Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 663 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.28376 OF 2020(V)

The President, Priyadarshini Ksheerolpadaka Sahakarana Sangham Pt 141(D) APCOS, Puthanambalam P.O., Kadambanadu, Pathanamthitta District-691553 v. State of Kerala, Department of Diary Development, Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram-695001 and others

Being aggrieved by inaction of the respondents in holding elections to the Priyadarshini Ksheerolpadaka Sahakarana Sangham, a society registered under the Kerala Co‑operative Societies Act, the petitioners approached the High Court seeking directions to convene elections and to declare the respondents statutorily bound to conduct the election before the term of the present managing committee expired (17.1.2021). The committee had taken a decision on 16.11.2020 to hold elections on 14.1.2021 and prepared a preliminary voters list, but the respondents did not act. The petition argues that the conflict between the society bye‑laws, which prescribe a 5‑year term from charge, and the Act, which prescribes a 5‑year term from the date of election, must yield to the Act (Section 13A and the explanation to Section 28A) where it overrides bye‑laws. The petition asserts that amendments were made in December 2020 to align the bye‑laws with the Act (Ext.P1) and that the election process was essentially ready, including payment of fees (Ext.P6 and Ext.P8). The Government Pleader notes that amendments must be registered before elections can proceed. The court recognizes the option under Section 33(1)(b) to appoint an ad hoc/administrative committee if elections cannot be concluded in time, and directs expeditious conduct of elections. It cites Division Bench guidance (WP(C) 18310/2017) and Board of Directors of Koliyoor Service Co‑operative Bank Ltd. for allowing members to be part of an administrative committee, and rejects the Chatha approach as per incurium. The petition is disposed of with directions to hold elections expeditiously; if not possible by 17.1.2021, an Administrative Committee comprising present managing committee members may be formed, subject to no surcharge proceedings against them. The decision underscores democratic governance in cooperatives and the supremacy of the Act over bye‑laws.

High Court of Kerala
OP(FC) No.161 of 2024

Nithyan Martin v Neenu Thomas and Others

This Original Petition (O.P. FC No.161/2024) under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges three Family Court North Paravur orders (Exts.P18, P22, P23) related to interim maintenance to the wife and minor children. The petitioner, Nithyan Martin, contends that the Family Court erred in ordering maintenance of Rs. 20,000 per month for each of the two minor respondents from 19.12.2022, and that subsequent review and pleadings-striking orders (Exts. P22, P23) were unjustified. The respondents are the wife and children, alleging non-payment. The High Court previously upheld the maintenance order via Division Bench in O.P.(FC)629/2023 (1.11.2023), noting the provision for reduction on material changes but not altering the mode. After the Division Bench’s endorsement, the petitioner moved for review, which was dismissed, and the Family Court struck off the petitioner’s pleadings for non-compliance with interim maintenance. The High Court, evaluating the sequence, held the maintenance order to be legal and justified, and found the petitioner’s conduct wilful and contumacious in not paying, despite opportunities. The court refused interference, but imposed a Rs.20,000 cost payable to the minor children within three weeks; failure to pay would trigger revenue recovery steps under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968. The bench observed that striking off pleadings is a drastic remedy, to be used as last resort.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1912 OF 2024

Sandeep.K v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by the fourth accused in Crime No. 1265/2023 of the Koyilandy Police Station, Kozhikode, charged with offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 324 and 307 r/w Section 149 IPC. The petitioner, Sandeep.K, was arrested on 26 February 2024. The prosecution alleges that on 19 November 2023, near Gayathri Auditorium, Kollam, about 15 persons, including accused 1 to 3, attacked the defacto complainant and friends with dangerous weapons such as a nanjakku, iron pipe and beer bottle, causing grievous injuries; collectively they are implicated in the said offences. The petitioner contends innocence, alleging false implication, and argues that the offence under Section 307 would not be attracted; the investigation is largely complete, and recovery has been effected, with Annexure A4 showing surrender before the Investigating Officer. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing a specific overt act and ongoing investigation, but concedes that accused 1–3 have already been granted bail (Annexure A3). Relying on Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh and State of Kerala v. Raneef, the court emphasizes presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, detention the exception. The court grants bail to the petitioner on Rs 50,000 bond with two sureties, subject to standard conditions, including regular appearances, non-interference with witnesses, prohibition on new offences, surrender of passport, non-issuance beyond jurisdiction, and possible modification or cancellation on breach, with recoveries permissible under Sushila Aggarwal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8623 OF 2024

K. Ouseppachan v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Pala; Agricultural Officer, Krishi Bhavan, Karoor Grama Panchayath, Valvoor P.O., Pala; Village Officer, Vallichira Village Office, Pala

The petitioner, K. Ouseppachan, is challenging Ext.P5, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting Form 5 seeking removal of his land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. He owns 9.60 acres (23.72 cents) in Re.Survey No.8/4, Block 19, Vallichira Village, Meenachil taluk. He asserts that the property does not come within the definition of paddy land or wetland and that the land was converted well before the Act’s date of commencement (12.08.2008); it is bordered by roads and surrounding converted lands and has notable trees (arecanut and mahagani) over 30 years old. The Tax/Data Bank inclusion is contested as erroneous. The RDO’s Ext.P5 failed to assess the land’s nature as of the Act’s date and did not properly evaluate whether the land is suitable for paddy cultivation; it also relied on LLMC conclusions without independent verification. The Court relies on statutory provisions (Act 2008 and Rules 2008) and binding precedents requiring independent assessment by the RDO, considering land’s status on the Act’s date and suitability for cultivation. The Court sets aside Ext.P5, directing reevaluation under Form 5 with KSRSEC report, and advocates a thorough, law-compliant reassessment within two months, with the petitioner obtaining the KSRSEC report within two weeks.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.30318/2019, 1529/2024, 17949/2020, 17828/2020, 17964/2020, 17972/2020, 28444/2021, 29846/2021, 30448/2021, 30354/2019, 30340/2019, 30373/2019, 32237/2019

P.A. Jose v Union of India

The batch judgment from the Kerala High Court concerns a set of writ petitions challenging the revenue\u2019s ICDS regime and the retrospective substitution of Section 145A in the Income Tax Act, 1961, concerning inventory valuation. Petitioners, including P.A. Jose and various Josco group entities, relied on conventional LIFO inventory valuation and contended that Notification Nos. 87/2016 and 88/2016 (ICDS II) and Circular No. 10/2017 compelled a FIFO/weighted-average approach for closing stock (and, retroactively, opening stock) for AY 2017-18, depriving them of the actual income picture and violating Articles 14, 19(1)(g), and 265 of the Constitution. The court traces the legislative arc: ICDS were notified under Section 145(2) and later substituted by Finance Act 2018 to validate the ICDS retrospectively from 1 April 2017, while Delhi High Court had struck down ICDS and related circulars as ultra vires. The judgment underscores the principle of rational classification and manifests arbitrariness under Article 14, but ultimately holds that the writ petitions are partly allowed: the impugned notices are quashed, and the respondents are directed to accept either LIFO for opening and closing stock for AY 2017-18 or permit FIFO/WA methods for both opening and closing stock. It also notes the need for consistency in stock valuation methods and recognizes the statutory shift as a balancing act between tax administration and constitutional safeguards.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 39008 of 2023

Jose Toby and Sangeetha Jose v. State of Kerala and Others

Jose Toby and Sangeetha Jose challenge Ext.P3, the Revenue Divisional Officer's order denying their Form 5 application to remove 0.4613 hectares of land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The land spans portions of Sy. Nos. 836/2, 836/3, 849/1, and 849/6 in Karamuck Village, Thrissur District. The petitioners contend the land is not paddy land or wetland as defined in the Act and Rules, and therefore should be excluded from the Data Bank. The RDO rejected the Form 5 after relying on a Village Officer report indicating on the western side a paddy field and that the site is water-logged during the rainy season, plus LLMC's recommendation. The petition emphasizes that Rule 4(4E) requires the RDO to obtain a report from the Agricultural Officer for paddy land and from the Village Officer for wetlands, and Rule 4(4F) allows direct verification through satellite images or other means. The court notes several precedents: Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, Mather Nagar Residents Association v. District Collector, Sudheesh v. RDO, and Adani Infrastructures. The court finds a total non-application of mind in Ext.P3, sets it aside, and directs the RDO to reconsider the Form 5 application with KSRSEC input and law, within two months, while the petitioner must obtain KSRSEC reports.

High Court of Kerala
WA NO.2017 OF 2022

Rachith M. Prabhu v. The Convener Recruitment Committee, Ernakulam Regional Co-operative Milk Producers' Union Ltd. (Milma) and Others

This writ appeal arises from the dismissal of WP(C) 4328 of 2021, challenging Milma’s eligibility notification Ext. P5 for the post of Technical Superintendent (Engineering). The petitioner, Rachith M. Prabhu, sought a direction to treat Apprenticeship as experience for employment and to permit participation in Milma’s selection process. Ext. P5 requires a Diploma in Mechanical/Electrical/Electronics/Refrigeration or Diploma in Dairy Engineering with a minimum of two years’ experience. The petitioner produced Exts. P10(a) and P10(b), certificates showing 14 months of trainee/apprentice experience, and Ext. P10(c) indicating graduate apprenticeship with Travancore Cochin Chemicals Ltd. The argument centered on whether apprenticeship can count as experience under Ext. P5, and whether Ext. P11 (Government Order) and Ext. P12 (MoHRD/MHRD) communications recognizing apprenticeship as experience should apply to Milma, an apex cooperative society governed by state statutes. The respondents argued that apprenticeship is not equivalent to in‑industry experience and that Milma is not a State government instrumentality under Article 12. The learned Single Judge held that apprenticeship cannot substitute for required experience and that Ext. P11 is not directly applicable to Milma. The Division Bench upheld, noting two years of experience is required, Ext. P10(c) cannot be considered; Exts. P11 and P12 are not directly applicable to Milma; accordingly, the writ petition could not be granted. The appeal is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 48/2020, 1562/2019, 2/2020, 314/2020, 323/2020, 324/2020, 328/2020, 332/2020, 333/2020, 339/2020, 342/2020, 343/2020, 361/2020, 365/2020, 379/2020, 383/2020, 385/2020, 394/2020, 398/2020, 399/2020, 400/2020, 402/2020, 412/2020, 431/2020, 437/2020, 447/2020, 448/2020, 449/2020, 451/2020, 459/2020, 463/2020, 467/2020, 475/2020, 477/2020, 480/2020, 481/2020, 487/2020, 490/2020, 497/2020, 512/2020, 514/2020, 516/2020, 518/2020, 520/2020, 539/2020, 540/2020, 541/2020, 542/2020, 551/2020, 562/2020, 567/2020, 568/2020, 569/2020, 571/2020, 574/2020, 580/2020, 587/2020, 589/2020, 591/2020, 596/2020, 606/2020, 607/2020, 611/2020, 615/2020, 617/2020, 621/2020, 628/2020, 629/2020, 630/2020, 643/2020, 652/2020, 662/2020, 669/2020, 703/2020, 722/2020, 742/2020, 785/2020, 877/2020, 892/2020, 912/2020, 986/2020, 1019/2020, 1528/2020, 1558/2020, 3/2021, 7/2021, 8/2021, 10/2021, 48/2021, 51/2021, 52/2021, 75/2021, 94/2021, 98/2021, 99/2021, 117/2021, 142/2021, 143/2021, 245/2021, 284/2021, 1056/2021

WA Nos. 48/2020, 1562/2019, 2/2020, 314/2020, 323/2020, 324/2020, 328/2020, 332/2020, 333/2020, 339/2020, 342/2020, 343/2020, 361/2020, 365/2020, 379/2020, 383/2020, 385/2020, 394/2020, 398/2020, 399/2020, 400/2020, 402/2020, 412/2020, 431/2020, 437/2020, 447/2020, 448/2020, 449/2020, 451/2020, 459/2020, 463/2020, 467/2020, 475/2020, 477/2020, 480/2020, 481/2020, 487/2020, 490/2020, 497/2020, 512/2020, 514/2020, 516/2020, 518/2020, 520/2020, 539/2020, 540/2020, 541/2020, 542/2020, 551/2020, 562/2020, 567/2020, 568/2020, 569/2020, 571/2020, 574/2020, 580/2020, 587/2020, 589/2020, 591/2020, 596/2020, 606/2020, 607/2020, 611/2020, 615/2020, 617/2020, 621/2020, 628/2020, 629/2020, 630/2020, 643/2020, 652/2020, 662/2020, 669/2020, 703/2020, 722/2020, 742/2020, 785/2020, 877/2020, 892/2020, 912/2020, 986/2020, 1019/2020, 1528/2020, 1558/2020, 3/2021, 7/2021, 8/2021, 10/2021, 48/2021, 51/2021, 52/2021, 75/2021, 94/2021, 98/2021, 99/2021, 117/2021, 142/2021, 143/2021, 245/2021, 284/2021, 1056/2021

The Kerala High Court, in a batch of writ appeals challenging amendments to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) via the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018, examined whether the amendments to Section 25(1) of the KVAT Act—substituting five years with six years and extending the period for assessments by proviso—could operate retrospectively after the 2016 Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) and the repeal of KVAT upon GST introduction. The court surveyed a web of authorities, including Baiju A.A., Hajee Abdul Shakoor, Jyoti Traders, Calcutta Discount Co., and Mohit Minerals, to determine the correct interpretive approach to retrospective operation and the legislative competence to amend a repealed Act. It ultimately held that the 2017 substitution is prospective (operating from 01.04.2017) and that the 2018 amendment extending the period under the third proviso lacked competence post-repeal, with the saving clause under KGST not sustaining legislative power to amend the pre-GST KVAT. The batch writ appeals were dismissed, and the reassessments challenged on retroactivity grounds were not permitted.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 395 OF 2006

Raju @ Pottar v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal under Section 374(2) CrPC, challenging a Sessions Court Thodupuzha judgment that convicted the sole accused, Raju @ Pottar, for offences under IPC sections 376 and 450 and under the SC/ST Act, 1989 (sections 3(1)(XI) and 3(2)(V)). The incident, alleged to have occurred at 12:30 PM on 16.07.2001 at PW1’s residence, involved sexual assault by the appellant along with a co-accused (Jolly, who was absconding). PW1, the prosecutrix, testified that a man entered her home when she was inside with family members and assaulted her; she later changed her account, initially implicating the appellant in Ext.P1, then stating only on cross-examination that Jolly was the assailant, prompting the trial court to consider Ext.P1 and medical evidence (Exts.P5, P8) in its conviction. The defense challenged the medical certificate and the application of Section 164A, arguing retroactive validity and lack of corroborative medical conformity. The State contended PW1’s testimony required little corroboration given her vulnerable status, and that Ext.P1 aligned with her in material particulars. The High Court scrutinized the prosecutrix’s reliability, citing Punjab v. Gurmit Singh and Himachal Pradesh v. Asha Ram, and concluded that, without credible evidence beyond medical and related materials, the prosecution failed to prove the charge. Consequently, the conviction was reversed and the appellant acquitted and discharged.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 121 of 2024

Thankachan and Beena Thankachan v. Jomon

This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC arises from O.S. No. 181/2018 of the Munsiff’s Court, Pala, and A.S. No. 44/2022 of the Sub Court, Pala. The plaintiff claimed title to the plaint schedule property and the building therein on the basis of Settlement Deed No. 463/2014 of the Meenachil Sub-Registrar, executed by the plaintiff’s mother in favour of the plaintiff. The defendants resided in the property and resisted title claims, contending that Ext. A1 (the settlement deed) was executed fraudulently. The trial court recorded evidence, accepted Ext. A1 and granted prohibitory and mandatory injunctions in favour of the plaintiff. The first appellate court confirmed the trial court’s verdict and directed the defendants to vacate the premises by 31.05.2023. In the second appeal, the defendants attacked Ext. A1 as fraudulent, but the High Court observed that counsel for the defendants conceded Ext. A1’s validity upon examination of the trial court’s reasoning, and it found Ext. A1 to be a legally executed document intended to confer title on the plaintiff. The High Court held that no substantial question of law arose, dismissed the appeal, and left the concurrent verdicts intact. It extended the time to vacate the building to 31.08.2024 subject to an affidavit to vacate by that date, failing which the decree could be executed. All interlocutory applications were dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020, 25202/2020, 25209/2020, 25213/2020, 26222/2020, 27386/2020, 22466/2020, 23782/2021, 27795/2021, 29919/2021, 30508/2021, 30564/2021, 30652/2021, 30668/2021, 30679/2021, 7461/2022, 27478/2022, 29383/2022, 35026/2022, 35173/2022, 35231/2022, 35246/2022, 453/2023, 456/2023, 1548/2023, 13827/2023, 16984/2023, 17289/2023, 25635/2023, 25814/2023

WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020, 25202/2020, 25209/2020, 25213/2020, 26222/2020, 27386/2020, 22466/2020, 23782/2021, 27795/2021, 29919/2021, 30508/2021, 30564/2021, 30652/2021, 30668/2021, 30679/2021, 7461/2022, 27478/2022, 29383/2022, 35026/2022, 35173/2022, 35231/2022, 35246/2022, 453/2023, 456/2023, 1548/2023, 13827/2023, 16984/2023, 17289/2023, 25635/2023, 25814/2023

The Kerala High Court, in a batch of writ petitions arising out Unit Run Canteen cases (URCs) across multiple URCs under the Canteen Stores Department (CSD) and Army Station Head Quarters, confronted whether URCs constitute "the State" or "other authority" under Article 12 of the Constitution of India, and whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is available. The court reviews the traditional tests for statehood (creation, finance, and control) drawn from Ajay Hasia and Ramana Dayaram Shetty, and surveys authorities such as Sombir Singh, Layak Ram, Rajesh Tiwari, Zee Telefilms, Rudani, Chotelal, and others. It finds that URCs are established by Army orders (AO/19/2003/QMG), financed by regimental non-public funds, and governed by SOPs and station-level control rather than by direct statutory State control. The court ultimately holds that URCs are not "State" or “other authority” within Article 12, dismisses the petitions, and grants liberty to petitioners to pursue industrial disputes or other remedies, while noting the need for a remedy outside writ jurisdiction.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 25209 of 2020

WP(C) No. 25209 of 2020

This judgment concerns WP(C) No. 25209 of 2020 and connected petitions filed by ex-servicemen and dependants who worked as Unit Run Canteen URC staff at various URCs under the Canteen Stores Department (CSD) of the Army. The petitioners challenged amendments to the SOP and related directives, arguing that URCs are an arm of the state and that their contractual employment is protected under writ jurisdiction. The respondents, including the Union of India, the Ministry of Defence, and URC authorities, contended that URCs are private undertakings financed through regimental non-public funds and governed by SOPs; they are not statutory bodies and do not fall within the definition of ‘State’ or ‘other authority’ under Article 12 of the Constitution, and hence writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is not applicable. The Kerala High Court, applying the Ajay Hasia framework and tests for creation, finance, and control (as elaborated in Ramana Dayaram Shetty and related authorities), concluded that URCs are not created by statute, are not funded from the Consolidated Fund of India, and are not under deep pervasive state control; staff are engaged under unit-specific SOPs and mutual contracts, not as government employees. The court held that URCs do not constitute State or other authority under Article 12, dismissing the petitions, but granted liberty to petitioners to pursue appropriate remedies such as industrial disputes or other forums,”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. No. 41 of 2017

Antony @ Jose v. State of Kerala

Antony @ Jose appeals against a Thalassery Sessions Court verdict convicting him for offences under Sections 447 and 302 IPC in connection with the 12 October 2008 murder of Pulikkal Kunjumon @ Thankappan in Kelakam, Kannur district. The prosecution alleged that the accused trespassed into the deceased’s yard at about 10:45 pm, abused the deceased, dragged him onto the tar road, and, while the victim lay on his back, sat on his legs and stabbed him with a rubber tapper’s knife, cutting the femoral vein. The victim expired despite hospital treatment. PW1 (neighbor), PW2 (wife), PW3 (son), PW4 and PW5 testified to the sequence; MO1 (knife), MO4 (lungi), and MO5 (shirt) were recovered; blood was detected on MO1 and the clothes. The Sessions Judge held the accused guilty of 302 IPC and 447 IPC, sentencing life imprisonment with a fine for 302 and a separate sentence for 447. The defence argued delays in recording statements, discrepancies among witnesses, lack of light, and absence of premeditation—contending possible self-defence or a sudden quarrel. The State contended the ocular evidence was credible and the weapon linked to the deceased. The Kerala High Court partially allowed the appeal: converting the conviction from 302 IPC to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under 304 Part II IPC, with a five-year rigorous imprisonment, while upholding the 447 IPC conviction and its sentence. The overall outcome preserves the remainder of the trial court order.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A 2126 of 2007

Moideen @ Bullet S/o Kasim v. State of Kerala

Moideen, alias Bullet, the accused, challenges a conviction under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) NDPS Act by the Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Thodupuzha. The prosecution alleged possession of 1.250 kg of ganja found in the toilet of the accused’s residence in Lakshamveedu Colony, Adimali, following confidential information received on 9 April 2006. PW1, the detecting officer, and several witnesses supported the seizure and sampling, with Exts.P9 (seizure mahazar), P11 (property list) and P20 (chemical analysis) forming the core documentary trail. The trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and Rs. 25,000 fine, with a default six months’ imprisonment. On appeal under Cr.P.C. 374(2), the appellant contends that possession and link to the contraband were not proven; independent witnesses were hostile; Exts.P17 and P19 certificates, relied upon to prove possession, are inadmissible under the proviso to Section 162 Cr.P.C.; and there were unexplained delays and concerns about tamper-proof handling of the sample. The High Court scrutinized the evidence, noting admissibility issues, gaps in possession proof, and unexplained delay. It ultimately allowed the appeal, acquitting the accused and cancelling bail, while highlighting the need for credible, unimpeachable proof in NDPS cases.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.30318/2019, 1529/2024, 17949/2020, 17828/2020, 17964/2020, 17972/2020, 28444/2021, 29846/2021, 30448/2021, 30354/2019, 30340/2019, 30373/2019, 32237/2019

P.A. Jose v Union of India (and connected cases)

This batch judgment from the Kerala High Court, delivered by Justice Dinesh Kumar Singh on 20 May 2024, deals with a common core issue: the validity and application of the Income Tax provisions governing accounting standards and stock valuation, specifically ICDS II Clause 16 and Section 145A as substituted by the Finance Act 2018. The lead case, WP(C) No. 30318/2019, concerns a jeweller/dealer of gold who had been valuing stock-in-trade by the LIFO method, with the Revenue repeatedly challenging the accounting approach in light of ICDS II. The Court reviews the evolution of ICDS, the 2016 ICDS notifications (87/2016 and 88/2016) and Circular 10/2017, and the Delhi High Court decision in Chamber of Tax Consultants v. Union of India striking them down as ultra vires. It then notes the Finance Act 2018 substitution of Section 145A with retrospective effect to validate ICDS, and proceeds to address whether the retrospective change can override established accounting principles, including the principle that opening and closing stock should be valued on the same basis. The judgment concludes that the writ petitions are partly allowed: the impugned notices are quashed and the Revenue must accept either the petitioners’ existing LIFO valuation for both opening and closing stock or permit FIFO/weighted average cost for both, for AY 2017-18. Interlocutory matters are closed. The decision navigates questions of delegation, judicial precedents, and the constitutional limits of executive action in tax accounting.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2154 OF 2007

Babu Kuttikkattill Veedu v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal against an order of conviction under Sections 8(2) and 55(a) of the Abkari Act, arising from a 30 July 2003 seizure of two litres of arrack at Pulinthanam Junction. The trial court convicted the appellant based on seizure proceedings, chemical analysis (Ext. P6) and related evidence. On appeal, the appellant challenges the linkage between seizure and laboratory analysis, arguing that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory, and that the seizure mahazar did not describe the seal or provide a specimen, nor was there a forwarding note establishing proper dispatch. The court relies on Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala, Rajamma v. State of Kerala and Ramachandran v. State of Kerala to reiterate procedural safeguards for sample seals, specimen production and chain of custody. The Bench finds that the prosecution failed to establish the tamper-proof link between the seized contraband and the chemical analysis, rendering Ext. P6 of no evidentiary value. Consequently, the conviction cannot be sustained and the appeal is allowed, resulting in acquittal.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2394 OF 2024

S.K KHUSIBUL, AMJAD KHAN, S.K ABDUL RAHMAN and KARIMKHAN v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by four accused in Crime No.178/2024 of the Edakkara Police Station, Malappuram, arising from alleged possession of 17.870 kg of ganja under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) NDPS Act. The petitioners were arrested on 10 February 2024. They contend innocence, false implication, and submit that investigation is complete with the final report filed, with no criminal antecedents and no roots in Kerala, making detention unnecessary. The prosecution opposes bail, noting that the final report has been laid on 13 March 2024 before the Special Court for NDPS Cases, Manjery, and expressing concern about flight risk if released. The court, after hearing counsel for petitioners and the Public Prosecutor and evaluating material on record, including the intermediate quantity of contraband and absence of antecedents, decides to grant bail subject to stringent conditions. The decision cites Hussainara Khatoon (I) v. Home Secy., State of Bihar to emphasize fundamental rights and the permissible scope of bail, while also acknowledging the need to safeguard the investigation. The order directs release on bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two solvent sureties each, and imposes conditions including regular appearances, avoidance of tampering with witnesses, passport surrender, travel limitations within the Special Court’s jurisdiction, and the possibility of cancellation for violation; with IO empowered to proceed with recoveries under applicable norms.

High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases)

WA No. 811 of 2020 & connected matters (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

These writ appeals arise from common judgments of the Kerala High Court (dated 25.02.2020) in WP(C) Nos. 10107/2019, 29541/2019, 6345/2019, 32695/2019, 30060/2019, 30377/2019, 34673/2019, 28110/2019, 6345/2019, among others, concerning eligibility for higher pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995 and its amendments (notably the 2014 amendment brought by GSR 609(E) dated 22.08.2014). The Division Bench, relying on Sasikumar P. and RC Gupta, held that employees could remit contributions on actual salary to claim higher pension, potentially eroding the pension corpus. The matter was referred to a Full Bench. The Full Bench analyzes the contributory nature of the pension scheme, the balance between regular contributions and corpus growth, and the legal regime governing option and remittance. It ultimately disposes of the appeals in light of the Supreme Court’s decision in Sunil Kumar B. and others (AIR 2022 SC 5634), directing EPFO to reconsider entitlement to higher pension consistent with that jurisprudence and the 2014 amendment framework, while acknowledging Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration in part. The judgment thus mandates a reassessment by the EPFO of higher-pension entitlements in line with the controlling constitutional/SC precedents, and remits other consequential directions to be implemented accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1763 OF 2024

Muhammed Ashique K.G v. State of Kerala

The petitioner, Muhammed Ashique K.G., is the seventh accused in Palluruthy Police Station Crime No. 900/2023, Ernakulam, facing offences under the NDPS Act (Sections 20(b)(ii)(C), 8(c), 25, 27(A), and 29(1)) for involvement in a conspiracy to transport narcotic drugs from Orissa to Kerala for sale. He challenges his pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC, arguing lack of material tying him to the conspiracy, innocence, and that custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The prosecution alleges a criminal conspiracy among accused 1–5 to transport a commercial quantity of ganja, with the first accused transferring money, accused 2–9 procuring 200 kg of ganja from accused 11 and 12, and accused 4–9 transporting the contraband in a lorry owned by the 13th accused, with seizure corroborating the case. The learned Public Prosecutor opposed bail, emphasizing the petitioner’s “criminal antecedents” through a similar offence in Oriya crime No. 34/2023 and asserting that the second limb of Section 37 NDPS applies, disqualifying bail in commercial quantity cases. The court clarifies that Section 37 requires ‘reasonable grounds’ for belief of the accused’s innocence and non-recidivism, citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and subsequent decisions, and notes that the two limbs should be read conjunctively, in light of the matter’s gravity and antecedents. The court ultimately finds no reasonable grounds to grant pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application, applying rigorous NDPS standards alongside general bail parameters.

High Court of Kerala
RP NO. 1231 OF 2023

Jayaprakash A vs Union Bank of India and others

This is a review petition (RP No. 1231 of 2023) by Jayaprakash A challenging the Kerala High Court’s 19 Oct 2023 judgment in W.P.(C) No. 30803 of 2023. The writ petition sought extending Exts. P2–P4 to MSME borrowers like the petitioner and to set aside SARFAESI proceedings initiated by Union Bank of India. The petitioner argued that the bank was duty-bound to constitute a committee before classifying an MSME account as NPA and that the MSMED Act (2006) and its notifications deserve a wide, benevolent interpretation as remedial welfare legislation; the MSMED Act should prevail over recovery actions. The High Court had held that recoveries under SARFAESI prevail over MSMED Act recoveries and that the petitioner had an effective remedy under SARFAESI Chapter VI, Section 13. It also referred to Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited v. Girnar Corrugators Pvt Ltd to interpret the MSMED Act’s scope, and emphasized guidelines on review under Section 114 CPC, citing Sow Chandra Kante, Meera Bhanja, Moran Mar Basselios, T.C. Basappa, Hari Vishnu Kamath, Kerala State Electricity Board, and other authorities. The review petition was dismissed as lacking extraordinary grounds. The order reiterates that review is not a de novo rehearing, and stresses limits on reargument and reappraisal of evidence.