The petitioner, Subi G.S., a bidder, challenged the award process for making Appam Prasadam at Sabarimala Devaswom for the Mandala-Makaravilakku season 1199 ME (2023-24). He filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a mandamus to direct the 2nd respondent Devaswom Commissioner to award the contract to him on the basis of the e-tender notification dated 22.06.2023 (Ext.P1) and the general and special conditions, as he was the successful bidder in the bid conducted on 25.07.2023, and to consider Ext.P3 representation dated 04.09.2023 with notice. During proceedings, the Court was informed that tenders for Unniyappam prepared in gas, steam, and electric kaara involved two bidders each, with credential verification pending before the Chief Vigilance and Security Officer (SP). The petition and related tenders were examined, and the Court directed disclosure of tender copies. The Board relied on Ext.P1’s conditions, the pending verification reports, and the need to follow due process. Citing a prior Suo Motu decision, the Court underscored the obligation of the Board to act with reasonable diligence and to ensure availability of Appam Prasadam during peak season. Ultimately, the Court disposed of the petition with a direction to decide the tender award expeditiously, within two weeks, in accordance with law and Ext.P1’s terms.
This MACA arises from an award by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kollam, dated 16.12.2021 in O.P(M.V) No.245/2018, concerning the death of Rajendran Pillai in a motor vehicle accident. The insurer, National Insurance Co. Ltd., challenges the Tribunal’s computation of compensation. The petitioners (legal representatives of the deceased) contend that the Tribunal correctly calculated dependency, added 15% for future prospects and included damages for transport, clothing, nourishment, funeral expenses, and loss of estate, while awarding pain and suffering. The insurer argues for several reductions: it contends the Tribunal did not deduct income tax in calculating dependency, used an incorrect multiplier (11) for pre-retirement loss of income, and failed to consider post-retirement implications; it also asserts that pain and suffering should not be awarded, citing Satinder Kaur, and relies on the scene mahazar as not establishing contributory negligence, arguing for a more cautious approach. The petitioners counter that the Tribunal’s multiplier and multiplicand were proper, statutory deductions were appropriately applied, and the 15% future-prospects addition aligned with Pranay Sethi. The High Court reviews jurisprudence, including Bhagyalakshmi (not preferred in light of Satinder Kaur), Pazhaniammal (scene-mahazar admissibility), Puttamma (discouraging split multipliers), and Satinder Kaur, to uphold a revised quantum. Ultimately, the Court partly allows the MACA, revising the sum to Rs 40,05,128 with 8% interest, directing deposit within two months.
This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, before the Kerala High Court by the tenant, B.K. Abdul Muneer, challenging an eviction order. The Rent Control Court (Principal Munsiff, Kasargod) had allowed eviction under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3), holding that the landlady’s need to occupy the petition schedule building was bona fide and that the tenant was not protected by the second proviso to Section 11(3). The Appellate Authority (Rent Control) also confirmed eviction on 22.02.2023. The case concerns eviction sought for the landlady’s grandson, who intended to start a real estate business in the scheduled building. The tenant contested the finding of bona fide need, while the landlady supported it with PW1’s testimony and Exts. A1–A4; the tenant adduced Exts. B1–B2. The High Court, after surveying the statutory scheme and precedents, concluded that the Rent Control Courts’ conclusion on bona fide need was not perverse, and that the authorities properly applied the provisos to Section 11(3). While upholding eviction, the Court granted four months’ time to vacate subject to conditions: affidavit, arrears payment, continued rent, and no third-party occupancy. The judgment emphasizes that revisional power tests legality, not a fresh reappraisal of evidence, and preserves the balance between landlord’s needs and tenant’s rights.
This is a Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No. 5300/2023) filed before the Kerala High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash proceedings in CC No. 493/2020, Judicial First Class Magistrate’s Court-I, Thamarassery, arising from Crime No. 1057/2019 of Thamarassery Police Station. The defacto complainant purchased a lorry (KL-73-A-5253) with a bank loan from HDB Finance and leased it to the second accused, with the understanding that the loan would be cleared and the vehicle would be returned. Allegedly, the second accused (the petitioner) and his brother (the first accused) dishonestly transferred the vehicle into their names by forging signatures and misusing original documents after claiming loan clearance. The police filed a final report under Sections 406, 420, 465, 468 and 471 read with Section 34 IPC. The petitioner contends the private complaint lacked a supporting affidavit initially, implying illegality in invoking 156(3) Cr.P.C._the Magistrate later verified the affidavit existed and referred the complaint accordingly. The petitioner further argued that the accused resided abroad since 2016, that cognizance was improperly taken without sanction under Section 188 Cr.P.C, and that the alibi and mens rea allegations require trial. The respondents counters that the affidavit was eventually filed and the inquiry under 156(3) was properly conducted. The High Court clarified that disputed facts are not suitable for resolution at the 482 stage, that alibi is a matter for trial, and that sanction issues are moot given the Indian locus of the alleged offences. The petition was dismissed; observations are limited to this petition and do not decide merits.
This High Court of Kerala, while sitting in a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. 7453 of 2023), deals with the challenge to an order of the Sessions Court, Palakkad, dismissing an application filed under Section 457 Cr.P.C to release a vehicle seized in connection with Crime No. 47/2021 of the Excise Enforcement and Anti-Narcotic Special Squad. The petitioner, Prasad K.R., owner of the bus KL-40/H-0452 and with a financing relationship to Cholamandalam Finance (as per the record), contends that the petitioner is not the accused in the contraband case and that the vehicle was hypothecated and later settled; he argues that Shanil v. State of Kerala (2023 (2) KHC 88) supports releasing the vehicle on appropriate conditions. The court below refused release, holding that the vehicle was used as conveyance for contraband. The High Court, after considering the submissions and noting that confiscation is not yet initiated, agrees with the Sessions Court’s reliance on Shanil but, invoking Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai v. State of Gujarat (AIR 2003 SC 638), directs valuation of the vehicle and, if the petitioner furnishes a bank guarantee for the value with stringent conditions, release of the vehicle with safeguards; it further allows repossession if there is a repeat offence and clarifies bank-guarantee invocation if confiscation occurs. The petition is thus disposed with a structured plan for conditional release pending trial and related proceedings.
Crl.A.No.1513 & 1514 of 2007 These are two criminal appeals by the accused, Jorson George and Manojkumar, challenging convictions under section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc), Palakkad, in SC No. 637 of 2005. The prosecution case arises from 20.03.2004, when police intercepted a Maruti Esteem with two occupants and seized 16 cans of spirit (35 liters each). The prosecution relied on documents such as seizure mahazar, forwarding note, and arrest memo, and the accused were tried under Cr.P.C. 313. The trial court convicted both appellants, sentencing them to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 with a nine-month default. On admission of the appeals, counsel for the appellants argued that the prosecution failed to prove the tamper-proof condition of the seized liquor due to lack of impression of specimen seals on Ext.P1 seizure mahazar and Ext.P8 forwarding note, and pointed out discrepancies in the arrest process, including a crime number appearing in the arrest memo before the FIR. The court observed absence of seal in the seizure documents and forwarding note, relied on earlier precedents such as Moothedath Sivadasan and Another v. State of Kerala and Vijay Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh, and ultimately allowed the appeals, acquitting the accused of all charges.
Thea Lifestyle Pvt. Ltd., owner of 133.3 acres in Re.Sy.Nos. 106/15, 110/1, 110/11-1, 110/11-2, 110/12-1 and 110/12-2 in Marathakkara Village, Thrissur, challenges the Tahsildar (LR) Thrissur Taluk’s inaction in considering Ext.P11, Form A, under Section 6A of the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961, seeking to revise entries in the Basic Tax Register following enabling orders under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967 (KLU). The land had been shown as nilam in the BTR and was removed from the Data Bank under Exts.P8 and P9 (both dated 16-11-2012). The petitioner contends that once a KLU order permits conversion, earlier BTR entries become superfluous and a fresh assessment must be made under Section 6A, with updated entries in the BTR. The petition relies on Mary Abraham v. State of Kerala and others (2020 (4) KLT 448) and District Collector, Ernakulam v. Fr. Jose Uppani and others (2020 (4) KLT 612) to support re‑assessment post-KLU. Tahsildar Thodupuzha Taluk v. Renjith George (2020 (1) KHC) and Prakash.R v. State of Kerala (2022 (4) KHC 504) are cited regarding the non-applicability of Section 27A where a pre-2008 KLU order exists. The court allows the petition and directs the 1st respondent to consider Ext.P11 in Form A in accordance with law, within two months of receipt of the judgment.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition filed by Vibin Meleppuram challenging a conviction for an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act). The petitioner was convicted by the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Chalakudy, in ST No. 4042/2016 for issuing a cheque for Rs. 24 lakhs, later dismissed on appeal by the Sessions Court, Thrissur. The revision contends that Ext. P1 (the cheque) was not duly proved to have been executed by the petitioner and that Ext. X1 (bank intimation of dishonour) and Ext. P6 (an agreement) cast serious doubts over the validity and consideration. The petitioner argues that the trial court did not allow handwriting comparison when sought, and that signatures on Ext. P6 are missing on two pages, undermining the chain of execution and consideration. The respondents contend that PW1 testified the cheque was brought filled and signed by the petitioner, and that the presumption under Section 139 NI Act applies, shifting the burden to the petitioner to rebut it with evidence. The court reiterates the law on presumptions, the limited scope of revisional review, and the binding authority of the concurrent findings, ultimately upholding the conviction and dismissing the revision petition.
CRL.M.C. No. 6490 of 2022 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by Suraj, the accused in CC No. 38/2021 before the Juvenile Justice Board, Ernakulam, arising from Crime No. 1589/2021. The offences charged are under Section 379 and Section 201 IPC (theft and related acts). The petitioner seeks quashing of the prosecution on the ground that the dispute has been settled and the parties no longer wish to pursue the matter. The victim has filed an affidavit in support of settlement, and the victim’s counsel states no objection to quashing; the Public Prosecutor, while expressing reservations about quashing merely on the basis of settlement, concedes that the matter has been settled. The court examines the issue in light of landmark authority, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688) and the earlier Gian Singh and Narinder Singh decisions, which permit quashing non‑compoundable offences under Sec.482 CrPC where the dispute is private, the entire matter is resolved, and public interest is not affected, with certain exceptions for heinous or societal-impact offences. The court also considers antecedents and conduct of the accused. On these grounds, the court holds the dispute private, accepts the settlement, and quashes the proceedings. The Criminal Misc. Case is allowed; CC 38/2021’s proceedings are quashed.
W.A. Nos. 219 and 233 of 2022 These writ appeals challenge the Kerala Government’s 2021-22 prospectus for admission to medical post-graduate courses, focusing on clauses 6.6.11 and 6.6.12 that allocate seats among three service quotas (MESQ, HSQ, IMSQ) and confer weightage for service in rural or difficult rural areas. The appellants, in-service medical officers, argue that Regulation 9(IV) of the Medical Council of India Post-Graduate Medical Education Regulations, 2000 and its proviso grant a right to weightage up to 10% per year (maximum 30%) for service in remote/difficult areas, and that the 2021-22 prospectus and government orders fail to implement this, violating the parent regulations and judgments such as Sudheer N. v. State of Kerala. They rely on older orders (Exts. P4-P7) to press a claim for incentives. The respondents (State and its officers) contend that the State has authority under Entry 25, List III of the Constitution to create service quotas and incentives, and that Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association v. Union of India (2021) 6 SCC 568 supports state policy to address public interest. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petitions, holding Regulation 9(IV) is only an enabling provision, not a substantive right. The Division Bench affirms, holding that the prospectus provisions are legal and not arbitrary, thereby dismissing the appeals. The outcome upholds state policy to split seats and grant incentives as framed for 2021-22.
This Kerala High Court criminal appeal arises from SC 409/2005 of the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-I), Thodupuzha, in which Thankappan and Reji were convicted under Section 307 IPC for stabbing PW1 during a dispute on 10 November 2000. The case originated from Peermade Police Station Crime No.330 of 2000, initially under sections 324, 341, and 34 IPC; during trial the charge was amended to include Section 307 IPC, which the trial court held was triable by the Sessions Court. The prosecution’s case rests on the testimony of PW1 (the injured), PW2 (PW1’s brother), and corroborating medical evidence (Ext.P5 wound certificate, PW6). The appellants argued that there was no premeditation or intent to kill, the injury was not serious, there was only a single stab, and the act occurred in heat of passion; they also highlighted a settlement seeking compounding under Section 320 Cr.P.C. The Public Prosecutor contended that PW1 and PW2’s testimonies, along with medical evidence, establish a premeditated act capable of causing death. The High Court rejected the heat-of-passion argument, finding the weapon (knife) and chest injury indicative of intent. However, taking due regard to the parties’ settlement, the court allowed the appeal in part, maintaining the conviction but reducing the sentence to two years’ RI with fines, and providing for set-off for time already spent in custody.
Cont.Case (C) No.1931 of 2023 This Contempt of Court case arises from OP No.465/2015 (Family Court, Irinjalakuda) and OP No.535/2015, where mediation resolved the husband’s divorce suit and the wife’s maintenance claim. Ajayaghosh, the petitioner-husband, contends that the mediation settlement, accepted by the Family Court on 12.06.2019, has been violated by his wife Beena and their son Akshay Ghosh, warranting contempt under Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act. The mediation settlement envisaged a re-union and peaceable co-existence, including: the wife would have a right of residence in the house during her lifetime and the husband would not evict her; the wife would meet the petitioner’s treatment expenses, with a mechanism to mortgage property to raise funds if needed; both parties would live without harassment; and a default clause enabling action if terms were not honored. The proceedings also referenced the Lok Adalath award and related police complaints. On merits, the court explored authorities including Rama Narang v. Ramesh Narang and Kakkoor Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Jinu Augustine, to outline that a consent decree is a court-approved contract (imprimatur) and may be enforceable in contempt when violated. Ultimately, the court found no willful breach or ongoing executory duty, noting reconciled parties and insufficient basis for contempt, and closed the Contempt Case.
V. Sreedharan, the petitioner, owns 0.2023 hectares of land in Thathamangalam, Palakkad district. The land traces through prior orders: Ext P2 (1984) under the Kerala Land Utilisation (KLU) order permitted conversion of a portion for non-agricultural use, and Ext P4 (2006) allowed further conversion for a proposed commercial project, though financial constraints prevented realization. The petitioner sought deletion of the land from the Chittur-Thathamangalam Municipality data bank via Form-5, arguing that the land’s status had transformed to dry land before the 12.08.2008 effective date of the Act and that its inclusion in the data bank is a mistake. He contends that no site inspection or KSRSEC report was obtained before Ext P5, and that the decision relied solely on an Agricultural Officer report. The petitioner invokes established parameters from Joy v. RDO and Arthasasthra Ventures to assert that the land’s nature as of the 2008 Act’s commencement and its suitability for paddy must guide the Form-5 decision, including the need for site inspection and relevant reports. The respondents counter that Ext P5 reflects procedure under the data bank regime. The High Court holds that Ext P5 violated required procedures, sets it aside, and directs the first respondent to reconsider the Form-5 application strictly in light of Joy’s case and Arthasasthra’s case, after site inspection if needed and KSRSEC input, considering Exts P2 and P4, within two months, at petitioner’s cost.
This High Court of Kerala is seized with an order passed by the Forest Tribunal, Palakkad, in OA 1045/1974 and subsequent amendments under O.P.(F.T.) No.3 of 2021 challenging those orders. The respondent Velandy filed OA 1045/1974; the petitioners, State of Kerala and the Custodian of Vested Forests, seek to amend the cadastral description of the scheduled property in the OA and the Tribunal’s order. The sequence shows the Tribunal initially disallowed an amendment in 2017 (Ext.P8), but later (Ext.P13, 22.2.2019) allowed an amendment to replace the original survey number 231/1 with 246/1, 246/7 and 247/1, relying on a commission report Ext.P6. The department opposed this on several grounds, including that the new survey numbers place the property far from the original site, and that the amendment would effectively substitute one property for another, especially after a 36-year delay. The court emphasizes the central CPC principle: amendments under Order VI Rule 17 may be allowed at any stage, but where a decree has become final, amendments must be bonafide, non-prejudicial, and not affect accrued rights (as clarified in Peethani Suryanarayana). It finds the amendment improper here due to misdescription, lack of satisfactory explanation for the vast survey-number changes, and absence of revenue involvement and proper verification. Consequently, the appeal succeeds; Ext.P13 is set aside and costs allocated between the parties. The bench comprises Justice K. Vinod Chandran and Justice C. Jayachandran (Division Bench).
This is a Kerala High Court revision petition under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1964, challenging an order of the Family Court, Kannur, under Section 125 CrPC (CrPC, 1973). The respondents, including Rincy Robert (wife) and her two children Manisha Manoharan and Abhishek Manoharan (minors), had sought maintenance from the revision petitioner, who admitted paternity but contested quantum and liability. The Family Court, after considering facts, materials, and medical evidence (the third respondent’s epilepsy), directed the revision petitioner to pay monthly maintenance to the two minors: Rs. 3,000 for the second respondent and Rs. 4,000 for the third, while denying maintenance to the first respondent (the wife). The petitioner contended that his income and obligations (approx. Rs. 5,000 monthly from auto-rickshaw business and additional agricultural income) did not justify such maintenance; he also argued Section 127 CrPC to cancel liability for the second respondent after majority. The court, noting the petitioner’s earnings and the third respondent’s medical needs, held him liable for maintenance, and ultimately dismissed the revision petition on merits, while acknowledging that any liability toward the second respondent could be ended if Section 127 relief had already been granted. The judgment emphasizes a statutory duty to maintain wife and child and the presumption of ongoing obligation where minimum support is required for the maintenance of minors and a sick child.
CRP Nos. 315 of 2021; 335 of 2021 This is a Kerala High Court decision in Civil Revision Petitions CRP Nos.315 and 335 of 2021 arising from an order of the Additional District Judge—VI, Ernakulam in O.P.(Electricity) No.356 of 2013. The petitioner in CRP315, Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd., challenged the compensation awarded for damage caused by the drawing of 400 kV transmission lines across the claimant’s property in Manjapra Village, Ernakulam. The claimant alleged that trees were cut and, more crucially, that diminution in land value due to the high-tension corridor was not adequately compensated. The court below had granted Rs.1,83,178/-, for trees, but did not compensate for land value diminution, and it fixed land value by deducting 10% from Ext.A13 and awarded 20% of land value for the outer corridor. The revision petitions were heard on 15.01.2024 and finally on 05.04.2024, with the Court observing that the claim for enhanced compensation for trees was rightly rejected for lack of evidence, while it considered diminution in land value guided by the principles in KSEB v. Livisha. The court in part allowed the claimant’s revision, deleting a deduction that required subtracting prior compensation from enhanced compensation, and directing payment within three months. The Corporation’s revision was dismissed.
This writ petition (WP(C) No. 25270/2019) challenges a Kerala Lok Ayukta order dated 10 January 2019 in Complaint No. 958/13-D directing the competent authority to re-survey and re-number a residential property of the late complainant, and to effect mutation in the joint names of her legal heirs, among other directions, including action against a Tahsildar for alleged malpractices. The petitioners contend that the Lok Ayukta Act, 1999 confers no jurisdiction to entertain the complaint (Exhibit-P2) and that the Lok Ayukta exceeded its powers by treating title to immovable property and taxation as matters of maladministration within its remit. They also argue that the complaint is time-barred under Section 8(2)(c) and that remedies exist under the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961 and the Kerala Survey and Boundaries Act, 1961 for rectification of resurvey records. During proceedings, respondents refuted the allegations. The court, in a Division Bench led by Chief Justice S. Manikumar and Justice Murali Purushothaman, allowed the petition, holding that the Lok Ayukta had no jurisdiction to adjudicate such civil-title disputes, and quashed the Exhibit-P1 order. The judgment directs pursuing available statutory remedies rather than Lok Ayukta intervention.
This is a Kerala High Court revision petition under RPFC 271 of 2022 challenging a Family Court order in MC 257/2018 (Family Court, Ernakulam) directing maintenance to be paid by the husband to the wife under Section 3 of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986. The parties married on 29.08.2004 in Lakshadweep; two children were born. The wife reportedly fled the matrimonial home due to alleged cruelty; the husband denies. The Family Court held that a 2018 registered agreement (Annexure A1) and related cross-examinations were procured under coercion and contrary to public policy, and consequently held that the wife had relinquished maintenance rights and consented to divorce (Khula). The revision petitioner argues that by giving up her maintenance claim and agreeing to Khula, the Family Court erred in directing maintenance; he contends Islamic law allows release from the matrimonial tie and that Rajnesh v. Neha (2021) guidelines were not properly applied. He also asserts the respondent did not actually seek compensation. The respondent contends she was forced to flee due to sustained cruelty and that the agreement was not free of coercion; maintenance is a statutory right under Section 125 Cr.P.C. and cannot be waived. The High Court ultimately upholds that waivers against public policy cannot defeat statutory rights, and dismisses the revision petition, thereby sustaining the Family Court’s maintenance order of Rs.10,000 per month.
The petitioner, Ansar K.B., is the proprietor of a rubber-sheet business and seeks police protection to carry on his establishment’s activities without interference from the third respondent. The dispute centers on whether loading and unloading constitute headload work under the Kerala Headload Workers Act, 1978, and whether the petitioner’s establishment falls within a scheme-covered area requiring registration under Rule 26A and engagement of pool workers. The petitioner contends that the activity of loading and unloading is incidental to the main business of storage, grading, cleaning, packing, and sale of rubber sheets; the predominant work is performed by the petitioner’s own workers, and there are only four workers with low volume of business. He relies on Theresa Jose v. Sub Inspector of Police, Thoppumpady and Ors. (2015) 1 KLT 485, which laid down a three-pronged test to determine headload status under item No.5 of the Schedule. The respondents contend that the area is a scheme-covered area and that loading/unloading is essential to the business, obliging registration and use of pool workers. The Larger Bench decisions in Theresa Jose and the Full Bench in Raghavan’s case are cited to argue that whether headload work is predominant depends on facts. The court ultimately disposes the petition by directing statutory resolution under Section 21 of the Act, while keeping the interim protection in force until final determination, without commenting on merits.
Three accused, Shobha, Valsala, and Devi, were convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track (Adhoc I), Kozhikode, under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of 172 bottles of Indian Made Foreign Liquor found in three big shopper bags aboard a bus during a routine check on 10 July 2003. The bus operated on the Parassinikadavu–Kozhikode route, with the bags placed in front of the seats behind the driver where the accused sat. The contraband was seized and samples were taken with seals, and the case was tried in S.C. No. 643 of 2005. After trial, the appellants were sentenced to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 each, with default imprisonment. The appeal was admitted on 16.02.2022 and heard on 03.03.2022. The appellants contended that guilt could not be established beyond reasonable doubt, emphasizing ambiguity about conscious possession, lack of documentary evidence linking them to Mahe, and questions regarding whether the samples were forwarded in tamper-proof condition due to missing details of the Excise Guard on forwarding notes. The State argued that PW.1 and PW.2, supported by Exts. P1–P3 and P6, established guilt. The High Court ultimately allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction, and acquitted the appellants, noting deficiencies in the chain of custody and forwarding procedure, and canceling their bail bonds. The judgment reinforces the necessity of a cogent chain of custody beyond reasonable doubt in excise cases.