Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 662 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020, 25202/2020, 25209/2020, 25213/2020, 26222/2020, 27386/2020, 22466/2020, 23782/2021, 27795/2021, 29919/2021, 30508/2021, 30564/2021, 30652/2021, 30668/2021, 30679/2021, 7461/2022, 27478/2022, 29383/2022, 35026/2022, 35173/2022, 35231/2022, 35246/2022, 453/2023, 456/2023, 1548/2023, 13827/2023, 16984/2023, 17289/2023, 25635/2023, 25814/2023

WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020 and connected cases, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The Kerala High Court, before Justice Basant Balaji, adjudicated whether Unit Run Canteens (URCs) are ‘the State’ or ‘other authorities’ under Article 12 of the Constitution and whether writs under Article 226 are maintainable against URCs. The judge examined the triad of tests for determining State status—creation, finance, and control—drawn from Ajay Hasia and subsequent authorities. URCs are created by Army orders (AO/19/2003/QMG) and operate as private undertakings financed not from the Consolidated Fund of India but via regimental non-public funds and loans from the Canteen Stores Department (CSD); staff are employed under unit-based SOPs and not as Government servants. The staff and units are managed with staff appointments by the station, with procurement and financial arrangements largely self-contained, and CSD has limited or no pervasive control over URCs. The court also cites cases such as Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Sukhdev Singh, Zee Telefilms, and Rudani to frame the evolving jurisprudence on Article 12’s “other authorities” concept and the breadth of writ jurisdiction. Ultimately, the court held URCs are not State or ‘other authorities’ under Article 12 and dismissed the writ petitions across connected cases, while granting liberty to petitioners to seek remedies under industrial law or other fora. The judgment is accompanied by extensive petitions, exhibits, and annexures.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 11371 OF 2023

FIJO v. Inspector of Police, Koratty Police Station, Thrissur; State of Kerala

This is a bail application by FIJO, the 3rd accused in Crime No.705/2021 of Koratty Police Station, Thrissur, challenging his detention under Section 439 CrPC for alleged offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 25 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act). The prosecution claims that on 12.08.2021, at 10:45 a.m., 20.845 kg of ganja was seized from a vehicle in which accused 1 and 2 were travelling, and that the 3rd accused financed the purchase of the contraband from Andhra Pradesh, implicating him in the crime. FIJO contends innocence and false implication, arguing that he has been in custody since 13.08.2021, the investigation is complete, and co-accused 1 and 2 have already secured bail; he seeks parity and enlargement on bail under Sec. 439 CrPC. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting that FIJO is a history-sheeter with over 20 cases including an IPC 302, and that he financed the transaction, making him unsuitable for bail under NDPS safeguards. Section 37 NDPS Act imposes stringent conditions for bail, requiring the Public Prosecutor’s opposition and “reasonable grounds” to believe the accused not guilty and unlikely to reoffend. Citing Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari, Mohd. Nawaz Khan, Rajesh, Ram Samujh, and Durand Didier, the High Court reiterates a rigorous standard for NDPS bail. The learned Judge ultimately holds that the application is meritless and dismisses it, upholding the NDPS bail framework’s rigidity.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1630 of 2008

Majeed v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal arises from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, whereby the appellant Majeed was sentenced to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 2 lakh fine for possession of 35 litres of illicit spirit found in a bathroom of his Kollam residence. The trial court convicted based on seizure evidence and the prosecution theory that the contraband was under the appellant's dominion. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized the essential ingredient of possession, emphasizing that the Abkari Act requires conscious possession and the prosecution must prove dominion or control over the contraband. The court found deficiencies: the evidence did not establish exclusive possession or dominion by the appellant over the bathroom or the building from which the spirit was seized; it did not identify who handled the can at the time of seizure; the two-building premises created ambiguity about ownership of the bathroom. The court also found that the Chemical Analysis certificate (Ext. P12) had no reliable link to the sample because the forwarding note (Ext. P9) lacked the identity of the forwarding official and the date, and key witnesses were not examined to prove tamper-proof dispatch. Relying on prior decisions (Santhosh v. State of Kerala; Ravi C. v. State; Gunwantlal; Kumaran), the court held that the prosecution failed to prove conscious possession and accordingly acquitted the appellant. Accused No. 2 was acquitted of the offence. The appeal is therefore allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WA 455 of 2023

Surya A.B. v. State of Kerala and others

Surya A.B., the appellant, challenges a writ appeal that upheld a learned Single Judge’s dismissal of her petition seeking a dependency-based eligibility certificate for appointment as a Project Officer in the Fisheries Department. The central issue is whether the applicant, whose father is a fisherman, can be treated as a dependent of a fisherman for eligibility under a direct recruitment notification that restricted appointments to fishermen or dependents of fishermen, with Note (4) mandating a dependency certificate issued by Revenue Officials on the basis of a Fisheries Officer certificate confirming Fishermen status or dependence. The appellant contends that the Single Judge erred in refusing to consider her claim of livelihood dependence on her father, arguing that the grounds for rejection were misconceived and not connected to public employment; she also relies on Supreme Court authorities concerning gender-based restrictions and within-class classifications. The respondents submit that the notification’s terms are clear and that dependency, if any, must be established under the stated procedure, as the appellant and her husband were employed elsewhere. The court notes Ext.P15’s erratum purportedly extending eligibility to living dependents and the Public Service Commission’s role under the extant notes, but ultimately agrees that the appellant failed to prove complete dependence on her fisherman father. The appeal is therefore dismissed, upholding the Single Judge’s order and the prescribed criteria for eligibility under the notification.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 38393 of 2023

Brijesh D. Kaithakkal v. Village Officer, Varapuzha Village Office; Sub Registrar, Alangad; Tahsildar, Paravur; Bank of Baroda; UCO Bank

This writ petition concerns a property dispute arising from SARFAESI proceedings against a borrower, where the petitioner, Brijesh D. Kaithakkal, purchased 6.80 ares in Sy No. 409/1-26 of Varapuzha Village under Ext. P1 sale certificate issued in favour of the petitioner after SARFAESI auction. The mortgage was created by Tiny Tomy by equitable mortgage with deposit of original sale deeds in favour of Bank of Baroda on 10.09.2013. The loan later defaulted, leading to a public auction on 24.02.2020 and sale certificate issued to the petitioner. Subsequently, the 1st respondent refused mutation of title, citing an attachment (E.P.No.270/2013 in O.S.No.144/2012) recorded by the Sub Court Ernakulam at the instance of the 5th respondent bank. Encumbrance Certificate Ext. P4 shows the attachment dated 07.02.2015. The petitioner contends that attachments created after the equitable mortgage cannot affect the SARFAESI sale and must be effaced to render marketable title. The respondents rely on the legal framework and prior orders; however, the court ultimately relies on Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar and Keechery Service Co-operative Bank decisions, and Phoenic ARC Pvt. Ltd. v. Sub Registrar, Feroke, to hold that subsequent attachments lose efficacy and should be obliterated from records. The court directs mutation and effacement of the encumbrance, disposing of the petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.2145 of 2007

Kishore v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal by Kishore challenging his conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court, Fast Track II, Ad hoc, Thrissur, in SC No. 30/2006. On 10 June 2003, at about 10:45 a.m., the accused was found in possession of 2 ¼ litres of arrack at Kuttipadam Desom, within Muriyad Village, Thrissur District, in violation of the Abkari Act. The prosecution submitted final reports and the case was committed to the Sessions Court and then to the Trial Court, which convicted him under Sections 8(2) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act. Prosecution evidence consisted of five witnesses and documentary exhibits Exts. P1–P13 and MOs 1–2. The defence raised two core challenges: (i) identity of the person found with the contraband, and (ii) whether the contraband was subjected to Chemical Examiner analysis. The High Court scrutinised the identification process, noting that PW1 and others identified the accused four years after the seizure without a prior test identification parade, rendering such identification unsafe. It also found defects in Ext. P1 seizure mahazar and Ext. P4 forwarding note, and absence of testimony from court staff and an Excise Guard who delivered the sample for analysis. Relying on Kumaran, Sasidharan, Daulat Ram and related authorities, the court held that the link between the seized contraband and the laboratory analysis was not proven. Consequently, the conviction was set aside and the appellant acquitted; the appeal was allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.25648 OF 2020

Mukesh and Others v. Union of India and Others

This writ petition, filed by twenty-seven retired employees of Bharath Petroleum Corporation Limited, EPF subscribers, challenges Employees' Provident Fund Scheme 2014 (GSR 609(E) dated 22-08-14) and seeks a higher pension entitlement under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. The petitioners contend that the pension must be calculated and paid under the Pension Scheme without being limited by the maximum pensionable salary cap prescribed in para 11(3) of the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995, and that they be permitted to exercise the option to contribute on actual salaries drawn, on a time-bound basis, in line with para 26 of the Provident Fund Scheme. They rely on earlier judicial directions and on established rights under the EPF framework. The petition asserts that the 2014 Scheme unfairly restricts pension benefits and deprives them of rightful gratuities and pension enhancements. The Union of India and EPFO respond by invoking a binding Supreme Court ruling in EPF Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B and Others (2022), which they say settles the issue and requires reconsideration consistent with that decision. The court, on 17 August 2023, disposes of the petition with a direction to re-consider the claims of the petitioners in light of the Supreme Court dictum, within three months from receipt of a copy of the judgment, thereby ensuring uniform application and remedy.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.7909 of 2024

K.P. Yusuf v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Thrissur

The petition challenges Ext. P-7, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting the petitioner’s Form 5 application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008. Petitioner K.P. Yusuf claims absolute ownership of about 7.28 acres in Survey No. 708/19 and 20.24 acres in Survey No. 708/3 & 709/1 in Ayyanthole, Thrissur, land long labelled as paddy land in Revenue records and included in the Data Bank covering 27.52 acres. He contends the land was not converted prior to 2008 and that neither he nor his predecessors cultivated it; the Data Bank status cannot substitute for the true status as of 12.08.2008. Ext. P-7, dated 30.06.2023, rejects Form 5 and directs consideration of KSREC/LLMC data, relying on a report from the Agricultural Officer. The petitioner argues the RDO did not apply his mind, did not inspect the property, and acted mechanically by adopting LLMC/KSREC findings without independent assessment. The court notes Ext. P-7 is not a speaking order and cites Muraleedharan Nair v. Revenue Divisional Officer and Aparna Sasi Menon v. Revenue Divisional Officer to emphasize independent evaluation and the predominant criterion for Form 5 is whether the land can be cultivated with paddy. Consequently, the court sets aside Ext. P-7 and directs the RDO to reconsider Form 5 within three months, with KSREC report to be obtained if sought, and compliance within three months from KSREC."

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2254 OF 2024

SAMBHUSEKHAR and others vs STATE OF KERALA

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 2254 of 2024) under Section 482 CrPC, filed by six petitioners-accused in Crime No.172/2024 of Vilappilsala Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The FIR alleges offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 326, 367 and 427 r/w 149 IPC, arising from an incident on 20.02.2024 in which the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly, abducted and assaulted the de facto complainant, and caused grievous hurt. The petition contends that the parties have settled their disputes and wish to quash the prosecution; the victim has filed an affidavit supporting the compromise, and the victim’s side openly states no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations but conceded the matter is settled. The court examines jurisprudence beginning with State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688), which holds that under Section 482 CrPC, non-compoundable offences may be quashed when disputes are private and settled, subject to checks outlined in Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, among others. The judgment reiterates the need to balance private settlement against societal interest and, on consideration, concludes the dispute here is private and the settlement acceptable. Accordingly, the court allows the CrLC.MC and quashes all further proceedings in the crime case against the petitioners on 23.04.2024.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020; 25202/2020; 25209/2020; 25213/2020; 26222/2020; 27386/2020; 22466/2021; 23782/2021; 27795/2021; 29919/2021; 30508/2021; 30564/2021; 30652/2021; 30668/2021; 30679/2021; 7461/2022; 29383/2022; 35026/2022; 35173/2022; 35231/2022; 35246/2022; 453/2023; 456/2023; 1548/2023; 13827/2023; 16984/2023; 17289/2023; 25635/2023; 25814/2023; 17289/2023

WP(C) Nos. 2517 of 2020 and connected cases (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

The judgment deals with a cluster of writ petitions challenging amendments and arrangements related to Unit Run Canteens (URCs) run by the Canteen Stores Department (CSD) for Army personnel, including ex-servicemen and dependents. The petitioners argue that URCs and the associated SOPs and extension orders affect their employment and status, seeking relief under Articles 226 of the Constitution. The respondents contend that URCs are private units operating with regimental funds and non-government financing, not State instrumentalities or authorities, and thus not amenable to writ jurisdiction. The court undertakes a constitutional inquiry into whether URCs fall under Article 12 as “State” or “other authority,” applying the Ajay Hasia framework (creation, finance, control) and accrues from multiple judgments on the reach of Article 12. After examining creation by AO/19/2003/QMG, non-consolidated fund financing, and lack of pervasive Government control, the court holds that URCs do not constitute “State” or “other authority” under Article 12. Consequently, the writ petitions are dismissed, though liberty is granted to petitioners to pursue appropriate remedies (e.g., industrial disputes) and to approach the proper fora for redressal. The decision is delivered by a Single Judge, Justice Basant Balaji, on 04-03-2024.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1933 OF 2007

SADASIVAN @ SADAN v. STATE OF KERALA

The appellant, Sadasan alias Sadasivan, was convicted by the Additional Judge/Special NDPS Court, Thodupuzha, under Section 55(g) of the Abkari Act for possession of 50 litres of wash intended for manufacturing arrack, and was sentenced to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1 lakh with a default sentence. The High Court of Kerala, in a 14 February 2022 judgment, allowed the criminal appeal and acquitted the accused, setting aside the trial court’s conviction. The prosecution case alleged seizure of wash on 04.02.2002 from the appellant’s property, followed by the sample being sent for chemical analysis (Ext.P9). The defense argued that the evidence did not prove conscious possession or the appellant’s intent to manufacture liquor, and highlighted defects in the chain of evidence: soil concealment, a 70-cent property with no proper boundary, lack of a clear link between seizure and the sample analyzed, delay in producing Ext.P5 before the court, and absence of a specimen seal on the seizure mahazar (Ext.P1). The court stressed strict adherence to statutory procedures under the Abkari Act and the necessity of proving that the specific sample tested indeed originated from the seized contraband. Relying on Kerala decisions such as Moothedath Sivadasan and Baburaj, it held that the prosecution’s case fell short of beyond reasonable doubt.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C.NO.1106 OF 2022

P. GOPALAKRISHNAN @ DILEEP v. STATE OF KERALA & OTHERS

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.M.C. 1106 of 2022) filed by P. Gopalakrishnan @ Dileep seeking to quash Annexure-9 FIR registered as Crime No.6/2022 by the Crime Branch, Ernakulam, alleging offences under sections including 506, 116, 118, 120B read with 34 IPC. The FIR arises from disclosures surrounding a prequel case (297/2017) connected with a sexual assault incident against a Malayalam film actress and alleged manipulation of the investigation by a Special Investigation Team led by senior police officers. The petitioner contends the FIR was improperly registered in contravention of Section 154 CrPC, claiming lack of cognizable offences and a malafide motive to trap him, with a broader conspiracy to frame him in the 297/2017 matter. The 3rd respondent’s 161 CrPC statements and a post-revelation report (Annexures 10–12) form the basis of Annexure-9. The court examines whether the information in the FIR discloses cognizable offences, especially conspiracy under Sections 120A/120B, and whether the registration was valid. It also considers whether to transfer the investigation to the CBI. The court ultimately declines quashing the FIR and rejects transfer to the CBI, holding that the information discloses a cognizable conspiracy and that interference at this stage is unwarranted. The petition is thus dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(FC) No.540 of 2022

Justine @ Joseph and others v. Mareena George

This is an original petition (OP)(FC) No.540 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court, challenging Ext.P5 in EA 8/2022 in EP No.3 of 2016 from the Family Court, Pala. The decree under scrutiny, dated 01.12.2012, granted the wife recovery of patrimony: Rs.8,70,601 against the husband and in‑laws, 53 sovereigns of gold valued at Rs.12,72,000, and an almirah and dress valued at Rs.70,000, with interest at 9% per annum from decree until realization. After Mat.Appeal No.173 of 2013 was dismissed in 2019, a review in RP No.175 of 2021 reduced the interest on the cash and the gold to 6% per annum from the date of disposal of the appeal, 17.05.2022. The petition challenges EA No.8/2022, which computed 6% interest on the alternate relief of the market value of gold from 26.07.2019 (date of disposal of the appeal) rather than from 17.05.2022. The court notes that the decree cannot be rewritten but may be recalculated, especially given the drastic rise in gold prices, and that delay could cause injustice. It cites Syamini S Nair v. Sreekanth to illustrate potential injustices of gold‑value relief and directs the petitioners to be given 15 days to return 53 sovereigns in specie. Ext.P5 is set aside; the Family Court is to recalculate the due amount and execute within two months, with options for adjustment if the gold is returned.

High Court of Kerala
CMR No.1 of 2010

Council of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. Shri George Thomas, Chartered Accountant

This is a Civil Miscellaneous Reference (CMR No.1 of 2010) before the Kerala High Court in which the Council of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India seeks guidance under Section 21(5) of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 following a Disciplinary Committee inquiry into allegations of professional misconduct by Shri George Thomas, a Chartered Accountant, in auditing accounts of the All Kerala Association for the Mentally Retarded (AKAMR). The disciplinary proceedings traced back to a 1996-2001 audit of the Development Centre for the Mentally Retarded (DCMR), where thumb-impression receipts were accepted as vouchers for travel allowances to differently-abled students. The Disciplinary Committee held that the respondent failed to exercise due professional skill, combining to find misconduct under Clauses (6) and (7) of Part I of the Second Schedule, and under Section 22 read with Section 21 of the Act, recommending reprimand. The Council recommended reprimand; the petitioner contends that the court should not disturb the Council's view. The respondent contends that not all allegations were established; the appropriate remedy may be remitted. The High Court, after reviewing record and considering authorities, upholds the Council's reprimand and dismisses the reference, concluding that reprimand is the appropriate punishment.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 2275 OF 2023

R. Manikuttan and others v. Registrar, Nair Service Society (NSS) and others

This Original Petition (OP(C) No. 2275 of 2023) challenges an Ext.P1 order of a Sub Court in Kattappana, dismissing an amendment to the suit filed by the petitioners, who claim to be office bearers of the NSS Taluk Union, High Range, Idukki. The petition seeks a declaration that the petitioners continue in office as per bye-laws, and two prohibitory/mando­tory injunctions: to stop obstruction by the Registrar in discharging their duties and to direct elections to NSS Taluk Union in accordance with the bye-laws. By Ext.P9, the petitioners sought to amend pleadings to include a relief for conducting elections to the Karayogams (village-level bodies) under the Taluk Union, arguing pendente lite expiries of prathinidhis created a real controversy and that such elections are necessary to realize the main relief. The Sub Judge rejected the amendment under the proviso to Order VI, Rule 17 CPC, holding it belated, enlarging the scope of the suit, and causing a de novo trial. The High Court dismisses the petition, holding that the amendment is barred by the proviso to Order VI, Rule 17, that the amendment would enlarge the scope in an unacceptable manner, that due diligence was not satisfied, and that the relief sought is not necessary to determine the real controversy. The court also notes that the Registrar’s power and quorum rules under bye-laws do not mandate such an amendment at this stage. Consequently, the petition is dismissed for lack of merit.

High Court of Kerala
TR.APPEAL(C) NO. 21 OF 2023; TR.APPEAL(C) NO. 22 OF 2023

Transfer Appeal (C) Nos. 21 and 22 of 2023

Two Transfer Appeals under Section 5 of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958 (TR.APPEAL(C) Nos. 21 of 2023 and 22 of 2023) arise from a common order dated 16 November 2023 passed by a learned Single Judge in Transfer Petitions Nos. 551 and 552 of 2023, seeking to transfer two original petitions from the Family Court at Kasargod to the Family Court at Pala. The appellants, Retheesh Kumar and Retheesh Kumar K., challenge the order, arguing that Kasargod should be the natural forum or that the transfer should be allowed on grounds of convenience and to avoid practical difficulties for the family and schooling of the children. The respondent, Sandhya K.S., opposes the transfer and contends that the Family Court at Kasargod has jurisdiction; she also indicates willingness to participate in mediation. The High Court, after reciting the relevant provisions of the CPC, particularly Section 24 (transfer and withdrawal) and Section 25 (power of Supreme Court to transfer), notes that Section 24(1) empowers a transfer by the court and that post-transfer, the case may be retried from the transfer point. It emphasizes that forum convenience is not ordinarily a factor except in extraordinary circumstances, and directs the Family Court Kasargode to dispense with the petitioner's presence except where indispensable. Ultimately, applying the well‑established caution urged in Balan v. Sivagiri Sree Narayana Dharma Sanghom Trust, the Division Bench disposes of the appeals by dismissing them, while keeping the possibility of mediation open. The judgment underscores that the two courts retain jurisdiction, and the petitioners’ attempt to shift the trial forum is rejected.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.1266 of 2024

Deepak Johnson v. State of Kerala

Deepak Johnson, the fifth accused in Crime No.19/2023 of the Excise Enforcement and Anti Narcotic Special Squad, Thiruvananthapuram, petitions under Section 439 CrPC for bail in the NDPS case involving a large seizure. The prosecution alleges that on 9 July 2023, the accused, in furtherance of a conspiracy with seven others, possessed 155.480 kg of ganja and 70.71 g of methamphetamine for sale, in a car and at a rented premises in Pallithura, Kerala. The state contends that the petitioner resided with accused 1–3 in the same rented premises, engaged in numerous telephonic and financial transactions with them, and even accompanied them to Karnataka to procure the contraband; a landlord-witness identified him as part of the group. The contraband is described as a commercial quantity, bringing Section 37 of the NDPS Act into play, which mandates stringent safeguards in bail matters, including opportunity for the Public Prosecutor to oppose and a court to be satisfied of reasonable grounds for belief that the accused is not guilty and is unlikely to commit an offence while on bail. The applicant argues innocence, alleging false implication, with Annexure A2 showing no incriminating material beyond co-accused confessions and some financial links; he was indisposed (chicken pox) at the time of the incident. The court, applying established bail paradigms from NDPS and CrPC, cites Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari, Union of India v. Mohd. Nawaz Khan, and Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, and dismisses the bail plea for the fifth accused, concluding prima facie incriminating materials and the gravity of the offence.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 21231/2023 & connected cases

Kaprat Family Trust v Union of India & connected cases

This batch of writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 21231/2023 and connected cases) concerns Kaprat Family Trust’s challenge to the CALA orders under the National Highways Act, 1956 in the context of acquisition for NH-66. The core issue is the proper scope of enquiry by the Competent Authority for Land Acquisition (CALA) under Section 3H(3) and when a dispute as to apportionment or entitlement to compensation must be referred to the Principal Civil Court under Section 3H(4). The petitions rely on Ext. P1 partition deed (752/1959, dated 10.10.1958) endowing properties for family deities, and assert that items listed in Schedule A of the partition deed were owned by deities and thus subject to family trust entitlements. They also rely on Certificate of Purchase under Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 (Section 72K) to challenge CALA’s determinations. Respondents submit that CALA’s determinations under 3G/3H are adequate and that a mere purchase certificate or partition deed cannot by itself create a “dispute arises” requiring referral under 3H(4). The High Court held that CALA must determine entitlements under 3H(3), and only if a genuine dispute as to entitlement or apportionment arises should 3H(4) apply. The judgment confirms CALA orders in most petitions, dismisses two, and directs CALA to disburse amounts; petitioners may pursue challenges to purchase certificates separately.

High Court of Kerala
WA 48/2020 (and connected cases)

State of Kerala v. Baiju A.A (and batch of connected writ petitions)

This is a batch of writ appeals filed by the State of Kerala and statutory functions challenging amendments made to the Kerala KVAT Act, 2003 by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018. The core issue is whether the amendments altering the period of reopening assessments under Section 25(1) of the KVAT Act (from five years to six years, and extending the period for proceedings including those under Section 25B up to 31 March 2019) operate retrospectively or prospectively, and whether the State Legislature had competence to enact these changes after the transition to the GST regime and repeal of KVAT under the Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 2016. The petitioners contend that the amendments either extend rights retrospectively or lack legislative competence post-CAA 2016, especially after KVAT’s repeal and the KGST regime’s savings clause. The Kerala High Court, in a landmark, consolidated judgment, held that the 2017 amendment is prospective and that the 2018 extension is beyond the State’s constitutional competence in the post-GST framework. It discusses Article 246A, the CAA 2016 sunset clause, the saving provision under KGST, and various constitutional and jurisprudential authorities, including references to Baiju A.A, Hajee Abdul Shakoor, Jyoti Traders, Calcutta Discount Co., Reliance, and Mohit Minerals. The Court ultimately dismissed the batch of writ appeals, upholding the constitutionality and prospective operation of the amendments to Section 25(1).

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1771 OF 2008

John @ Podimon Cardose v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 1771 of 2008) by the sole accused John @ Podimon Cardose challenging a conviction under sections 8(1) & (2) of the Kerala Abkari Act in SC 522/2005 before the Additional District and Sessions Judge (Adhoc) II, Kollam. The prosecution case rests on a 22.07.2002 detection of contraband (a 10-litre can containing 5 litres of arrack) by a Preventive Officer of the Excise Range, Karungapally, who intercepted the accused with a bag. The trial court sentenced the accused to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 1,00,000 fine, with an additional six months’ simple imprisonment on default. The appellant contends that (i) there is a two-day delay in producing the contraband without explanation, (ii) the case was registered by an Assistant Excise Inspector who was not authorized to register the case at the time of detection, and (iii) the forwarding note was not produced; these defects break the chain of evidence. The Public Prosecutor argued that the evidence (PW1–PW5, Exhibits P1–P8, MO1–MO2) suffices to sustain conviction. The High Court ultimately held that the forwarding note’s non-production is fatal, and considering delays and officer authorization, allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction and sentence, and ordered the accused’s release, with bail bond canceled.