This Motor Accident Claims Appeal arises from a Tribunal award under OP(MV) No.18/2018, Kozhikode, in which the Principal Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal determined compensation for injuries sustained by the claimant, Biju Sunil M., in a motor vehicle accident. The appellant challenges the quantum on grounds that the Tribunal ignored substantial documentation (Exts. A2, A7) and misapplied the evidence regarding disability. The evidence included a bimalleolar fracture of the left ankle with two surgeries and an implant removal, accompanied by a certificate (Ext. A13) indicating 15% partial disability, though the Tribunal computed disability at 10%. The Tribunal fixed monthly income at Rs 10,000 and awarded compensation under several heads, including pain and suffering, loss of amenities, transportation, bystander expenses, and extra nourishment. The appellant argues for a higher disability percentage and a higher monthly income, citing Ext. A11 showing Rs 30,000, and seeks re-calculation of loss of earnings. The respondent insurer contends the Tribunal’s verdict is adequate, noting the 15% disability certificate came from a doctor not examined and that disability may change after implant removal; they urge adherence to the original award and reliance on Ramachandrappa for income assessment. The Kerala High Court partly allows the appeal, recalculating compensation: monthly income fixed at Rs 11,000, loss of earnings for about 5 months, enhanced amounts for pain, loss of amenities, bystander expenses, transport, and nourishment, and an additional Rs 16,800 as loss of earning power. The total additional compensation amounts to Rs 1,05,800 with 7.5% interest, payable by the insurer within two months, with 404 days’ delay excluded. MACA stands allowed.
This writ petition by Sathianarayanan T.V., a Sr. Very High Frequency (VHF) Operator in the Cochin Port Trust, challenges a denial of up-gradation of his post despite Afzulpurkar Committee recommendations that included up-gradation for Senior VHF Operator and related posts. The petitioner joined the Port Trust in 1994, was promoted to Senior VHF Operator in 2006, and claims stagnation since then while peers have been promoted or up-graded. The Afzulpurkar Committee’s report, which recommended upgrading several posts including VHF-related posts, was forwarded to the Port Trust and the Ministry (Exts. P4–P6). However, Ext. P8—an internal communication from the Under Secretary to the Chairperson of the Cochin Port Trust—denies the upgrade for the VHF Operator without reasons. The petitioner sought quashing Ext. P8 and mandamus to implement the committee’s recommendations (and a speaking order on Ext. P9) within a timeframe. The respondents contend that Ext. P8 reflects an administrative decision; the committee’s two Senior VHF Operator posts are not separately approved and the recommendations mostly pertain to pay-scale and entitlements, not universal upgrades. The Court ultimately disposes of the petition by directing the 2nd respondent to forward the petitioner’s Ext. P7 to the 1st respondent for proper consideration, with a reasoned order within two months, in consultation with the 2nd respondent.
Cont.Case (C) No.270 of 2019 This Contempt of Court case is filed by petitioners 1, 15 and 18 in W.P.(C) No.33185 of 2014 against the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and a respondent, challenging alleged willful disobedience of Annexure A1 judgment dated 16 December 2014. The 2014 judgment in WP(C) No.33185/2014 directed that 8.33% of the employer’s contribution, proportionate to the employee’s salary in excess of Rs. 6,500, be credited to the Pension Scheme, and that interest accrued in the Provident Fund to that extent would be transferred to the Pension Account. It also mandated extant employees to submit joint applications with their employer for implementation. The matter ties to a line of decisions in other writ petitions and a Division Bench’s confirmation in W.A.No.1442/2004, with the Apex Court’s involvement via SLP No.7074/2014 (Annexure A2). On 4 November 2022, the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal Nos.8143–8144 of 2022 held the 2014 notification (G.S.R.609(E)) legal and valid, directing read-downs and read-across to exempted establishments, including options under the pension scheme. In view of that decision, the Kerala High Court notes that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO. The court closes the Contempt Case, but preserves EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement in light of the Apex Court’s 2022 judgment.
This Original Petition (OP) before the Kerala High Court concerns a daily-wage Electrician employed in the Biotech, and Model Floriculture Centre (BMFC) at Kazhakoottam who, after more than ten years of service, was terminated by Annexure-A7 while regularization and appointment under a regular cadre were in contemplation. He challenged the OA 947/2020 before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, which on 06.01.2023 dismissed the challenge, holding that a daily-wage worker cannot claim regularisation as a matter of right. The petitioner relied on earlier regularisation patterns (Annexure-A2, 2015) and a Government Order (Annexure-A5, 26.02.2016) permitting regularisation for those who had worked ten years or more, subject to verification of performance and conduct. The State argued that regularisation under Umadevi’s principles is a one-time measure with a cutoff date, limited to those who were appointed on or before that date, and that A6 (2019) directed temporary engagement through Employment Exchange cannot convert the status to regularity. The High Court, noting that the PSC conducts regular recruitment and that the 179-day break was treated as service continuity, upheld the Tribunal’s view. It affirmed that daily-wage or temporary employees cannot acquire regularisation as a right, though it acknowledged hardship and left open other lawful avenues. The petition is ultimately dismissed.
WP(C) Nos. 13741 of 2019 & 22129 of 2019 Two writ petitions (W.P.(C).Nos.13741/2019 and 22129/2019) filed in the Kerala High Court challenge Ext.P6, a Government order permitting the construction/opening of a concrete vault cemetery on the premises of the 9th respondent church near Thanneermukkom, Alappuzha. The petitioner in 13741/2019, Dileep, a resident of Ward XIV in Thanneermukkom Grama Panchayath, asserts that the proposed cemetery would adversely affect the religious customs of nearby sites, including the 10th respondent temple, and argues that the decision was cryptic, non-speaking, and not properly reasoned, with procedural lapses under the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Burial and Burning Grounds) Rules, 1998 (Rules 5, 6, 7, 8, 9). The petitioners in 22129/2019 include the Annaporneswari Temple Trust and Sunil Kumar V, challenging the same Ext.P6 on grounds of improper hearing, insufficient consideration of police reports indicating potential disharmony, and non-compliance with the notice and publication requirements. The respondents contend that the application was processed strictly in accordance with the Rules, that distances from dwelling houses (minimum 25 metres for concrete vaults) were satisfied, that objections were heard, and that public order concerns cannot alone deny a license. The High Court, applying decisions such as WA 1169/2014 and Pentecost Mission, held that the Rules were complied with, the alleged public-order concerns did not override the statutory framework, and dismissed both petitions. The judgment was delivered by a Single Judge, Justice Viju Abraham, on 21 March 2023.
W.P.(C) No. 17115 of 2022 This writ petition challenges Exhibit P11, a Sub Treasury Officer’s order denying payment of salary arrears of Rs.11,14,191 to the petitioner, HSST in Political Science at Vadakkumpad Higher Secondary School, despite an approval of appointment with retrospective effect from 30.08.2013 and a subsequent order (Exhibit P9) directing disbursement. The Court had earlier, by Ext.P7 (9.03.2021), directed the Regional Deputy Director Kozhikode to consider approval from 30.08.2013 and to disburse all consequential benefits, including salary, and Exhibit P8 (04.08.2021) granted such approval. Respondents argued that Circular No.7/2021/Fin (27.01.2021) requires arrears to be deposited in the Provident Fund (PF), a policy justification for deferment, and relied on G.O.(P.) Nos.29/2016 and related rules to justify the position. The petitioner contends that (a) the Government cannot override statutory provisions using circulars; (b) salary is a “property” under Article 300A and cannot be withheld without law; (c) Circular P12 cannot apply to him since his approval was not under GO 29/2016. The Court agrees with the petitioner, holding that Ext.P11 is illegal, Ext.P12 circular cannot trump statutory rights, and directs immediate disbursement of arrears, quashing Ext.P11, with further directions to pay Rs.11,14,191 within eight weeks and without interest since the petitioner did not seek it.
M.F.A.(Forest).No.158 of 2019 The appeal challenges the Forest Tribunal, Kozhikode, OA No.33/2013, and relates to MFA (Forest) No.158 of 2019. The Tribunal had held that the scheduled property—7.50 acres in Sy. No.83/1, Ongallur-II, Ottappalam—was not a “forest” and therefore not a “private forest” under Section 2(f)(1)(i) of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act (Vesting Act). The State of Kerala and the Custodian of Vested Forests (appellants) contended that the land forms part of “Chovallurmanakkad Malavaram,” a notified private forest under the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act (MPPF Act), which would have vested in the State as of 10.5.1971, and sought exclusion under 2(f)(1)(i) and exemptions under Sections 3(2) and 3(3) of the Vesting Act. Hamza, the cultivating tenant holding an Ext.A1 certificate of purchase under the Land Reforms Act, sought relief as an exempted holder. The Tribunal relied on a decision in K.M. Abdu (Abdu) to conclude not a private forest, but the High Court held that Abdu applied to a different clause (2(f)(1)(ii)) and not to the instant property under 2(f)(1)(i). Citing State of Kerala v. Purushothaman, Menon A.K. and Mohammed Basheer, the court rejected the dictionary-based approach, emphasized pre-vesting applicability of the MPPF Act, and recognized Ext.A1 as conclusive proof of possession and title. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed, but Hamza is held exempt from vesting.
WP(C) No. 6735/2022 & O.P.(FC) No.127/2022 The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, adjudicates two connected petitions filed by Anjana challenging the registration of her marriage with J.A. Jayesh Jayaram under the Kerala Registration of Marriages (Common) Rules, 2008, and seeking restitution of conjugal rights. The Local Registrar of Marriages (Common) and various government authorities cancelled or questioned the marriage registration following earlier judicial directions and administrative orders. Jayesh sought relief by filing a restitution petition in the Family Court (O.P. No. 85/2016) and challenged these orders across multiple forums, including revision and SLP proceedings. The court traces a long history of orders and interventions by the Appellate Authority, the Government, and the Supreme Court, revealing a tug-of-war over the marriage’s validity. The key legal question is whether not-pressing the restitution petition by Jayesh can terminate or negate the ongoing inquiry into the marriage’s validity by the Family Court. The Division Bench emphasizes that the Family Court is not bound by rigid procedural rules and that its primary task is the truth-seeking and welfare-based resolution of matrimonial disputes, while recognizing that the master of the case remains the presiding officer. It remands for a merits-based determination of the marriage’s validity, with the outcome affecting cancellation or retention of the marriage registration and with no costs awarded."
OP (FC) NO. 606 OF 2021 & CONNT. CASES These petitions arise from a Khula invoked by Fathimathul Nabila Noushad challenging an interim Family Court order restraining action on the Khula and seeking a declaration of her status on the Khula dated 21.10.2021 in OP 1/2022. Her husband Mohammed Aslam filed OP 2721/2021 in the Family Court, Ernakulam, seeking a declaration that the Khula is invalid. The matter expanded into transfer petitions (OP (FC) 606/2021 and connected cases) and related TR.P(CRL.) 29/2020, TR.P(C) 261/2020, TR.P(C) 306/2020, TR.P(C) 308/2020, TR.P(C) 404/2021 and TR.P(C) 175/2022, all seeking transfer of cases between Family Courts located at Ernakulam, Thalassery and Kozhikode. The core issue is convenience and welfare, given a geographic gulf (Ernakulam/Thalassery about 260 km apart). After evaluating convenience for both sides, the Kerala High Court, sitting as a Division Bench, transferred O.P. 599/2020 and O.P. 600/2020 from Ernakulam to Kozhikode, and M.C. 88/2020, O.P. 231/2020 and O.P. 877/2020 from Thalassery to Kozhikode. The parties were directed to appear before the Kozhikode Family Court on 04.05.2022, with online options permitted; proceedings were to be recorded digitally. The court urged expeditious disposal, guided by Asbi K.N. v. Hashim M.V (2021) 6 KLT 292, which mandates time-bound disposal of declarations of status in related cases. The orders dispose of all connected petitions accordingly, and the matter is to be resolved at Kozhikode.
This High Court of Kerala judgment arises in CRL.MC No.3689/2022 challenging proceedings in LPC 53/2010 arising from Crime No.581/2009 of Kasaragod Police Station. Petitioners (accused Nos. 2 and 3) are challenged under Section 420 r/w Section 34 IPC based on a sequence: two foreign cheques presented for collection were credited notionally to the account of the first accused, who allegedly issued cheques to the petitioners; the petitioners then withdrew sums amounting to Rs.3,60,000 and Rs.3,40,000 using those cheques. The foreign cheques were dishonoured, and a final police report (Annexure-A3) was submitted. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kasaragod, took cognizance and conducted trial in CC No.529/2013 against the first accused, who was ultimately acquitted by judgment Annexure-A4 dated 4/5/2019. The case against the petitioners, however, continued in LPC No.53/2010. The petitioners submit that having regard to the acquittal of the first accused, the substratum of the case is lost and further prosecution is a wastage of judicial time, relying on Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police (Full Bench). The High Court, after examining the record and the available evidence, held that the credit to the first accused’s account was a bank mistake and the withdrawals did not constitute the offence, thereby destroying the substratum. Consequently, the court quashed Annexure-A3 final report and all further proceedings in LPC 53/2010, allowing the CRL.MC.
This is a Kerala High Court original petition under Article 227 challenging Ext P10 (21.12.2022) in I.A.669/2022 in O.S.225/2017 before the Munsiff, Pattambi. The suit, initiated by the plaintiff (first respondent) for partition, arises from a dispute over paternity and inheritance: the plaintiff claims to be the daughter of Kuttikrishnan Nair and Lakshmi Appissi, while the petitioner (first defendant) and the second respondent (second defendant) are alleged illegitimate children from a relationship between Kuttikrishnan Nair and Madhavi Amma. The Munsiff allowed Ext P3, an order to conduct a DNA profiling test to determine whether the first respondent, the petitioner, and the second respondent share the same father, despite opposition from the petitioner and the second respondent. The petition contends that there is no proven marriage between the mother and Kuttikrishnan Nair and that the suit is not a suitable vehicle for a DNA inquiry. The High Court surveys evolving jurisprudence on DNA testing in paternity and matrimonial contexts, citing Goutam Kundu (1993), Sharda (2003), Bhabani Prasad Jena (2018), Nandlal Wasudeo Badwalk (2014), Dipantwita Roy (2015), and Prabhavini Devi (2017). It concludes that the law has shifted to permit DNA testing under controlling principles, but distinguishes Prabhavini Devi on facts. It sets aside Ext P10 and directs reconsideration of I.A.669/2022 by the trial court, while urging expeditious disposal of O.S.225/2017 given the age of the first respondent.
The Kerala High Court, in Bail Applications Nos. 5363 and 5367 of 2024, comprising a common order by Justice C.S. Dias, heard two concurrent bail petitions arising from Crime Nos. 725/2024 and 726/2024 of Karunagappally Police Station, Kollam. Vinod, the petitioner, is accused of offences under IPC Section 354A and various provisions of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO) incl. sections 7, 8, 9(m), 10, 11(i), 12, read with other sections. The offences allegedly involve sexual assault against Vinod’s two daughters, aged 17 and 15, with incidents purportedly occurring long ago and reported recently. The petitions seek bail under Section 439 CrPC after Vinod’s detention since 21.05.2024. The prosecution contends incriminating materials exist and that Vinod’s status as father of the victims creates a real risk of intimidation and tampering, warranting denial of bail. The defense argues innocence, emphasizes the long interval since the alleged acts, and highlights that investigations are ongoing with final reports not yet laid; the offences carry less than ten years’ imprisonment. The court notes Vinod has already served about 66 days in custody and emphasizes that the merits will be determined at trial. It references statutory bail under Section 167(2) CrPC, including indefeasible rights on failure to complete investigation within prescribed periods. The order grants bail with conditions including Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, periodic appearances, non-interference with witnesses, no new offences, and surrender of passport, while clarifying that observations are for the bail proceeding only and not merits of the case.
Cont.Case (C) No. 2442 of 2019 This is a contempt of court case filed under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 by petitioners (the employees) against the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) alleging willful disobedience of directions issued by the High Court in W.P.(C) Nos. 38819/2016 and connected matters, and finally in light of the Supreme Court’s judgment of 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 and connected matters (EPFO v. Sunil Kumar B.), which upheld the legality and validity of Notification G.S.R.609(E) (2014) and directed read-down of certain provisions. The petitioners argued that higher pension and the option rights under paragraphs 11(3)/(4) of the pension scheme ought to be implemented and extended as per the 2014 amendments and pre/post amendment scheme interpretations, with time extensions and adjustments. The respondents argued that the directives must be implemented in accordance with law and that reconsideration of entitlement for higher pension could be undertaken by EPFO in light of the apex court’s 2022 judgment. The High Court, after considering the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision, closed the contempt petition, directing EPFO to reconsider petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension consistent with the apex Court’s judgment.
Joseph George, proprietor of Appu Pathu Pappu Production House, sought permission to shoot select scenes of his film PANI at Sree Vadakkunnathan Kshethra Maidan (Thekkinkadu Maidan) in Thrissur, to park the production unit’s vehicles in the Maidan, and to provide food there, including use of a Helicam during filming around Swaraj Round. He paid the title registration fee of Rs. 1,000 (Ext. P1) and filed Ext. P2 before the Devaswom Board seeking permission to shoot, park, and feed; Ext. P3 (04.10.2023) rejected Ext. P2, with the Devaswom Commissioner invoking Ext. P4 judgment (11.04.2023) in W.P.(C) Nos. 26499/2018 and 4617/2022 to deny the request. The petitioner challenged Ext. P3 under Article 226, arguing that Ext. P4 does not bar limited filming. The Board countered that Ext. P4 and earlier orders, including observations in contiguous contempt/DBP matters, constrain such activity and protect temple rituals and temple precincts. The Court analyzed the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 (Sections 62, 62A, 62B, 68, 73A, 74, 86), the Trusts Act and related fiduciary duties, and the doctrine of parens patriae, as background in governing Devaswom property, guardianship, and permissible uses of Thekkinkadu Maidan. It ultimately upheld the respondent’s order, holding no merit in extending Ext. P4 to permit filming. The petition was dismissed with no order as to costs.
This is ITA No.25/2017 before the Kerala High Court (Division Bench) arising from the assessment-year 2012-13. The Revenue challenges an ITAT Cochin Bench order (ITA No.360/Coch/2016) in favor of the cooperative bank. The central issue concerns whether the CBDT Circular No.3/2018’s monetary ceiling governs the appeal and, if so, whether the present matter falls within its ambit given the alleged cascading effect of Circulars under the Income Tax Act, 1961. Counsel for the Revenue relies on apex court authorities: Commissioner of Income Tax v. Surya Herbal Ltd (2013) 350 ITR 300 (SC); Tarun R. Tahiliani (Civil Appeal No.7526/2011); S.C. Naregal v. Commissioner of Income Tax (SC); DIT v. S.R. M. B. Dairy Farming (P.) Ltd. (SC); and the Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Commissioner of Income Tax. The respondent bank contends that the matter may not cascade into a group of cases and that the appeal should be treated within the protective limits of the circular. The bench acknowledges the guiding principles from those decisions, notes the absence of cascading effect, and applies the monetary-limit framework. Ultimately, the court dismisses the Revenue’s appeal as the tax effect is within the threshold, aligning with Circular No.3/2018 and related Supreme Court guidance.
This Kerala High Court case arises in CRL.M.C. 7805 of 2023, where five accused (Shanavas @ Sana; Ramsheed A; Manikoth Aboobacker Abdulla; Asif P; Muhammad Mudasir Ahammad) move under Section 482 CrPC to quash Crime No.217/2021 of Hosdurg police, Kasaragod, which charged them with offences under Section 326 read with Section 34 IPC for allegedly assaulting the victim, causing grievous hurt. The petition contends that the parties have settled their dispute and the victim has no objection to quashing the prosecution. The Public Prosecutor offers reservations but concedes the dispute is settled. The court scrutinises precedents from the Supreme Court, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303, and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab and others (2014) 6 SCC 466, which delineate when the inherent power under S.482 CrPC may be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offences that are private in nature and resolved between parties. The court emphasizes that such power is not available for heinous or serious offences, or offences under special statutes (e.g., Prevention of Corruption Act) or where public interest is involved, and may consider the accused’s antecedents and conduct. Applying these principles, the court holds the dispute private, the settlement genuine, the victim’s consent clear, and thus allows the petition and quashes all further proceedings, including the final report.
W.P.(C) No.16820 of 2020 and W.P.(C) No.21994 of 2022 The two connected writ petitions, W.P.(C) No.16820 of 2020 and W.P.(C) No.21994 of 2022, were heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The petitioner, K.N. Krishnakumar, claims title to and possession of six cents in land comprising old Sy.No. 6639/3 and Re-survey No.292/5 in Cheranalloor Village, asserting purchase documents and release deeds to establish sole ownership. The disputes arose with the Cochin Devaswom Board and its temple land, notably over a disputed strip of land around Sy.No.640/4 (Re-survey 292/5), where the temple property allegedly faced encroachment and trespass by a neighboring landowner. Ext.P4 (28.08.2014) and Ext.P6 (20.12.2014) proceedings initiated by the 3rd respondent (Special Tahsildar) were challenged as illegal, and the petitioner sought identification and demarcation of his property based on Ext.P18 (district collector’s altered area memorandum and revised sketch). The court traced a long history of petitions under the Land Conservancy Act and related orders (Exts. P5, P7, P8, P9, etc.), noting suppression of material facts in WP 21994/2022 and directing a reply. The court emphasized the need for full disclosure (citing Prestige Lights Ltd. v. SBI and KD Sharma) and held the petitioner not entitled to relief, while directing the 5th respondent to decide Ext.P8 within six months. The two petitions were disposed/dismissed with these directions, forming a Division Bench decision upholding orderly demarcation and expeditious adjudication of the temple land dispute.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No.1118 of 2023) filed under Section 482 CrPC in the Kerala High Court, seeking to quash proceedings in CC No.325 of 2016 (Judicial First Class Magistrate, Punalur-II) for offences under Sections 143, 147, 323, 343, 294(b) read with Section 149 IPC. The petitioners—accused Nos. 1 to 6—are alleged to have formed an unlawful assembly on 13.05.2014 at about 6:45 PM, restrained the 3rd respondent and assaulted him, causing injuries. The petitioners contend a full amicable settlement with the victim, supported by Annexure-A2, and urge termination of proceedings in the interest of peace. The court had earlier directed investigation to verify the authenticity of the settlement and to check for any antecedents in respect of the petitioners. The Public Prosecutor opposed quashing solely on the basis of settlement. The bench, invoking settled law, particularly State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and related decisions, held that Section 482 CrPC power to quash can be invoked in private, non-compoundable offences where the dispute has been resolved, especially where the offence has civil character, but not for heinous or public-official offences. After considering gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the harmonious settlement, the court concluded quashing would further peace and ends of justice. The petition stands allowed; Annexure-A1 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC No.325/2016 are quashed, bringing the matter to a close.
Balan C., the claimant in O.P.(M.V.) No. 274/2000 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Vadakara, seeks compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for injuries arising from a July 6, 1999 accident involving two stage carriage buses. The Tribunal found both vehicles’ drivers liable and held the insurers responsible, awarding Rs. 1,49,784 with interest at 6% per annum. Dissatisfied, the appellant contends the compensation is inadequately calculated and that Ext.A7, the Village Officer’s certificate indicating his occupation as a carpenter, is not proven or competent to establish his earnings; hence the Tribunal’s monthly income of Rs. 1,500 is too low. Citing Ramachandrappa, Raj Kumar and other authorities, he argues for a higher monthly income appropriate to a carpenter in 1999, and for damages to reflect loss of earnings, medical expenses, and non-pecuniary losses. The respondents challenge Ext.A7’s validity, maintain the Tribunal’s findings, and contend the claim is excessive; they acknowledge insurance coverage for the two vehicles but oppose enhanced liability. The High Court reconsiders evidence and applicable law, fixing monthly income at Rs.2,750 ( Rs.2,500 plus 10% future prospects), applying the multiplier rule and accounting for 36% permanent disability with a 10% future prospect, plus six months’ loss of earnings. It awards enhanced compensation of Rs.81,900 with 7.5% interest and directs payment by insurers within two months, with bank details to be furnished by the claimant.
Mat.Appeal Nos.221/2018; 222/2018; 224/2018; 225/2018 These four matrimonial appeals arise from judgments of the Family Court, Ottappalam, in OP Nos. 412–415 of 2017, challenging orders including restitution of conjugal rights and related relief. The appeals—Mat.Appeal Nos. 221/2018, 222/2018, 224/2018 and 225/2018—were heard together before a division bench of the Kerala High Court on 9 December 2022 after mediation, leading to a common judgment. Mediation produced a memorandum of settlement dated 09.11.2022, and the parties were directed to proceed in terms of that settlement; the court recorded that the memorandum would form part of the judgment. A key issue was whether the mandatory six-month cooling period under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act could be dispensed with. Relying on Amardeep Singh v. Harveen Kaur (2017) 8 SCC 746, the court held that the cooling period is discretionary and not mandatory, where mediation has yielded genuine settlement and the parties have lived apart, among other considerations. Consequently, the court granted a decree of divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B, dissolving the marriage between the appellant-husband and respondent-wife in Mat.Appeal No.221 of 2018, and disposed of the connected appeals in terms of the memorandum of agreement dated 09.11.2022. The judgment is a product of the Division Bench presided by Anil K. Narendran, J., and P. G. Ajithkumar, J.