by the fifth respondent) ran over the deceased. The Tribunal held joint negligence of the tipper lorry driver and the Mini lorry driver and directed the sixth respondent to pay Rs.32,55,200 and recover 50% of that amount from the third respondent (insurer of the tipper). The insurer challenged: (i) the direction to pay and recover half the sum from the tipper insurer; and (ii) the quantum of compensation. The High Court, applying established principles, upheld the Tribunal’s approach, citing Khenyei v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd and later decisions, and affirmed the notional income calculation (Rs.875/day, 24 days/month, Rs.21,000/month) guided by Pranay Sethi and Satinder Kaur. It also relied on New India Assurance v. Kiran Singh to condemn delaying insurer tactics. The appeal was dismissed, preserving the Tribunal’s award and the liability framework among insurers.
CRL.M.C. No. 5076 of 2018 (and connected cases) This batch order from the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, deals with whether non‑compoundable sexual offences under IPC and the POCSO Act can be quashed under the High Court’s inherent powers under section 482 Cr.P.C. in the context of amicable settlements between accused and victims. The matter spans multiple petitions (Crl.M.C. Nos. 5076/2018 and many connected cases) heard by a single judge, Dr. Kauser Edappagath, on 24 May 2023. The court acknowledges divergent jurisprudence from the Supreme Court and other High Courts regarding whether recovery of “ends of justice” can override the rigidity of sections that render certain offences non‑compoundable. The bench canvasses key precedents (Joshi, Nikhil Merchant, Manoj Sharma, Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Shimbhu, Laxmi Narayan, Saju P.R., Kapil Gupta, etc.) and lays down the guiding principles: the High Court’s inherent power is not bound by section 320; it must consider the gravity of the offence, the nature of injuries, the voluntariness of the settlement, best interests of the victim (especially if a minor), and the impact on society. The order ultimately quashes criminal proceedings in a large number of connected cases where the settlement, affidavit evidence, and circumstances justify dismissal under 482 Cr.P.C./Article 226, while dismissing a few petitions where quashing would not serve justice (notably where the victim’s best interests or public policy demand continuation). The Judge concludes with a comprehensive list of FIRs/cases that are quashed and those that stand dismissed or allowed, and signs off with the order date and the judge’s initials.
This is a regular bail application (BA No.1323 of 2023) filed by the second accused, Sahul U, in Crime No.763/2022 of Kozhikode Town Police Station. On 20.11.2022 around 16:30 hours, authorities recovered 34.79 grams of MDMA, 1.105 kg of ganja, and 21 grams of hashish from a Mahindra SUV (registration KA-49-M-4546). A body search yielded 19.050 grams of MDMA in the possession of the second accused, and 15.740 grams of MDMA was found with the first accused; additional items were seized. Prosecution charges include Sections 22(c), 20(b)(ii)(B), 20(b)(ii)(A), 21(b) read with 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985. The petitioner contends lack of conscious possession and innocence, arguing that the actual possessor fled and other occupants were innocent, thus the bail should be granted given custody duration and ongoing investigation. Opposing, the Public Prosecutor asserts that the contraband was seized from the second accused and that the quantity constitutes a commercial quantity; hence bail must satisfy the stringent NDPS Section 37 criteria. The court revisits the standard of “reasonable grounds” under Section 37, citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and subsequent authorities, and concludes that the twin conditions (not guilty and not likely to commit a crime while on bail) must be satisfied conjunctively. Finding no such reasonable grounds, the court dismisses the bail application. The order is by a Single Judge, Justice A. Badharudeen, on 9 March 2023.
TR.P(C) NO. 103 OF 2023; TR.P(C) NO. 556 OF 2022 Common Order in TR.P(C) Nos. 103/2023 and 556/2022 before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, delivered by Justice C.S. Dias on 28 March 2023. The petitions, filed by Renjith B.R. (husband) and Sathya Dhara Vasudhasree (wife), seek transfers of Family Court proceedings between Alappuzha and Chavara. In TR.P(C) 103/2023, the husband seeks to transfer OP 748/2022 (Family Court, Alappuzha) to Family Court, Chavara, citing a benchmark disability and impracticality of travel. In TR.P(C) 556/2022, the wife seeks transfer of OP 184/2022 (Family Court, Chavara) to Alappuzha, arguing the wife’s permanent residence in Alappuzha and the heavy travel burden from Alappuzha to Chavara; she also highlights the husband’s employment in Kollam and alleged extravagance. Both petitions were heard together on 28.03.2023. The court cites a lineage of Supreme Court judgments emphasizing the welfare and convenience of the wife and children in transfer decisions, and notes that the husband’s hardship can be mitigated through dispensation of personal appearance, video conferencing, or representation by an agent. The final order dismisses TR.P(C) 103/2023 and allows TR.P(C) 556/2022, transferring OP 184/2022 from Chavara to Alappuzha, with directions for consolidation, potential dispensation, and transmission of records to Alappuzha.
This writ petition challenges Exhibit P16, the promotion of the 7th respondent as Head of Department in Computer Engineering at NSS Polytechnic College, Pandalam, along with Exhibits P11, P3 and P4 which relate to AICTE approvals and University sanctions. The petitioner contends that two private self-financing colleges admitted teachers for M.Tech without prior AICTE approval and that the qualifications acquired through these arrangements (often weekend/part-time) cannot be validated for the purposes of promotion under AICTE norms. She relies on the Supreme Court’s Vinit Garg decision to argue that AICTE approval is mandatory for conducting technical courses and that lack of such approval undermines the validity of the respondents’ qualifications. The respondents, including the government, AICTE, Mahatma Gandhi University, and the college managements, counter that Ext.P2, Ext.P3, Ext.P4 and the government orders create a framework wherein the AICTE scheme and subsequent committee recommendations validate the qualifications acquired via weekend/part-time arrangements, subject to certain conditions, and that there was no unequivocal finding of invalidity. The court examines the evidence, including AICTE’s position, government orders, and a committee report, and concludes that the respondents’ M.Tech qualifications were treated as valid by law, and the petitioner’s challenge lacks sustainable grounds. The petition is dismissed.
WP(C) 30155/2022; WP(C) 4975/2023 Two connected writ petitions filed by M.V. Sathyabalan, who held a license for a Minor Catering Unit at Mangaore Junction Railway Station, challenge actions of the Southern Railway and related authorities concerning tendering, award of contracts, and extension of license. The petitions seek to quash Exhibits P10 and other tender/award communications, and to extend the license period in light of letters issued by the Ministry of Railways (Exhibits P5, P6) interpreted through a Delhi High Court interim order (Exhibit P4). They also seek to restrain coercive steps pending final resolution, and, in WP( C).4975/2023, seek to declare tender notifications and awards as illegal. The matter has a background of interim permissions allowing operation pending re-tender, with the unit ultimately put up for re-tender and awarded to a different party. The Kerala High Court disposes of the petitions by common judgment, directing the petitioner to make a formal representation within two weeks; the 2nd respondent must consider and decide expeditiously, within a month, after hearing; and the Railway can continue with re-tender proceedings, with the successful bidder occupying the unit. The order clarifies no new rights for the petitioner beyond these directions.
Crl. Appeal No. 1807/2007 Girish and Ratheesh, the appellants, challenge their conviction under the Kerala Abkari Act (Sections 8(1), 8(2) and 55(a)) arising from an incident on 09.07.2002, when 35 litres of spirit was found being transported in a car (KL 4H/2244) on the PIP canal road at Kollakadavu. The Sub Inspector, Venmony Police Station, intercepted the vehicle and arrested the accused; the case proceeded from the magistrate to the Fast Track (Adhoc) Sessions Court, which convicted them and sentenced them to 3 ½ years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 each, with a further year’s imprisonment in default. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized the evidence, focusing on the prosecution’s chain-of-custody and sampling procedures. The appellants argued that the investigating officer failed to testify about the seal on the contraband and sample bottles, that specimen impressions were absent, that there was no seal impression in the mahazar or the property list, and that there was delay in forwarding samples to the chemical laboratory. The court highlighted that the prosecution must prove tamper-proof despatch and the integrity of the sample (link evidence). Citing Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, the court found serious defects in the chain of custody and concluded that the evidence could not rule out reasonable doubt. As a result, the appeal was allowed, the conviction and sentence set aside, and the accused acquitted with bail bonds cancelled and refunds of any deposited fines ordered."
CRL.M.C. Nos. 8035 of 2017; 3446 of 2018; 6608 of 2018 This is a set of Criminal Miscellaneous Cases in the Kerala High Court challenging criminal proceedings arising from defamation allegations linked to a parish dispute at St. John’s Salem Orthodox Church, Ayroor, Pathanamthitta. Petitioners, seven elected parish members, face charges under sections 120-B and 500 IPC in CC Nos. 164/2015, 165/2015 and 23/2016 in the Chief Judicial Magistrate’s Court. They seek quashing of the proceedings on grounds that Annexure A2, a response to an earlier complaint, contains no defaming material and is protected by the Eighth Exception to Section 499 IPC, as it was made to a lawful religious authority (the Metropolitan Bishop) for addressing grievances. Respondents argue that Annexure A2 contains defamatory statements and that the Metropolitan Bishop is not the lawful authority for the purposes of the Eighth Exception; Annexure A2 cannot be treated as a reply to Annexure A1. The court analyzes the concept of good faith under Section 52 IPC, the due‑care standard, and the scope of the Eighth Exception, citing Subramanian Swamy, Chamanlal, and Jeffrey Diermeter to emphasize that good faith is a nuanced, fact‑intensive inquiry. The judge applies Bhajan Lal’s categories and Neeharika guidelines to assess whether the extraordinary power to quash should be exercised. Concluding that the facts do not fall within the narrow exceptions for quashing, the petitions are dismissed, and the criminal proceedings continue.
WP(C) No. 36903/2022, 37050/2022 and 38477/2022 These writ petitions challenge the recruitment process for the post of System Administrator under the Kerala Cooperative Services Examination Board across five co-operative banks. Petitioner Krishnashri B. (WP(C) 36903/2022) and, in later linked petitions, Rinsy K M. (WP(C) 37050/2022) contend that the preliminary rank lists were flawed due to errors in the eligible list, and the addendum notification issued on 31.08.2022 to include additional candidates was issued after substantial delay and without opportunity for hearing. The petitions trace back through Exts. P3–P7, P8–P12 and P19–P22, highlighting that revised rank lists were published, interconnected by a judicial direction in earlier W.P.(C) Nos. 26093/2022 and 27333/2022. The Board defends its action as a necessary correction to rectify errors identified in the evaluation process, supported by verifications, addenda, and eratum notices, and argues that the amendments serve transparency and fairness. The petitioners rely on S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath to protest alleged fraud, but the court distinguishes that decision, noting no substantiated fraud. The judge concludes the corrections were permissible under statutory rules and directed actions, ultimately dismissing the petitions. Common issues were disposed of by a single judgment, preserving the integrity of the recruitment process while refusing the petitioners’ relief.
This writ petition (C) challenges Ext.P6, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting Form 5 under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The petitioners—four owners of 31.10 ares in Re-Sy. Nos. 457/5 and 457/6, Kadamakkudy Village, Kanayannur Taluk, Ernakulam District—assert that their land is neither paddy land nor wetland as defined by the Act and Rules, and was wrongly placed in the Data Bank. They had filed Form 5 before the RDO seeking removal, but Ext.P6 relies on the Agricultural Officer’s report and the LLMC’s recommendation without independent verification of the land’s status as of 12.08.2008, the date the Act came into force. The petition contends that Rule 4(4E) and 4(4F) require consideration based on actual status and, if necessary, verification through satellite imagery or other expert reports, with involvement of KSRSEC. The court refers to prior judgments—Arthasasthra Ventures (2022) 7 KHC 591; Muraleedharan Nair (2023) 4 KLT 270; Aparna Sasi Menon (2023) 6 KHC 83—to emphasize that (i) the RDO must independently assess land status and (ii) the dominant criterion is whether paddy cultivation is feasible. The court sets aside Ext.P6 and directs the RDO to reassess Form 5, obtain the KSRSEC report at petitioners’ expense, and decide within two months, after considering Rule 4(4F) factors and the KSRSEC input.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No. 8288 of 2022) under section 482 Cr.P.C. arises from Crime No. 336/2022 registered at Thrikunnapuzha Police Station, Alappuzha, alleging offences punishable under sections 406 and 420 read with 34 IPC. The petitioners, accused nos. 1 and 2, contend that the dispute has been settled between the parties and they no longer wish to pursue the prosecution. The informant/victim has filed an affidavit in support of the settlement, and the victim does not oppose quashing. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but concedes that a settlement has occurred. The High Court, after considering the submissions, evidence, and the controlling precedents, notes the overarching principle laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, which itself relied on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab, for guidance on exercising the power under section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash non-compoundable offences where disputes are private and the parties have settled. The court analyzes the private nature of the dispute, the lack of communal/public interest concerns, and the accused’s antecedents. Ultimately, the court concludes the dispute is private, accepts the settlement, and allows the Crl.M.C., quashing all further proceedings against the petitioners in Crime No. 336/2022.
This writ petition challenges two memos of charges (Exts. P4 and P6) issued in disciplinary proceedings against Ullas Bhanu U., an employee of Kandalloor Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. The petitioner contends, relying on Kodanchery SCB v. Joshy Varghese (2020 4 KLT 129 (DB)), that the authority competent to issue a memo of charges is the Managing Committee; a memo issued by the President without explicit Managing Committee authorization renders the disciplinary process defective and liable to be interfered with. The respondent Society counters that the President acted with due approval by the Managing Committee, and therefore Exts. P4 and P6 were issued lawfully. The court recalls Kodanchery, which held that the Managing Committee, as appointing authority, is the competent body to issue the memo of charges, and that merely the delinquent’s failure to object or his participation cannot validate a memo issued by an incompetent authority. On examination of Exts. P4/P6 and the related resolutions, the court finds no explicit indication that the President was acting on behalf of the Managing Committee, and there is no clear authorization in the record. Consequently, the petition is allowed and Exts. P4 and P6 are quashed. The court indicates that the petitioner may seek consequential relief from the Society in accordance with law."