Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 440 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CUS.APPEAL NOS. 11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018

Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Willingdon Island, Cochin v KIMS Health Care Management Ltd.

This batch of Customs Appeals before the Kerala High Court concerns the entitlement to exemption under the Served from India Scheme (SFIS) for an MRI scanner imported by KIMS Health Care Management Ltd. The Revenue (Commissioner of Customs) challenged the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, South Zonal Bench, Bangalore, order dated 21.08.2017 that allowed the importer’s exemption claim under Notification No. 20/2006-Cus and SFIS credits. The importer contends that the goods were fully exempt from basic Customs duty and CVD, and that the exemption under the SFIS regime and SAD should apply, relying on Notification No. 20/2006 and earlier jurisprudence such as Gujarat Ambuja Exports Ltd. v. Union of India. The Revenue argues that the importer had insufficient SFIS credit (Rs. 18,96,214 against a duty payable of Rs. 33,43,605) and that Education Cess and the Special Additional Duty were not properly accounted for, rendering the exemption untenable. The court treats Cus.Appeal No. 11/2018 as representative, considers the identical issues across connected appeals, and examines the notified exemptions, procedural compliance, and relevant case law. Ultimately, the High Court holds that the Tribunal’s reasoning is tenable and the cited precedents support the importer; the Revenue’s appeals are dismissed, upholding the Tribunal’s decision in favor of the importer.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.19821 of 2023

P. Santhakumary Amma and S. Devika @ Devika Pillai v Indian Overseas Bank and Others

This writ petition (WP(C) No.19821 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court seeks to quash Exts. P3, P5 and P6 and to compel the Indian Overseas Bank (IOB) to return title deeds Nos. 2031/1973, 194/1953 and 307/1964 of SRO Palugal, Kanyakumari district, to the legal heirs of late P. Gopinathan Pillai (petitioners and respondents 3–5) without delay. The background: Gopinathan Pillai, proprietor of M/s Laxmi Cashew Corporation, died in 2003 after cash-credit facilities were availed in 1997. He discharged the liability by 1999, but the bank later pursued suits against KJP Group; Decrees listed properties of the company but not those of Pillai. The bank claims it retained title deeds under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (general lien) because Pillai had given personal guarantees for the KJP Group loans. The petitioners contend that discharged liability extinguishes the lien and that the bank’s retention cannot be a contract enforcement; they assert maintainability under Article 12 (State) of the Constitution. The bank counters that the writ petition is not maintainable as it involves non-public duties; it relies on Syndicate Bank v. Vijay Kumar and related precedents to justify the lien. The court examines Sections 171 and 128 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, discusses the definition of general lien, and surveys governing jurisprudence (including Unimoni, Sleebachan, Devi Ispat, Jayanthi and Nakulan) to determine maintainability and entitlement to retain title deeds. Ultimately, the court holds that the bank, being a public sector bank, can retain the title deeds as a general lien and dismisses the petition.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1043 of 2012

Vinod T.V. v. Sherif S/o Majeed and A.K. Ashraf and The Oriental Insurance Company Limited

This Motor Accidents Claims Appeal arises from an award under O.P. (M.V.) No.372/2008 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, challenging the compensation granted for injuries sustained in a 16.11.2007 accident when a Tipper Lorry KL-8/Z-9739 allegedly negligent struck the claimant at Kozhivettumveli Junction, Eroor. The appellant, Vinod T.V., contends that the Tribunal erred in awarding meagre compensation under head(s) of damages in spite of substantial injuries and prolonged treatment, including a 45-day inpatient stay and surgeries (e.g., ORIF with bone grafting). The Tribunal held the 2nd respondent driver liable and the 1st respondent vicariously liable, with the 3rd respondent insurer directed to indemnify, awarding Rs.1,83,561. The appellant argues for enhancement across all heads, citing the Supreme Court’s discussion on personal injury damages (pecuniary and non-pecuniary) and the need to reflect loss of earning, medical expenses, nourishment, transportation, bystander expenses, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and potential loss of future prospects. The respondents submit that the Tribunal’s quantum is just and no interference is warranted. The court relies on Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and Another for the general principles of compensation in injury cases and ultimately allows the appeal, enhancing the compensation to Rs.36,800 with 6.5% interest, directing payment within two months and requiring bank details to be furnished by the claimant.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.16144 of 2020

Vibin Das Aged 55 Years S/o Dasan v. District Collector, Malappuram and others

Vibin Das, a resident of Ward No.15 of Thalakkad Grama Panchayath in Tirur, Malappuram, filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging encroachment on temple property recorded in Survey No.371/3 and seeking eviction of the 7th respondent from the Perumthrikkovil Devaswom property and to stop construction of a mosque thereon. He prayed for mandamus to the District Collector to dispose of Ext.P5 (09.12.2019) and Ext.P6 (16.01.2020) representations and to implement Ext.P7 order of the Supreme Court in W.P.(C) No.649/2018, dated 05.07.2018. The temple property is settled in the Settlement Register as belonging to the Perumthrikkovil Devaswom, and the petitioner claims encroachment on temple land by the 7th respondent. The petitioner also sought action by the Thalakkad Grama Panchayath to halt the construction and a report from the Additional 8th Respondent District Judge under the Apex Court's order. The court referenced constitutional and statutory protections for Devaswom property, including the duty of courts under A.A. Gopalakrishnan (SCC 482) and Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair, to safeguard temple endowments, and drew on parens patriae jurisdiction derived from previous Kerala decisions. It concluded by disposing the petition and directing the District Judge to consider Ext.P9 in light of the Apex Court order, issuing directions as necessary and reporting back within four months. It stressed that merits are not decided in this petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 7744 of 2023; CRL.M.C. No. 7875 of 2023

CRL.M.C. Nos. 7744 of 2023 and 7875 of 2023: Dileep Devasia & Others v. State of Kerala & Others; Ragesh Raj & Others v. State of Kerala & Others

Two Criminal Misc. Cases (CRL.M.C. Nos. 7744 of 2023 and 7875 of 2023) were heard by the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam for quashing criminal proceedings arising from two separate regimes: Crime No.1086/2016 (CC 297/2017) and Crime No.1085/2016 (CC 558/2017) of Thadiyittaparambu Police Station. The petitioners in 7744/2023 are Dileep Devasia, Sreejith K.R., Rosamma Devasia, and Sreeja Dileep; the petitioners in 7875/2023 are Ragesh Raj, Hima, ShankarAn, and Girija. The respondents include the State of Kerala (through the Public Prosecutor) and the individual complainants/injured persons, along with the Sub Inspector in the second case and others. In both matters, the petitioners contend that the disputes with the defacto complainants have been settled, supported by affidavits, and that further prosecution is not in the public interest given the non-heinous nature of the offences. Relying on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, the Court held that quashing is permissible on the basis of settlements where public interest is not served by continued prosecution. After hearing the Public Prosecutor, the Court quashed proceedings in CC No.297/2017 and CC No.558/2017, on Kakkanad, noting minimal chances of successful prosecution and absence of public interest in continuation. Judge: Gopinath P.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 20391/2023, 30155/2023, 33968/2023

V H Mohamed Basher and Shakeela Basheer v State Bank of India and South Indian Bank Ltd.

The Kerala High Court heard three connected writ petitions (W.P.(C) Nos. 20391/2023, 30155/2023, 33968/2023) filed by V H Mohamed Basher and Shakeela Basheer challenging SARFAESI-led sale processes conducted by the State Bank of India (SBI) and the South Indian Bank Ltd. The petitioners had participated in an e-auction of property belonging to M/s Pushpa Diams and were declared successful bidders on 04.12.2021 for ₹1,11,10,000. They paid ₹28,10,000 on the date of sale and were to remit the balance by 19.12.2021; the balance could not be remitted and the bank cancelled the auction. The court had earlier directed sale confirmation and issuance of a sale certificate, with Ext.P1 guiding the sale, Ext.P2 the sale certificate, and Ext.P3 a Division Bench order in WA 1045/2022 setting aside Ext.P2, ultimately confirmed by the Supreme Court (Ext.P4). The petitioners subsequently sought refund of the entire sale price; Ext.P5 representations were filed. In the 20391/2023 matter, the court ordered refund of the entire sale price within two weeks, rejecting reliance on Rule 9(5) and citing a Supreme Court decision to prevent unjust enrichment. For the other petitions, the court directed repayment of outstanding amounts in five instalments. The judgment emphasizes refund where the sale is declared invalid and prescribes instalment-based relief for the other accounts, balancing refund rights with recovery interests.

High Court of Kerala
BA 1023 of 2023

Sunil N.S v. State of Kerala

Sunil N.S., the first accused in Crime No.297/2017 of Nedumbassery Police Station, Ernakulam, petitions for bail while the case remains before the Principal Sessions Court, Ernakulam (Sessions Case No.118/2018). The prosecution alleges a criminal conspiracy, abducting and sexually assaulting the victim in a moving car, with multiple charges under IPC sections 120B, 109, 342, 366, 354, 354B, 357, 376D, 201, 212 read with 34, and under IT Act sections 66E and 66A. He has been in judicial custody since 23.02.2017, i.e., about six years. The petitioner had previously sought bail in B.A. 2594/2022, which was dismissed in 2022; The Supreme Court directed that if the trial is not concluded within a reasonable time, the petitioner could renew his bail application before the High Court. On 13.02.2023, the Sessions Judge furnished a report noting that the trial would require six more months; The Supreme Court extended the time and accepted the lower court's extension petitions. The Court then examined whether the delay is unreasonable, given the monitoring by the Apex Court and the large number of witnesses. It concluded that the trial is being pursued with diligence; Nevertheless, it found that the gravity of the offences and the victim's deposition, which was kept in sealed cover, indicate that the accused should remain in custody pending trial. The bail application was dismissed on merits, and the deposition was retained.

High Court of Kerala
Criminal No.756/2018; BA Nos.1716/2021, 1838/2021 & 7402/2021

BA Nos.1716/2021, 1838/2021 & 7402/2021 in Crime No.756/2018 (Pozhiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram)

These are anticipatory bail applications arising out of Crime No.756/2018 of Pozhiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, filed by accused numbers 3, 4, 5–15. The Kerala High Court, with Justice Viju Abraham presiding, considered the petitions on 17 January 2023 along with connected matters. The prosecution alleges misappropriation of bank funds and offences under IPC sections 409, 420, 465, 468, 471 read with 34. The court noted that the crime was registered in 2018 and there exists an earlier order prohibiting arrest, and that the petitioners have approached the court after a long interval. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail. The court observed that custodial interrogation may not be required at this stage given the lapse of time and the lack of arrest history since the prior order, and that only limited custody would be necessary for investigation. It referred to common orders in BA Nos.5265/2018 and 5369/2018 directing surrender for interrogation and stated that, in the event of arrest, the petitioners would be produced before the jurisdictional court and released on bail subject to conditions. The final decision grants anticipatory bail with specified conditions, including bond and sureties, regular appearances, reporting, no contact with victims, and no involvement in other crimes; surrender before the IO on 20.01.2023. The order cites the Supreme Court decision in Sushila Aggarwal to justify police power to recover if necessary, even during bail.

High Court of Kerala
OP (CAT) NO. 59 OF 2022

R. Sasi Kumar v. Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax Range Satna; Principal Commissioner of Income Tax II; Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (CCA), MP & Chhattisgarh

This Original Petition, OP (CAT) No. 59 of 2022, before the Kerala High Court, challenges the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench, order dated 17 June 2022 in OA 180/00567/2019, which dismissed the applicant’s application seeking records (Exts. A1–A10) and to grant service benefits. The petitioner, R. Sasi Kumar, a former Stenographer with the Income Tax Department, contends that his resignation in 1981 was never accepted and that his 1986 recall letter, although not accepted, reflects an ongoing status in service. He seeks relief including retrospective service benefits and setting aside Ext. A10 (12.03.2019) rejecting his claim. The respondents contend that the OA was hopelessly barred by limitation and laches, noting resignation in 1981, no joinings thereafter, and only belated representations from 2014 onward. The Tribunal relied on established jurisprudence that delay or laches defeats relief. The High Court, after careful examination, upholds the Tribunal’s reasoning, clarifying that the petitioner abandoned service by remaining out of duty for five years in contravention of CSS Rules, and that repeated representations cannot cure the delay. The petition is devoid of merit and is dismissed with no relief granted to the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.28783/2022

M/S Pankaj Cottage v. Goods and Service Tax Officer, Central Tax and Central Excise, Munnar; Assistant Commissioner, Central Tax and Central Excise; Appellate Authority, Goods and Service Tax, Cochin

The petitioner, M/S Pankaj Cottage, challenges Ext. P1, an order canceling its registration under the CGST/SGST Acts, issued in the wake of a show-cause process and later affirmed/recounted by Ext. P1. The show-cause notice (Ext. P5) allegedly issued in Form REG-31 (purportedly for suspension) and not in Form REG-17 (required for cancellation) lacked the essential particulars mandated by the Rules. Ext. P1 cancels registration and triggers a consequential revocation path, while the petitioner’s revocation application under Section 30 was rejected on time-bar grounds, leading to the filing of a Section 107 appeal. Counsel for the petitioner argues that the procedure was not only procedurally defective but also that delays in compliance with tax filings were due to financial distress, not willful default. He relies on Gujarat High Court decisions Aggarwal Dyeing and Printing v. State of Gujarat and Sing Traders v. State of Gujarat, which faulted vague show-cause notices and improper form. The respondents urge strict construction of the fiscal scheme, contending that cancellation is a valid tool when returns are not filed. The Kerala High Court ultimately holds that Ext. P5 is deficient and Ext. P1 without proper jurisdiction because REG-31 cannot substitute for REG-17. While acknowledging the general need for strictness in fiscal matters, the court relies on established admin-law principles and distinguishes the improper form from the underlying policy aim, quashing Ext. P1 but directing the petitioner to settle defaults post-restoration.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1328 OF 2023

Nishan v. State of Kerala

This case concerns a bail application by Nishan, the second accused in Kadakkavoor Police Station Crime No. 625/2022, Thiruvananthapuram, under the NDPS Act. The prosecution alleges that on 28 September 2022, accused Nos. 1 and 2 were found in joint possession of 320 grams of MDMA (commercial quantity) along with three ATM cards, three mobile phones, two purses and cash, while traveling on a scooter near Mass Auditorium, Manamboor, leading to registration of NDPS offences. Nishan contends he merely gave a lift to accused No.1 without knowledge of the contraband and has been in custody since 28 September 2022. He seeks regular bail, arguing lack of direct involvement and the possibility of a safe release subject to conditions. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, emphasizing that the contraband was recovered in red-handed circumstances and that commercial quantity triggers stricter bail restrictions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The court scrutinizes Section 37(1)(a)(i) and the requirement to show two conditions before granting bail where commercial quantity is involved: reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty and that he will not commit an offence while on bail, with the public prosecutor allowed to oppose. The court cites Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari to define ‘reasonable grounds’ as more than prima facie, and repeatedly notes that the court is not deciding guilt at bail. After evaluating the materials, the judge concludes there are no reasonable grounds to believe Nishan is not guilty or that he will refrain from crime on bail, hence dismissing the bail petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.20526 of 2023 & 37083 of 2023

WP(C) Nos.20526 of 2023 & 37083 of 2023

The two writ petitions challenge Ext.P3, an order under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, which changed the land's nature (nilam to purayidam) and was issued in the name of the prior owner. The petitioners purchased the property in 2021, after the Form 6 application had been filed by the erstwhile owner, and contend that Ext.P3 was not issued in their name and that they should not be compelled to pay new conversion fees. They rely on the statutory framework (Sections 27A and 27C of the Act, and Rule 12(9) of the Rules) and amendments to the fee schedule to argue that conversion and subsequent actions should be feasible for the subsequent purchaser without restarting the process. The Government circular of 08.06.2023 is cited to support seniority-based processing of transfers via no-objection certificates, but the Court notes that Ext.P3 had already been issued in the name of the original owner and that the purchaser’s rights survive transfer under Section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act, as interpreted in Union of India v. Iqbal Singh. The court also emphasizes public authorities’ duty not to defeat honest claims by technical pleas, citing The Trustees of Port of Bombay v. Premier Automobiles. The judgment ultimately holds that Ext.P3 should be deemed to have been issued in the name of the petitioners’ land, with 45 days to issue related entries under Section 27C and 6A, and the writ petitions are allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P No.469/21

Pokker A v. State of Kerala

Pokker A v. State of Kerala (CRL.R.P No.469/21) concerns an arch erected by the Mambatta Shiva Temple on a public panchayat road near Kandamangalam, Palakkad. The temple’s semicircular arch, constructed at the beginning of the public road, allegedly encroached upon a public way, reducing the road width from 4.15 metres to about 3.65 metres and constraining vehicular access. The petitioner (complainant) filed a complaint under section 133 Cr.P.C alleging unlawful obstruction to a public road; the Sub Divisional Magistrate (SDM) issued a conditional order directing removal of the obstruction, which, after several postings, was made absolute on 15.03.2021. The temple president filed a criminal revision before the Sessions Court (Crl.R.P. No.9 of 2021), arguing procedural irregularities in the SDM’s conduct before making the order absolute and seeking remand for fresh evidence. The Sessions Court allowed the revision, remanding for fresh consideration. The High Court, however, allowed the revision petition to the extent of setting aside the Sessions Court’s order and upheld the SDM’s order, ruling that no cause was shown against the conditional order and that the road is a public road; no permission from the Panchayat had been obtained for the arch. The court relied on binding precedents and directed removal of the obstruction, emphasizing that unauthorised encroachments on public streets must be removed, following Supreme Court and Kerala decisions on encroachments.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.5177 of 2023

ABOOBACKER v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a regular bail application (Section 439 CrPC) by the second accused, ABOOBACKER, in Crime No. 1071/2022 of Tirur Police Station, Malappuram, arising from alleged transportation of 190 grams of MDMA (a commercial quantity) from Malappuram to Tirur in a car. The FIR records offences under Sections 22(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act. The prosecution contends that grant of regular bail is barred under Section 37 of the NDPS Act where a commercial quantity is involved, and that the accused is not entitled to bail given the severity and nature of the offence, while the defense urges that the petitioner is a first-time offender and that the investigation has progressed with custody since 31.10.2022, arguing for bail in light of the ratio in Fasil v. State of Kerala (2023 (3) KHC 212) since the trial could not be completed within six months. The court previously dismissed a prior bail application (BA No.1502/2023) emphasizing Section 37 constraints. A report from the Special Judge, Manjeri, indicates the trial in S.C.No.493/2023 would be disposed of within four months from 10.11.2023. Based on this report, the court holds that the ratio in Fasil is not applicable here and accordingly refuses regular bail, directing expedited trial within four months and dismissing the bail petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 4898 of 2023

Vikas @ Vyas v. State of Kerala

Vikas @ Vyas, the petitioner/accused, approaches the Kerala High Court challenging a detention-extension order under NDPS Act Section 36A(4) passed by the VII Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam. In Crime No. 51 of 2022, police seizures on 28.06.2022 included 200 LSD stamps (3.952 g) and other contraband; the accused was arrested on 29.06.2022. The 180th day of remand fell on 26.12.2022. On 22.12.2022 an application under NDPS Act, Section 36A(4) for extension of detention was filed; the Sessions Court allowed the extension of detention by two months by its 26.12.2022 order, with the extended period ending 24.02.2023. A final report was filed on 24.02.2023 and the petitioner sought statutory bail the same day, which was rejected as the final report was within the statutory period. The petitioner contends that extending detention on the ground of non-receipt of laboratory/Forensic reports is untenable, and that the extension application was not served on him or his counsel; he relies on Sanjay Dutt v. State through CBI Bombay and Jigar alias Jimmy Pravinchandra Adatiya v. State of Gujarat, asserting that the Sessions Court must inform the accused and require presence at extension proceedings. The Public Prosecutor argues the extension satisfied the statutory prerequisites and that the final report was timely. The High Court ultimately dismissed the petition, upholding the extension and the detention as lawful.

High Court of Kerala
OP (FC) Nos.420 and 442 of 2021

OP (FC) Nos.420 and 442 of 2021, High Court of Kerala

This judgment concerns two family-court petitions—OP (FC) No.420 of 2021 filed by Hazeena and OP (FC) No.442 of 2021 filed by Sareena—seeking custody and related relief regarding four minor children of Faizaludheen and Sareena. The Family Court, Kollam, by its order dated 30.06.2021, granted interim custody to the respondent mother with a structured regime for visitation, exchange and communication, while allowing the paternal grandmother to seek custody at times. The petitions were referred to mediation but failed to settle. On 20.02.2023, this Court, after hearing both sides, modified the impugned order in light of welfare-oriented custody principles and recent Supreme Court precedents. It held that the father may be granted interim custody for a short, specified period when he returns to India, ensuring the child’s education and welfare are not adversely affected. The Court reiterated that custody decisions must prioritize the child’s welfare and the right to maintain contact with both parents, permitting limited face-to-face interaction and sustained virtual communication. Maintenance was also enhanced provisionally (Rs.20,000 per month for the four children and their mother) pending final orders. The petitions were disposed of accordingly, subject to earlier orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 21821 of 2022

Geethakumary J v District Educational Officer, Punalur; Director, General Education, Thiruvananthapuram; Manager, All Saints High School, Puthayam; Government of Kerala

Geethakumary J., the petitioner, was promoted in 2017 to Headmistress of All Saints Higher Secondary School, Puthayam (an aided institution) against a retirement vacancy. The District Educational Officer approved the promotion, and Ext. P1 formalized it with effect from 01.04.2017. The petitioner, who had been serving as High School Assistant in Hindi since 2003, possessed degrees in Hindi and additional qualifications and argued that she met the graduate service requirement under Rule 44A of Chapter XIV(A) of the Kerala Education Rules (KER), including training deemed collegiate under Explanation I. The fourth respondent later cancelled the promotion (Ext. P11) on the ground that she did not possess 12 years of graduate service after acquiring collegiate training, and her appeal (Ext. P12) was refused. The petitioner challenged these orders in a writ petition. The court found Ext. P11 void for lack of due process and examined whether Acharya training (Ext. P7) qualifies as graduate service. It held that “collegiate training” includes such qualifications, interpreting Explanation I to Rule 44A and Rule 2 of Chapter XXXI of the KER, aided by amendments (Ext. P6) and contemporary judicial authority (Praveen Kumar, Sambasivan, Balakrishna Pillai). The petition was allowed: Exts. P11 and P15 were quashed, Ext. P1 promotion was upheld, and the state was ordered to disburse service benefits from 01.04.2017 and pay arrears within three months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C). No.26568 of 2022

Subhash G. and Smitha Ravi v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others

This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges Ext.P3 dated 06.08.2022, whereby the Travancore Devaswom Board extended the term of the 5th respondent Temple Advisory Committee of Kottarakkara Sree Maha Ganapathy Temple for a further six months. The petitioners, devotees of Lord Ganapathy, contend that the extension runs contrary to statutory limits under Section 31A of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 and the associated Rules, which fix a two-year term for Temple Advisory Committees, with limited permissible extensions. The respondents argue statutory power exists to extend for development works or unavoidable rituals and that the Navarathri festival necessitated continuity, especially since no ready alternative arrangements existed; interim orders and tenders are discussed in detail. The matter traverses precedent such as Chandu K. v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Sunil Kumar C. cases, which emphasize that extensions cannot be made as a matter of course and should be grounded in legitimate development or ritual needs. Ultimately, the court held Ext.P3 illegal for flouting the two-year limit, set aside the extension, and directed fresh elections to form a new Temple Advisory Committee, with the 3rd respondent convening mandalam elections within 45 days and, for Navarathri, an Ad-hoc committee may be formed excluding members of the pre-existing extended committee.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 917 OF 2006

Pious, S/O Mente's D'Cruz v. State of Kerala

Pious, the appellant, was convicted in CRL.A. 917/2006 by the Kerala High Court. The prosecution’s case stems from an incident on 2 December 1998 near Imamudheen’s shop at Paravur, where CW1 and CW2 were allegedly assaulted by the appellant with a concealed knife after an altercation in which CW1 was addressed as “Annan.” CW1 sustained a stab wound to the abdomen, and CW2 received multiple stab injuries on the stomach and chest after attempting to intervene. The injuries were treated at Holy Cross Hospital, and a first information statement (FIS) was recorded the following day; the FIR was registered shortly thereafter. The investigation culminated in the appellant’s trial in SC No.259/2000 in the Additional District & Sessions Court (Adhoc)–II, Kollam, where PW1 to PW10 testified and Exhibits P1–P12 and MO1 were marked. The defence contended lack of independent corroboration, delay in FIR, and that wound certificates (P2/P3) and treatment record (P4) were unreliable; the weapon’s recovery premised on a confession under Section 27 of the Evidence Act was also challenged. The prosecution maintained that the evidence of PW1–PW3, aided by PW4 (hostile in part) and medical corroboration, established the guilt. The Sessions Judge convicted under Section 307 IPC and sentenced four years’ rigorous imprisonment with a Rs.25,000 fine, plus a six‑month default sentence; set‑off under Section 428 Cr.P.C. was allowed. On appeal, the Kerala High Court upheld the conviction and sentence, emphasizing coherent testimonies, lighting conditions near the shop, and medical corroboration.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.19714/21

W.P.(C) No.19714/21 – Rev. T.G. Johnson v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition challenges the suspension and subsequent actions involving Sivakumari R., the principal of Sankara Menon Memorial Higher Secondary School, Pazhampalacode. The fourth respondent was initially suspended on 23.09.2020, with a six-month extension on 06-10-2020. The High Court had previously quashed Exts. P18 and P20 in a 30.03.2021 judgment (W.P.(C) No.125859/2020) and directed that any disciplinary action be taken strictly in accordance with the Kerala Education Rules (KER). Nevertheless, an order of suspension was issued on 07.04.2021, and Contempt Case No. 788 of 2021 followed, which was closed on 10.08.2021 with a reminder that a statutory remedy must be pursued for any violation. Petitioner sought to reinstate or otherwise challenge the later extension and reinstatement orders, alleging lack of authority to sanction beyond 15 days and questioning the legal footing of Ext. P7. The court examined the amendments to Rule 67(7) and Rule 68 of Chapter XIV-A of the KER through GO(MS) No.235(1)/2009 and SRO 433/2019, noting that sanction for beyond-15-day suspensions must come from an officer authorised by the Government. It held that without such sanction the extension is invalid and dismissed the petition, concluding there is no need to exercise jurisdiction under Article 226."