Yazin Sasi, the first accused in Crime No.1738/2023 of the Ernakulam Town North Police Station, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC after arrest for alleged offences under Sections 22(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act. The prosecution case rests on a 26 July 2023 seizure at Ascot Hotel, SRM Road, Ernakulam, where MDMA was allegedly seized from four accused in four separate packets, subsequently consolidated into a single packet weighing roughly 60.45 g (58.82 g after deducting the pocket weight). The chemical analysis reportedly identified methamphetamine instead of MDMA. The petitioner challenges the seizure, inventory, sampling and disposal procedures under the NDPS Act and the 2022 Rules, arguing violations of Sections 42 and 52A and Rules 3, 5, 8, 9 and 10, and contends the Detecting Officer improperly merged the four packets without magistrate approval, compromising a fair trial. The Public Prosecutor contends the contraband constitutes a commercial quantity, invoking Section 37’s rigour, and asserts joint liability under Section 29; he relies on various precedents to argue that procedural irregularities are trial issues. The judge grants bail, finding that procedural violations prejudiced the accused and, given no criminal antecedents, that the rigour of Section 37 is diluted. Bail is granted with conditions, without deciding merits.
This writ appeal challenges the Kerala High Court (Division Bench) decision dated 7 February 2019 in W.P.(C) No. 38875 of 2015, regarding salary claims of teachers in an aided school. The Manager of Niduvaloor AUP School appointed two teachers (petitioners 2 and 3) in 2004-2005, where vacancies and preferential claims of other teachers under Rule 51A were involved. The Educational Officer declined to approve these appointments, and later judgments/Orders (Exts. P1, P13) directed/considered rearrangements and approvals. The Government contends that the State’s liability to pay salary to teachers in aided schools arises only for appointments duly approved against sanctioned posts, and that the appointments here were illegal and void for contravening the Act and the Rules. The petitioners argued that they worked in sanctioned posts and that, as in several precedents, they should be paid salary notwithstanding non-approval, citing Man Singh, Selvaraj and other decisions, along with Turquand’s Rule and de facto doctrine. The Court analyzed the statutory framework (Kerala Education Act, Rules Chapter XIVA, Rules 7, 43, 51A, etc.) and concluded that salaries are payable by the State only for positions duly approved; otherwise, payment would be improper. It found the earlier view that compelled salary for unapproved appointments inappropriate, and held that the impugned judgment was unsustainable. The appeal was allowed and the impugned judgment was set aside.
WP(C) Nos.30515/2021 & 7574/2022 The Kerala High Court, in a consolidated writ petition challenging KITCO Ltd’s termination of an academic block project and related payments, examines whether KITCO qualifies as a State under Article 12 and whether a writ under Article 226 is maintainable when the dispute is contractual. Disputes had arisen over slow progress, extra items, and cost overruns in a contract awarded through KITCO for the Institute of Hospitality Management. Bank guarantees were sought to be encashed, and earlier interim orders stayed coercive action; termination order dated 20.11.2021 is now under challenge. The petitioners sought mandamus to pay amounts due on various works, arguing that KITCO’s structure and governance imply public function and state control, and that disputes are inherently public in nature; hence a writ should be entertained. KITCO’s counsel counters that KITCO is a private company under the Companies Act with no Government majority control; Article 12 protection does not extend to it; disputes pertain to contract and are not amenable to writ jurisdiction. The court first examined maintainability, referring to jurisprudence on State or instrumentality status. It ultimately held KITCO is not an authority under Article 12; relying on Ajay Hasia and K.J. Johnson, and clarifying the scope of “other authorities” per Pradeepkumar Biswas. Consequently, the writ petitions were dismissed, with liberty to pursue civil remedies, and with a possible exclusion of pendency for limitation.
Udayan, aged 38, was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-I), Pathanamthitta, for possessing 5 litres of arrack in a black can at Poozhikadu muri on 25.08.2003. The High Court’s criminal appeal challenges the conviction and sentence: (1) the arrest of the accused; (2) whether the contraband allegedly seized reached the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory in tamper-proof condition; and (3) whether the sample actually tested in the lab was the same as that seized. The trial court’s findings relied on Exts. P1–P4 and MO1, but the defense contends that the arrest memo was never produced and that the lab analysis cannot be linked to the seized sample due to gaps in the chain of custody, sealing, forwarding notes, and their descriptions. The Court emphasizes mandatory arrest memo and strict chain-of-custody formalities, drawing on D.K. Basu and subsequent Kerala authorities (Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Bhaskaran, Rajamma, Ramachandran) to stress that non-compliance defeats the prosecution’s case. It notes issues such as lack of arrest memo, missing forwarding note, and absence of specimen seal production, which undermine the genuineness of the sample and its analysis. Consequently, the High Court holds that the link between arrest, seizure, and chemical analysis is not established, acquits the accused, and allows the appeal.
Global Missions India, a society registered under the Travancore Cochin Literary, Scientific and Charitable Societies Registration Act, 1955, runs a Pentecostal Church. The petition seeks writs of mandamus to respondents 1–4 to provide police protection to its office bearers against alleged threats by respondents 5–7 and others, and to ensure compliance with Ext.P4’s injunction and maintain law and order. The short facts reveal a dispute within the Mission’s leadership: Late P.M. Baby (father of respondent 5) was a former Secretary and was expelled for acting against the Mission; suits were filed (O.S. 173/2015, 287/2016, 116/2018) before the Munsiff, Peerumedu, which were decreed in the petitioner’s favour, restraining Baby from collecting money, alienating properties, or using the church’s name/emblem. Although interim injunctions were issued (O.S. 7/2023), the petition contends that respondents 5–7 continue activities in violation of these directions, including public meetings and collection of funds. The petitioner approached the District authorities under Section 63 of the Kerala Police Act, seeking police protection and enforcement of the injunction (Ext.P4) with Ext.P8. The respondents contested, arguing civil-in-nature disputes and the police’s limited role in enforcing civil orders. The High Court, citing Krishnan B.K., Kunhumuhammed, and Raman, held that police protection based on ex parte civil orders is inappropriate; the remedy lies in civil courts and execution. The petition is dismissed, directing the petitioner to seek relief through civil-court channels and execution proceedings.
A.S Nos.474 & 549 of 2001 These appeals arise from a suit filed for specific performance and partition in OS 838/1995, Thrissur, based on Ext. A2 dated 12-09-1986, by which four co-owners agreed to sell 4 cents within six months. An advance of Rs. 24,500 was paid, and over a long period (approx. nine years) the period was extended 26 times. In the intervening period, a total of Rs. 49,500 was paid, and the legal heirs of deceased co-owners were not originally impleaded. The trial court decreed specific performance but did not grant partition. The plaintiff appealed in AS 474/2001; the defeated defendants (AS 549/2001) appealed challenging the mental element of readiness and willingness required under Section 16 of the Specific Relief Act, arguing that direct evidence by the plaintiff was not necessary where the power holder testified and corroborating documentary evidence existed. The respondents contended that the prolonged extensions, unilateral acts by the first defendant, and partial payments undermined readiness and willingness. The Kerala High Court, without overturning the core principles, examined the attending circumstances and extensions, and exercised its discretion under Section 20 of the Act to fashion relief. Ultimately, both appeals were allowed in part, directing the plaintiff to be paid Rs.10,00,000 with limited interest, and ordering return of a quarter of the total advance (Rs.49,500) along with deposits and interest, while leaving tenancy rights open. The judgment emphasizes evaluating readiness and willingness in light of attested circumstances and endorses relief under Section 20 where appropriate.
The petitioner Rashiq KS moved the Kerala High Court (WP(Crl.) No. 246 of 2024) seeking a writ of habeas corpus and related relief to secure the release of Mrs. X, an adult woman who the petitioner says is illegally detained by the 3rd to 5th respondents. Mrs. X left her matrimonial home on 13 January 2024 after marital discord. A complaint was filed; the detenu was produced before the magistrate and released on the ground that she left voluntarily. The petitioner contends that the detenu is being forcibly detained by her husband (a police officer) and her father, and seeks her production before the court, protection for both Mrs. X and the petitioner, and production before a medical board to assess her sound mind. The Court initially directed production and counseling at the Family Counselling Centre, and the detenu was subsequently accommodated at the SAKHI, One Stop Centre at Kakkanad with ongoing interaction by a counsellor. On 11 June 2024, after further interaction, Mrs. X informed the Court she is an adult, desires not to join either her husband or parents, wishes to meet her child, and does not suffer psychiatric illness. Relying on Supreme Court precedents on habeas corpus—Devu G. Nair; Shafin Jahan; Anuj Garg; Gian Devi—the Court held that the detenu’s choice must be respected and released Mrs. X from detention. The petition was disposed of accordingly.
These connected writ appeals arise from orders passed by a learned Single Judge in WP(C) Nos. 10107/2019, 29541/2019, and related petitions, challenging the computation of pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995 (as amended by 2014) and the consequent remittance of higher pension contributions. The petitions argued that pension should be calculated without the ceiling of the salary cap, i.e., on actual salary, and that the 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22.08.2014) and associated directions should be read into the scheme, effectively enabling higher pension on actual wages. The Division Bench referred certain questions to a Full Bench, noting the need to re-examine Sasikumar P. v. Union of India ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614 and RC Gupta v. Regional PF Commissioner (2018) 14 SCC 809 in light of subsequent Supreme Court rulings, particularly Sunil Kumar B. and others v. EPFO (AIR 2022 SC 5634). The Full Bench ultimately holds that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration and that Sunil Kumar B. provides controlling guidance. The court disposes of the appeals by applying the Sunil Kumar framework, directing the EPFO to reconsider entitlement to higher pension and to proceed in accordance with the Court’s directions in Sunil Kumar, including actuarial considerations and potential time-bound remedies. The judgment emphasizes corpus preservation and uniform treatment among members, while acknowledging the need for central action and actuarial valuation.
BAIL APPL. NO. 981 OF 2024 This is a bail application by Haris A.K. in Crime No.963/2023 of Kasaragod Police Station, Kasaragod district, seeking bail under Section 439 CrPC. The accused faces offences under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 308 read with Section 34 IPC following an incident on 25.10.2023 at a cricket ground, in which the de facto complainant was allegedly assaulted by accused 1 to 3; the second accused is said to have struck with a pipe causing grievous injuries. The petitioner contends that he is innocent and has been falsely implicated; after surrender on 16.01.2024 he has remained in judicial custody. The investigation is described as practically complete; the only non-bailable count is 308 IPC; the wound certificate has not been produced; the Sessions Court had previously refused bail. The learned counsel for the petitioner argues that continued detention is unnecessary and that the petitioner is willing to abide by strict conditions. The Public Prosecutor opposing bail contends that the investigation is ongoing and that the 308 charge is serious, and the wound certificate is missing. The High Court, while noting the custody period and the near completion of investigation, allows bail on a bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, subject to conditions including regular appearances, non-interference with witnesses, nondetention of passport, and potential cancellation on breach. The court also cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State to sustain the principle that investigation may proceed under bail.
BAIL APPL. NO.1716 OF 2024 This bail application under section 439 CrPC concerns Naresh and Mahendra Kumar, accused 1 and 2 in Crime No.304/2024, Ernakulam Town South Police Station, charged under section 420 read with section 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that, through their employer’s medical establishment named New Life Diagnostics at Pallimukku, Ernakulam, the petitioners conspired to cheat the de facto complainant and others by promising to issue medical certificates enabling overseas employment, and collected Rs 18,000 without issuing receipts; the tests were conducted without proper licensing, rendering the certificates invalid. The petitioners contend they were merely employees following their employer’s instructions and that the offence under section 420 IPC cannot be fastened on them; they have been in custody since 17 February 2024, and the investigation is almost complete, with recovery effected, and no prior criminal record. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, arguing the petitioners have no roots in Kerala and may flee, and the investigation requires time to gather all angles. The High Court found that the petitioners are employees, not principal offenders, and that the absence of roots in Kerala and the small amount involved, along with the lack of any antecedents, warrants consideration of bail. Relying on Hussainara Khatoon’s principles, the court allowed the application, but with stringent bail conditions including bond Rs 1,00,000 each, two solvent sureties, regular appearances, travel restrictions, and other conditions, to safeguard the ongoing investigation.
This is a criminal appeal from S.C No.346/2005, tried for offences under Section 55(a) and Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The appellant was found in possession of about 3 litres of arrack in a 5‑litre can in a public place in front of Parappuram Kunju’s house at Anakkara Village, Thrithala region, on 08.10.1998. He was arrested and the contraband seized. The case travelled from the Judicial Magistrate of First Class Pattambi to the Sessions Court, Palakkad, and was tried as S.C No.346/2005 before the Fast Track Court‑III, Palakkad, resulting in a conviction. The Sessions Court sentenced the accused to two years’ simple imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 and a default sentence of six months. The appeal challenges several points: (i) a delay of over five years in filing the final report, allegedly violating Section 50 of the Abkari Act; (ii) lack of proof that the sample subjected to chemical analysis was the same sample drawn from the accused, as Ext. P2 does not record the seal impression or its description; (iii) absence of seal comparison in the chemical analysis report. The Public Prosecutor contends that the available materials suffice for conviction. The High Court found merit in the appellant’s grounds, relying on precedents, and concluded that the chain of evidence was not proven and that prejudice to the accused existed, ultimately acquitting the appellant. The court’s reasoning underscores the necessity of an unbroken chain of custody and timely investigation in Abkari prosecutions.
CRL.A No. 2388 of 2006; CRL.A No. 597 of 2010; CRL.A No. 2356 of 2009 This judgment consolidates three criminal appeals (CRL.A. Nos. 2388 of 2006, 2356 of 2009 and 597 of 2010) heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court on 18 March 2024. The core prosecution case arises from Crime No. 24 of 2004 registered at Ernakulam Town South Police Station, based on PW2 Anilkumar’s statement that PW1 Shiju and PW3 were attacked by Shibu (Accused No.1) and others on 25 January 2004, near Thevara–Konthuruthy Road, resulting in grave injuries to PW1, PW2, and PW3. The trial court convicted the 1st accused under multiple IPC provisions (Sections 143, 148, 324, 326, 307 read with 149, and 120B/109 IPC), while acquitting others. On appeal, the court held that the identification of accused Nos. 2–9 was not sufficiently established, and that PW2’s inconsistent versions compromised reliability. It affirmed the conviction of the 1st accused (Shibu) while setting aside the conviction of the 7th accused and upholding acquittals of 2–6, 8, 9. The appellate court also relied on jurisprudence governing appeals against acquittals (Chandrappa, Shyam Babu, Ravi Sharma, Shyam Bihari, etc.). The final orders modified the sentence for the 1st accused (reducing 326/307 to 5 years each) and disposed of the three appeals as partly allowed/partly dismissed. The Court directed surrender within one month for execution of sentence.
The appellant Vinod Kumar V., who had filed O.P.(M.V.) No.1549/2003 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Attingal, seeks compensation for injuries from a motor accident on 12 April 2001 when the autorickshaw capsized due to the negligent driving of the 2nd respondent. The Tribunal found the accident was caused by the 2nd respondent but exonerated the 3rd respondent insurer on the ground that the policy stood in the name of Thomas, a person not impleaded as a party. The insurer’s liability for third-party claims under the Motor Vehicles Act (Sections 147 and 157) was not in dispute, but the tribunal’s exoneration was challenged. The High Court held that policy ownership alone cannot absolve the insurer where the vehicle owner is identifiable and the policy coverage extends to third parties; it relied on Section 157 (deemed transfer) and Section 147 to hold the 3rd respondent liable. The court reassessed the compensation, accepting a monthly income of Rs.3,000 (citing Ramachandrappa) and increasing the disability and other heads of compensation to Rs.87,730 in total. The order directs deposit of the amount with interest and clarifies the treatment of a long delay in payment.
This is a writ appeal under WA No. 477 of 2024 arising from WP(C) No. 3661 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court. The appellant, S. Vijayan, proprietor of Pooja Cashew Factory, challenged the demand-recovery notices issued for dues under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) and Central Sales Tax Act (CST Act) for several assessment years. He had opted for settlement under Amnesty Scheme 2020, and on 28.11.2020, he applied for settlement for various years. The department intimated on 12.02.2021 that Rs. 1,28,373 would be payable in one installment (or Rs. 1,60,465 in four installments with a cut-off date). Instead of paying, Vijayan requested adjustment of Rs. 5 lakh refund due to him against the Amnesty settlement, relying on a 2020 judgment (Steel Exchange India Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner) and its Division Bench affirmation (WA No. 189 of 2021). The department treated this as non-compliance, issuing recovery notices. The Single Judge dismissed the petition, holding Amnesty Scheme to be a self-contained code and functus officio post its settlement order. The Division Bench, after considering arguments and a counter-affidavit, held that adjustment of the refund towards Amnesty settlement was permissible, citing Steel Exchange. The court directed that Rs. 1,60,465 be deducted from the Rs. 5 lakh refund and the balance used to settle other dues or future Amnesty Scheme allocations; the Amnesty terms for the opted years were thus treated as finally settled. The appeal was allowed with directions to adjust the refund accordingly.
Shaji, the appellant, challenges a 2007 conviction under Section 8(2) Abkari Act by the IV Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Thodupuzha, on the ground that the prosecution failed to establish the chain of custody and other procedural safeguards. Police recovered 2 litres of illicit arrack from the accused's shop on 10.07.2005. The trial court convicted after examining witnesses and documentary exhibits, but the defense argued that there was inordinate delay in producing the seized articles (Ext. P9) and that the sample and residue were not properly proven to have reached the Chemical Examiner, raising doubts about the integrity of the analysis. The defense also contended that there was no arrest memo, questioning whether the arrest itself was properly established. The High Court scrutinizes these contentions in light of established precedents. It cites Ravi v. State of Kerala for the principle that delay in producing seized property requires explanation, Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala on seal and custody of samples, and Daulat Rama and Sasidharan on chain-of-custody. The court also relies on Basu for arrest-memo requirements. Ultimately, due to unexplained delays, lack of proven custody of the sample during transit, and absence of an arrest memo, the court acquits the accused and allows the appeal, emphasizing that the prosecution failed beyond reasonable doubt to link the contraband to the laboratory analysis.
BAIL APPL. NO. 11606 OF 2023 This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Section 439 CrPC by Mohammed Farshad, first accused in Crime No. 921/2023, Kozhikode Town Police Station, NDPS Act offences. The state accuses three accused of possessing 29.285 kg of ganja, seized from a pickup van on Beach Road, Kozhikode, around 11:30 am on 16 September 2023, allegedly procured from Odisha for sale. The petitioner challenges the indictment, asserting he was merely a passenger and not involved in the illicit enterprise; he has been in judicial custody since 16.09.2023, and the investigation is largely complete with the contraband already recovered. The case cites that a similar order in BA 538/2024 granted bail to the second accused, suggesting the contraband corresponds to an intermediate quantity, not a clear commercial quantity. The prosecution contends there is a common intention to procure the contraband from outside the state and that the contraband was intended for sale; Section 37 NDPS Act would then be applicable to justify denial of bail. The court ultimately exercises its discretion to grant bail with stringent conditions, noting the near-commercial quantity, substance of the investigation, and the absence of antecedents, limited to the balance of convenience and public interest, and references Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) to justify that police recoveries may be made while on bail.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2456 OF 2024 This Kerala High Court bail application concerns two accused, Sobi @ Devasya and Sijo George, in Crime No. 2/2024 of Sholayur Forest Range, Palakkad. The petitioners were arrested on 06.03.2024 in connection with alleged trespass into a Government forest area at VetikundChavadiyur Malavaram (VFC item 118), where two deer were reportedly killed and sandalwood recovered. They seek bail under Section 439 CrPC, contending lack of material linking them to the offences under the Kerala Forest Act, 1961 (27(i)(e), 27(iv)(iii), 47C, 47F, 47G, 47H, 61A) and the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 (2(16), 9, 29, 31, 39, 50, 51). The State opposes bail, arguing ongoing investigation and risk of reoffending if released. The court notes the petitioners have been in custody for about 50 days and that the investigation is practically complete with recoveries effected. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (2012), Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. (2018), State of Kerala v. Raneef (2011), Hussainara Khatoon (I) v. Home Secy. (1980), and Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2020), the court reiterates that bail is the norm and detention is exceptional when warranted. On these facts, the court allows the application and grants bail on Rs.50,000 bond with two solvent sureties, under conditions to cooperate with investigations, refrain from tampering with witnesses, surrender any passport, and comply with all orders. The decision underscores that ongoing recoveries may be effected on bail as permitted by precedent.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2409 OF 2024 Shinoy, the third accused in Crime No.238/2024 of Maradu Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks pre-arrest bail under Sec.438 CrPC. The alleged offences include Sections 451, 341, 323, 324 and 326 read with Section 34 IPC, arising from an incident on 04.02.2024 around 15:15 hours, where the accused purportedly trespassed into the residence of the defacto complainant Vimal and assaulted his relative Dileep. The defacto complainant intervened; Shinoy and the 2nd accused allegedly restrained the injured to facilitate the 1st accused’s assault with a helmet, causing fractures to Jishnu and Vimal, and a swelling on the defacto complainant’s knee/palm. The defense contends that the 3rd accused had no specific overt act attracting Section 326; his participation was limited to aiding in restraint, and custodial interrogation is unnecessary, with no recovery sought from him. The State counters that investigation is ongoing and custodial interrogation is necessary; the prosecution produced medical records to substantiate injuries and noted the investigation’s preliminary stage. The petitioner had moved a similar application before the Court of Session, which was dismissed. The High Court, after examining the alleged overt acts, found that the 3rd accused lacked a direct overt act under Section 326, but nonetheless allowed pre-arrest bail subject to stringent conditions: surrender within ten days, production before the court on arrest, bond and sureties, cooperation, no witness intimidation, no involvement in other offences, passport surrender, and potential cancellation on violation. The order states observations are confined to bail and not merits of the case, and cites Sushila Aggarwal for the relevant principle.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was filed by Joby Furniture and Joby K.J. challenging SARFAESI Act proceedings initiated by the 2nd respondent bank for recovery of a loan availed in 2013. The loan, of ₹25,00,000, was secured by mortgage of the petitioners’ property. Default led to the bank declaring the account as NPA and issuing notices under sections 13(2) and 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, followed by ex parte orders for possession and appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. The petitioners claim partial repayments: ₹7,14,000 on 29.03.2013 and ₹32,000 on 30.03.2023, and later ₹1,38,000 on 15.12.2023; they state the outstanding dues (about ₹27,00,000) cannot be cleared in one lump sum and seek permission to repay in instalments (about 25 instalments). They argue that SARFAESI proceedings should be kept in abeyance to allow instalment payments, and question the bank’s readiness to accept such terms. The respondents submit that the loan was secured on property later alienated to multiple parties and allege wrongdoing by the petitioners, asserting no instalment facility should be granted. The court cites settled law that writs do not lie against SARFAESI proceedings where a statutory remedy exists, referencing Satyawati Tondon and subsequent judgments, and dismisses the petition as not maintainable, emphasizing the efficacious remedy under the Act. The decision reflects the prevailing stance that Article 226 relief is unavailable in such SARFAESI matters when a dedicated quasi-judicial forum exists.
The petitioners in WP(C) No.13772 of 2024 challenge a direction to deposit licensed arms ahead of the Lok Sabha Elections 2024. They contend that surrendering arms, even temporarily, defeats the purpose of possessing a valid arms license and would deprive them of life protection during a critical period; the deposit would keep arms inaccessible for at least two months until election results are declared. The petition relies on Ext.P1 Circular issued by the Election Commission, which prescribes procedures for arms retention/deposit during elections, and on the High Court precedent in Joseph K. A. v. District Collector, Kottayam, 2019 (1) KLT 1034, that orders for depositing weapons during elections must follow the Ext.P1 process. The petition argues no proper procedure under Ext.P1 was followed in their cases, rendering the directive untenable. The respondents, through Standing Counsel, state that a Screening Committee has been constituted to consider exemptions and that licensees desiring retention may seek exemption. The court acknowledges time constraints and, to avoid infructuity, directs interim relief: petitioners may apply to the Screening Committee for exemption within two days; if they do so and file copies of the judgment and exemption application, the authorities shall refrain from demanding surrender until the Committee decides. Thus, the petition is disposed by enabling exemption applications rather than a universal surrender.