Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 671 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020; 25202/2020; 25209/2020; 25213/2020; 26222/2020; 27386/2020; 22466/2021; 23782/2021; 27795/2021; 29919/2021; 30508/2021; 30564/2021; 30652/2021; 30668/2021; 30679/2021; 7461/2022; 27478/2022; 29383/2022; 35026/2022; 35173/2022; 35231/2022; 35246/2022; 453/2023; 456/2023; 1548/2023; 13827/2023; 16984/2023; 17289/2023; 25635/2023; 25814/2023

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam; W.P.(C) Nos. 2517 of 2020; 25202 of 2020; 25209 of 2020; 25213 of 2020; 26222 of 2020; 27386 of 2020; 22466 of 2021; 23782 of 2021; 27795 of 2021; 29919 of 2021; 30508 of 2021; 30564 of 2021; 30652 of 2021; 30668 of 2021; 30679 of 2021; 7461 of 2022; 27478 of 2022; 29383 of 2022; 35026 of 2022; 35173 of 2022; 35231 of 2022; 35246 of 2022; 453 of 2023; 456 of 2023; 1548 of 2023; 13827 of 2023; 16984 of 2023; 17289 of 2023; 25635 of 2023; 25814 of 2023; (and connected cases)

This batch of writ petitions challenges actions affecting Unit Run Canteens (URCs) run under the Canteen Stores Department (CSD) of the Army, and questions whether URCs fall within the definition of \"the State\" or \"any other authority\" under Article 12 of the Constitution, and thus are amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. The Kerala High Court, with single-judge BASANT BALAJI, examines the creation, finances and control of URCs, relying on the Ajay Hasia framework (Ajay Hasia v Khalid Mujibur Sehravardi) and subsequent authorities to determine State-hood. The court finds that URCs are not created by statute nor financed by Consolidated Fund, operate with regimental non-public funds, and are managed by unit-based SOPs under station headquarters. The decision traverses multiple precedents (Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Sukhdev Singh, Zee Telefilms, Rudani, Layak Ram, Chotelal, RR Pillai, Layak Ram) to conclude URCs are not \'State\' or \'other authority\' within Article 12, and thus writ petitions under Article 226 are not maintainable against URCs. The petitions are dismissed, but liberty is granted to petitioners to pursue remedies under industrial or civil avenues, if available. The judgment emphasizes purposive interpretation of Article 12, and confirms a narrow avenue for writ jurisdiction where private entities perform limited public duties under government-administrative guidance.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 268 of 2017

Majeed C. v. State of Kerala

This appeal arises from the conviction of Majeed C. for a violent, premeditated assault on an eyewitness who had testified against him in a prior murder case. The prosecution examined 13 witnesses and relied on Exts. P1–P17 and several Mahazar documents; the court found that the accused, a life convict, attacked PW1 with a billhook in a public park near a busy bus stand, shouting that he would kill him as he had testified in the earlier case (SC No. 60/1991). PW1 (the injured) and PW2 (an onlooker) testified to the attack; PW10’s medical evidence corroborated the injury, and PW5, PW7–PW9 connected the weapon, blood stains, and the recovery of MO1. The FSL report matched blood on the weapon and on the victim’s clothing. The defense argued that the witnesses were accomplices or interested and that the scientific evidence was unreliable due to seizure timing and color discrepancies in witness descriptions. The court rejected these contentions, noting the consistency of ocular testimony, motive (vengeful prosecution of an earlier case), and corroboration by medical and scientific evidence, including a confession under Section 27 of the Evidence Act and recovery of the weapon. The court ultimately upheld the conviction under Section 324 IPC and maintained the sentence, while explaining that a life-convict’s punishment cannot be mandatorily death under S.303, citing Mithu v. State of Punjab. The appeal was rejected.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 5716 OF 2022

Vipin Mathew and Baburaj C.S v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a writ petition under WP(C) No. 5716 of 2022 filed by Vipin Mathew and Baburaj C.S., who are working as Office Attendants/Peons in N.M. High School, Kariamplave. The petition challenges the rejection of their promotions to the post of Office Attendant/Peon in N.M. High School, Kariamplave and N.M. High School, Kumbanad, on the ground that the schools are uneconomic. The petition asserts that the post of Peon/Office Attendant is a statutory post mandated in the non-teaching cadre under the Kerala Education Rules (KER), and that promotion rights arise under Rule 43 of Chapter XIV A read with Rule 7 of Chapter XXIV B of the KER. It relies on the judgment in Bipin Pavithran v. State of Kerala (2021 (2) KHC 515) and subsequent Division Bench decisions (e.g., Writ Appeal No.1346 of 2021) to contend that uneconomic status cannot override statutory entitlements, and that Government orders cannot curtail the statutory right to regular pay scales. The petition prays for mandamus to approve the promotions, disburse salaries and allowances from appointment dates, and to quash orders Exts. P6 and P7 that denied promotions. The learned Judge ultimately agrees that statutory provisions prevail over circulars and governmental orders, quashes Exts. P6 and P7, and directs the authorities to grant promotion approvals within three months, with salary disbursement within one month, thereby disposing of the writ petition.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 39 of 2022

Saumya M.S. v. State of Kerala & Others (OP(KAT) No. 39 of 2022)

This Original Petition (OP) challenges the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT), Thiruvananthapuram Bench, final order of 5 May 2021 in OA No. 880/2020, which held that a serving government employee who had earlier enrolled as an Advocate and subsequently suspended practice cannot be treated as a “member of the Bar” for appointment as Assistant Public Prosecutor Grade II (APP Gr. II). The petitioner, Saumya M.S., was enrolled as an Advocate in 2007 and suspended her practice in 2012 when she joined government service as a Lower Division Typist in the Excise Department. The Public Service Commission’s notification (Anx. A-1, 30-08-2017) required a Bar membership and not less than three years of active practice in criminal courts as on 1 January 2017. The petitioner argued that suspension does not terminate Bar membership, and enrollment remains valid for eligibility. The Division Bench of the High Court agrees with the Tribunal, holding that once voluntary suspension occurs and employment begins, the person ceases to have the right to practice; hence she cannot be considered a member of the Bar for the purposes of Anx. A-1 and R-4(b) special rules. It relies on the Advocates Act, Bar Council of India Rules, and precedents (Deepak Aggarwal, Amar Sinha, Mahin) to hold that eligibility must persist through the selection process and up to appointment. Consequently, the petition is dismissed and the Tribunal’s decision is upheld.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. Nos. 8/2020, 23/2020, 1663/2020, 1666/2020

Aroon Purie v. State of Kerala & Anil Kumar alias Chenthi Ani (CRL.M.C. Nos. 8/2020, 23/2020, 1663/2020, 1666/2020)

This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A., consolidates four criminal miscellaneous petitions filed by accused persons in CC No.532/2019 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Thiruvananthapuram, challenging proceedings under Sections 499 and 500 IPC (defamation). The petitioners include Aroon Purie (Chairman and Whole Time Director of TV Today Network Ltd.), Ashish Bagga (CEO of Living Media India Ltd.), a senior Aditya Birla Group executive (Chairman and MD of Living Media India Ltd.), and TV Today Network Ltd. The complaint alleges that on 3 August 2017 a news item telecast by TV Today identified a man as the main suspect in a murder, using the complainant’s photograph with a misattribution for several days. The core issue is whether the complaint discloses offences against these petitioners, given the absence of specific allegations tying each accused to the act of publishing or selecting the defamatory material, and whether vicarious liability can attach to corporate officers absent statutory basis. The court surveys several precedents on defamation, vicarious liability, and mens rea—most notably KM Mathew, Maksud Saiyed, S.M.S. Pharmaceuticals, and Mammooti—but ultimately concludes that no offences are disclosed against any petitioner and quashes all proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A.No.1255 of 2007

Prasad and Lal v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (Crl.A. No.1255 of 2007) by two accused, Prasad and Lal, challenging a conviction recorded by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Thodupuzha, in SC No.584 of 2005. The case arises from Murikkassery Police Station Crime No.52 of 2005, where the accused were charged under Sections 8(2) and 55(a) of the Kerala Abkari Act, as well as offences under Section 201 IPC and Rule 22(a) of Road Regulation, 1989 read with Section 177 of the MV Act, for detaining and discarding cans smelling of arrack after their autorickshaw allegedly failed to stop during a police check. The prosecution alleged that on 11.06.2005 at Thopramkudy a police patrol chased the vehicle; two cans were thrown away and the autorickshaw capsized, with the driver fleeing and two passengers (the appellants) allegedly found beneath the vehicle. The trial court convicted the appellants and sentenced them to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and Rs.1,00,000 each for 8(2) Abkari Act, plus one year for 201 IPC, with a default sentence; no separate sentence for 8(2) was imposed. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized crucial evidence, especially PW4 and Exts.P1–P3, and noted serious deficiencies: arrest memos bore crime numbers prior to FIR, ownership of the autorickshaw was not established, and there was no definitive proof that the cans contained arrack. It held the prosecution failed to prove the offences and allowed the appeal, acquitting the appellants of all charges and setting aside the conviction and sentence.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 48/2020 and connected cases

State of Kerala & Others v. Baiju A.A. and Others (Writ Appeals challenging KVAT amendments in the GST era)

This batch judgment from the Kerala High Court deals with writ appeals challenging amendments to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) in the GST era, and the related question of legislative competence after the 2016 Constitution Amendment and KVAT’s repeal. The court examines whether amendments introduced by Kerala Finance Act 2017 (Section 25(1) substitution of ‘five years’ with ‘six years’ and a revised third proviso) and Finance Act 2018 (extended period for reopening assessments) could operate retrospectively or prospectively, particularly for assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12, in the wake of the 2016 Constitution Amendment (Article 246A) and the emergence of the KGST regime. It discusses the constitutional framework, savings clauses, and the interplay between State and Union taxation powers with respect to GST. The judgment surveys a panoply of authorities, including Hajee Abdul Shakoor, Calcutta Discount Co., Jyoti Traders, Baiju A.A, Najeem, Mohit Minerals, and Reliance Industries, to determine whether the amendments could validly extend the limitation for reopening assessments and whether the 2018 amendment to the third proviso has legislative competence. The court ultimately holds that the 2017 amendment is prospective for assessments completed by 31.03.2017, and that the 2018 amendment to the third proviso is unconstitutional for want of legislative competence, resulting in dismissal of the appeals. The decision thereby clarifies the transitional architecture of KVAT amid GST integration.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.9881/2020 & connected cases

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam - WP(C) Nos.9881/2020 & connected cases

This is a consolidated writ petition (and connected matters) challenging Government Orders Ext.P2 (G.O.(Ms) No.16/2020/PWD, 10.02.2020) and Ext.P4 (G.O.(Ms) No.67/2020/PWD, 16.10.2020) which prescribed norms and guidelines for Access Permissions to Fuel Stations along State Highways and Major District Roads. The petitioners include major Oil Marketing Companies (BPCL, HPCL, Indian Oil, Nayara Energy) and individual applicants seeking No Objection Certificates (NOCs) under Rule 144 of the Petroleum Rules, 2002 to establish or operate petroleum outlets. The petition contends that the Petroleum Rules, and the central statutes governing access to highways, are the proper locus for such regulation, and that Ext.P4 Guidelines and the related State norms improperly abridge or substitute those rules, violate Article 14 (fair treatment) and Article 19(1)(g) (right to practice trade), and amount to executive overreach beyond what the Rules contemplate. The State argues Ext.P4 is a valid exercise of executive power backed by Entry 13 and 66 of List II and 35 and 47 of List III, supported by expert committee reports and MoRTH guidelines (IRC 12-2016) subsequently withdrawn by the Centre. The court, after detailed consideration of constitutional frames and statutory schemes, holds that District Authorities cannot base refusals solely on Ext.P2/Ext.P4; retorts that the same are not valid substitutes for statutory access provisions. The judgments emphasize that where statutory rules exist (Petroleum Rules) District Authorities must act within those bounds and the appellate remedies under the relevant Acts remain intact. The petitions are allowed with directions to reconsider NOCs under Rule 144 in light of prevailing rules on the date of each application, within two months, and to set aside Ext.P2 and Ext.P4; other issues kept open.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO.906 OF 2006

Maniyan v. State of Kerala

Maniyan, the second accused in S.C.No.55/2003 on the file of the Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track-III), Thiruvananthapuram, challenges conviction under Section 489D IPC, imposed on 19.04.2006, by the Sessions Court, following a trial in a counterfeit currency case. The prosecution alleged that the accused, along with others, was involved in making and possessing instruments for forging currency. The trial court acquitted accused Nos.1, 2, 4–6 but convicted Maniyan under 489D and sentenced him to five years’ rigorous imprisonment with a Rs.5,000 fine. On 19.07.2022, the Kerala High Court admitted the appeal under Section 374(2) CrPC and heard submissions. The appellant argued that Ext.P6(a) disclosure statement leading to MO2–MO6 recoveries was the sole basis of guilt, the crime was registered in 1987, but he was arrested only in 1993, and key witnesses turned hostile; Ext.P6 was produced belatedly, and there was no corroboration of the recovery. The State contended that PW15’s investigation and the recovery of MO2–MO8 and Ext.P6, along with PW7’s evidence, linked the appellant to the counterfeiting operation. The court scrutinized the essential ingredients of 489D, including possession of instruments, knowledge or belief of their use, and nexus to the alleged offense; ultimately, it found the recovery evidence doubtful and acquitted Maniyan, setting aside the trial court’s verdict and suspending the sentence. The appeal is thus allowed and the conviction annulled.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1684 OF 2007

Biju and Joy v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal under the Abkari Act, challenging a conviction under Section 55(i) by the Additional Sessions Court (Ad hoc)-II, Thodupuzha, in Sessions Case No. 455/2006. The appellants were found in possession of 8.600 litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor at a building in Kanjikuzhy, in violation of the Abkari Act. The trial court convicted them and sentenced them to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh each. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized the prosecution’s chain of custody and the linkage between the seized contraband and the sample analysed in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The appellants argued that the seizure mahazar (Ext. P1) did not describe the seal, the custody of the sample during the interval before analysis (19.03.2004 to 23.03.2004) was unexplained, and the transit personnel who delivered the sample to the laboratory were not examined. Authorities cited Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala and Viswanadhan v. State of Kerala to emphasize tamper-proof seals and chain-of-custody requirements. The Court noted that the Certificate of Chemical Analysis (Ext. P9) had limited evidentiary value since the sample’s tamper-proof provenance could not be established, and there was no proof that the analysed sample originated from the seized contraband. Relying on Sasidharan and Daulat Ram, the Court held the prosecution failed to prove the necessary link beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the conviction is set aside and the accused are acquitted and discharged. The appeal is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1447 of 2007

SREEKUMAR, SREEKALA SADANATHIL vs. STATE OF KERALA

This criminal appeal challenges a 3 July 2007 conviction under Abkari Act Sections 8(1) and 8(2) by the Additional Sessions Judge (Abkari Cases), Kottarakkara, arising from a 13 August 1999 detection of 4 litres of arrack in a jerry can at Keezhvatta Muri, Elamad u Village. PW6, the Assistant Excise Inspector, detected the contraband; the trial court convicted the appellant on circumstantial and documentary evidence. The appellant contends that the detection was by an officer who was not authorised under the Abkari Act at that time (PW6), that the forwarding note for samples was not marked, and that there was an unexplained three‑day delay in producing the contraband before the court. The State disputes these points, arguing that oral and documentary evidence suffice to prove the offence, and submits that later notifications cannot retroactively validate earlier acts. The High Court discusses Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala, Subrahmaniyan v. State of Kerala, and Sasidharan v. State of Kerala to address police/officer empowerment, and Gireesh @ Manoj, Prakasan, Vijayan, and other cases to underscore the evidentiary impact of the forwarding note and delays. It ultimately finds that the lack of proper empowerment and the procedural lacunae undermine the prosecution, and the appeal is allowed, setting aside the conviction and sentence and cancelling any bail bond.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.1244 OF 2020

Gopalakrishnan and Kunjumon v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court decision concerns quashing of proceedings in a crime linked to alleged immoral trafficking violations under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956. Petitioners, Gopalakrishnan (manager) and Kunjumon (owner) of Star Ruksana Hotel, Thiruvananthapuram, are accused in Crime No. 482/2014 (Valiyathura Police Station), now pending as CC No. 1184/2017 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate. The offences alleged involve Sections 3, 4, 5 and 7 of the Act, with the prosecution alleging that the hotel premises were used as a brothel and that the petitioners knowingly facilitated this exploitation. The petitioners contended that mere booking of a room and the presence of the accused at the hotel do not prove the hotel’s status as a brothel or the petitioners’ knowledge or involvement, and that Annexure-IV (final report) contains no admissible evidence to substantiate the charges. The Public Prosecutor urged that the question of involvement is to be decided at trial and that Section 482 Cr.P.C. proceedings are unsuitable for disposition of the matter. The court found that the material does not establish the essential elements of Section 3; statements are confessional in nature and hit by Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act, lacking independent corroboration. Relying on Kunjumon v. State of Kerala, the court held knowledge is essential and mere booking cannot attract Section 3. Accordingly, the petition was allowed and Annexure-IV’s final report, along with all further proceedings in CC 1184/2017 against petitioners, were quashed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.177 of 2010

Rajan v. State of Kerala

Rajan, the appellant, challenged a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for allegedly possessing four litres of arrack on 27.06.2005. The Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Kozhikode, convicted him on the basis of the testimonies of PW1 (Preventive Officer) and PW2 (Excise Guard) and Ext. P1, despite PWs 3 and 4 denying knowledge of the incident and the investigating officer not being examined. The trial record showed seizure of the contraband and sampling, with samples sealed and labelled on the spot. On appeal, this Court noted that the prosecution relied on the legal principle from Tahir v. State (Delhi) and Karamjit Singh v. State (Delhi Administration) to hold that the evidence of PW1 and PW2, corroborated by Ext. P1, sufficed to prove the charge. However, the High Court scrutinized compliance with Sections 50 and 53A of the Abkari Act, emphasizing that seizure, inventory, and production of contraband require the involvement of officers empowered to perform those acts, and the investigating officer’s non-examination created gaps in the chain of evidence. Citing Appu v. State of Kerala, the Court underscored that non-compliance with Section 53A can be fatal to the prosecution if not satisfactorily explained. Ultimately, the Court held that the prosecution failed to establish the required compliance and the conviction could not stand, resulting in acquittal of Rajan.

High Court of Kerala
OP (WAKF) NO.8 OF 2024

OP (WAKF) No. 8 of 2024

This is a Kerala High Court supervisory petition under Article 227 challenging Ext.P8 of the Waqf Tribunal Kozhikode dated 18.01.2024, which allowed I.A.987/2023 in W.O.S. No.103/2022 seeking appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to ascertain certain matters. The petitioners, defendants 1–9 in the Waqf Tribunal suit, contend that the Ext.P8 order is vitiated for lack of reasons and for failing to address the grounds raised; they urge that the order breaches the procedural requirements and the principle of natural justice. The respondents (plaintiffs 1–3 in the Waqf Tribunal suit) support the order, asserting that valid reasons are stated in the supporting affidavit. The High Court refrains from substantial interference absent patent perversity, gross failure of justice, or violation of natural justice, citing Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil and K.V.S. Ram v. Bangalore Metropolitan Transport Corporation to underscore that supervisory intervention must be minimal. The court also reiterates the importance of reasons in administrative decisions, referencing Breen, Alexander Machinery, Gordhandhas Bhanji, Mohinder Singh Gill, Chairman & M.D. United Commercial Bank v. P.C. Kakkar, and others, to emphasize that a decision with no or vague reasons undermines judicial review. The judgment ultimately sets aside Ext.P8 and directs the Waqf Tribunal to pass a reasoned order after hearing both sides within one month, keeping in view the legal and factual contentions.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(Crl.) No.1222/23

W.P.(Crl.) No.1222/23

This Kerala High Court writ petition (criminal) by a wailing mother seeks transfer of the ongoing investigation into her daughter’s death and alleged sexual abuse to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) under Article 226 of the Constitution. The case originated with Crime No. 344/2023 under section 174 Cr.P.C. and later Crime No. 377/2023 before Museum Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, registering offences under IPC sections 376DA, 376E and 377, together with sections 3(a), 3(d), 4(2), 5(i) and section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012. The investigation was entrusted to the District Crime Branch, but the petitioner contends that there has been no breakthrough, several leads remain uninvestigated, and possible involvement of police personnel cannot be ruled out since the child resided in police quarters. The petitioner argues that strong indications exist against certain suspects and that delay jeopardizes evidence. The State and CBI counsel defend the ongoing inquiry as thorough but admit no arrest. Relying on the Supreme Court’s Vishal Tiwari decision, the court holds that the investigation is inadequate and extraordinary circumstances exist to transfer the case to the CBI to restore confidence and deliver justice to the victim and family. The judgment transfers Crime No. 377/2023 to the CBI and directs prompt file transfer and investigation with reporting to the jurisdictional court.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.38290 of 2023 and 38495 of 2023

Sumesh Kumar R v State of Kerala and Travancore Devaswom Board and others

This is a Kerala High Court writ petition (WP(C) Nos. 38290 of 2023 and 38495 of 2023) filed by Sumesh Kumar R challenging an open tender conducted by the Travancore Devaswom Board for certain Kuthaka items (5 and 31) during the Mandala-Makaravilakku season 1199 ME (2023-24) at Sabarimala. The petitioner, who was the second highest bidder for both items (5 and 31), sought a writ of mandamus to be declared the highest bidder or, in the alternative, for a re-tender of the two items. The highest bidder for item 5 was Jayadeep Sasidharan (5th respondent); for item 31 it was the same bidder. The core dispute is whether the 5th respondent’s remittance of bid amounts on 15–16 November 2023 complied with the tender conditions (Ext.P2) and the extended deadline granted by Ext.R2(a). The court examined clause 4 of Ext.P2, which classifies Kuthaka items and prescribes the time-bound remittance regime, including 18% GST and other deposits, and bars remittance from third parties (bearing on RTGS/NEFT/DD). After detailed analysis, the court held that the remittance by the 5th respondent on 16 November 2023 could not be treated as within the extended time for item 5, and accordingly allowed the petitioner’s challenge in WP(C) No.38290 of 2023 with respect to item 5, directing re-tendering for the remaining period up to 31 October 2024. The court disposed of WP(C) No.38495 of 2023 with respect to item 31 and directed audit by the Kerala State Audit Department (DBAR) and related records verification, while noting certain evidentiary constraints. The judgment emphasizes public interest and compliance with tender terms, and orders further action including re-tender, audit, and record verification.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1814 OF 2024

K.S. Sanjeev v. State of Kerala and The Manager, Canara Bank

K.S. Sanjeev, the second accused in Crime No.178/2024 of Arthungal Police Station, Alappuzha, filed Bail Application under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam. The prosecution alleges theft of movable property after the Canara Bank, the secured creditor, invoked the SARFAESI Act and took possession; the movable property allegedly belonged to the petitioner, while the immovable asset is claimed by the bank. The petitioner contends that the FIR lacks incriminating materials against him and that, per Annexure A1, only immovable property was mortgaged to the bank, with the movable property in his possession, so Section 379 IPC would not be attracted. He asserts custodial interrogation is unnecessary and seeks pre-arrest bail on exceptional grounds. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing ongoing investigation and potential interference; the bank’s counsel also contends custodial interrogation and recoveries are necessary. On 3 April 2024, it was stated that the movable property does not form part of the secured asset under the loan agreement. After evaluating the materials, the court found that only the immovable property was mortgaged and held that, prima facie, the offence under Section 379 IPC may not lie against him, though this is a matter for trial. The court granted pre-arrest bail, subject to conditions including surrender within 10 days, bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, appearance for interrogation, non-inducement, passport surrender, and prohibition from other offences; observations are not merits-based. It cites Sushila Aggarwal for guidance on bail conditions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1752 OF 2024

Manoj v. State of Kerala

Manoj, the second accused in Crime No. 234/2024 of the Chathannur Police Station, Kollam, moves for pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in a case in which twelve persons are charged with offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324 and 307 read with Section 149. The prosecution alleges that on 26 February 2024, in furtherance of their common intention, the accused formed an unlawful assembly, restrained the injured person, and assaulted him; the first accused allegedly inflicted stabbing injuries, with the second and third accused also injuring the victim along with others. The petitioner claims innocence and asserts he was falsely implicated because his brother is the first accused. He submits that, as per the First Information Report, there is no overt act attributable to him and that Section 307 IPC cannot lie against him; custodial interrogation is unnecessary and no recovery is contemplated. The Public Prosecutor contends there is a specific overt act against him and that arrest is necessary to secure custodial interrogation and prevent tampering with evidence, citing medical records of the injured. The court relies on Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre and Sibbia to emphasize that anticipatory bail should not be granted by rigid guidelines and must be decided on facts with caution. Ultimately, the court finds an overt act attributed to the petitioner and declines anticipatory bail, dismissing the application, but directs surrender within ten days for possible revival on merits.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1772 OF 2024

Jayesh M. M v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court heard Bail Application No. 1772 of 2024 on 12 June 2024 in relation to Crime No. 1356/2023 of Alakode Police Station, Kannur, involving the sole accused Jayesh M. M, charged with murder under IPC Section 302. The prosecution alleges that on 13 November 2023, driven by a grudge over the deceased's alleged extramarital relationship with the accused's estranged wife, the accused stabbed the deceased in the chest, resulting in death. The petitioner has been in judicial custody since 14 November 2023; the investigation was completed and the final report laid on 9 February 2024. The petitioner maintains his innocence, arguing there is no material establishing his involvement and claiming the case is a product of animosity, with his estranged wife also facing a separate case under IPC Section 498A (Crime No. 1047/2023). The prosecution opposes bail, contending risk of witness intimidation and tampering with evidence. The court acknowledges the strained marital relationship and the absence of prior criminal antecedents beyond two related cases, but notes that the investigation is complete. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., State of Kerala v. Raneef, Hussainara Khatoon (I), and Sushila Aggarwal, the judge reiterates the presumption of innocence and the bail-general-rule principle, ultimately allowing bail with stringent conditions (bond Rs. 1 lakh with two sureties, reporting requirements, travel restrictions, and other safeguards).

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.1723 OF 2024

H.A. Sidddiq and Aneesh v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court bail application under Section 438 CrPC concerns accused Nos. 3 and 4, H.A. Sidddiq and Aneesh, in O.R No.10/2023 of Mupliyam Forest Station, Thrissur, registered for offences under Sections 47G and 47H of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961, arising from alleged sandalwood tree cutting on land belonging to Saju in Kodakara Grama Panchayat within Mupliyam Forest Range. The crux of the prosecution rests on a confession attributed to the first accused, which would implicate the petitioners. The petitioners contend that the confession is inadmissible and a nullity because it was recorded by forest officers not empowered under Section 72 of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961, relying on Luca Beltrami and Others v. State of Kerala (2020 (4) KHC 603), Prakashan v. State of Kerala (2023 (1) KHC 536), and Gopi v. State of Kerala (2024 KHC 18). The State opposes bail, arguing the confession is admissible, that the petitioners have criminal antecedents, and that custodial interrogation is necessary for investigation. The court analyzes the statutory provisions and precedents, emphasizing that confessions recorded by officers not empowered under Section 72 are illegal and void, and that exceptional grounds justify invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction under Section 438. Accordingly, the court grants pre-arrest bail to the petitioners subject to stringent conditions, including surrender, bond, cooperation with investigation, non-interference with witnesses, and other standard bail conditions, with directions for production before the jurisdictional court as required.