Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 673 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No. 2130 of 2007

Manumayaseelan s/o Sreedharan v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C. by the convicted appellant under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of the NDPS Act, 1985, arising from a Special Court (NDPS) judgment in SC No.1/2007 at Vadakara. The prosecution alleged possession of 1.10 kg of ganja by the accused near the Thalassery bus stand in a public place on 05.03.2006. PW1, the Sub-Inspector, testified that he recovered ganja from a polythene cover in the accused’s hand after guiding him to a search and obtaining consent in writing, followed by a seizure (Exts. P5 and P6; MO1–MO3) and chemical analysis (Ext. P12) confirming the contraband. The defence contended violation of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, arguing the accused was not informed of his right to be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer or magistrate, and questioned the evidentiary weight issue—whether the 1 kg 10 g weight included the wrapping materials, which would affect the quantity category (small vs intermediate). The prosecution relied on Sections 43 (public place seizure) and 42/42(2) (reasons for belief and information in writing) while asserting the vehicle/public-space context. The court below convicted and sentenced the accused; this appeal challenges that conviction and seeks acquittal on the S.50 and Ext. P1 issues, as well as weight and sufficiency of evidence. The High Court sustains the conviction and dismisses the appeal, with reasoning outlined in the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 734 OF 2008

Sreenivasan v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 734 of 2008) arising from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The appellant, Sreenivasan, was found manufacturing arrack on 02.02.2005 in a shed adjoining his residence in Kakkody and was convicted by the Adhoc-II Fast Track Sessions Court, Kozhikode, in Sessions Case No. 723 of 2006, receiving three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the appellant challenges the conviction on two main grounds: (i) the arrest and seizure are doubtful, and (ii) the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband substance reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The court scrutinizes the arrest on 02.02.2005 by PW1, noting Ext. P2 contains the crime number, which the defense argues undermines the seizure’s genesis. Relying on the decision in Santhosh v. State of Kerala, the court recognizes that a crime number in an arrest memo can cast doubt on the prosecution’s account, and cites Karunakar Bindhani and Rafeeque as supportive authorities. The judgment also highlights unexplained delay in producing seized properties, absence of seal description in Ext. P1, and non-examination of custody officers, invoking Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala and Ravi v. State of Kerala to emphasize the need for proper seal particulars and chain of custody. Consequently, the court finds the link to the Chemical Analyst’s Certificate tenuous and allows the appeal, acquitting the appellant and directing release and disbursement of deposits as per law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1424 OF 2007

Thankam v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal against a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act, arising from a 1998 seizure of 1.5 litres of illicit arrack at Malayinkeezhu. The Trial Court convicted the appellant, Thankam, and sentenced one year of rigorous imprisonment plus a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The High Court, in a single-judge judgment by Justice K. Babu, scrutinizes the legality of the sample-drawing and the chain of custody, as well as the propriety of sending the sample for chemical analysis. The court notes that the sample was drawn not by a police or excise official at the scene, but by the Court’s Property Clerk under magistrate instructions, and that Ext. P9 (the chemical analysis certificate) may lack evidentiary value in light of rulings that the Magistrate cannot perform sampling duties. The judgment cites a series of Kerala High Court decisions (Baburaj; Smithesh; Baby; Bhaskaran; Rajamma) to emphasize that the sampling process must be legally sanctioned, conducted by appropriate officials, and that the integrity of the seal and the chain of custody must be preserved. It further finds delays in forwarding the sample to the laboratory and non-examination of the excise guard fatal to the prosecution. Consequently, the appeal is allowed and the conviction reversed, leading to acquittal of the accused.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No.2187 of 2007

Arjunan v. State of Kerala

Arjunan, the appellant, was convicted by the IIIrd Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-I), Thodupuzha, under Sections 55(a) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing 6 litres of arrack and a glass tumbler for sale. The High Court of Kerala, while hearing Crl.A No.2187 of 2007, scrutinized the prosecution's evidence and found material deficiencies affecting the link between the seized contraband and the analysis of the sample. The defence highlighted irregularities such as the arrest memo bearing a crime number that suggested pre-registration or post hoc insertion, lack of a seal description on the seized bottle, and delays in forwarding the sample to the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory, with no satisfactory explanation for custody and delay. The court also noted a delay in producing the seized properties before the court, citing prior jurisprudence to emphasize that production should occur without unnecessary delay and that delay can cast doubt on tamper-proof handling of the sample. Several precedents addressing chain-of-custody, tamper-evident despatch, and the necessity of proving that the analysed sample originated from the seized contraband were invoked. Ultimately, the court held that the prosecution failed to establish the requisite link and the contraband was not proved to have been analyzed properly. Consequently, the conviction was set aside and the appellant acquitted, with liberty to discharge any deposits as directed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 28461/2018

WP(C) Nos. 28461/2018 & connected cases (KSRTC regularisation matter) - High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This judgment consolidates a batch of writ petitions by KSRTC provisional/emplaced staff challenging termination orders following government and KSRTC policies on regularisation. The Court traces a 2008 bipartite settlement and government orders (notably GO MS 78 of 2011, GO MS 105 of 2013, and GO MS 129 of 2018) that conditioned regularisation on ten years of service and minimum days of duty (120 per year) as on specific cut-off dates. It notes conflicting judicial positions: the Kerala High Court’s 2013 decision in Suresh Kumar v. State of Kerala (2 KLT 258) held that KSRTC could not impose extra conditions beyond government orders; this was later reversed by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeals Nos. 4435–4438/2017 (Ext.P7) and related orders (Ext.P17), which held that employers could impose appropriate conditions for regularisation, even for those already regularised. The core issue is retrospective application and vested rights from earlier judgments. The Court ultimately sets aside KSRTC termination orders in a broad sweep, directing a fact-specific hearing to determine whether each petitioner had met ten years of service and 120 days of duty up to 21.12.2011; if satisfied, regularisation should be ordered within three months; if not, termination may follow. It also ensures pension and other benefits for those who were superannuating or whose families are affected, subject to the hearing outcomes. The judgment binds all persons under Article 141 through the Supreme Court’s later ruling, albeit with a nuanced implementation timeline.

High Court of Kerala
WA 48/2020 (and connected cases)

WA Nos. 48/2020 and connected matters (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

This is a batch of writ appeals challenging the validity and application of amendments to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) and related tax statutes in the wake of the introduction of the GST regime. The Kerala High Court examined whether amendments to Section 25(1) KVAT (substituting ‘five years’ with ‘six years’) and the third proviso thereto, made by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 (11 of 2017) and 2018 (5 of 2018), could operate retrospectively in reopenings of assessments for years prior to the GST regime and the KVAT repeal. The court analyzed the constitutional framework (Article 246A), the CAA 2016, and the saving provisions under KGST Act (Section 174), along with the Kerala Finance Acts’ commencement and operation dates. It held that the amendments are prospective in nature for the assessment years in question (notably 2010-11 and 2011-12), and that the State legislature lacked competence to amend the KVAT Act post-repeal to revive older rights. The judgment surveys several precedents on retrospective legislation, vested rights, and saving clauses, and ultimately dismisses the writ appeals (with a finding consistent with Baiju A.A. and related Kerala cases).

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal Nos. 43 & 72 of 2020

Beena M.S. v. Shino G. Babu (Mat.Appeal Nos. 43 & 72 of 2020)

These are two matrimonial appeals (Mat.Appeal Nos. 43 and 72 of 2020) arising from the Family Court, Nedumangad, involving Beena M.S. and Shino G. Babu. They are Christians, married on 30.04.2015. The husband filed for divorce on the ground of cruelty; the wife countered with lack of emotional bond and incompatibility, denying misbehavior while admitting lack of care during pregnancy. The Family Court granted a decree of divorce to the husband and dismissed his petition for permanent custody of the child. The High Court, after considering pleadings, evidence, email communications and messages (Exts. A2–A8), found that the couple suffered from a deep-seated incompatibility from the beginning, resulting in emotional turbulence and recurring quarrels. It held that “cruelty” in the modern sense can be inferred from persistent incompatibility and the reluctance to sever the relationship when mutual consent fails. Citing Naveen Kohli and Samar Ghosh, the court explained that prolonged separation and withholding of consent for mutual separation may amount to cruelty. The High Court sustained the Family Court’s order—divorce in favour of the husband—and declined to grant custody to the father, noting the child has lived with the mother since birth and no interim custody was sought; it left open visiting rights. The appeals were dismissed with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 4601 OF 2021

M.D Esthappan vs Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund Organization, Regional Office, Kochi and Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, EPFO, Kochi

This writ petition challenges the order dated 22.09.2017 passed under Section 7A of the Employees Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, which determined a liability of Rs. 67,42,464 against the petitioner, and the subsequent review order dated 01.02.2018 and the appeal order dated 10.02.2020 in Appeal No.295 of 2018, all of which were upheld by the relevant authorities. The petitioner, a proprietor engaged in civil contract works and registered under the EPF Act, contends that the order and the review were received in February 2018, and that an appeal had to be filed within 60 days; he filed a belated appeal on 13.09.2018 with a condonation application, explaining his old age and health problems. The review petition was dismissed for lack of new matters or evidence. The respondent authority argued that the appeal is time-barred, with limitation of 60 days plus a further 60 days, and that Section 5 of the Limitation Act cannot extend this period. They further contended that the 7B review allows re-examination only for discovery of new matters, and that the petitioner had ample opportunities during the inquiry to place evidence. The High Court held that once the statute prescribes the limitation period (60 + 60 days), condonation cannot extend it, and that the impugned orders do not warrant interference; accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 48/2020; 7/2021; 8/2021; 10/2021; 98/2021; 99/2021; 117/2021; 142/2021; 143/2021; 245/2021; 284/2021; 1056/2021

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam (Batch: WA Nos. 48/2020 and connected cases)

This batch of writ appeals concerns the validity and retrospective v. prospective effect of amendments to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) introduced by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018, in the wake of the transition to GST. The petitions challenge notices issued under Section 25(1) of the KVAT Act for reopening assessments for the years 2010-11 and 2011-12. The court surveys a long line of authorities on retroactivity, sunrise vs sunset clauses, commencement versus operation of statutes, and the constitutional distribution of tax powers post-CAA 2016. It emphasizes that the legislature can enact retrospective or prospective amendments, but the operative effect depends on express language and necessary implication. The Kerala High Court ultimately upholds a position that the 2017 amendment substituting “five years” with “six years” is prospective, and that the 2018 extension (to 2019) goes beyond the State’s competence given the repeal of KVAT and the advent of KGST, with saving provisions not rendering retroactive amendments tenable. The decision aligns with Baiju A.A. and Najeem lines, while distinguishing Jyoti Traders and other precedents. The batch is disposed of with the appeals dismissed, upholding the learned judgments below and endorsing the non-retroactive effect of the challenged amendments.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No.1903 of 2007

CRL.A No.1903 of 2007

Aggrieved by the judgment dated 06.10.2007 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No.III, Palakkad, convicting the appellants under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act and sentencing them to four years' imprisonment and fines, the accused challenge the legality of the trial Court’s link between the seized contraband and the Chemical Analysis report. The prosecution alleged the seizure of about 75 litres of toddy in a jeep at 4th Mile, Chittur taluk, and its subsequent examination. The defence reframed the issue around the lack of chain-of-custody and tamper-proof handling of the sample: the seizure mahazar (Ext.P1) omits seal description; the specimen seal was not produced; the forwarding note lacks the official’s name; there was an unexplained delay in forwarding the sample to the Chemical Examiner; and custody of the sample between 26.06.2001 and 14.08.2001 was not explained. The Kerala High Court cites Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala (2020 KHC 5296) and Viswanathan v. State of Kerala (2016 (3) KHC 38), emphasizing the need for a tamper-proof chain of custody and explanation of delays, to test the integrity of the laboratory report Ext.P8. Finding no satisfactory link evidence or tamper-proof proof, the court acquits the accused and allows the appeal, setting them at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 27610 of 2020; 4836 of 2021

Manjusha Nair v. District Geologist, Office of Mining and Geology Department, Mini Civil Station, Aranmula, Pathanamthitta; Village Officer, Cherukole Village, Ranni; Cherukole Grama Panchayat, Kattoor P.O.; The Secretary, Cherukole Grama Panchayat; Vargheese (and Rajan Pillai) — WP(C) Nos. 27610 of 2020 & 4836 of 2021

The two connected writ petitions (WP(C).Nos. 27610 of 2020 and 4836 of 2021) arise from a dispute over removal of rocky formations for construction of a commercial-cum-residential building on the petitioners’ properties in Cherukole, Pathanamthitta. The petitioner Manjusha Nair contends that Ext.P6 stop memo and the subsequent inspection and notices (Exts. P8–P9) were issued contrary to the Court’s directions in Ext.P7, which required the District Geologist to notify, inspect with prior notice, and afford a hearing before deciding on a non-explosive method for removal and to record the inspection via mahazar. The related matter involves Rajan Pillai (W.P. 4836/2021) and his father-in-law’s properties, with notices demanding recovery under the Revenue Recovery Act’s Section 34 and Section 7. The petitioners rely on the principle that notices must reflect the extent of removal, the quantity, and the proposed action, citing Biju K. Varghese v. Geologist, which mandates issue of notices with mahazar and prior inspection. Government Pleader supports the impugned Exts. P8–P9 as compliant with Ext.P7. The court ultimately disposes of the petitions by directing further inspection with notice and mahazar, within two months, deferring coercive steps, and enabling leveling applications with non-explosive methods while final orders are prepared.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1811 OF 2008

Baby, S/o Rajan v. State of Kerala

Aggrieved by a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act for storing 22.5 litres of coloured illicit liquor at his residence, Baby, the appellant, is challenging the judgment of the Additional District & Sessions Judge (Adhoc-III), North Paravur in SC 133/2008. The Trial Court convicted him and sentenced him to two years' rigorous imprisonment plus a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The High Court scrutinizes whether the prosecution proved conscious possession, as required by Abkari Act; whether the recovered liquor was properly linked to the accused; and whether the chemical analysis was tainted by delays and an insecure chain of custody. The Excise Inspector recovered the liquor from building V/304; the accused was not in exclusive possession and the building’s ownership related to Ally, wife of Rajan, as per Ext.P11; the court relied on jurisprudence that possession requires dominion or control, including constructive possession, and on the need to prove that the contraband samples reached the laboratory in tamper-proof condition. The court finds failure in proving possession and chain-of-custody; key custodians were not examined; Ext.P12 analysis is inadmissible; delay in analysis is unexplained. Supported by Santhosh, Ravi, Sasidharan, Sathi, Gunwantlal and others, the High Court acquits the appellant. The appeal is allowed; disposal of deposited money is ordered.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R.No.76 of 2021

P.A. Johnson v. Akhil Syamkumar and Rahul Syamkumar

This is a Rent Control Revision (R.C.R.No.76 of 2021) before the Kerala High Court, arising from eviction under Section 11(4)(v) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court, Kottayam, had granted eviction on 31 October 2016; the Rent Control Appellate Authority-II, Kottayam, by its judgment dated 20 December 2019, dismissed the appeal (R.C.A.No.3 of 2017). The revision challenges both the RCP order and the RA order, invoking Section 20 of the Act, and questions whether the landlord discharged the initial burden and whether there was cessation of occupation for six months. The petitioner-tenant, P.A. Johnson, contends that the landlord failed to prove cessation of occupation and that the evidence does not establish non-use of the premises for the statutory period. The landlords rely on Exts.A1–A4(a), PW1–PW3, Exts.B1–B10, and Exts.C1–C1(a), including the Advocate Commissioner’s report showing the premises locked, a street vendor’s activity in the verandah, and a functioning meter. The High Court surveys a lineage of controlling authorities on the meaning of “occupation,” the burden of proof, and the proper scope of revisional review, including Dunlop India Ltd. v. A.A. Rahna and others, Abbas, Mathai Antony, Liji Agencies, Sabeer, and the revisional line culminating in Thankamony Amma. The court ultimately upholds the eviction finding and dismisses the revision, confirming that the petitioner failed to establish reasonable cause for non-occupation and that the lower courts were not perverse. The revision is dismissed with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1300 of 2007

Thamizharasan v. State of Kerala

Thamizharasan v. State of Kerala concerns a criminal appeal under the Abkari Act against a conviction for possession of arrack in a moving autorickshaw. On 24.04.2005, around 11:30 am, the appellant and co-accused were found in possession of 10 litres of arrack in a can during a check on the Munnar-Kannimala road, Idukki district. The case was investigated, with a final report under Section 8(2) Abkari Act; it was committed to the Sessions Court and tried in SC No. 89/2006. The Trial Court convicted the accused under Section 55(a) Abkari Act and sentenced them to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, counsel for the appellant argued that the arrest was doubtful because the arrest memos (Ext. P3) bore a crime number, raising concern whether the FIR was registered before or after the seizure; that the appellant did not prove conscious possession; and that there was no satisfactory explanation of the chain of custody or tamper-proof handling of the sample sent for chemical analysis. The Kerala High Court, after reviewing the record and the authorities cited, held that the arrest’s genesis was doubtful and that the appellant did not have dominion or control over the contraband. It found the failure to prove tamper-proof custody and to link the sample to the lab report undermined the prosecution. Relying on Santhosh and other precedents, the court acquitted the accused; the appeal was allowed, with the conviction and sentence set aside.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Appeal Nos. 2019 & 2197 of 2007

Dharamarajan S/o Narayanan and Vinod S/o Balakrishnan Pulickal v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court judgment arises from two criminal appeals challenging a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The 3rd Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc-I), Thodupuzha, convicted accused 1 (Dharamarajan) and 2 (Vinod) for transporting 420 liters of spirit in August 2001 and sentenced them to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh each; six accused were tried, with accused 3–6 acquitted. On appeal, it is submitted that the sole evidence creating guilt is PW3’s testimony, which the defence argues is unreliable, with occurrence witnesses hostile and crucial evidence (CW1, the detecting officer) not examined. The prosecution relies on Ext. P1 seizure, Ext. P13 chemical analysis, and PW3’s narrative. The court weighs authorities including Ravi v. State of Kerala (2011 (3) KLT 353), Raja Khima v. State of Saurashtra (AIR 1956 SC 217), Tahir v. State (Delhi) (1996) 3 SCC 338, Baldev Singh v. State of Haryana (2015) 17 SCC 554, State of Rajasthan v. Daulath Ram (AIR 1980 SC 1314), and Valsala v. State of Kerala (AIR 1994 SC 117) to test credibility, chain-of-custody, and sufficiency of evidence. It concludes that the evidence is unsafe beyond reasonable doubt due to lack of examination of CW1, delays in producing the sample, and identification of only two accused by PW3. Consequently, the convictions cannot stand. The appeals are allowed, and the conviction and sentence are set aside, with the appellants to be released. The decision reiterates the need for credible, corroborated evidence and strict chain-of-custody in narcotics-like matters.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No. 18 of 2021

KANDAMBATH ACHAMVEETTIL LAKSHMIKUTTI AMMA v. VANNADIL PRAMEELA and others

This High Court of Kerala, Divisional Bench comprising Anil K. Narendran, J. and P. G. Ajithkumar, J., decided FAO No. 18 of 2021, challenging an order in O.S. No. 2 of 2009 (Payyannur) that dismissed an application under Order IX, Rule 13 CPC to set aside an ex parte decree dated 15.01.2019. The appellant, Kandambath Achamveettill Lakshmikutti Amma, the 8th defendant in the original suit, argued that she could not appear for medical reasons and was laid up for about 45 days starting 04.12.2018, supported by Ext. A1 (a medical certificate). She contended that other defendants were out of station and that the ex parte decree was passed without sufficient opportunity to adduce evidence. The plaintiff (1st respondent) contended the petition under Order IX, Rule 13 was a delaying tactic and that, even if illness occurred, the other defendants could have appeared, so the request should not be allowed. The Sub Court dismissed the RP I A No. 341 of 2019. The High Court, applying liberal interpretation of “sufficient cause” and the discretionary approach in setting aside ex parte decrees, held that the order under challenge cannot stand and allowed the appeal with costs, directing expeditious disposal of O.S. No. 2 of 2009 within four months of certified copy of the judgment and payment of Rs. 5,000 within three weeks.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 41887 OF 2023

Shamsudheen P. v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others

This writ petition challenges a blanket, indefinite debit freeze imposed on the petitioner’s bank account pursuant to police requisitions. The Kerala High Court recalls its earlier decision in Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India, which cautioned against blanket freezes and directed proportionate action by banks in coordination with law enforcement. In the present case the bank has received requisitions that allegedly seek to freeze all credits in the account but without specifying any particular amount. The court notes that such an unbounded freeze would injure the account holder’s livelihood and disrupt ordinary banking activity, undermining the rights of account holders and the banking system. The court clarifies the balance between investigative needs and individual rights and reiterates the principle that a blanket, indefinite freeze should be avoided unless imperative. While acknowledging the bank’s practical difficulty, the court holds that it is bound by the Dr. Sajeer framework and must ensure protections for the petitioner. Following Dr. Sajeer, the court directs the bank to secure the exact amount to be frozen from the Investigation Authority within one month; if an amount is specified, the freeze is to be limited to that sum; if no information is received within two months, the petitioner may transact fully, subject to future police information. It also provides an alternative and an eight-month contingency, ensuring investigation while safeguarding livelihoods.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 755 of 2007

Roy Varghese v. State of Kerala

Roy Varghese, the appellant, challenges the judgment of the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Kalpetta, which convicted him under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of six bottles of Indian Made Foreign Liquor. The offence was alleged to have been detected on 01.05.1999 at Mananthavady. The trial court convicted him after trial under Cr.P.C. Section 232, concluding that the prosecution proved the contraband possession. The High Court, however, on full scrutiny of the prosecution evidence, particularly the chain of custody and the lab analysis, held that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband seized from the place of occurrence reached the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory in a tamper-proof condition. It noted unexplained delays in producing the seized properties (the properties reportedly reached the Court only on 27.05.1999, though seizure was recorded on 01.05.1999) and the absence of proof regarding the seals and the modes of transit. Relying on a series of precedents—Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Rajamma, Bhaskaran, Ramachandran and others—the Court emphasized the indispensability of a tamper-proof chain of custody for contraband in Abkari cases. The cumulative deficiencies led the High Court to acquit the appellant, setting aside the conviction and allowing the appeal. The appellant is to be released. The Court delivered the judgment on 15 June 2022.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2378 OF 2024

Ajmal P.K and others v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by four accused (Ajmal P.K., Aswin A.U., Aman Roshan, and Muhammed Nasim) in Crime No. 97/2024 of Sulthan Bathery Police Station, Wayanad, challenging their detention in custody since 28.02.2024. The offences alleged are under IPC Sections 325 (hurt), 341 (wrongful restraint) and 395 (dacoity). The prosecution asserts that, on 30.01.2024, while the complainant and his family were travelling, the accused, driven by prior animosity, blocked the vehicle, restrained the complainant, injured him, and looted gold worth Rs. 1,11,000. The petitioners contend road rage rather than robbery, and maintain their innocence, emphasizing the investigation is substantially complete and that recoveries have been effected. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail but concedes the petitioners have been in custody since 28.02.2024 and that recoveries have been made. Citing Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, and State of Kerala v. Raneef, the court underscores the presumption of innocence and that detention prior to conviction is punitive. It ultimately holds that release on bail is warranted given the lack of a compelling reason to continue detention, and grants bail subject to standard conditions, including Rs 50,000 bond with two sureties, regular appearances, abstaining from tampering with witnesses, surrendering passport, and adherence to further conditions, with the court retaining power to modify conditions if necessary.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2103 OF 2007

Jalal v. State of Kerala

This is an appeal under Cr. A. No. 2103/2007 from the Kerala High Court challenging a 2007 conviction under Sections 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act for possession of 1.5 litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) for sale. The prosecution case, arising from a seizure on 14.06.2005 at Jalal’s vegetable shop at Muttom junction, rests on PW3 (the Sub-Inspector) who testified that the accused fled when the police approached and that contraband was recovered from the shop. The trial court convicted after considering PW1–PW5, Exts P1–P10 and MO1, and the defence’s version was rejected. On appeal, the court scrutinized key elements: identity and possession of the contraband; whether the seized liquor was subjected to chemical analysis; and the chain of custody of the sample until analysis. It held that independent witnesses did not support the case, PW3 had only a fleeting identification, and there was no reliable identification parade or proof that the sample tested in the lab was the same as that seized. Relying on established case law about identification, chain of custody, and lab linkage, the High Court acquitted the appellant, setting aside the conviction and sentence and directing release.