This writ petition challenges the Thrissur Municipal Corporation’s rejection of the petitioner’s application for a completion certificate and occupancy certificate on the ground that the transfer of property with a building permit was not intimated to the local authority. The petitioner purchased 3.24 acres in Nettissery Village; prior to sale, a building permit was issued (05.04.2018) and extended to 31.10.2026. At the time of sale (21.07.2022), there was no structure on the property, and only the permit existed. The sale was not intimated to the Secretary, as required by Rule 19 of the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019 (KMBR). The Respondents contended that Rule 19 obliges both transferor and transferee to inform the Secretary and obtain permission to continue construction, and that the permit cannot be issued if the transfer is not intimated. The petitioner argued that Rule 19(1)-(2) are directory, and non-intimation is a curable irregularity, not a nullification of a valid permit, especially since construction had begun under the existing permit. The court concludes that Rule 19(5) targets division of the plot; non-intimation in non-dividing cases is a curable irregularity. Citing Kailash v. Nanhku to support directory nature, the court allows the petition and directs the Secretary to process name transfer and occupancy/completion certificates within 30 days.”
The petitioner, SHAMNASKSHAJI, challenges an order dated 08.06.2023 passed by the Sessions Court canceling bail granted in Crime No.24/2022 (NDPS) on the ground that the petitioner allegedly violated a bail condition by becoming involved in Crime No.23/2023 (NDPS). The bail was granted by this Court on 13.10.2022 subject to conditions, including a ban on the petitioner’s involvement in any other crime while on bail. The State contends that the subsequent offence and possession of 720 mg of MDMA while on bail constitute misuse of liberty and justify cancellation under established legal principles. The petitioner contends innocence regarding the subsequent crime and argues that mere registration of a new crime cannot automatically cancel bail, citing Godson v. State of Kerala and Renjith v. State of Kerala as authorities that stress caution against automatic cancellation. The court clarifies the legal distinction between setting aside an unjust or perverse order and cancelling bail on account of misconduct or supervening facts, citing Gurcharan Singh, Puran, Abdul Basit alias Raju, Ranjit Singh, Dolat Ram, CBI v. Subramani Gopalakrishnan, and Deepak Yadav, among others. Ultimately, it holds that the petitioner misused liberty by engaging in a similar offence and that cancellation was justified, though it notes that surrender for regular bail remains possible in appropriate proceedings. The petition is dismissed; however, the petitioner may pursue fresh bail in accordance with NDPS Act principles.
Crl. Appeal No. 1149/2018 This is a criminal appeal filed under section 374(2) Cr.P.C. by Devarajan challenging the conviction for rape under section 376(2)(j) IPC and the sentence of life imprisonment with fines imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Thiruvananthapuram. The incident is alleged to have occurred on 10 November 2015 in a shed attached to the house of the victim’s sister, where the victim, a 78-year-old deaf and mentally ill woman belonging to a Scheduled Caste, was allegedly raped. The trial court found that the victim was not capable of giving reliable testimony due to mental illness but held that PWs 1 and 2 (neighbors and the victim’s sister) testified to the commission of the offence and thus convicted the accused under 376(2)(j). The court acquitted him of the offence under section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989. The appellant challenged alleged non-compliance with Sections 154 and 164 Cr.P.C. and the lack of cross-examination of the victim, contending that there were inconsistencies in the witnesses’ accounts and no supporting medical or scientific evidence. The Kerala High Court, considering the testimony of PW1 and PW2 credible and supported by medical opinions indicating mental illness, upheld the conviction and dismissed the appeal, affirming the sentence and order of fine.
Criminal Appeal No.1309 of 2018 This is a Kerala High Court judgment in Criminal Appeal No. 1309 of 2018 challenging a conviction for murder recorded in SC No. 122 of 2015 by the Additional Sessions Court, Muvattupuzha. The sole accused, Vasu, faced charges arising from an incident on 10 February 2013 at his house, where the victim Mathews sustained injuries during a confrontation allegedly over money lent. The police registered offences under Sections 341, 323 and 325 of the IPC; after the victim died, Section 302 IPC was added. The trial proceeded with the prosecution examining 33 witnesses and producing 29 documents; the accused denied the charges and opted for no evidence in his defence. The defence argued that the case rests on circumstantial evidence and demanded a complete chain of circumstances beyond reasonable doubt, asserting that the facts do not establish guilt or murder. The State contended that the circumstances irrefutably point to the accused’s guilt, including that the injuries were caused by stamping and kicking and are sufficient to cause death. The High Court, after evaluating the evidence, held the death as homicide but concluded that the prosecution failed to establish motive and that the circumstances do not conclusively prove the accused’s intended killing beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the Court altered the conviction to Part I of Section 304 IPC (culpable homicide not amounting to murder) and reduced the sentence to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment, allowing the appeal in part.
BAIL APPL. NO. 9386 OF 2023 This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by four accused in Crime No. 8/2023 of Mupliyam Forest Station, Thrissur, alleging offences under sections 27(1)(e)(iii)(iv) and 47A–47D, G, H of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961. The prosecution alleges trespass into the Kodassery notified Reserve Forest and illegal felling and removal of sandalwood trees, with the 4th accused allegedly transporting the sandalwood and supplying it to petitioners 6–9. The case primarily leans on the confession of the 4th accused linking the petitioners to the crime. Counsel for petitioners argues the confession statements are inadmissible, citing Luca Beltrami and Others v. State of Kerala and subsequent Kerala High Court decisions (Prakashan v. State of Kerala; Gopi v. State of Kerala) and Article 20(3) of the Constitution, Section 72 of the Kerala Forest Act, and Section 25(3) of the Indian Evidence Act. They contend the petitioners have no criminal antecedents and are ready to cooperate, seeking pre-arrest bail. The Special Public Prosecutor counters with reliance on precedents that confessions recorded by forest officers can be admissible, evidenced by other materials and the necessity of custodial interrogation. The Court ultimately allows the bail application, subject to stringent conditions, after finding exceptional grounds under Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre and balancing public interest and the petitioners’ rights.
CRL.M.C. No. 4124 of 2023 This is a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court to quash a bail-cancellation order in Crime No. 96/2022. The petitioner Shaji alias Thokkushaji was charged with offences under IPC sections 294(b), 195A, 307 and 506(ii). He was granted regular bail by the Sessions Court with a specific condition: he shall not enter the limits of Neyyar Dam police station, where the de facto complainant resides, for six months. While on bail, a subsequent crime, No. 306/2022, registered at Neyyar Dam police station under IPC sections 341, 323, 324, 308, was allegedly committed by him, leading the Investigating Officer to seek cancellation of bail. The Sessions Court cancelled the bail, observing misuse of liberty and re-entrustment of the applicant into a volatile situation; sureties were directed to respond. The petitioner contends the second crime was committed to comply with bail conditions, alleging mala fide registration and false allegations, citing Godson v. State of Kerala and Renjith v. State of Kerala to argue that bail should not be cancelled for mere violation. The State counters with the habitual-offender backdrop, reliance on Supreme Court guidance in P. v. Madhya Pradesh, Edwin Thomas and other cases, and the fact that the de facto complainant was attacked while on bail. The High Court distinguishes between cancelling a bail and setting aside an unjustified order, endorsing the reasoning that misuse of liberty constitutes a valid ground for cancellation. It dismisses the petition, while noting surrender for fresh bail could be considered under NDPS Act principles.
This judgment from the Kerala High Court concerns two connected writ petitions by tenants Akhilesh M. and Vavakumar M. against possession notices issued under SARFAESI by the South Indian Bank and its Regional Officers, following proceedings instituted after orders of the Chief Judicial Magistrate Kozhikode under Section 14. The tenants allege eviction threats and contend that eviction from tenanted rooms should proceed only under Rent Control Act, as they have continuously paid rent and invested in their business in the premises leased by Sri K.P. Shafeeq. They rely on precedents such as Harshad Govardhan Sondagar, Bajarang Shyamsunder Agarwal, Mohan Sundaram and Roshan Narayanan C.S. to argue that possession cannot be taken while the lessee has lawful possession and that the Bank cannot bypass tenancy rights via Section 14. The Standing Counsel for the Bank counters that SARFAESI provides an efficacious remedy under Section 17(4) and that writ petitions are not maintainable against private banks; he cites Hemraj Ratnakar Salian on Rent Act limitations, and the court’s earlier decisions such as Shiju Mani. Ultimately, the court dismisses the writ petitions, directing the tenants to approach the Debts Recovery Tribunal and allowing exclusion of time for limitation if they do so.
This is a Kerala High Court revision petition under Sec.125 CrPC challenging a Family Court order (M.C No.127/2016) directing the revision petitioner to pay maintenance to his divorced wife at Rs.5,000 per month from 17.6.2016. The respondent-wife had approached the Family Court asserting she had no means to sustain herself, even though the revision petitioner allegedly earned about Rs.1,00,000 per month while abroad. The Family Court fixed Rs.5,000 per month after evaluating the evidence, including the divorce Ext. D1 decree dated 2.5.2013, which established the petitioner’s divorce from the respondent. The petitioner contended the respondent had deserted him, misappropriated earnings, and that he was unable to work due to age-related illness and remarried after the divorce, making maintenance unreasonable. The High Court discussed that an application under Sec.125 is a remedy in social justice for dependants, and it treated the proceedings with careful scrutiny, noting that the notional income and quantum assessments can be guided by settled jurisprudence. The court relied on several precedents to justify the maintenance order’s retention while addressing abatement concerns and ultimately dismissed the revision petition on merits, upholding the Family Court’s order.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges an eviction order (Ext.P3) issued by the Maintenance Tribunal under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007. The 1st respondent, Mary, a senior citizen, owned a two-acre property and alleged that after the death of her elder brother Mani and Mani’s wife, she was forcefully evicted from her home. The petitioners, Molly (wife) and Thomas (husband), argued that the Tribunal's order to vacate the building was beyond its statutory competence, since the Act primarily enables maintenance relief rather than eviction. Counsel for the petitioners relied on C.K. Vasu v. Circle Inspector of Police and Others (Kerala) and Leelamma Eapen v. District Magistrate, Kottayam, among others, to argue that Ext.P3 exceeded jurisdiction. The respondents contended that the Maintenance Act grants District Magistrate powers to ensure a senior citizen’s security and dignity, and that eviction matters may be addressed by the DM-rule under Rule 9 and related provisions, with possible delegation to the Tribunal as per Thoppil Anto v. Glancin T A and Others. The Judge held that the Act does not empower eviction by the Tribunal; Ext.P3 is quashed. The Court noted, however, that a senior citizen’s rights may be safeguarded byDM action under Rule 19, to be expeditiously considered within six weeks, keeping alive the respondent’s life and property protections.
The petitioner challenged an auction sale conducted under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968 in respect of a 33-cent plot in Melukavu Village, Meenachil Taluk, Kottayam District. Distress warrants issued by the Erattupetta Magistrate for maintenance default led to the sale, completed on 28.04.2004, with the 4th respondent as the successful bidder. The petitioner alleges the auction occurred without active bidding, and subsequently filed W.P.(C) No.29959 of 2004 challenging the sale. The writ petition was admitted, and the court ordered that confirmation of sale would be subject to the writ petition’s fate. The petition was ultimately dismissed for default in 2006, and the petitioner later deposited the dues with the Family Court, Ettumanoor; he also obtained a family court order closing CMPs, yet extant notices and sale confirmations persisted. The 2nd respondent informed that the property had been sold and mutation recorded in the 4th respondent’s favor. The petitioner then challenged Exts. P6 and P7 in the present writ petition. The court found suppression of material facts, including non-disclosure of a 2007 civil suit, and held that timely action under Sections 52 and 53 of the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act was not taken. Distinguishing Chandrasekharan, the court concluded no interference with the sale and dismissed the petition.
Rakesh Kumar, the sole accused in Crime No.1280/2018 of Kottarakkara Police Station, Kollam, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC while his trial in SC No.1259/2018 remains partially concluded and proceedings were halted for further investigation following Annexure A2. The prosecution alleges that on 27 May 2018, the father of the deceased was murdered in his shop, with a gold chain and ring stolen and Rs.7,500 recovered; the prosecution contends the accused throttled the victim during the attempted robbery. Arrested on 28 May 2018, the case was committed to the Sessions Court, which concluded the trial up to the final stage, including the recording of the accused’s statement under Sec.313 CrPC. When the case was listed for final hearing, the 3rd respondent sought to stop the proceedings on grounds of further investigation in light of an FSL report linking nail clippings/hair to the petitioner. The Sessions Court allowed further investigation and halted the proceedings. The bail petition was rejected by the trial court on grounds that the accused is a wanderer with no fixed address and that the investigation would prolong. The High Court held that prolonged detention in the face of pending investigation and the accused’s roots in Kollam warrant careful consideration of bail. It ultimately allowed bail with stringent conditions to safeguard the ongoing inquiry, emphasizing the constitutional guarantee of speedy justice and the right to life under Article 21.
WP(C) Nos. 25233/2022, 32096/2022, 32568/2023 These connected writ petitions challenge four Government Orders issued by the Kerala Government that provided price-difference benefits for bitumen used in road construction. The petitioners, contractors associated with the Public Works Department, contend that the orders dated 13.11.2018, 17.04.2020, 25.09.2020 and 30.04.2021 created a right to payment of the price difference between the bitumen price at tender closing and invoice, and that similarly situated contractors were granted such benefits while they were denied. The Government later issued clarifications and amendments (Exts. P2–P4) adjusting the calculation and eligibility, and a 26.08.2022 order (Ext. P11) purportedly withdrew the benefit prospectively for future tenders. The Court examines the nexus between ongoing works as on 01.11.2018 and the eligibility criteria, noting that Exts. P1–P4 confined benefits to those whose works were ongoing on that date and whose tenders closed before it, despite later amendments. It relies on decisions in M/s Malabar Tech v. State of Kerala and Mohammed Ahnas.B v. State of Kerala to underscore that the relief cannot extend to contracts entered after the cut-off date. Ultimately, the Court dismisses the petitions, holding that the statutory framework and the 01.11.2018 cutoff remain controlling, and the officers’ recommendations or attempts to broaden eligibility do not create new rights.
This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit for fixation of boundary and a permanent prohibitory injunction in respect of plaint A schedule property of 4.5 cents, adjoining a 0.5-cent western strip claimed to be a private road (plaint B schedule). The plaintiffs purchased the property from the defendant (Ext.A1, Ext.A4) subject to a restriction that a 0.5-cent strip would remain for ingress and egress and vest as a jenm right in the defendant. The defendant allegedly advised conveyance of the path and used the western boundary to establish a wider pathway, and in 2012 he removed boundary stones and erected an iron gate encroaching upon plaint A schedule and annexing it to the B schedule path. Plaintiffs moved authorities and then filed suit. The trial court and the first appellate court fixed the western boundary as the NI line in Ext.C2(a) and granted permanent injunction, which the appellant challenged. The High Court reaffirmed that the boundary was correctly fixed along NI, found no substantial question of law, and dismissed the appeal. It rejected the theory of acquiescence or pre-existing path and held that the encroached area was not in settled possession. The result is that the appeal is dismissed, maintaining the NI boundary and injunction.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC arises from CC No.2496/2021 pending in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Chengannur, involving five accused charged under Sections 341, 323, 324 read with Section 34 IPC. The petition seeks to quash the criminal proceedings on the ground that the parties have settled their dispute and the victim has supported quashing by affidavit. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged that the matter is settled. The court, after considering submissions, the victim’s affidavit, and controlling precedents, proceeds to analyze the scope of its power under Section 482 CrPC as laid down by the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan (State of MP) and related judgments (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh). The Laxmi Narayan decision emphasizes that quashing is permissible for non-compoundable offences with predominantly civil or private character when parties settle, excluding heinous offences or matters of public interest; it also contemplates examination of the nature of injury, evidence, and antecedents. The present case is found to be private in nature, and the settlement is deemed acceptable. Accordingly, the court allows the Criminal Miscellaneous Case and quashes all proceedings in CC No.2496/2021, effectively terminating the prosecution in the given Crime No.2299/2019, Chengannur Police Station. The order reflects a cautious application of settled law to private disputes while preserving public interest in serious offences.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam). The petitioners, Purushothaman and T.U. Biju, challenge the final report filed in Crime No. 59/2020 of the Ernakulam Excise Range, alleging offences under Sections 57(aa) and 56(b) of the Kerala Abkari Act. The prosecution contends that samples of toddy collected on 27.11.2019 from Toddy Shop No. 38/2019-2020 contained starch, violating the licence conditions. The petitioners claim they are innocent and contend that Section 57(aa), introduced in 2018 by the Abkari Amendment, is a specific provision for adding starch to toddy, while Section 56(b) is a general provision penalizing misconduct by licensees. They argue that charging both provisions together is violative of settled law, citing Ani & Another v. State of Kerala & Another (2021) 6 KHC 176, and seek to excise the 56(b) charges from the final report and/or allow compounding under Section 67A for both offences. The respondent State contends that both offences can be charged and that the final report should reflect the applicable provisions. After hearing, the Court, relying on Ani and the statutory framework, holds that the continuation of Section 56(b) in the final report alongside Section 57(aa) is not permissible, and the petition is allowed in part. The final report is quashed to the extent it charges 56(b); proceedings under 57(aa) may continue.
CRL.M.C NO. 5539 OF 2021; CRL.M.C NO. 5530 OF 2021 These are consolidated Criminal Miscellaneous Cases filed in the Kerala High Court challenging Annexure-A1 complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, filed before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Palakkad. The petitioners, Sahfeer N.M. (CRL.M.C.5539/2021) and Shafeern.M. (CRL.M.C.5530/2021), contend that the cheques were issued under coercive circumstances—allegedly obtained from the petitioner at his work site after abduction and assault—and that there was no legally enforceable debt, as supported by Annexure-A5 FIR (Crime No.423/2019). They argue that the cognizance taken by the Magistrate is unfounded and that the prosecution is built on a false premise, seeking to quash the complaints under inherent powers of the High Court (Section 482 CrPC). The respondents counter that mere registration of a crime and filing of a complaint do not justify quashing and that the trial court must determine the existence of a debt and liability with evidence. The court cites established principles on the exercise of inherent power (Golconda Linga Swamy; Rathish Babu Unnikrishnan; RP Kapur) to emphasize restraint and the duty to let the trial unfold the facts. Ultimately, the petitions are dismissed, holding that the trial court shall evaluate the evidence; no premature enquiry into the merits shall be undertaken at the quash stage. The order directs proceeding in the trial court without hindrance from the observations.
This writ petition (criminal) is filed by six accused in Crime No.930/2020 of Kalpetta Police Station seeking post hoc reinvestigation by a specialized agency and removal from the list of accused. The petition contends that they have been prosecuted despite their innocence and prays for further investigation to be directed by a higher-ranking agency to achieve justice. The 3rd respondent had earlier indicated that further investigation was not necessary, leading the petitioners to approach this Court. Before addressing the merits, the Court considered whether an accused may seek a direction for further investigation; it relied on the Supreme Court’s guidance in Arnab Ranjan Goswami v. Union of India and Others, affirming that an individual under investigation does not have a free choice in the mode or agency conducting the inquiry and that extraordinary powers to transfer to the CBI are to be exercised sparingly. The judgment then surveys a line of precedents—Narmada Bai; Sanjiv Rajendra Bhatt; Divine Retreat Centre; Romila Thapar—holding that an accused has no unconditional right to dictate the investigation, and that High Courts should exercise caution in directing alterations of the investigative process. Ultimately, the Court held that there is no legal basis to interfere with the ongoing investigation and dismissed the petition, though it granted liberty to the petitioners to raise their contentions at trial.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC arises from CC 1060/2021 (Judicial Magistrate of First Class-II, Hosdurg), where 12 petitioners-accused were charged under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324 r/w 149. The prosecution alleges unlawful assembly and assault on the de facto complainant on 04.07.2021. The petition seeks quashing on the basis of an amicable settlement between the parties, evidenced by Annexure A2 affidavit and supported by the victim’s statement recorded by the investigating officer. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing non-compoundable offences but acknowledged absence of other impediments and lack of prior criminal antecedents. The Court undertook a detailed survey of the principles governing Section 482 CrPC quashing, citing State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, and the line of decisions including Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and others, emphasising that quashing is permissible in civil/private matters with settlements, unless the offence is heinous or under special statutes. The Judge concluded that the settlement would not adversely affect society, and continuing the prosecution would be a waste of time given the bleak prospects of conviction. Consequently, the petition is allowed and Annexure-A1 Final Report and further proceedings in CC 1060/2021 are quashed.
Aggrieved by a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act, the appellant Mohanan challenged the judgment of the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc), Fast Track Court-I, Thrissur, which convicted him for possession of illicit liquor (8 bottles of 750 ml) on 19 June 2006 and sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment along with a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The Kerala High Court, on admission of CRL.A No.869 of 2008, examined the trial record, including PWs 1–5, Exts P1–P6 and MOs 1–9, and DWs 1–3 with Exts D1–D11. The appellant contended that the arrest was doubtful and that the prosecution failed to demonstrate that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory; more critically, arrest memo and arrest intimation were not produced. Relying on a string of Supreme Court and Kerala High Court authorities, the court noted that the arrest memo is mandatory (D.K. Basu) and that non-compliance with arrest formalities undermines the entire prosecution case (Ramankutty; Sasidharan; Daulat Ram lineage). The court also highlighted the necessity of endorsing the tamper-proof chain of custody and showing linkage between seizure, the sample, and laboratory analysis (Ramachandran; Rajamma; Vijay Pandey; Daulat Ram). Because the prosecution failed to establish the arrest, seizure, and sample linkage, the apex argument failed, leading to acquittal. The High Court ultimately acquitted the appellant and directed return of any deposited amount.
Criminal Appeal No.412 of 2008 Chandrika d/o Devayani, the appellant, challenged the conviction under Section 8(2) Abkari Act by the Adhoc-I Sessions Court Kollam for possession of 3 litres illicit arrack seized at Vallikkavu, Kulashekarapuam village on 9 July 2000. The trial court sentenced her to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The Kerala High Court, in a detailed re-appraisal, found material gaps in the prosecution's case: lack of proven identity of the person who carried the contraband at the scene; unexplained delay in producing the seized property; the propriety and legality of the sample drawn by a Court officer rather than by the investigating/excising officials; and questions about whether the seized contraband was ultimately examined by the chemical examiner. The prosecution relied on PW1 (Excise Circle Inspector) and other witnesses, but the delay in production and the absence of a prior test identification parade weakened credibility. The court reiterated well-established principles from Kanan and other authorities: identification in court without a prior identification parade is unreliable; the Magistrate cannot draw samples; the sampling process, as conducted by the court's property staff, lacks legal sanction. Consequently, the High Court concluded that the evidence failed to connect the accused to the contraband or to the chemical analysis, and held the appellant not guilty. The appeal was allowed, acquitting Chandrika and setting her at liberty.