Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 665 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2722 OF 2024

Anoop Nambiar and Aswanth P Sunil v. State of Kerala and Varandarappilly Police Station

This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Section 439 CrPC by two accused in Crime No. 300/2024 of Varandarappilly Police Station, Thrissur, seeking release from custody. Accused Nos. 1 and 3 challenge continued detention while the 2nd accused is separately sought to be released on bail. The offences charged are 341 (wrongful restraint), 323 (hurt), 324 (grievous hurt with a weapon), 308 (attempt to cause grievous hurt) and 506 r/w 34 IPC, in connection with an incident on 20.03.2024 at about 22:15 hours, where the de facto complainant was restrained, stabbed by the 1st accused, a knife was allegedly placed to his neck by the 2nd accused, and the 3rd accused kicked him. The petitioners claim innocence and contend the addition of Section 308 is a tactic to deny bail; they have remained in custody since 22.03.2024, investigation purportedly completed, and recoveries effected, so further detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor counters that the 1st accused inflicted a grievous injury and the investigation is ongoing; release on bail would hamper the investigation. The court applies bail principles from leading judgments (Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, and Mahipal) and notes the prima facie involvement, gravity, risk of tampering with evidence, and need to balance competing interests. The result is: the 1st accused’s bail application is dismissed, while the 2nd/3rd accused is granted bail subject to conditions including bond, two sureties, appearance, no tampering with evidence, surrender of passport, and other standard conditions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1688 OF 2024

Renjith.R v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court bail application (Section 438 CrPC) by Renjith.R, second accused in Crime No.200/2024 of Nooranadu Police Station, Alappuzha. The FIR alleges that, during a procession on 11 February 2024, ten accused formed an unlawful assembly with dangerous weapons, abused the complainant, and assaulted him; the first accused allegedly injured the complainant with a weapon, with the second accused (the petitioner) also using a weapon and striking him on the forehead, leading to injuries including a nasal bone fracture. The Sessions Court rejected the co-accused’s anticipatory bail and the petitioner approached the High Court seeking pre-arrest bail, arguing innocence and that the offence under Section 326 IPC could not be attracted to him since the first accused caused the weapon injury. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, citing an overt act, injury corroborated by medical records, and the necessity of custodial interrogation for investigation. The court examined the relevant legal principles governing anticipatory bail, citing Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra (no rigid guidelines; discretion must be fact-specific), the Sibbia case (principles on prudent exercise of discretion), and Jai Prakash Singh. Ultimately, the judge found no exceptional grounds for pre-arrest bail and dismissed the application, directing surrender within ten days with subsequent merits to be considered by the proper court if surrendered.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 7901 OF 2024

Davis P A v. Nedumbasserry Village Officer, Nedumbassery Grama Panchayat, Convener/Agricultural Officer, Agricultural Officer, Revenue Divisional Officer, Kerala State Remote Sensing and Environment Centre

On 1 March 2024, the Kerala High Court heard WP(C) No. 7901 of 2024 filed by Davis P A challenging Ext.P4, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting Form 5 for removal of land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The petitioner co-owns 5.45 and 5.60 acres in Re. Sy. Nos. 125/10, 125/11 in Nedumbasserry Village. He contends the land does not fall within paddy land or wetland definitions and was wrongly included in the Data Bank. Ext.P4 records the RDO’s reliance on the Agricultural Officer’s report and LLMC recommendation, with no independent assessment of the land’s status as on the Act’s date or its suitability for paddy cultivation. The petitioner invokes Rule 4(4E) and 4(4F) to obtain independent verification via site inspection or satellite imagery. The court cites Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, to stress independent assessment and the Act’s date as determinative. The court holds Ext.P4 vitiated by non-application of mind and directs the RDO to reconsider the Form 5 application within two months, using KSRSEC report and court observations, after serving a copy of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2033 OF 2023

Suma T.S v. State of Kerala

This bail application under Section 438 CrPC concerns Suma T.S., the secretary of the Kuttur Ksheera Vyavasaya Sahakarana Sangam, Kannur district. She stands accused in Crime No.896/2022 of the Peringome Police Station for alleged misappropriation of Rs.11,36,992 and for offences under sections 406, 420, 468 and 471 IPC. The prosecution alleges that, during 10.8.2019 to 17.11.2021, she manipulated the Society’s stock Register, Day Book and Cash Book, tearing pages and destroying evidence to conceal the loss. The private complaint was filed after nearly a year, and the jurisdictional Magistrate forwarded it to police under Section 156(3) CrPC; the investigation is still at a nascent stage. The defense argued innocence, compliance with superiors’ directions, and that custodial interrogation was unnecessary; the petitioner expressed willingness to cooperate and to accept reasonable conditions. The Public Prosecutor contended that there is widespread manipulation and that arrest is necessary to recover evidence and ensure a fair investigation. In a reasoned order, the High Court relied on Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre and the Sibbia line of cases on anticipatory bail, noting that such relief is exceptional and must be exercised with care, considering nature and gravity of the offence, antecedents, likelihood of flight, and risk of tampering. The Court ultimately held that pre-arrest bail is not warranted, but directed surrender within 10 days and that, on surrender, an application for bail on merits may be considered, failing which arrest may be effected.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811/2020

Employees' Provident Fund Organisation v. Sasikumar P. and Others (and connected WP/Cases) - WA 811/2020 and connected appeals, Kerala High Court

These writ appeals arise from a common set of petitions challenging pension calculations under the Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995, specifically the entitlement to a higher pension based on actual salary as opposed to the statutory maximum pensionable salary. The petitioners, principally the Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and related authorities, had relied on Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614) and RC Gupta v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (2018) 14 SCC 809 to direct remittance of additional contributions for higher pension amounts. The Single Judge initially granted relief, and the Division Bench, in a reference order dated 21.12.2020, suggested reconsideration of Sasikumar P. in light of a contributory-scheme framework and the need to protect corpus growth (noting Pawan Hans Ltd. v. Aviation Karmachari Sanghatana and the 2014 amendment). The matter was referred to a Full Bench to reconcile Sasikumar P. with subsequent jurisprudence, particularly the Supreme Court's three-judge decision in Sunil Kumar B. and others (AIR 2022 SC 5634), which upheld the amended pension scheme provisions. The Full Bench ultimately directs EPFO to reconsider entitlement to higher pension consistent with Sunil Kumar and its directives, while recognizing the need for actuarial valuation and potential central government action to address the scheme’s long-term viability.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811/2020 and connected matters (EPFO v Union of India) – Kerala High Court

WA 811/2020 and connected matters (EPFO v Union of India and others) – High Court of Kerala (Full Bench)

These writ appeals arise from a common challenge to the computation of pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995, especially the question whether pension should be calculated with reference to actual salary or the maximum pensionable salary fixed under the scheme. The Division Bench referred the matter to a Full Bench in 2020 in light of conflicting precedents, notably Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614) and the Supreme Court’s decisions in RC Gupta, Pawan Hans, and the 2014 amendments to the pension scheme. The Full Bench identifies that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration of its negative stance on the 2014 amendments and on allowing regular contributors to shift to actual-salary-based pension. It reasons that the corpus must be preserved and that actuarial valuation and central-government policy decisions are necessary before altering the contributory structure. The judgment ultimately disposes of the appeals by following the Sunil Kumar B. framework (AIR 2022 SC 5634), directing EPFO to reconsider higher-pension entitlements consistent with the Supreme Court’s directions, including extended time for options and adherence to the amended scheme, while holding the corpus integrity paramount. The order thus emphasizes a cautious, policy-guided approach rather than a mechanical expansion of pension rights.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 4398 OF 2022

Indian Pentecostal Church of God (IPC) Faith Centre, Kayamkulam v. District Collector, Alappuzha & Others

This writ petition challenges a notice under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act for converting wetland to dry land in Re-Survey Nos. 32/8 and 9 at Kayamkulam. The petitioners, IPC Faith Centre Kayamkulam and office-bearers, submitted Form 6 for 11.63 ares of land. They contend that the notice demanded a fee of Rs. 6,65,170 for conversion, computed on the fair value as of 19.03.2020 (Ext.P7), which they allege undervalues the subject property and includes an already existing building (construction dating to 2009–2011). They argue that Rule 12(9) of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Rules prohibits charges for the building and that Ext.P8 circular and Government Order dated 25.02.2021 limit the fair value to the date of application, with further constraints if the extent is below 1 acre. The respondents contend that a uniform regime under REVP1/313/2021-REV (10.12.2021) fixes a 10% fee of the fair value of similar dry land to change classification to 1 acre, irrespective of locality, resulting in Rs. 4,54,085 (Rs. 2,11,085 for land and Rs. 2,43,000 for building). The High Court found the impugned Ext.P9 erroneous, quashed it, and directed refixation of the fee strictly under the 2008 Act, Rules, Fee Schedule, and relevant Government Orders, while considering the petitioners’ building contention, within one month.

High Court of Kerala
CMR NO.2 OF 2010

Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. Sri P. Subramanian

This Civil Miscellaneous Reference (CMR No.2 of 2010) was brought by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India under Section 21(5) of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, seeking the removal of Sri P. Subramanian from the Register for five years over alleged professional misconduct arising from presenting forged and bogus stay orders to stall tax recovery. The matter traces back to a complaint in 2002 that the respondent allegedly used stay orders, purportedly issued by appellate authorities, which were later found bogus; the disciplinary committee found him guilty of ‘other misconduct’ and the Council, after considering representations, recommended his removal. The respondent contested, arguing the disciplinary process was not properly conducted (ex parte in parts), that there was no direct evidence of personal presence and handover of forged orders, and that taxes due had been paid; the criminal case ended in acquittal. The High Court, in a Division Bench, surveys the Act’s wide supervisory jurisdiction, the requirement of fair procedure, and the need for clearly reasoned findings. Relying on authorities such as Shadi Lal Batra and L.K. Ratna, it emphasizes that misconduct requires proof beyond mere suspicion or negligence and that the Council must provide reasons. Ultimately, the Court held that the material did not prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and dismissed the reference, with no costs awarded.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1861 OF 2024

Junaid M.V v. State of Kerala

This is a bail petition filed under Section 439 CrPC by the sole accused, Junaid M.V., in Crime No.132/2024 of Pazhayangadi Police Station, Kannur, alleging offences under Sections 341, 324 and 307 IPC. The prosecution contends that on 19 February 2024, driven by animosity toward the de facto complainant, the accused forcibly restrained the friend of the complainant and attempted to murder him by strikes with a sharp weapon, resulting in grievous injuries. The petitioner has been in custody since 20 February 2024. The defence argues innocence, false implication, and submits that Section 307 is not attracted; the investigation is reportedly complete with recoveries effected, and the petitioner has no criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor highlights medical records (wound certificate, accident register) to show the severity of injuries and the possibility of interference if released. The court relies on Supreme Court principles—presumption of innocence until conviction, and that bail is the rule with imprisonment as an exception—while acknowledging the near-completion of investigation and lack of antecedents. Citing Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, and State of Kerala v. Raneef, the court ultimately allows the bail petition, imposing standard conditions including a Rs 50,000 bond with two sureties, periodic appearances, restrictions on travel, and other typical bail conditions, with power to cancel for violation and allowing modifications as needed (per Sushila Aggarwal guidance).

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 20 of 2006

SHAJAHAN v. STATE OF KERALA

SHAJAHAN v. STATE OF KERALA arises from a conviction for culpable homicide and a subsequent acquittal on appeal by the Kerala High Court. The appellant (accused No.1) stood convicted under Section 304 IPC and sentenced to five years’ rigorous imprisonment, while the Section 395 IPC charge was acquitted; accused Nos. 2–5 were acquitted. The prosecution’s case was that on 13.12.2003 at about 7:20 p.m., the appellant, who was driving a jeep, repossessed it on Mundkayam–Poonjar road and, at Kavali junction, drove at high speed and, with knowledge that death was likely, ran over wooden logs and rocks placed across the road to block movement, resulting in the death of Kurian Mathew. The Trial Court held the driving to be high-speed and reckless, but the High Court allowed the appeal, acquitting the appellant of the 304 IPC charge. The court scrutinized whether the prosecution proved culpable homicide beyond reasonable doubt, especially whether the appellant had the requisite mens rea (knowledge that death was likely) or intention to kill. It emphasized Section 80 IPC (accident in doing a lawful act) and the burden on the accused to rebut presumption under that section. Concluding the prosecution failed to establish the essential ingredients, the High Court acquitted the appellant. The appeal was allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.5672/2022

Great India Estate Private Limited v. Union Bank of India and The Manager, Union Bank of India, Chalai Branch

The petitioner, Great India Estate Private Limited, approached the Kerala High Court to quash Ext. P3 and to challenge the bank’s freezing of its current account with Union Bank of India, Chalai Branch. The sequence began with the petitioner transferring Rs. 1 crore from its own account to the bank’s current account on 01.02.2022; the amount did not get credited, and after providing fresh KYC on 03.02.2022, the current account remained non-operational. On 14.02.2022, the bank informed the petitioner that the debit facility was disabled and transfers could not be processed. The petitioner argued this would jeopardize a housing project mandated by the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) and would affect payments to suppliers, wages, and compliance with RERA orders. The respondents contended that the petitioner and Green Gateway Leisure Limited are interconnected through common directors and control, and that funds were diverted to the petitioner through various subsidiaries; invoking Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, the bank claimed general lien and even lifting of the corporate veil to justify withholding the petitioner’s account. The court examined the doctrine of lifting the corporate veil, citing Star Battery, Balwant Rai Saluja, Syndicate Bank and others, and found that the petitioner’s separate corporate identity could not be ignored. The writ petition was allowed, Ext. P3 was set aside, and the bank was directed to reactivate the petitioner’s account forthwith to enable normal operation.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 104 of 2018 & 592 of 2018

M/S M.K.ASSOCIATES v A. RAJAMANY alias GOURIMUTHU; R. MURALEEDHARAN; K.N. RADHAKRISHNAN; A. JYOTHIPRAKASH; THE DISTRICT LABOUR OFFICER PALAKKAD; THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY, REGIONAL JOINT LABOUR COMMISSIONER, ERNAKULAM (WA Nos. 104 & 592 of 2018)

This intra-court appeal arises from a 2010 writ petition challenging a Kerala Headload Workers Act order that directed reinstatement with back wages. The appellants were engaged as headload workers and were denied employment on 26 March 2002. They invoked Section 21 of the Kerala Headload Workers Act, leading to conciliation and, failing settlement, a Section 22 decision ordering reinstatement with back wages. The employer challenged Ext. P9 before the High Court, arguing lack of jurisdiction of the competent authority and contending that relief of reinstatement with back wages cannot be granted; it urged adherence to remedies under the Industrial Disputes Act, including Section 10A. The respondents argued Articles 19 and 21 protection and that reinstatement with back wages is justified to restore livelihood, while reiterating the need for a just remedy. The High Court, noting the close alignment of Headload Act procedures with IDA-like conciliation, proceeded to examine the trend in jurisprudence. It relied on Deepali Gundu Surwase to discuss gainful employment and held that backwages cannot be awarded in absence of gainful employment evidence. Citing BSNL v Bhurumal and Jagbir Singh, the court concluded that reinstatement is not automatic and monetary compensation can serve ends of justice. The appeals were disposed with modified relief: backwages negated; compensation fixed at Rs.5,500 per month for the period of lay-off, from denial to Ext. P9, as gainful employment pleadings were lacking.

High Court of Kerala
WA NO.900 OF 2022

Travancore Devaswom Board & Others v Premachandran Nair

This writ appeal arises from a challenge to a learned Single Judge’s order in WP(C) No. 33322 of 2017. The appellants (Travancore Devaswom Board, Devaswom Commissioner and Devaswom Accounts Officer) contend that the writ petition, filed in 2017 by Premachandran Nair, seeking regularisation of two spells of suspension, was wrongly decided. Nair, who joined service in 1988 as a Panchavadyam artist, was suspended twice (10.08.1994–19.03.1996 and 03.07.1997–08.04.1998) and reinstated afterward; no disciplinary proceedings were shown to have been concluded against him. Although a memo of charges (Exhibit P3) was issued in 2000, no further action followed; later representations (Exhibits P4 and P8) sought regularisation of the suspension, and a reply (Exhibit P10, 29.08.2017) stated that the suspension periods were already regularised as Leave Without Allowances (LWA). The learned Single Judge held that Rule 56B of Part I KSR requires a regularisation order with notice and hearing and, in the absence of ongoing/disposed disciplinary proceedings, the suspension could not be treated as justified; thus, P10 was quashed and consequential benefits directed. The appellants argue belatedness and lack of records, while the respondents rely on the service-book endorsements and long-past orders. The Division Bench ultimately confirms there was no proper order regularising the suspension as LWA, and the delay by the respondent in addressing representations did not justify the relief sought. The appeal is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.28565/2020-U

Sambasiva Sarma K. v. Kerala Cricket Association and The Ombudsman cum Ethics Officer, Kerala Cricket Association

Petitioner Sambasiva Sarma K., a member of the Kerala Cricket Association (KCA) Apex Council, challenges the Ombudsman cum Ethics Officer’s Ext.P6 order directing that he shall not participate in Apex Council meetings while his writ petitions against KCA governance are pending. The petitioner has a record of advocating governance reforms, including a 2018 forensic audit petition (W.P.(C) No.26059 of 2018) and a 2019 challenge to the election/admission of clubs (W.P.(C).No.19249 of 2019), and he claims to have contributed to the Lodha Committee report. He asserts that the KCA is a legally constituted society and that as an ICA-nominated Apex Councillor he can pursue writ petitions without disbarring himself from governance activity; he contends the challenged order is issued without a valid complaint, violates bye-laws and fundamental rights, and that withholding participation in meetings will not advance resolution of the governance disputes. The respondents contend that the KCA, registered under the Travancore-Cochin Societies Act, functions through its Apex Council; ICA nominees have limited governance roles and cannot interfere with management; Ext.P6 is a legitimate action, and ongoing litigation by a sitting Apex Councillor would impede governance. The court analyzes the Memorandum of Association, the 1955 Act (Act 22/55), and bye-laws to determine whether a sitting Apex Councillor may continue litigation while participating in governance, ultimately interfering with Ext.P6 and allowing the writ petition in part with conditions for participation.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.190 of 2022

K.G. Poulose and Saramma Philip v. The Regional Director, Southern Region, Ministry of Corporate Affairs; C.S.Nair; Pramod V; Mary Rani Popular Nidhi Pvt Ltd; Thomas Daniel Popular Tower; Prabha Tomas Popular Tower; Reba Mary Thomas; Rinu Mariam Thomas; Riya Ann Thomas; MRPN Minority Share Holder Customers Welfare Association (represented by S. Subramanian Potti); Mary Jacob

This writ appeal (WA No. 190 of 2022) arises from a challenge to an interim order (Exhibit P3) passed by the National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench, appointing an Interim Management Committee to form a Kerala Bank. The writ petitioner in W.P.(C) No. 227 of 2021 sought quashing Exhibit P3 and directed action against a Nidhi Company for non-compliance; The Single Judge of this Court invoked Article 227 to stay Exhibit P3 for six weeks, allowing the parties to pursue an alternative statutory remedy. The appeal in this Court is filed by additional respondents who supported the writ petitioner’s contentions but contend maintainability of the appeal itself. The core issue is whether a writ appeal is maintainable where the writ petition reliefs were dismissed and whether a respondent can pursue relief when the writ petitioner had liberty to seek an alternative remedy. The court refers to a Karnataka High Court decision in Mallikarjunagouda v. Principal Munsiff, Hubli to illustrate the principle that a person who could have filed an election petition within time cannot transposed himself as petitioner. After considering the arguments, the Division Bench holds that the writ appeal is not maintainable in law and dismisses it, noting that the writ petitioner’s liberty to seek an alternative remedy had lapsed without being pursued. The order emphasizes that two separate proceedings would arise if alternative remedies were invoked, and a respondent cannot forestall the writ petitioner’s remedy by filing an appeal.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. No. 832 of 2008

Noushad and others v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Appeal under Section 374(2) CrPC filed by five appellants (accused Nos. 1 to 5) challenging their convictions in SC No. 140 of 2006 of the I Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam, for offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 307 and 324 read with Section 149 IPC, with acquittal only of Section 27 Arms Act. The incident occurred on 27.07.2002 on Kalamassery–NAD Road when the accused, in a jeep, allegedly attacked a passing autorickshaw carrying two injured witnesses (PW2 and PW3) with swords after a collision. PW1, a doctor, documented extensive injuries to PW2 and PW3; MO1, a sword, was recovered; Exts. P4 (scene) and P5 mahazar support the prosecution narrative. The Sessions Court found the ocular evidence of PW2 and PW3 credible, corroborated by medical evidence and recovery of MO1, and convicted the appellants. On appeal, the High Court acknowledged injuries and corroboration but noted inconsistencies; however, it held the evidence credible and refused to quash under Section 482 CrPC, citing precedents about FIRs not being encyclopedias of events. It partially allowed the appeal by reducing the substantive sentence under Section 307 IPC from three years to one year, with other sentences unchanged, directing surrender on 19.09.2022. The judgment maintained the conviction and modified the sentence in part.

High Court of Kerala
OP(Crl.) No.235 of 2024

Faizal and Jameela v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Alathur Police Station

The petitioners Faizal and Jameela challenge the order dated 17.11.2023 (CMP 4516/2023 in S.T. No. 977/2022) of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Alathur, in a matter arising from Crime Nos. 212/2022 and 399/2022 at Alathur Police Station. Petitioner No.2 is the defacto complainant; Petitioner No.1 is her son and a accused in S.C. No.945/2022 before the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act Cases, Mannarkkad. The petition seeks committal of S.T.977/2022 to the Special Court for SC/ST Act or, alternatively, to the Sessions Court, arguing that the two cases are cross-cases and should be tried by the same court. The Magistrate had ruled that the two cases cannot be treated as cross-cases because the defacto complainant is not an accused in S.C. No.945/2022, and because the place and time of occurrence differ. The High Court, after examining authorities and precedents, including Nathi Lal v. State of U.P., Sudhir v. State of M.P., Goriparthi Krishtamma, Krishna Pannadi, and Archana on Cr.P.C. 323, held that cross-cases should ordinarily be tried by the same Court and by the same Judge, with two separate judgments, relying only on the evidence of each case. Accordingly, the petition is allowed; the order of the Magistrate is set aside. S.T.977/2022 is to be committed to the Court of Sessions, Palakkad, which shall transfer the case to the Special Court for SC/ST Act Cases, Mannarkkad, for trial in accordance with the discussed principles.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2098 of 2007

P. Razak v. State of Kerala (Criminal Appeal No. 2098 of 2007)

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by the convicted accused, P. Razak, challenging a 2007 conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Kasaragod, in SC No.48/2002. The prosecution case was that on 07.07.2000 at about 5:30 p.m., the accused was found transporting 200 packets of illicit arrack (100 ml each) in a bag along the Nellikatta Pottipalam road; the Preventive Officer seized the contraband and the matter was investigated and charged. The trial court convicted Razak and sentenced him to one year of simple imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine. On appeal, the defense argued that the prosecution failed to prove the chain of custody and the chemical analysis: absence of seal description in the seizure mahazar Ext.P2; lack of evidence about the seal; no proof that the specimen was forwarded to the Chemical Examiner; unexplained delay in forwarding and analysis of the sample. The judge relied on authorities including Bhaskaran, Viswanadhan, and Krishnadas to scrutinize the tamper-proof nature of the sample and the delay. The court held that the link between the accused and the contraband was not proven beyond reasonable doubt, and the conviction could not stand. The appeal was allowed; Razak was acquitted and set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
AR Nos.112/2021 and connected cases (and AR Nos.7/2022, 12/2022, 13/2022, 20/2022, 22/2022, 23/2022, 24/2022, 25/2022, 26/2022, 27/2022, 28/2022, 31/2022, 32/2022, 33/2022, 38/2022)

AR Nos. 112 of 2021 and connected cases (Suresh Kumar Ramakrishnan Kallada & Sindhu v Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited)

These Arbitration Requests before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam challenge arbitration proceedings instituted by Kotak Mahindra Bank under loan agreements containing arbitration clauses. The petitioners, Suresh Kumar Ramakrishnan Kallada and K. S. Sindhu, contend there is an arbitration clause and that a mutually agreed sole arbitrator should be appointed. They challenge the bank’s appointment of Sri Suchit Anant Palande as the sole arbitrator on 11 February 2021, arguing that the appointment was unilateral and against the consensus ad idem principle. The respondents submit that the agreement contemplates a sole arbitrator nominated by the bank and that the petitioners appeared in the arbitration and acquiesced, so challenge to the appointment is untenable. The court, applying TRF Ltd. v. Engineering Projects Ltd. (2017) and Tulsi Developers India Pvt. Ltd. v. Dr. Appu Benny Thomas, holds that unilateral appointment by a party is irregular and unsustainable, and that an independent sole arbitrator must be appointed by the Court under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Accordingly, Sri. K. Balachandran (Retired District Judge) is appointed as the sole arbitrator to arbitrate the disputes, with liberty to rule on jurisdiction, and with directions to disclose, fix fees, and allow appearances on dates set by the arbitrator. The order consolidates AR 112/2021 and connected cases and directs timely communication and compliance.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 41300 of 2023

Gopakumar P. v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Others

The petitioner, a devotee of Thrippapoor Major Sree Mahadevar Temple under the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), filed this writ petition under Article 226 seeking a mandamus to compel respondents 1–4 to conduct an audit of the Temple Advisory Committee’s (TAC) accounts and to direct action on Ext.P16, a report dated 15 August 2023 by the Vigilance Wing’s Sub Inspector. The petition, joined by three other devotees, follows an earlier petition (W.P.(C) No. 20753 of 2023) disposed by Ext.P15 on 26 July 2023, directing the Board to decide after considering the Vigilance report, with temple activities to be run by the Board via the Sub Group Officer under the supervision of the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner pending decision. On 07 February 2024, additional respondents 10 and 11 were impleaded. The petition contends mismanagement and irregular fund collection by the TAC; it seeks statutory compliance under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 and the TAC Rules framed under Section 31A. The respondents counter that the Board already initiated vigilance investigations, ordered reinvestigation due to deficiencies in the initial report, and proposes a further enquiry under the Vigilance Officer, with due process, depositions, and a reasoned Board order. The Court emphasizes statutory duties, safeguards, and the need for a transparent, accountable audit process in temple administration.