This is a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the order in CMA No. 21 of 2021 arising from OS No. 171 of 2021 (Munsiff Court, Muvattupuzha) concerning a suit for partition instituted by Ramla, the plaintiff and daughter of late Makkar. The petitioners are eight legal heirs of late Makkar who contend that the plaint schedule properties are not available for partition due to prior transfers and settlements in their favour, including udampadi (gift) and deeds executed in their favour. The Trial Court granted a temporary injunction restraining the defendants and their men from inducting strangers, encumbering, alienating, or removing valuable trees from the properties. The defendants challenged this order before the Sub Court in CMA No. 21 of 2021, which modified the interim injunction to restrain transfer or creation of rights while noting the pendency of the suit. The High Court, exercising its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227, examined the discretionary nature of interim relief and the principles governing interference. It relied on established authorities to emphasise that relief should not be granted or refused without considering prima facie rights, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury, while also cautioning against unwarranted interference with trial court discretion. Ultimately, the Court held that the lower court’s discretion was exercised properly and disposed of the petition; the injunction stood, and the trial was directed to proceed promptly within three months of receiving a certified copy of the judgment.
Ratheesh, a devotee of Keezhanikavu temple in Alangad Village, Paravoor Taluk, filed a Writ Petition under Article 226 seeking a mandamus to recover possession of 1.46 acres of land described as Keezhanikavu Kshethram Irippu Nilam (Sy. No. 434/4) in Alangad, from respondents 5–12 who allegedly encroached temple land, and to hand over the property to the Keezhanikavu Temple administration. The petition relies on Exts. P2 (settlement register) and P5 (representation dated 20/08/2015) to press for recovery, with the Travancore Devaswom Board (respondent 1) and district authorities (respondents 2–4) arrayed as opponents. The court notes previous proceedings in W.P.(C) No. 26494 of 2014 (Keezanikkavu Samrakshana Samithi) disposed of on 15.10.2018, which directed the Special Tahsildar to consider the matter under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act after notice and hearing, and to complete the exercise expeditiously within eight months. The 3rd respondent counters that Sy. 434/4 is recorded as Keezhanikkavu temple land with a partition deed (817/1958) showing inter alia 3 cents set aside for temple, while the rest is in others’ possession and not clearly identifiable. The petitioner’s counsel rely on post-2018 Supreme Court guidance in Mrinalini Padhi to address shrine-management issues through appropriate jurisdictional channels. The High Court disposes of the petition, without deciding merits, directing the petitioner to pursue remedies before the District Judge under the Mrinalini Padhi framework, emphasizing public-interest considerations and lawful procedural action under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act. The order reflects a cautious, non-merits-based disposition with a pathway to a scheme/arrangement if appropriate under law.
Jamshad Ali v. State of Kerala concerns an NDPS case (Crime No.206/2022, Kondotty police) in which Jamshad Ali, accused no.1, sought regular bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. The petition arises after the Special Court for NDPS cases, Manjeri, dismissed the bail application on 30/09/2022, holding that the 180-day period for investigation under the proviso to Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. did not include the remand date, and relying on Ravi Prakash Singh alias Aravind Singh v. State of Bihar (2015) SCC 340. The prosecution argued that 180 days expired on 29/09/2022 and the prosecution could seek extension under Section 36A(4) NDPS, a view supported by several rulings. The petitioner contends that Rule 22 of the Criminal Rules of Practice requires including the remand date in computing the period, and that Chaganti Satyanarayana and others v. State of A.P. (1986) SCC 141, Harish Babu Maddineni v. State of Kerala (2012) KHC 62, and Rakesh Kumar Paul v. State of Assam (2017) SCC 677 provide a stricter reading in favor of liberty under Article 21. The High Court, acknowledging conflicting precedents and the larger bench reference in Kapil Wadhawan, adopts inclusion of the remand date, aligning with Rule 22 and Article 21, and grants statutory bail on specified conditions.
Sayana, the petitioner-mother, challenges Ext.P6 (the common order dated 04.10.2021) in IA Nos. 6599/2019, 6/2021, 7/2021 and 9/2021 in OP 1621/2019 of the Family Court, Thrissur. The order granted interim custody of the child to the father for portions of the school vacation periods and directed contact through telephone and video conferencing, with advance notice of vacation dates. The petitioner argues that the interim custody arrangement was arbitrary and prejudicial to the minor Imran (aged 8), particularly since the child studies in Bangalore and there is no Onam or Christmas vacation in that location, thereby affecting his education. She contends the welfare of the child requires revision of Ext.P6, as well as modification of contact arrangements to preserve the child’s education and mother-child interaction. The respondent-father maintains the child’s custody in his hands is feasible, acknowledging the child’s studies in Bangalore but endorsing ongoing visitation rights. The High Court relies on the welfare principle for children, citing Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan (2020) 3 SCC 67 and Vasudha Sethi v. Kiran V. Bhaskar (AIR 2022 SC 476), underscoring that the child’s welfare is paramount and that visitation rights are generally provided when custody is altered. In light of these authorities and the record, the court declines to interfere with Ext.P6 and Ext.P9 and dismisses the Original Petition, thereby upholding the Family Court’s orders and preserving the custody and visitation framework.
The petitioners, a group of 17 landholders in Kozhimala, KaanchiYar Grama Panchayat, Idukki, claim ownership and possession of non-patta land (5 to 25 cents each) where they constructed thatched residences. They purchased from original settlers who occupied the land for decades, but no registered sale deeds were executed since the land is deemed non-patta. The Government’s Life Mission Scheme provided an initial installment of Rs. 40,000 for constructing residential buildings; petitioners built the foundation and awaited the second installment. They were served with Ext.P1 notices indicating the land falls within reserved forest and is demarcated as tribal land, and Ext.P2 communications from the Panchayat informed that balance installments would be disbursed only after securing government sanction and forest clearance (NOC). Petition seeks: (i) certiorari to quash Ext.P6; (ii) mandamus to disburse balance Life Mission installments; (iii) patta under Kerala Land Assignment Rules; (iv) NOC/Patta under Forest/Rights regimes; (v) relief on Ext.P2. Counsel representing petitioners argued that stopping installments and demolishing existing structures leaves families homeless and that Life Mission benefits are being misapplied, with non-tribal settlers also receiving funds; they rely on Eacharan Ittiathi to challenge Section 76(a) of the Kerala Forest Act as unconstitutional and invoke FRA rights. Respondents contend that the area is within Cardamom Hill Reserve and that FRA 2006 restricts rights to those who qualify as OTDF with 75 years’ residence prior to 13.12.2005. The court held FRA 2006 governs; petitioners are not OTDF; petition dismissed with liberty to pursue other remedies.
The petitioner, a jewelry manufacturer and retailer, challenged Ext.P19, a show-cause notice issued by the respondents alleging contravention of the Central Excise Act, 1944, the Central Excise Rules, 2002, the Articles of Jewellery (Collection of Duty) Rules, 2016, and the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The central issues include whether Ext.P19 was issued within the normal limitation under Section 11A(1)(a) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, and whether the extended period under Section 11A(4) can be invoked given the absence of mens rea or suppression. The petitioner contends that hedging activity—part of the show-cause subject matter—is a trading activity outside the Finance Act’s service tax regime. The petitioner also argues there was no suppression or misstatement and materials forming Ext.P19 were within departmental knowledge since 2018, relying on several Supreme Court precedents (Continental Foundation Joint Venture, Nizam Sugar Factory, Padmini Products, Jaiprakash Industries) to claim that extended period cannot be invoked in such circumstances. The respondents argue that a writ petition against a show-cause notice is not maintainable and that issues must be addressed during adjudication; they stress that the extended period is for the adjudicating authority to decide, and that hedging was not the subject matter of Ext.P19. The court ultimately holds the petitionerineligible and dismisses the petition, granting 30 days to reply and directing adjudication of Ext.P19 in due course, while clarifying that findings are for Article 226 purposes only.
CRL.Rev.Pet.No.662 of 2022 Saleesh, the revision petitioner, challenges a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for issuing a cheque for Rs. 2,80,000 which was dishonoured for want of funds. He was convicted by the trial court and sentenced to six months’ simple imprisonment and to pay Rs. 2,80,000 as compensation under Section 357(3) Cr.P.C., with a default sentence. On appeal, the learned Special Additional Sessions Judge (Marad Cases), Kozhikode, confirmed the conviction and, while modifying the quantum, upheld the core finding of guilt. The prosecution’s case rests on the complainant’s testimony and documents (PWs 1–2; Exts P1–P5) corroborating that the accused borrowed the money and issued the cheque, and the notice of dishonour was served but payment was not made. The defence raised an alibi, supported by DW1–DW2, but the courts below rejected it, finding the alibi evidence unreliable and discounting the purported difference between signatures as not disproving the debt. This Kerala High Court revision petition examines the scope of its revisional power under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C., reiterating that revisional interference is limited and not a second appellate review, and that there is a strong presumption in favour of debt under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, which the accused failed to rebut. The court ultimately dismisses the revision petition but grants two months to pay the compensation and defers execution of the sentence to 15.12.2022.
CRL.REV.PET NO.774 OF 2022 This Kerala High Court revision petition under sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. challenges a conviction under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The petitioner (Babu) was convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Sulthan Bathery, for dishonour of a cheque dated 03.12.2016 for Rs. 1,09,550 in a transaction for gold ornaments purchased from Chemmannur Fashion Jewellers. Sessions Court upheld the conviction on appeal. The revision petition contends misappreciation of evidence and misstatement of the debt; it emphasizes that the complainant’s case involved a larger transactional record, including repayments, and contends that the exact liability remains disputed in light of payments made and the manner in which the suit amount was calculated. The High Court addresses the scope of revisional jurisdiction, reiterating that it is supervisory and not an appellate reweighing of evidence, and that presumptions under sections 118 and 139 NI Act operate in favor of the complainant unless rebutted by the accused by evidence on a preponderance of probabilities. The court surveys several Supreme Court precedents—Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri, Rangappa, Bir Singh, Sanjaysinh Chavan, Kalamani Tex, Kishan Rao—to support the proper limited use of revision and the continuing validity of statutory presumptions. The petition is dismissed, but the court grants one month to pay the compensation, with further conditions for execution and appearance before the trial court."
This writ petition under WP(C) No. 30719 of 2021 is filed in the Kerala High Court by Annie John and three other family members (represented by Annie John as power of attorney holder) seeking expeditious consideration of an Ext.P13 application (Form No.5) under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, for deletion of the subject property from the data bank, and directions to the additional 6th respondent Tahsildar (LR) to accept an application submitted under Section 6A of the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961, to carry out corrections in the Basic Tax Register, taking into account a prior order under the Kerala Land Utilization Order, 1967 (KLUO). The petition concerns 87.04 ares in Re-survey No. 109/1-5, Block 7, Kakkanad, Kanayannur Taluk, Ernakulam, with deed evidence (Exhibit P1) and family heirs (Exhibit P3). The petitioners allege past permissions (Exhibit P4 and P4(A)-(D)) and seek deletion from the data bank and conversion/correction in tax records. The respondents contest that Form A under Section 6A has not been properly filed, but the court notes that predecessors obtained permission in 1996 and directs consideration of Ext.P13 after inputs, with a two-month deadline, including an opportunity to file Form A within two weeks. The court also directs the additional 6th respondent to follow relevant precedents (Tahsildar v. Renjith George; District Collector v. Fr. Jose Uppani) and complete orders within two months if the property is excluded from the data bank.
Parvathy Ramachandran, an Assistant Professor of English at S. N. College, Chengannur, has approached the Kerala High Court challenging a proposed enquiry proceeding initiated by the college management with the 3rd respondent as Enquiry Officer. The petitioner contends that the Enquiry Officer is an advocate by profession and that she must be afforded an opportunity to engage a lawyer to safeguard her interests; she also apprehends being heckled or harassed by teachers allied to the respondents during the proceedings. She relies on a prior order in W.P.(C) No. 24604/2021 directing copies of documents relied upon and an opportunity to present her explanations before the Enquiry Officer. The enquiry scope is stated to be limited to four items: (a) a complaint petition dated 17.02.2021 filed by the petitioner, (b) an application dated 04.05.2021 filed by the petitioner, (c) a complaint by some parents and students, and (d) an enquiry report dated 13.07.2021 based on a complaint lodged by the petitioner herself. The 2nd respondent contends the inquiry is not a formal enquiry under Kerala University Statute Chapter 4A (Section 71(1)-(15)), and the management does not propose to retain counsel; hence the petitioner cannot demand counsel. The court notes the enquiry’s primary function is to ascertain the genuineness of the petitioner’s allegations. It directs that copies of documents (a)-(d) be furnished, that the petitioner be protected from harassment, and that the venue may be changed if harassment occurs. The writ petition is disposed of with these directions.
RCRev. Nos. 179 of 2021, 183 of 2021, 2 of 2022, 6 of 2022 This is a common order disposing of four Rent Control Revision petitions filed under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, arising out of eviction proceedings under Section 11(3) for shop rooms in Kollam. The petitioners (landlords) challenged orders of the Rent Control Court directing deposit of admitted arrears of rent under Section 12, where the tenant had filed appeals challenging the fair rent fixed under Section 5(1). The Rent Control Appellate Authority, upon hearing, allowed those appeals and directed deposit of arrears at the rate fixed by the District Court from 01.01.2014, with costs. The tenants approached the High Court challenging these appellate orders. The High Court, after hearing, rejected the revisions, holding that Section 12 obliges the tenant to pay or deposit admitted arrears up to the date of payment/deposit and to continue paying rent due thereafter; mere filing of appeals does not stay eviction proceedings. The court relied on Williams Daniel v. Jose, Inderchand Jain, Madan Kumar Singh, and Ambika Kumari K. to reiterate that stay of proceedings is not automatic on filing an appeal, and that fair rent fixed by the court stands in parity with “admitted rent.” The revisions are dismissed accordingly.
The petitioner, Sukanya Haridasan K.H., filed O.P.(FC) No.574 of 2022 in the Family Court, Ernakulam, seeking a decree of dissolution of marriage under Section 13(1)(i)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The marriage, solemnized on 03.02.2022, was registered and the couple reportedly did not live together; the respondent reportedly went to the United Kingdom the day after marriage. The petitioner contends the marriage was not consummated and seeks leave to present the petition for divorce within one year from the date of marriage under the proviso to Section 14(1) on grounds of exceptional hardship. The Family Court, by its order dated 27.08.2022 in IA No.5271/2022, dismissed the application for leave without issuing notice to the respondent, holding no exceptional hardship or depravity. On admission of the matter, the High Court issued notices and observed service by email. The question before the court is whether there can be interference with the Ext.P1 Order and whether leave under Section 14(1) should be granted. The High Court relies on decisions such as Akshara A. v. Rohin S. Raveendran, Vishnudas H. and Nil, and Amardeep Singh v. Harveen Kaur to illuminate the parameters for waiver of the one-year requirement, including factors like the interests of children, possibility of reconciliation, absence of misrepresentation, and the age and hardships of the spouses. The court deemed the Family Court’s non-notice dismissal improper and allowed the petition, directing the Family Court to reconsider IA 5271/2022 with notice to the respondent and to issue a reasoned order within one month, expeditiously.
This is a Kerala High Court (Ernakulam) writ petition (WP(C) No. 28288 of 2021) filed by Peggy Fen, an advocate, seeking mandamus to remove the Malayalam film Churuli from the OTT platform SonyLIV, arguing that its dialogue is obscene, vulgar, and morally deleterious, especially for children during the pandemic. The petition contends that the film’s language offends public morality and tranquility and could attract offences under the IPC; it also asserts that the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) acted improperly by releasing an uncensored version on an OTT platform. Respondents challenge the petition by distinguishing OTT from public venues and by invoking the Information Technology Rules, 2021, which regulate online content, including an ‘A’ (Adults) rating and a grievance redressal mechanism. The court, after admitting the petition, directed a State Police team to view the film to assess potential statutory violations. The team found no statutory violation or criminal offence. The court emphasized artistic freedom under Article 19(1)(a) and held that the film’s context, overall impact, and compliance with IT Rules justify not directing removal from SonyLIV. The petition is dismissed with observations about media conduct and the need for measured criticism of judgments.
This writ petition by Bindu M. challenges Ext.P12 and seeks regularisation of her appointment as Higher Secondary School Teacher (Zoology) at Shivagiri Higher Secondary School, Sivagiri Mutt, under the Sree Narayana Dharma Sanghom Trust, along with arrears for the period she worked (Aug. 2000 – Mar. 2002). The background involves the Shivagiri Mutt (Emergency Provisions) Act, 1997, under which a government-appointed administrator managed the trust, leading to an appointment process for H.S.S.T (Zoology) based on open selection and later an adhoc/guest arrangement (Ext. P3). The petitioner asserts her appointment as per Ext. P3 was valid and should be regularised in line with Supreme Court guidance; she worked for about 20 months but was not paid. The State, Director, and Trust argue the post was filled on an adhoc basis, contingent on final Supreme Court orders, and Ext. P12 denying relief is justified for lack of a proper selection committee endorsement. The petitioner relies on the Supreme Court’s Dolichan decision (2001 (1) SCC 151) to obtain regularisation of such ad hoc appointments, and Ext. P1 indicates permissible adhoc hires during pendency. The High Court considers Ext. P1 and extracts the four doctrinal directions from Dolichan, then sets Ext. P12 aside and directs the 2nd respondent to produce the appointment file (Ext. P3) and reconsider, with an opportunity of hearing, within three months, in accordance with law.
Ajayan K. Madhavan, a bidder for the project upgrading 12.5 km of 66KV Pudukkad Kattoor SC Line to 110 KV DC Line, challenges RP 1017/2022 against the Kerala High Court’s WA 1344/2022 judgment (delivered 19 September 2022) in a review petition. The writ appeal had held that the Electricity Board could not be faulted for withholding the bidder’s security deposit, a consequence of a stay granted by this court and the subsequent challenge by the second lowest bidder. The single Judge had permitted recovery of interest via Section 9 CPC, but the writ appeal rejected any arbitrariness or illegality by Board officials in withholding the deposit. The review petition contends that the WA decision deprived him of remedies under CPC Section 9 and that counter affidavits were not properly considered; it also seeks interest at 12% per annum for the security deposit, arguing financial burden and the Board’s beneficial use of funds for six years. The respondents contend that review is not an appeal and that there was no jurisdictional error; the delay resulted from stay orders, not Board fault. The Division Bench ultimately dismisses the review petition, reaffirming the WA 1344/2022 outcome and leaving the security-deposit status intact.
This is a Rent Control revision under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (R.C.Rev. No. 1 of 2022) challenging the judgment of the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-II), Manjeri (dated 16.07.2021) and the Rent Control Court order (27.02.2018) granting eviction under Section 11(3) and denying eviction under Section 11(2)(b). The petition schedule building, let in 2006 for five years and extended, houses a post office. The landlords claim bona fide need to start a child clinic by Dr. M.P. Kammara Menon and to demolish part of the tiled building to create a parking space; the tenants argue lack of bonafide need. The learned courts below held the need bonafide, relying on PW1–PW2 and Exts A1–A4, C1–C2, finding the clinic plan and occupation by a medical professional credible. The petitioners contend the evidence is not cogent and that the need is not bona fide, prompting revisional scrutiny under Section 20. After detailed analysis of the bonafide need principles (citing Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath and others) and revisional limits (Rukmini Amma Saradamma, T. Sivasubramaniam, Ubaiba, Hindustan Petroleum, Thankamony Amma), the High Court concludes the findings are not perverse. It dismisses the revision petition but grants eight months to surrender possession on conditions.
This Regular Second Appeal (RSA 862/2020) before the Kerala High Court arises from eviction and possession proceedings in respect of plaint schedule properties at Varkala. The plaintiffs claim title and possession derived from Gift Deed No. 2406/1984 executed by their mother in favour of the plaintiffs, with mutation reflected in Ext. A5 and tax payments evidenced by Ext. A4/A5. The plaint schedule A property includes a building corresponding to B schedule. Earlier litigation established plaintiffs’ possession: O.S. No. 225/1996 (injunction) was decreed, confirmed on appeal as A.S. No. 83/1998, and subsequent proceedings related to trespass and enforcement followed. On 01.08.2008 the defendants allegedly trespassed into the plaint schedule building, leading to the present suit O.S. 5/2013 for eviction and recovery of possession, which the Munsiff decreed and which was affirmed by the Sub Court in A.S. No. 39/2017. The High Court held that Exts. A1–A3 prove plaintiffs’ possession and Ext A4 gift deed, supported by mutation via Ext A5, vested them with title; the defendants have no subsisting rights in the B schedule property. The court rejected the adverse possession contention (not pleaded) and dismissed the appeal, granting the defendants six months to vacate with an undertaking, failing which delivery proceedings could proceed.
CRL.M.C. No. 7853 of 2022 This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No. 7853 of 2022) preferred to quash the further proceedings in C.C. No. 648/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kattakkada. The petitioner is accused No.2; the de facto complainant (respondent No.1) has pursued four co-accused, including the petitioner, in a dispute arising under offences punishable under Sections 406, 420, 465, 323, 354 and 294(b) read with Section 34 of the IPC. The respondent entered appearance through counsel, and an affidavit sworn by the de facto complainant, together with an inquest by the investigating officer, indicates that the dispute between the complainant and accused No.2 has been amicably settled and the complainant does not intend to pursue the crime against accused No.2 further. The court relied on Supreme Court authorities Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and Laxmi Narayan, and on Lovely Salhotra and Sajeev & Another, to hold that under Section 482 Cr.P.C the High Court can quash criminal proceedings relating to non‑compoundable offences when there is a settlement, if ends of justice or avoidance of abuse of process warrant it. In view of the settlement with accused No.2 alone, the court holds that quashing the FIR/Final Report against accused No.2 is appropriate. The order is thus to quash only against the petitioner, leaving other accused to proceed as necessary.
This Rent Control Revision under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 concerns whether the heirs of a tenant who occupied the premises from 1938/1981 can claim protection under Section 11(17). The revision petitioner, M.P. Suresh Babu, challenging an eviction order under Section 11(3) on the ground of bona fide need by the landlady, Sobha Rajan, to establish a computer sales and service centre in the petition schedule premises. The landlady owns a building with seven rooms; six are let out, and one small room (No. 30/382) lies vacant due to its dilapidated condition and is intended for the business. The landlady contends that the ground-floor room is needed for sales and the upper room for the service centre for her son, while the tenant argues there is no genuine need since the landlady is financially well-off and owns other properties, with a longstanding tenancy dating to 1938 (father) and 1981 (tenant). The Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority upheld eviction. The High Court relies on Prabhakaran v. Sulaikabi to hold that legal heirs are not entitled to Section 11(17) protection, and on Shahul Hameed A. v. P.E. Abdu Razak to require the tenant to prove the second proviso to Section 11(3). The revision petition is dismissed, with time to vacate granted subject to conditions.
This writ petition (WP(C) 29105/2019) challenges orders Ext.P27, Ext.P28 and Ext.P29 issued by GCDA and government authorities regarding the cancellation of ratio-based higher grade promotions granted to employees of the Greater Cochin Development Authority (GCDA) and the consequent recovery of excess salary. Petitioners—nine GCDA employees who rose from Peons/Office Attendants to Attender Higher Grade, Clerk and Senior Clerk—allege that GCDA followed a Secretariat pay pattern and extended pay revisions to certain categories in line with the Municipal Common Service. Ext.P24 notified that future appointments in GCDA would be on par with Municipal Common Service, not Secretariat. Ext.P26 granted ratio-based higher grade promotions to analogous posts in Municipal Service; however, the Government later directed sanction prerequisites, leading to Ext.P27 (sanctionless promotions), Ext.P28 (cancellation) and Ext.P29 (refund of excess pay). Petitioners rely on State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) to contend that recovery, especially after long periods, is impermissible and against equity. Respondents argue that GCDA promotions lacked Government sanction and that pay revisions for GCDA require Government permission; therefore, cancellation and recovery are justified. The court ultimately disposes of the petition with directions relating to salary re-fixation and non-enforceability of recovery of past excess payments.