The present Arbitration Request (AR No.16 of 2021) before the Kerala High Court arises from a lease dispute between Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (tenant) and its landlord, N. Krishnan. The Annexure A lease deed contains an arbitration clause (Clause 3(e)) mandating sole arbitration by the Chairman and Managing Director/Director (M) of the Corporation or an officer nominated by them. The applicant-tenant filed the arbitration request after the parties failed to agree on the appointment of the arbitrator. The respondent-landlord filed a counter-affidavit and disputes the scope and appointment of an arbitrator. The court heard the matter and noted that, in light of amended Section 12(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the Chairman/Director cannot be appointed as arbitrator. The apex court decisions in TRF Limited v. Energo Engineering Projects Limited (2017) 8 SCC 377 and Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and Another v. HSCC (India) Limited (2020) 20 SCC 760 are cited to support this position, and the judge concludes that the person named in Clause 3(e) cannot be nominated as arbitrator. Consequently, the arbitration request is ordered: Retd. Justice M. Sasidharan Nambiar is provisionally nominated as the Sole Arbitrator, with directions for disclosure under Section 11(8) read with Section 12(1) and for filing and confirmation of appointment, including the arbitrator’s fees under the IV Schedule. The proceedings are to be conducted in Ernakulam, and rival contentions are left for adjudication before the arbitrator.
This is a criminal appeal under Section 378 CrPC challenging a conviction under Section 304 Part II read with Section 34 IPC in the bus accident at Neriyamangalam on 29 December 2002, which resulted in five deaths and injuries to 63 persons. Appellants Martin Jinu Sebastian (driver) and Anil Sebastian (bus owner) were convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge-II, Thodupuzha, for committing culpable homicide not amounting to murder under 304 Part II read with 34 IPC, and were sentenced to five years’ rigorous imprisonment with a set‑off for the first accused. The prosecution alleged that the driver, who had a deformity of the left wrist and lacked a valid driving licence, drove the bus at high speed, and that the owner entrusted the vehicle with knowledge of the driver’s disability, resulting in a fatal crash. The defence argued that the evidence did not prove any offence under 304 Part II and that the appropriate conviction/ sentence should be under 304A IPC. The State contended that both accused acted with knowledge that death was likely and with common intention. The High Court, in a detailed judgment, upheld the trial court’s finding, relying on jurisprudence including Alister Pareira, Prabhakaran, Rathnashalvan, Lodhi Colony and Kalabhai to distinguish 304 Part II from 304A and to sustain a conviction under 304 Part II r/w 34 IPC while keeping the punishment intact. The appeal was dismissed, and the sentence confirmed, with bail/suspension orders canceled.
A wedding eve turned deadly when the appellant allegedly assaulted the deceased with a wooden weapon during a party at PW8’s house on 28 January 2006, resulting in death four days later. The trial court convicted Devarajan under Section 302 IPC, imposing life imprisonment with a minimum term of 14 years, and ordered payment of Rs. 1,00,000 as compensation with a default simple imprisonment of five years if not paid. The prosecution examined 14 witnesses, with material reliance on three eye-witnesses (PW6, PW8, PW10) and documentary Exts. P1–P11; however, the defense argued grave credibility issues: delay in registering the FIR by a person not directly involved, hearsay statements, and contradictions among key witnesses. They contended that several witnesses were suspects during investigation and were not independently corroborated, and that hospital histories inconsistently described the incident as a fall from height, not a deliberate assault. The defense invoked Machindra V. Sajjan Galpha and Jarnail Singh to emphasize unreliability of witnesses under suspicion and to scrutinize direct testimony. The prosecution maintained direct evidence of the attack, a clear weapon, and adequate light at the scene. The High Court, after detailed analysis, found serious credibility gaps and irregular sentencing by the trial court, and allowed the appeal, acquitting the appellant, and directing immediate release; it also criticized the sentencing structure as irregular and inconsistent with law.
This batch of writ appeals, heard together on 22 August 2022, challenges presumptively the Kerala KVAT amendments (Finance Acts 2017 and 2018) that extended the period for reopening assessment under Section 25(1) of the KVAT Act and its third proviso. The petitions question whether these amendments could operate retrospectively, in light of the Constitutional changes ushered in by the 101st Constitution Amendment and the subsequent repeal of KVAT with the GST regime, as well as compatibility with Article 246A and the saved rights under the KGST Act. The Kerala High Court (S.V. Bhatti and Basant Balaji, JJ.) analyses the commencement vs operation of amendments, the substitution from five years to six years, and the scope of the saving clause. It reviews precedents such as Najeem, Baiju A.A., Jyoti Traders, Hajee Abdul Shakoor, Calcutta Discount Co., Mohit Minerals, and Reliance Industries on retrospective vs prospective operation and legislative competence post-CAA. Ultimately, the court holds that the amendments to Section 25(1) (both the five-to-six-year substitution and the third proviso) are prospective, and that the State Legislature lacked power to extend reassessment beyond the pre-CAA regime for certain periods. The batch appeals are dismissed, upholding the impugned judgment.
NEEV ENERGY LLP challenges the award of Kochi’s Pan City Smart LED Street Lighting project under the Smart Cities Mission. The petitioner contends that CSML disqualified its Technical Bid on the ground of non-submission of Audited Balance Sheets for five years, while the NIT’s Third Call allowed a Financial Statement in lieu of audited accounts when legally permissible. The Tender followed a two-cover system (Technical Bid first, then Financial Bid) and the petitioner argues that Project Consultant KIIFCON recommended their disqualification to favour the second respondent, Lighting Technologies India Private Limited, which was later awarded the contract (Ext.R2(1) and Ext.R2(2)). The petitioner attacks the reasons given for disqualification as untenable, and accuses the CSML of capriciousness, malafides, and breach of fairness by allowing post-qualification modification of bids and by negotiating the second bidder’s price to fit an estimated project figure (as per Ext.R1(b) and Ext.R1(d)). The CSML and the second respondent deny the petition, arguing that the petitioner was rightly rejected at the Technical Bid stage for non-conformities in samples and documents, that the NIT and two-cover procedure permit such action, and that judicial interference would disrupt a live procurement process. The Court ultimately emphasizes deference to procurement governance and, following established tender jurisprudence, dismisses the petition in the interest of public funds and timely project completion.
The appellant, T. Balan, challenged the judgment convicting him under Section 55(g) of the Abkari Act for possession of 18 litres of wash meant for manufacturing arrack. The conviction was based on a seizure on 20.04.2004 and a sample taken from the wash, with the bulk substance allegedly destroyed at the scene. The trial court framed the charge and convicted the accused, but the High Court evaluated key procedural safeguards, including Section 53A of the Abkari Act, which requires proper inventory and disposal of bulk quantities and creates a mechanism for primary evidence of seizure. The court noted the prosecution did not establish that the bulk quantity was produced or that the residue was destroyed following the prescribed process; there was no showing that the sample’s seal was described or that officials who handled the sample were examined to rule out tampering. Citing Bhaskaran, Balakrishna Rai, Appachan, and other authorities, the court held that lack of compliance with Section 53A and failure to prove a reliable chain of custody undermined the link between the seized contraband and the sample analysed, as well as the link to the accused. It also relied on Vijay Pandey and Sasidharan to emphasize narrative consistency between seized material and laboratory analysis. Consequently, the court acquitted the accused and allowed the appeal, holding the conviction unsustainable and the accused at liberty.
This original petition (Rent Control) was filed by the landlord, V.A. Abraham, seeking eviction of the respondent, Tom Philip, from a petition schedule building on grounds of arrears of rent and bona fide need under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The respondent denied the landlord-tenant relationship and claimed no lease existed. During proceedings, the Rent Control Court found the lease deed relied upon to be insufficiently stamped and issued Ext.P7 under Section 34(a) of the Kerala Stamp Act, directing deficit stamp duty (Rs.11,800) and a Rs.2,40,000 penalty, with the document admissible only upon payment. The petitioner sought withdrawal under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC with liberty to file a fresh suit; the Court allowed withdrawal but refused leave to institute a fresh suit. Aggrieved, the petitioner approached this Court under Article 227 challenging the order. The High Court clarifies that withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit is a permissible course under the cited rule and that the penal action under the Stamp Act would apply only if the document is admitted in evidence. Citing Harihara Iyer v. Varkey and Ramachandran K.P, the Court disposes of the petition by modifying Ext.P1 to permit withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit, and denying setting aside Ext.P7.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2259 OF 2024 This Kerala High Court bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 2259 of 2024) is filed under Section 438 CrPC by Anil Kumar K.G., the first accused in Crime No. 234/2024 of Kattappana Police Station, Idukki. The prosecution alleges that, in furtherance of common intention with other accused, he pledged gold ornaments with the Central Bank of India, Kattappana branch, while employed as an appraiser, and that the gold was spurious, leading to a loss of Rs. 2,29,50,000 for the bank. The charge sheet targets the applicant under Section 420 r/w 34 IPC. The petitioner contends innocence, claiming false implication and asserting that his role was limited to certifying the gold; the loan was sanctioned by superior authorities at their discretion; Annexure A1 FIR lacks precise particulars and obscures the allegations; custodial interrogation is unnecessary and no recovery is planned, entitling him to pre-arrest bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes the relief, noting that the investigation has been entrusted to the District Crime Branch, Idukki, and that there are incriminating materials showing the petitioner’s involvement; custodial interrogation is necessary to further the inquiry. The court cites Supreme Court precedents on anticipatory bail—Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre, Sibbia, Jai Prakash Singh, Srikant Upadhyay, and HDFC Bank—emphasizing that bail is an extraordinary remedy to be granted only in exceptional circumstances. After considering the stage of investigation and the gravity of the accusation, the court refuses to grant pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application.
TR.APPEAL(C) NO. 21 OF 2023; TR.APPEAL(C) NO. 22 OF 2023 These Transfer Appeals under Section 5 of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958 arise from a common order dated 16.11.2023 of the learned Single Judge in Transfer Petitions (C) Nos.551 and 552 of 2023, which sought to transfer two matrimonial original petitions (O.P. Nos.1009 of 2022 and 989 of 2022) pending in the Family Court, Kasaragod, to the Family Court, Pala. The appellant-husband contends that the forum should be shifted to facilitate convenient, regular participation in proceedings and to enable mediation; he also argues about jurisdiction and attendance requirements. The respondent-wife opposes the transfer, but engages in mediation talks with conditional participation (initially online, with in-person attendance if a concrete proposal arises). The High Court, in a Division Bench, cites Section 24 CPC (general power of transfer) and Section 25 CPC (power of Supreme Court to transfer), and Section 5 of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958. It reiterates that convenience is not ordinarily a decisive factor in forum selection, except in extraordinary circumstances, and notes that the Family Court Kasaragod has natural jurisdiction. The court approves the learned Single Judge’s order to not insist on the husband’s presence except when indispensable and dismisses the appeals, while recording mediation-friendly proposals. The decision emphasizes caution in appellate interference per established law (citing Balan v. Sivagiri Sree Narayana Dharma Sanghom Trust).
The petitioner, a religious denomination registered as a society, owned a building in Punalur Village used principally for religious and charitable purposes. It sought an exemption under Section 3(1)(b) of the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975, for 924.50 sq.m. This exemption was granted by the Government in Ext.P1 (30 January 2007). Subsequently, additional constructions were made beyond the exempted area, prompting Ext.P2 demand notices for the extra area. The petitioner contended that since the entire building, including the added area, is used mainly for religious and charitable purposes, the exemption should extend to the entire building automatically; Ext.P8 reflected the government’s stance in 2018 denying such extension. The petitioner argued reliance on the Supreme Court’s Government of Kerala v. Mother Superior Adoration Convent (2021) to claim exemption also for connected residential portions of the building, and cited India Bible College and Seminary v. State of Kerala (2022) to stress that when the whole building is used for religious purposes, partial denial of exemption would be impermissible. The respondents contended that the exemption from Ext.P1 applies only to 924.50 sq.m., and the Assessing Authority may determine tax for the additional area. The High Court, while noting the cited authorities, held the petitioner did not pursue statutory remedies under the 1975 Act for the added area and dismissed the writ petition, directing the petitioner to file an appeal within two weeks, to be decided as if timely filed by the Appellate Authority.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2820 OF 2024 Pranav, the sole accused in Crime No. 158/2024 of Kondotty Police Station, applies for bail under Section 439 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The prosecution alleges that in November 2023, the accused, being the stepfather of the minor victim, assaulted him and inflicted grievous injuries, including burning the buttocks with a heated iron spatula, constituting offences under IPC Sections 341 and 324 and Section 75 of the Juvenile Justice Act. He was arrested on 13 February 2024. The petitioner contends innocence and argues he was falsely implicated due to animosity from relatives of his wife; asserts lack of corroborating material and that investigation is complete with the final report filed, hence continued detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing incriminating materials and a likelihood of intimidating the victim, witnesses, or tampering with evidence if released. The court recalls Supreme Court doctrine: in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, the presumption of innocence governs; in Dataram Singh, bail is the rule; in State of Kerala v. Raneef and Hussainara Khatoon, undertrials’ rights under Article 21 require timely trials. After considering the 70 days in custody, the near-completion of investigation, and the peculiar facts, the court grants bail subject to stringent conditions, including a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, regular appearances, restrictions on contacting witnesses, residence limits near the victim, passport surrender, and power to cancel for violations; recoveries on bail are noted with reference to Sushila Aggarwal.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 233 of 2018) decided by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A. The petition challenges the cognizance taken by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thalassery, in C.C.No.1619/2016 (Annexure-A1 complaint) under IPC sections 120B, 420, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 IPC, in connection with alleged contract arrangements for supplying manpower and other workers for Kannur Medical College. The petitioners, accused nos. 1 and 3-6, contend that even if the allegations are assumed correct, no offence would be attracted, and more crucially that cognizance was taken in a mechanical manner without proper application of mind, violating settled principles. They argue non-compliance with procedure reportedly required by Priyanka Srivastava v. State of UP (affidavit requirement) and that the cognizance order does not reflect the requisite satisfaction or mind applied to the facts and law. The respondent (2nd petitioner) defends cognizance on the basis that it was after recording the 2nd respondent’s statement and that questions on ingredients should be addressed during trial, not at the pre-trial stage. The High Court, citing Pepsi Foods and Birla Corporation decisions, finds that the cognizance order lacks explicit application of mind and sets aside the cognizance order. It remands the matter to the Magistrate for re-consideration, while directing consideration of Priyanka Srivastava’s aspect during re-evaluation.
WP(C) Nos. 11249/2010, 26458/2014, 35030/2016, 335/2017, 17010/2017, 12389/2018, 8244/2019, 8913/2019, 10754/2019, 34020/2019, 3012/2020, 4070/2020, 11627/2020, 17240/2020, 8203/2021, 16223/2021, 16880/2021, 18523/2021, 25475/2021, 25917/2021, 29510/2021, 30550/2021; WA Nos. 1434/2017, 477/2018, 478/2018, 480/2018, 663/2018, 712/2018, 713/2018, 714/2018, 1453/2019, 1397/2020, 1145/2020, 8/2022 This judgment consolidates a batch of writ petitions challenging government actions and stop memos issued in relation to quarrying/mineral extraction on lands assigned under Kerala Land Assignment Rules and Rubber Cultivation Rules. The core issue is whether lands assigned for cultivation or other specific purposes can be used for quarrying or mining, and whether the State can resume such lands for breach of patta/assignment conditions. The court analyzes the interplay between state statutes (Kerala Government Land Assignment Act, 1960; Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964; Rubber Cultivation Rules, 1960; Arable Forest Land Assignment Rules, 1970) and central legislation (Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957; Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2015). It reviews a line of precedents, most notably Omana v. Anil Kumar (Overruled), Manu Anand (Public Trust/Rule 24 considerations), Haridas, One Earth One Life, Nature Lovers Movement, and Thressiamma Jacob, to evaluate the government’s authority to reserve subsoil rights and resume lands assigned for specific purposes. The bench ultimately upholds the State’s power to stop quarrying on assigned lands, overrules Omana’s contrary position, and directs Revenue authorities to enforce patta conditions with due regard to environmental protection and public interest, while permitting challenges and future proceedings subject to due process.
CRL.RC Nos. 269/2018, 273/2018, 275/2018, 276/2018, 277/2018, 278/2018, 279/2018, 281/2018, 282/2018, 287/2018, 290/2018, 291/2018, 292/2018, 296/2018, 298/2018, 300/2018, 301/2018, 303/2018, 307/2018, 308/2018, 309/2018, 311/2018, 315/2018, 317/2018, 319/2018, 323/2018, 327/2018, 328/2018, 330/2018, 336/2018, 342/2018, 346/2018, 348/2018, 349/2018, 350/2018, 351/2018, 353/2018, 356/2018, 357/2018, 358/2018, 359/2018, 361/2018, 362/2018, 363/2018, 374/2018, 375/2018, 376/2018, 383/2018, 386/2018 & 393/2018) These Criminal Revision Cases, numbered CRL.RC Nos. 269 of 2018 and connected cases, were heard in a batch before Justice P. Somarajan on 7 June 2024 at the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam. The proceedings arise from suo motu actions under Section 258 Cr.P.C. challenging acquittals in a constellation of cases before the Judicial Magistrates of Kollam-II, involving numerous ST and CR cases from 2013. The central issue is whether the Magistrate can halt proceedings in summons cases when the prosecution has shown due diligence to locate the accused and the cost of securing their presence would exceed the maximum fine prescribed, and whether such stoppage should be interfered with in revision. The court cites a Division Bench decision in State of Kerala and Another (2023 KHC Online 821), which articulates the settled position that Section 258 enables stopping proceedings in summons cases under appropriate conditions. The judgment reproduces the text of Section 258 Cr.P.C. to clarify its ambit and the manner of termination of proceedings if stoppage is warranted. While acknowledging the rule, the Court ultimately holds that the present revisions do not merit interference and are to be dismissed/closed, thereby disposing of the batch. The order emphasizes caution in invoking Section 258 and confirms that the revisions fail and are closed, without disturbing the trial court’s orders on the acquittals, in a procedural posture rather than re-examining the merits of the acquittals.
CRL.MC Nos.5207/21 & 2005/22 This is a Kerala High Court (Ernakulam) judgment by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A. delivered on 6 December 2023, disposing CRL.MC Nos. 5207 of 2021 and 2005 of 2022 challenging FIR No.1107/2021 (Infopark Police Station, Kakkanad) and the connected private complaint under the Companies Act, 2013 and IPC. The petitioner, Jenson Paul, alleged misappropriation and fraudulent issuance of share certificates by a company in which the complainant invested Rs.6 crore, with the funds allegedly diverted for personal enrichment. The Private Complaint, filed by Siddique Ahammed Haji, led to Annexure-A1 FIR and Annexure-A2 civil complaint. The Special Court designated under the Companies Act referred the private complaint to the police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. The petitioner sought quashing of Annexure-A1 and Annexure-A2, and sought to challenge the order referring the matter for investigation. The respondents argued that the Special Court, applying Cr.P.C provisions, can refer to police for investigation, and that cognizance under the Companies Act is not yet taken; they relied on provisions 212(2), 212(6) and 436(2) of the Companies Act, and on case law including Gopalakrishnan P. @ Dileep v. State of Kerala, Jayant Etc. v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Sumana Paruchuri v. Jakka Vinod Kumar Reddy, and Bhajan Lal. The Court held that there is no absolute bar on police investigation at the pre-cognizance stage and that the petitioners’ challenges to the referral/order lack merit, distinguishing Sumana Paruchuri and clarifying that Bhajan Lal’s criteria do not compel intervention under Section 482 Cr.P.C. Consequently, the petitions were dismissed, allowing the investigation to proceed and indicating that observations are not to prejudice merits of trial.
The appellants, accused Nos. 1, 2 and 5, challenge the conviction by the Kalpetta Addl. Sessions Court for offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 324, 326 and 307 read with Section 149 IPC, arising from an assault on PW1 and PW2 during encroachment-related tensions at Withgard, Wayanad. The prosecution relied on eyewitnesses PW1, PW2, and PW4, supported by medical exhibits Exts.P20 and P21 showing grievous injuries. The trial court acquitted accused Nos.3 and 4 but convicted 1, 2 and 5 with multi-year terms and fines, including a conviction under 120B against A5. On appeal, the High Court (Single Judge) partly allows the appeal: A1 and A2 are acquitted of Section 307 (attempt to murder); their convictions under 143, 147, 148, 324 and 326 are maintained; A5 is acquitted of all charges. The judgment emphasizes evaluating eyewitness testimony for its overall reliability, noting that minor inconsistencies do not necessarily negate credibility when the evidence, considered as a whole, bears the ring of truth (citing established Supreme Court principles). It also discusses Section 149 IPC, holding that five or more assailants need not all be convicted and that the assembly may still be Five or more in number based on the evidence, even if some named are acquitted. The court relies on Mohan Singh and Kartar Singh for this point, and distinguishes some contrary precedents where appropriate.
CRL.A 395/2008; CRL.A 398/2008 This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal involving Shaji and co-accused challenging their conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of liquor. The prosecution case, based on a search conducted at Mala, revealed 10225 litres of spirit distributed across 293 cans from two shop rooms (XII/332 and XII/334), leading to a charge against five accused. The trial court convicted Shaji (AC 1) and accused Nos. 3 to 5, while acquitting accused No. 2. The appellants assailed the conviction on several grounds: (i) detection by an officer allegedly incompetent to exercise Abkari powers under SRO 321/96; (ii) failure to prove the recovered spirit ultimately reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory in tamper-proof condition; (iii) lack of a forwarding note and seal description; (iv) unexplained delay in producing property and samples before the Court; and (v) absence of link evidence connecting the seized sample to the laboratory analysis. The High Court undertook a thorough examination of chain of custody, sampling/sealing protocol, and compliance with statutory formalities, citing Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Bhaskaran, Rajamma, Ramachandran, and Vijay Pandey among others. It concluded that the prosecution failed to prove that the seized sample reached the lab in tamper-proof condition and that the detecting officer had jurisdiction, thereby undermining the link to the contraband. Consequently, the appeals were allowed and the accused were acquitted.
This is a criminal appeal filed by Ramachandran (the appellant/accused) challenging a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Ad-hoc-I), Pathanamthitta, in Sessions Case No. 71 of 2005. The incident occurred on 08-03-2003, when 350 litres of spirit were found in the appellant’s possession at Pallickal Village, Thengamam. The trial court convicted him under Section 55(a) Abkari Act and sentenced four years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000. The State’s case included seizure of the contraband, collection of samples, forwarding to the Chemical Examiner, and testimony of witnesses. On appeal, the counsel for the appellant argued (i) identity of the person found in possession was not established; (ii) delay in producing the sample and properties; (iii) absence of proof that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner; (iv) conscious possession by the appellant was not established. The State's counsel contended that the prosecution had proven the offence. The High Court systematically examined issues of identification (highlighting the need for test identification parade per established jurisprudence), chain of custody, tamper-proof despatch of samples, and the element of possession. Relying on multiple authorities on identification, sampling, and possession, the court ultimately held that the chain of custody and evidence were flawed, and that the prosecution failed to prove conscious possession and tamper-proof dispatch. The result: the appeal is allowed, the conviction set aside, and the appellant acquitted and set at liberty.
This is a Kerala High Court writ petition (WP(C) No. 699 of 2019) by four petitioners (the complainants in CC No. 28/2010) challenging two subsequent orders (Exts. P3 and P4) of the Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Thiruvananthapuram, issued during execution of a final award in CC No. 28/2010. The State Commission’s Ext. P1 judgment (5 May 2016) awarded specific registrations: Flat 12-C with two car parks in favour of the 1st petitioner and Flat 8-B in favour of the 3rd petitioner, along with 18% interest for delayed possession from June 19, 2007 to 2012. During execution, Ext. P2 EA 19/2016 led to Ext. P3 directing the 2nd respondent (GCDA) to execute a registered sale deed in favour of the 3rd petitioner for an undivided share, with costs to be borne by the petitioners. IA No. 1005/2018 culminated in Ext. P4 amending the correction to include the 1st petitioner but denying car parks. The petition contends Exts. P3 and P4 override Ext. P1 and are not subject to challenge in execution. The High Court, after considering arguments and cited Supreme Court decisions, held that Exts. P3 and P4 require setting aside and remittance to the State Commission for fresh consideration after hearing, directing expedited processing of EA 19/2016. The petition is allowed in part, with directions to re-examine the matter under law.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CrL.A No.1000 of 2008) filed by the appellant Sanal Kumar against the conviction and sentence recorded by the Additional Sessions Court, Fast Track-II, Alappuzha, for an offence under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The prosecution story is that on 24.06.2002, at about 6:00 pm, 20 litres of arrack were found in the store room of the house of the accused at Ambalappuzha, in violation of the Abkari Act. The trial court convicted the accused under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act and sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh, while acquitting co-accused. On appeal, the appellant contends that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband was subjected to chemical analysis in a recognized laboratory, and that several irregularities taint the chain of custody and sampling. The court scrutinizes delays in producing seizure properties and the absence of a seal description, forwarding notes, and specimen seal, relying on several precedents (Ravi v. State of Kerala; Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala; Rajamma v. State of Kerala; Ramachandran v. State of Kerala; and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram) to emphasize that production of samples without delay and proper verification is essential for reliability. The court ultimately holds that the prosecution failed to establish a tamper-proof chain of evidence and that Ext.P14 (Chemical Analysis) has no evidentiary value, leading to acquittal of the appellant and setting aside the conviction.”