The appellant, Narendran Purakunnel House, was convicted by the Special Court (NDPS) at Thodupuzha under Section 20(a)(i) NDPS Act for cultivating seven cannabis plants found near his residence at Mammattikkanam. The Narcotic Enforcement Squad, led by PW1, detected the plants on 26.02.2005, arrested him, and seized one plant as a sample and six others after uprooting, with specimens sealed as required (Ext.P7). The trial court accepted the prosecution case that cannabis plants were on the appellant’s land and convicted him despite defense arguments that the cannabis plants were not on his property. The appellant challenged the conviction under CrPC 374(2). On appeal, the court noted that the prosecution relied on PWs 1 and 2 and Exts P14 and P7, while PWs 3 and 4 contradicted some aspects of the case and lacked reliability. The key issue was whether the land where the plants stood was in the appellant’s possession. The court referred to decisions holding that possession requires physical control and animus, and that there must be evidence that the appellant cultivated the plants. Holding that the evidence did not prove cultivation by the appellant beyond reasonable doubt, the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction, and acquitted the appellant, granting liberty.
Kunju Pilla, the appellant, challenges a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Kerala Abkari Act, recorded by the Additional Sessions Court Ad-hoc, Mavelikkara, in S.C.No.27/2002. In the impugned judgment, the trial court held that illicit arrack—1500 ml in two bottles—seized on 3 November 1998 near Moorthi Temple, Palathingal, Vettiyar, constituted contraband, and the appellant was sentenced to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000. On appeal, the appellant’s counsel argued that the prosecution failed to establish that the sample tested in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory originated from the sample seized at the scene and presented in court. They highlighted critical deficiencies: the seizure mahazar did not describe the seal, no specimen seal was produced or forwarded to the lab, the specimen impression of the seal was not proven, and the sample allegedly changed hands without examination of intervening officials. The judge relied on Baburaj v. State of Kerala and related precedents establishing the necessity of a tamper-proof chain of custody for Abkari Act prosecutions. The court enumerated defects including lack of seal description, absence of forwarding note, and unexamined custodians, concluding the certificate of chemical analysis (Ext.P6) had no evidentiary value. Consequently, the appellant was acquitted, the conviction unsustainable on the given chain-of-custody defects, and the appeal was allowed with the appellant set at liberty.
The appellant, Jayakumar, challenged his conviction under Sections 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Abkari Cases), Kottarakkara, which sentenced him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and fines of Rs. 1 Lakh on each count for possession of contraband (15 plastic covers each containing 100 ml of arrack) seized on 12 February 2000 at Oyoor. The High Court undertook a comprehensive scrutiny of the evidence, focusing on crucial infirmities: absence of mandatory arrest documentation (arrest memo and arrest intimation) and its impact on the legitimacy of the arrest; the non-examination of seals and lack of chain-of-custody documentation for the seized sample; unexplained delay in production of property and sample before the court; and the timeliness and integrity of the chemical analysis (Certificate of Analysis) linking the seized contraband to laboratory testing. The Court relied on established authorities emphasizing strict compliance with arrest formalities (D.K. Basu), chain-of-custody (Sasidharan, Sathi), and the need for prompt production of seized properties (Ravi), while noting delays and missing links undermine the prosecution’s case. It also cites Ramesan for the principle that composite-sentence appeals do not abate. Ultimately, due to the failure to prove arrest and chain-of-custody beyond reasonable doubt, the court acquits the accused and allows the appeal, directing disbursement of any deposited amount as directed by this Court.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1741 OF 2024 In Akhil Raj v. State of Kerala, the High Court of Kerala considered a bail application under Section 439 CrPC in respect of NDPS Act offences (Sections 22(c) and 29) arising from Crime No.41/2023 of the Vadanappilly Police Station. Accused No.1 Akhil Raj was arrested on 20.12.2023. The prosecution alleged involvement in the sale/deal of 3.75 grams of MDMA from the accused’s person and 10.44 grams MDMA found in a postal parcel addressed to the co-accused; the parcel was allegedly delivered to the residence of the petitioner upon instruction by him. A Post Lady testified to delivering the parcel addressed to the 2nd accused at the petitioner’s address, creating the suggestion of conspiracy. The chemical analysis reportedly showed a mixture of MDMA and cocaine, with the report not specifying quantities by constituent. The defense argued innocence and contended that only 3.75 grams were in conscious possession and the parcel related to the 2nd accused, thus the quantity should be treated as an intermediate one; hence, Section 37 NDPS should not apply. The State contended that, based on Hira Singh and Yethul, the entire mixture must be treated as gravest contraband, resulting in a commercial quantity of 14.19 grams MDMA and thus rigour under Section 37. While refusing to decide on the merits of search/seizure at this nascent stage, the court held that there are no reasonable grounds to believe the accused not guilty or unlikely to commit an offense on bail; the application was dismissed.
This is an appeal under Section 14-A of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, challenging an order dated 28.02.2024 in CMP No.342/2024 passed by the Sessions Court, Kottayam, which presumably refused anticipatory bail. The appellant (accused No.2) is prosecuted in Crime No.2044/2023 of Vaikom Police Station for offences including IPC sections 448, 294(b), 323, 324, 354 and 427 r/w Section 34, alongside provisions of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989 (amendment 2015). The prosecution case alleges trespass into a residence belonging to a Scheduled Caste member and assaults on the complainant and her family, with accompanying mischief causing Rs.1500/- loss. The Court notes the defence contends lack of prima facie materials and argues animosity between the parties due to political rivalry. The Public Prosecutor submits that there are materials to attract the alleged offences. Notably, the court scrutinizes Section 3(1)(r) of the Act, observing no evidence of public insult against the complainant, and relies on case-law to interpret the Act’s stringent provisions, especially the requirement that insults must relate to caste status. The judge ultimately allows the appeal, holds that the bar under Sections 18-18A is not applicable here, and grants anticipatory bail with conditions and scheduled appearances, while cautioning not to tamper with witnesses or influence evidence.
Petitioner P. V. Muraleedharan, a devotee of Sree Perumthrikkovil Mahasiva Kshethram (a temple controlled by the Malabar Devaswom Board), challenged Ext.P1 notice issued by the Maha Sivarathri Maholsavam Aghosha Committee for the Sivarathri Maholsavam, alleging interference with temple administration and fundraising outside sanctioned channels. He contends that, being a controlled institution, the temple’s management must be conducted by the temple administration with no unauthorized committee collecting funds. The court’s order dated 06.03.2024 deleted Respondents 6 and 7 (6 & 7 deleted from party array) and held that in the absence of a devotees’ committee under Circular HRH5/8246/2006, the temple administration must manage all festival activities, and the Aghosha Committee cannot collect money for renovations or conduct of the festival. The respondent board countered with sections of the Madras HRCE Act, emphasizing Section 14 (Temple Advisory Committees) and the need for devotees’ participation without disturbing ongoing customs, and referred to Payyannur Sree Subrahmanya Swami Kshethrodharana Samithi and other decisions for guidance. The Court, relying on these precedents (Hindu Seva Kendram, Major Vellayani Devi Temple Advisory Committee) and the statutory framework, held that unauthorised committees cannot meddle with temple administration. The petition was disposed by making the interim order absolute, directing temple administration to conduct all activities and regulate fundraising, with a report to recover funds within three months.
CRP Nos.381 of 2023; 379 of 2023; 382 of 2023 This common order of the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam, dated 9 January 2024, arises from three Civil Revision Petitions (CRP Nos. 381/2023, 379/2023, 382/2023) challenging execution petitions filed in the Sub Court, Kottarakkara, connected to three suits (O.S. No. 22 of 2013). Abbas, the judgment-debtor, contends that the decrees are not executable because the compromise reached through mediation under Section 89(1)(d) CPC was not correctly implemented in the decrees. The mediation, concluded in 2013, resulted in an agreement to pay Rs.16,00,000 with interest, with revival of the suit amount if default occurred; the terms were recorded as “Matter settled in mediation centre by separate award.” The petitioner argues that the decree erroneously uses the term “award,” and there is no decree passed in terms of the compromise, nor any clear incorporation of the compromise into the decree; he asserts coercion in signing and seeks modifications to the decrees to reflect the compromise in compliance with Order 23 Rule 3 and ADR Rules. The respondents contend the compromise is effectively part of the decree and that the decree remains executable; they rely on the court’s view that the terminology does not vitiate the decree. The court concludes there is a technical snag—the decree does not explicitly state that the suit is decreed in terms of the compromise or that the compromise forms part of the decree—and directs modification of decrees to conform to law, noting applicability of ADR rules and a guiding precedent (Sethumadhavan M. v. Savitha V.C.). The petitions are disposed accordingly, with leave for modification and possible fresh execution petitions after modification.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1793 OF 2024 This is a Kerala High Court bail petition under Section 438 CrPC concerning eleven accused in Crime No. 134/2024 of Munnar Police Station, Idukki. The petitioners (accused 1–11) are alleged to have participated in offences including criminal conspiracy, rioting, assault and related offences under IPC Sections 143, 144, 147, 148, 323, 294(b), 324, 326 and 367 r/w 149, arising from an incident on 05.02.2024 where the first accused allegedly knocked down the injured with a car, the second assaulted with a hammer, and the third with an iron pipe; accused 4–11 allegedly facilitated the assault. The petitioners contend their innocence, challenge the inclusion of Section 326, submit custodial interrogation is unnecessary, and are willing to abide by stringent conditions. The Respondent State argues there are specific overt acts by accused 1–3 and points to medical records showing fractures, asserting custodial interrogation is essential, while acknowledging no overt act against accused 4–11 with regard to 326. Relying on Supreme Court precedents (including Srikant Upadhyay v. State of Bihar; Jai Prakash Singh; HDFC Bank Ltd. v. J.J. Mannan; Sushila Aggarwal) the court holds that pre-arrest bail should be rare. The court disallows bail for accused 1–3 but grants pre-arrest bail to accused 4–11 with conditions, including surrender within ten days, bond and sureties, cooperation, no witness intimidation, passport surrender, and no subsequent offences, with potential cancellation on violation.
BAIL APPL. NO.1828 OF 2024 This Kerala High Court bail application under Section 438 CrPC concerns Sajeev M, the fourth accused in OR No.3/2024 of Pathanapuram Forest Range Office, Kollam. The accused are charged under Section 27(l)(e)(iii) of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961, for allegedly cutting and removing trees from forest land leased to the State Farming Corporation of Kerala for cashew plantation. The prosecution contends that the accused acted in furtherance of a common intention and felled 130 trees, of which 47 timber loads were recovered, and that the investigation is in a preliminary stage; custodial interrogation and recovery are necessary to advance the case. The petitioner, represented by Denizen Komath, claims total innocence, asserting he was an employee executing duties to remove weeds and wild growth rather than cutting forest trees, and that custodial arrest is unwarranted. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing that the acts amount to dishonest removal of forest property and that arrest and custodial interrogation are essential to preserve evidence and progress the investigation. The High Court cites Supreme Court dicta on anticipatory bail as an extraordinary remedy to be exercised in exceptional circumstances, referencing Srikant Upadhyay v. State of Bihar, Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar, and HDFC Bank Ltd. v. J.J.Mannan. After careful consideration, the court finds no exceptional grounds for pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application, with directions for ten-day surrender and subsequent reconsideration on surrender."
RP Nos.1238 and 1268 of 2023 These review petitions arise from Company Appeal No.6/2023 concerning a sale conducted by the Official Liquidator of BST Ltd (in liquidation). The property was brought to sale on 23.08.2017, sale confirmed on 18.11.2017, and the entire sale consideration paid on 10.07.2019, with possession delivered on 27.11.2019. The sale deed was finally executed on 08.03.2022, after land tax payments were completed on 27.12.2021. The single judge initially held that the Official Liquidator had acted with reasonable expedition and that there was no need to award interest for the delayed sale. However, the High Court, noting the delay from 27.12.2021 to 08.03.2022 for execution of the sale deed, held that interest at 6% per annum was payable by the Official Liquidator for that period. The Official Liquidator sought review, arguing that the delay was not contumacious and the execution was tied to Company Court orders, with the draft deed and orders evolving over time. The Court ultimately found that the sale deed was executed strictly under Court direction (02.03.2022) and that the delay did not justify interest for the disputed period, recalling the earlier judgment in part and dismissing one review petition. The judgment underscores the Company Court’s supervisory role in liquidations and the need for judicial discretion in confirming sales.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1750 OF 2024 This bail application under Section 438 CrPC concerns accused nos. 10 and 11 in Crime No.236/2021 of CBCID, Alappuzha (earlier Nooranad PS Crime No.850/2015). Petitioners RENU KA.R (53) and K.G. VIJAYAMANI (67) were senior executives of PACL Ltd., alleged to have convinced a defacto complainant to invest about Rs. 61,616 in Pearls Agro Tech Corporation Ltd. (PACL) with promises of large profits, but failed to remit or return the capital. They are charged with offences under IPC Sections 420 (cheating), 511 (attempted offences), and 465 r/w 34, along with Sections 2(c), 3, 4, 5 and 6 of the Prize Chits Money Circulation Scheme (Banning Act, 1978) and Section 45S of the RBI Act. The prosecution asserts defrauding several persons and ongoing investigation; however, the petitioners contend they had no active role in company management, which was handled by accused 1 and 2, and that Annexures A2 and A3 show pre-arrest bail granted to similarly situated employees. After hearing, the Court found custodial interrogation unnecessary, relied on the similarly situated orders, and granted pre-arrest bail subject to conditions to cooperate with investigation and other safeguards. The order reflects the caution of procedural safeguards while permitting release on bail, with reference to the Sushila Aggarwal principle for recoveries during bail.
BAIL APPL. NO.1843 OF 2024 This is a Kerala High Court bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 1843 OF 2024) by accused nos. 4 and 8 in Crime No.164/2024 of Kadakkavoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The petition seeks release on bail under Section 439 CrPC for offences under IPC including 143, 147, 148, 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 365 and 308 r/w 149. The prosecution alleges that on 22.02.2024, in pursuance of a common intention, the accused restrained the informant and his friend, assaulted them with a knuckleduster, abducted the informant’s friend, and caused grievous injuries. Petitioners were arrested on 25.02.2024. They claim innocence and that their false implication is evident; they argue investigation is practically complete and recoveries have been effected, so further detention is unnecessary. The State opposes bail, citing ongoing investigation and the likelihood of witness intimidation given criminal antecedents. The court acknowledges the presumption of innocence and the discretion in bail, noting the nearly complete investigation and recoveries. It cites Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh and State of Kerala v. Raneef to emphasize that bail is the norm and pre-trial detention must be justified. After consideration, the court grants bail with stringent conditions: bonds of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, regular reporting, non-tampering with witnesses, surrender of passports, provision of addresses and contact details, and potential for cancellation or modification of conditions with authority to continue investigations, including recoveries if needed per Sushila Aggarwal.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1791 OF 2024 Shiyas, the first accused in Crime No.146/2024 of Kolathur Police Station, Malappuram, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in a case registered under Sections 22(b) and 29 of the NDPS Act for alleged possession of MDMA. The prosecution alleges that on 01.02.2024, the accused was found in possession of 2.98 grams of MDMA, with co-accused amounts of 0.23 gram and 0.05 gram, totaling 3.26 grams. The petitioner has been in judicial custody since 01.02.2024; the investigation is described as practically complete, with recoveries effected. The defense contends total innocence and false implication, stressing no criminal antecedents and willingness to abide by stringent conditions. They argue that the contraband quantity is intermediate and that ongoing investigation would not be hindered by release on bail. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail but conceded that the contraband is of intermediate quantity and that there are no antecedents, noting the investigation is in progress. After weighing the materials, the court finds that continued detention is unnecessary and grants bail. The order imposes bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties for equal amounts, and conditions including regular appearance before the IO on Saturdays for two months, propagation of non-tampering with witnesses, prohibition on offense commission while on bail, passport surrender or affidavit, and the possibility of cancellation or modification of bail for violation. The court also cites Sushila Aggarwal for the authority to impose such conditions and supervise investigations while on bail.
The petitioner, N.K. Anitha, approaches the Kerala High Court seeking directions to the respondents to consider and pass orders on Ext.P3, within a time frame after affording an opportunity of hearing as per Ext.P2 judgment. The matter arises from a loan taken by her husband from the 1st respondent bank on 20.10.2004 for ₹4,30,000, repayable in 180 monthly installments of ₹5,435. The bank filed OS No.128 of 2009 in the Sub Court for recovery and obtained a decree—ex parte—permitting realization of ₹7,15,556 with 14.25% interest. The petitioner was unaware of the decree; her marriage deteriorated during that period, and she learned of the EP only after service. An attempt to set aside the ex-parte judgment failed, the property went to auction, and the bank ultimately acquired it to satisfy the decree. The petitioner subsequently deposited ₹7,20,000 to the loan account under court directions, in hopes the respondents would refrain from eviction. She then moved OP (Civil) No.144/2022, and this Court indicated reconveyance after payment could be pursued through conciliation. The respondents opposed, arguing writ petition is not maintainable in view of Supreme Court judgments cited. The Court, however, holds that in the interests of justice the respondents must consider Ext.P3 and attempt amicable settlement through conciliation, directing a decision within one month and disposal of the petition.
WP(C) No.31363 of 2009 & WP(C) No.4856 of 2019 The Kerala High Court, in a common judgment authored by Justice P. V. Kunhikrishnan, adjudicates two connected writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 31363 of 2009 and 4856 of 2019) involving the Kaikkara Construction Company (petitioner) and the State of Kerala along with Harbour Engineering Department officials and revenue authorities. The core issue is whether the State could unilaterally claim damages for breach of contract by withholding sums due to the contractor, where disputes regarding breach persisted. The petitioner asserted that Ext P7, a demand notice for damages, was issued without hearing and without adjudication, and relied on established Supreme Court jurisprudence (e.g., Raman Iron Foundry) that damages arising from breach cannot be treated as debt until liability is adjudicated; the State defended the position by invoking Clause 18 of the standard form contract and later authorities (Kamalu DIN Ansari, Amber Builders, Gangotri) to contend that the State could withhold and recover sums due. The court undertook a detailed review of authorities, noting Raman Iron Foundry’s ratio has been reconsidered and overruled by Kamaluddin Ansari, while emphasizing that the fundamental principle—disputes over breach should be adjudicated by an independent forum—remains. Ultimately, the court quashes Ext P7 (and related orders) in WP(C) 31363/2009, allowing the parties to pursue civil litigation; WP(C) 4856/2019 is dismissed but similarly leaves room to approach civil courts. The judgment also acknowledges the desirability of an institutional arbitration framework for such disputes.
WP(C) Nos. 23673/2021, 616/2022, 29525/2021, 30169/2021 These consolidated writ petitions challenge the determination of compensation for land and buildings acquired for the National Highway project under the National Highways Act, 1956 (NH Act) for the National Highway Authority of India (NHAI). The court notes that while there is no express assertion that Awards under Section 3G(1) have been issued, it proceeds on the assumption that such orders may exist so that petitioners can pursue remedies under Section 3G(5) before the Statutory Arbitrator. The learned Special Government Pleader explains that, although some petitioners may not yet have individual Awards, the CALA has completed the compensation determination under Section 3G(1). The court directs that petitioners who have not yet received 3G(1) Awards may approach the CALA within one week from the date of receipt of this judgment, provide titles, and obtain the requisite Awards within two weeks thereafter. Petitioners may challenge the Awards under any NH Act provision within one month of receiving the Awards, with the statutory Arbitrator to hear and decide promptly. The Court leaves open contentions under the Fair Compensation Act schedules and Section 3H of the NH Act for arbitration. It cites Aboobacker M. & Others v. Union of India and a common judgment dated 24.9.2021 as guidance. Liberty is granted to revisit this Court after eight months if the arbitration remains pending, and CALA orders Exts.P14–P17 may be considered by the Arbitrator.
CRL.M.C. No. 1045 of 2021 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No. 1045 of 2021) decided by a single judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitioner, Udayakumar K.U., accused No. 2 in CC 89/2019 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Sulthan Bathery, seeks quashing of Annexure-A FIR and Annexure-B final report in Crime No. 3/2019 of Pulpalli Police Station, along with related proceedings. Crime No. 3/2019 relates to acts during a harthal protesting entry of women into Sabarimala, including unlawful assembly and stone-pelting, with allegations under multiple IPC sections and a Kerala Police Act provision. The petitioner had already faced trial and been convicted in S.C. No. 135/2019 (Annexure-E) for offences arising from the same incident, leading to a plea that continuing with Annexure-B proceedings is barred by double-jeopardy principles and Article 20(2) of the Constitution. The High Court held that, while the two crimes stemmed from the same transaction and time/place, the protective scope of Section 300 Cr.P.C. extends to bar a second trial on the same facts even if different charges could have been framed. Relying on Nalini and Thakur Ram, the court ruled that section 300 bars a second trial and quashed Annexures A and B, exonerating the petitioner. The order emphasizes the broader reach of Section 300 Cr.P.C. beyond Article 20(2).
WP(C) Nos.26003 of 2017; 13823/2021; 13834/2021; 14067/2021; 14136/2021; 14283/2021; 14484/2021 The batch of writ petitions, including WP(C) Nos. 26003/2017 and 13823/2021 et al., challenge Exts. P1 (2017) and P13 (2021) notifications that restricted Melsanthi (archaka) appointments in Sabarimala Devaswom and Malikappuram Devaswom to Malayali Brahmins. The petitioners, employed or aspiring to be Melsanthies across temples under the Travancore Devaswom Board, argue that such caste-based eligibility violates Articles 14, 15 and 16 of the Constitution and undermines the freedom to worship under Articles 25-26. They rely on precedents like Adithyan (2002) SCC 106, Seshammal (1972) SCC 11, Kailash Sonkar, and others to contend that eligibility for religious offices must not be restricted by caste, and that religious practices and temple usage are governed by Agamas and temple tradition, not secular recruitment rules. Respondents contend the selection of Melsanthies in these temples is a unique religious practice, essential to the temple’s rites, often Purappeda Santhies who stay for the yearly tenure, and must be guided by Tantri and temple custom rather than standard public employment norms. The Court recognizes Travancore Devaswom Board’s trustee-like role and historical guidelines/settlements, and ultimately dismisses the petitions, holding that the contested caste criterion does not violate constitutional protections given the temple’s religious nature and the framework of applicable statutes and rules.
The Kerala High Court, in CRL.A No.1858 of 2007, allowed an appeal by Lalitha challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing illicit arrack. The trial court had sentenced the appellant to one year of imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine based on proof of seizure at her residence on 21.07.2002 and a chemical analysis of the sample. On review, the court scrutinized pivotal procedural aspects: arrest, seizure, seals, forwarding notes, chain of custody, and the link between the seized contraband and the laboratory analysis. It highlighted several deficiencies: the arrest memo bore a crime number, raising doubts about the genesis of the case; absence of a seal description or specimen, and forwarding notes; the sample allegedly drawn and tested may not be the same sample; several officials who handled the sample were not examined; and unexplained delays in the chemical analysis. Relying on various forensic precedents addressing chain-of-custody and sampling, the court held that Ext.P4, the Certificate of Chemical Analysis, lacked evidentiary value due to the failure to establish a tamper-proof linkage from seizure to laboratory testing. Consequently, the prosecution failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt, the conviction could not stand, and Lalitha was acquitted; the appeal was allowed.
The petitioner, Shyly Suresh, challenges Ext. P6, a communication denying Ext. P4 building permit on a property claimed to be plantation under the Kerala Land Reforms Act (KLR Act). The petitioner asserts the land, described in Ext. P1 sale deed for 4.05 ares in Re. Survey No. 245/6-31, Mundakayam, is alienable and should not be permanently barred from construction merely because revenue records classify it as plantation; the sale deed remains valid and alienation is not prohibited unless a prohibitory order under Sec. 120A of the KLR Act is issued. The petitioner relies on decisions including Kinallur Rock Sand v. State of Kerala, Devassia R.V. v. Sub Registrar, State of Kerala v. Fr. Xavier Karuvallil, and Elias T.V., to argue that exempted plantation lands may be used for non-exempted purposes and that protection under Article 300A applies. The court notes that Ext. P7 (a Kerala High Court judgment) supports reconsideration of such matters and that Mundakkayam Panchayat should re-evaluate the building permit in light of those propositions. On hearing, the court holds that there is merit in the petition, quashes Ext. P6, and directs the respondents to reconsider Ext. P4 within one month, directing compliance with the judgment.