Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 540 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.27587/2022

Devandan M.C. Lakshmi Nandanam and others v. Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) and others

This Kerala High Court case concerns elections to District Cricket Associations (DCAs) in Kannur district and whether they should be conducted strictly under the Lodha Committee reforms adopted by the Kerala Cricket Association (KCA) or could continue under the pre-existing byelaws. The petitioners, office bearers of local cricket clubs, contended that the Lodha-derived Ext.P4 Memorandum of Association and Rules should govern DCAs, and that their elections (to CDA) must follow Ext.P4’s three-year terms, cooling-off period, age cap, and term limits, with Ext.P2 (common byelaws for DCAs) being superseded. They argued Ext.P7/Ext.P8 elections based on older byelaws would be illegal and arbitrary. The respondents argued that the Lodha reforms pertain to the BCCI and SCAs, not to DCAs, and that Ext.P2 remains applicable to DCAs, as a binding framework adopted by the DCAs themselves. The court noted that the Lodha reforms aim to reform governance, accountability, and transparency, but reasoned that the Supreme Court did not intend to apply these directly to DCAs. It held that Ext.P4 does not replace Ext.P2 for DCAs; hence there was no illegality in proceeding with Ext.P2-based elections to CDA. The petition was dismissed, with the court emphasising that Ombudsman orders are not universally applicable to all DCAs.

High Court of Kerala
O.P. (KAT) No. 202 of 2023

O.P. (KAT) No. 202 of 2023

This Division Bench of the Kerala High Court hears an Original Petition under Articles 226 and 227 challenging Ext.P-4, the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s final order in O.A. No. 1625/2022 (dated 28-03-2023). The subject matter concerns appointments to the post of Instructor Grade-I, Electrical Engineering, in Government Engineering Colleges (Technical Education Department). The statutory framework centers on the Kerala Technical Education Service Special Rules (Anx-A3) dated 8-11-2010, which regulate appointment by-transfer and direct recruitment. The Tribunal held that by-transfer appointments made under Annexures A-6 and A-7 in pursuance of Ext.P-3 (Draft Rules) to amend the rules were ultra vires since Anx-A3 had not been amended by proper statutory process, and it directed reporting of four vacancies to the PSC for filling by direct recruitment from the Anx-A2 ranked list (dated 29-08-2022). The petitioners contest the Tribunal’s decision, arguing that executive orders can guide appointments in the absence of statutory rules and seeking quashing Ext.P-4. The respondents contend that the by-transfer route violates statutory rules and that direct recruitment should be used where feeder categories under Anx-A3 are not available. The High Court ultimately dismisses the OP, upholding the Tribunal’s view, vacates an interim status quo, and directs PSC to advise and fill vacancies via direct recruitment from the existing rank list.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)NO.10085 OF 2013

Executive Officer, Sree Makreri Devaswom, Kannur District v. K. Krishnan and Others

The petitioner, the Executive Officer of Sree Makreri Devaswom (a controlled institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board), filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging Exts.P5 (05.08.2011) and P6 (21.01.2013), which respectively set aside Ext.P2 and directed reinstatement in the disciplinary proceedings against the 1st respondent, a Vazhipadu Clerk. Ext.P4 had earlier dismissed him from service (04.05.2001). The matter has a long procedural history, including an appellate intervention directing a fresh enquiry and subsistence payments during suspension; interim relief granted by this Court since 2013; and complex questions relating to the interplay between pending criminal proceedings and departmental discipline. The 1st respondent’s criminal case (C.C.No.287 of 2001) and related appeals are referenced, with the 2nd respondent’s Ext.P6 attempted reinstatement being scrutinized. The Court noted that while the decisions in Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. and Jagdamba Parasad Shukla v. State of U.P. were discussed, they do not squarely apply to grant immediate reinstatement. The Court ultimately set aside Ext.P6 to the extent of reinstatement and directed the disciplinary authority to complete the proceedings within three months, while ensuring subsistence allowances as previously ordered. The challenge to Ext.P5 was not upheld to the extent of quashing the fresh enquiry, but the reinstatement relief was curtailed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12675 of 2011

Damodharan and Others v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Palakkad; Cherplacherry Service Co-operative Bank Limited; Life Insurance Corporation of India

This writ petition challenges an order disposing of gratuity payments under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The High Court had, in December 2020, disposed of the case by directing the respondents to pay gratuity in terms of the Full Bench judgment in Chandrasekharan Nair G. v. Kerala State Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. & Others (2017 (4) KLT 276). An interlocutory application was filed by the 2nd respondent to recall the order on grounds that amendment to sub‑section (3) of Section 4 of the Act was effected on 24.05.2010, raising the gratuity cap from Rs. 3.5 lakh to Rs. 10 lakh, and that petitioners had retired before 31.01.2010, with LIC already disbursing Rs. 3.5 lakh. The petitioners argue that the pre‑amendment limit should govern their cases, as they retired prior to the amendment and the general order did not address individual circumstances. The respondents contend that the Full Bench doctrine requires any excess payments under employer‑insurer arrangements to be passed to the employee, and hence the IA should be dismissed. The court heard both sides and held that since the amount paid by LIC corresponded to the pre‑amendment limit, the 17.12.2020 judgment must be recalled. Consequently, the IA was allowed and the writ petition closed, with no further directions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.18551 and 18564 of 2022

W.P.(C) Nos.18551 and 18564 of 2022

The Kerala High Court, in two connected writ petitions filed by temple contractors, deals with payment disputes arising from works carried out under the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDV). The petitioners allege non-payment of substantial bills for multiple works undertaken at Navaikulam and Aniyoor Devaswom (Varkala and Ulloor Groups) and at Sabarimala, totaling several lakhs, despite timely completion and submission of bills. They claim financial distress and adverse bank actions due to non-payment, and seek a mandamus under Article 226 to direct the respondents to release pending payments with interest. The Travancore Devaswom Board counters that most of the works were either not completed or were tainted by irregularities, forged signatures, and manipulations in files; it contends that the issues involve contractual disputes and disputed facts, inappropriate for adjudication by a writ court. The court notes that the petitioners suppressed material facts and that the Board contemplates serious corrective action, including possible action against officers/contractors. After hearing, the court dismisses the petitions, but directs a detailed enquiry by the Chief Vigilance Officer into the contract works with notice to the petitioners and involved officers, insisting on recovery of losses, if any, and places a three-month deadline for reports, with further steps to follow. The petitions are disposed of with these directions, and no immediate relief is granted to the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.1796 of 2020

Chandy Kuriyakose and Sony Philip v Mor Gregorious KuriaKose; Mor Ivanios KuriaKose; Malankara Suriyani Knanaya Samudayom; Malankara Suriyani Knanaya Association; Mor Severous KuriaKose

This is an original petition under OP(C) 1796 of 2020 filed in the Kerala High Court by members and entities of the Malankara Suriyani Knanaya community challenging an edict/kalpana (No. EI 82/19 dated 13 December 2019) issued by the Patriarch of Antioch governing administration of the Knanaya Samudayom. The petition seeks a permanent injunction restraining defendants 3–5 (the Knanaya Samudayom, its association and related bodies) from implementing the Kalpana, arguing that it contravenes the 1952 Constitution of the Samudayom and intrudes into internal governance. The suit originally sought interim relief, which was granted by the Munsiff’s Court, Thiruvalla, and later reversed by CMA No. 39 of 2020 before the Addl. District Court, Kottayam. The petition challenges the CMA judgment, arguing procedural improprieties—particularly admission of four additional documents and an additional counter affidavit after arguments concluded—under the rubric of Order XLIII Rule 1 and the applicability of Order XLII? / Order XLI Rule 27. The respondents contend the documents were relevant, largely pre-existing in the suit, and that the appellate court’s discretion to admit evidence is proper. On 22 February 2022, the High Court, led by V. G. Arun, dismissed the original petition, holding that the Kalpana forms part of interim arrangements and that the related proceedings (including OS 506 of 2013) justify not granting a separate injunction at this stage. The decision treats appellate evidentiary discretion as not strictly mandatory and affirms the CMA’s reversal of the interim injunction in a manner consistent with the ongoing litigation.”

High Court of Kerala
CRP NO. 533 OF 2017

Mohan Das P.A. v. Thuravankara Puliyampully NNamboodiriyachan Nada Devaswom Trust, Thuravankara and Others

This Kerala High Court civil revision petition concerns whether a trust dispute involving the Thuravankara temple trust falls within the special jurisdiction of Section 92 CPC for public charities, or should be dealt with under the ordinary Civil Procedure Code. The petitioner, Mohan Das P.A., challenged an order in I.A.951/2017 in OS 74/2017 of the Munsiff Court, Aluva, which had been framed as a challenge to the convening of an extraordinary general body meeting and the election of an advisory committee within the trust. The trial court reportedly repelled the contention that Section 92 CPC applies, leading to the petitioner filing CRP 533/2017. The court’s analysis centers on whether the suit, which seeks removal of trustees, appointments, delivery of possession of trust property, accounts, and other relief, is tantamount to invoking the jurisdiction of Section 92(1) CPC for public charitable or religious trusts, or whether it seeks declarations that would operate as removal of trustees and thus fall outside Section 92 CPC. The judgment invokes Vidyodaya Trust and Others v. Mohan Prasad R. to emphasize that Section 92 CPC is a special provision applicable to public trusts, and cites Swami Paramatmanand Saraswathi to caution against confounding private rights with trust administration. Concluding that the suit is within Section 92 CPC, the High Court sets aside the trial court’s order and allows the CRP by dismissing the suit under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for proper presentation under Section 92 CPC.

High Court of Kerala
CO No. 86 of 2015; MACA No. 498 of 2015

MUMTHAS MUHAMMED v. THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD

Two related appeals arising from the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal's award in OP(MV) No.250/2011 were heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The Cross Objector, Mumthas Muhammed, sustained serious injuries after being knocked down by an offending car on 16 January 2011 while walking on a public road. She required prolonged treatment, including 12 days of inpatient care and ongoing rest for about six months. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 2,12,000 as compensation, whereas the Original Petition sought Rs. 6,95,000. The Insurance Company challenged the award contending that compensation under heads like pain and suffering and loss of amenities was excessive, and that the head of disfiguration lacked evidence. The Cross Objector contended that the Tribunal erred in not adequately compensating for permanent disability, loss of earnings during the rest period, and other heads such as bystanders’ expenses and extra nourishment; she also asserted that her income could not be ascertained since she worked as a tailor. The Court relied on Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd and Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation to determine notional income and multiplier. It revised the permanent disability compensation from Rs.20,000 to Rs.26,808, increased loss of earnings by Rs.56,000, and enhanced extra nourishment to Rs.3,600, while keeping other heads intact. The appeal is allowed in part; enhanced amounts are payable with 8% interest from the claim date and proportionate costs, to be deposited within two months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.29149 OF 2021

Jesinlal James and Mary Dasi Manuel v. Revenue Divisional Officer Kollam; Registrar of Births & Deaths Kollam Corporation; Secretary Perayam Grama Panchayath

This writ petition, filed by a mother (Mary Dasi Manuel) and her son (Jesinlal James), seeks either a birth certificate or a non-availability certificate in relation to the birth of the first petitioner on 05 January 1973. Ext.P7 shows Kollam Corporation stating that no entry exists for the birth of a boy to Mary Dasy and James at Bisnu Nivas, while a separate entry exists for a birth on 05 February 1973 to James and Daisy James at Bunglavil House, which differs in mother’s name and address. The petition contends that there is no authentic record of the first petitioner’s birth in the municipal registers and thus a non-availability certificate should be issued; it relies on Section 13 of the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969 and Rule 9 of the Kerala Registration of Births and Deaths Rules, 1999. The court notes that Section 13(3) enables delayed registration via a Magistrate’s order, but the verification is an executive function about the fact of birth, not adjudication of the birth date. Citing Velu v. Madathi and Kausalya P.K., the bench emphasizes Magistrate-level verification. The petition is disposed by directing the respondents to issue a non-availability certificate for the birth claimed by the petitioners, within three weeks of this judgment’s certified copy.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 8632 of 2023

Justin Mathew Baby v. State of Kerala and Others

This criminal miscellaneous case challenges CC No.668/2023, on the file of the Special Court of Judicial First Class Magistrate XI, Thiruvananthapuram, arising from Crime No.283/2023 of Peroorkada Police Station. The petitioner, Justin Mathew Baby, is charged under sections including 294(b), 323 and 427 IPC, and under Section 138 of the NI Act. He seeks exercise of the court’s constitutional power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the criminal proceedings on the ground that the parties have amicably settled the dispute; the victim has filed an affidavit in support of the settlement, while the Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations but conceded that the matter is settled. The court relies on Supreme Court guidance in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), which holds that the power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash non-compoundable offences can be exercised when the dispute is private and the parties have resolved the entire dispute, subject to limitations for heinous offences or offences under special statutes. The court peruses the records and the affidavits, finds the dispute to be private, and accepts the settlement. Accordingly, the Criminal Misc. Case is allowed and all further proceedings in CC No.668/2023 arising from Crime No.283/2023 are quashed, aligning with the Laxmi Narayan framework as summarized in this judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.4655OF2023

Muhammad Suneer, Ramshad, Muhammad, Muhammad Farhan Firoze v. State of Kerala and Shafeeque K.

In the Kerala High Court, this criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC challenges the quashing of proceedings arising from CC No. 5 of 2023 of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Payyoli. Accused Nos. 1 to 4 contend that a settlement has been reached with the de facto complainant and that the injuries alleged on 15.08.2022 were the result of a dispute resolved amicably; this is supported by Annexure-3 sworn affidavit. The prosecution records show charges of offences under Sections 342, 323, 324 read with Section 34 IPC. The Public Prosecutor indicated reservations about terminating the proceedings solely on settlement but acknowledged that there are no other serious crimes against the petitioners. The Court directed the Investigating Officer to verify the authenticity of the settlement and whether the petitioners have any other criminal antecedents or impediments to quashing. The ruling cites State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; State of Rajasthan v. Shambhu Kewat; State of M.P. v. Deepak; State of M.P. v. Manish; J. Ramesh Kamath v. Mohana Kurup; State of M.P. v. Rajveer Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir v. State of Gujarat; State of M.P. v. Kalyan Singh; State of M.P. v. Dhruv Gurjar to outline the law. The court holds that under the settled principles, quashing is permissible for non‑compoundable offences where the dispute is private and resolved, provided serious offences are not involved. It emphasizes that offences like murder, rape, or acts under special statutes are not quashed merely on settlement. After examining factors such as gravity, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the court concludes that quashing the proceedings would serve the ends of justice. Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the final report/trial proceedings are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5818 OF 2024

Bail Application No. 5818 of 2024

The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, hears Bail Application No. 5818 of 2024 under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) for pre-arrest bail in Crime No. 885/2024 (Ottapalam Police Station, Palakkad), registered for offences under Sections 451 and 354 of the IPC. The petitioner is the brother‑in‑law of the defacto complainant’s husband; the prosecution alleges that on 12.06.2024, at around 10:20 hours, the accused trespassed into the complainant’s house, hugged her, and attempted to remove her churidar, with a design to outrage her modesty. The case is complicated by familial property disputes: the FIR was lodged 13 days after the incident, and the petitioner contends that the complaint is a spiteful act driven by animosity, aiming to pressure him in civil disputes. The petitioner’s counsel asserts innocence, no criminal antecedents, and argues that custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor counters that there are incriminating materials and ongoing investigation, and arrest could hinder the probe. The court notes the delay and familial ties but emphasizes that the matter will be decided at trial. Relying on Bhadres Bipinbhai Sheth v. State of Gujarat (2015 KHC 4579) for the pre‑arrest bail framework, the judge holds that valid grounds exist to exercise discretionary jurisdiction under Sec. 438 CrPC and grants pre‑arrest bail subject to conditions, including surrender within 10 days, bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, cooperation, no intimidation, passport surrender, no other offences, and the court’s power to cancel bail for violations, with recoveries permissible during bail per Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi). The observations herein are not to be construed as merits.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 19474/2022

W.P.(C) No. 19474/2022 (Mohammed Ahnas. B vs State of Kerala & others)

Mohammed Ahnas. B, a PWD contractor, challenges the denial of price escalation for bitumen on a road-improvement project awarded in Kasaragod. The petitioner contends that government orders issued in 2018 and revised in 2020–2021 mandated payment of price differences for bitumen on ongoing works, and that Exhibit P4 (30.04.2021) expands relief for open-tender and nominated contracts. The project involved the Nellikatta Karamathodi Road (Km 7/000 to 10/9000) with tender submitted in Oct 2020 and an agreement executed on 21.12.2020; the final bill was submitted to the Public Works Department. The government contends that the contract contained a definite, fixed price and did not incorporate a price-escalation clause; the government orders are administrative measures addressing a 2018 spike in bitumen prices, not contractual promises. The High Court held that Exhibit P4 is a revision of the 2018 order made under exceptional circumstances and cannot be read as a blanket entitlement for all contracts post-01.11.2018. Citing Indian Contract Act provisions (Sections 32, 56, 65) and authorities such as SEAMEC Ltd., Century Spg., Joshi Tech., and AP Transco, the court concluded that contractual obligations cannot be displaced by promissory estoppel or post-tender guidelines. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed for lack of a contractual right to price escalation.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 643 of 2022

Harrisons Malayalam Limited v. Ramachandran and Others

This Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 643 of 2022) concerns a challenge to the order of the Sulthanbathery Sub Court, which dismissed IA No.1/2022 in AS No.2/2022 as barred by limitation, and arose from the decree and judgment in OS No.183/2008 (Munsiff Kalpetta) dated 09.11.2012. The appellants, four defendants, seek to condone an enormous delay in filing the appeal (3366 days) against the 2012 decree, arguing that they did not wilfully delay and that various factors—chiefly the inadvertent management of the case by the first defendant, Ramachandran, who claimed to have entrusted the matter to others including his wife, and the appellants’ age-related ailments and mental health issues—prevented timely filing. The respondent plaintiff, Harrisons Malayalam Limited, contends that the delay is excessive and not supported by sufficient cause. The First Appellate Court disposed of the delay petition in a manner that condoned some days (1011 days), and the Sub Court dismissed the IA as time-barred. The High Court, applying a line of Supreme Court decisions (notably Basawaraj, P. Ramachandran, Ramlal line of authorities, and related precedents on delay and sufficient cause), held that condoning such a large delay cannot be justified and that the delay must be decided within a strict framework. Consequently, the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, admission refused, and all pending interlocutory applications are dismissed. The Registry is directed to inform the trial and appellate courts accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No.513 of 2021

Mat.Appeal No.513 of 2021 (C.R.)

This matrimonial appeal arises from a Family Court dissolution of marriage under Section 10(vii) for non-consummation, with the Court remanding earlier issues of cruelty under Section 10(x). The wife filed OP 1060/2011 after a prior order; on remand, the Family Court Ettumanoor dissolved the marriage on 25/08/2021 under 10(vii). The respondent-husband challenges the decree, arguing that there were no pleadings for non-consummation, that the evidence is insufficient to prove willful non-consummation, and that the trial court erred in relying on Ext.A4 and PW2's testimony. The petitioner-wife asserts willful non-consummation aided by Ext.A4’s medical certificate that hymen intact with circular opening, and PW2's testimony that intercourse is possible only with surgery in this case; She also contends cruelty under 10(x). The court examines the meaning of 'willful' under 10(vii), relying on Kuruvilla Varghese and Md. Illiyas, the meaning of 'consummation' as sex after marriage, and whether lack of consummation arises from deliberate conduct. The court acknowledges that pleadings were not originally precise but reads the pleadings in substance. It held that the evidence, including PW3’s testimony, tends to show lack of consummation, but ultimately found cruelty and allowed the appeal, modifying the decree to dissolution under 10(x). The judgment contributes to evolving jurisprudence on cruelty in matrimonial disputes and liberal approach to pleadings and evidence.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 8895 of 2019

Fr. Jose Mathew Parappallil v. The State of Kerala and Others

Fr. Jose Mathew Parappallil, Manager of St Antony's High School, challenged GO (MS) No.49/2017/G.Edn (14.06.2017) and GO (MS) No.53/2018/G.Edn (07.05.2018) which denied sanction for Higher Secondary courses for 2017-2018 and 2018-2019. The petitioner, an aided private high school functioning since 1979 with an exemplary academic record, had long sought Plus Two sanction and argued that past orders and judgments directed the Government to consider applications in light of educational need and backward-area considerations. It contended that the State’s two-level committee process and the policy decisions to withhold sanction violated the directions in this Court, notably in St. Sebastian’s High School v. State of Kerala (and related cases), and were discriminatory given the school’s performance and backward-area location. The Government argued that the decision was based on data from the State and Regional Committees showing no need for additional batches in the relevant districts and that several seats remained vacant in other areas; it asserted policy decisions are within executive competence and should not be disturbed absent capricious conduct. The High Court acknowledged constitutional obligations to provide education, but, after reviewing the record and precedent (including St. Sebastian’s line and related judgments), held that the impugned order must be tested for fairness and transparency. It set aside the impugned judgment and directed immediate Government action to determine how to address Malappuram district’s needs, with scope to sanction additional batches per St. Sebastian’s framework if required.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No. 970/2023

Writ Appeal No. 970 of 2023 (W.A. No. 970/2023) – Tirur Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. v. T.N. Sivasankaran and others

This intra-court appeal arises from a 30.03.2023 judgment of a learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.36589/2022, where the writ petition filed by T. N. Sivasankaran (the writ petitioner) challenged Ext.P12, a bank order denying promotion, despite an Arbitration Award (Ext.P-1) directing reinstatement with full service benefits including back wages. The petitioner had been suspended in 2006 and dismissed in 2008; Arbitration ultimately directed reinstatement. The Co-operative Tribunal and the High Court’s jugement history varied back wages (25% then 50%, later limited to 25% by the Apex Court in Ext.P-5). The petitioner claimed entitlement to promotion to the next higher category (Senior Supervisor) with retrospective effect from 16.06.2008 (the date his junior was promoted) and sought consequential benefits and pensionary adjustments. The appellant bank contended that promotion was contingent on ongoing disciplinary proceedings and concerned with retroactive, notional, or sealed-cover promotions; it relied on legal doctrines around rule-in-force, and the Sealed Cover procedure. The High Court, after analyzing the arbitration award, natural justice issues, and precedents, held that the petitioner is entitled to be promoted at par with his junior from 16.06.2008 and directed the bank to pass fresh orders, with reasonable opportunity, within a specified period. The W.A. is disposed of accordingly, extending time for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P.No.519 of 2021 & Crl.M.C.No.4545 of 2021

Crl.R.P.No.519 of 2021 & Crl.M.C.No.4545 of 2021

This is a consolidated criminal revision petition and a criminal miscellaneous petition arising from the de novo investigation by the CBI into a murder case in Kollam. The 18th accused, Jayamohan, challenged a common order dated 20 September 2021 passed by the Special Judge (SPE/CBI), Thiruvananthapuram, which, while dismissing discharge applications under Section 227 Cr.P.C., ultimately framed a court charge against nineteen accused including the petitioner, alleging multiple offences under the IPC and the Indian Arms Act. The court charge, however, was criticized for not matching the prosecution’s pleaded case of pre-incident conspiracy and for erroneously casting the petitioner in a larger conspiracy to commit the murder, as opposed to the post-incident harbouring of culprits. The High Court held that while discharge under Section 227 Cr.P.C. is warranted only when there is no prima facie case, framing charges must reflect the prima facie case and the broad probabilities. After evaluating the materials and the broad probabilities, the Court found prima facie materials against the petitioner under Section 212 IPC for harbouring accused after the crime, but not evidence of his prior involvement in the conspiracy that led to Ramabhadran’s death. The court quashed the court’s charge against the petitioner and directed fresh charge framing consistent with its observations, while dismissing the revision petition and allowing the M.C. to the stated extent. It also directed expedited pre-trial steps and a ten-month timeline for disposition of the case.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

These writ petitions challenge Government Order G.O.(MS.) No.121/2022 dated 07/07/2022 and the Plus One admission prospectus, which together reduce the management quota in Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools to 20% and provide that 10% of management seats be reserved for the community to which the management belongs, to be allocated on merit. The petitioners, managers of Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools, contend that this constitutes unconstitutional discrimination under Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, and that no vested right exists to maintain a 30% management quota; they argue the policy intrudes upon secular education and undermines merit-based admissions. The respondents defend the policy as a legitimate executive decision aimed at curbing corruption, ensuring transparency, and aligning admissions with merit through a Centralized Allotment Process (CAP). The Kerala High Court, led by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V, finds that while the 20% management quota is permissible, the 10% community quota accompanying it is arbitrary and violates Articles 14 and 15. The court does not direct reallocation of the 10% seats to management; instead, it directs that those seats be treated as open merit seats and filled through CAP, and that admissions already made remain undisturbed. The petitions are disposed of accordingly, with a careful review of constitutional principles and policy considerations governing education admissions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 7330/2023 & 10818/2023

WP(C) Nos. 7330 of 2023 & 10818 of 2023, High Court of Kerala

The judgment deals with two connected writ petitions in the Kerala High Court: WP(C) No. 7330/2023 filed by Sivanandan and Reena and WP(C) No. 10818/2023 filed by Prabhakaran. The core dispute concerns two coconut trees on the property of the third respondent (Prabhakaran in the first petition) which are leaning towards the petitioners’ house, creating a danger to life and property. The first petition sought enforcement of a Panchayat order (Ext P3) directing the third respondent to cut and remove the trees, while the second petition challenged a prior notice (Ext P2, treated as Ext P3 in the other petition) and sought to stall any action. The third respondent contends that the trees are young, are tied to prevent leaning, and he is ready to reinforce or cut them if necessary; he also sought an opportunity of hearing. The petitioners rely on the authorities and on the general principle of natural justice, arguing that Ext P3 was issued after an inspection and should not be stayed without hearing the owner. The court, applying the dictum from Rajkumar v. Mathaikutty (2013 KHC 2251) on natural justice, held that the owner must be given a hearing before further action is taken. It disposed of both petitions by directing the Panchayat to hear all parties within 10 days and decide within a further week, keeping the interim stay in force for WP(C)10818 until final decision. The order emphasizes due process and timely resolution while ensuring safety.