Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 607 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P(C).6215/2021

M. Prem Kumar and others v. Kerala State Electronics Development Corporation and Regional Provident Fund Commissioner

The writ petitioners are officers of the Kerala State Electronics Development Corporation who retired between 2014 and 2016. They were enrolled in the EPF scheme and contributions were made, including under the EPF pension scheme introduced later. After retirement, they received terminal benefits (pension, provident fund, ESI, leave encashment and gratuity) calculated on the last drawn salary. The pay revision (wage revision) year 2017 was implemented for existing and retired employees; the corporation decided to pay arrears in 12 equal monthly installments from Oct 2018, with financial constraints guiding the distribution. Petitioners contend they are entitled to enhanced terminal benefits (gratuity, earned leave encashment, half-pay leave encashment) and to adjust PF contributions according to the revised salary. The respondents refute this, noting the wage revision was government-sanctioned in 2017 for longer-term financial reasons; those superannuated before revision had terminal benefits based on last drawn salary; pension should be claimed from PF authorities based on the last salary used for remittance. The court examined the Board resolutions and Exts. P1–P14 and concluded there is no record supporting enhanced gratuity or related benefits; however, it left the EPF claim open for the petitioners to make representations within one month for a possible decision. The writ petition was disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 396 of 2022

Chakkittappara Grama Panchayat v. The Ombudsman for Local Self Government, Thiruvananthapuram; Ravi Ulliyeri; Panchayat Deputy Director, Kozhikode; K. Sunil, President, Chakkittappara Grama Panchayat

Chakkittappara Grama Panchayat, represented by its Secretary, challenges an order of the Ombudsman directing appointment through the Employment Exchange for contractual posts under the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS). The writ appeal contends that the Employment Exchange (Compulsory Notification of Vacancies) Act, 1959 does not mandate recruitment through Employment Exchanges for temporary posts, and relies on Krishnankutty v. State of Kerala (2005 KHC 1494), which held that Section 4(4) and Sub-Sections (1)–(2) do not impose an obligation to recruit via the Employment Exchange merely because a vacancy is notified. It also invokes Bihar v. Upendra Narayan Singh (2009 KHC 4572). The writ court, and now this Court, consider Government orders and NRGA guidelines; they note these do not prescribe an exclusive mode of employment, and that posts under schemes often operate on contract and public advertisements, with Employment Exchanges as one possible sponsor if live registers exist. The respondents advocate adherence to guidelines that prioritise the Employment Exchange path for non-permanent posts. The Division Bench ultimately holds that the NRGA scheme does not specify a mandatory mode of employment and that the petition fails to show an exclusive contractual-only requirement, upholding the writ court’s order and dismissing the appeal, thereby preserving the Ombudsman’s directions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.2017 of 2008

Unni @ Pramod v. The Excise Inspector, Kozhikode Excise Range & State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court heard Criminal Appeal No. 2017 of 2008, challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) Abkari Act by the Fast Track (Adhoc-I) Court, Kozhikode, for possession of 5 litres of illicit arrack. On 08.04.2003, near V/35, the appellant was found with contraband; the sample was sent to the Chemical Examiner, with chain-of-custody issues. The trial court convicted the appellant after trial. On appeal, counsel argued that the prosecution failed to prove that the sample tested was the same sample seized, and that crucial witnesses who handled the sample were not examined, raising doubts about tampering and link to the contraband. The court cited Sasidharan v. State of Kerala and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram, emphasizing that the prosecution must establish a tamper-proof chain of custody of the contraband to link the sample to the defendant. It noted delays in laboratory analysis and lack of explanation for such delays, and highlighted that mere production of a laboratory report cannot be conclusive without correlating it to the seized sample. Relying on Sathi and Ravi, the court held that the prosecution failed to establish the necessary link, and the benefit of doubt must go to the accused. Therefore, the conviction was set aside and the appellant acquitted, with the appeal allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.28947/2022

Rahul Subash & Others v Union of India & Others

This writ petition challenges Ext.P10, the Agnipath recruitment scheme, introduced by the Government of India for the Indian Army, and seeks to quash the notification and compel continued processing under the pre-existing recruitment regime. The petitioners, aspirants who had participated in rallies under Notifications dated 21.10.2020 and 18.12.2020, cleared medicals, and faced delays in the written examination due to lockdown, allege a legitimate expectation that their recruitment via the regular stream would proceed. They contend that the Agnipath scheme, which modifies eligibility (age up to 21 with a relaxation for some years) and replaces permanent enlistment with a four-year Agniveer term, undermines that expectation, alters pay and pension, and introduces a temporary cadre without legislative backing under Article 309. They argue social and economic consequences, including the precarious life of short-term service and the risk of unemployment after four years. The respondents defend the scheme as a policy decision to address security challenges and border realities, citing international models and the need for a youthful, agile force. The court, relying on constitutional doctrine and service jurisprudence, holds that policy decisions in national security matters are within the executive domain and should not be interfered with absent infringement of fundamental rights; consequently, the petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 13592 of 2015

M.R. Prabhakaran Nair v. State of Kerala and Director of Panchayats

This writ petition challenges Exhibit P1, a Lok Ayukta order in Suo Motu Proceedings No.1064/2014 dated 18 December 2014, passed against M.R. Prabhakaran Nair, Secretary of Kolayad Grama Panchayat, Kannur district. The petitioner contends the order was issued without hearing him or impleading him in the proceedings, arising from a complaint by Muraleedharan, a resident of Thavinjal Grama Panchayat, who sought his transfer. Subsequently, Exhibit P2 transferred him to Paivalike Grama Panchayat in Kasaragod District, allegedly on the Lok Ayukta’s influence, with the petitioner having appeared before the Lok Ayukta on 18 December 2014 to seek impleadment, but the proceedings were closed without hearing. The petitioner challenged the transfer before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (OA 2390/2014), and the Tribunal directed that the State consider his representation within three months. He argued that the Lok Ayukta lacks jurisdiction to issue such orders without a proper complaint and due hearing, since no disciplinary or vigilance proceedings are pending. The judgment cites Ramachandran Master v. Kerala Lok Ayukta (2006 (4) KLT 166) to stress that the Lok Ayukta can investigate only on a written, properly constituted complaint in prescribed form, not suo motu or on defective/anonymous complaints. The High Court ultimately agrees, holding that the Lok Ayukta had no jurisdiction in this case and quashing the impugned orders; the writ petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.10351 OF 2022

Koroth Prabhakaran and Others v. Commissioner of Police and Others

This writ petition concerns seven petitioners who claim ownership and possession of two parcels of land (37.5 cents and 66 cents) in Thillankeri Amsom, Kannur District, derived from a larger ancestral holding. The petitioners assert delivery of the final decree properties on 24 May 2012 after a partition, and allege obstruction by respondents 4 and 5 (co-owners) who threaten their peaceful enjoyment. They seek a mandamus directing police to protect their lives and possession and to ensure continued enjoyment of the property delivered under Ext. P4, and an order directing the government to take immediate action on Ext. P11 complaint. Respondent 4 counters that the petitioners do not have exclusive possession and that co-ownership persists; they rely on Exts. P6 to P8, delivered during an interim stay granted in 2011 in a pending appeal (AS 166/2011). They contend the delivery during stay is not legally founded and that the delivery cannot be asserted against a pending appeal. The court notes Ext. P4 is the final decree in O.S. No. 168/1989 and that Ext. P5 (the appellate judgment) upheld it in 2019. It holds that the interim stay ended and that the petitioners are entitled to the final decree rights; police protection should be provided if obstructed, without prejudice to the rights of others in appeal. The petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 6885 OF 2022

Nizamuddeen I. v. State of Kerala and others

The petitioner, Nizamuddeen I., a retired Senior Superintendent seeking to progress within the government college system, challenged Exts. P4 and P6, communications which rejected his request for a declaration of probation in the post of Head Accountant so as to enable promotion to the post of Senior Superintendent in Milad-E-Sherief Memorial College, Kayamkulam. He contends that the rejection rested on an erroneous premise that he had not completed sufficient tenure in Head Accountant, which would block the promotion; he relies on Rule 28(a) of the Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958 (KS&SSR) to argue that celebration of a probation is not a prerequisite for promotion after promotion to Head Accountant, provided there is no allegation of lack of educational qualification or failure in tests. He also cites a past instance (through Ext. P1(a) and the case Devaki v. State of Kerala, ILR 2006 (3) Kerala 825) to substantiate his position, and points to Ext. P3 as the valid Promotion Order. The respondents insist Ext. P3 and the chain of decisions conform to the statutory regime and that without declared probation the promotion cannot proceed. The High Court ultimately emphasizes that Rule 28(a) must be examined before adverse action and that the petitioner must be heard. It sets aside Ext. P6 and directs the Government to reconsider Ext. P5 after due hearing within two months, with the fresh decision to be independent of Ext. P4.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 214 of 2023

OP(KAT) No. 214 of 2023

This High Court of Kerala Original Petition (KAT) arises against the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s (KAT) final order in OA No. 1074/2020, which held that the State/Department respondents erred in not promoting the applicant to the post of Joint Director (SC/ST Development Department) with effect from the vacancy date of 1.4.2020 and directed notional promotion with consequential benefits up to retirement. Jacqueline Shinny Fernandez, the sole applicant in the OA, asserted that she was next in line for promotion to Joint Director as per the final gradation list dated 30.11.2016 (rank No.2) and that vacancy arose on 1.4.2020. She contended the Department delayed the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meetings and neglected Rule 28(b)(i)(4) of Part II KS&SSR, aided by circulars (Anxs. A-2 to A-4), violating the right to timely promotion and resulting in loss of benefits. The Tribunal found breach of statutory duty and ordered notional promotion from 1.4.2020 with consequential benefits; actual promotion was effected belatedly on 20.8.2020. The State challenged, arguing that DPC need not meet before retirement and citing Covid-19 constraints, along with reliance on prior judgments (notably State of Kerala v Narayanan) and amendments (Rule 28(b)(i)(14)). The High Court, adopting a purposive interpretation and citing O.P(KAT) No. 38/2022, dismissed the petition but upheld the Tribunal’s liberal approach that notional promotion can be granted with pensionary adjustments, directing compliance within two months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2079 of 2008

MOHANAN v. STATE OF KERALA

Criminal Appeal No. 2079 of 2008 before the Kerala High Court arises from a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Additional District & Sessions Court, Vadakara, for possession of 9.075 litres of Indian-made Foreign liquor in a bus on 22 December 2004. The trial court sentenced Mohanan to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh after trial and conviction under the cited provision. The High Court, in a judgment dated 7 June 2022 by Judge K. Babu, allowed the appeal and acquitted the accused, holding that the prosecution failed to establish a decisive link between the contraband seized, the sample tested in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory, and the accused. Key issues concerned the chain of custody and the delay in producing the sample before court; the bottles containing the sample were only produced on 23 December 2004, with no satisfactory explanation for the delay; several custodians were not examined; Ext. P11’s chemical analysis lacked evidentiary value due to non-proof of tamper-proof handling. Relying on Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Daulat Ram, and Vijay Pandey, the court held the prosecution did not establish the required link beyond reasonable doubt, acquitting Mohanan and allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8500 OF 2022

Mohammed Hinas and Others v. District Labour Officer, 1st Circle, Kannur; Registering Authority under Kerala Headload Workers Act and Rules; Assistant Labour Officer, 1st Circle, Talipparamba; Chairman, Kerala Headload Workers Welfare Board

This writ petition challenges the District Labour Officer’s appellate order under Rule 26A of the Kerala Headload Workers Rules, which rejected registration of headload workers employed by the petitioners’ establishment, Core Stone. The petition and its supporting materials argue that granting registration to the petitioners’ headload workers is legally warranted under the 1983 Scheme, and that the sole ground—protection of existing pool workers—is not a legally adequate rationale to deny registration, a view supported by this Court’s Division Bench in Nishad M.B. The respondents contend that the pool area operates under a pool system where work cards are allocated to workers, and that permitting new registrations would reduce opportunities for already registered workers. The judgment reaffirms the distinction between attached and unattached headload workers: attached workers can work in the establishment to which they are attached without immediate registration under Rule 26A, whereas unattached workers require registration for headload work; it further holds that the registration enquiry must determine whether the applicant is actually engaged in headload work of predominant nature in the employer’s establishment, based on records and on-site inspection. The court overrules Rajeev and Manzoor, upholds Raghavan (Full Bench) and Theresa Jose guidance, and directs registration of nine workers, quashing Ext. P3 and P5 to ensure compliance with the 1983 Scheme, while allowing attached-work in the interim.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 23 of 2018

Malankara Plantations Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax Circle-1, Kottayam

Malankara Plantations Ltd., the assessee, challenges an ITA 90/COCH/2016 order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Co­chin Bench) relating to AY 2011-12. The appeal concerns disallowance of claims under Rule 7A(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 for replantation expenses and the deduction of upkeep and maintenance of rubber saplings till maturity. The Tribunal had relied on a Division Bench of this Court’s decision in Rehabilitation Plantations Ltd. v. CIT, prompting a Full Bench reference. On 01.08.2022, the Kerala High Court Full Bench answered two facets: (i) under Rule 7A(2), the assessee is entitled to an allowance for replacement of dead and useless rubber trees in a non-abandoned area, subject to Section 10(31) of the IT Act, 1961; and (ii) the upkeep and maintenance expenses incurred till maturity are revenue expenditures eligible for deduction under Section 37 of the IT Act. The present High Court, after examining the questions, held that questions 1 and 2 need no interference; question 3 relates to subsidy from Tea Board and aligns with the Full Bench’s working principles; questions 4-6, on replantation allowance and related deductions, are answered in favor of the assessee but remitted to the Assessing Officer for fresh assessment in light of the Full Bench order. The overall result is a remand to the AO with guidance from the Full Bench’s conclusions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 9340 of 2022

Director (Reji Varghese) SAJ Lucia v. Labour Court, Kollam & Others

The petitioner, Director (Reji Varghese) SAJ Lucia, challenged the Labour Court, Kollam’s Ext.P5 order in ID No.85/2019, which was initiated after the 2nd respondent, dismissed from the petitioner's service on 30.09.2018, raised an industrial dispute under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The petitioner contended that the 2nd respondent is not a “workman” and that the Labour Court should decide this and the issue of administrative or supervisory status at an early stage, not at the final award stage. The Labour Court had held that these questions require evidence and could be addressed at the final stage, thereby deferring decision on preliminary issues. The High Court invoked a string of Supreme Court authorities beginning with Cooper Engineering Ltd v. P. P. Mundhe and followed by S.K. Verma v. Mahesh Chandra and D.P. Maheshwari v. Delhi Administration to emphasize that there is no justification to stall final adjudication by ruling on preliminary issues and that such questions should ordinarily be resolved during the final award. It also cited Kerala decisions (Rajamoni; Amrita Institute of Medical Sciences; Chelamattom Sree Krishna Swami Devaswom Trust; President, Kunnampetta Ksheera Vyavasaya) to uphold the principle of not interfering with preliminary Labour Court orders, allowing challenge only with the final award. The writ petition was dismissed, with liberty to challenge the final Labour Court award if aggrieved.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No. 438 of 2021

Kavitha V. Kurup v. State of Kerala & others

The writ appeal arises from a challenge to the order of the Government of Kerala regarding the date from which the post of Head Subordinate Assistant (Hindi) at St. George’s Mount High School, Kaipattoor, should be treated as filled. The appellant Kavitha V. Kurup, who was the 4th respondent in the writ petition, contends that her promotion to H.S.A (Hindi) should have been from 01.06.1998, when the then-incumbent went on leave preparatory to retirement, since the vacancy created by that leave was temporary and the earlier process for Hindi promotion was not properly computed. The writ petition by Smt. A.K. Jayasree sought that the Government consider her claim; Exts. P6 and P7 show that the Government rejected the petition, holding that she did not serve as H.S.A with effect from 01.06.1998 and that the substantive vacancy arose only from 01.07.1998. The learned Single Judge remanded the matter to the Government for hearing and to pass orders after considering evidence about work performed by the petitioner during 01.06.1998 to 30.06.1998. On appeal, the Division Bench partially allows the appeal, holding that the remand was limited to evaluating whether the petitioner actually worked as H.S.A in the June 1998 period for possible service benefits, while affirming that the substantive appointment date lay from 01.07.1998. The Government is directed to decide within two months after hearing, applying the modified directions as to the 01.06.1998 period. The decision thus narrows the controversy by recognizing the substantive vacancy date while permitting limited fact-finding on the interim period.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2530 OF 2022

Jagath Ram Joy v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Jagath Ram Joy, the accused in Crime No. 17/2022 of the Excise Range Office, Ernakulam, under Section 22(c) NDPS Act. The pivotal legal questions were whether the quantity of contraband—0.3868 gms of LSD stamps—should be treated as a small quantity after excluding the weight of stamps, and whether Section 37 NDPS Act rigour should apply. The petitioner contends the weight stated in the mahazar includes stamp material, and if LSD alone is weighed, the quantity would fall below the small-quantity threshold, citing Bombay High Court’s Hitesh Hemant Malhotra v. State of Maharashtra (2021) 3 MhLJ(Crl) 78, and prior Kerala decisions. He also argues a violation of Section 50 NDPS Act because the option to call a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate to conduct the body search was not provided before seizure. The prosecution maintains the seizure and the materials indicate a commercial quantity and thus Section 37 should apply. The judge examines the Mahazar, notes the accused’s admission and seizure of LSD stamps, but observes that Section 50 was not invoked prior to seizure and questions the treatment of weight. Ultimately, the court holds that the rigour of Section 37 NDPS Act would not apply, cites the lack of antecedents and examination imminence, and grants bail with conditions including bond, co-operation, regular appearances, non-tampering with witnesses, and travel restrictions.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1617 of 2012

Managing Director, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Raziya Uluvan and others

This Kerala High Court MACA is an appeal by the Managing Director, KSRTC, challenging the quantum of compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri, in O.P.(MV) No.120/2008 arising from a road accident in which a motorcycle rider (deceased) was knocked down by a KSRTC bus. The Tribunal found the bus driver negligent and awarded Rs. 4,76,000 as compensation. The KSRTC challenged the quantum, while the legal heirs of the deceased (petitioners) filed a cross-objection seeking enhancement. The dispute centers on the deceased’s monthly income, the application of future prospects, the proper multiplier, and the division of heads for loss of dependency, loss of love and affection, and loss of consortium. The appellants argued for a lower monthly income (Rs.3,000–3,500) and questioned the deductions made, contending the petitioners hadn’t established the deceased’s income. The respondents urged Rs.6,000 monthly income per Ramachandrappa and demanded 40% future prospects per Pranay Sethi, with a 16 multiplier and correct deductions for dependents (1/4) and for personal expenses. The court ultimately adopts a Rs.6,000 base, applies 40% future prospects, and, correcting the deductions, computes Rs.9,42,600 as additional compensation, with 7.5% interest, directing payment within two months. It also holds that compensation cannot be awarded for both loss of love and affection and loss of consortium. The appeal is dismissed and the cross objection allowed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT).65 of 2022

State of Kerala and others v. V.P. Kunhalan

This High Court of Kerala judgment arises from an original petition filed by the State challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) order in OA (EKM) No.1205 of 2020. The KAT directed that the pensionary benefits of V.P. Kunhalan, a retired U.D. Clerk under the Panchayat service, be revised to reckon 794 days of provisional service as qualifying service for pension and to disburse related benefits with 6% interest. Kunhalan had worked in prior temporary posts totalling 794 days before his regular appointment in 1982–2003 and sought to count this provisional service for pension and increments, citing Government Decision No.2 under Rule 33 Part 1 KSR and related Government orders. The State contends that provisional service is only for increments, that Panchayat employees were not Government servants until 3.2.1987, and that the three conditions under Decision No.2 are not satisfied, hence not pensionable. The State relies on statutory rules and the 1987 Government Order treating Panchayat employees as Government service from 1987, while the Respondent argues for counting provisional service as Government service. The High Court ultimately holds that the three conditions are not met and that provisional service cannot be reckoned for pension, upholding the State’s petition and setting aside the KAT order.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2859 OF 2008

Lalithakumari v. State of Kerala

This criminal appeal challenges a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by a Fast Track Sessions Court (Adhoc No.1), Thiruvananthapuram, for possessing one litre of illicit arrack. The trial court convicted the appellant after examining the prosecution’s witnesses and documentary exhibits, including a seizure memo (Ext.P1) and a chemical-analysis certificate. The Kerala High Court, however, set aside the conviction on grounds that the prosecution failed to prove the identity of the person in possession at the scene and did not establish that the seized liquor subjected to Chemical Examiner analysis was the same sample tested, highlighting deficiencies in the chain of custody and seal descriptions. The court emphasized the necessity of a prior test identification parade when a witness identifies the accused for the first time in court and relied on a line of authorities, including Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, Sathi v. State, Ravi v. State of Kerala, Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala, and Rajamma v. State of Kerala, to stress strict compliance with sampling/sealing and custody formalities. Consequently, the court held that the evidence did not meet legal standards, acquitting the appellant and ordering the deposit, if any, to be disbursed. The appeal was allowed with liberty to the appellant.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2481 OF 2008

Rajesh v. State of Kerala

The appellant, Rajesh, challenged a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court, Kozhikode, for possessing 5 litres of illicit arrack on 29.10.2002. The trial court convicted him based on the chemical analysis of the contraband and other material (Exts. P1–P8, MO1). On appeal, the Kerala High Court scrutinized crucial prosecution failures: (i) lack of evidence establishing an unbroken chain of custody from the place of occurrence to the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory; (ii) non-examination of officials who handled the sample during transit; and (iii) absence of proof regarding the date the sample was forwarded to the laboratory. The court noted that the sample remained under court custody and moved through the Court’s staff before reaching the laboratory, but the prosecution did not prove the seals’ integrity or tamper-proof handling. Relying on Sasidharan v. State of Kerala and Sathi v. State of Kerala, it held that the chain of custody must be established and that the presumption under Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act cannot substitute for shown acts. The analysis showed a delay between sample receipt (13.11.2002) and analysis (23.01.2004) without explanation, undermining the reliability of Ext. P6. Consequently, the court acquitted the appellant and allowed the appeal, setting aside the conviction and sentence and directing release and disbursement of any deposited amount.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 711 of 2014

K. Rajendran v. State of Kerala

This criminal appeal arises from a conviction under Sections 55(a) and (g) of the Abkari Act, following a detection on 13.08.2010 at around 7:15 a.m. of illicit arrack and wash in the lean-to adjacent to the appellant’s residence in Hosdurg. PW6, the Sub Inspector of Police, along with his team, recovered 2 litres of arrack, 15 litres of wash and distillation utensils, and prepared samples, with Exts. P1–P2 and P7–P10 forming the documentary trail. The Additional Sessions Judge-I convicted the appellant after trial, and the judgment was challenged under Section 374(2) CrPC. The appellant argues multiple defects: an improper search, delay in forwarding contraband and samples to court, alleged non‑compliance with Section 53A of the Abkari Act, and lack of independent corroboration for the testimonies of PW1 and PW6. The High Court, in a detailed evaluation, found the ocular and documentary evidence credible, noting that Exts. P10–P11 inventories and the Magistrate’s certification under Section 53A were properly handled. It rejected the procedural flaws urged by the appellant, accepting the explanation for a two‑day delay due to holidays and endorsing the Magistrate’s certification as primary evidence. Relying on a Supreme Court principle that police testimony is not intrinsically suspect, the court upheld the conviction and sentence and directed surrender on 08.08.2022.

High Court of Kerala
2158/2022; 2162/2022; 2163/2022; 2167/2022

Anez Anzare v. State of Kerala

This is a consolidated bail–related judgment of the Kerala High Court (Single Judge) delivered on 25 April 2022 by Justice Gopinath P. Monday. The petitioner, Anez Anzare, moved four anticipatory bail petitions (BAIL APPL. Nos. 2158/2022, 2162/2022, 2163/2022, 2167/2022) arising from four separate FIRs/Crime Nos. 267/2022, 266/2022, 268/2022 and 274/2022 registered at Palarivattom Police Station, Ernakulam. The charges span sexual offences under IPC Sections 354, 354A(1)(i), 354A(2), 354A(1)(iv), 354A(3) and 509, with Crime No. 267/2022 additionally invoking 354B. The petitions spanned allegations of inappropriate touching and related conduct during bridal make-up sessions, with one complaint arising from an email and others dating to 2015–2016. The petitioner contended that the complaints are malafide, part of a campaign to ruin his business, and that custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The State contended that the offences are serious, with multiple victims and potential for witness interference, justifying the need for custodial control. The court relied on established bail jurisprudence (including Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, Sibbia, Sushila Aggarwal, Amarmani Tripathi, and others) and noted the victim’s right to be heard per Jagjeet Singh. Ultimately, the court granted anticipatory bail in all four cases subject to conditions, emphasising cooperation with investigation, bonds and sureties, passport surrender, non-contact with witnesses, and avoidance of new crimes during bail.