This is a bail application under section 438 CrPC filed by accused 2 and 3 in Crime No. 713/2024 of Kuttippuram Police Station, Malappuram. The matter concerns alleged offences under sections 341, 323, 324, 326, 307, 294(b) and 506 read with section 34 IPC arising from an incident on 02.04.2024, when a verbal altercation with the defacto complainant’s family escalated into violence. The prosecution asserts that the first accused attacked the defacto complainant’s brother with a nunchaku causing grievous injuries, while accused 2 and 3 assaulted the defacto complainant and his brother and abused the wife of the defacto complainant. The petitioners contend that they are innocent as to the charges against them, argue that custodial interrogation is unnecessary, and emphasize lack of recovery; they seek pre-arrest bail. The Public Prosecutor counters that incriminating materials exist and that granting bail could hamper the investigation, especially with respect to the second accused’s use of a weapon. The court notes that the explicit overt act involving a weapon is attributed to the first accused, while the petitioners are alleged to have used only their hands and to have uttered obscene words. On balance, the court prima facie considers that offences under 307 and 326 may not be attracted against the petitioners, though trial will determine this. Ultimately, the court grants pre-arrest bail subject to conditions including surrender within 10 days, bond and sureties, cooperation with the investigating officer, no tampering with evidence, passport surrender, prohibition from new offences, and possible cancellation on violation, citing Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another for the procedural framework.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5584 OF 2024 This Kerala High Court bail application concerns two accused (Manu M and Manoj) in Crime No. 599/2024 of Kunnicode Police Station, Kollam Rural. The petition was filed under Section 438 CrPC seeking pre-arrest bail. The offences alleged include 452 (house trespass), 294(b) (obscene words), 323 (causing hurt), 326 (grievous hurt with a weapon) and 506 r/w 34 IPC. The prosecution contends that on 24.05.2024, the accused, in furtherance of their common intention, trespassed into the de facto complainant’s house, abused him, and assaulted him with a helmet and a brick, resulting in a nasal bone fracture; treatment records from a medical college hospital corroborate the injury. The petitioners’ counsel argues innocence, asserts that no case for Section 326 is made out, and contends custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor counters with incriminating materials linking the first accused to the offence, including injury evidence, and asserts custodial interrogation is necessary. The court cites Jai Prakash Singh to emphasize that pre-arrest bail is an extraordinary privilege to be granted only in exceptional cases, and cites Sushila Aggarwal for allowing recoveries during bail. On balance, the court dismisses the bail plea of the first accused (Manu) but allows the second (Manoj) with conditions, including surrender, bonds, and cooperation, without expressing a view on merits.
CRL.MC Nos.3703/2024, 3701/2024, 3702/2024, 3706/2024, 3709/2024, 3715/2024, 3725/2024 This is a batch of criminal miscellaneous petitions under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by the same accused, Josey Mathew, challenging orders/judgments in several criminal cases registered against him at the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Ernakulam, including CC Nos. 1386/2020, 1387/2020, 1388/2020, 1389/2020, 794/2021, 1609/2020, and related LP Nos. 28/2022 and 101/2022. The petitioner contends distress over potential remand on surrender, alleging a loss of contact with counsel during the lockdown and requesting bail protections. The State and Kadavanthra SHO oppose direct bail directions, asserting that bail decisions are to be made by the trial court and that no coercive steps should be pre-emptively imposed by this High Court. The Court, citing precedents Vineeth Somarajan @ Ambadi and Biju S. Praveen, analyzes the fear of remand and the necessity of quick, principled bail consideration. It confirms the well-settled preference to protect personal liberty and to avoid punitive remand absent proper judicial appraisal. Ultimately, the Court disposes of the petitions with directions: the petitioner shall surrender within three weeks with an opportunity to move for bail providing advance copies to the prosecutor; coercive proceedings will be kept in abeyance for three weeks to facilitate surrender and appearance. The bench holds a Single Judge posture, delivering a precautionary but practical order aimed at expediting bail considerations while balancing state interests.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4474 OF 2024 This bail petition relates to three accused in Crime No. 274/2024 of Thiruvalla Police Station, Pathanamthitta. Accused 1 to 3 are charged under IPC sections 452, 323, 324 and 326; they allegedly trespassed into a residence on 19 February 2024, where the de-facto complainant and family were assaulted. The prosecution asserts accused 1 inflicted a grievous injury on the de-facto complainant (nasal bone fracture) with a weapon; accused 2 and 3 are said to have caused injuries to Anson and others inside the same house. The petitioners surrendered after an earlier order under Section 438 CrPC, but the court below had rejected bail for the first accused. The High Court reiterates the fundamental presumption of innocence and the bail-as-rule principle, citing Sanjay Chandra and Dataram Singh to justify that pre-conviction detention must be judicious and compassionate, not punitive merely on past conduct. It notes that the weapon has not been recovered and the investigation is ongoing, with no overt act attributed to accused 2 and 3 to attract Section 326 at this stage. On consideration, the court refuses bail to accused 1 given gravity and ongoing investigation, while allowing accused 2 and 3 to be released on bail subject to strict conditions, including appearance, non-interference with witnesses, surrender of passports, and bonds of Rs 50,000 each.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5470 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by two accused in Crime No.1008/2023 of Pattambi Police Station, Palakkad, charged under NDPS Act Section 20(b)(ii)(C) for allegedly possessing 49.320 kg of ganja on 13 November 2023. The petitioners were arrested on the spot and remanded to judicial custody on 13.11.2023. They contend complete innocence and that they have been falsely implicated; there is no material to substantiate the offence; the Investigating Officer allegedly implicated them; they have been in judicial custody for about 250 days; investigation is complete and final report filed; hence, further detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, invoking Section 37 of the NDPS Act due to the contraband’s commercial quantity, and argues there are no reasonable grounds to dilute the rigour of bail. The court explains that Section 37’s conditions apply even while considering bail under CrPC, requiring opportunities to oppose and a finding of reasonable grounds that the accused is not guilty and will not commit offences on bail. It reviews Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari, State of Kerala v. Rajesh and others, Union of India v. Ram Samujh, Durand Didier, and Prasanta Kumar Sarkar to fix the standard and factors. Concluding that the material does not justify relaxing Section 37’s rigour, the court dismisses the bail application.
Petitioner M/S Adani Vizhinjam Port Pvt. Ltd., selected as the concessionaire for the Vizhinjam Seaport DBFOT project, sought a D&O/Trade License to conduct quarrying in Block No.47, Aryanad Village, Nedumangadu Taluk. The applicant submitted Ext.P8 on 26.07.2022 and, after curing defects on 15.09.2022, alleges no decision was taken by respondents 1–3 within the mandated 30-day window and that PESO certification was supplied via Ext.P12 on 13.09.2022. The Panchayat Committee, by Ext.P13 dated 25.10.2022, communicated an intent not to grant the license for the time being. The petitioner argues that because no decision was communicated within 30 days of re-submission, a deemed license arose on 15.10.2022 under Section 236(3) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and that Ext.P13 amounts to abdication of the Secretary’s powers under Section 232 of the Act. The respondents contend the application was defective for lacking PESO certification and that Ext.P13 merely conveys an internal decision, not a final rejection; hence no deemed license. The court scrutinized precedents from Abdul Kharim (FB), Aniyeri Satyan, Sudhakaran, and Sreedharan to determine the viability of deemed licensing and the consequences of non‑communication within the statutory period. It ultimately held that the petitioner secured a valid deemed D&O/Trade License as of 15.10.2022 and allowed the writ, directing issuance of the license and directing the Director of Mining and Geology to consider the quarrying lease within six weeks of receipt of the license copy.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5202/2024 & Connected Cases These bail applications arise from nine connected cases registered at Erumapetty and Guruvayoor Police Stations, Thrissur, under sections 406 & 420 IPC and Section 3 read with Section 21 of the Banning of Unregulated Deposit Schemes Act, 2019. Muhammed Faizal, the petitioner-accused, sought statutory bail under Section 167(2) CrPC after being in judicial custody for over 60 days since his arrest on 06.06.2024. The applications were heard together on 06.08.2024 by Justice C.S. Dias and the Court consolidated the evidence and prosecution’s and defence’s submissions across the connected crimes: Crime Nos. 36/2023, 558/2022, 556/2022, 557/2022, 881/2022, 772/2022, 792/2022, 793/2022, 882/2022, all at Erumapetty or Guruvayoor Police Stations. The de facto complainants alleged that Faizal and associates induced deposits via the My Club Traders scheme, promising high profits but failed to repay. Prosecutors argued the petitioner is an inveterate offender with a pattern of economic offenses, and that releasing him would undermine ongoing investigations. Faizal’s counsel contended innocence and emphasized the statutory right to bail once investigations exceed the 60/90 day limit, given no final reports have been laid. Relying on Uday Mohanlal Acharya, Sanjay Dutt and Sushila Aggarwal, the Court held the indefeasible right to statutory bail accrues when investigations are not completed within the prescribed period, and accordingly allowed the applications with conditions including bond, two sureties, appearance, no inducement, no tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, and continued monitoring of investigations.
W.P.(C) No. 23612 of 2024 Kumaran Namboothiri, a devotee, filed W.P.(C) No.23612 of 2024 seeking a writ of mandamus to compel the 2nd respondent Devaswom Commissioner to consider Ext.P2, the complaint dated 12.06.2024, and to initiate action against respondents 4 to 7 based on Ext.P1 FIR in Crime No.436 of 2024 registered at Kumarakom Police Station. The complaints relate to Kiliroor Kunnummel Devi Temple, a temple under the Travancore Devaswom Board, with respondents 4–7 allegedly involved in misappropriation of revenue and manipulation of temple receipts. The petition invokes the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, highlighting statutory duties of the Board under Sections 3 (vesting administration and funds in the Board), 15A (duties to ensure proper rites and administration), and 31 (management of Devaswoms) to supervise temples and safeguard assets. The judgment cites precedents: Ram Mohan Das (trustee-like status of the Board and accountability to worshippers); A.A. Gopalakrishnan (protection of deity properties against misappropriation); Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair (parens patriae and inherent jurisdiction); and Suo Motu v. State of Kerala (2022) and related orders (2023) to stress the Board’s duty to proper administration and the necessity of cogent reasons when acting on disciplinary recommendations. The court disposes by directing the Chief Vigilance and Security Officer to include Ext.P2 in the ongoing inquiry and to issue notice to the petitioner, without deciding merits.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Cr.M.C. No. 3789 of 2024) arising from Crime No. 768 of 2021 at Sooranadu Police Station, Kollam Rural, which is pending as SC No. 210 of 2022 before the Fast Track Special Court (PoCSO), Karunagappally. The petitioner, Dileep, challenges Annexure A7 to an order in Cr.L.M.P.No.347 of 2023 that dismissed a petition under Section 311 Cr.P.C. The relief sought includes quashing Annexure A7, recalling PW1 (the victim) and related witnesses PW25 and PW27 for cross-examination, and waiving the translation of vernacular documents. The petition argues that there are omissions and contradictions in PW1's 161 and 164 statements and that the cross-examination is necessary to expose tutoring. The Public Prosecutor counters that there is no valid reason to recall PW1; the accused is now in custody after new offences, and PW1's life is at risk; the court notes restriction under Section 33(5) of PoCSO on recalling a child witness multiple times. The court surveys Section 311 Cr.P.C, emphasizing its two parts and that recall must be used in the interests of justice, with caution, not to fill gaps or prejudice the defense. Relying on Mohanlal Shamji Soni and Ramchandra Rao, the court concludes that the evidence does not justify recalling witnesses, and Annexure A7 is left undisturbed. The petition is dismissed; the interim stay is vacated.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5299 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by George Cheriyan, the sole accused in Crime No.465/2024 of Maradu Police Station, Ernakulam, alleging offenses under Sections 354-A, 354-B, 376 and 506 IPC. The prosecution case claims that on 06.02.2024, around 22:00 hours, the accused, with an intent to sexually harass the de facto complainant, went to her rental premises, committed rape and outraged her modesty. The petitioner pleads innocence, asserting a total misconception of fact; he and the second respondent were in a live-in relationship and had consensual intercourse. The second respondent has filed Annexure A2 stating there is no subsisting grievance and disputes have been amicably settled. The Investigating Officer’s statement corroborates that the relationship was consensual, and the second respondent has no subsisting grievance. The petitioner’s counsel argues custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The prosecution, including the second respondent’s counsel, supports the lack of subsisting grievance and the settlement. After considering the rival submissions and record, the court holds that valid grounds exist to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Section 438 CrPC and grants pre-arrest bail, subject to conditions such as surrender within 10 days, bond with two sureties of Rs. 50,000 each, appearance for interrogation, avoidance of tampering, passport surrender, and no new offenses. The order clarifies its observations are for the bail application only and does not decide merits, and cites Sushila Aggarwal for investigative powers on bail.
Syamlal C.S., a 21-year-old petitioner, filed Bail Application No. 5295 of 2024 under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court seeking pre-arrest bail in Crime No. 918/2024 of Kilimanoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, for offences under Sections 294(b), 324 and 326 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 18.06.2024 at around 23:15 hours, the petitioner uttered obscene words to the de facto complainant, assaulted him with a knife on his left wrist, and caused grievous injuries. The medical record, including an accident register-cum-wound certificate, purportedly corroborates the injuries, including a distal ulna fracture and a type 3 open unicortical fracture of the left ulna. The petitioner contends innocence, claiming the de facto complainant trespassed into his house and that the scuffle led to injuries to the complainant; he asserts no criminal antecedents and that custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The State counters that investigation is ongoing and custodial interrogation is required to recover evidence; granting bail would undermine the investigation. The High Court, citing Supreme Court authorities that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy to be granted only in exceptional circumstances, assessed the materials and found no valid ground to grant Section 438 relief. Consequently, the application is dismissed, with a conditional direction that surrender within a week for interrogation may lead to merits-based consideration of bail; otherwise, arrest may proceed.
Vipin Varghese, the petitioner-accused 1 in Crime No.219/2024 of Mannar Police Station, Alappuzha, approaches the Kerala High Court under Section 439 CrPC seeking bail in a cheque-for-employment fraud case. The accusations allege that the petitioner, along with co-accused, lured the de facto complainant with promises of overseas employment in Canada and New Zealand, receiving Rs.15,00,000 with the intent to deprive or defraud by deceit; however, the employment was not provided and the money was not repaid. The petitioner claims innocence and asserts false involvement, highlighting that he has been in judicial custody since 10 March 2024 and that his arrest was noted in the present crime on 9 April 2024. The prosecution grounds its case on prior allegations—Criminal Nos. 387/2024 (Ernakulam Town South) and 479/2021 (Chenngannur)—arguing that the petitioner has criminal antecedents and may commit similar offences on bail. The Court notes that investigation is practically complete with recoveries effected and that the petitioner has already been enlarged on bail in Crime No.387/2024, with custody lasting about 70 days. The Court, after hearing, allows the bail application in the interest of justice, imposing a bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, and standard conditions including appearance, non-interference with witnesses, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, and contingencies for cancellation or modification of bail, citing Sushila Aggarwal for applicable principles on bail conditions.
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases This is a consolidated set of writ petitions challenging freezing of bank accounts by cybercrime police across multiple banks and states. The Kerala High Court, presided by Justice T.R. Ravi, on 26 March 2024 admitted WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 and connected matters and issued substantive interim directions to limit freezes to the amounts stated in police requisitions. The court relied on prior decisions including Dr. Sajeer v. RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and a prior W.P.(C) (28155/2023) to frame a proportionality-based approach to freezing. The orders direct respondent banks to confine the freeze to the disputed amount, require police to inform banks about the extent of seizure, and permit petitioners to transact beyond the freeze limit. The court also gave a timeframe: eight months from receipt of copy of the judgment for continued freezing, after which petitioners may approach the court again. The judgment reflects a balance between anti-money laundering/cybercrime actions and the financial rights of individuals and entities whose accounts were frozen, and consolidates the stance of multiple financial institutions and law-enforcement agencies under the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal/ICCC framework.
CRL.M.C. No. 6140 of 2021 Moosa Pattuppara, the sole accused in SC No. 826/2017 on the file of the Fast Track Special Court, Manjeri, moves a Criminal Miscellaneous Case challenging the trial court’s order that required him to obtain permission under the Passports Act to travel abroad. He is charged with offences under IPC Section 376 and the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. The trial court dismissed his application under Cr.P.C. 317 (incorrectly cited as 205) on the ground that an express order under the Passports Act was necessary before departure. The High Court examines the Passports Act, especially Section 6, the related exemption under Section 22 and the notification GSR 570(E) (1993), and the constitutional right to travel under Article 21, as reinforced by jurisprudence in Francis Manjooran, Satwant Singh Sawhney, and Maneka Gandhi. It is held that a person with a valid passport may travel abroad without prior court permission, and that pendency of a criminal case is not a ground to bar travel for such a person, unless restricted by bail conditions or due process. The court directs the Magistrate to consider the application in the petitioner’s absence and pass orders in accordance with law, with reasonable conditions to secure presence if required. The Crl.M.C. is disposed of accordingly.
WP(C) Nos. 19923 and 19969 of 2024 The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, heard two writ petitions challenging the denial of marks for Question No.63 in the K-TET examination held in March 2023. The question asked: “A tool which is not commonly found in a First Aid Kit.” Petitioners answered “Safety pin,” while the official answer key listed “Stethoscope” as the correct option. The petitioners sought mandamus and other relief, requesting cancellation of the question for all four sets and grant of one mark to those who answered in the same manner, along with issuing passing certificates. The court referred to Ext.P10, a Division Bench decision in W.A. No.539/2024, which held that the petitioner in that case was entitled to one mark for answering “Safety pin.” Relying on parity with similarly situated candidates and the expert opinion in Ext.P10, the court directed the 1st respondent to grant one mark to petitioners for Question 63 if their answer was “Safety pin,” and to issue certificates indicating that they have passed K-TET. Accordingly, the writ petitions were disposed of with these directions. The decision underscores the court’s willingness to ensure fairness in evaluation by aligning with a prior, closely related ruling. The matter was disposed by a single judge.
OP(KAT) Nos. 434 & 511 of 2019 These petitions challenge the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s final order dated 12 March 2019 in OA No.1177/2017, which held that the non-advising of the physically handicapped applicant against one of six vacancies reported in 2017 was illegal and directed the appointing authority to report two more substantive vacancies to the PSC for implementing the interim arrangement, and to advise disabled candidates from a revised special ranked list (Annexure-A6) within six weeks. The PSC’s stance was that all vacancies were exhausted and that the expired ranked list could not be revived. The Tribunal relied on central law requiring 3% reservation for physically disabled candidates and the duty of the government to identify posts suitable for such candidates and relate the priority to the Act’s enforce date (07-02-1996). The High Court, while acknowledging that the original applicant deserves relief, held that there is no legal necessity to compel the State to report two more vacancies. It directed the State Government to issue out-of-turn appointment orders to the original applicant as APP Grade II within six weeks, treating him as advised against one of the six interim vacancies or among the ten vacancies under GO137/2017. The Court clarified that the Tribunal’s other directions may be adjusted, and that the matter stands disposed of with modified directions maintaining the applicant’s rights while recognizing the expiry of the ranked list.
TR.P(C) Nos. 695/2019, 693/2019, 696/2019 This batch of three transfer petitions (Tr.P(C) Nos. 695/2019, 693/2019 and 696/2019) concerns Mohandas P.K.’s request to transfer divorce, maintenance and related proceedings from the Family Court, Kattappana to the Family Court, Thrissur. The petitioner contends that the 190-kilometer distance between his home in Thrissur district and Kattappana makes travel onerous given his age (57) and health issues, and that his elder sister, aged 65 and bedridden, requires his care. He also argues that the Family Court, Kattappana has been used to harass him. The respondent Jalaja Augustine resists the transfer, citing that she and her family reside in Upputhodu, Idukki, and that travel to Thrissur would impose hardship on her given her father’s 88-year-old bedridden condition and her mother’s cardiac issues; she notes that the petitioner previously traveled to Mumbai, suggesting he can travel to Kattappana if needed. The court heard submissions and, relying on Apex Court decisions such as Sumita Singh v. Kumar Sanjay and Rajani Kishor Pardeshi v. Kishor Babulal Pardeshi, held that the hardship to the female respondent in traveling outweighed the petitioner’s convenience. Consequently, the petitions were dismissed. The court directed that the Kattappana court require personal appearance only on postings that require physical presence.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A. No.1213 of 2019) challenging a trial court conviction under IPC sections 302 (murder) and 394 (robbery) arising from the murder of a co-employee in a lodge. The prosecution examined 28 witnesses, marked 46 documents and produced 20 material objects. The trial court convicted the appellant to life imprisonment for murder and five years for robbery, with fines and compensation. On appeal, the High Court scrutinizes circumstantial evidence: the “last seen together” theory, CCTV footage, and the chain of custody of exhibits, including MO1 knife, MO2 pillow, a gold chain and the deceased’s mobile. The court examines the admissibility and reliability of recoveries, such as those under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, and the translation issues in mahazars (one English, another Malayalam). It notes significant gaps: unclear FIS timing, absence of CCTV hard disk/viewing in court, non-examination or confrontation of crucial witnesses, inconsistent signatures, and absence of definitive proof that recovered items belonged to the deceased. The judgment emphasizes that the entire chain must be unbroken; it also underscores the accused’s right to explain incriminating circumstances under S.313 Cr.P.C. On these grounds, it acquits the appellant, holding the evidence insufficient to sustain a conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
This High Court, exercising its power under Section 482 CrPC, quashes a criminal complaint under Section 138 NI Act against the accused Dr. Baiju Senadhipan. The matter arises from ST No. 1046/2018 filed before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, South Paravoor, and the corresponding CRLMC No. 7533 of 2019. The sole dispute centers on Annexure A2, an agreement dated 21.11.2017 for the sale of 20,40,000 equity shares of Kerala Academy of Health Sciences and Research Pvt Ltd for Rs 2 crore. Clause 3 required Rs 50,00,000 to be paid forthwith by RTGS to the company, and Clause 4 provided that the balance Rs 1,50,00,000 would be paid within a month; it also states that non-payment of the advance or balance would automatically rescind the agreement. The complainant alleged that Rs 50 lakh was paid by a cheque (not RTGS) and that the cheque was dishonoured, yielding a prosecution under Section 138. The petitioner contends that the contract was never acted upon; because the agreement did not crystallize into a legally enforceable debt, the cheque cannot represent such a debt. The court relies on Supreme Court authority, notably Dashrathbhai, that a cheque must represent a legally enforceable debt at encashment, and relies on established quashing principles to conclude that the complaint does not disclose a criminal offence. It further notes that quashing is without prejudice to any mediation in related civil matters.
ST.Rev. Nos.13, 14 & 15 of 2021 Three Sales Tax Revision Nos. 13, 14 and 15 of 2021, heard together by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, challenge orders of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal (AGRL I.T.) at Kozhikode and Ernakulam, relating to assessment years 2010–11 and 2011–12 under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963. The State (revision petitioner) contends that the Tribunal erred in holding that Annexure-A orders were time-barred and that the Tribunal relied on an earlier ratio from Hotel Breezeland Ltd., which this Court had reversed in Commercial Tax Officer v Hotel Breezeland Ltd. The respondent hotel company opposes the revision, relying on the Tribunal’s findings and annexures, including assessment orders and common orders in T.A. Nos. 45/46 of 2018 and 53/2018. On 29 November 2022, the Court set aside the Tribunal orders, holding that limitation findings require independent re-consideration and that the Hotel Breezeland ratio is not binding due to reversal in Commercial Tax Officer v Hotel Breezeland Ltd.; the matters are remanded to the Tribunal for fresh consideration in light of governing law, with merits left open for decision by the Tribunal.