CRL.APPEAL NO. 886 OF 2021; CRL.APPEAL NO. 504 OF 2022; CRL.APPEAL NO. 746 OF 2023 These three appeals arise from S.C.No.951 of 2014, challenging the murder and related offences alleged to have occurred on the night of 28.03.2014 at the house of Sri Jayesh in Kainakary, Alappuzha. The trial court convicted accused Nos.1–4, 9 and 10 for various offences, while accused Nos.5–8 were acquitted. The High Court, in a consolidated judgment dated 27.09.2023, examines whether the common object of an unlawful assembly and the individual acts of the accused led to Jayesh’s death and the disappearance of evidence under IPC. The occurrence witnesses—PW14 (father), PW16 (wife) and PW17 (mother)—testified that accused Nos.1–4 formed an unlawful assembly, attacked Jayesh with swords and an iron bar near his house, chased him into a nearby paddy field, and caused fatal injuries. The court scrutinizes contradictions, the scene mahazar (Ext.P10), the identification of accused Nos.2–4, and the recovery of weapons and dresses (MOs 5–7, 8–12), plus blood-stain confirmation by FSL. Relying on settled doctrines about eyewitness credibility of close relatives and the procedure under Section 145 of the Evidence Act, the court allows the appeal of accused Nos.9–10 (acquittal) and dismisses the appeals of accused Nos.2–4 (convictions sustained). The final disposition leaves 2–4 convicted and 9–10 acquitted, with the State’s appeal largely upheld.
Manoj Kumar Upadhyay, a CISF Constable posted at the Cochin International Airport Unit from 2009 to 2017, filed WP(C) 28630/2017 in the Kerala High Court seeking House Rent Allowance (HRA) and Transport Allowance with arrears and a writ of certiorari quashing Ext. P3. He contends that there was no family accommodation available at the unit, and therefore, under Rule 61(2) CISF Rules, 2001, he was entitled to HRA in lieu of rent-free accommodation. He asserts he stayed in CISF barracks for the entire period and was denied HRA and TA. The respondents contend that HRA/TA require submission of outliving permission, that no government family accommodation was provided at Cochin, and that the petitioner did not apply for outliving permission; they cite Ext. P4 (Delhi High Court) and Ext. P5 (Calcutta High Court) directing implementation of HRA in similar situations and note that a portion of family accommodation allowance was paid in lieu of rent-free accommodation. The court ultimately held that HRA is a component of pay and, since no family accommodation existed, the petitioner was entitled to HRA at applicable rates for 2009–2017, directing payment within three months.
Crime No. 942/2023; S.C. No. 1095/2023 Rasal Paul, the petitioner in Crl.M.C. No. 7773 of 2023, challenges the continuation of proceedings arising from Crime No. 942/2023 of Thrissur East Police Station, now SC No. 1095/2023 before the Fast Track Special Court-II, Thrissur, for alleged offences under Section 376(2)(n) IPC. The High Court addresses whether private settlement between the accused and the victim can justify quashing a rape case under the inherent powers of Cr.P.C. Section 482. The petitioner contends the FIR and final report reveal a consensual relationship between two educated adults, founded on promises of marriage, which could not be fulfilled; the victim was in a subsisting marriage at the relevant time, a fact also known to the petitioner. He relies on decisions including Shambhu Kharwar, XXX v. State of Kerala, Ranjith v. State of Kerala, Gian Singh, and Laxmi Narayan, arguing that once consent is shown to be voluntary and not framed by a false promise of marriage, quashing should be permissible on merits if material does not establish the offence. Annexure-3 affidavit purportedly shows the victim does not wish to prosecute. The respondents contend that rape cannot be nullified by settlement. After considering the materials and the cited authorities, the court holds that the circumstances, including subsisting marriages and a consensual relationship, do not establish rape; the petition is allowed and all further proceedings in SC No.1095/2023 against the petitioner are quashed.
This bail application relates to accused no.2 in SC No. 378/2022 pending before the Addl. District and Sessions Court, Ernakulam, concerning Crime No. 36/2022 of the Excise Range Office, Ernakulam. The petitioner, Sreemon, asserts that although the total contraband seized amounts to 83.896 g, only 12.218 g of MDMA were recovered from him, and argues that the contraband is methamphetamine hydrochloride, which is not listed in the NDPS Act’s Schedule and therefore is neither a narcotic nor a psychotropic substance. He contends that the MTM (methamphetamine hydrochloride) salt form is not covered; there is also a claim that annexure A3 and the chemical analysis do not establish narcotic/psychotropic status for the seized material, and that he was not in possession at the time of seizure since he had been incarcerated for over a year. The state counters that 83.896 g of MDMA was seized and 12.218 g recovered from him, with evidence of drug smuggling across routes to Kerala, including use of dogs and misrepresentation with a uniform photo to mislead authorities. It is argued that methamphetamine hydrochloride is a central stimulant and falls within NDPS via Note 1 of the Schedule. The court cites Sadiq Basha v. State to discuss bail standards and ultimately dismisses the bail petition, citing commercial quantity and serious antecedents, while noting that reasons are prima facie and not dispositive on merits.
This writ petition challenges the February 27, 2020 Ext.P3 election notification issued by the Returning Officer for the Kerala State Council for Child Welfare and the subsequent March 28, 2020 election results (Ext.P10). The petitioner, a life member of the Council, contends that the election was notified and conducted in a secretive and illegal manner to advance loyalists of the ruling dispensation, with the procedure under Clause 47 of the Ext.P2 bye-laws flagrantly ignored. The core grievance is non-compliance with Clause 47(2), which requires that the Returning Officer inform all members at least 21 days prior to the election, publish a draft voters list 30 days before the election, and notify the date and procedure for nominations. The petitioner points to the post-dated notices, late posting of election information, and the absence of district-wide publication of the draft voters list, depriving life members of an opportunity to file objections or nominations. The Government Pleader counters by arguing maintainability concerns, noting the Council’s public-function status and its regulation under a Society Act, and contends the remedy lies in a civil suit; he relies on decisions distinguishing notice from intimation and on the general principle that writs should not disturb internal elections absent extraordinary circumstances. The court ultimately finds mandatory constitutional and statutory requirements unmet, declares the Ext.P3 election illegal, sets aside Ext.P10, and directs re-election within three months with interim administration by the Government.
This is an anticipatory bail petition filed by accused Nos. 2 to 4 in Crime No.393/2022 of Edacherry Police Station, Kozhikode. The prosecution contends that on 28.12.2022 around 22:00 hours, the accused formed into an unlawful assembly armed with deadly weapons to assault the defacto complainant, resulting in serious injuries including a fracture. The First Information Statement (FIS) and medical records indicate the following roles: the 1st accused beat the complainant on the right wrist with a wooden rafter; the 2nd accused assaulted the complainant on the nose and chin using a stone; the 3rd accused’s alleged role is not detailed in the FIS; the 4th accused kicked the complainant and others. The defacto complainant initially stated the injuries occurred from a fall during the Thira festival but later admitted an attack by the petitioners. Wound certificates show multiple injuries, including an incised wound on the tongue and a chin laceration, with a right wrist fracture. The court notes inconsistencies in the complainant’s versions and observes that the dispute appears festival-related. It also finds the investigation can proceed without custodial interrogation. Thus, the court grants anticipatory bail to accused Nos.2 and 4 with conditions: surrender within ten days, cooperation, no witness intimidation, and production on arrest with bond; the 2nd accused is to facilitate recovery of the stone.”
This writ appeal challenges a learned Single Judge’s order dated 15.01.2021 in W.P.(C) No.6700/2020, directing the State Government to nominate a representative to a Selection Committee to fill two Assistant Professor posts in the Department of Business Administration of Rajagiri College of Social Sciences, Kalamassery. The appellants—The State of Kerala and its officials—contend that for an arts and science college affiliated to a university (Mahatma Gandhi University) the regulatory framework is governed by UGC norms for workload and staff in private colleges under the Direct Payment Scheme, and not by AICTE norms, which are applicable primarily to technical institutions. They argue that GO(Ms) No.155/2020/H.Edn (01.04.2020) revised workload to 75 hours weekly and that four teaching posts would suffice (one for every 16 hours since the college’s actual workload falls short of eight posts previously claimed). The private college’s request to fill two posts should be considered within Direct Payment and AICTE/UGC considerations. The respondents/counter-parties emphasize AICTE norms tied to AICTE‑approved programs and that, for affiliated institutions, the university regulates technical education with AICTE advisory input; the Syndicate decision of 1996 to adopt AICTE norms was not contested. The court ultimately allowed the appeal: the impugned judgment was set aside and the writ petition dismissed, clarifying the regulatory balance between AICTE norms, UGC norms, and the university’s role in affiliated technical education.
CRL.M.C Nos. 7257/14 & 7381/2014 These connected Criminal Miscellaneous Cases challenge the order issuing process in CC 2359/2010 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Ernakulam. The petitioners—two groups of accused in a consigned agent/agency agreement—contend that the complaint under sections 406 and 420 read with section 34 IPC does not disclose a prima facie case. Annexure-3, the Consignee Agent Agreement dated 01.05.2007, provides an arbitration clause (clause 13) and a jurisdiction clause (clause 16) specifying New Delhi courts and arbitration, with clause 17 limiting validity to the financial year 2007-2008. The petitioners argue that the contract terms predominate, and any alleged misrepresentations or false statements do not automatically amount to cheating or a criminal offence; the complaint and summons were issued in a routine manner, contrary to established principles. The High Court, relying on Mehmood Ul Rehman, GHCL Employees Stock Option Trust, Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma, Vijay Dhanuka, and Deepak Gaba jurisprudence, held that there must be prima facie material and that summoning should not be a mere formality. It held that summoning outside jurisdiction requires Section 202 Cr.P.C inquiry. Ultimately, the court allowed the petitions and quashed cognizance and proceedings against the petitioners in CC 2359/2010.
The petitioner, Muhammad Sabir, proprietor of M/s Shah Traders and Minerals, filed this writ petition challenging Exhibit P5 dated 27.12.2022 issued by KSIDC and the minutes of the first respondent’s meeting denying the claim for a return of Rs. 5,00,000 deposited as security for allotment of a depot license for distributing sand and minerals. The deposited amount was paid in two installments (11.03.2015 and 09.06.2015) for a depot license in Thaliparamba and Kasaragod Taluk, but the license was never granted; no communication cancelling the allotment was issued. The petitioner had earlier approached this Court in W.P. No. 16329/2022, which directed the respondents to consider the request (Exhibit P4). The Managing Director, KSIDC, rejected the refund, citing time bar. The petitioner contends that since no depot license was declined or cancelled, the respondents cannot withhold repayment on the ground of limitation, and the obligation to refund is continuing. The court notes a line of Supreme Court and Kerala decisions emphasizing that the State and its Corporations cannot defeat just claims by technical limitation arguments and that there is a continuing obligation to repay amounts due to citizens. The petition is allowed; Exhibit P5 is quashed, and KSIDC is directed to refund Rs.5,00,000 with 6% interest from the expiry of one year after deposit, within six weeks.
Ratheesh, the sole accused in SC No. 172/2013 on the file of the Additional Sessions Court-II, Palakkad, challenges his conviction for offences under Sections 449, 392, 397 and 302 IPC. The trial court found that Madhavi, a neighbor of the accused, was murdered in her drawing room on 23 August 2011 while she was alone at home, and that gold ornaments were stolen. The prosecution's case rests on circumstantial evidence: witnesses testifying to the accused’s proximity to the victim’s house and his presence near the scene around the time of death; the recovery and identification of MO1 (ring) and MO2 (chain) and MO3 (bangles) from the accused and MO4 (the iron box cord) from a crime scene/collection; MO7–MO9 and cash recovered from a location based on the accused’s information; PW20’s post-mortem noting ligature strangulation; DNA evidence from nail clippings linking the accused to the victim; statements and conduct of the accused; and the absence of any plausible alternative explanation. The High Court, in a two-judge bench, reaffirms the trial court’s conviction, holding that the circumstantial evidence forms a complete chain, and that Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act justifies the inference of murder in the same transaction with robbery in light of Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi). The appeal is dismissed; the conviction and sentences stand.
W.P.(C).Nos.9934 & 14560/22 These two writ petitions challenge the National Health Mission’s recruitment of Mid Level Service Providers (MLSPs) on contract terms across multiple districts in Kerala. Petitioners, included in district-ranked lists published in 2020-21 for Thrissur, Idukki and other districts, seek directions to appoint from the existing lists against vacancies and to prevent fresh selections, alleging that the ranked lists were valid for two years or until all candidates were advised. The respondents contend NHM Kerala operates as a project under the State Health and Family Welfare Society, with posts filled on deputation or contract without a statutory cadre, and that there is no guaranteed continuity of service or statutory rule binding appointments from such lists. They further argue that more than the advertised vacancies have already been advised, necessitating a fresh recruitment, and that the lists themselves carried no binding right to appointment beyond contractual postings. The court, after considering counter-affidavits and earlier orders, relied on precedents: Balu S.S. v. State of Kerala and Vinod Kumar M.K., noting that participation in a selection and inclusion in a ranked list does not guarantee appointment, and that a ranked list ceases to be operative once vacancies are filled or when rules do not provide for continued validity. Ultimately, the petitions were dismissed. The judge observed that eligible petitioners may apply to future notifications.
WA Nos. 303 & 395 of 2023 The two writ appeals challenge a common Kerala High Court judgment concerning compassionate appointment in an aided school under Rule 51B of Chapter XIVA KER. Amarnath G.K., whose father was a teacher at AMUP School, Kayakkodi, claimed employment assistance after his death in harness on 07.04.2015. He filed Ext. P1 on 15.06.2016, Ext. P3 on 23.08.2017, and Ext. P4(b) on 03.04.2019, seeking compassionate appointment. The Manager rejected Ext. P4(b) on 08.06.2019 on the ground that it was beyond the two-year deadline prescribed by Government orders. The petitioner then approached the Educational Officer, who directed appointment, a decision contested in Ext. P7 and Challenged in Ext. P14, with Ext. P14 ultimately explaining the two-year time limit under G.O. No. 12/99/P&ARD (24.05.1999) and the mutatis mutandis application of Government orders per Rule 51B. Concurrent developments involved the appointment of Roshni P.T. in 2021 and a Government order Ext. P15 directing approval for Roshni P.T. subject to the outcome of W.P. No. 11793 of 2020. The Government/Revision orders were contested in W.P. Nos. 11793/2020 and 22031/2022. The learned Division Bench held that while the scheme is beneficial and requires liberal interpretation, the two-year time limit cannot be ignored. On this basis, the writ appeals were dismissed. The Court upheld Ext. P14 and the Government orders, dismissing the petitions.
Prabha Industries Proprietrix v Cochin Port Trust & Ors arises as WA No. 368 of 2007 challenging the demurrage levy on a consignment of defective pre-painted sheet cuttings imported from Sweden. The petitioner, an importer of metals and scrap, faced detention of the consignment by Cochin Port Trust from 11.11.2003 to 29.04.2004 for duty verification. A detention certificate (No.2/2004, 03.05.2004) later surfaced with no explicit grounds for detention; customs officials conveyed no objection to clearance subject to formalities, while Ext.P8 (12.05.2004) computed demurrage at about Rs. 9 lakhs, asserting the port was not responsible for delivery delays. The writ petition attacked Ext.P8, P10, and P12, arguing that the period of detention fell within the free period for import cargo and that delays caused by customs actions could not attract demurrage. The matter matured through a sequence of interim orders and Supreme Court directions, culminating in a decision that the demurrage demand was illegal and unsustainable, and that the petition should be allowed. The court remitted to consider lawfulness and released the goods after a fixed deposit, following Supreme Court directions. The writ appeal was thus allowed, with no costs and directions for release of the fixed deposit in the petitioner’s favor.
Satheesh Babu, the sole accused, was convicted by the Sessions Court for multiple offences including murder (302 IPC), theft (380, 392), house trespass by night (449) and rape (376A, 376) in a case arising from the murder of a septuagenarian nun in a convent at Palai in 2015. The trial court recorded that the prosecution examined 65 witnesses and proved 88 documents, leading to a conviction and life sentence for murder with related punishments for theft and trespass, while convicting for rape under IPC as well. The High Court of Kerala heard Crl.A. No.811 of 2019 on 22.11.2023 and delivered its judgment on 11.12.2023. The judgment meticulously re-evaluates circumstantial evidence, including the time, place and manner of the crime; the accused’s presence in the vicinity; eyewitness-like circumstantial threads such as 13 chance fingerprints matching the accused, mischief of MO1, and the MO3 axe; the seizure and discovery process; and forensic science inputs such as vaginal semen, DNA profiling, and Y-chromosomal DNA matching. The court notes defence contentions about potential manipulation of fingerprints, the non-identification of a weapon, and possible suppression of certain findings (notably the spade) but still concludes a strong chain of circumstantial evidence linking the accused to the crime, with the DNA evidence corroborating the prosecution’s case. Importantly, the court holds that the rape conviction is unsustainable due to lack of evidence establishing the time of death, but upholds the conviction under Sections 302, 449 and 457 IPC and its sentences, while setting aside the rape conviction.
This Kerala High Court Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA 897 of 2012) is filed by Latha, the injured claimant in OP(MV) 313/2010, challenging an award of Rs 32,500 by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam, for injuries sustained in a road collision on 27 August 2009 involving a lorry KL-11B 0216. The Tribunal held the driver negligent and the owner and insurer liable; however the award was found inadequate. The appellant contends that the notional income used by tribunals should reflect her earning capacity; she asserts that, following Ramchandrappa, notional income for a homemaker in 2009 could be Rs 7,000 per month, and argues for calculation of loss of earnings over two months since the injuries left her unable to work for a prolonged period. She also seeks substantial compensation for future dental treatment (Ext. A9 shows Rs 45,000) and increased sums for pain and suffering and loss of amenities due to facial injuries and missing teeth. The insurer defends the policy terms and raises the issue of the driver’s licence being invalid; it seeks recovery against the owner and driver and argues against substantial enhancements. The High Court, applying Ramchandrappa’s principle, fixes a notional income of Rs 3,000 per month (the appellant’s claim), awards two months of loss of earnings, and increases damages under future treatment, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities. It ultimately enhances total compensation by Rs 46,500 and directs deposit by the insurer with a recovery clause to follow.
This writ petition filed by Dr. Sasi Eloor, a senior citizen and owner in possession of property at Survey No 137/19, seeks police protection to complete construction of a go-down in accordance with Exhibit P3 building permit. After unloading materials on 16.11.2021, intruders allied with respondents 2 and 3 allegedly obstructed unloading and threatened to withhold access unless demanded payment. The petitioner approached the 1st respondent for protection but claims no action was taken. The respondents contend that the area is a scheme covered region and the construction site is an establishment where loading and unloading is an integral function requiring registered headload workers. They argue the petitioner has no registered workers and must engage the Board's pool workers for such activity and pay wages in accordance with the Scheme and Rules. The petitioner contends that the activity is purely construction and loading/unloading is casual, not constituting an establishment, and relies on Theresa Jose and other judgments to resist mandatory registration. The court, after considering the Act, Rules and Scheme and the cited judgments, holds that the loading/unloading dispute in a scheme area is a matter for Section 21 dispute resolution. The Assistant Labour Officer is suo motu added as Addl.R5 to inspect and settle the dispute under Section 21. If it is only construction, the petitioner may continue; if it is an establishment, he must engage registered headload workers. In the interim, there shall be no obstruction and the parties shall follow the authorities' decisions within three weeks.
W.P.(C) No.3525 of 2022; D.B.P.No.32 of 2022; W.P.(C) No.6259 of 2022 This is a combined Kerala High Court judgment involving petitions filed in relation to Valliyamkavu Devi Temple at Idukki. The primary petitioner, Soman P.K., along with others, alleged trespass on temple property, obstruction of a 12-km road providing access to the temple, non-constitution of a Temple Advisory Committee, and unauthorised stalls selling pooja items near the temple. They sought mandamus to direct the State and several authorities to implement court orders Exts. P4–P7, to open the access routes, and to ensure proper temple governance, including opening Devaswom pooja stalls on temple land. A separate writ petition, WP(C) No.6259/2022, by Radha Gangadhar Kannatt, challenged notices calling her stall unauthorised, claiming long-standing livelihood support and family property interests. The Court examined prior orders and reports, including directives from Suneesh K.S. v. Travancore Devaswom Board ILR 2022 Ker 1091, and noted law-and-order concerns arising from trader activity near the temple. The judgment disposed of WP3525/2022 and DBP No. 32/2022 with directions: police and excise authorities to curb obstructions and unauthorised sales; the Administrative Officer to inform the Panchayat and police for action; the matter of constituting a Temple Advisory Committee kept open. WP6259/2022 was dismissed, directing Panchayat proceedings under law.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4102 OF 2023 This anticipatory bail petition under Section 438 CrPC concerns Thahir P.K., accused in Crime No. 221/2023 of Payyoli Police Station, Kozhikode, presently before the Kerala High Court in Bail Application No. 4102 of 2023, arising from an order/judgment in MC 758/2023 of the District Court & Sessions Court, Kozhikode. The prosecution alleges that on the night of 27.04.2023, accused Nos. 1 to 4 trespassed into the residence of the defacto complainant and that the first accused, who is the brother of the wife of the defacto complainant, assaulted the complainant with an iron rod with an intent to commit culpable homicide, resulting in injuries. The offences include IPC sections 323 (hurt), 324 (voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapon), 452 (house-trespass), and 427 (mischief), read with 34 of the IPC, and the later incorporation of Section 308 IPC (attempt to cause culpable homicide). The petitioner’s counsel submits that there is a family dispute linked to business dealings, injuries were minor, and the petitioner is willing to cooperate with investigation and the recovery of the weapon. Opposing bail, the defacto complainant contends this is the second trespass and assault, with a prior related incident (crime No. 34/2023) indicating propensity to violence; granting anticipatory bail could impede investigation and jeopardize the complainant. The High Court, after hearing, notes prima facie repeated assaults and the need to address safety and investigation, and accordingly grants anticipatory bail with conditions including surrender within ten days, two days of interrogation, conditional access for interrogation, recovery of the weapon, bond for Rs. 30,000 with two sureties, and strict restrictions on entering the complainant’s house and on harming witnesses. The order emphasizes that violation of conditions could cancel the bail.
CON.CASE(C) NO.334 OF 2021 This Contempt Case (Civil) No. 334 of 2021 in the Kerala High Court arises from alleged willful disobedience of directions contained in Annexure A1 of the judgment dated 12 October 2018 in WP(C) No. 34792 of 2016 and connected matters. The petitioners, being petitioners 3, 7, and 8 (among others) in the linked writ petition, challenged the implementation of pension-related provisions under the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) scheme post-2014 amendments. The Supreme Court later delivered judgments, first in 2022 in Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO (AIR 2022 SC 5634) and Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-44 of 2022, which held that the Notification No. G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22 August 2014 is legal and valid, and directed read-downs and extensions of time for certain options under the pension scheme. The Kerala High Court, citing these authorities, held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment. The contempt petition was closed, with a direction that EPFO reconsider the petitioners’ entitlement within the framework of the Supreme Court’s decision, preserving the petitioners’ rights while acknowledging the need for lawful recalibration of benefits. The order reflects a balance between finality of earlier directions and subsequent Supreme Court guidance.
This is a writ petition filed by auto-taxi drivers of Palakkod in Ramant hli Gram Panchayat seeking police protection from harassment and violence allegedly by the fifth respondent and his associates when parking their autorickshaws/taxis at Palakkod road side. The petitioners, who hold All Kerala Permits, claim that attacks and ransacking of their vehicles by the fifth respondent have impeded their right to park and operate their vehicles, thereby jeopardizing their livelihood and ability to repay bank loans. They invoke Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, contending the Government authorities have failed to provide adequate protection and regulate parking spaces. Respondents 2–4 argue that the Panchayat was directed to explore alternate parking sites, but no viable site has been identified; the Government Pleader cites Section 72 of the Kerala Police Act, 2011, underscoring the Panchayat’s duty to consider public-interest parking decisions. The court cites Gopalan v. Vellangallur Grama Panchayat (2021) and Jestin Thomas v. Circle Inspector of Police (2019) to uphold the principle that Traffic Regulatory Committees and local authorities must earmark and regulate parking stands in consultation with stakeholders. The judgment disposes the petition by directing the 1st respondent to examine parking for auto-taxis in accordance with law and take a final decision within two months, with notice to the fifth respondent dispensed with.