Petitioners, a group of 29 retired employees of the Employees’ Provident Fund establishments, challenge the computation of pension under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, and the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. They contend that pension must be fixed on the average monthly pay drawn during the 12 months immediately preceding retirement and must include 8 1/3% of the full contribution made by the employers in respect of them, without applying any artificial wage ceiling prescribed by the pension scheme. The reliefs sought include (i) a mandamus directing respondents 2 to 5 to re-fix pension on that basis; (ii) arrears and revised pension after re-fixation; and (iii) a declaration that they are entitled to the benefits conferred by Ext.P2 judgment. Respondents 2–5 (EPFO) submit that the issue is settled by the Supreme Court in EPF Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B and Others (2022), and the petition should be decided in light of those directions. The High Court, noting the Supreme Court ruling, disposes of the petition by directing the competent authorities to reconsider the petitioners’ claims in light of the Sunil Kumar B dictum within three months from receipt of this judgment. Appendix lists petitioners’ and respondents’ exhibits; the judgment underscores applying the Supreme Court’s directives for pension computation under the relevant schemes.
This High Court of Kerala decision deals with a criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC filed by four petitioners (Navas. P; Abdul Nazer. P; Abdul Basheer. P; Abdul Kareem) seeking quashing of proceedings in CP No.49/2023 arising from Crime No.535/2023 of Hosdurg Police Station. The offences charged include sections 341, 323, 324, 506 and 308 read with 34 IPC. The petitioners contend that the parties have settled their dispute and the victims do not oppose quashing; affidavits from the victims in support were filed. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, though he acknowledged the dispute’s settlement. The court examined the matter in light of the Supreme Court’s guidance on quashing non-compoundable offences under Section 482 CrPC, citing Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012 (10) SCC 303), and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab and another (2014 (6) SCC 466). The court held the dispute to be private in nature and that settlement can be accepted, directing quashing of all further proceedings in CP No.49/2023. The decision clarifies that such quashing is appropriate when offences are private, non-serious, and the accused’s antecedents and conduct support settlement, not in cases involving heinous or statute-based offences. The order effectively terminates the criminal proceedings against the petitioners.
This is a Kerala High Court writ appeal (W.A. No.2424 of 2016) arising from an industrial dispute concerning a dismissed workman. The appellant, N. Nandakumar, challenged Ext.P7, an award of the Labour Court, Kollam in ID No.123/99, which held the dismissal of the workman to be unjustified and directed reinstatement with 30% back wages. The factual matrix shows that on 11-09-1997 the workman (the first respondent) faced a charge-sheet amid an incident involving preventing entry of the managing partner into the factory for over two hours and using filthy language; although two co-accused received some leniency, the first respondent was dismissed. The Labour Court found the domestic enquiry valid and that the charge was proved, and it proceeded to consider proportionality under Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act. It ultimately modified the punishment to reinstatement with 30% back wages and withholding 70% back wages. The learned single Judge affirmed the Labour Court’s findings but did not disturb the reinstatement order.
On appeal, the management contended proportionality and relied on a Supreme Court decision (Mahendra Nissan Allwyns, Ltd. v. M.P. Siddappa) to argue against interference. The High Court approved the Labour Court’s and the learned Judge’s conclusion that the punishment was proportionate and dismissed the writ appeal. The court thus upheld the reinstatement with 30% back wages and maintained 70% non-payment. The appeal failed; the Labour Court’s award stood.
WPC 16372/23, 17807/23, 18324/23, 17085/23 & 20070/23 These writ petitions challenge a Labour Court preliminary ruling that a charge memo issued by the disciplinary sub-committee of a Pannianore Pancha- yath Consumer Co- operative Stores was issued by an incompetent authority under Rule 198 of the Kerala Co- operative Societies Rules. The Labour Court had relied on Kodanchery Service Co- operative Bank Ltd. v. Joshy Varghese to hold that the charge memo was void and directed fresh memos by a competent authority. The petitioners’ counsel submitted that a Full Bench of this Court in Mattannur Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. The Co- operative Arbitration Court and another (ILR 2023 (3) Kerala 863) has settled the issue in their favor, holding that the Disciplinary Sub-Committee, under Rule 198(2A)/(2B), and the Managing Committee both possess jurisdiction to issue memos in disciplinary proceedings, with the President’s role left open. The judgment overrules the earlier Kodanchery line and clarifies that the Apex Court alone can adopt a doctrine of prospective overruling (Golak Nath doctrine). It also directs circulars for timely constituting a disciplinary sub-committee and remitting the cases for fresh merits in light of Mattan- nour. Accordingly, the petitions are allowed, the impugned awards set aside, and the matters remitted to the Labour Court for fresh consideration on merits in accordance with law.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC challenges the continuation of CC 692/2019 filed by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Nedumangad, arising from Venjaramoodu Crime 546/2019 in Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners, accused 1–3 (Tha ha, Hassain, and Althaf), through Adv. V. A. Vinod, seek quashing of proceedings for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 294(b), 506(ii), and 427 read with 149. The State and police officials (respondents) oppose quashing, though the public prosecutor concedes that the dispute has been settled between the parties. The prosecution alleges an unlawful assembly, filthy language directed at victims, and acts of mischief. The central issue is whether non‑compoundable offences can be quashed under Section 482 CrPC based on a private settlement and lack of public interest. The High Court relies on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others, and on Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to articulate a set of conditions under which quashing can be permissible. The court notes that the offences are private in nature, the dispute is settled, and the victims do not object. After considering the facts and affidavits, the court holds that the settlement is bona fide, the matter private, and the entire proceedings can be quashed. The order, dated 15 November 2023, allows the Crl.M.C., quashing CC 692/2019.
This Kerala High Court Insurance Appeal (INS.APP No. 6 of 2019) challenges the Employees’ Insurance Court (Kozhikode) order in EIC No. 23 of 2015, which held that the death of Santhosh Kumar Kolody, a canvassing/marketing employee of Indus Motors Company (P) Ltd, while deputed to the UAE, was an employment injury and entitled his dependents to ESI benefits. The deceased reportedly died on 20/21 December 2012 during overseas duty for marketing Maruti cars; he was treated as an employee of the 2nd respondent (employer) and his ESI contributions were remitted to the 1st respondent until December 2012. The 1st respondent ESIC contends that the employer had no UAE branch and that the deceased’s employment abroad did not fall within the Act’s scope, arguing that he cannot be an employee under Section 2(9) of the ESI Act. The EIC found the deceased to be an insured person and concluded the death, caused by stress and strain arising from employment, was an employment injury; dependents were entitled to benefits. The High Court affirms, citing liberal construction of the ESI Act as a beneficial social security measure and relying on Shakunthala v. Prabhakaran, Shah v. Rajankutty, and Bombay Anand Bhavan Restaurant v. ESI Corp. The appeal is dismissed, upholding the EIC’s findings.
This original petition (OP(C) No. 460 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam challenges Ext.P7, a common order passed on 15.02.2023 in I.A. Nos. 02/2023 and 04/2023 in A.C. No. 02/2021 before the Arbitral Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners (respondent Nos. 1 and 2 before the Tribunal) argue that the Arbitral Tribunal erred in denying permission to hold an oral hearing or to examine the Secretary of the Kerala Football Association, seeking summons to secure his presence for presenting evidence. They contend that Section 24 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 vests the tribunal with discretion to determine whether hearings should be oral and when they should occur, and that the stage at which the tribunal refused was improper and violative of law. The petition relies on Delhi High Court dicta (Sukhbir Singh v Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd) and Supreme Court dicta (Bhaven Construction v E.E., Sardar Sarovar; Deep Industries v ONGC) about limits on judicial intervention under Articles 226/227 and the exceptional rarity standard. The Tribunal’s order dismissed the IAs, effectively denying oral examination at the current stage, and the High Court ultimately held that the matter did not exhibit exceptional rarity for interference. The petition is dismissed with no costs, but the petitioners retain legal remedies.
The petitioner, Tiju K. John, a teacher in S.H. Mount Higher Secondary School, sought medical reimbursement for treatment related to a pre-term delivery and neonatal care at Caritas Hospital, Thellakom, after an emergency sequence starting 23.04.2014. She was referred to a medical college but, due to complications, was admitted to the non-empanelled Caritas Hospital where the premature baby was born at six months and treated in NICU until 07.06.2014. The hospital’s non-recognition led to Ext.P6, an order dated 25.09.2015, rejecting the reimbursement claim. The petitioner submitted a representation again, but it was rejected on the ground that the hospital was not approved by the Government. The petitioner relied on George Thomas (Dr.) v. State of Kerala, Surjit Singh v. State of Punjab, and Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India, which discuss non-empanelled facilities in emergencies and emphasize that the essential test is the actual treatment with proper records, not the panel status. The court, noting the directive in WP 6214/2015 to consider Ext.P4 representations, held that the Ext.P6 reasoning was unsustainable and relied on the cited judgments to protect a government employee’s right to medical care in emergencies. The writ petition was allowed, with directions to reimburse within a month plus interest, and further interest on delay.
Mat.Appeal No.107 of 2023 This is a Matrimonial Appeal (Mat.Appeal No.107 of 2023) filed under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, challenging the Family Court, Kalpetta’s order dated 24/11/2022 in OP 187/2020, which dissolved the marriage on the ground of cruelty. The appellant husband (Oshin James) seeks to upset the trial court’s decree; the respondent wife (Tinto Varghese) defends it. The parties married on 06/11/2016; they have a child. The wife allegedly developed mental illness from childhood and, after disputed incidents including alleged harassment and the family’s insistence on attendance at counseling, left the matrimonial home. The husband contends that there was continuous mental cruelty, non-cooperation, and acts such as false police complaints stemming from alleged dowry harassment; he asserts the marriage has broken down with no chance of reconciliation, making continued cohabitation itself cruel. The wife’s countered allegations include harassment and false criminal proceedings against the husband and his family. The bench considers whether the trial court’s findings of cruelty are sound, applying established doctrine that mental cruelty cannot be confined by a fixed formula and depends on circumstances. Relying on precedents like Samar Ghosh, Naveen Kohli, and K. Srinivas Rao, the High Court dismisses the appeal, upholding the dissolution of marriage and declining costs, with interlocutory applications closed.
O.P.(DRT) No. 393 of 2022 The petitioner, Vinu Thomas, challenges Ext.P2, an un-numbered Securitisation Application rejected as time-barred under the SARFAESI Act. The undisputed facts show that the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam, issued a notice under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act for taking physical possession of the secured asset. An Advocate Commissioner served a notice on 29-07-2022 directing vacant possession within 14 days. The petitioner filed a Securitisation Application under Section 17 on 14-09-2022, which the Tribunal rejected for lacking within 45 days from 29-07-2022, deeming it time-barred by two days. The petitioner contends that limitation cannot start from 29-07-2022 because each day after the Advocate Commissioner’s notice constitutes a continuing cause of action; the threat of dispossession itself is a trigger that empowers filing before the Tribunal before possession is complete. The respondent bank relies on Varimadugu Obi Reddy and argues Ext.P2 is an appealable order under Section 18, with limitation starting on 29-07-2022. The Court, however, allows the petition, holding that a cause of action accrues on each day after the notice and that the remedy under Section 17 is available prior to actual possession, citing Sami K., Roshan Narayanan CS, and related authorities. The petition is allowed, Ext.P2 is quashed, and the Tribunal is directed to number and decide the securitisation application in accordance with law, with a stay until 10-01-2023 to enable interim relief proceedings. The judge emphasizes liberal interpretation of SARFAESI remedies and notes that this is not a writ petition under Article 226 but a challenge under Article 227.
State Bank of India, the petitioner, seeks to quash Ext.P9 and compel registration of the Sale Certificate in favour of the auction purchaser, and to cause attachments placed on the mortgaged property to be effaced following the creation of mortgage. The Bank extended a package of facilities to M/s A.R. Enterprises, secured by an equitable mortgage of 29.96 acres in Elamba Village, with title deeds deposited. On borrower default, the accounts were classified as NPAs and proceedings under the SARFAESI Act, 2002 were initiated, leading to possession, and an auction sale on 17.03.2023, with the Sale Certificate issued on 08.05.2023. The Encumbrance Certificate recorded attachments by civil courts (OS 264/2022 and OS 55/2023). The 1st respondent Sub Registrar refused registration pending lifting of attachments. The petitioner contends that post‑mortgage attachments have no legal efficacy against the mortgage or SARFAESI sale and must be effaced, citing Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar and Keecheri Bank v. Sajitha Nizar. The respondents argued that civil attachments render conveyances invalid and that a writ petition is not the proper remedy; civil remedies should be pursued to vacate attachments. The High Court, relying on prior pronouncements, held that attachments after mortgage do not affect title or the sale and should be effaced, directing registration of the Sale Certificate within two weeks and the removal of attachments.
This High Court of Kerala, at Ernakulam, hears a bail petition under Section 439 CrPC filed by the fourth accused in Crime No. 467/2022 of Walayar Police Station, under NDPS Act offences. The prosecution alleges possession of MDMA, initially claimed to be with the first accused, and later a larger quantity recovered from accused Nos. 4 and 5. The petitioner contends innocence, arguing no recovery was effected from him on the date of occurrence and that he, a Nigerian national in India for studies, was nabbed on the basis of confessional statements made by co-accused. He has been in custody since 10.11.2022; his name does not appear in the FIR as having recovered contraband. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail on the ground that 166.5 grams of MDMA were recovered from the fourth and fifth accused during investigation, constituting a commercial quantity, which triggers the rider under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The court explains that when commercial quantity is involved, bail is permissible only if two conditions under Section 37(1)(a) are satisfied: (i) there are reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty, and (ii) he will not commit any offence while on bail. It then discusses Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and several subsequent pronouncements to interpret this standard. After applying the settled law, the court concludes that the two ingredients are not satisfied and dismisses the bail petition. The order ends with the bail application being dismissed."
This writ appeal challenges a judgment of the Kerala High Court dismissing WP(C) 34537/2019. The appellants are four doctors (Mathew Jacob, Sangeeth P.S., Shejoy P. Joshua, and T.R. John) who received show-cause notices under the Travancore-Cochin Council of Modern Medicine regulations alleging professional misconduct in the context of organ transplantation surgeries at Aster Medcity, Kochi. Respondents include the State of Kerala, the Travancore-Cochin Council of Modern Medicine (TCMCM), Dr. S. Ganapathy, and several other doctors named in the complaint. The core dispute is whether the notice and inquiry under the Indian Medical Council Regulations, 2002 (Ethics Regulations, 2002) can proceed alongside investigations under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 (THOT Act), a comprehensive, sector-specific statute. The learned Judge held that while the THOT Act governs organ transplantation, there is no legal bar to the TCMCM’s inquiry into alleged professional misconduct under the 2002 Regulations; the authorities may examine professional ethics allegations even when the THOT Act is in play. The appeal ultimately fails: the Division Bench upholds the impugned order and dismisses the writ petition, finding the notice to conduct an enquiry under the Ethics Regulations 2002 to be lawful. The decision emphasizes that general statutes yield to special statutes only in appropriate contexts and that disciplinary action under the Ethics Regulations remains a valid mechanism for addressing professional misconduct in medicine.
CRL.Appeal No.1452 of 2019 This is a criminal appeal under section 378(4) CrPC challenging the judgment in a Section 138 NI Act prosecution. The trial court had convicted the 1st respondent for issuing Ext. P1 cheque for Rs. 1,50,000 in discharge of a debt and sentenced a term of three months’ simple imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1,50,000. The appellate court reversed that conviction. The High Court of Kerala, in a single-judge sitting, reaffirms the trial court’s view that Ext. P1 was duly executed by the 1st respondent and that it was supported by consideration. It sets aside the appellate reversal and restores the conviction and the sentence, holding that the prosecution satisfied the statutory requirements under Section 138 NI Act and that the presumption under Section 139 NI Act is rebuttable and can be proved by the complainant’s evidence. The appellant contends that the evidence on passing of consideration was insufficient and that pleadings in the notice/complaint were defective; reliance is placed on Divakaran v. State of Kerala. The court discusses and overrules Divakaran through Basheer K. v. C.K. Usman Koya and relies on current NI Act jurisprudence, including Krishna Janardhan Bhat and ANSS Rajashekar, to sustain its finding that the prosecution adequately proved the debt and its relation to the cheque. The result is that the conviction stands restored and the appellate reversal is set aside.
This is an anticipatory bail application filed by the accused in Crime No.123/2023 of Kalady Police Station, Ernakulam, under IPC sections 376, 376(2)(f) and 376AB and under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) sections 4(2)(d)(b), 6, 5(i), 5(n) and 5(m). The mother of the victim, the defacto complainant, alleged sexual assault on her 3½-year-old daughter. The investigation included a clinical psychologist report suggesting possible tutoring by the mother; a Medical Board was constituted to evaluate the child, but the child was not produced as directed. Subsequently, the defacto complainant declined to produce the child for examination, prompting the court to direct expeditious interaction with a panel of child psychiatrists/psychologists. By mid-June 2023, the defacto complainant again refused production, and a Section 91 notice was issued to produce the smartphone video, which allegedly contained incriminating material. The court observed matrimonial tensions and non-cooperation, yet invoked the Prathvi Raj Chauhan v. Union of India principles to safeguard personal liberty where there is doubt about the veracity of the allegations. Ultimately, the court allowed the bail application, subject to stringent conditions including surrender for interrogation, bond, sureties, weekly appearances, no tampering with witnesses, and no leaving the country.
WP(C) Nos. 73 of 2020; 126 of 2020; 97 of 2020; 100 of 2020 This group of writ petitions is filed by M.A. Latheef, Secretary of Pallikkere Islamic Education Society, challenging orders under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 that awarded gratuity to teachers of the Society’s school. The Controlling Authority held the teachers to be employees and the Society as the employer, directing payment of gratuity based on last drawn wages and periods of service. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeals on the ground that they were filed beyond the statutory period under Section 7(7). The petitions trace a previously unsettled path: in a 2019 common judgment (WP(C) No. 2198/2019 and connected cases) the High Court had set aside an order and issued directions to dispose of the appeals within time. Here, the Controlling Authority and Appellate Authority’s orders were reviewed; the petitioner argued lack of opportunity to present evidence, dispute over whether teachers fall within the Act’s definition of “employee,” and the sufficiency of material to prove 240 days of service. The respondents argued that teachers are employees under the Act and that the school is an employer, relying on liberal construction of social welfare legislation. The Court ultimately affirmed the impugned orders, noting the liberal interpretive approach due for social welfare statutes, and dismissed the writ petitions with no costs.
This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 read with 401 CrPC challenging the order of a Judicial Magistrate, Perinthalmanna, that diverted seized funds to the Income Tax Department. On 30.03.2022, an amount of Rs. 1,03,00,000 was seized from the petitioners’ car. Unable to account for the funds, the magistrate directed the money to be released to the Department after the petitioners furnished security, while the petitioners sought interim release under Section 457 CrPC (CMP 1107/2022). The Department filed CMP 1948/2022 claiming the amount should be released to the Department for assessment under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (Section 132A). The Sessions Court and this Court’s Annexures were cited, including Annexure II (CRL.M.C. 8195/2017), which guided earlier directions to release funds if the Department failed to conclude assessment within six months. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners relied on Ravirajan R. v. State of Kerala (2023) to argue that the Department cannot stake a claim under Section 132A while the money is in court custody, and that Section 451 CrPC cannot compel a time-bound assessment. This Court, while agreeing with Ravirajan, sets aside the impugned order and allows the revision, subject to security provisions. The petitioners are to be released Rs.1,03,00,000 on a bond to repay/redeposit and with a bank guarantee, and the 3rd respondent is directed to finalize assessment in accordance with law, disposing of the revision petition accordingly.
Mezhuveli Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. (the appellant) challenges a Kerala High Court writ petition judgment (WPC 11479/2005) that upheld the dismissal of an employee, K. Harichandran, under the Industrial Disputes Act. The Labour Court had, as a preliminary issue, held the disciplinary inquiry valid and discarded challenge to the inquiry proceedings, with evidence not led on the quantitative aspect of punishment (dismissal). The writ appeal contends that a critical flaw was the non-supply of the Enquiry Officer’s report to the delinquent employee, and that the approach grounded in ECIL, Hyderabad v. B Karunakar was misapplied. The appellant relies on the ECIL decision to require furnishing the report and providing an opportunity to show prejudice before any interference with the punishment, and argues that the Labour Court did not adequately assess whether the non-supply prejudiced the petitioner or the quantum of punishment. The High Court, however, notes that the reasoning in the original judgment was incorrect and that the Karunakar principle is not attracted to this case. Consequently, the judgment under appeal is set aside, and the matter is remitted to the disciplinary authority to issue a show cause, furnish the enquiry report, consider replies, and proceed with action within three months, continuing from the stage at which the judgment interdicts the proceedings. The writ appeal is allowed.
WP(C) No. 3549/2023 & connected cases (11526/2023, 15258/2023, 20721/2023) This common judgment consolidates four writ petitions challenging environmental clearances, quarrying permissions and related orders in the Thekkumala/ Maneed area of Ernakulam/Thrissur districts, Kerala, tied to a National Highway (NH) project. The petitions allege that the District Geologist and other authorities granted a quarrying permit (Ext.P2) for extraction of ordinary earth to private entities, without Environmental Clearance (EC) under the EIA Notification, 2006, and/or contrary to SOPs introduced by MOEF&CC in Ext.P2 (OM dated 08.12.2022). The petitioners invoke the 2020 SRO amendment (Ext.P1) and subsequent clarification (Ext.P2), as well as GO(P) No. 14/2022 authorizing district geologists to issue permits subject to SOP. They also contend water scarcity and potential pollution of Ayyancode Pond, and implicate Panchayat tariffs and traffic restrictions. The respondents, including SEIAA, the Panchayats, the District Geologist, and contractors, defend the permits as valid exemptions from EC for linear projects and emphasize the SOP’s procedural safeguards. The Court holds that EC is not required for the quarrying activity under the SOP, dismisses certain petitions for lack of merit, and grants police protection to a petitioner in a separate case for mining in accordance with the mining plan, reflecting a nuanced balance between development and environmental safeguards.
Jinil George, the petitioner-father, filed O.P.(FC) No.81 of 2023 challenging the Family Court’s order dated 15.11.2022 in O.P.168 of 2022, which in turn had regard to the compromise decree Ext.P1 of a multi-petition custody matter (O.P.No.763/2017, etc.). The child Leona Jinil @ Anvy Rose, born 10.08.2017, has been living with the maternal grandparents since the respondent mother went abroad, and the father sought interim custody via I.A.5/2022 while asserting the mother’s absence and possession of the child by her parents. Ext.P1 had settled custody terms granting permanent custody to the mother and arranging limited visitation for the father on specific Saturdays; the Family Court ordered both parties to comply with those terms. The petitioner contends such arrangement fails the child’s welfare as there is emotional distance and inability to foster a bond if interaction remains restricted to brief, scheduled visits. The respondent argues there is no basis to modify the extant custody decree and defends the current arrangement, including the name change of the child. The High Court engaged in counselling, reviewed welfare considerations, and relied on Supreme Court precedents to emphasize welfare as paramount, ultimately granting the father temporary custody on a tightened schedule, reversing portions of Ext.P1 as to custody.