Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 576 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 112 OF 2019

M/S West Line Auto Hire Purchase v. Joemon Poulouse & State of Kerala

The appeal concerns a criminal case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, filed by a hire-purchase firm (the appellant) against Joemon Poulouse (the guarantor) and the State of Kerala. The trial court acquitted the accused in CC 2333/2009 on 30 May 2015, holding that the complainant failed to prove the execution of the cheque Ext.P2 and the debt it purportedly discharged. The appellant contends that Ext.P2, a cheque for Rs 16,000 issued on 3 June 2009, was given as consideration for terminating the hire-purchase agreement and as a payment for damages; it was accepted by the complainant and dishonored on presentation. The prosecution relies on the presumption under Section 139 NI Act that a signed cheque issued for a debt raises a presumption of liability, reversing the burden on the accused to prove otherwise. The trial court’s misapplication of the evidence is challenged on the basis of Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, a Supreme Court decision stating that a signed, voluntarily issued cheque attracts the presumption unless rebutted. However, the High Court acknowledges that termination of the hire-purchase agreement discharged the principal debtor, invoking Section 128 of the Indian Contract Act to hold that the guarantor’s liability is co-extensive with the principal debtor; once the principal is released, the guarantor is discharged. The Court dismisses the appeal, affirming the acquittal and holding that the evidence supports that the accused discharged his liability. The judgment thus reinforces the rule that termination of the underlying debt can absolve a guarantor from liability even where a signed cheque was produced.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1334 of 2021

Ponnappan P.V. v. Santosh P.R and Others

The appellant, Ponnappan P.V., sustained grievous injuries in a road traffic accident on 16 March 2015 when his autorickshaw was struck by a tipper lorry driven rashly and negligently. He remained bedridden and in a vegetative state for an extended period and filed OP(MV) No.1103/2016 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, seeking compensation of Rs. 1,21,26,000 (capped at Rs. 50 lakh). The Tribunal awarded Rs. 15,90,000, prompting a challenge in MACA No. 1334 of 2021, arguing that as a professional autorickshaw driver he deserved higher income and that notional income fixed by the Tribunal was unfounded. The appellant contends Ext.A23 proves professional earnings around Rs. 1,500 per day and relies on Ramachandrappa to set a higher notional income with future prospects; further, given a completely vegetative state, he merits an attender and maintenance, supported by Kajal and Jithendran. The Insurance Company counters that there is no proof of professional driving and the Tribunal’s figures are correct. The High Court found Ext.A23 credible, applied Ramachandrappa to set a notional income of Rs. 11,000 per month with 25% future prospects, and held the appellant entitled to attendant care and enhanced damages in several heads, while deleting loss of earning and sustaining other heads with adjustments. The appeal was partly allowed, amplifying compensation in key categories and directing payment with interest.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C NO. 8461 OF 2022

Ramsheed K.K. and Arafath N.P. v. State of Kerala and Manoj P.

The petitioners, Ramsheed K.K. and Arafath N.P., are accused in Crime No. 503/2016 of Hosdurg Police Station, charged with rioting and various offences under the Indian Penal Code (sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 324, 326 and 308) read with section 149. The trial before the Additional Sessions Court-II, Kasaragod, led to acquittals of accused 1, 2 and 5–7 under Section 232 Cr.P.C., while the petitioners’ case was separated and refiled as SC No. 179/2021. The petition seeks quashing of all further proceedings in SC No. 179/2021 on the ground that the dispute between the parties is private and has been settled, with the injured party swearing an affidavit (Annexure-A4) stating no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. The SHO verified the settlement, and the injured party reiterated consent to quashing before the SHO. The court found the dispute essentially private, and continuing proceedings would unlikely lead to a successful prosecution. Relying on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another, the court held that its power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is applicable. Though offences under Sections 326 and 308 IPC are involved, the acquittals of other accused and lack of prosecution substratum support quashing. The Crl.M.C. is allowed; Annexure-A2 final report and all further proceedings in SC No. 179/2021 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 24621 of 2017

Revenue Divisional Officer, Idukki v. Mathews T. L. and Sibi Thomas

The petition challenges interim Lok Ayukta directions that effectively granted access for a private road through the complainant’s land to facilitate a crusher unit, which the petitioner contends is beyond the Lok Ayukta’s power. Lok Ayukta Complaint No. 816/2017 admitted for investigation on 12.06.2017, observing that the complainant owns land within which a crusher unit is proposed after environmental clearance; the data bank classified a road through Sy. 226/2 as paddy field, while reports (Exts. P5–P7) showed the road existed for long and that land conversion had occurred long before the Paddy Land and Wet Land Protection Act, 2008. The Lok Ayukta issued interim orders directing permit for the crusher and road use (Exhibits P6 and P8). The Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejected vehicular permission on 16.06.2017 citing the 8-metre road through Nilam on Sy.226/2, and the Lok Ayukta’s interim directions effectively granted the relief sought by the complainant. The petitioner contends that the Lok Ayukta acted without authority under the Kerala Lok Ayukta Act, 1999 and without following statutory procedures—especially given the Data Bank status and the State Government circulars restricting powers under the Kerala Land Utilization Order. The High Court, without addressing merits, holds that interim relief cannot substitute final relief, sets aside the interim orders, and directs expedited final disposal by the Lok Ayukta while closing interlocutory applications.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 30487, 31008 & 31242 of 2022

W.P.(C).Nos.30487,31008 & 31242 of 2022

These connected writ petitions challenge the refusal by Marriage Officers to solemnize intended marriages by video conferencing, arguing for virtual solemnization given spouses working abroad. Petitioners Lucy Rajan Ag, Krishnapriya P.S., and Seethalakshmi P filed notices of intended marriage under the Special Marriage Act and sought permission to solemnize through online mode. They contended that a Division Bench of this Court had previously permitted marriages via video conferencing and that this practice has been consistently followed during the COVID-19 pandemic, allowing marriages to proceed with witnesses and documents furnished electronically. The Government Pleader argued that the Division Bench order was pandemic-era in origin and that the statutory procedure under the Act and its Rules must be followed, creating practical difficulties for Marriage Officers to conduct online ceremonies. The court analyzed precedents: Paradeep Kodiveedu Cletus v. Local Registrar of Marriages (2018) and Dioncey Augustine v. State of Kerala (2019). It held that Paradeep Kodiveedu Cletus, affirmed by the Division Bench, supports online solemnization and should guide the present matter, while the latter decision was distinguished. The judge directed that marriages be solemnized through video conferencing with conditions: witnesses present before the Marriage Officer; witnesses identify parties online; copies of passports and essential documents furnished in advance; signatures by Power of Attorney when necessary; the Marriage Officer to fix date/time and platform; certificate issuance per Section 13 of the Special Marriage Act, with a two-week extension of statutory deadlines.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) Nos.585 & 608 of 2022

JAMINUDEEN v. ASWATHY NATH

These Original Petitions (O.P.(FC) Nos.585 & 608 of 2022) arise from a cross-challenge to an interim custody order issued by the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, concerning a minor Aliya Sulthana (12). The Family Court’s order of 27.08.2022 laid down shared custody on alternate Saturdays, with exchange at Palayam Juma Masjid, restricted travel outside the district, and limited telephonic contact. The father (585/2022) and the mother (608/2022) contend that the order did not adequately evaluate the child’s welfare and accordingly seeks modification or reversal. The Court cites Rosy Jacob v. Jacob A. Chakramakkal and Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan to emphasize that the child’s welfare is paramount, that a child is not a mere chattel, and that custody decisions must consider the child’s best interests and ensure ongoing contact with both parents. The High Court finds that an independent welfare evaluation is essential before finalizing any interim custody order, sets aside the impugned order, and remits the matter to the Family Court with directions to address the child’s health and to conduct a thorough welfare inquiry. The Court directs the parties to appear with the child on 31.10.2022 for fresh proceedings, underscoring that the child’s welfare governs the outcome rather than litigants’ positions.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.3019/2019

OP(C) No.3019/2019; Sangeeth M.S & Vineeth M.S v. Sujatha, Vasanti, Vimala, Jyothi, Valsan, M.K. Yajithra & M.K. Rajeev

This Original Petition (OP(C)) challenges an order passed in I.A.1298/2019 in O.S.488/2011 of the Additional Sub Court, Irinjalakuda. The plaintiffs in the partition suit moved to amend the valuation of the relief 'AA' to Rs.25,01,000 and to add a declaration that Thriprayar documents 1285/2011 and 1286/2011 are null and void and not binding on the plaint schedule property. The Munsiff initially allowed the amendment, treating the 'AA' relief as ancillary and thus not requiring a separate court fee. Petitioners (defendants 2 and 4) challenged this on the ground that aa relief is not purely incidental and should attract ad valorem court fee under Section 25(d)(1) of the Kerala Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act, relying on Shamsher Singh v. Rajinder Prashad. Respondents argued that the 'AA' relief is ancillary, and the court should not require a separate fee. The Kerala High Court analyzed authorities, including Sankaran v. Velukutty, which held that in partition suits, a prayer for declaration that a settlement deed is invalid is incidental, and no separate court fee should be paid. The court held Sankaran would apply here; thus the order permitting amendment was proper and did not require interference. Accordingly, the Original Petition was dismissed. The decision clarifies the boundary between main relief and incidental relief in partition suits and the corresponding court fee obligations.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 28946 OF 2020

K. Premarajan v State of Kerala and Others

This Kerala High Court writ petition challenges Ext. P10, an order denying the petitioner pension for his service as a member of the Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) and refusing him a re-option under amended pension regulations. The petitioner, aged 66, served as Commissioner in the Malabar Devaswom Board and as Additional Secretary to Government before being appointed as a PSC member on 29 January 2011, retiring on 28 January 2017. He contends that he has been drawing a pension only for his Government service and not for PSC service, and that Regulation 7A of the Kerala Public Service Commission Regulations, 1957 (as amended) and its retrospective amendments entitle him to pension based on PSC service. He argues that he exercised an option to draw pension for prior Government service, and that the amended Regulation 7A(1) and 7(1) retrospectively allow pension at 7.5% of basic pay per year for PSC service up to 50% of basic pay plus Dearness Allowance. Ext.P10 purportedly relies on unamended provisions and denies re-option. The petitioner relies on Ramakrishnam Raju P. v Union of India (2014 KHC 4209) to claim non-discrimination among PSC appointees, and points to Exts.P13, P17, P20 showing similarly situated persons granted benefits. Respondents contend there is no statutory basis for re-option and the amendments do not confer a new right. The court holds Ext.P10 unwarranted, sets it aside, and directs the Government to reconsider the petitioner’s case for re-option and pension under the amended Regulations, following due procedure and considering relief already granted to similarly placed individuals, within three months.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 310 of 2019

Joseph Thannikottu Korah v. The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax

This Kerala High Court judgment concerns an Income Tax Appeal filed by Shri Joseph Thannikottu Korah, an employee of KMML Ltd., Kollam, for AY 2011-12. The assessee disclosed an income of Rs.5,77,610, but scrutiny under the CASS scheme and a notice under section 143(2) of the IT Act prompted examination of a Rs.30,00,000 cash deposit in his ICICI bank account on 20 January 2011. The case centers on the appellant’s claim that the Rs.30 lakh represented sale proceeds of land belonging to his wife, Saly Joseph, who had transferred 76.73 ares to a buyer, Sajeev Mathai, for Rs.31,00,000, although the sale deed shows a sale consideration of only Rs.3,35,700. The appellant contended that Rs.1,00,000 and Rs.30,00,000 represented the actual consideration; the balance difference was allegedly due to the difference between document value and market value. A sworn statement was recorded; despite opportunities, the source of the money could not be substantiated, and the Assessing Officer treated the amount as cash credit. The CIT(A) upheld the assessment; the ITAT partly allowed the appeal, crediting Rs.3,35,700 against the Rs.30,00,000 deposit. The appellant argued that the Assessing Officer should verify the buyer’s position to confirm the source. The High Court ultimately dismissed the appeal, holding the substantial questions of law against the appellant and sustaining the Tribunal’s findings. The decision emphasizes that the source must be substantiated beyond the document value; merely relying on the sale deed without corroboration is insufficient.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 10612 of 2024

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam — WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases (consolidated)

This is a consolidated batch of writ petitions filed in the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam challenging freeze orders on a large number of bank accounts in the wake of cybercrime investigations. The petitions involve individuals, service cooperatives, travel and financial entities as petitioners, and various banks, police authorities, and the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal as respondents. The court, on 26 March 2024, heard these petitions together with connected matters (WP(C) 10612/2024 and others) and issued uniform interim directions to limit freezes to the amounts specified in the police notices, and to inform the banks about any further freezing. The orders emphasize balancing anti-fraud enforcement with petitioners’ banking rights, directing banks to restrict the freeze to the disputed sums and allowing transaction beyond those limits, while keeping the petitioners’ other contentions alive for potential future adjudication. The judgment relies on earlier precedents, notably Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), and cites prior Writ Petitions such as WP(C) 28155/2023 and others for guidance. The court ultimately disposed of the petitions with directions to implement these interim safeguards, and to permit petitioners to approach the court if required. The decision consolidates procedure to safeguard account operation during ongoing investigations.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5528 OF 2024

Appu v. State of Kerala

Appu, a 19-year-old accused in Crime No. 221/2024 of Aruvikkara Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC after being in judicial custody for 132 days. The allegations against him include rape and penetrative sexual assault, sexual offences against a 16-year-old girl, and related charges under the IPC (sections 376(2)(n), 354, 354(B), 452, 323, 506(i)) and the POCSO Act (section 6(1) r/w 5(l), 12 r/w 11(v)). The prosecution contends that there is incriminating material and risk of intimidation of the victim and witnesses, as well as possible tampering with evidence. The defense argues innocence, falsely implicated, and asserts a long-standing relationship with the victim, with consent in the alleged acts. The court notes that the investigation is complete, medical examinations conducted, and a final report laid. It cites well-established bail principles from Dataram Singh, State of Kerala v. Raneef, Hussainara Khatoon (I), and the broader constitutional mandate under Article 21, declaring that bail is the rule and detention is an exception. After balancing the facts—age, custody duration, and lack of prior antecedents—the judge grants bail with stringent conditions, including bond of Rs 1 lakh with two sureties, mandatory biweekly appearances, non-interference with witnesses, passport surrender, travel restrictions, and a reservation of power to cancel or modify conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases — In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This batch of writ petitions, including WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 and connected matters, was heard by the Hon'ble Justice T. R. Ravi on 26 March 2024. The petitions challenge freezing of bank accounts by various banks on police/intimation in cybercrime investigations across multiple states. The petitioners, consisting of individuals and financial/credit-cooperative entities holding accounts with Federal Bank, ICICI Bank, Canara Bank and others, assert that blanket freezing of their entire balances is disproportionate and causes grave hardship, particularly where there is no proven proceeds of crime or where transactions are bonafide. They argue that freezing orders should be confined strictly to the amounts mentioned in police requisitions and that any further freezing should be anchored to defined legal grounds with judicial oversight. The respondents—government agencies, police cybercrime departments, and banks—contend that freezing is a precautionary measure to preserve assets pending investigation and that banks must comply with lawful directions to counter money laundering and cybercrime. The court issued interim directions directing the respondent banks to confine freezes to the disputed sums specified in the police orders, to inform the banks whether freezing should continue and for how long, and to limit continuation to a maximum period of eight months from the date of the order. If information is not supplied, petitioners may apply again. The judgment aims to balance effective crime prevention with safeguarding legitimate banking needs.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C).No.2535/2021

Big Movers 2/439-B v. Reeni George & Others in OP(C) No.2535/2021 (Impleadment in AS 11/2021)

Big Movers, a tender bidder, challenges Ext.P6 (order in IA 5/2021 in AS 11/2021) of the Additional District Judge-VII, Ernakulam, under Article 227 of the Constitution. The petitioner sought impleadment as an additional third respondent in the appeal arising from Cochin Port Trust’s tender for open space comprising around 14,260 sq meters, which was being contested due to the pendency of the appeal and an interim order. Big Movers had submitted the highest bid ( Rs.65,10,000 against a base price of Rs.21,50,650) and paid an Earnest Money Deposit, but the tender was not awarded because of the litigation. The petitioner argued that, because the space is licenced to others and the highest bidder stands to suffer substantial financial losses during the extended validity of the tender, impleadment as a party was necessary for a complete and effective decision. The respondents contended that the petitioner is neither a necessary nor a proper party, as its presence is unnecessary for a just resolution of the appeal. The High Court examined the dis-tinction between necessary and proper parties, citing Udit Narain Malpaharia, Razia Begum, and Union of India v. Sher Singh, and concluded that the petitioner has no direct nexus with the lis and is not indispensable for adjudication. Consequently IA 5/2021 was dismissed, Ext.P6 upheld, and the petition disposed with directions to expeditiously dispose of the main appeal (A.S.No.11/2021).

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 689 OF 2024

Sabari S. Nair v. State of Kerala and Divya G.G.

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Revision Petition (CRL.RP No. 689 of 2024) filed by Sabari S. Nair challenging a Magistrate’s order under the Domestic Violence Act (DV Act) and an appellate order in a criminal appeal arising from proceedings in M.C. No. 11/2023. The M.C. was instituted by Divya G.G. (the wife) seeking relief under the DV Act; an interim order under Section 18 was granted and a vehicle (Toyota Fortuner, KL-01-CG-7777) in the shared household was ordered to be returned to the petitioner, and the husband’s acts were alleged as exercise of economic abuse. The Magistrate’s order was later affirmed by the Additional Sessions Court. The revision contends maintainability under Cr.P.C. (Sections 397/401) and questions the propriety of a separate interim relief under CMP No. 1536/2023 in M.C. 11/2023, arguing that it undermines the mandate of Section 25(2) of the DV Act. The High Court examines whether a revision is permissible against an appellate order under DV Act, considers the interplay between DV Act provisions (Sections 5, 18, 25, 28, 3 and their explanations) and Cr.P.C., and discusses precedents such as Harshakumar v. State of Kerala, Shalu Ojha, Nishant Krishna Yadav, and Dinesh Kumar Yadav. Ultimately, the court holds that revision is maintainable but dismisses the petition, clarifying that the impugned orders do not require interference and the interim order stands vacated, with directions to transmit the order to the trial court for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024

M/S PTC Builders v. Mariamma Stephan

This Miscellaneous Second Appeal arises from a Kerala Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) order directing refund of Rs.27,44,000 with simple interest to the complainant for allotment of a residential flat in the PTC Western Ghats project. The complainant alleged the builder delayed construction beyond the time frame stated in Ext.A1 (agreement dated 23/11/2013), withheld payments, and sought refund under Sections 18 and 19 of the Kerala Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act. The Authority ordered refund with interest; the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal affirmed, and the appellants challenged in MSA No. 17 of 2024. The appellants contended that the complainant defaulted in payments per the payment schedule (Ext.A1) and that Section 19(6) Mandates timely payment; they argued cancellation by the allottee was not shown. They also argued delays were due to unforeseen circumstances such as rocky soil and permit issues, with occupancy certificate issued only in 2020. The respondent contended the project was not completed on time and cancellation (Ext.A6) entitles refund under Section 18. The Kerala High Court upheld the refund, held the builder responsible for the delay, and dismissed the appeal, thereby confirming the Authority’s order and Tribunal’s affirmation.

High Court of Kerala
TR.P.(Crl.) No.33 of 2024 & Tr.P.(C) No.167 of 2024

Julie Mariam John v. Manoj Varghese T

Julie Mariam John, the petitioner-wife, moved two transfer petitions before the Kerala High Court seeking transfer of two Family Court proceedings from Aluva to a more convenient forum: MC No.87/2023 (maintenance) and OP No.483/2023 (divorce) pending in Aluva. The divorce petition originated in Ernakulam and was transferred to the Family Court, Aluva, on its constitution. In 2024, after relocating to Pathanamthitta to live with her mother, she sought transfer to Pathanamthitta or a nearby court, arguing inconvenience at Aluva and highlighting a need for convenience for both parties. The respondent opposed automatic transfer and invoked prior authorities including Anindita Das v. Srijit Das, Vidhya Mundekkat v. Akhilesh Jayaram, and Silpa Shaji v. Satheesh K.S. The High Court, however, found that while there is no universal rule mandating transfer for every such request, the facts favored transferring both cases to a mutually convenient forum. Noting the petitioner’s move to Pathanamthitta and her mother’s residence there, the court identified Thiruvalla (within Pathanamthitta District and with better rail connectivity) as a convenient forum for the proceedings. The cited decisions were distinguished on facts. Accordingly, the Court allowed the transfers, directing the Family Court, Thiruvalla, to take up and dispose of the proceedings at the earliest, and to transmit records from Aluva without undue delay.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 33002/2018

Annamma Kurien v. State of Kerala & Others

The Kerala High Court considered a writ petition challenging the denial of arrears of pension for the period 01.06.1995 to 31.10.2005. The petitioner, Annamma Kurien, retired as a High School Assistant in 1995 and had availed leave without allowance from 19.08.1981 to 30.03.1995; during this period she states she resided in South Africa with her husband and did not draw pension. Pension was sanctioned in 1997 but could not be drawn until 2005. In 2006 the Accountant General revalidated the pension from 01.11.2005, but arrears for the 1995–2005 period were refused on the ground that undrawn pension lapses after three years under Rule 135 of Kerala Service Rules Part III, and that arrears require prior sanction when the amount is large. The petitioner submitted Exts P4–P6 and argued that personal inconvenience and health issues (cerebral stroke, bypass surgery) prevented timely drawing and sought authorisation to pay arrears. She invoked Ext.P13 (the 2011 W.P.(C) No.15009/2011) which required reconsideration if additional records were produced. The respondents maintained that no administrative delay occurred and that contemporaneous records from 1995–2005 were lacking; a 2018 District Medical Board report was not treated as contemporaneous evidence. The High Court, relying on Rules 110, 129, 133, 135, and 136 of KSR Part III and cited authorities, upheld the Government’s decision and dismissed the petition, emphasizing that discretion must be properly exercised and not in a mechanical manner.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 29432 of 2021

Puthettu Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Kerala and Others

The petition challenges a stop memo and seeks completion and occupancy certificates for a commercial development known as Puthettu Arcade at Pala, Meenachil taluk. The 1st petitioner is Puthettu Developers Pvt. Ltd., with the 2nd–5th petitioners as relatives. The project lies on land settled by Ext.P3 (1955) and subsequently by Ext.P4 (Will, 1977), which allegedly granted 140.25 cents of land to the petitioners’ family and depicted a road running through the property. The road (extending along the western boundary) is central to a long-standing dispute with alienees (respondents 9–11) who claim rights to use the road, backed by an older civil decree (O.S. Nos. 165/1995 and 71/1998) acknowledging right of way, and by revenue records listing the road as government property. Respondents 6–8 (Pala Municipality) initially issued a building permit but later, following a vigilance inquiry and a stop memo (Ext.P6, P7), questioned the legality of the permit and the alleged reduction of the road width, while a Village Officer report (Ext.R6(i)) suggested the government ownership could be determined only after survey. The petitioners contend the road is private and not a government road, that revenue/RTI records are miscast, and that occupancy should not be delayed on such grounds. The High Court ultimately held the road cannot be treated as a public road, quashed Exts.P14 and P15 to the extent of government ownership, and directed issuance of completion and occupancy certificates if the building otherwise conforms, while preserving the decree rights of the respective parties.

High Court of Kerala
Bail Appl. No. 6046 of 2024

Vivek v. State of Kerala

Vivek, the sole accused in Crime No.677/2024 of Vattiyoorkavu Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, filed Bail Appl. No.6046 of 2024 under BNSS Section 483 seeking bail after 55 days in judicial custody. The prosecution alleges the accused attacked the defacto complainant with a chopper on 05.06.2024 around 13:30 hours, causing a severed left ear and injuries to the index finger, with offences under IPC sections 294(b), 324, 326 and 308. The petitioner contends innocence and claims false implication, stating the incident occurred at his house and that the defacto complainant and his friends assaulted the accused and his son, with Annexure A3 FIR registered against them. The defacto complainant reportedly received pre-arrest bail; the petitioner remains in custody though the investigation is nearly complete and recoveries have been effected. The learned counsel for the petitioner emphasizes lack of criminal antecedents and seeks release on bail. The learned Public Prosecutor counters that the act is serious and there is a danger of witness intimidation; however the court notes the investigation is practically complete and the accused has already remained in custody for 55 days. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., the court upholds the presumption of innocence, but grants bail with stringent conditions due to the gravity of the offences and potential risk to witnesses. The order directs release on bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, subject to conditions (appearance, non-interference with witnesses, no new offences, passport surrender, possible cancellation on violation, and IO supervision).

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 37177/2017 & 38280/2017

WP(C) Nos. 37177/2017 & 38280/2017: M/S. P.T.X SONS CONTRUCTIONS AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT PVT. LTD. v. State of Kerala & Others

The judgment concerns two writ petitions filed by a private contracting company (and its Managing Director) challenging revenue-recovery actions following termination of works awarded by the Harbour Engineering Department. Ext.P6 records termination of the contract after the petitioner failed to execute the agreement following Ext.P1 selection notice. Ext.P7 proposed recovery of Rs.7,27,762, calculated as the shortfall between the retendered amount (Rs.79,14,409) and the petitioner’s quoted amount (Rs.71,86,647). The petitioner contends that the proposed recovery was fixed unilaterally, without hearing, violating the principles of natural justice; reliance is placed on Kaikkara Construction Co. v. State of Kerala (2022 (2) KLT 1182) and earlier Supreme Court rulings (Raman Iron Foundry, Shree Rameshwara Rice Mills) and this Court’s Build Tech India Ltd. dictum. The respondents concede some merit in the hearing aspect but argue that liability is not seriously disputed and that the fresh decision should consider the petitioner’s contentions. The Court holds that the liability cannot be fixed without hearing and directs a two-week reply window to Ext.P7, followed by a fresh decision after hearing; WP38280 is disposed by setting aside revenue-recovery to allow a fresh decision after hearing. Both petitions are disposed accordingly.