Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 672 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.8372/2024

Sai Rajesh & C. Reeja v State of Kerala & Others

The Kerala High Court, in a writ petition (C) filed by two hotel operators under FL-3 licenses, challenges Ext.P1, an order issued by the District Magistrate and District Collector under Section 54 of the Kerala Abkari Act, directing closure of all liquor shops and bars during Pattambi Nercha Festival on 02-03-2024 and 03-03-2024 from 6 am to 10 pm within Pattambi Municipality and the Karimbankavu outlet of the Kerala Beverages Corporation. The petitioners operate Three Star hotels near the festival area, where the Nercha festivities involve elephants and a large-scope celebration with multiple sub-committees, raising concerns about public order and safety. The District Magistrate’s decision is premised on maintaining law and order due to potential unrest and past incidents, citing nearby bars as hotspots for social miscreants. The petitioners argue Ext.P1 lacks evidentiary basis, was not requested by police, and violates directions from Hotel Vijaya Palace v. State of Kerala (2016 (1) KLT 284). The Government Pleader defends the measure as a legitimate exercise of Section 54 power in larger public interest. After considering submissions and materials, the Court concludes the District Magistrate reasonably assessed the need for a dry day, notes the festival’s scale, and declines to interfere. The writ petition is dismissed, leaving Ext.P1 intact and in force for the festival period.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.1697 OF 2024

MIDHLAJ v. STATE OF KERALA

Case: MIDHLAJ v. STATE OF KERALA. This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the first accused in Crime No.164/2024 of Karunagapally Police Station. The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act offences charged are Section 20(b)(ii)(B) and Section 29. The prosecution case relies on seizure of 3.101 kilograms of ganja from the accused’ rented premises on 27 January 2024. The petitioner contends that he is innocent, falsely implicated, without criminal antecedents, and that the contraband represents an intermediate quantity; further, he has remained in judicial custody since 27 January 2024 and the investigation is practically complete, so further detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, noting ongoing investigation but acknowledging lack of antecedents and the intermediate quantity; she prayed for dismissal. After hearing, the judge found no antecedents, that the recovery was effected, and the investigation was practically complete, and thus allowed the bail application. The order imposes bond of Rs 50,000 with two solvent sureties, and conditions including Saturdays appearances before the IO for a month or until final report, prohibition on inducement or tampering with witnesses or evidence, no offence on bail, surrender of passport or affidavit, and power to cancel or modify bail. The decision explicitly cites Supreme Court guidance in Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another for the IO's authority to investigate and recover on bail. The order was delivered by Justice C. S. Dias on 20 March 2024.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.(Rev) No. 263 of 2023

KIZHAKKAYIL HAMZA HAJI v. PUTHIYAPARAMBATH AMMED HAJI and others

This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court, challenging the maintainability of R.C.P. No.21 of 2019 before the Rent Control Court, Kalpetta and the judgments of the Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority. The revision petitioner-tenant contends that the landlord’s title to the petition schedule building is not exclusive because his wife allegedly holds a fractional share of the property. He argues that because of this claimed wife’s share, the title of the landlords is contested, rendering the eviction proceedings potentially unsustainable. The landlords seek eviction on arrears of rent and for bona fide personal need under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, alleging a tenancy started from a rent kaichit dated 28.06.2017 and that the entire building is needed for the landlords’ supermarket business. The Rent Control Court rejected the challenge to title, which was upheld by the Appellate Authority. The court relied on Exts. A2–A6, showing transfers by the tenant’s wife that undermine the wife’s claimed 87.5% share. Citing Retheesh Chandran A. R. v. Sarojini Amma and other precedents, the court held that the denial of title need only be bona fide and supported by substantial material. The revision petition is ultimately dismissed, affirming the concurrent findings that the landlord’s title and the maintainability of proceedings were sound.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 38454 of 2023

Tomy Isac v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Kanhangad; Local Level Monitoring Committee, Kanhangad Municipality; Village Officer, Kanhangad Village; Kerala State Remote Sensing and Environment Centre

Tomy Isac, the petitioner, challenges Ext.P8, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting his Form 5 removal application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The land in question is 25.06 acres of Re. Sy. No. 508/3 (old Sy. No. 385/2) in Kanhangad. The petitioner contends the property is neither paddy land nor wetland, yet it was included in the Data Bank. Ext.P5, Ext.P6 and Ext.P8 trace a sequence where the RDO refused removal relying on the Agricultural Officer's report, without an independent assessment of the land’s status as on the Act’s date or its suitability for paddy cultivation. The court recalls Arthasasthra Ventures v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, Aparna Sasi Menon, and other precedents, underscoring that the RDO must independently evaluate whether removal would affect paddy cultivation or sustenance of wetlands. It also reiterates that fallow status or water logging is not determinative. The court ultimately finds Ext.P8 unsustainable, sets it aside, and directs the RDO to reconsider Ext.P6 with KSRSEC input within two months, with the petitioner obtaining KSRSECreport and submitting copies for compliance. The petition is disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1749 OF 2024

REJI KURIAKOSE v. STATE OF KERALA

The petitioner, Reji KuriaKose, stands as the sole accused in Crime No.1529/2023 of Adimaly Police Station, Idukki, seeking pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. The prosecution accuses him of offences under IPC sections 379 (theft), 420 (cheating), 447 (criminal trespass), 451 (house-trespass), 294(b) (obscene acts), and 506 (criminal intimidation), arising from an alleged civil settlement that spiraled into criminal allegations. The crux is a dispute memorialized in Annexure-4, executed on 05.09.2022, where the defacto complainant and the petitioner allegedly agreed to transfer and exchange property upon payment; the defacto complainant alleges the petitioner diverted property, extracted 50 trees, and looted tools, in breach of the agreement and thereby cheated him. The defense argues the dispute is civil; custodial interrogation is unnecessary; no recovery is claimed. The prosecution contends the ongoing investigation and possible tampering with witnesses justify arrest. The court, citing Indian Oil Corp. v. NEPC India Ltd., Sarabjit Kaur, ARCI v Nimra Cerglass, Sachin Garg, Siddharam Mhetre, Sibbia and Sushila Aggarwal, underscores that anticipatory bail cannot follow rigid rules; it must be grounded in facts and the probability of prejudice to investigation and risk of misuse. On prima facie assessment, custodial interrogation is not essential, and pre-arrest bail is granted with conditions, including surrender, bonds, and compliance obligations.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.7867 of 2024

NITHIN N. v. SUB COLLECTOR/REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER OTTAPALAM & OTHERS

The petition is by Nithin N., absolute owner and possessor of 6.97 acres in Old Sy. No.163/8, Vaniyamkulam 2 Village, challenging Ext. P5, the order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) that refused to exclude the land from the Land Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008. The peti­tioner had submitted Form 5 seeking exclusion after mutations and obtaining a possession certificate, and the 2nd respondent (Local Level Monitoring Committee) decided not to exclude. Ext. P5 was passed by the 1st respondent (RDO) in a mechanical manner, relying on the 2nd respondent’s report without independent merit assessment. The petitioner contends violation of statutory procedures, non-application of mind, and improper consideration of the KSREC report; he also argues that Ext. P5 is not a speaking order. The court notes that Muraleedharan Nair v. Revenue Divisional Officer and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO have laid down that the RDO must independently assess the land status and consider whether removal would adversely affect paddy cultivation and wetlands, rather than merely endorsing a committee’s decision. The judgment concludes Ext. P5 is not a speaking order and sets it aside, directing fresh consideration within three months, with an opportunity to obtain KSREC reports, and final orders within a further three months thereafter, after proper independent appraisal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 7807 OF 2024

Jayaprakash v. State of Kerala & others

The petitioner, Jayaprakash, seeks to challenge Ext.P4 and obtain correction of revenue records for his 0.0243 hectare residential plot in Sy No. 1111/4P, Ayyanthol Village, Thrissur, to be recorded as dry land rather than Nilam. The land has allegedly remained pucca dry land for about four decades, supported by Exhibits P1–P3. Ext.P4, issued by the Revenue Divisional Officer, fixed a fair value of Rs. 9,76,800 for the property (as per Ext.P2) and rejected the Form 5 application to delete the land from the Data Bank without hearing the petitioner or supplying a copy of the report of the 4th respondent Agricultural Officer. The petitioner contends that the impugned order is not a speaking order and simply relies on the Agricultural Officer’s report; it is alleged that the Department neglected to apply mind or consider KSREC findings as required under law, and that the Kerala Conservation of Paddy and Wet Land Act, 2008 has not been properly invoked. The court cites Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, underscoring the need for independent assessment by the RDO and for consideration of whether the land can support paddy cultivation when deciding Form 5. Finding Ext.P4 non-speaking and lacking necessary consideration, the court sets aside the order and directs reconsideration of Form 5 within three months, with an option to obtain KSREC report and to evaluate the petition accordingly, ensuring due process and compliance with law.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(KAT) No. 325 of 2018

T. N. Leela v. State of Kerala and others

This is an original petition under the Kerala (KAT) sought by T. N. Leela challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's order dated 27 July 2018 (OA 661/2018) which dismissed the application seeking restoration of service. Leela contends she was engaged as a casual sweeper from June 2007 and continued in service until 2017, but was not permitted to rejoin. She prays for rejoining till superannuation and relies on Government Order GO(P) No.501/2005/Fin. dated 25.11.2005, which provides a framework for regularisation of existing casual sweepers and future appointments, along with GO(P) No.61/2010/Fin. (dated 09.02.2010) and Annexure A3: Circular No.98/2010/Fin (dated 19.11.2010). Respondents contend post-2005 appointments as part-time sweepers must be through the Employment Exchange or Kudumbasree, and that the 2005 GO was intended to protect only existing casual sweepers and not create a general right for those engaged later. The High Court clarifies that Annexure A3 does not create an absolute right to regularisation but allows consideration on representation, directing the petitioner to submit a representation to the first respondent within two months. While confirming the Tribunal’s finding on regularisation under GO 501/2005 to the extent of the government’s power, the court emphasises that the government may grant regularisation if entitled, after hearing. Costs follow the outcome.

High Court of Kerala
R.P.No.175 of 2021 in Mat.Appeal No.173 of 2013

R.P.No.175 of 2021 in Mat.Appeal No.173 of 2013

This is a Kerala High Court review petition (RP 175/2021) arising from the judgment in Mat Appeal No.173 of 2013, which affirmed the Family Court, Kottayam Ettumanoor’s order in O.P. No.1164 of 2010. The petitioners, Justine @ Joseph, Mathew, and Gracy Mathew, challenge two aspects of the 26 July 2019 judgment: (i) the finding that 53 sovereigns of gold ornaments were entrust ed with the first petitioner and that the respondent was entitled to retrieve patrimony from the petitioners, and (ii) the award of interest at 9% per annum on the decretal amount. They contend that oral evidence of PW1 and PW4 does not establish entrustment and that the court misread Annexure 1. The respondent argues delay was condoned and the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP on merits; the right to review cannot be foreclosed. The petition relies on established review jurisprudence, including Kunhayammed and others, Parsion Devi, and Aribam Tuleshwar Sharma, to argue that review is permissible for errors apparent on the face of the record and not a vehicle for re‑hearing. The High Court ultimately allows the review petition in part, reducing the rate of interest from 9% to 6% per annum from the date of decree till realisation, while other grounds are rejected.

High Court of Kerala
WA 297 of 2020

Mohan Nair P.G. v. Omallur Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. & Others

This intra-court appeal arises from a writ petition filed by Mohanan Nair P.G., a retired employee of Omallur Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. The petitioner, who retired on 30.04.2015, challenged the withholding of terminal benefits—gratuity, leave surrender, balance provident fund, welfare fund, security deposit, and related arrears—on the footing of a liability certificate Ext.P-5 issued on 17.08.2019 in pursuance of audit objections (Ext.R-1(a)). The Single Judge had dismissed W.P.(C).No.24570/2019, directing the petitioner to challenge Ext.P-5 and pursue relief through the Cooperative Arbitration Court under Sec.69 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act. The appellant contends that no disciplinary memo of charges was issued, Rule 198(7) cannot be invoked, and Rule 198(8) requires issuance of a non-liability certificate within 30 days of retirement, failure of which bars unilateral liability fixation. The court surveys precedents—Kottayam District Co-operative Bank, Philip.C.M., Pappachan, and Association of Milma Officers—holding that withholding retiral benefits without due process violates law; while respondents defend the action as a liability fixed via audit objections and urge Sec.69 arbitration. The Division Bench ultimately holds that withholding gratuity and provident fund is illegal, directs full gratuity with 8% interest (later increasing to 10% if delayed), and directs payment within one month, with liberty to seek other benefits via the Joint Registrar. The judgment overrules the earlier dismissal and sets a broader remedy framework for similar co-operative society disputes.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.910 of 2008

SATHEESAN v. STATE OF KERALA

Satheesan, the sole accused in an Abkari Act case (Section 55(a)) challenged a 2008 conviction by the Additional Sessions Court, Adhoc-I, Thalassery arising from SC No. 309/2006. The prosecution alleged that on 06.12.2004, at about 5:35 pm, the accused was transporting six bottles of Indian Made Foreign Liquor in violation of the Abkari Act. The trial court convicted after trial and the appellant escalated to the Kerala High Court. The appellant’s grounds centered on two critical issues: (i) the arrest being doubtful because the arrest memo (Ext. P1) bore a crime number, and (ii) the prosecution failing to prove that the contraband actually reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory for analysis. Relying on the decision in Santhosh v. State of Kerala, the court noted that the presence of a crime number in the arrest memo can imply that the FIR was registered before seizure or that the number was inserted afterward, casting doubt on the genesis of the case. The court also scrutinized delays in producing seized properties and the custody of the sample, citing Ravi, Viswanadhan, Daulat Ram, Sasidharan, Rafeeque, Karunakar Bindhani, and Vijay Pandey to emphasize that the link between seized contraband and the laboratory analysis must be demonstrated and that tamper-proof handling is essential. The absence of such link led to the acquittal. Ultimately, the appeal is allowed and the accused is acquitted and set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.259 of 2022

Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church Catholicate Palace, Devalokam, Muttambalam Village, Kottayam v. Eldho Basil and Others (OP(C) No.259 of 2022)

This Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenges a common order dated 27 January 2022 of the District Court, Kottayam, allowing amendments in I.A. Nos. 1/2022 and 2/2022 in O.P. No. 10 of 2022 under Section 92 CPC to permit respondents to sue to challenge post-sanction decisions of the Malankara Orthodox Church administration. The petitioners contend that there is no provision to amend a petition under Section 92 CPC, that the proposed plaint is not registered, and that amendments would alter the nature and scope beyond the sanctioned relief. The respondents argue that Order VI Rule 17, CPC can apply to proceedings under Section 92 CPC by virtue of Section 141 CPC, and that amendments are necessary to incorporate post-filing events to adjudicate the real controversy. The court surveys jurisprudence, including Ram Chandra Aggarwal on the scope of Section 141 CPC, Ranjithmon v. Mary on the broader meaning of “proceeding,” and distinguishes Meeran Maluk Mohammed’s decision while endorsing the general principle that suits under Section 92 must align with the sanction. The judge concludes amendments do not alter the character of the suit and that supervisory interference under Article 227 is limited, ultimately dismissing the petition and vacating the interim stay. The decision reflects a cautious balancing of procedural flexibility with the sanctity of the original sanction in trust matters.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases)

WA 811 of 2020 (and connected matters) - High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam

This batch of writ appeals, heard by a Full Bench of the Kerala High Court, challenges the common judgment dated 25 February 2020 in WP(C) Nos. 10107/2019 and allied petitions, concerning pension under the Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995 and its amendments for employees of exempted establishments under the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO). The petitioners claim entitlement to a pension calculated without reduction for ceiling limits once additional contributions are remitted to the pension fund, invoking Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614) and the Supreme Court’s RC Gupta decision (2018) 14 SCC 809, among others. The respondents, EPFO and related trustees, assert the contributory character of the pension scheme; contributions and pension are bound by the 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E), 22.08.2014) and the cap on pensionable salary, with actuarial considerations and fund corpus protections emphasized. The Division Bench order highlighted the need to reconsider Sasikumar P. and reject any course that would erode the fund corpus, while acknowledging the harsh reality of insufficient pension on the current ceiling. The Court ultimately disposes of the appeals in light of the Supreme Court’s Sunil Kumar B. decision (AIR 2022 SC 5634), directing EPFO to re-examine higher pension entitlements consistent with paragraph 44 of Sunil Kumar and related authorities, thereby harmonizing scheme provisions with the latest authoritative guidance and actuarial considerations.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 897 OF 2008

Rajan v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal under Cr. A. No. 897 of 2008, filed before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The appellant Rajan (accused) was found in possession of 5 litres of arrack on 03.06.2004 at Kumbalangad, Vadakkanchery, violating the Abkari Act, leading to a trial and a subsequent conviction by the Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track II Adhoc), Thrissur, for the offence under Section 8(2). The High Court examines whether the prosecution reliably linked the bulk contraband to the sample that was analyzed in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The defense argued gaps in the chain of custody and handling of the sample: Ext.P2 seizure mahazar allegedly lacks seal description; several officials involved in transit were not examined; there was unexplained delay in laboratory analysis. The court scrutinizes Ext.P11 forwarding notes, Ext.P13 Chemical Analysis, and the custody chain, noting the sample changed hands multiple times, and that those responsible for forwarding and maintaining the sample were not examined. Citing Krishnadas v. State of Kerala and other precedents, the court finds that the link between the seized contraband and the analyzed sample is not established, and the lab report alone cannot be decisive. Ultimately, the court allows the appeal, sets aside the conviction and sentence, acquits the accused, and orders his release with any deposited amounts disbursed in due course.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases)

WA 811 of 2020 (and connected writ appeals) – Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and others v Union of India and others

This is a Full Bench decision of the Kerala High Court arising from a cluster of writ petitions challenging the grant of enhanced pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme (EPS) 1995 in the context of the EPFO’s statutory corpus. The petitions contended that pension entitlement should be computed with reference to actual salary and that the 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E)) to EPS 1995 should apply to exempted establishments, allowing higher pension upon regular contributions on actual salary. A Division Bench’s reference order in 2020 tallied Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019) and RC Gupta (2018) to permit remittance of back contributions to base pension on actual salary, arguing corpus erosion would be inevitable. The present Full Bench disagrees with the Sasikumar approach, preferring the Supreme Court’s guidance in Pawan Hans and the Three‑Judge Sunil Kumar B. decision (AIR 2022 SC 5634), which validate the 2014 amendment and direct the fund to avoid erosion and to protect those who contributed regularly. It holds that the correct approach is to apply the amended scheme consistently, extending protections to exempted establishments, and directs EPFO to reconsider higher‑pension entitlements in light of Sunil Kumar B.’s directions. The judgment emphasizes Article 142 authority for extending interim measures and preserving corpus integrity while addressing pension adequacy.”,

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A Nos.2218 & 1687 of 2008

Criminal Appeal Nos. 2218 of 2008 and 1687 of 2008, Aji v State of Kerala; Francis @ Panchi and Bijoy v State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala judgment, delivered by Justice K. Babu, addresses two connected criminal appeals arising from an Abkari Act case involving a large seizure of spirit in 2004. The prosecution claimed that accused Nos. 1–3 were in possession of 1190 litres of spirit, recovered from a Maruthi Omni van and a room, and that samples drawn from the seized liquor were sent to the Chemical Examiner for analysis. The trial court convicted the accused under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act and imposed sentences. The High Court scrutinizes crucial aspects: whether the same samples seized at the scene were those tested in the laboratory, and whether the samples were properly sealed and preserved. It highlights serious procedural deficiencies raised by the appellants, including lack of sealing descriptions, a three-day delay in producing articles before court, and unexplained MO2 bottles in court records. Relying on established authorities (Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Daulat Ram, Narayana Velichappada) the court emphasizes the chain-of-custody requirement and the strict compliance with Section 53A, noting that mere lab reports cannot conclusively prove linkage without proper custody. Ultimately, the court finds the prosecution failed to establish the necessary link and acquits the appellants, allowing the appeals.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 908 of 2008

Rajan v. State of Kerala

Aggrieved by a judgment of the Third Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-I), Thodupuzha dated 07.05.2008 convicting Rajan under Sections 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act for possession of 22 litres of toddy for sale, the appellant preferred this criminal appeal. The High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, heard on 28 October 2022, allowed the appeal and acquitted the accused. The prosecution case rested on the arrest of the accused on 30.04.2003 and seizure of contraband from his premises, followed by laboratory analysis. The defense challenged the validity of the arrest, arguing that arrest memo and arrest intimation were not produced, undermining the chain of custody. It pressed that essential safeguards urged by D.K. Basu regarding arrest memos were not complied with, and that delays in forwarding the seized properties to court and then to the chemical laboratory, plus non-examination of officers who handled the sample, created reasonable doubt about the link between the accused and the contraband. It also relied on Ravi v. State of Kerala to emphasize that production of property before court should be prompt and that unexplained delays erode evidentiary value, and on Daulat Ram and Krishnadas to underscore risks of tampering and delays. As a result, the court held the prosecution failed to prove the arrest, seizure, or laboratory link, and acquitted the appellant.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.24620/2020

PRADEEP V. v. STATE OF KERALA & OTHERS

This writ petition challenges the Government’s rejection of an equivalency claim for a Post Graduate Diploma in Accommodation Operation and Management (PGDAO&M) issued by the National Council for Hotel Management and Catering Technology (NCHMCT) for the post of Junior Instructor in Hospital Housekeeping in the Industrial Training Department. Petitioner Pradeep V, who ranked in the short-list for the post under PSC category No.539/2012 (2017), contends that his PG diploma is equivalent to the Diploma in Hospital Housekeeping prescribed for the post. He sought a writ of certiorari to call for records, and a mandamus to issue an equivalency certificate. The matter has a protracted history: initial rejection by the Director of Industrial Training, remand by this Court in W.P. 28000/2018, Ext P6 GO rejecting the claim, and Appeals culminating in Ext P6’s implementation following directions of the Court. Petitioner argues the Technical Committee (Ext P7) lacked direct technical representation and its conclusions are void ab initio. He relies on Exh P9 to P13 to show overlap between the course content and Hospital Housekeeping. The respondents counter that equivalency hinges on the prescribed diploma and that the competent technical committee’s findings deserve deference; Courts are not to reexamine merits in writ jurisdiction unless irregularities in the proceedings are shown. The Court ultimately declines to scrutinize the merits and dismisses the petition, noting the committee’s findings and lack of appellate jurisdiction, while acknowledging the petitioner’s contentions and the cited apex court authority.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1394 OF 2009

State of Kerala v. T.C. Suresh @ George, C. Selvaraj, P. Suresh @ Suresh Babu

State of Kerala v. T.C. Suresh @ George, C. Selvaraj, and P. Suresh @ Suresh Babu is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal challenging an acquittal in CC 43/2001 by the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kozhikode. The State contends that accused 1 (Secretary of the Attappadi Co-operative Farming Society during 1988–1996) and accused 2 (Agricultural Assistant) abused their official positions, colluding with accused 3 (a contractor) to misappropriate assets of the Society by fabricating and passing bogus invoices totaling Rs. 25,857.50 for electrical materials and thereby obtaining wrongful gain. The trial court had acquitted all three under Section 248(1) CrPC after hearing PW and documentary evidence (PWs 1–19, Exts P1–P26). The State argues that Exts P1(d) and P1(e) show that materials were not delivered to the Society, and that the stock records (Ext. P5) and other evidence establish a conspiracy and misappropriation. The High Court, however, reaffirms the trial court’s view; it relies on established jurisprudence that conspiracy can be proven by direct or circumstantial evidence and that a meeting of minds is essential, but finds no prima facie case of conspiracy and that the trial court’s acquittal is plausible. Citing Bhagwan Swarup Lal Bishan Lal, Zakia Ahsan Jafri, and Chandrappa, the court dismisses the appeal and maintains the acquittals, underscoring the strong presumption of innocence in cases of acquittal.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 29165 & 29210 of 2020

W.P.(C) Nos. 29165 & 29210 of 2020

The two connected writ petitions arise from challenges to the cancellation/withdrawal of community certificates issued under the Kerala (Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificate Act, 1996 and the Rules framed thereunder. The petitions concern the Arakulam Grama Panchayat elections, where the President's post is reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates. The 3rd respondent issued a provisional withdrawal of a community certificate on the ground that the holder had converted to Christianity, and questions were raised about the genuineness of the certificate. The petitioners contend that the act and the rules contemplate issuance and possible cancellation only through a statutory process; a mere withdrawal by an issuing officer is not authorized and violates Section 11 and related provisions. The court examines the scope of the Scrutiny Committee, the possibility of fraud, and the standard required to cancel a certificate, emphasizing that fraud vitiates everything but requires a proper enquiry and opportunity. It cites Vijayan P.S. and several precedents to distinguish between withdrawal and cancellation and to emphasize that cancellation can occur only after due process. The judgment ultimately quashes the withdrawal order Ext.P5 as unsustainable, and directs the Scrutiny Committee to consider the complaint and issue a final decision within two months, keeping the certificate in question valid until a final determination. The petitions are disposed of with costs.