Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 578 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 7685 OF 2022

Adarsh@Kannan v. State of Kerala

This bail application concerns the third accused, Adarsh@Kannan, in SC No.20/2020 arising from Poovar Police Station crime 723/2019. The prosecution alleges that three accused conspired to abduct and murder the defacto complainant’s daughter on 21.06.2019 after the first accused, a soldier, faced an opposition to his marriage with another woman. The body was buried on the first accused’s property and steps were taken to destroy evidence. The 2nd accused was granted bail earlier; the petitioner’s bail was denied in two previous orders, with a directive to complete the trial in a time-bound manner. Counsel for the petitioner argued that despite the court’s directions, trial has not progressed because the presiding officer handling SC 20/2020 was transferred and charge given to another judge, delaying proceedings for over a month. He contended that the prosecution has not adduced evidence linking the petitioner beyond possible involvement under Section 201 IPC and that, even if the case is admitted as true, the petitioner’s role would be at most under Section 201 IPC. The petitioner has already been in detention for more than three years and three months; further detention would be unjust. The State argued the gravity of the offence, the murder’s planning, burial of the body, and the risk of witness interference. The learned court dismissed the bail application, transferred the case under Section 407 Cr.P.C to Sessions Court VI Thiruvananthapuram for expeditious trial within three months, and directed communication to the concerned court.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P.No.657 of 2022

Abdulla Kunhi C.H. v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Revision Petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by the sole accused, Abdulla Kunhi C.H., challenging the conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) for Rs. 5 lakh. The underlying case, CC No. 89/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-III, Kasaragod, arose from a financial dispute where the complainant alleged that the accused received Rs.5 lakh on 24.08.2011 and executed a written agreement, with a promise of 12.5% profit. When the complainant allegedly retracted, the accused issued a cheque for Rs.5 lakh on 30.03.2012, which was dishonoured for insufficient funds. Notices were issued, and proceedings under NI Act were instituted. The trial court convicted the accused under Sec. 138 NI Act and sentenced him to imprisonment until rising of the court and to pay Rs.5 lakh as fine, with the fine to be compensated to the complainant under Cr.P.C. Sec. 357(1). The Sessions Court upheld the conviction and sentence on appeal. The petitioner contends that Exts. P1 (cheque) and P6 (agreement) signatures should have been subjected to expert opinion and disputes the weight of the evidence; he seeks re-appreciation of evidence. The High Court, however, relies on settled revisional principles, upholding the concurrent findings and rejecting the petition for interference, citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and Rangappa v. Mohan, among others. The Court ultimately dismisses the revision, but grants two months to pay compensation and defers execution until 13.12.2022, adjusting Rs.1 lakh deposited.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.18464 of 2024

Finzer Muhammed v. Union of India and others

Finzer Muhammed, the petitioner, holds an account with the Ramanattukara branch of Federal Bank. He suddenly faced difficulties in operating his account and was informed that his account had been frozen based on requisitions received from the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal due to alleged suspicious transactions. The petitioner could not obtain specific details about the transactions, and the blanket debit freeze caused substantial hardship, hampering his ability to conduct day-to-day banking. He approached this Court seeking a writ of mandamus to direct the bank to lift the debit freeze. During hearing, it was submitted that a batch of similar matters had been disposed of in light of the decision in Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2023 KHC online 661). The respondents did not appear despite service. The Court found the directions in Dr. Sajeer supra to be sufficient to safeguard the petitioner's interests and disposed of the writ petition with those directions. The directions include: (i) where the disputed amount is not specified, the bank must request the Investigation Authority to indicate the freeze amount within one month; (ii) if the police specify a limit, freeze should be confined to that amount, enabling the petitioner to transact beyond that limit; (iii) police must inform within eight months whether freezing should continue and for how long; (iv) if no information is received, the petitioner may approach the Court again; (v) if no information within two months, the bank may allow full transactability subject to future information; (vi) if the police require full freeze, continue for eight months; (vii) if the requisition is not withdrawn after eight months, the petitioner may seek relief again.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 10612 of 2024 & con.cases

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam; WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases (consolidated)

The judgment arises from a large batch of writ petitions challenging and seeking to regulate the freezing of bank accounts by financial institutions in the wake of cybercrime investigations. The Kerala High Court, before Justice T.R. Ravi, consolidated WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected matters involving numerous petitioners whose bank accounts were frozen following police intimations under cybercrime/is investigation. The Court examined interim directions and the constitutional and statutory guarantee of due process for banks and account holders, noting the risk that pending criminal investigations could lead to unjust deprivation of legitimate funds. Relying on an earlier Kerala High Court decision in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and referencing W.P.(C) 28155/2023, the Court directed that freezes be confined strictly to the amounts specified in the police requisitions and that banks inform the police whether the freeze should continue for a further period. It preserved the petitioners’ right to approach the Court again if information was not furnished. The disposition closes the petitions with directions to limit freezes, mandate transparency, and provide a time-bound mechanism (eight months) for continuation, while keeping the petitioners’ and banks’ rights intact. The judgment emphasizes balancing investigative needs with the protection of civil liberties and the prudent use of banking powers in cybercrime contexts.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 6146 OF 2024

JENTLE GEORGE and others v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) filed by five accused in Crime No.241/2024 of Rajapuram Police Station, Kasargod, for offences under Section 3 r/w 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act. The petitioners were arrested and remanded on 02.07.2024. The prosecution case is that, on 13.06.2024 around 22:00 hours, the accused were found in a reserved forest area in Panathady with an unlicensed gun, allegedly with an intent to kill animals. The main factual backdrop is that the accused were caught with the weapon, there is no prior criminal antecedent, and the investigation is essentially complete with recovery effected. The petitioners contend innocence, false implication, and lack of material substantiating the offences, emphasizing their one month in judicial custody. The Respondent State, through the Public Prosecutor, counters that possession of an unlicensed weapon in a forest area creates a credible risk of witness tampering and interference if released. The court, drawing on Supreme Court precedents such as Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P, reiterates the presumption of innocence and the bail-rule principle, but also recognizes that bail is not an absolute right. After considering the circumstances — no antecedents, completion of investigation, ongoing recovery — the court allows the bail application with stringent conditions to ensure fair investigation and prevent abuse of liberty.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No.4233 of 2024

Yusuf v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application (B.A. No.4233 of 2024) filed before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam by Yusuf, accused in Crime No.46/2024 of Kallambalam Police Station. The petitioner faces charges under IPC sections including 376 and related clauses, along with seduction/assault provisions and POCSO Act sections. The FIR was registered on 11.01.2024 after the victim, a minor aged 13, disclosed multiple instances of sexual assault spanning about four years, with the most recent incident reported on 28.12.2023. Yusuf’s counsel contends that the allegations are vague and fabricated, highlighting a strained matrimonial relationship, a talaq notice issued by Yusuf, and a lack of penetrative injury on medical examination. They argue the case appears to be a weapon in matrimonial litigation and emphasize the accused’s status as a breadwinner, with his prolonged detention (217 days) already completed for investigation. The Public Prosecutor refutes these claims, pointing to incriminating materials, repeated penetration allegations, and the protection concerns for a minor victim. The court, noting the investigation is complete and there are no antecedents, nevertheless considers bail feasible under stringent conditions, applying well-known constitutional and jurisprudential principles that bail is the rule and jail is an exception, especially where the right to liberty is implicated under Article 21. The order ultimately grants bail with conditions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NOS. 8197 OF 2022, 8205 OF 2022, 8207 OF 2022

K.R. Prasad v. State of Kerala

Petitioner K.R. Prasad, sought anticipatory bail in three connected bail applications (BA 8197/2022, 8205/2022 and 8207/2022) arising from Palakkad Town South Police Station cases registered for offences under IPC sections 406, 420 and 120B and under the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning Act), 1978 (Sections 3, 4 and 5). The 2nd and 3rd accused allegedly induced the defacto complainant to invest in a company, promising large profits, but the invested amounts were not returned. The petitioner contends that though the defacto complainant claims he was a director of the first company, annexures filed with the petitions show otherwise; he was not a director and had no contact with the company. He also submits that after notices under Section 41A Cr.P.C. he appeared for interrogation, cooperated with the investigation, and that a sworn affidavit with Annexure-6 in one case states the complainant has no subsisting grievance. The Public Prosecutor confirms the 41A notices and cooperation. Having regard to the facts and the nature of the allegations, the learned judge held that custodial interrogation is not essential; only limited custody is needed. The petitions are allowed with stringent conditions: the petitioner shall surrender on 14.12.2022 for interrogation; if arrested in connected crimes, he shall be produced before the Magistrate on the same day and released on bail on conditions including a bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties of like amount, appearance as required, not tampering with evidence, not inducing witnesses, and not committing any other crime while on bail. The court also notes it is within police power to effect recoveries even while on bail, by relying on Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another (2020 (1) KHC 663).

High Court of Kerala
Crime No. 327/2024; Bail App No. 5871/2024

Pauloose Varkey v. State of Kerala

Pauloose Varkey, the sole accused in Crime No. 327/2024 of Kanjikuzhy Police Station, seeks pre-arrest bail under BNSS, 2023 before the Kerala High Court. The prosecution alleges that on 16.06.2024, around 18:45 hours, the accused attempted to outrage modesty; a scuffle ensued after the de facto complainant and his son questioned the incident at the accused’s shop. The de facto complainant and his son sustained injuries when the accused allegedly stabbed them with a knife; the son also sustained injuries. The prosecution anchors its case on medical records showing incised wounds and surgeries, and asserts that custodial interrogation and recovery of the weapon are necessary to advance the investigation. The petitioner’s counsel contends his innocence, asserts the incident involved private defence, highlights lack of prior criminal antecedents, and argues there is no necessity for custodial interrogation. He also disputes the inclusion of section 308 in the FIR. The Public Prosecutor counters with incriminating materials and medical evidence, emphasising the need for investigation and that grant of bail would hamper it. The court relies on Supreme Court principles that anticipatory bail is extraordinary and should be granted only in exceptional circumstances, and ultimately dismisses the bail application while directing surrender within a week for interrogation with a pathway to later consideration on merits.

High Court of Kerala
RP Nos. 697 & 847 of 2021

RP Nos. 697 & 847 of 2021 (Review Petitions) v. WP(C) 2983/2015, High Court of Kerala

This is a two-file review of the 2019 judgment in WP(C) 2983/2015, heard by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V. The petitions—RP No.697/2021 (Director, ANERT and ANERT represented by its Executive Committee) and RP No.847/2021 (State of Kerala)—challenge the order promoting scientists in relaxation of CSR norms and the denial of arrears in terms of earlier CSIR patterns. The petitioners argued that Annexure-1 (G.O. 13/2010/PD) was not produced before the court at the time of the writ petition and that had it been placed, the outcome might have differed. They contended that the promotion grant based on Annexure-III and the retrospective relaxations were improper, involving misrepresentation and faulty practices. The respondents contended that review jurisdiction is narrowly confined to discovery of new matter, errors on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason, and not to merits. The court reaffirmed the limited scope of review (citing Moran Mar Baselios, Shivdev Singh, and Lily Thomas), noted that Annexure-1 was already discussed and references to it appeared in pleadings, and found no new grounds for review. It ultimately held that the review petitions are not permissible and dismissed them, leaving the original judgment in WP(C) 2983/2015 intact and the arrears/promotions order undisturbed.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.5617 of 2024

Rajesh @ Pappali Rajesh v. State of Kerala

This bail application concerns Rajesh alias Pappali Rajesh, the second accused in Crime No. 218/2024 of Mararikulam Police Station, Alappuzha, charged with offences under Sections 506(1), 541, 323 and 326 read with 34 IPC, and Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The petitioner, who has been in judicial custody since 13.06.2024, seeks bail, noting that the investigation is complete and recoveries have been effected. It is argued that the inclusion of Section 326 aims to deny bail without warranted basis, and that co-accused 1 and 3 have already been released on bail. The prosecution counters that the petitioner has criminal antecedents across eight cases from 2009 to 2019 and that there is a real risk of witness intimidation and tampering if he remains at large. The court places weight on the presumption of innocence, the general principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception under Article 21, and relevant Supreme Court authorities including Hussainara Khatoon, Sanjay Chandra, and State of Kerala v. Raneef, noting that pre-conviction detention must be carefully justified. After considering the length of detention, completion of investigation, prior bail granted to co-accused, and lack of post-2019 cases, the court concludes that further detention is unnecessary and allows the bail application. The order imposes bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties, and conditions requiring weekly appearances before the Investigating Officer, non- interference with witnesses, no offence on bail, passport surrender (or an affidavit), and a provision for cancellation or modification of bail on violation, with authority to recover as needed under Sushila Aggarwal guidance.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 2037 OF 2022

Kunjumol Thankappan v. Parvathi and others

This original petition (OP(C) 2037/2022) before the Kerala High Court challenges Ext.P10 in E.A.229/2022 in E.P.11/2017 in O.S.189/2016 of the Munsiff Court, Perumbavoor. The decree-holders obtained an ex-parte decree in 2016 for possession of a building on 30 cents in Koovappady and for Rs.1,12,500 for unauthorized occupancy. An Advocate Commissioner’s report misreported the land; the petitioner contended that the building (No.19/340) was not properly identified and that the property is secured asset of Koovappadi Service Cooperative Bank due to mortgage. She sought to stay delivery (Ext.P7) and to remit back the commission report (Ext.P8). The court below dismissed Ext.P8, prompting this petition alleging perjury and concealment of earlier litigation. The petitioner later admitted non-disclosure of related cases in an affidavit, leading the court to find willful suppression and abuse of process. The learned Judge rejected Ext.P8 as barred by res judicata, citing prior judgments (including RSA 181/2020 and a Supreme Court SLP) and following the Supreme Court’s directions in Rahul S. Sahah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi (2021) 6 SCC 418 to dismiss frivolous execution petitions with exemplary costs. The court ultimately dismissed the petition, confirmed Ext.P10, and imposed a Rs.50,000 costs order payable within three weeks, with execution rights reserved if unpaid. The bench declined contempt due to age.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 1207 of 2019

Bhageerathi (Appellant) v Chandrika and Others

This Regular Second Appeal challenges the judgment and decree in AS No.189/2015 of the Additional District Court, Irinjalakuda, which affirmed a trial court decree in OS No.464/2012 of the Additional Subordinate Judge’s Court, Irinjalakuda. The dispute concerns boundary fixation and permanent injunction over land in Koolimuttam Village (survey No.188/7). An extent of 1.23 acres was allotted: 50 cents sold to the defendant; the remaining 73 cents (plaint A schedule) in the plaintiffs’ possession. The defendant allegedly trespassed into plaint A schedule, asserting the boundary is at a higher level aligning with plaint B schedule land, and he constructed a northwestern boundary wall. The trial court found plaintiffs had title and possession over plaint A schedule (except the B schedule), and decreed fixation of the eastern boundary and a permanent injunction. The Additional District Judge affirmed this, prompting Bhageerathi (wife of the original defendant) to approach the High Court in RSA 1207/2019. The High Court, while acknowledging admissions of trespass, analyzed whether a suit for fixation of boundary without a prayer for possession constitutes maintainable relief where part of the land is found in possession of the defendant. It concluded that approximately 12.4 cents of the plaint A schedule lay in the defendant’s possession and that fixing a boundary could not substitute for possession recovery. The appeal was allowed in part: the boundary fixation decree was set aside and the suit dismissed, while the injunction against trespass was confirmed; the plaintiff’s right to seek possession in appropriate proceedings remained reserved. The court observed that the proceeding should not substitute for recovery of possession and that the boundary as per Ext. C1(a) could be treated separately for purposes of the injunctive relief. The bench was a Single Judge, and the neutral citation is not provided in the document.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO. 768 OF 2021

Archana v. Rajeesh A.J. and Others

Archana v. Rajeesh A.J. and Others is a Kerala High Court matrimonial appeal arising from the Ottapalam Family Court's order striking off the pleadings in OP 573/2014 for recovery of gold ornaments. The petition, under the Family Courts Act, 1984, sought return of jewels and related relief in a context permeated by multiple disputes between the parties, including child custody proceedings. The Family Court, noting repeated non‑compliance with custody orders, struck off the pleadings of the petitioner, effectively terminating her case on the merits. The appellants challenged this drastic action, arguing that the pleading strike‑off is an extreme, drastic remedy inappropriate for a matter unrelated to the alleged non‑compliance and that the court’s jurisdiction was exceeded. The respondents defended the order as a legitimate use of the court’s inherent powers to enforce compliance with its orders and to prevent abuse of process, even in proceedings that are separate. The judgment cites Shyju.P.K v. Nadeera to emphasize that inherent powers under Section 151 CPC are limited to procedural matters and cannot affect substantive rights, drawing on Padam Sen v. State of Uttar Pradesh for the doctrine that such powers are not to override substantive rights. Ultimately, the High Court allowed the MAT.APPEAL, set aside the impugned order, and restored the pleadings, clarifying that the Family Court may act against non‑compliance in custody matters in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.4668 of 2024

Salam M.S. v. State of Kerala and Others

Salam M.S., the petitioner, challenges Ext.P2, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting his Form 5 application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, to remove his land from the Data Bank. He owns 4.05 ares of land in Re-Sy.No.18/1-3, Pattimattom, Ernakulam. He contends the land is not paddy land or wetland and should not be included in the Data Bank; the RDO relied on the KSRSEC report and the LLMC’s recommendation to retain the land. The KSRSEC report indicates the land as fallow with mixed vegetation as of 2008, and the petitioner argues Ext.P2 misquotes Ext.P1 and that no independent assessment of the land’s nature was done as on the date of coming into force of the Act, 2008. The petitioner invokes precedents including Mather Nagar Residents Association and Adani Infrastructures to argue that fallow land cannot be treated as wetland or paddy land under the Act. The court ultimately holds that there is non‑enlightened application of mind in Ext.P2 and sets it aside, directing the RDO to reconsider the Form No.5 application in light of Ext.P1 and binding precedents within two months, and dispose of the petition with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No. 762 of 2024

Sreejith v. State of Kerala and Ors.

This writ petition challenges Ext. P2 externment order under the Kerala Anti Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAPA), which restricted the petitioner’s movements in Thrissur Revenue District for six months, later reduced to three months by the KAAPA Advisory Board (Exts. P1–P4). The petitioner, a ward member, contends the order is vitiated by delay, lacks a live link to the last prejudicial act, and misapplies KAAPA by treating routine criminal conduct as anti-social activity. The record shows four IPC cases over several years, including grievous hurt, attempted culpable homicide not amounting to murder, trespass into a hospital and assault on a Lady Doctor, and a 2024 medical-practitioner-related matter that culminated in bail in March 2024. The challenge argues that, given long intervals between some offenses, the “known rowdy” classification and externment are politically motivated, and there is no direct connection to current threats. The respondents contend that the petitioner’s ongoing pattern of conduct prejudices public order and that externment is a protective, pre-emptive measure permitted by KAAPA. The court emphasizes that, while subjective satisfaction in KAAPA proceedings is not ordinarily justiciable, it must be grounded in record materials and not mala fide or legally irrelevant. Citing Ibrahim Bachu Bafan and Benoy @ Gillappi, the court ultimately dismisses the petition and upholds the externment regime and its limited duration.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 4914 of 2024

Hashique v. State of Kerala

Hashique, the sole accused in Crime No.1000/2023 of Parappanangadi Police Station, Malappuram, challenges an order canceling his bail issued by the Special Court in SC No.102/2024 following a subsequent crime registered against him. The bail order in the crime stage had imposed stringent conditions, including reporting to the Investigating Officer on Thursdays, surrender of his passport, and not tampering with evidence or contacting the victim or witnesses. The prosecution later moved to cancel bail after the victim’s mother alleged that the accused sent threatening messages to pressurize withdrawal of the case, and a new crime (No.20/2024) under IPC 506(1) and the Kerala Police Act 120 was registered. The Special Judge granted cancellation, citing material from the case diary and messages recovered in the investigation. Hashique has contended that the second crime is baseless, that the court did not examine it prima facie, and that the bail cancellation was effected without reviewing the records. The High Court surveys a line of precedents on bail cancellation: Sobhin Sunny; Sreeja Mannangath; P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh (three-judge bench) and related cases (Dolat Ram, Dataram Singh, X1); Godson; Ajwar; and Deepak Yadav. The court affirms the principle that bail cannot be canceled mechanically and requires supervening circumstances and proper consideration of material. It concludes that the accused violated bail conditions 4–6, justifying cancellation, and dismisses the petition, directing surrender and coercive arrest if necessary; interim orders stand vacated.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5547 OF 2024

USMAN PULAKKAL v. STATE OF KERALA & THE INTELLIGENCE OFFICER, INTELLIGENCE UNIT – VI, KERALA STATE GST DEPARTMENT

USMAN PULAKKAL, the sole accused in Crime No. 219/2024 registered with InfoPark Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks bail under Sec.439 CrPC. The Kerala State Goods and Services Tax Department alleges that he procured fake registration certificates in multiple names to claim inadmissible input tax credit and thereby evade payment of GST to the tune of Rs.15.91 crore, an offence under Sec.132(1)(i) of the Central and State GST Act, 2017. The petitioner was arrested on 06.06.2024 and has remained in judicial custody for 61 days; the investigation is not complete and the final report has not been laid. The prosecution filed a Bail Objection Report and opposed bail, asserting incriminating materials and a risk of tampering with witnesses if released. The defence contends innocence and lack of material to substantiate the accusation, arguing that the offence carries a maximum sentence of five years and that bail should be granted as per statutory rights given the delay in investigation. The judge relies on jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, notably Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (2001) 5 SCC 453, which, along with Sanjay Dutt v. State (supra), reiterates that after expiry of 60/90 days the accused may be released on bail as a matter of right if the investigation remains incomplete. The court also cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) for permissible exercise of police powers during bail. On considering the circumstances, the court holds the petitioner is entitled to statutory bail and orders release on a bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including appearance, non-tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, and compliance with further orders if the final report is laid.

High Court of Kerala
RP 770/2024; RP 771/2024

RP Nos. 770/24 & 771/24: Sayyid Hashim K.V.K. v. Anas Mohammed T.K. & others; Sayyid Hameed Ali.K.V.K. v. Anas Mohammed T.K. & others

These review petitions were filed by Sayyid Hashim K.V.K. and Sayyid Hameed Ali.K.V.K. challenging two appointment approvals under Exts. P4–P6 dated 26.02.2022 and 28.02.2022 in IKT HSS Cherukulamaba, Malappuram. The writ petition in which the appointments were sought for approval had results, and respondents 1–3 sought the court's directions to approve; The common interim order in W.P.(C). Nos. 7202/2022 and 7864/2022 interdicted the Manager from making new appointments; Hence, the writ petition argued the approvals could not be granted. The Hon'ble Court, by its judgment dated 01.06.2024, directed the 1st respondent to reconsider the approval of the appointments if the petitioners are eligible. The review petitions argued that Annexure-A2 Government Order No.169/04/G.Edn dated 15.06.2004, Clause 5(ii), precludes approval on regular basis where appointment began after reopening and ends within next academic year; it states fractions of the year will not be considered for regular pay when vacancies are filled mid-year. However, the court relied on Sneha Cherian v. State of Kerala (2013 (1) KLT 755) and concluded that where vacancies are regular and extend beyond one academic year, approvals on the scale of pay can be granted even for mid-year appointments; Annexure-A2 cannot override. In these circumstances, the petitions were dismissed; the court directed reconsideration of approvals if eligibility persists.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5335 OF 2024

Soumya and Thankamma v. State of Kerala

This is a pre-arrest bail petition under Section 438 CrPC filed by accused 3 and 4, Soumya and Thankamma, in Crime No.366/2024 at Cumbummettu Police Station, Idukki. The petition, B.A. No. 5335 of 2024, challenges the investigation initiated by the police for offences under sections 294(b), 323, 324 and 326 read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution asserts that the investigation is ongoing and there is a risk of tampering with evidence or intimidating witnesses if bail is granted. The petitioners contend that their involvement is limited to allegedly uttering obscene words; the more serious offence under Section 326 IPC is alleged only against the 1st accused, who is said to have assaulted the defacto complainant resulting in a rib fracture, and the 2nd accused allegedly struck the complainant with a soda bottle. The court notes that there is no specific overt act attributed to the petitioners for the 326 IPC offence and finds that custodial interrogation is not necessary. The order grants pre-arrest bail subject to conditions: surrender before IO within 10 days; bond of Rs. 50,000 with two solvent sureties for the same amount; cooperation with IO; no tampering or intimidation; passport surrender; avoidance of other offences; and possible modification of conditions only by court. The court cites Sushila Aggarwal for the principle permitting certain police actions during bail, while clarifying the decision does not express a finding on merits.

High Court of Kerala
Bail Application No.4725 of 2024

Agnel Mathew v. State of Kerala

The applicant, Agnel Mathew, filed Bail Application No.4725 of 2024 under Section 439 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, seeking bail in Crime No.393/2024 of the Ernakulam Town North Police Station. The First Information Report alleges offences under Sections 363, 370(4), 354, and 354A(1)(i) IPC and Sections 7 and 12 read with Section 11(1) of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, arising from events in February 2024 where the minor victim (16 years) was allegedly enticed by telephone, trafficked on a scooter to a lodge, and subjected to sexual acts and outraging modesty. The accused was arrested on 2.4.2024. The petitioner contends innocence, arguing there is no material establishing guilt and alleging police vendetta due to a related case (Crime No.262/2024). He has been in judicial custody for about 112 days, with investigation not yet completed and no final report laid. The State opposes bail, citing incriminating materials and the accused’s prior antecedents, though acknowledging the investigation is pending. The court invoked Section 167(2) CrPC and, applying the principles in Uday Mohanlal Acharya and Sanjay Dutt, held that the indefeasible right to statutory bail accrues on default in investigation within the prescribed period, given the factual delay. The application is allowed, and bail is granted on conditions including a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, and supervision by the Investigating Officer, among others, with references to Sushila Aggarwal for permissible on-bail investigations.