Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 568 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 40812 of 2018; 2774 of 2019; 5691 of 2019

W.P.(C) Nos. 40812 of 2018, 2774 of 2019 and 5691 of 2019; Hakkeem K. v. District Educational Officer, Malappuram; Vidya Dharithri M.P. v. State of Kerala & Others

These connected writ petitions challenge appointment and salary issues of High School Assistants in IK.T. Higher Secondary School, Cherukulamba, Malappuram, under the Kerala Education Rules (KER). Hakkeem K. was initially appointed as HSA (English) in a leave vacancy during 2011-2013, received subsequent extensions, and remained in service through various temporary posts. In 2015, a permanent vacancy arose to which Vidya Dharithri M.P. was appointed. Hakkeem contends he is a Rule 51A claimant entitled to precede in the same or a higher/lower category of teaching posts within the same educational agency, based on his leave-vacancy service and termination-of-vacancy relief; he relies on Rule 51A and prior orders recognizing him as a 51A claimant. Vidya Dharithri argues against Hakkeem’s claim, invoking Rule 53 and arguing that Hakkeem’s resignation/extension does not create a valid 51A entitlement; she seeks salary from 01.06.2015 onward. The court examines Rule 51A, its notes, and relevant precedents, notably distinguishing the 2022 Division Bench decision in Sreejith v. Manager, AM Upper Primary School, to hold Hakkeem’s entitlement valid. Ultimately, the court allows WP5691, setting aside Exts. P4 and P7 and directing appointment from 01.06.2015 with consequent benefits; WP40812 is disposed per the earlier order; WP2774 is dismissed. The decision clarifies the scope of Rule 51A for teachers relieved on termination of vacancies within the same educational agency.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)No.32652/2018

N.P. Padmanabhan v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition challenges the delay in granting environmental clearance (EC) for a quarry project on 2.32 hectares in Kayakodi Village, Kozhikode. The petitioner submitted an EC application on 30 May 2018. The file was forwarded to the District Environment Impact Assessment Authority (DEIAA) and then to the District Level Expert Appraisal Committee (DEAC). DEAC recommended EC on 7 September 2018, but no EC was issued within the stipulated period. The petition relies on the deeming theory in the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006, which provides for a deemed grant or denial if the regulatory authority fails to communicate within the prescribed 105-day period. The National Green Tribunal (NGT) had already directed adjustments to the EIA notification and noted concerns about public hearings for small mines. The High Court examines Clause 8 of the EIA Notification (i–vi), the four stages of consideration (screening, scoping, public consultation, appraisal), and relevant case law. It cites East End Dwellings, Noida v Yunus, DEIAA v Manikkampara Granites, Abdul Kharim, and Kerala Coastal cases to frame the doctrine of legal fictions and time-bound procedures. The Court ultimately holds that the petitioner is entitled to a deemed EC, effective on 11 September 2018 (105th day), and directs the SEIAA/8th respondent to issue EC in paper form within three weeks, clarifying this is only about deemed EC and not broader approvals.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 302 OF 2006

Suresh v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C. by the appellant Suresh challenging a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Fast Track Court-III, Thiruvananthapuram, in Sessions Case No. 985/2004. The prosecution case, based on seizure on 22.06.1998 of 4 litres of arrack at Chala Karipattakada, relied on Exts P1–P5 and MO-1, with the contraband allegedly subjected to chemical analysis (Ext. P5). The defence argued that the prosecution failed to prove that the seized contraband sample reaching the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory originated from the scene, as no forwarding note or proper chain of custody was produced, and there was an unexplained delay in presenting the properties before the Court. Citing Ravi v. State of Kerala (2011 (3) KHC 121), the High Court emphasized that while it is not mandatory to produce the seized article forthwith before Magistrates, production before the Court must occur without unnecessary delay and must be explained if delayed, else tampering with samples cannot be ruled out. The prosecution’s inability to establish a proper chemical analysis link and the unexplained delay undermined the conviction. The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction and sentence, acquitted the accused, and directed liberty with costs and disbursement of any deposited amount in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.3184/2020

A. Abdul Rasheed v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioner, A. Abdul Rasheed, is the Managing Trustee of the Badariya Educational Trust and Manager of Badariya U.P. School, Velichikkala, Kollam. He has pursued a long quest to establish a Higher Secondary School, seeking the addition of Lower Primary sections and a higher grade upgrade for the U.P. School. Beginning with an application in 1998 and subsequent directions from this Court (O.P. 22789/2000; 2004 petitions), the Government repeatedly rejected the proposal on the ground that there is no policy for upgrading or sanctioning new aided schools, and that applications can only be made in response to a Government notification under Rule 2A of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules (KER). The petitioner’s case traverses through a series of judgments, reports, and policy statements, including GO guidelines (2007) and a string of writ petitions (2012–2017), culminating in a Division Bench decision (WA 1504/2017) which set aside a single-judge order. The Supreme Court in 2018 dismissed the SLP but allowed liberty to represent under Rule 2 of the KER. The core legal issue remains whether a school can apply for L.P./LPS and upgrade without a notification under Rule 2A. The present judgment emphasizes strict compliance with Rule 2A and the need for a gazetted notification, dismissing the petition but allowing the petitioner to apply once a notification is issued.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.16345 of 2023

Sheelakumari v. Corporation of Kollam & ors

This is a Writ Petition (C) under Article 226 of the Constitution of India filed by Sheelakumari, a tenant in a shop-room in the Kalangara Memorial Devaswom Building, Kollam, seeking a mandamus to renew her license for running a beauty parlour and stitching centre. The matter traces a lease/tenancy history: Ext.P1 (letter) allotting a room following public auction; Ext.P2 (lease deed); disputes over room numbering due to ward delimitation led to Ext.P4 (consent deed) stating room No.210 was allotted; Ext.P5 license dated 19.04.2018 is for a different room (27/210). The petitioner contends renewal should be granted despite COVID-related disruptions and rent arrears, and relies on precedents such as Sudhakaran v. Corporation of Trivandrum to argue that landlord consent is not a prerequisite for renewal of a local authority licence. Respondents 3–5 (Travancore Devaswom Board and associated offices) contend rent arrears of Rs. 7,41,223 and highlight a civil suit (O.S. No.5 of 2022) decreed for eviction and arrears, while the petitioner suppressed that decree and facts about misappropriation of Rs.3 lakhs paid toward rent. The court meticulously scrutinises suppression of material facts, notes that the licence was for a different room, and ultimately holds that the petitioner did not disclose critical facts, did not demonstrate candid conduct, and that the writ petition must be dismissed. The judgment emphasizes candour in writ jurisdiction and disfavors concealment of material facts, invoking principles from Prestige Lights Ltd. and related authorities to deny relief.

High Court of Kerala
RFA Nos. 582 of 2010 and 416 of 2013

Muraleedharan M. v. Jude Thadevus

The judgment consolidates two Regular First Appeals (RFA Nos. 582 of 2010 and 416 of 2013) arising from two suits pending before the Sub Court, Ernakulam, both involving the same property and related sale transactions. RFA 582/2010 challenges a decree in OS 358/2007 awarding the plaintiff return of the advance sale amount instead of specific performance; the plaintiff (Nevil John in the 582/2010 matter) contends that the defendant’s breach warrants either specific performance or a remedy for the advance money with interest. RFA 416/2013, arising from OS 439/2011, is filed by the defendant (Muraleedharan M.) challenging the decree for specific performance obtained by the plaintiff in that suit, which sought to enforce an agreement dated 17.03.2010 (Ext. A1) for sale of the same property. The High Court, after hearing together, holds that the trial court’s discretion under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act was appropriately exercised in OS 358/2007, resulting in a decree for return of the advance amount with interest, and affirms it with a clarification that the amount will be a first charge on the plaint schedule property. In OS 439/2011, the court allows the plaintiff to recover 20,00,000 with interest (12% p.a. up to decree, then 9% p.a.), granting the decree as a second charge on the plaint schedule property. The rulings thus vindicate part of the plaintiff’s claim and partially modify/overrule the trial court’s outcomes, with the combined result that RFA 582/2010 is disposed of in favor of the respondent and RFA 416/2013 is allowed in part for the plaintiff.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 33774 of 2018 & connected cases (including 33778/2018, 33932/2018) and 3529/2019, 5443/2019, 5478/2019, 5510/2019, 8293/2019, 10979/2019, 13419/2019 and 5498/2023

W.P.(C) Nos.33774 of 2018 & connected cases (33778/2018, 33932/2018) and 3529/2019, 5443/2019, 5478/2019, 5510/2019, 8293/2019, 10979/2019, 13419/2019 and 5498/2023

These writ petitions, filed by various road transport undertakings and individuals, challenge the statutory obligation under the Kerala Motor Transport Workers Welfare Fund Act, 1985 to contribute to the Welfare Fund, arguing that their establishments are already covered by the Employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF Act) or the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The petitioners contend that Section 4 of the 1985 Act, and its proviso, should not compel them to remit Welfare Fund contributions where the EPF/Gratuity regimes apply. They also challenge the requirement under Section 4(7) of the Motor Vehicles Taxation Act to produce proof of Welfare Fund remittance before paying tax, asserting that such proof is unnecessary where EPF/Gratuity provisions apply. The court recalls a Division Bench decision in George Antony v. State of Kerala, which held that exemption under the proviso to Section 4 is a matter to be proved in adjudication, not in writ proceedings, and should be resolved by the Welfare Fund Board and competent authorities. The judgment directs swift, dischargeable steps: the Regional Provident Fund Officer to issue EPF remittance certificates on request; the District Executive Officer to verify coverage and issue clearance if eligible; and the RTO to accept tax dues upon production of a clearance certificate, or for the officer to complete adjudication and determine contributions if not exempt. The overall aim is to harmonize EPF coverage with tax and Welfare Fund obligations while expediting remittance and enforcement.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 3989 of 2023

Deepu v. State of Kerala

Deepu, the accused in CC 645 of 2023 registered at the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Varkala, seeks relief under Section 482 CrPC to quash proceedings in the wake of an amicable settlement with the de facto complainant. The case pertains to an alleged theft under Section 379 IPC for stealing a Hercules bicycle valued at Rs. 400 on 28 September 2008. The petitioner contends that the matter has been settled between the parties and there is no desire to pursue prosecution, supported by Annexure-2 affidavit and accompanying materials. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about terminating proceedings solely on a settlement, but conceded there are no prior criminal antecedents against the petitioner. The High Court, after examining the law, relied on Supreme Court guidance beginning with Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, as well as later decisions in Parbatbhai Thakkar and others, State of Rajasthan v. Shambhu Kewat, and others, to set the framework: quashing under Section 482 is permissible for non‑compoundable offences with a civil/private dimension where the entire dispute has been settled, provided serious/public-interest offences are not involved. The court found the offence not to be of a grave, societal nature, the absence of antecedents, and the amicable settlement to be compelling factors. Consequently, it allowed the petition, quashing the Final Report in Crime No. 273/2008 and all further proceedings in CC 645/2023 before the JMFC, Varkala.

High Court of Kerala
RFA 306 of 2010

Santhakumari v. Swaminathan

This Regular First Appeal arises from the dismissal of a suit for partition of the plaint schedule property, held under Ext.A3 Sale Deed No.358 of 1972 in the joint names of the plaintiff, Santhakumari, and the defendant, Swaminathan. The appellant seeks partition and separate possession of her half share. The respondent-defendant contends that although Ext.A3 is in both names, the acquisition was for religious purposes on behalf of the public, with Pangunni and Theethan, father of the defendant and plaintiff respectively, acting as trustees for the Desom Committee to conduct festivals; it is argued that the plaintiff has no exclusive rights to the property. The trial court dismissed the suit after finding that the predecessors were trustees and that the property was used for public religious functions. On appeal, the Kerala High Court found the trial court’s conclusions unsupported by credible evidence. It noted that Ext.A3 is in the individual names of the parties and there is no documentary evidence of public involvement or formation of any trust, nor explicit public funds. Ext.C1’s observations were read as supportive of the defence, yet the court found the defence’s evidentiary basis weak, and that the plaintiff’s burden to prove a trust was not satisfactorily met."

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.57 of 2023

Kakkottakath Puthiya Purayil Moideen and Kakkottakath Puthiya Purayil Abdu v. Punakkkan Ayisha

This is a Rent Control Revision under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging eviction under Section 11(3) of the Act. The petition before the Rent Control Court, Taliparamba (RCP No. 19 of 2014), was filed by the landlady, seeking eviction on bona fide grounds for her husband Mujeeb Rahiman to use the petition schedule shop for a readymade clothing business. The Rent Control Court found the need bona fide, held that the first proviso to Section 11(3) did not apply, and that the second proviso did not protect the tenants. By an order dated 27.07.2019, eviction was directed if possession was not delivered within a month. The tenants challenged this order in RCA No. 134 of 2019 before the Rent Control Appellate Authority, Thalassery, which dismissed the appeal on 31.01.2023. The tenants then filed this revision under Section 20 of the Act before the Kerala High Court. The High Court, after considering pleadings and evidence (PW1 landlady, PW2 husband; RW1 RW2 with expert testimony; Exts. A1–A3, B1–B5(a)), and extensive precedent on bona fide need, confirmed that the need was genuine and that the first and second provisos were not applicable. The revision petition is dismissed, but three months’ time is granted to surrender possession, with conditions including an affidavit, arrears deposit, and continued rent payments. The decision emphasizes that bona fide needs must be genuine, not pretexts, and that revisional interference is limited to legality, regularity, and propriety of the order.”

High Court of Kerala
RFA No.347/2009

L.K. Prabhu @ L. Krishna Prabhu v. K.T. Mathew @ Thampan Thomas and Others

This Regular First Appeal (RFA 347/2009) arises from the dismissal of a claim petition under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC in a suit for attachment before judgment of a property under Order XXXVIII Rule 5 CPC. The dispute centers on Ext.A1, a transfer deed executed about seven months before the attachment, and whether it can be voided under Section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act as a fraudulent transfer intended to defeat creditors. The claimant/purchaser contends the transfer was collusive and constituted a fraudulent conveyance designed to defeat the plaintiff’s rights; the sale consideration is stated as Rs 35 lakhs, with Rs 23.93 lakhs allegedly due from the transferor and a token cheque of Rs 2.5 lakh, while evidence of actual payment or encashment is absent. The trial court did not consider the scope of Rule 58 in adjudicating these questions. The court relies on Verizon Builders and Developers Ltd. v. Jyothi Susan John (2019 (1) KLT 100 (FB)) to hold that it is permissible under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC to examine Section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act in the context of a claim petition or objection to attachment. The judgment proceeds to analyze good faith, the entire consideration, and the consequences of a fraudulent transfer, including the availability of alternate avenues for unsettled creditors. The High Court ultimately allows the appeal in part, sets aside the trial court’s dismissal of the claim petition, disallows the title claim, and remands the matter to determine the amount due, with a two‑month deadline from appearance on 14/03/2023.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.3891OF2023

T.P. Salim v. State of Kerala and Wallmax Paint Pvt. Ltd.

This is a criminal misc petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by T.P. Salim, the 2nd accused in CC 803/2022 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class (NI Act cases), Ernakulam, seeking to quash the proceedings under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1882 (NI Act). The core charge concerns a dishonored cheque dated 20.04.2018 for Rs. 1,08,748 issued by the petitioner in discharge of a liability claimed by Wallmax Paints Pvt. Ltd. The cheque was dishonored on presentation, and a demand notice followed; the complaint under Section 138 NI Act was instituted in 2018, and a non-appearance by the petitioner is noted. The petitioner contends that the cheque was given as security and that there was no consent to present the cheque; a related Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum award directing payment of Rs. 20,000 in a separate dispute alleged deficient goods, but the petitioner argues that the award has no bearing on the NI Act liability. The respondent argues that the NI Act case is properly instituted and that the burden to prove no debt lies with the accused, with a trial to determine the existence of debt; presumption under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act applies. Relying on Rathish Babu Unnikrishnan and Rajeev Kourav, the High Court refuses to quash, upholding the trial’s role to evaluate evidence. The petition is dismissed, but the petitioner is directed to appear before the Magistrate within two weeks to seek recall of any warrant and bail, with coercive actions stayed for two weeks.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 600 OF 2011; CRL.REV.PET NO. 669 OF 2011

Sunil Kumar @ Rakkan v. State of Kerala; Liju Oommen @ Liju v. State of Kerala

This common order arises from two criminal revision petitions filed by Sunil Kumar @ Rakkan and Liju Oommen @ Liju challenging the judgments convicting them under Section 447 IPC for criminal trespass and sentencing to simple imprisonment. The prosecution case claimed that on 16 February 2006 the accused, driven by enmity, trespassed into the house of PW1 and assaulted Santhosh with an iron pipe and a sword-stick, while also beating PW1 and PW2. The Trial Court convicted under Section 447 IPC and sentenced them to three months’ imprisonment with fines; the Sessions Court affirmed the conviction and sentence on appeal. The High Court consolidated and heard both petitions, scrutinising the essential element of criminal trespass under Section 441 read with 447 IPC: entry into property with the specific intent to commit an offence or to intimidate, insult or annoy the possessor. The court evaluated the reliability of witnesses, noting that PW1–PW2 denied the incident, whereas PW3 claimed Santhosh pulled the sword-stick from the accused. Relying on the evolving legal standards on trespass and intent, and distinguishing earlier authorities (Mathri and others; Laxmanan Raghunath; Sellamudhu Servaigaran), the court held the prosecution failed to prove the required mens rea at the time of entry. Consequently, the revision petitions are allowed, and the accused are acquitted, with bail bonds cancelled.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.3983OF2023

Thajudin and Ashok Kumar v. State of Kerala and Adhur Police Station, Kasaragod; Pradeep Kumar (de facto complainant) and others

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC filed by accused Nos. 1 and 2 (Thajudin and Ashok Kumar) challenging Crime No. 121/2023 of Adhur Police Station (Kasargod) for offences under Sections 447 and 427 read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 25 February 2023, around 8 a.m., the accused, in furtherance of their common intention, trespassed on the de facto complainant’s property and committed mischief causing a loss of Rs. 5,000. The petition asserts that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by Annexure A2 (affidavit by the third respondent), and seeks quashing of the criminal proceedings so that they may move forward without the burden of prosecution. The investigating officer was directed to record the victim’s statement and verify the genuineness of the settlement and whether there are any impediments or antecedents. The Public Prosecutor voiced cautious reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged no other recorded offences against the petitioners. The High Court canvassed relevant jurisprudence, notably State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and cases deriving from Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and others, to outline that quashing under Section 482 is permissible where the offence is non‑compoundable but has predominantly civil character and the parties have settled. The court concluded that the gravitas of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the settled posture support quashing in the interests of ends of justice, and therefore allowed the petition. The FIR and proceedings were quashed.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos.1372/2014; 2267/2014; 2298/2014

MACA Nos. 1372/2014, 2267/2014 & 2298/2014

Three Motor Accident Claims Appeals arising from a common award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, were heard together in the Kerala High Court. The underlying accident involved a motorcycle rider and a pillion rider on a motorcycle that collided with a bus. The Tribunal held both the bus driver and the motorcycle rider negligent and apportioned liability equally, with quantum awards of Rs. 2,94,000 in OP(MV) No. 2170/2002 and Rs. 2,29,603 in OP MV No. 859/2013, with 7% interest. The appeals were filed by the insurer of the bus (MACA 2267/2014) and the insurer of the motorcycle (MACA 2298/2014), while the claimant’s MACA 1372/2014 challenged the Tribunal’s finding of joint negligence. The High Court examined whether the rider’s negligence could be sustained, noting reliance on Ext. A2 (police final report) and relevant precedents such as Pazhaniammal and Others, Jiju Kuruvila, and Ramachandrappa. The court ultimately held sole negligence by the bus driver, making the bus insurer liable to pay the entire compensation, while the motorcycle insurer was exonerated. It revised the quantum to Rs. 3,52,003 in OP MV 859/2013, with deposit orders and related costs within three months. The judgment disposes of all three MACAs with directions for deposit and liability.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.3935/23

Vasanthakumari Member v. Kerala State Election Commission and M.V. Ramesh

Vasanthakumari, a ward member of Mangara Grama Panchayat, challenges the Kerala State Election Commission’s order disqualifying her under section 3(1)(c) of the Kerala Local Authorities (Prohibition of Defection) Act, 1999. The Commission, in its impugned 17 January 2023 order in O.P. No.10 of 2021, held that she had defected after contesting the 2020 local elections as an independent candidate and later declaring herself to be supported by CPI(M) within the LDF coalition. The petitioner argued that she was always treated publicly as CPI(M)-aligned, and that the nomination papers and campaign materials identified her as independent; therefore, mere post-election declarations cannot render her a defector. The respondent contended that the post-election declaration constitutes joining a party or coalition, triggering disqualification under 3(1)(c). The EC relied on Ext.A3 (nomination) and Ext.A8 (post-election declaration) and Rule 3 of the Kerala Local Authorities (Disqualification of Defected Members) Rules, 2000, which provides a deeming fiction that a member is part of a party upon declaration. The petition was examined against established jurisprudence, including Sheeba George v. State Election Commission, which the court applies, and distinguishes D. Sudhakar v. Jeevaraju where applicable. The High Court finds no perversity in the EC’s reasons, upholds the order, and dismisses the writ petition, thereby maintaining the defection finding.

High Court of Kerala
CRP(WAKF) NO. 359 OF 2015

Tath-Heerul Muslimeen Mahallu Committee Kootavil v Sangham (Masjid Rahman Juma Ath Palli) - CRP(WAKF) No. 359 of 2015

This Kerala High Court judgment deals with a Wakf dispute concerning the administration of Masjid Rahman Juma Ath Palli and Wakf properties at Kootavil, Malappuram. The revision petitioners (defendants 4–6) challenged the Wakf Tribunal’s decree declaring that the first defendant Sangham, an unregistered body, was the proper administrator of the plaint schedule Wakf and Wakf properties, and restraining the 4th defendant society (registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860) from interfering with Wakf administration. The plaintiffs and other defendants contended that the 4th defendant society usurped Wakf governance through a bylaw restricting membership to a subset of Sunni Muslims tied to other Sunni organizations, with a “superior body” over the general body. The Wakf Tribunal decreed that Sangham is in administration and that the 4th society’s creation is unenforceable, issuing a perpetual injunction. The revision petition argued Section 67 Wakf Act, 1995, governs supervision/supercession of committees and that the suit for injunction should lie under that framework. The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s reasoning, endorsing the Wakf Board’s supervisory framework under Section 67, distinguishing contrary authorities, and ultimately dismissing the CRP. The decision clarifies jurisdictional boundaries between Wakf boards, tribunals, and committees in Wakf governance.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1121 OF 2022; CRL.A NO. 1132 OF 2022

Crl.Appeal Nos. 1121/2022 & 1132/2022, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This common judgment by Justice A. Badharudeen addresses two criminal appeals, Crl.A. Nos. 1121/2022 and 1132/2022, arising from orders dated 20.10.2022 and 18.10.2022 respectively, in Crime No. 159/2022 of Agali Police Station under the SC/ST (POA) Act. Accused Nos. 11, 2 and 5 sought default and regular bail, challenging the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act’s denial of bail. The prosecution alleges a conspiracy to murder Vinayan and his companion, resulting in fatal assaults and ultimately death, with offences under IPC and SC/ST (POA) Act. A central issue is whether filing an online bail application within time, without a physical copy, can be treated as a timely petition for default bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. The Special Court/Impression rejected the bail pleas, relying on an earlier Kerala decision (State v. Muneer) that non-filing of final report/charge sheet within the period could extinguish the right to default bail if the final report is filed before remand. The Kerala High Court, relying on Supreme Court precedents such as Rakesh Kumar Paul and Satender Antil, held that a bail application filed electronically within time (and even an oral request) can be timely, and that personal liberty merits a flexible, non-technical approach. Consequently, the appeals are allowed and bail is granted on specified conditions to the appellants.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 207 of 2019

Jhun Jhun Kumar @ Jun Jun v. State of Kerala

This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court hearing Criminal Appeal No. 207 of 2019 against the judgment in SC No. 778 of 2012 of the Additional Sessions Court-I, Pathanamthitta. The appellant, Jhun Jhun Kumar, a worker from Bihar, was convicted for murder (Section 302 IPC) and for offences related to attempting to commit rape (Sections 511 and 376 IPC). The prosecution case rests on circumstantial evidence: the deceased Sandhya Kumari was found dead at the residence of PW1, her sister’s husband, where the appellant resided for a time; PW1 and others testified that the accused and the deceased were alone at the house around the time of death. Autopsy (PW10) concluded ligature strangulation with several injuries; forensic reports (PW15, PW18, PW14) linked the shawl (MO1) to the scene and found tissue from the accused on nail clippings of the deceased. Despite the lack of direct eyewitnesses, the trial court convicted the accused under 511 IPC and 302 IPC. On appeal, the High Court reaffirms the homicide finding and, applying the doctrine on circumstantial evidence, holds that the circumstances point to the accused with no reasonable alternative explanation, but holds that the conviction under 511 IPC is unsustainable. The result is a partial allowance: 511 IPC set aside; 302 IPC conviction and life sentence upheld. The judgment emphasizes Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act in requiring an explanation from the accused for the circumstances.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 7793 of 2022

M/S Jayalakshmi Silks Pvt Ltd. v. Assistant Controller, Flying Squad, Legal Metrology, Thrissur

This criminal miscellaneous case arises from a private complaint filed by the Assistant Controller, Flying Squad, Legal Metrology, Thrissur, alleging violations of Section 18(1) read with Section 36(1) of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009 and Rules 4, 18(1) of the Legal Metrology (Packed Commodities) Rules, 2011. The petitioners, five individuals and the private limited company M/S Jayalakshmi Silks Pvt Ltd, are accused in CC 185/2019 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur. The complainant alleged that during inspection of the petitioner's trade premises, certain pre-packaged commodities bore no month/year of manufacture, MRP, or customer care contact details, in violation of the packaging declarations required by law. The petitioners contend that they neither manufactured nor packed the products nor sold them; the only issue was that the product did not carry the mandated declarations, and that responsibility for declarations lay with the manufacturer under Rule 4, with liability for non-conformity to be assessed under Section 36 only when sale or transfer of non-conforming goods occurs. Relying on Leo Crasta v. State of Karnataka (2019), the counsel argued that a retailer cannot be prosecuted for offences framed as Section 18/36 absent evidence of sale or non-declaration in sales. After hearing, the Court held that the allegations do not establish sale of non-standard packaged commodities by the petitioners, and that Section 36 penalties do not apply; therefore, quashed the complaint and all further proceedings against petitioners.