Vishnu, the first accused in Crime No. 117/2024 of the Anchalummoodu Police Station, Kollam, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC before a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The charges include offences under Sections 294(b), 323, 324, 447 and 302 read with Section 34 IPC, with Vishnu arrested on 29.01.2024. The prosecution case relates to an incident on 27.01.2024 at around 01:00 hours, when the accused, in concert with others, trespassed into the courtyard of the defacto complainant Sreejith’s residence, uttered obscene words, and assaulted him with an iron rod. The defacto complainant’s brother-in-law intervened; accused 3 and 4 attacked him; the defacto complainant’s brother Mohanan Pillai (deceased) tried to help and was kicked down; the second accused stamped him, resulting in fatal injuries. The fifth accused allegedly abused. Vishnu disputes the allegations, contending there is no specific overt act attributable to him and that the 302 offence is attributable to the second accused only. He has remained in custody since 29.01.2024 and the investigation, as far as Vishnu is concerned, is practically complete; thus further detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor concedes lack of a specific overt act against Vishnu, and the court notes that the core overt act is attributed to the second accused. Relying on Supreme Court precedents emphasizing presumption of innocence and bail as a rule, the court grants bail subject to stringent conditions, directing bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, and imposing conditions on appearance, non-inducement, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, territorial limits, and potential cancellation on breach, while allowing continued investigation if necessary. The application is allowed.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2434 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by accused 1 to 7 in Crime No.160/2024 of Pattambi Police Station, Palakkad, before the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam. The petition, titled B.A. No.2434 of 2024, seeks bail in a matter alleging offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, and 308 read with 149, as well as Section 118(e) of the Kerala Police Act, 2011 and Section 11(1)(a) of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960. The accused were arrested on 4.3.2024 and their custodial detention extended in the present crime on 12.3.2024; 13 co-accused are noted in the case. The prosecution claims common intent among the accused, an unlawful assembly with dangerous weapons, and assault on the commandos during a parade near Krishi Bhavan, Pattambi. The petitioners contend innocence, false implication, and that inclusion of the 308 IPC and 118(e) Kerala Police Act offences was a strategic move to deny bail. They point out that investigation is virtually complete, recoveries have been made, and they have already been enlarged on bail in a connected crime. The Public Prosecutor acknowledges custody since 4.3.2024 and that connected-crime bail has been granted, but the court ultimately considers the overall facts, past record, and the late stage of investigation to grant bail with stringent conditions, citing presumption of innocence and the general bail principle.
This bail application before the Kerala High Court concerns five petitioners accused in Crime No. 181/2024 of North Paravur Police Station. The accused face offences under sections 143, 144, 147, 323, 341, 324, 294(b), 307 and 506 read with 149 IPC, arising from an alleged unlawful assembly near Thonniakavu temple on 20 February 2024, during which the complainant and others were assaulted. The prosecution claims enmity due to a pending case and asserts that the accused formed an unlawful assembly to prosecute the common object, resulting in multiple injuries to the complainant and bystanders. The petitioners seek protection under Section 438 Cr.P.C. with their bail; counsel for the petitioners points to a connected case, B.A. No. 2413/2024, in which bail was granted, and states that the matter is settled with affidavits from victims. However, the court notes that Section 307 is involved and that affidavits cannot be accepted at face value in such circumstances; nonetheless, after considering that there is a case and counter case, the court concludes that bail can be granted subject to stringent conditions. Citing the Supreme Court’s Chidambaram decision on bail as a rule rather than an exception, and guidance from Sushila Aggarwal on appropriate bail conditions, the judge grants bail with specific directions: cooperation with investigation, appearance within ten days, bond of Rs. 50,000 with two sureties, no travel abroad without permission, avoidance of further offences, and the court’s authority to cancel bail if conditions are violated.
Remesh Babu, the appellant, was convicted under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Additional District & Sessions Judge (Adhoc) I, Kollam, for possessing 750 ml of arrack at Veliyil Mukku, Kochalumood junction, Karunagappally. He was sentenced to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 with a default period of six months’ simple imprisonment. On appeal, the appellant, represented by Adv. Dileep P. Pillai with Amicus Curiae Jinu Antony, challenged the conviction on grounds that Ext. P8 forwarding note lacked a seal and did not indicate the person who forwarded the sample to the Chemical Examiner, thereby questioned the authenticity and chain of custody linking the sample to the accused. The Public Prosecutor urged that oral and documentary evidence established the offence and did not warrant interference. The Kerala High Court, upon examining Ext. P8, observed the absence of a seal and relied on Ravi v. State (S.I. of Police, Meppadi) and Smithesh v. State of Kerala to emphasize that the forwarding note must bear the specimen of the seal, with deficiencies undermining proof. Kumaran v. State of Kerala was cited for the necessity of tracing the sample’s despatch through the appropriate official. Given the unresolved chain of custody, the court held a benefit of doubt in favor of the appellant and allowed the appeal, setting aside the conviction and sentence and ordering the appellant’s release.
CRL.A Nos.1350 of 2016, 1320 of 2016, 1327 of 2016 & 48 of 2017 The Kerala High Court, in a common judgment disposing of four connected criminal appeals (CRL.A. Nos. 1350 of 2016, 1320 of 2016, 1327 of 2016 and 48 of 2017), examines conspiracy, unlawful assembly and murder charges arising from the 1 April 2008 attack on Vishnu, a CPI(M) worker, in Thiruvananthapuram. The trial court sentenced multiple accused under IPC sections 120B, 143, 147, 148 and 302 read with 149 IPC; there were accompanying charges under the Explosive Substances Act and Arms Act, plus various offences under the Evidence Act and CrPC. The High Court scrutinises the prosecution’s case across three layers: conspiracy (PW13/14), the assault (PW1/PW4) and the getaway (PW3/PW15), with particular focus on identification procedures (TIP) and recoveries of weapons, dresses and bikes. A central theme is the reliability of eyewitness testimony in a daylight crime executed in broad public view, and the integrity of the investigation, including the absence of a Case Diary, allegedly tutored witnesses, inconsistencies in FIRs and inquest reports, and the manner of TIP. After detailed analysis, the court finds the prosecution’s evidence unreliable, the TIPs are marred by procedural lapses, and many witnesses turn hostile. Consequently, it acquits all accused and releases them. The judgment emphasizes safeguards in identification procedures and cautions against relying on embellished, poorly corroborated testimony where other independent evidence is lacking.
WP(C) Nos.9881/2020 & connected cases This is a consolidated batch of writ petitions filed by Oil Marketing Companies (and franchisees) challenging Government Orders Ext.P2 (G.O.(Ms) No.16/2020/PWD dated 10.02.2020) and Ext.P4 (G.O.(Ms) No.67/2020/PWD dated 16.10.2020) which laid down Guidelines for Access Permission to Fuel Stations along State Highways and Major District Roads. The petitioners contend the guidelines amount to executive rules that encroach upon central legislation (Petroleum Rules, 2002) and on central/regulatory powers over petroleum operations; they argue the District Authorities cannot rely on Ext.P4 to deny NOCs under Rule 144 of the Petroleum Rules, 2002, and that the Rules themselves and central jurisprudence (Mary Ulahannan, Reliance Industries) require that decisions be governed by statutory provisions rather than broad guidelines. The State contends the guidelines are within its legislative/executive power (involving Entry 13 of List II and related constitutional provisions) to regulate public safety and traffic. The Kerala High Court, in a detailed judgment dated 5 August 2021, held Ext.P2 and Ext.P4 invalid as they cannot override statutory rules, directed District Authorities to reconsider NOC applications under Rule 144 in light of existing rules as of the dates of the applications, and set aside district refusals grounded on Ext.P2/P4. It also held that any prior NOC conditions requiring a PWD NOC were nullified, with a two-month deadline for re-consideration and leave-open other issues.
WP(C) Nos.9881/2020 & connected cases This is a consolidated writ petition (WP(C) Nos. 9881/2020 and connected cases) challenging Government orders and guidelines issued by the Public Works Department regarding accesspermits for Petroleum Fuel Retail Outlets (PFRs) along State Highways and Major District Roads in Kerala. The petitioners are oil marketing companies and franchisees who sought No Objection Certificates (NOCs) for establishing fuel outlets. The State/government issued Ext.P1–Ext.P4 norms/guidelines (IRC-based norms, GO Nos. 16/2020, 46/2019, 67/2020, etc.) and related expert committee recommendations, which were challenged as unconstitutional, arbitrary, and violative of central Petroleum Rules and constitutional rights (Article 14, 19(1)(g)). The petitioners argued that the District Authorities cannot substitute statutory conditions under the Petroleum Rules (Rule 144) with guidelines; that the guidelines were framed without proper consultation; and that the central statutes (Petroleum Rules 2002) and MoRTH/IRC norms govern access to highways, with central control and appellate remedies. The Kerala High Court held Ext.P2/P4 and the guidelines invalid, set aside the district decisions relying on them, and directed district authorities to reconsider NOC applications under Rule 144 of the Petroleum Rules, 2002 without reference to Ext.P2/P4, within two months, while allowing cure of defects. The judgment discusses case-law on executive instructions (Mary Ulahannan distinguished), reliance on Reliance Industries, and the scope of statutory vs. executive powers under Article 162 and related Acts.
WA 811 of 2020 (connected cases) These writ appeals arise from a common judgment dated 25 February 2020 of a Single Judge in W.P.(C) nos. allocations involving Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and the pension scheme under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. The Full Bench was constituted to consider the correctness of the Single Judge’s directions that in the context of a contributory pension scheme, higher pension can be sought by remitting contributions based on actual salary, and whether no-cut-off-date decisions in Sasikumar P. and similar cases should stand. The bench, after examining the Supreme Court’s decisions in Pawan Hans Ltd. v Aviation Karmachari Sanghatana; RC Gupta v Regional Provident Fund Commissioner; and Sunil Kumar B. v EPFO, held that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration to the extent it struck down the 2014 Amendment scheme and its consequences for those who had been contributing on actual salary. It concluded that the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar governs the entitlement to higher pension and directed EPFO to reconsider entitlement in light of those directions, while cautioning against erosion of the corpus and ensuring actuarial prudence. The judgment ultimately disposes of the appeals in terms of Sunil Kumar’s directions and related paragraphs, including an eight-week implementation period and further steps as directed by the Supreme Court.
WP(C) 9881/2020 and connected cases The Kerala High Court delivered a consolidated judgment on WP(C) 9881/2020 and numerous connected petitions filed by Oil Marketing Companies and their franchisees challenging Government Orders Ext.P2 (GO 16/2020) and Ext.P4 (GO 67/2020)—the Guidelines for Access Permission to Fuel Stations along State Highways and Major District Roads. The petitioners argued that these guidelines/orders, being executive instruments, contravene central petroleum laws and violate fundamental rights, especially Article 14 and Article 19(1)(g), by unduly restricting entry for fuel stations and discriminating in favor of incumbent operators. They asserted the State had no authority to fix distance norms and plot sizes, that IRC/MoRTH norms were withdrawn by MoRTH and that the Government’s process lacked consultative, legislative legitimacy, making the measures arbitrary and violative of natural justice. The respondents defended the measures as a safety-oriented regulatory framework under State powers, highlighting central control through Petroleum Rules/Act and state enactments, and argued district authorities can consider traffic/public-safety factors under Rule 144. The Court held that Ext.P2 and Ext.P4 cannot justify refusal of NOC under Rule 144 and set aside the challenged orders, directing District Authorities to reconsider NOC applications in light of prevailing rules within two months, while leaving other issues open. The decision emphasizes limited scope for district authorities to rely on guideline-based restrictions in lieu of statutory petroleum/rules frameworks.
The petition challenges the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s Ext.P2 order dated 9 July 2021 in OA 925 of 2021, whereby the Tribunal allowed a medical reimbursement claim filed by Dr Kavitha J.B., a government servant, for treatment of her elderly father who was wholly dependent on her. The Kerala High Court exercises jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution to quash Ext.P2 and restore the position in accord with the governing rules. The petitioner contends that the impugned order relies on Annexure A12 (the 2017 W.P. (C) 21627 judgment interpreting ‘dependant’) and Annexure A13 (Supreme Court’s M.P. Ojha decision) to treat the applicant’s father as “wholly dependent,” but Annexure A12 has since been reversed by the Division Bench in State of Kerala v. Sunu George (2019) (4) KLT 288 (DB). The petition also argues that the pension payable to the father in 2020—around Rs. 21,000 per month—renders him financially non-dependent, contrasting with the far lower pension in M.P. Ojha’s 1987 scenario, which the Supreme Court used to define “wholly dependent.” The respondents counter that the definition of ‘Family’ in Rule 3(e) includes parents wholly dependent on the government servant and that the Tribunal’s order reflected this principle. After considering competing authorities, the court holds that the Tribunal’s reasoning cannot be sustained in light of the Division Bench’s reversal of Annexure A12 and the evolved understanding of ‘wholly dependent,’ and accordingly sets aside Ext.P2. The petition is disposed with directions consistent with this view.
Litty Mathew, a joint owner of 22.20 acres in Kuravilangad, petitions against Ext.P6, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer rejecting her Form 5 application to remove land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. She contends the property is not paddy land or wet land as defined by the Act and was wrongly included. Ext.P3 (Form 5) was filed before the RDO, but Ext.P6 relies solely on the Agricultural Officer’s report that the land had been converted after 2008, with no independent assessment. The petitioner asserts non‑application of mind and violation of the Act and binding precedents, highlighting the KSRSEC report (Ext.P4) and Village Officer’s Ext.P5 suggesting removal. The court notes Rule 4(4E) and 4(4F) require an independent assessment, possibly via satellite imagery, and that the land’s status as of the Act’s commencement date must be considered, not merely the LLMC’s position. Cited authorities include Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, reinforcing the need for independent evaluation and the predominant factor being whether paddy cultivation is possible. The court holds Ext.P6 unsustainable for relying on a single report and sets it aside, directing the RDO to reconsider Ext.P3 in Form 5 with Ext.P4, Ext.P5 and Rule 4(4F) considerations within two months, at the petitioner’s cost for fresh reports.
WA 811/2020 (and connected cases) These writ appeals, listed before a Full Bench of the Kerala High Court, arise from a common judgment dated 25 February 2020 in WP(C) No.3846 of 2019 and connected petitions. The petitions sought a pension calculation under the Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995, without a cap on pensionable salary when additional contributions to the pension fund were remitted. The Single Judge had allowed the petitioners to remit additional contributions toward the pension fund and to calculate pension on actual salary, either by adjusting amounts in the provident fund account or by remitting the shortfall. The Division Bench of this Court referred the matter to a Full Bench, noting a need to reconsider Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 Ker 614) in light of later Supreme Court decisions. The Full Bench examined the contributory nature of the pension scheme, the growth of the corpus through regular contributions and investments (as explained in Pawan Hans Ltd. v. Aviation Karmachari Sanghatana and RC Gupta v. Regional PF Commissioner), and the controlling effect of the Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO (AIR 2022 SC 5634). It held that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration only to the extent it struck down the 2014 Employees’ Pension Amendment and allowed irregular, ad hoc remittance. The court disposed of the appeals by directing EPFO to reconsider entitlement to higher pension in accordance with the Supreme Court’s directions (paragraph 44 of Sunil Kumar B.), while safeguarding the fund corpus. It also noted the potential actuarial implications and extended the window for action in line with the Sunil Kumar decision, as clarified in the judgment, with the objective of avoiding erosion of the corpus and ensuring equitable treatment for those who contributed regularly. The judgment reflects a balancing approach: upholding the integrity of the pension corpus and aligning with Supreme Court authority, while providing avenue to reconsider individual entitlements in light of post-2014 amendments, and while ensuring prospective implementation.
WP(C) Nos. 10835/2021, 27494/2021, 4823/2020, 679/2022 The Kerala High Court considers whether the Authority under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 can entertain a complaint filed by an Inspector under section 20(2) alleging non-payment of minimum wages by an employer. The lead petition concerns M/S Kalyan Silks (Thrissur) Pvt. Ltd., where an Inspector inspected the establishment and claimed underpayment for 31 employees. The petitioner argued lack of jurisdiction, contending that Section 20 primarily fixes minimum wage rates and does not adjudicate quantum, recommending remedies under the Industrial Disputes Act or the Payment of Wages Act for any shortfall. The respondents argued that Section 20 empowers the Authority to adjudicate all claims arising from payments below the minimum wage, to direct payment of the differential, and even award compensation and penalties; Forms and procedures are prescribed under the Act. The court analyzes Sections 20(1)-(3) and other connected provisions, emphasising that the Act is welfare legislation aimed at ensuring compliance with notified minimum wages. It distinguishes the Town Municipal Council Athani decision, citing Steel Authority of India Ltd. and Jharkhand judgments to adopt a purposive interpretation, and holds that Section 20(1) enables adjudication of such claims. The petitions are dismissed, upholding maintainability of inspector-initiated complaints under Section 20 of the Act.
This High Court of Kerala judgment arises from Criminal Appeal No. 373 of 2015, challenging a conviction recorded in the earlier trial for murder and conspiracy in a major smuggling case. The narrative centers on Hamza, a smuggling operative who turned informant, and PW41, another informer, whose disclosures triggered a large seizure of contraband gold by the DRI in 1989. Hamza and PW41 were later murdered; the accused A2 (the appellant) was implicated as an active conspirator in a larger scheme run by A1. The prosecution relied on eyewitnesses, diary entries Ext.P2 and Ext.P1, vehicle movements, and seizure reports to prove a conspiracy and murder under IPC sections 120B, 302, and related provisions, as well as alleged destruction of evidence. The defence argued lack of direct identification, unreliable diary entries, and absence of a pre-murder meeting of minds, noting the evidence of PW3, PW55, and others as insufficient to establish conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt. The court examines the standard of conspiracy evidence, citing Purushothaman, Yogesh Jagadish Joshi, Parveen, Firozuddin Basheeruddin, and especially Nalini’s guidelines, to assess whether a sufficient meeting of minds existed before the murder. The result is a critical re-evaluation of the evidence, leading to acquittal of the appellant for the alleged conspiracy and related offences, on grounds of lack of proven meeting of minds and unreliable documentary/evidentiary links.
Beena Antony, the wife of PW23 Antony who had an alleged illicit relationship with the deceased Meenakshi, challenges a 2015 Sessions Court conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC and causing disappearance of evidence under Section 201 IPC. The High Court of Kerala, Division Bench comprising K. Vinod Chandran and C. Jayachandran, on 16 June 2022, reconsiders the prosecution’s circumstantial case. The trial relied on motive (illicit relationship between the husband and the deceased), the fact that the deceased was found dead in a shed on the husband’s property, and several circumstantial links including the last-seen-alive theory, a recovery of an axe (MO14) under Section 27 of the Evidence Act with blood, and an alleged extra-judicial confession to the accused’s brother (PW17). Key witnesses PW3 and PW4 (sons of the deceased) testified to the events, though several important witnesses (PW23 and PW17) turned hostile. The defence criticized the lack of direct evidence, inconsistencies in footwear and whereabouts, and the supposed confession’s nature. The court scrutinized the chain of circumstantial evidence and the admissibility/value of the recovered weapon, noting uncertainties about the blood’s origin and the link to the offence. Ultimately, the High Court held that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and allowed the Criminal Appeal, acquitting Beena Antony and directing her release.
Petitioner M. Aboobacker, an A Class Government Contractor, participated in a tender floated by the Kerala Water Authority for Jal Jeevan Mission works in Kasaragod district. Respondents 5 to 8, a Joint Venture, also participated. The petitioner approached this Court seeking to command the 1st respondent to declare him the successful bidder and disqualify the 6th respondent. Technical bids were opened on 14.01.2022; financial bids were opened on 31.01.2022. In the financial bid, the petitioner was found as L1 and the 6th respondent was L2. However, under the QCBS system followed by the Kerala Water Authority, the 6th respondent was found to have superior merit and eligible for award. The petitioner contended that Ext.P5 tender conditions require rejection of offers by contractors who are blacklisted or who failed to complete works or refrained from executing the agreement; he submitted that the 6th respondent, a member of the JV with the 5th respondent, was selected but later expressed unwillingness to execute Ext.P6 work and his EMD was forfeited, rendering the JV ineligible under Clause 7.18(4). The respondents argued that even if the petitioner is L1, he has no right to insist on award; the 6th respondent’s withdrawal was due to Covid-19, and he was not blacklisted. The Court held that the QCBS framework allows a more meritorious bidder to prevail, and the tendering authorities acted within their powers; the petition was dismissed. The court also relied on State of Punjab and others v. Mehar Din to illustrate discretionary award of contracts.
This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by a Division Bench, concerns OP(CAT) No.8 of 2022 challenging a Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) order vacating an interim stay in OA No.180/441/2021. The petitioners are five Income Tax cadre officers whose challenge centers on the inter-se seniority between direct recruits and promotees in the Income Tax Department. They contend that Annexure-A3, issued on 05.08.2021, is a provisional seniority list prepared after the Supreme Court’s Meghachandra Singh & Ors. v. Ningam Siro & Ors. decision (2020) 5 SCC 689, and that Meghachandra’s ratio should govern the inter-se seniority in this case. They point to Tribunal directions in OA No.143/2019 and the Tribunal’s final order (Annexure-A2, 10.01.2020) directing finalization of seniority in line with Meghachandra, arguing that Annexure-A3 undermines those conclusions. The respondents contest that the seniority position had already been settled and published, and that Parmar’s principles (NR Parmar & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., 2012) may apply, with Delhi High Court’s Annexure-A5 offering a contrary perspective. The Court notes the tribunal’s omission to address Meghachandra’s impact and directs that interim relief be continued, pending expeditious disposal of the OA. It ultimately set aside the Ext.P-9 order vacating the stay and restored the Ext.P-2 stay, while directing the CAT to decide the OA promptly within the parameters of Meghachandra and Parmar jurisprudence.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2626 OF 2024 Adithyan R., aged 19, seeks pre-arrest bail under section 438 CrPC in Crime No. 1/2024 of Kochi Metro Police Station, Ernakulam. The prosecution alleges that in July 2023 the accused subjected a 17-year-old defacto complainant to sexual intercourse at Hi bye Entertainments, Ernakulam, and on two occasions in August 2023 at the accused’s residence, on the promise of marriage. The offences alleged include sections 354, 354A(1)(i), 376(2)(n) IPC and sections 3(a) read with 4, 5(1) read with 6, 7 read with 8 of the POCSO Act. The petitioner argues the acts arose from a love relationship and consent, contending that in cases of lovers involving a minor above 16 years there should be cautious handling of POCSO charges; cites Bombay High Court’s B.A. No. 997 of 2022 (26.04.2023) and Calcutta High Court’s CRAN 2 of 2020 (17.09.2021) as supportive guidance. The prosecution maintains the offences are clearly made out and that consent is immaterial for a minor under POCSO. The court notes the FIS indicating rape on three occasions during a continuing love relationship and emphasizes that in serious offences involving a minor, bail should not be granted. Relying on Sumitha Pradeep v. Arum Kumar (2022 SCC OnLine SC 1529), the court holds that custodial interrogation and the protective objective of POCSO weigh against anticipatory bail. The petition is dismissed; the petitioner must surrender and may approach regular bail thereafter.
The petitioner, Abdulkhader, the husband of the woman referred to as Ms. X, filed a writ petition under a habeas corpus move alleging his wife and their minor child were abducted by the 5th respondent and illegally confined. The case unfolded after Ms. X was traced and produced before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Tripunithura, prompting directions for her appearance before the Kerala High Court along with the minor. The 4th respondent, a 21-year-old woman, testified that she left the petitioner of her own free will, endured alleged physical and mental abuse, and expressed a desire to accompany the 5th respondent, who afforded her refuge. The petitioner and his supporters contended that the minor child’s safety would be jeopardized if the mother remained in the company of a person with criminal antecedents and urged custody or visitation rights for the parents. The Court directed interaction through a Family Counselling Centre and reviewed a report from that process. It observed that the alleged detenu is an adult who asserts she is not under illegal confinement, and that the primary remedy lies in the jurisdiction of the Family Court for custody or visitation, not immediate habeas relief. Relying on Devu G. Nair v. State of Kerala for habeas corpus guidelines, the Court ultimately disposed of the petition, finding the petitioner not entitled to relief.
This Kerala High Court criminal appeal arises from a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of contraband arrack. Soman, the appellant, was found in possession of 13 packets of 100 ml each at Pulpally, Wayanad, on 24.04.2004. The Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc)-II, Kalpetta, convicted him and sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1 lakh. The prosecution relied on seizure Mahazar Ext P1, samples prepared at the scene, and chemical analysis Ext P7. The defense challenged the conviction on the ground that the prosecution failed to establish that the contraband tested in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory was the same seized from the accused, arguing delays in producing the samples and lack of seal description; no testimony from officials who handled the samples; and missing tamper-proof chain. The High Court examined numerous authorities on chain of custody, sampling/sealing, and delay, including Sasidharan v State of Kerala, Sathi v State of Kerala, Ravi v State of Kerala, State of Rajasthan v Daulat Ram, and Bhaskaran v State of Kerala, among others. It held that the prosecution failed to prove the chain of custody and that Ext P7 had no evidentiary value; the conviction could not stand. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the conviction and sentence set aside, the accused acquitted and released, with any deposited amount to be disbursed.