Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 690 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2447 OF 2024

null

This is a Kerala High Court bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 2447 OF 2024) by the fourth accused in Crime No. 129/2024 of Wadakkanchery Police Station, Thrissur. The accused, aged 18, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in a case alleging offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 326 and 307 read with Section 34 IPC arising from an incident on 20 February 2024 in which the defacto complainant and two friends were injured. The prosecution asserts that all four accused formed an unlawful assembly and, with common intention, assaulted the victims; the 1st accused is alleged to have inflicted grievous injuries by stabbing, while the petitioner is said to have been present and aided, though no direct overt act by him is charged. The petitioner has been in custody since 03 March 2024. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing ongoing investigation; however the court notes that the 1st accused caused the major injuries and that the petitioner’s involvement is limited. Relying on Supreme Court precedents on bail and fundamental rights, the court emphasizes presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, detention is an exception. After evaluating the evidence, the court concludes there is no material linking the petitioner to the 326/307 offences, and grants bail on a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties and standard conditions, including appearance, non-interference, no new offences, passport surrender, and potential cancellation on breach. The order also cites Sushila Aggarwal for bail procedure.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 11043 OF 2023

Shajil v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Kazhakkottom Police Station

This is a pre-arrest bail application (Section 438 CrPC) filed by the sole accused, Shajil, in crime No.1689/2023 registered at Kazhakkuttom Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The accused is alleged to have assaulted the defacto complainant in an autorickshaw after a dispute over unpaid fare, causing grievous injuries including a fracture to the ulna; the offences initially cited include 294(b), 324, 341, 506 and 308 IPC, with Section 326 IPC subsequently added. The petitioner contends innocence and false implication, arguing the defacto complainant has criminal antecedents and that the accused is the family’s sole breadwinner with two minor children; he is ready to comply with any conditions and cooperate with the investigation. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, stating that custodial interrogation is necessary due to ongoing investigation and recovery. The court relies on Supreme Court authority including Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra, Sibbia (Constitution Bench) and Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar to frame the discretionary parameters for anticipatory bail, emphasizing no rigid guidelines and the need to weigh gravity, antecedents, likelihood of fleeing, witness tampering, and genuineness of prosecution. Ultimately, the court dismisses the bail petition, while granting a conditional pathway: if the petitioner surrenders within 10 days, he may be interrogated and later moved for bail in the jurisdictional court on merits; non-surrender permits arrest.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.11016 OF 2023

Junaid and Subair v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Chalissery Police Station

This High Court of Kerala bail petition concerns accused Junaid and Subair in Crime No. 882/2023 of Chalissery Police Station, Palakkad, challenging denial of bail under Section 439 CrPC. The FIR alleges that on 19 October 2023, the petitioners, along with others, in pursuance of common intention, armed with swords and wooden sticks, restrained a bus, damaged it, hurled abusive words, and assaulted the first informant, resulting in injuries. The petition is opposed by the State on grounds of serious offences including sections 341, 323, 324, 326, 352, 294(b), 506(ii), 427, 212 and 307 read with section 34 IPC, and on account of alleged criminal antecedents. The investigating agency contends that the petitioners have severe criminal backgrounds (first petitioner in five crimes; second in three) and that proceedings under the KAAPA Act are pending. Final report was laid on 08 January 2024 and recovery has been effected; KAAPA action is proposed. The Public Prosecutor argues that bail could lead to witness intimidation and tampering with evidence. The petitioners claim innocence, false implication, and urge that investigation is complete; they seek bail to prepare their defense. The court relies on Supreme Court bail principles and holds that due to antecedents and risk of interfering with witnesses, the bail application is meritless and must be dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.2482 of 2024

Selvan v. State of Kerala

Selvan, aged 46, the first accused in Crime No. 460/2022 of Vithura Police Station, seeks bail in the Kerala High Court under Sec.439 CrPC against the order in Bail Application No.384/2024. The offences charged include sections 294(b), 323, 324, 326, 452, 506(ii), and 307 r/w 34 IPC, arising from an incident on 16 May 2022 when, it is alleged, the accused trespassed into the defacto complainant’s residence, forced him to consume alcohol, uttered obscene words, and assaulted him with an iron rod while his co-accused allegedly manhandled him. The petitioner has remained in judicial custody since 18 May 2022; the prosecution states the investigation is practically complete and a final report has been laid. The defense submits total innocence, alleging false implication and alleging prior animosity with the investigating officer; they argue there are no supervening circumstances justifying further detention. The Public Prosecutor counters by highlighting the petitioner’s history-sheet comprising eight prior offences, a prior bail in Crime No. 945/2020 that was cancelled for post-bail conduct, and the likelihood of repetition if released. The court recalls well‑established bail criteria from Prasanta Kumar Sarkar and Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, and notes post‑bail conduct should be a ground to cancel bail per P. V. State of Madhya Pradesh. On evaluating gravity, antecedents, and conduct, the court concludes that bail would undermine public interest and accordingly dismisses the application.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2500 OF 2024

Satheesan v. State of Kerala

Satheesan, the sixth accused in Crime No.240/2024 of Hill Palace Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala. The FIR, dated 11 February 2024, alleges unauthorised storage of explosives at the Puthiyakavu Temple by the temple committee and its office bearers and others, for the purpose of conducting fireworks. The original offences cited in the FIR are Section 286 IPC (negligent conduct with explosive substances), Section 118(f) of the Kerala Police Act (unauthorised transport of explosive articles), and Section 9(B)(1)(b) of the Explosives Act. The matter was later connected to another episode in which an explosion occurred on 12 February 2024, resulting in Crime No.242/2024 against 34 accused and the addition of non-bailable offences under Section 308 IPC and Section 3(a) of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908. The petitioner submitted that the added offences cannot be attracted to the present crime and that the petitioner's role is limited to the unauthorised storage; he contends that the original offences are bail-able and there is no direct involvement in the explosion. The State opposed bail, emphasizing the gravity of the explosion, multiple accused, and ongoing investigation. After hearing, the learned Judge held that the primary accusations relate to unauthorised storage, which are bailable, while the later additions are non-bailable. Weighing the stage of investigation and the personal circumstances of the petitioner, the court allowed the bail application on conditions including a Rs 1 lakh bond, two solvent sureties, and periodic appearances, with further guidance on modification of conditions if warranted by law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.11125 of 2024

Sunilkumar K.P. and Asha Nair v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Fort Kochi; Village Officer, Karukutty; Agricultural Officer, Krishi Bhavan, Karukutty; Director, Kerala State Remote Sensing and Environment Centre (KSREC)

This writ petition challenges Exts.P3 and P3(a) by which Form 5 applications filed to remove certain lands from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 were rejected by the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO). The petitioners own 0.76 acres (Sy.Nos. 914/6A, 915/1E) and 3.95 acres (Sy.Nos. 914/6A, 915/1E) in Karukutty Village, Ernakulam District. They contend the properties do not fall within paddy land or wetland as defined by the Act, and were wrongly included in the Data Bank; hence Form 5 should be allowed to remove them. The RDO relied on a report from the Agricultural Officer and the LLMC’s recommendation not to remove, without independent assessment of the status of the land as on the date of the Act’s coming into force. The petition cites several precedents: Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, which require the RDO to independently evaluate the land’s status, and to consider whether removal would adversely affect paddy cultivation or wetlands. The court ultimately sets aside Exts.P3 and P3(a), directing the RDO to reconsider Form 5 applications in light of law, obtain a KSRSEC report, and issue a fresh decision within two months, with the petitioners bearing the cost of the KSRSEC report.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 10456 of 2024

Dr. Nizar Mohammed N.M. v. District Collector, Kozhikode; Revenue Divisional Officer, Eranhipalam; Agricultural Officer, Olavanna Krishi Bhavan; Village Officer, Pantheerankavu

Dr. Nizar Mohammed N.M. filed this writ petition challenging Ext. P3, an order rejecting his Form 5 application to delete his land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The petitioner submits that his property at Pantheerankavu, Kozhikode, is located in a densely urban area, surrounded by public institutions, and is not suitable for paddy cultivation; he applied to delete the land from the Data Bank. Ext. P3 relied on a Village Officer’s report and stated the land was not converted before 2008, and the 2nd respondent did not call for satellite data from KSREC. The petitioner contends Ext. P3 is not a speaking order and that KSREC data was not considered, which undermines the basis of the decision. The court notes Ext. P3 is not a speaking order and that the petitioner’s contentions were not adverted to by the 2nd respondent. Citing relevant precedents, the court emphasizes that the Revenue Divisional Officer must independently assess the land’s status and determine whether removal from the Data Bank would adversely affect paddy cultivation or wetlands. The predominant factor, as held in Aparna Sasi Menon, is whether the land is suitable for paddy cultivation. The order is set aside, and the 2nd respondent is directed to reconsider the Form 5 application within three months, with the option to obtain KSREC data, and the petitioner may obtain a copy of the judgment for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.10707 OF 2023

CRL.M.C No. 10707 of 2023

This criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. challenges the FIR No.1222/2022 of Manimala Police Station and the proceedings in SC No. 837/2022 before the Fast Track Special Court, Changanassery. The sole accused seeks to quash the FIR and the trial, arguing that a settlement has been reached with the respondents 2 and 3—the victim and defacto complainant—and that the petitioner subsequently married the second respondent on 26 December 2023, creating a peaceful married life. The prosecution alleges offences under IPC Sections 363, 450 and 376(2)(n), and corresponding provisions of the POCSO Act, arising from a sexual relationship with a minor under promise of marriage. The lower court proceedings and the POCSO allegations are contested as to whether a quashing is warranted in light of the settlement and the victim’s present consent. The court noted that although the 2nd respondent was a minor at the time, the couple's current marriage and the victim's consent render continued prosecution inconsistent with justice. Relying on Vishnu v. State of Kerala, the judge considered the peculiar facts and allowed the petition, quashing the FIR and the criminal proceedings. The order emphasizes the “ends of justice” and the settlement's beneficial effect on the victim and the family life. The result is a quashing of all pending proceedings in this case.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10851 OF 2024

NIRAM ARTS AND SPORTS CLUB v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Thalassery, Kannur District; Agricultural Officer, Krishi Bhavan, Panniayannur, Kannur District; Village Officer, Panniyannur, Kannur District; State of Kerala

The petition challenges Ext.P8, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting the petitioner’s Form 5 application for removal of land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 (Act, 2008) and its Rules. The petitioner owns 4.05 acres in Sy. No.55/1B, Panniyannur, Kannur District, characterized as garden land—not paddy or wetland—yet it was included in the Data Bank. The RDO relied on a report from the Agricultural Officer and the Local Level Monitoring Committee’s (LLMC) recommendation not to remove the land, and noted a District Collector action under Section 13 of the Act. The petitioner contends that the land’s status as of 12.08.2008, the Act’s date of coming into force, should be ascertained, ideally with KSRSEC input and satellite data, and that Section 13 proceedings do not automatically bar Form 5 consideration. The petition relies on several precedents, arguing that the RDO must independently assess whether removal would harm paddy cultivation or wetlands, and that mere pendency or conclusion of Section 13 proceedings cannot defeat Form 5. The High Court holds that Ext.P8 is unsustainable for reliance on a single report and directs the RDO to reconsider Ext.P3 with KSRSEC input, at the petitioner’s expense, within two months, after the petitioner secures KSRSEC reporting.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.11108/2023

ABOOBACKER SIDEEQUE v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by the sixth accused in Crime No.493/2023 of Manjeswar Police Station, Kasaragod. The applicant ABOOBACKER SIDEEQUE seeks pre-arrest bail in a case involving nineteen co-accused charged with offences under IPC sections 341, 324, 364, 302, 201, 212 and 120B read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution contends a conspiracy to murder the deceased linked to a financial dispute and asserts a tangible overt act, necessitating custodial interrogation, with investigation still in nascent stages. The petitioner argues his innocence, lack of criminal antecedents, willingness to cooperate, and contends custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The State's counsel opposes bail, warning that release would impede investigation and risk public order given the gravity of the offences and alleged involvement of multiple accused. The court invokes principles from Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra and Sibbia to emphasize case-specific discretion and cautions against rigid guidelines, while reiterating Jai Prakash Singh that pre-arrest bail is an extraordinary remedy to be granted only in exceptional circumstances. After carefully weighing the materials and submissions, the judge concludes the petitioner is not entitled to pre-arrest bail. The application is dismissed, but a conditional pathway is laid: if the petitioner surrenders within 10 days, he shall be interrogated and may apply for bail on merits; non-surrender allows arrest as if no order was passed.

High Court of Kerala
Bail Application No.2252 of 2024

UNAIF v. STATE OF KERALA and THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, PANAMARAM POLICE STATION

Unaif, the second accused in Crime No.18/2024 of Panamaram Police Station, Wayanad, petitions this Court for pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. Eight persons are charged with offences under 341, 324, 326, 427 and 294(b) read with 34 of the IPC. The prosecution case is that on 8 January 2024 at about 21:30 hours, the accused, in furtherance of their common intention and from prior animosity toward the de facto complainant, wrongfully restrained him, pulled him from his car, and assaulted him with a helmet and a stone, causing a nasal bone fracture. The de facto complainant was abused in obscene language and his vehicle was damaged, causing about Rs. 5,000 in loss. The petitioner contends that the only overt act attributed to him is a hand strike and an attempted strangulation, and that the core assault was by Rasheed, now the first accused, with the third accused allegedly using a stone. He argues that the earlier pre-arrest bail order (Annexure A2) was based on a mistaken report of his rank and that there is no material to substantiate Sec. 326 against him. He asserts custodial interrogation is unnecessary and that exceptional circumstances exist to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of Sec. 438 CrPC. The State seeks to maintain the investigation with appropriate conditions. The Court, after considering the IO’s statements and submissions, notes that the evidence does not prima facie connect the petitioner with Sec. 326, though the issue will be decided at trial, and grants pre-arrest bail subject to standard conditions, including surrender and cooperation with the investigation.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.2368 of 2024

Anisha v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under section 438 CrPC filed by Anisha, the sole accused in Crime No.1455/2022 of Anthikad Police Station, Thrissur. The prosecution alleges that while employed with Muthoot Finance, she induced a depositor to redeposit Rs. 4,00,000 and fabricating a debenture certificate, resulting in offences under sections 406 and 420 IPC. The petitioner contends innocence, asserts she was a paid employee with no role in the alleged fraud, and argues custodial interrogation is unnecessary; she seeks pre-arrest bail on grounds of non-involvement and no recovery needed. The Public Prosecutor counters that the accused induced the investment, fabricating the debenture certificate and continuing interest payments, and that she has criminal antecedents including other cases, making custodial interrogation essential and bail would jeopardize the investigation. The court refers to a line of bail jurisprudence, notably that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary power to be exercised in exceptional circumstances in order to prevent harassment or interference with investigations. Upon evaluation, the judge finds no exceptional ground to grant anticipatory bail, particularly given antecedents and the need for recovery and investigation. The order dismisses the bail application but directs that if the petitioner surrenders within 10 days, she shall be interrogated and then produced for consideration of bail on merits; failure to surrender permits arrest as if no order existed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL.NO.2564 OF 2024

Dinesh Kumar K. @ Vinesh v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala, filed by the sole accused in Crime No.120/2024 of Alathur Police Station, Palakkad, seeking bail in offences punishable under IPC Sections 341, 324, 294(b) and 308. The incident, dated around 26 January 2024, involved the accused entering the home of his father-in-law (the de facto complainant) and assaulting him with a chopper, causing injuries to the rear of the head and right eye; when his mother-in-law attempted to intervene, she was abused and restrained, with a de facto risk to her life alleged. The prosecution relies on an Accident Register-cum-Wound Certificate and states investigation is complete with the final report laid. The petitioner contends innocence, argues that Section 308 is not attracted, asserts the injuries were not as grievous as alleged, and notes more than 60 days in custody with investigation complete and no prior antecedents. The respondent State contends grievous injuries and the seriousness of the act. The court relies on Supreme Court principles: presumption of innocence (Sanjay Chandra v. CBI), bail as a rule (Dataram Singh), protection of life under Article 21 (Raneef), and post-bail guidelines (Sushila Aggarwal). After balancing facts and law, the court allows bail subject to conditions, noting the accused’s lack of antecedents and completed investigation.

High Court of Kerala
WA 48/2020 (and connected cases)

Baiju A.A. v. State Tax Officer & Ors (consolidated WA Nos. 48/2020 and connected matters)

This judgment consolidates a batch of writ appeals challenging reassessment notices issued under the Kerala Values Added Tax Act (KVAT) after amendments effected by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018, in the wake of the constitutional shift to GST. The petitioners/ respondents challenged the competence of the assesses to reopen assessments for escaped turnover for years prior to and during the transition to GST, arguing that the 2017 amendment substituting five years with six years for Section 25(1) KVAT Act and the 2018 amendment extending further were either prospective or unconstitutional, especially in the context of the post-CAA 2016 landscape and the repeal of KVAT. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, held that: (i) the 2017 amendment is prospective in operation (not retrospective) and thus cannot reopen assessments where time-bar had expired before 31 March 2017 for years like 2010-11; (ii) the 2018 amendment to Section 25(1) lacks legislative competence in the changed constitutional framework post-CAA 2016 and repeal of KVAT, making it unconstitutional. The court followed Baiju A.A. and Najeem and refused to validate the 2018 amendment; it upheld the impugned decisions and dismissed the appeals. The overarching theme is the reconciliation of timing, legislative competence, and the transitional GST framework.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1419 of 2022

Writ Appeal No.1419 of 2022

This writ appeal arises from the Kerala High Court’s decision on a salary disbursement dispute under the Direct Payment Scheme for private colleges. The petitioner, Shalini Thomas, an Assistant Professor of Economics at BCM College, Kottayam, claimed salary and arrears after University approval of her appointment, despite the Deputy Director of Collegiate Education arguing there were only two sanctioned posts for Economics and that payment required Government concurrence. The case traces the post-de-linking workload reassessment (40 hours) and the accompanying norms: four teachers occupied two sanctioned posts, with one leaving and another retained as surplus for redeployment; no re-deployment occurred. Exts. P8-P9 show the workload and sanctioned post fixation, while Exts. P4-P11 reveal government and college-level contention about whether the post existed and whether sanction could be granted retroactively. The court recalls Cherian Mathew and Shalini Rachel to emphasize that salary payments from the Government, under the Direct Payment Scheme, depend on posts sanctioned by the Government and approved by the University. Dr. Sina A.R. is discussed and distinguished. The Division Bench ultimately holds that the petitioner’s appointment was against a non-existent post, denying Government salary obligation, though interim salary already disbursed will not be recovered; the college may adjust the appointment to future vacancies.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A Nos. 753 and 764 of 2008

State of Kerala v. Madhu A.P., Mahesh K.P. alias Muthu, and Praveen alias Kuttan; State of Kerala v. Aneesh K.

These appeals arise from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act in SC No.436/2006 (Valancheri Police Station crime 167/2005) by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court-III (Adhoc), Manjeri. On 13.06.2005, 15 litres of illicit arrack were seized from an auto-rickshaw on Chembra-Valanchery road; the accused were convicted and sentenced to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 each. The High Court examines whether the prosecution established a proper chain of custody from seizure to chemical analysis and whether the sample presented in court was the same sample tested in the laboratory. The appellants challenge the prosecution’s case on several grounds: (i) lack of proof that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory in tamper-proof condition; (ii) misdescription or absence of seal details in the seizure mahazar; (iii) failure to produce the specimen seal and to prove its genuineness; (iv) presence of the crime number in arrest memos, which casts doubt on the genesis of the case. Relying on earlier precedents (Baburaj, Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Rajamma, Bhaskaran, Santhosh, Karunakar Bindhani, Rafeeque) the court found that the prosecution failed to establish a direct link between the contraband, the sample, and its laboratory analysis. Consequently, the court acquitted the accused and allowed the appeals.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 732 OF 2008

Yasodha v. State of Kerala

The appellant Yasodha stood convicted in SC No.59 of 2003 (Additional District & Sessions Judge, Fast Track I, Thiruvananthapuram) for offences under Section 8(1) and (2) of the Abkari Act, based on possession of ten litres of arrack near Kadinamkulam Panchayat Office on 27-04-1999. The trial court sentenced her to one year of simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with default imprisonment for six months. On appeal, counsel for the appellant submitted that the sample was taken in Court and, per decisions of this Court, the procedure was not correct; Ext.P5 forwarding note lacked a seal and did not identify the person who sent the sample to the analyst. The Public Prosecutor argued that evidences on record justified conviction. The High Court examined the forwarding note (Ext.P5) and noted the absence of a seal, which the court deemed fatal to the prosecution because the chain of custody from seizure to analysis must be proved. Relying on Ravi v. State – S.I. of Police, Meppadi (2018(5) KHC 352), Smithesh v. State of Kerala (2019(2) KLT 974), and Kumaran v. State of Kerala (2016(4) KLT 718), the court held that the insufficient forwarding note and the lack of identification of the sample handler create reasonable doubt. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the conviction and sentence set aside, and the appellant was to be released. The bail bond, if any, was cancelled.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. No. 754 of 2008

Charlie Mayiladumpara Veedu v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A. No. 754 of 2008) arising from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc) Fast Track Court-II, Pathanamthitta, in SC No. 654/2006. The appellant was found in possession of 750 ml of arrack in a bottle at the residence area of Mathai Kannoli on 30 September 2004 and was convicted and sentenced to six months’ imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The appellate court scrutinises the prosecution’s chain of evidence, highlighting key deficiencies: (i) arrest and seizure details rely on Ext. P2 with a crime number, creating doubt about whether the FIR predated the recovery; (ii) there is no reliable evidence that the seized contraband underwent Chemical Analysis; (iii) the seizure mahazar (Ext. P1) lacks seal specification, and no witness testified about the seal or its specimen; (iv) Ext. P7 lacks the seal specimen, and Ext. P8 shows the sample reaching the laboratory, but the personnel who handled it were not examined; thus the chain of custody fails. Relying on Bhaskaran, Rajamma and other authorities, the court holds that the prosecution failed to establish the link between seizure and laboratory analysis. The court acquits the appellant, holding the conviction unsustainable and allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 2258/2015 & CO 65/2016

National Insurance Company Limited v. Ganesh (MACA 2258/2015 & CO 65/2016)

Ganesh, a construction worker, sustained serious injuries in a December 24, 2012 motor-vehicle accident involving a car, leading to hospitalization for 13 days. The Addl. Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, awarded Rs. 20,01,600 as compensation. The petitioner-insurer, National Insurance Company Limited, challenged the quantum as excessive and urged conformity with Supreme Court precedents. The insurer argued for higher notional income (Rs. 7,000/month) and for applying 40% future prospects (resulting in Rs. 9,800/month), and contended the Tribunal erred in applying a 100% functional disability to a person capable of some alternate employment. The claimant Ganesh countered that the award was inadequate, and filed a cross-objection. The High Court, while recognizing the need to adhere to current jurisprudence (Pranay Sethi, Raj Kumar, Pappu Deo Yadav, Syed Sadiq), re-fixated the income and recalculated disability using modern guidelines. The Court held that future prospects could be applied and concluded that functional disability should be treated as 85% in light of potential alternate employment, rather than 100%. It reassessed the permanent disability to Rs.14,99,400 and recalculated other heads, ultimately scaling down the total to Rs.19,17,500 and dismissing the cross-objection. The court also directed deposit of the balance with 9% interest within two months and clarified that future-treatment interest runs from the date of award.

High Court of Kerala
WA 1435 of 2023

Shibli K v. Union of India and Others

Shibli K, a 30-year-old visually challenged candidate with 100% disability, challenged the Kerala Public Service Commission’s handling of scribe facilities for the post of Assistant Professor in Business Administration. He argued that no extra time had been provided in the KPSC objective examination and that the scribe arranged from the Commission’s panel did not meet his communication needs. He also sought the right to bring his own scribe for competitive examinations, asserting that RPwD Act, 2016 and government circulars require reasonable accommodation and flexibility to meet individual needs (as in Vikash Kumar v UPSC). The Single Judge had allowed PwD candidates above 40% disability to meet the scribe from the Commission’s panel at least two days in advance and to obtain a replacement scribe if unsuitable. The appellant contended that this scheme did not fulfill the rights guaranteed by RPwD Act, and urged a broader policy allowing personal scribes. Respondents argued that own scribes may invite malpractice and that the KPSC panel scribes, governed by extant rules and memoranda (Exts. P4, P5, P6), adequately protect examination integrity and stakeholder interests. The court examined RPwD Act provisions and the Constitution, and ultimately held that scribes from the KPSC panel satisfy the Act’s objective, dismissing the appeal, thereby upholding the existing panel-scribe mechanism as a valid reasonable accommodation.