Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 670 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
R.C.(Rev) No.65 of 2024

Chethil Tharemmal Rasheeda v. Peedikayilakath Muhammad

This Rent Control revision challenges concurrent eviction orders under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, arising from a landlord’s prayer to evict the tenant from the petition schedule shop on the ground of bona fide need to commence business for fancy and cosmetic items. The Rent Control Court, Payyoli, allowed eviction under Section 11(3) on 02.02.2022. The Rent Control Appellate Authority, Kozhikode, in RCA 68 of 2022, upheld that order on 12.12.2023. The revision petitioner contends that the findings are illegal, irregular and improper, while the landlord’s case rests on evidence showing a genuine need to occupy the premises for a business. The court notes the rental arrangement is undisputed and that the arrears, as calculated, were remitted by the tenant; consequently the eviction under Section 11(2)(b) was not pursued. The judgment cites several decisions emphasizing that bona fide need must be sincere, real, and not a pretext, and that the onus to prove provisos to Section 11(3) lies with the tenant. It reiterates that once the landlord demonstrates a natural, real, sincere and honest need, eviction under Section 11(3) is permissible, subject to the provisos. Ultimately, the court dismisses the revision but grants five months for the tenant to vacate, subject to conditions including an unconditional affidavit, arrears deposit, and no third-party possession during the period.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 3340 OF 2018

Moncy Daniel v. State of Kerala and Sussan

Moncy Daniel, the second accused in Crime No. 259/2009 of Kattappana Police Station, moves the Kerala High Court for quashing all further proceedings in LP No.3/2017 (C.C.847/2015) before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Idukki, arising from the same crime. The prosecution case alleged that on 15-04-2009 the accused, along with her husband (accused No.1), trespassed into the 2nd respondent’s property and the 1st accused assaulted the de facto complainant with a knife; the trial court registered C.C.290/2011, examined PW1–PW9, marked Exhibits P1–P3 and D1–D7, and convicted the husband under IPC 323 and 324. The 1st accused’s conviction was reversed in CrL.A. No.7/2016 with acquittal by the IIIrd Addl. Sessions Judge, Thodupuzha. The case against the petitioner was split up and re-numbered as C.C.No.847/2015 and is pending as LP No.3/2017. The petitioner argues that Annexure-AIII (the appellate judgment) contains adverse observations about the prosecution’s evidence, so the substratum of the case is lost; relying on Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police (2006 KHC 184), she seeks quashing under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The State opposes. The High Court, scrutinising Annexure-AIII and core evidence, finds the key witnesses unreliable or planted and the place of occurrence uncertain, concluding the substratum is lost. Following Moosa, the court allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes the proceedings against the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
ARB.A NO.28 OF 2023

Alexander Luke v. Aditya Birla Money Ltd

This arbitration appeal questions whether a Commercial Court order under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is appealable to the Kerala High Court. The appellant, Alexander Luke, invested in securities through M/S Aditya Birla Money Ltd, a trading member of NSE, and sought Rs 2 crore in damages. After NSE’s Investor Grievance Redressal Proceedings (IGRP) were closed in 2016, Luke escalated the matter to SEBI, which directed IGRB to re-examine the complaints. An arbitration award was issued on a split verdict; the Appellate Tribunal panel later found Luke entitled to Rs 7,29,58,796 with interest of 6%. Aditya Birla Money Ltd filed OP(Arb) No.8/2022 before the Commercial Court, Kollam, which on 27.09.2023 set aside the award on grounds of limitation and alleged patent illegality, contradicting public policy. Luke challenged the Commercial Court’s order by filing ARB.A No.28 of 2023 in this Court. The core issue is whether the appeal lies here under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act or before the Commercial Appellate Court under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The respondents insist the dispute is “commercial” and governed by the CTA, while the appellant argues for the A&C Act’s appeal route. After considering statutory language and case law, the High Court held that the CTA governs and the proper forum is the Commercial Appellate Court (District Court). The Registry was directed to return the appeal to the appropriate forum, reflecting the plain language and the later statute’s scheme, and rejecting the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s contrary view.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.8846 of 2024

Anil Joe Paul v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Fort Kochi and Agricultural Officer, Kalady

Anil Joe Paul, the petitioner, challenges Ext.P4, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer denying removal of his land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. He owns 1.38 acres of land in Re-Sy.No.39/3-2-3, Block No.27, Mattur Village, Aluva Taluk, Ernakulam District. He contends the land does not fall within paddy land or wetland as defined by the Act and is wrongly included in the Data Bank based on pre-2001 notes. He filed Form 5 seeking deletion. Ext.P4 records that the LLMC's inquiry and the Agricultural Officer’s report concluded that complete conversion prior to 2008 could not be presumed, and hence the lands should not be removed. The petitioner argues that the RDO failed to independently assess the land; no direct field inspection was conducted; no verification from KSRSEC was obtained; The Rules, especially Rule 4(4E) and 4(4F), require independent verification and possible satellite imagery. The court is urged to apply the principles laid down in Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala and Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, which compel consideration of whether the land was paddy land on the Act’s date and whether paddy cultivation remains feasible. The petition seeks remand for an independent assessment and a decision based on Rule 4(4F), with KSRSEC input, within two months. It also seeks to ensure that the decision is not merely a reiteration of LLMC conclusions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1914 OF 2024

Prabhul K.P. v. State of Kerala

This bail application before the Kerala High Court is filed by Prabhul K.P., the first accused in Crime No.1275/2023 of Meenangadi Police Station, Meenangadi, Wayanad, under Section 439 CrPC. The FIR alleges that on 7 December 2023, around 8:30 PM, the accused and others, in furtherance of a common intention to commit dacoity, blocked the de facto complainant’s car, presented themselves as police officials, abducted the occupants, assaulted them, and robbed Rs. 20,00,000 from the vehicle. The petitioner contends total innocence, a false implication, and argues that Sections 365 and 395 IPC are not attracted; he has been in judicial custody since 22 January 2024, exceeding 60 days, and the investigation remains incomplete with no final report. He seeks statutory bail under Sec. 439 CrPC. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, opposes bail, highlighting criminal antecedents and connections to other crimes (Crime Nos. 920/2015 and 2/2020) under Sections 338 and 308 IPC, ongoing investigation, and the risk of tampering with evidence or witness intimidation if released. The court cites Supreme Court bail principles from Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, and Ash Mohammad, emphasizing factors like prima facie case, gravity of the offence, punishment, likelihood of absconding, and societal impact. After careful consideration, the court finds the balance unfavourable to bail at this stage and dismisses the application.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 38281 OF 2018

O.T. Alexander v. General Secretary, Industrial Complex Labour Union (INTUC) and Labour Court, Ernakulam

This writ petition challenges a Labour Court preliminary award in I.D. No.22 of 2016 dated 08.08.2018, which set aside the domestic enquiry conducted against the petitioner on grounds of violation of principles of natural justice. The petitioner contends that the issue falls under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution and should be entertainable in a writ petition. The respondent Labour Court’s order and the related enquiry record are central to this dispute, including the sequence of show-cause notices, the appointment of an Enquiry Officer, the charge sheet, and subsequent inquiry proceedings. The thrust of the court’s reasoning, however, relies on a binding precedent: Chelamattom Sree Krishna Swami Devaswom Trust v. State of Kerala and Others (2022(4) KHC 215), where a Division Bench held that a preliminary Labour Court award cannot be challenged in a writ petition under Articles 226/227. The Court had already issued an interim order on 26.11.2018 suspending the preliminary award, but in light of the supra Division Bench judgment, the writ petition is considered to be liable for dismissal. Consequently, the petition is dismissed and the challenge to the preliminary award repelled. Exhibit materials in the appendix detail the exhibit chronology surrounding the enquiry process initiated by the management and the delinquencies of the officer involved.

High Court of Kerala
BA No. 1883 of 2024

Shibin.S v. State of Kerala

Shibin.S, the seventh accused in Crime No.164/2024 of Kadakkavoor Police Station, seeks anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The eight-accused case concerns a February 22, 2024 incident in which the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly, wrongfully restrained the defacto complainant and his friend, abducted them in an autorickshaw belonging to the seventh accused, manhandled them, and inflicted grievous injuries. The offences charged include sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 363 and 308 read with Section 149 IPC. The petitioner maintains his innocence, contending there is no specific overt act attributable to him and that the addition of sections 363 and 308 is an attempt by the investigating officer to deny bail. He stresses he has no criminal antecedents, is ready to cooperate, and is willing to comply with stringent conditions if necessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes the application, arguing that the complainant and his friend were abducted from the scene in an autorickshaw linked to the seventh accused; there is a specific overt act alleged against him; the petitioner’s prior antecedents in 2015 and 2023 justify custodial interrogation and recovery, and granting bail would hamper the investigation. The court references Supreme Court jurisprudence on bail, including Srikant Upadhyay, HDFC Bank Ltd. v. J.J.Mannan, and Jai Prakash Singh, to reiterate that anticipatory bail is extraordinary and to be granted only in exceptional circumstances. After careful consideration, the court dismisses the bail application, but offers a conditional path: surrender within 10 days for interrogation and potential merits-based bail thereafter; failure to surrender permits arrest.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.2322 of 2024

CRL.MC No. 2322 of 2024

This is a criminal miscellaneous case under section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court, relating to nine accused (A1–A9) in Crime No. 9/2016 of Anchalummoodu Police Station, Kollam, arising from SC No. 65/2017. The offences alleged include 143, 147, 148, 294(b), 323, 341, 324 and 308 read with 149 IPC. The petitioners seek quashing of the criminal proceedings on the ground that the parties have resolved their dispute and do not wish to pursue the prosecution. The State, through the Public Prosecutor, expresses reservations but concedes that the matter is settled. The court cites State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, and reliance on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) (10) SCC 303 and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) (6) SCC 466, to articulate the scope of its power under Section 482 to quash non‑compoundable offences in private settlements. It emphasizes factors such as the private nature of the dispute, the absence of serious societal impact, and the need to consider antecedents of the accused. After reviewing the records and affidavits, the court holds that the dispute is private and can be settled, and accordingly allows the CRL.MC and quashes all further proceedings in SC No.65/2017 arising from Crime No.9/2016.

High Court of Kerala
2517/2020; 25202/2020; 25209/2020; 25213/2020; 26222/2020; 27386/2020; 22466/2021; 23782/2021; 27795/2021; 29919/2021; 30508/2021; 30564/2021; 30652/2021; 30668/2021; 30679/2021; 7461/2022; 27478/2022; 29383/2022; 35026/2022; 35173/2022; 35231/2022; 35246/2022; 453/2023; 456/2023; 1548/2023; 13827/2023; 16984/2023; 17289/2023; 25635/2023; 25814/2023

WP(C) Nos.2517/2020 and connected petitions before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This batch of writ petitions concerns the status and remedies of personnel employed in Unit Run Canteens (URCs) run under the Canteen Stores Department (CSD) of the Indian Army. Petitioners, largely ex-servicemen, dependents, or contractual staff of URCs across multiple stations in Kerala, challenge amendments (and related actions) affecting their employment and seek writ relief. The core issue is whether URCs constitute “the State” or “another authority” under Article 12 of the Constitution, making them amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. The court embarks on a constitutional- and public-law analysis, applying the Ajay Hasia framework (creation, finance, and control) and then considering broader authorities jurisprudence (Andi Mukta, Rudani, Zee Telefilms, Sukhdev Singh, Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Layak Ram, etc.). It notes URCs are created by Army orders (AO/19/2003/QMG), financed by regimental non-public funds rather than the Consolidated Fund, and operated under SOPs framed by URC management with staffing by unit authorities rather than CSD or the Ministry of Defence. The court concludes that URCs do not satisfy the classic tests of “State” or “other authority” under Article 12; there is no deep and pervasive State control, nor direct funding, and staff are contracted or unit-based. Accordingly, the petitions are dismissed, though liberty is granted to petitioners to pursue other remedies (e.g., industrial disputes) if desired.

High Court of Kerala
CRP Nos. 492 and 627 of 2017

Moideen v. Omanadas

Moideen, the revision petitioner in CRP Nos. 492 and 627 of 2017, challenges a common order dismissing two execution applications (EA Nos. 390 of 2008 and 425 of 2011) in execution proceedings arising from O.S. Nos. 179 of 2005 and 212 of 2004 before the Munsiff Court, Ottapalam. The facts trace a property saga wherein Moideen entered into a sale agreement with Ramadevi and her sons, paid part of the consideration, and obtained possession but was not given the sale deed. A compromise decree for specific performance was recorded in 2005. Subsequently, a collusive suit in O.S.212/2004 was decreed in 2004, and the first respondent purchased the property in execution, delivering possession in 2006. Moideen moved execution applications under Order XXI Rules 97/99 to remove obstruction and reinstate possession; these were dismissed on grounds of limitation. He argues maintainability under Rule 99, citing authorities such as Saviour v. E.V. Mathai and Full Bench authorities including Danish Varghese v. Jancy Danish to support the proposition that actual possession need not precede an application under Rule 99 and that an immediate remedy lies in execution rather than a separate suit. The respondents contend revision is not maintainable under Order XXI Rule 103 and that the order is effectively a decree. The Kerala High Court, while discussing adjudication under Order XXI and the interplay of Rules 97–99, 58, and 103, ultimately dismisses the revisions. The decision emphasizes limitation and non-maintainability of the revision petitions and upholds the executing court’s orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & con.cases

WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The Kerala High Court, in a consolidated hearing on 26 March 2024 before Justice T. R. Ravi, dealt with a batch of writ petitions challenging the freezing of bank accounts by cybercrime authorities on police intimation across multiple states. Petitioners include individuals and financial/institutional entities whose accounts were blocked amid cyber fraud probes. The Court acknowledged that freezing measures are sometimes necessary to preserve proceeds of crime, but emphasized proportionality and due process. It issued interim directions restricting freezes to the exact amount in dispute as per police requisitions, directing banks to preserve the rest of the funds and allow normal transactions, and required the police to inform banks of the duration for which freezing should continue. The court relied on a precedent in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) to justify these directions and cited a prior order in W.P.(C) No. 28155/2023. The petitions were disposed of with directions to implement the described framework, preserving petitioners’ rights to approach the court again if information or timelines were not provided. The decision aims to balance anti-crime measures with protection of legitimate funds and corporate/commercial activity during ongoing investigations.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.811 of 2020 (and connected cases)

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam – WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases) – Employees Provident Fund Organisation v Union of India and others

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment rendered on 25 February 2020 by a learned Single Judge in WP(C) 2019–2019 and connected matters concerning entitlement to pension under the Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995, in exempted establishments and the computation of pension on actual salary versus maximum pensionable salary. The Division Bench had referred the matter to a Full Bench for reconsideration of Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 Ker 614) in light of the EPS amendments and subsequent Supreme Court decisions. The core issue is whether pension under the contributory EPS 1995 can be calculated with reference to actual salary when employees in exempted establishments contributed at the actual salary rate, and whether the 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E)) should be read down or extended to exempted establishments. The Full Bench notes the evolving jurisprudence, including Pawan Hans and the three‑judge Sunil Kumar decision (AIR 2022 SC 5634), and concludes that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration; it ultimately disposes of the appeals by directing EPFO to reconsider entitlement for higher pension in light of the Sunil Kumar decision, with directions for actuarial valuation and possible adjustments by the Central Government. The judgment affirms that the corpus must be preserved while ensuring just pension outcomes within the amended framework.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam – WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases (consolidated).

This is a consolidated judgment of the Kerala High Court, delivered on 26 March 2024 by Justice T. R. Ravi, disposing a batch of WP(C) petitions challenging freezing of bank accounts under cybercrime investigations and the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal. Petitioners include individuals and corporate entities whose accounts were frozen by police/intimation notices, with banks also named as respondents. The Court acknowledges the need to preserve proceeds of crime but holds that freezing should be confined to the exact amounts mentioned in police requisitions and intimations. The judgment draws on existing guidance from Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), extracting para.12 to endorse a proportionality-based approach to freezes, and directs respondent banks to limit freezing to the specified amounts, allowing operations beyond those amounts and mandating police to specify a time-frame for the freeze and notify banks accordingly. It cites prior orders, including W.P.(C) 28155/2023, and emphasizes that any continued freeze must be justified and not disproportionately impair legitimate trade and livelihood. The petitions are disposed of with directions to implement these principles, while preserving petitioners’ rights to return for further relief if required. The judgment thus advances a balanced framework for freezing assets in cybercrime cases, aligning investigative prerogatives with civil-liberties concerns.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020

WA 811 of 2020 and connected matters (Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation v Union of India and others)

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment dated 25 February 2020 rendered by a learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 3846 of 2019 and connected petitions, concerning pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995 and its interaction with the contributory pension regime. The court had held that pension can be calculated without reference to a ceiling, if higher salary contributions are remitted to the pension fund, following Sasikumar P. and the Supreme Court’s guidance in RC Gupta and Sunil Kumar B. The Division Bench later noted that Sasikumar P. required reconsideration in light of the 2014 amendment to the pension scheme (G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22.08.2014) and its implications for exempted and covered establishments. The Full Bench ultimately disposed of the appeals by applying the Sunil Kumar B. framework, directing the Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) to reconsider entitlement to higher pension in accordance with the Supreme Court’s decision in Sunil Kumar B. and related authorities (para. 44). It refused to undermine the corpus growth or erosion while acknowledging that a subset of pensioners may require reconsideration under post-2014 provisions. The judgment emphasizes actuarial adequacy, central government guidance, and a cautious approach to adjust pension calculation in line with the 2014 amendments, and directs EPFO to re-evaluate higher pension claims within those limits.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1778 OF 2024

Ajad Biswas and Shahid Alam Biswas v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC before the Kerala High Court by two accused in Crime No.113/2024 of Palakkad Town South Police Station. The petitioners were arrested on 21 January 2024 and are accused of offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)(B) and 29 of the NDPS Act for allegedly possessing 14.355 kilograms of ganja from a bus at Kazchaparambu, Palakkad. The applicants contend they are falsely implicated and maintain their innocence. They have been in judicial custody since 21 January 2024, the contraband is described as an intermediate quantity, and the investigation is reportedly practically complete with recovery effected. The public prosecutor opposes bail, arguing the petitioners hail from West Bengal with no roots in Kerala, raising the likelihood of flight if enlarged on bail; however, he concedes the contraband quantity is intermediate and that the petitioners have no criminal antecedents. After considering the materials, the court finds detention unnecessary and, while allowing bail, imposes stringent conditions to ensure appearance and prevent tampering with evidence. The order relies on Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar (1980) SCC 98 and Sushila Aggarwal v. State of Delhi (as cited) to justify liberty with conditions. The bail bond is fixed at Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, and conditions include regular IO appearances, no tampering, passport surrender, and restrictions on travel within Kerala, among others.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No. 33 of 2024

MOHANDASAN v. PUSHPAVENI AMMA (DIED) and others

This is a Kerala High Court appeal (FAO No. 33 of 2024) arising from an order in I.A.(RP) No.1623 of 2021 in O.S. No.38 of 2018, a suit for partition. The appellant-plaintiff Mohandasan contends that the trial court erred in dismissing his restoration application for default on 5 October 2021. He attributes the non-appearance to sufficient cause (ill health and his daughter's accident) and seeks restoration within the statutory period. The Additional Sub Court Palakkad had dismissed the restoration application with costs on 21 November 2023, holding that no medical records were produced to prove the claimed illness. The High Court, considering principles from several judgments (notably G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada; M. Shivananda; Peeves Enterprises v. Muhammed Ashraf), allows the appeal, holding that sufficient cause can be liberally construed and that the rule governing restoration can be equitably applied. The Court sets aside the impugned order on payment of Rs. 5,000 to the 5th respondent, restores O.S. No.38/2018 to file, and directs the Sub Court to proceed with the suit and dispose of it expeditiously within five months. Annexure 1 discloses a discharge summary dated 21.09.2021 related to the daughter’s accident.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 30318/2019

P.A. Jose v Union of India and Others (WP(C) Nos. 30318/2019, 1529/2024, 17949/2020, 17828/2020, 17964/2020, 17972/2020, 28444/2021, 29846/2021, 30448/2021, 30354/2019, 30340/2019, 30373/2019, 32237/2019) and connected cases

This batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court challenges the Notification Nos. 87/2016 and 88/2016, and Circular No. 10/2017, which introduced and clarified Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS) under Section 145(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The principal controversy concerns Clause 16 of ICDS II, which mandates that stock/inventory be valued using FIFO or weighted average cost, thereby overriding the taxpayer’s prior practice of LIFO. Petitioners argue that this retroactive imposition (via Section 145A substituted by Finance Act 2018 with retrospective effect from 1.4.2017) alters basic accounting principles and overruns binding judicial precedents, violating Articles 14 and 265 of the Constitution. The Delhi High Court’s Chamber of Tax Consultants decision and various precedents are discussed to illustrate the policy and constitutional constraints on delegated accounting standards. The respondents contend that the ICDS framework, adopted after extensive consultation and consolidated under Section 145A, seeks uniformity in tax computation. The judgment, pronounced by a Single Judge, partly allows the petitions, holding that opening and closing stock cannot be valued under two different methodologies for AY 2017-18; instead, the department must accept either consistent LIFO for both opening and closing stock or permit FIFO/weighted average for both, with notices quashed and interim orders closed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.8467/2024

Federal Bank Ltd. v. Sub Registrar, Kottayam-Kumali Road, Collectorate Kottayam, Village Officer Thirunakkara, Sebastian Xavier Bhagavath Paramppuzha Karappuzha and Philip George Padamattumel

The Federal Bank Ltd. filed a writ petition in the Kerala High Court seeking a declaration that a sale agreement executed after the Ext.P1 mortgage is non-existent in the wake of Ext.P5 sale notification under Section 13(8) of the SARFAESI Act (as amended) and to compel registration of Ext.P6 Sale Certificate by removing the entry of Ext.P3 Encumbrance Certificate. The bank had extended two cash credit facilities to M/s. BB Agencies secured by a mortgage on property in Re-survey No.43 (old 136/B) in Kottayam taluk, created on 30.07.2017, and possession was taken on 22.06.2022 under Section 14 SARFAESI. A sale was conducted and the property sold by auction to the 4th respondent. When the petitioning bank sought registration, the Sub Registrar refused citing an existing court attachment reflected in Ext.P3. The petitioner relied on Celir LLP v. Bafna Motors (Mumbai) Private Limited (2023 KHC 6860) to assert SARFAESI’s overriding effect over general laws, including the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and on Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar, Kollam (2014 (1) KLT 406) and Kerala State Financial Enterprises Ltd. v. Meenachil (2004 (3) KLT 369) to argue that attachments after mortgage do not defeat mortgagee rights. The court ultimately held that post-mortgage entries such as the sale agreement cannot prejudice the mortgagee and directed registration of Ext.P6 within one month after removing Ext.P3’s entry, disposing of the writ petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8339 OF 2024

Thomas v. State of Kerala & Others

The petitioner, Thomas, owner of 6 Ares 7 square metres of land at Wadakkanchery, Thrissur District, challenges Ext.P5, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting his Form 5 application to remove his land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 (Act, 2008) and its Rules. He asserts the land is not a paddy land or wetland as defined and argues the data bank listing is erroneous. The RDO relied solely on an Agricultural Officer’s report, without an independent assessment of the land’s status as on the date of coming into force of the Act. The petitioner contends that Rule 4(4E) requires a report from the Agricultural Officer in paddy lands and Rule 4(4F) permits verification via satellite or field inspection if necessary; hence Ext.P5 is vitiated by non-application of mind and inconsistent with binding precedents. The judgment cites Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Adani Infrastructures, Mather Nagar Residents Association, and Sudheesh v. RDO to emphasize that the RDO must independently assess land status and determine whether removal from the Data Bank would affect paddy cultivation or wetlands. The court ultimately sets aside Ext.P5 and directs the RDO to reconsider Ext.P4 in light of KSRSEC reports, with timelines, and to require the petitioner to obtain the KSRSEC report, disposing of the writ petition with directions.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected WAs)

Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) v Union of India and others (Writ Appeals)

These writ appeals arising from W.P.C Nos. 3846 of 2019 and connected petitions concern the computation of pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995 (EPS 1995), including whether pensionable salary for calculation should be based on actual salary or the statutory maximum pensionable salary. The Kerala High Court, after a reference order by a Division Bench, referred to several earlier decisions (Sasikumar P., RC Gupta, Pawan Hans) and to three-judge-SC decisions (Sunil Kumar B. and others) to resolve a critical issue: whether the 2014 amendment to EPS (GSR 609(E)) could be read down to allow higher pension for those who contributed on actual salary, and the impact on the corpus when exempted establishments and other entities remitted pension contributions. The Full Bench ultimately aligns with the line laid down by the Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar and related cases, directing EPFO to reconsider entitlement to higher pension and extending time for such reconsideration. It notes Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration, reads RC Gupta favorably, and relies on Pawan Hans and the Sunil Kumar judgment. The matter was disposed of by a directions-based disposal to ensure actuarial and corpus considerations are balanced with workers’ pension expectations.