Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 439 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 30 of 2016

Vengoyil V.N. Anilkumar v. Anandhoth A Kunhikannan & others

This Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 30 of 2016) is a Kerala High Court decision in a Rent/arrears dispute arising from O.S. No. 135/2008 before the Subordinate Judge, Vadakara. The plaintiff (Respondent) held that the plaint schedule building belonged to him and had earlier obtained eviction of defendants 2–4 (who later surrendered) through Rent Control proceedings. The suit was filed for arrears of rent amounting to Rs. 1,42,481/-, after the first defendant (Appellant) allegedly took possession of the building on 01.01.2006 under Ext. A1 rent deed for Rs. 3,750 per month, with the 4th defendant managing operations. The appellant contends Ext. A1 is a sham document entered at the plaintiff’s request to secure higher rents, and that no genuine landlord–tenant relationship exists. Ext. A2 (a letter) and Ext. A3 (licence request to a Grama Panchayat) are argued as post hoc contrivances; the handwriting expert’s report is criticised for lacking conclusive proof and is said to be corroborated by other evidence. The trial court and II Additional District Judge found Ext. A1 genuine and the appellant as the tenant in arrears, and both courts rejected the sham-document arguments. The High Court, after reviewing evidence and applicable law, held there was a tenancy and dismissed the second appeal for lack of substantial questions of law, upholding the decrees.”

High Court of Kerala
BA No.6034 of 2024

RINSHAD and MUHAMMED v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 6034 of 2024) before the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, arising from Crime No. 401/2024 of Guruvayoor Police Station, Thrissur. The petitioners, accused 2 and 5, challenge detention under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 and seek bail under Section 483 BNSS. The prosecution alleges that on 05 July 2024 at about 22:45 hours, accused 1–3 formed an unlawful assembly and, armed with sticks and an iron pipe, trespassed into the Polakulath Sree Krishna Regency Bar Hotel where the defacto supervisor was assaulted, resulting in grievous injuries. Accused 5 allegedly aided their escape in a private vehicle. The offences cited include BNSS sections 189(2), 191(2), 191(3), 329(3), 126(2), 118(1), 118(2) and 190. The petitioners have been in judicial custody since 10 July 2024; the investigation is claimed to be largely complete with some recoveries. The petitioners contend innocence, challenge the invocation of 118(2), and note the lack of demonstrated grievous injury. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing imminent investigation and the risk of interference if released. The court cites Prasanta Kumar Sarkar to articulate bail considerations and ultimately holds that the first petitioner/second accused is not entitled to bail, while the second petitioner/fifth accused is entitled to bail upon a bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties and several conditions, including reporting to the IO weekly, non-interference with witnesses, no new offences, passport surrender, and a provision for cancellation of bail if necessary, with powers reserved for continued investigation and possible recoveries under law.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 20753 of 2023

W.P.(C) No. 20753 of 2023 — Thrippapoor Major Sree Mahadevar Temple v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others

This writ petition, filed by devotees of the Thrippapoor Major Sree Mahadevar Temple under the Travancore Devaswom Board, challenges the functioning of the Temple Advisory Committee (the 6th respondent) led by its President (7th) and Secretary (8th). The petition contends that the Committee operates without Board approval, raises funds from devotees in the temple’s name using allegedly fake receipts, and undertakes activities—such as Udayasthamana Pooja and Thulam Mahotsavam—without proper authorization or audit, as evidenced by receipts (Exts.P2–P9) and a public notice (Ext.P10). The petition seeks mandamus directing the Board to consider Ext.P14 in light of Ext.P1 Rules on Temple Advisory Committees and Ext.P11 circular (Finance and Accounts Officer, 01.08.2013), and to direct the Vigilance Officer to inquire into Exts.P12–P14. The case outlines statutory duties under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, particularly Sections 3, 31 and 31A, and the Rules framed for Temple Advisory Committees (Clauses 2, 3, 9, 9.1–9.4, 11, 18), including the requirement of board permission for fund collection and annual audit of accounts. The respondents deny wrongdoing, asserting prior permissions and proper accounting. The Court ultimately directs continued Board management of temple activities pending a vigilance report and final Board decision, while keeping the matter open for further submissions and ensuring vigilance oversight.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 3687 OF 2019 & MACA NO. 73 OF 2020

Divya Sajikumar and Others v. Kuldeep Mistri and Ashly K. Varghese and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal from the Kerala High Court arising out of O.P.(MV) No.1008/2015 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, involving the death of Sajikumar in a road accident on 11.09.2014. The Mahindra autorickshaw (KL 17 J 6584) owned by the 2nd respondent and insured by the 3rd respondent struck the decedent while he stood by the roadside. The Tribunal held the driver negligent and that the insurer could pay the compensation initially, with a right of recovery against the driver and the owner since the vehicle was allegedly driven without the owner’s consent. The 3rd respondent Insurance Company contested liability on grounds that the driver was a minor and license issues, while the 2nd respondent argued there was no employer–employee relationship and disputed the quantum. Evidence on record led the Tribunal to fix a quantum of Rs.13,57,250 with 8% interest. On appeal, the High Court reassessed the income of the deceased, applying the Ramachandrappa principle, and increased monthly income to Rs.11,000 with 25% future prospects and a multiplier of 14, resulting in a higher dependency figure. It also adjusted loss of consortium and rejected separate compensation for love and affection in light of Somwati and Satinder Kaur. The Court held that the insurer has a right of recovery, upholding it against the driver and owner, while granting the claimants an additional Rs.5,81,250 as enhanced compensation. The 2nd respondent’s recovery challenge was dismissed. The overall outcome: MACA 3687/2019 allowed, MACA 73/2020 dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 1152 of 2014

Balan v. Mohanan and Others (Regular Second Appeal)

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a partition suit filed by the plaintiff, Balan, seeking to partition and realize relinquishment of his co-sharers’ rights in a 13-cent property at Kalloor Village, Thrissur District. The co-heirs included defendants 1–4 (the widow and children of the late Madhavan) and defendants 5–7 (the children of the deceased son Raman) who allegedly entered into a family arrangement. The plaintiff claimed an oral partition on 28 December 2005, whereby the siblings relinquished their rights to him for Rs. 9,000 per cent, with a formal relinquishment deed to be executed. Defendants 5–7 allegedly executed Ext.A3 relinquishment deeds in 2006; defendants 1–4 did not execute to date. The trial court dismissed the suit for partition, and the first appellate court confirmed. The plaintiff challenged in the Kerala High Court, contending that Ext.A2 (an alleged agreement) and the oral partition were not properly denied and that family arrangements should be upheld. The High Court found no proven oral partition or family arrangement, noted that Ext.A2 was not pleaded or proved, and observed that the defendants’ denial was not specifically addressed in the plaint. It cited pleadings-related authorities as not applicable to the facts. The court did, however, modify the counter-claim decree, holding that defendants 5–7 should not receive 1/6 shares, while defendants 2–4 are entitled to 1/6 each. The appeal is dismissed, with no costs, and the counter-claim decree is partially modified.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.16454 of 2022

Periyar Arcade Kottamam and Others v. Village Officer Kalady, Tahsildar and State of Kerala

Periyar Arcade Kottamam and two partners approached the Kerala High Court seeking mutation of immovable properties contributed by them as capital into the partnership firm. The petition challenges Ext.P8, an order returning mutation applications on the ground that there is no provision under the Transfer of Registry Rules, 1964 enabling mutation in the name of the firm absent a registered transfer document, and in the absence of a court order. The petitioners rely on Ext.P1 (partnership deed) and Ext.P2 (registration acknowledgement) to show that the properties were brought in as capital by the partners, thereby becoming the firm’s assets. They argue that under Section 14 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, a transfer by operation of law occurs when property is contributed to the firm, and that mutation should therefore be granted. The respondents contend mutation requires registered documents or a court directive under the relevant rules. The court references George V.J. & Ors. v. V.V.George & Ors. (2010) and Park Residency (M/s.) v. State of Kerala (2013) to endorse the proposition that partners may convert their individual property into the firm’s property by agreement, not necessitating a separate registered transfer. Ultimately, the court holds that the firm owns the property by operation of law and directs mutation in the firm’s name, allowing the writ petition.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.2250 of 2023

M/S.ELSTONE TEA ESTATES LIMITED v. STATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS

The petitioner, Elstone Tea Estates Limited, challenges the restoration of three plots (Plot B: 2.10 hectares in Survey No.658/6; Plot E: 3.5250 hectares in Survey No.659/5; Plot F: 12.5 hectares in Survey No.659/6) vesting with the Government under the Kerala Private Forest (Vesting & Assignment) Act, 1971. The matter traces back to O.A. 217/1977 and subsequent proceedings before the Forest Tribunal Palakkad (O.A.44/1990) and the High Court in MFA No.428/1991, culminating in a Division Bench judgment dated 07.06.2002 holding that Plot E and F were exempt from vesting as well, despite earlier orders. The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition on 08.01.2004, rendering the High Court’s order final for those plots. In 2018, the Court directed restoration in WP(C) 2667/2018, and later in 2022, WP(C) 20572/2022 directed restoration. The Divisional Forest Officer, however, issued Ext.P12 (04-01-2023) certifying restoration of only two plots with recitals asserting Central Government permissions for non-forestry uses and restricting the land’s use under Ext.P13 via conditions. The petitioner contends that vesting never occurred for these plots; the conditions imposed are illegal and the restoration must be to the owner as on 10.05.1971. The Court quashes Ext.P12 and Ext.P13, and orders restoration of Plot B to the petitioner within three months, refusing costs. The writ petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.5909/2023

Prasanth Bhattathiri v. State of Kerala and Others

The case arises from a writ petition (W.P.(C) No.5909/2023) filed by Prasanth Bhattathiri, a co-owner of padasekharam land in Keerikkad, Alappuzha, challenging the inaction of state authorities against the 11th respondent, who allegedly seeks to reclaim padasekharam land. The petitioner alleges that the 11th respondent is digging earth to a depth of 10–15 metres and constructing an unauthorized bund on land that forms part of a larger padasekharam, thereby threatening irreparable loss to the petitioner's land and to the padasekharam as a whole. He claims that this reclamation violates the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 and the Rules thereunder. Despite complaints to the Grama Panchayat Secretary (10th respondent), Village Officers (5th and 6th respondents), Tahsildar, RDO and District Collector, no effective remedial action was taken. The petitioner contends that the 5th and 6th respondents were duty-bound to intervene and prevent reclamation. The 11th respondent counters that he sought to cultivate paddy but topsoil removal rendered cultivation unsuitable; Fisheries Department permission in 2020 allegedly authorizes pisciculture, an intermediary crop that could enhance land fertility. The court cites Wonderla Holidays v. RDO, Muvattupuzha to acknowledge permissible intermediary-crop activity in padasekharam and ultimately dismisses the petition, while clarifying that authorities may act if statutory violations are found.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 7479 of 2011

Alex Mathew and Mariamma Mathew v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner-II, EPFO and EPF Appellate Tribunal

Petitioners Alex Mathew and Mariamma Mathew, heirs of late A.T. Mathew, challenge orders under the Provident Fund Act concerning a 100-acre Mettukuzhy Estate and its alleged disruption into six units. The estate was partitioned in 1967 among six buyers; the PF authorities initially treated KR/2378 as the estate code and later assessed dues from the six owners up to 5/75 and from the heirs of Mathew up to 31-10-1980. The petitioners contend that the sale and management of six separately treated estates created a real and bonafide division resulting in six separate establishments, with distinct personnel and separate tax registrations; therefore they should not be held liable for Provident Fund contributions as a single unit. They rely on Ext.P1 (teer deed) and Ext.P3-P7 documents showing separate treatment, Ext.P2 Extinguishing earlier orders, and on this Court’s Full Bench decision in TA Zainulabdeen v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner. The respondents maintain that the estate continued under common management with shared employees; a single agreement and consolidated management existed. The High Court found the enquiry deficient, set aside the impugned order Ext.P8, and allowed the writ petition, directing fresh consideration consistent with TA Zainulabdeen and the KM Eapen line of authorities, thereby guiding a reassessment in light of partition doctrine and functional integrity.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.26954/18

Mohana Kumar.K.P. v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition, filed by Mohana Kumar K. P., a former employee of the erstwhile Malabar Marketing Committee (MMC), challenges government orders that regularized MMC staff into government service but denied retroactive benefits to the petitioner who retired in 2006. The MMC was held to be defunct by this Court in Ext. P1 (1998) and its assets and liabilities vested in the Government. Pursuant to Ext. P3, MMC employees were redeployed to Government service; 58 were redeployed, with 53 remaining in service when Ext. P9 (2007) regularized their service, but without retrospective effect. Ext. P17 (2011) further modified Ext. P9 to count MMC service for pension calculations for those regularized, yet the petitioner was denied these benefits. The Government contends there is no retrospective effect and relies on Ext. R1(a) (2018) clarifying this policy. The Court highlights the lack of justification for denying benefits to a person who had 17 years of MMC service and notes the identical treatment accorded to others. It holds that differential treatment without justification undermines Article 14 protections. Accordingly, the petition is allowed, Ext. P25’s denial is set aside, and the Government is directed to grant Ext. P9 and Ext. P17 benefits to the petitioner forthwith, while cautioning that stale claims may not be entertained.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 291 OF 2023

Raseena and Hanna Fathima (Minor) Represented by Mother v. The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA No. 291 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court, arising from an award in OP(MV) No.1931/2016 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kollam. On 13 July 2016, a minor claimant was struck by a vehicle driven rashly, sustaining serious injuries resulting in 13% permanent disability. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 2,97,000 as compensation, which the appellant contends is inadequate. The appellant relies on Master Mallikarjun v. Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Another (2014) 14 SCC 396, arguing that for a child with 13% disability the disability head must be at least Rs. 3,00,000, and seeks enhancement under other heads such as Extra Nourishment and Bystander’s Expenses. The insurer counters that the Tribunal’s assessment, including the notional monthly income (Rs. 5,000) and overall computation, is appropriate and should be sustained. During the hearing, the court notes the need to examine evidence and, following Master Mallikarjun (Supra), concludes that the disability compensation must be fixed at Rs. 3,00,000 and that Extra Nourishment and Bystander’s Expenses warrant increases. The court partially allows the appeal, deletes portions of the previous award, and recalibrates compensation while keeping other heads intact. Interest at 7.5% and costs are also addressed, with deposits to be made within two months.

High Court of Kerala
OP (DRT) No. 212 of 2021

Ideal Powertech Ltd. and Others v State Bank of India

This High Court original petition challenges the Debt Recovery Tribunal proceedings in TA 210/2017 and DRC 105/2019, praying to stay the proceedings till MA 75/2021 is heard. The petitioners, M/S Ideal Powertech Ltd., M/S Thomas Easaw Ltd., Thomas Easaw, Grace Thomas and Mathai Easaw, allege serious irregularities by the DRT, including disobedience of court orders by the presiding officer Smt. S.V. Gowramma and tampering with documents. They contend that essential records were not certified and that a banker's cheque dated 02.01.2006 was pre-dated, suggesting fraud and collusion by bank counsel; they also argue that the loan transaction lacks a valid agreement and that the OA/ securitisation proceedings were conducted mala fide. They have moved amendments and impleadment of additional respondents, arguing that the petition raises issues affecting the conduct of the Tribunal; they seek stay of the OA and related proceedings until the amendment is decided, and costs. The respondent State Bank of India counters that the OA was filed within the statutory limitation under Article 62 of the Limitation Act and that mortgage documents are in the bank’s custody; it asserts that there is no fraud and that the petition is an abuse of process. The High Court, after weighing the arguments and the record, rejects the petition, finds no prejudice as alleged, refuses the amendment, and dismisses the petition with no orders on costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.4353 OF 2019

Muhammedshafi v. State of Kerala

MUHAMMEDSHAFI v. State of Kerala (CRL.MC 4353/2019) involves a petition to quash CC 1264/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Muvattupuzha. The accused is charged with offences under IPC sections 448 (trespass) and 506 (criminal intimidation). The informant, MD of Sabine Hospital, alleges the accused trespassed at midnight on 19 May 2018, photographed the informant, and threatened to circulate the pictures if hospital equipment purchases were not made. The FIR was registered on 30 June 2018, initially listing section 506; counsel contends section 506 is non-cognizable, and that section 448 was slapped in at the time of filing the final report to circumvent Section 155(2) Cr.P.C. Relying on Haneefa v. State of Kerala (2023 KHC Online 973), the petitioner argues that investigation for a non-cognizable offense cannot commence without a magistrate's order, and that such maneuvering invalidates the investigation. The Public Prosecutor counters that 448 was incorporated at registration. The High Court finds the FIR to show 506 with 448 inked later, and holds that the initiation of investigation without a magistrate’s order for a non-cognizable offense renders it faulty. It also finds no material for the 506 offense and, applying the broad cautionary principles from Bhajan Lal, and Madhavrao Scindia, invokes its inherent power under 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the proceedings. The petition is allowed; CC 1264/2018 is quashed.

High Court of Kerala
OP (CAT) Nos.188/2014, 95/2015, 124/2015 and 189/2014

Union of India and Others v. P. Sethumadhavan and Others (OP CAT Nos. 188/2014, 95/2015, 124/2015 and 189/2014)

This batch of Original Petitions (OP (CAT) Nos. 188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015) was heard in the Kerala High Court challenging Central Administrative Tribunal orders directing financial upgradation of Grade Pay in the next promotion hierarchy for staff of Naval Armament Depot and other central government cadres. The petitioners, led by Union of India, submitted that such upgradation is governed by the Central Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 and the related DoPT memoranda, and that the CAT orders were legally unsustainable. The respondents (the petitioners in various OAs before the CAT) urged entitlement to the financial upgradation, citing the pay structure and representations under the revised pay framework. During arguments, counsel for the parties referenced a Supreme Court decision in Union of India v. MV Mohanan Nair (2020), which allowed the Union of India’s appeals and effectively influenced the interpretation of upgradation in the batch. The High Court, applying Mohanan Nair, held that the batch is decided in favour of the petitioners and against the respondents, and accordingly allowed the Original Petitions. The judgment was delivered by Justices S. V. Bhatti and Basant Balaji on 23 March 2023, reaffirming the government’s stance on pay upgradation under the 2008 rules and related memoranda.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 1901 OF 2012

The Malanad Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. v Employees Provident Fund Organisation (and Others)

This writ petition challenges orders under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF Act) concerning exemption from the EPF Scheme for a co‑operative bank. The Malanad Bank, a Primary Co‑operative Agricultural & Rural Development Bank in Idukki, had followed a self‑financing pension scheme rather than the statutory EPF/MP scheme. It joined the State government pension scheme in 1993 and claimed exemptions under Sections 7A and the provision governing exemptions (and related Sections 16(1)(a) and (c)) on the grounds of the bank’s size and structure. The Regional PF authorities assessed dues under Section 7A, and the EPF Tribunal dismissed the appeal (Ext.P12). The High Court, noting a divergent line of authorities and the bank’s pleadings, revisits the matter, including reliance on earlier Kerala and national precedents that exemptions can be permissible for similar cooperative entities. The court quashes Ext.P12, sets aside the Tribunal’s order, and directs the Tribunal to rehear the appeal in accordance with law, while keeping an interim stay in force. It also emphasizes the need for pragmatic consideration by quasi‑judicial bodies and allows the parties to rely on additional law and documents. The writ petition is disposed of with directions to decide afresh within four months from a certified copy of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
RP (FC) No.496 of 2016

Nizar v. Habeebath M.K. and Ors.

This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC challenging the Family Court, Chavara’s order in MC 276/2014 directing maintenance to the wife and children. The revision petitioner, Nizar, a police head constable, contends that the Family Court erred in fixing maintenance at Rs. 5,000 to the wife, Rs. 6,000 to the second respondent (son), and Rs. 4,000 to the third respondent (daughter/minor) per month from 24.11.2014 onward. The respondents assert that the first respondent was married to the petitioner on 3.5.1998 and that two children were born in 1999 and 2002; the petitioner allegedly deserted the family on 03.10.2013 and has refused to maintain them despite a substantial monthly salary and additional income from a business. The Family Court found the petitioner well employed and liable to pay Rs. 15,000 per month, observed to be reasonable, and directed payments accordingly. The petitioner argues that the wife is living separately without sufficient cause and offers to maintain Rs. 1,500 per month for each child. He produced a salary certificate showing about Rs. 31,640 monthly salary and claimed he has not moved to restore conjugal relations. The High Court upheld the Family Court’s order, relying on social-justice principles behind maintenance law, and dismissed the revision petition. The case underscores the protective intent of Sec.125 CrPC and the social-justice framework for wives and minor children.

High Court of Kerala
WP.(C)No.14342 of 2019 & con.cases

Thiruvabharana Patha Samrakshana Samithi v. Travancore Devaswom Board

This is a cluster of writ petitions concerning encroachments along the Thiruvabharana Patha, the ceremonial route used to transport Tiruvabharanam (Lord Ayyappa’s sacred ornaments) from Pandalam Palace to Sabarimala during Makara Makara Sankramam. The primary petitioner, Thiruvabharana Patha Samrakshana Samithi, along with several other petitioners, challenged encroachment on the traditional path and sought immediate implementation of the survey and eviction measures mandated by Ext. P1 (2009 decision) to clear the path of encroachments by 31 December 2009 and, more broadly, to restore the Patha to its original extent. The petitions argue that encroachments risk the sanctity of the Patha and impede the religious procession, and request urgent protective measures, surveys, demarcation (mahazar), and eviction orders via the Land Conservancy Act and related legal framework. The State, Travancore Devaswom Board (TDW), and district authorities contest the procedural posture, arguing that enforcement must proceed under established statutory frameworks (Land Conservancy Act, Panchayat Raj Act) with due process. The judgment ultimately directs a time-bound, mahazar-based eviction process through Tahsildars and Revenue authorities, unsettles prior notices lacking mahazar, and mandates a fresh round of notices and hearings, aiming to complete encroachment removal within a defined period.

High Court of Kerala
OP (RC) No.114 of 2021

OP (RC) No.114 of 2021 (Akbar Ali v. Dr. Shahida Madathil and Dr. Nadheer Pallimooppan)

Akbar Ali, the tenant, challenges an eviction order issued under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, by the Rent Control Court, Kannur, in EP 322/2019 arising from RCP 13/2018. The eviction arose after a mediation (Ext.P1) that culminated in Ext.P2, directing payment of Rs.19,250 in arrears by 13.10.2018, plus rent at Rs.1200 from 01.08.2018 and a 10% annual increase, with occupancy to continue unless default occurred. The petitioner contends Ext.P1 remains executory rather than converting into a fresh eviction framework; accordingly, the respondents cannot obtain possession through Ext.P2 without a new eviction order under Section 11, and the tenancy arrangement should persist under the mediatory terms. The petitioner argues he paid rent up to March 2019 (receipts and subsequent money orders) and that the Respondents’ claims of non-payment are unproven; he also asserts that the eviction order is not properly executable since an eviction under Section 11(2)(b) would only be final if not vacated within the statutory period. The Munsiff found that Rs.19,250 was not paid on 02.08.2018 as claimed, rendering the Ext.P2 order mature into eviction under Sec. 11(2)(b). The High Court dismissed the petition, holding there was no valid basis to interfere with Ext.P6 and relying on a binding precedent regarding deposit within time. The petition was dismissed with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 28461 of 2018 (and connected cases)

Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 28461/2018 & connected cases (KSRTC regularisation) - High Court of Kerala

The batch of writ petitions arises from the KSRTC regularisation regime created by bipartite settlement and government orders. Petitioners,KSRTC provisional empanelled drivers, conductors and mechanics, challenged termination/termination-like actions by KSRTC following the government and Supreme Court guidance on regularisation. The core dispute centers on conditions for regularisation as of 21.12.2011, notably ten years of service and a minimum 120 days of duty per year, and whether post hoc government instructions could affect those already regularised. The High Court traced the history: bipartite settlement of 2008; Government orders 22.12.2011 (GO MS 78/2011) setting ten-year duration and related criteria; subsequent directives including 21.11.2013 (GO MS 105/2013) and 26.03.2018 (GO 129/2018); KSRTC’s 2012-2018 actions terminating services; Suresh Kumar v. State of Kerala (2013) KLT 258, and later Supreme Court interventions in Civil Appeals Nos. 4435-4438/2017 and SLPs 18803-18806/2014. The judgment ultimately holds that the Supreme Court’s declarations bind all, including those with separate judgments, and sets aside KSRTC’s termination orders. It directs KSRTC to grant hearing to petitioners to establish ten years’ service and 120 days’ duty up to 21.12.2011, and to regularise those meeting the twin criteria within specified time, while providing pension/benefits for eligible cases and preserving rights of those already superannuated or deceased.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) Nos. 2631/2023, 2404/2023, 2409/2023

OP(C) Nos. 2631/2023, 2404/2023 and 2409/2023 collectively titled: Shadiya Beevi KVK v. Sayyed Hashim K.V.K; Sainaba Beevi v. Sayyed Hashim K.V.K; Mariyam Beevi KVK v. Sayyed Hashim K.V.K

Three Original Petitions, OP(C) Nos. 2631/2023, 2404/2023 and 2409/2023, in the Kerala High Court challenge an order Ext. P6 consolidating three suits in the Sub Court/Commercial Court, Manjeri, all for specific performance of separate sale agreements executed among siblings. The petitions are by Shadiya Beevi and Sainaba Beevi and Mariyam Beevi (petitioners/defendants) against Sayyed Hashim K.V.K (plaintiff). All three suits concern contiguous properties owned by four siblings; the disputes primarily rest on similar documentary evidence and a common plaintiff, though different witnesses and forms of evidence would be adduced in each case. The petitioners argue that the three suits are distinct and should not be tried together, given the differences in transactions, witnesses, and evidential aims. The respondent contends that consolidation would save time and avoid conflicting decisions, since the properties lie contiguously and the factual framework overlaps. The High Court, after hearing counsel, observed that while consolidation is not prohibited, it is not mandatory to consolidate; it relied on Prem Lala Nahata and Janardhanan Pillai to emphasise that consolidation may be allowed where common questions of law or fact arise, or where convenience justifies it. It held that Ext. P6 does not suffer illegality, and the petitions fail. The court thus dismissed the Original Petitions.