Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 541 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.34497 of 2018 and 35718 of 2018

T.G. Mohan Das v State of Kerala and others (W.P.(C) Nos. 34497 of 2018 and 35718 of 2018)

These are two related writ petitions under Article 226 challenging the entry rules governing the Sabarimala temple. The petitioner contends that permitting entry of non-Hindus and non-idol worshippers into the Sannidhanam violates Rule 3 of the Kerala Places of Public Worship (Authorization of Entry) Act, 1965 and the corresponding Rules, and seeks a declaration to regulate entry strictly for devotees in line with Rule 3(a). The petitions rely on the Apex Court’s dictum in Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (2019) 11 SCC 1 to argue against broader access, while praying for a mandamus to ensure compliance and to initiate investigations into police actions that allegedly allowed non-Hindu entrants. The respondents, including the State and the Travancore Devaswom Board along with law and order authorities, counter that the issues are sub judice before the Supreme Court and that the State has legitimate authority to regulate temple entry in the interest of public order and religious practices. On admission, the court noted that WP(C) No.35718/2018 had already been admitted and, after detailed hearings, the matter was considered with the pendency before the Supreme Court’s Constitution Bench. On 15 November 2022, the High Court disposed of both petitions by dismissing them, keeping open the legal and factual contentions for the higher court’s decision, thereby upholding the status quo while deferring final resolution to the Apex Court.

High Court of Kerala
M.F.A.(FOREST).110/2020

M.F.A.(FOREST).110/2020

This appeal, filed by the State of Kerala and the Custodian under the Kerala Forest (Vesting and Management of Ecologically Fragile Lands) Act, 2003, challenges an OA 23/2008 award of the Forest Tribunal, Palakkad, that declared the schedule property not to be an ecologically fragile land under Section 2(b) of Act 21/2005 and directed restoration of possession to the applicant. The applicant is M.K. Unni Nethiyar, a co-owner whose title is traced through earlier proceedings (O.A. No. 11 of 1997, final decree in O.S. No. 56/1966 and I.A. No. 392/1969). The Tribunal concluded the property lacks natural vegetation, is a paramba/dry land, and is not forest land under Section 2(c). On the contrary, the respondents contend the land is forest land, linked to vested or reserved forests, and contiguous to such forests; they note the property is described as paramba in earlier decrees and that there is no cultivation or buildings, and that extension was reduced. The High Court agrees with the Tribunal that the property does not predominantly support natural vegetation and is essentially a paramba; it cites Kumari Varma to support the approach and distinguishes Unnikrishnan. The court dismisses the appeal but directs the Custodian to restore possession within two months of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.1538/2022

George Abnu alias George A. Vettath; Susan Platto alias Usha; Elizabeth Alexander; Thomas A. Vettath v. Vettath Eapen Mathai; Gregorions Thomas Vettath

This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenges Ext.P4 in E.P. No.326/2013 in O.S. No.1890/1990, which was decided by the Principal Munsiff, Ernakulam. The Ext.P1 decree granted a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining trespass into the plaint schedule property but did not authorize construction of boundary walls. The respondents filed Ext.P2 execution petition seeking to construct boundary walls on the northern and western sides; Ext.P4, the impugned order, permitted such construction at respondents’ expense under supervision. The petitioners filed Ext.P3 objection, and the matter involved survey reports and an Advocate Commissioner’s findings. The petitioners contend Ext.P4 goes beyond the decree’s scope, violating the principle that an Execution Court cannot travel beyond the decree or sit in appeal. The respondents rely on a long history of litigation and on Ext.R2(a) (Division Bench) judgment which had directed relief through execution and on prior decisions like Jai Dayal and others and Brakewel-like authorities to justify the order. The High Court ultimately holds Ext.P4 vitiated by irregularity, distinguishes Ext.R2(a) to emphasize it did not permit boundary construction, and directs that the execution petition be decided under law within the decree’s framework, allowing evidence and expeditious disposal, with parties bearing their own costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO.175 OF 2018

Babu v. State of Kerala

The revision petitioner (2nd accused) challenges the conviction under Section 27(1)(e)(iii) of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961, for trespass and removal of rosewood logs from a Reserve Forest. On 9 May 2007, he was found transporting three logs in a Goods Autorickshaw, allegedly cut and removed from Chenoth Nair Reserve Forest. The Judicial First Class Magistrate, Palakkad, convicted him under 27(1)(e)(iii) and acquitted him of 27(1)(e)(iv), sentencing one year imprisonment and a fine. The Sessions Court affirmed, noting consistency of PW1-PW2’s seizure evidence and Ext. P1 (mahazar). The revision petition argues that the conviction rested on uncorroborated evidence, particularly a confession to a Forest Range Officer, and relies on Lucca Beltrami to challenge the admissibility of such confessions and the scope of forest-offence enquiries by forest officers. The State contends that the wood was found and that Sections 27(1)(e)(iii) and related provisions were rightly applied, citing Mundamdra Kareem to support trespass-based liability and a presumption under Section 69 about forest-produce belonging to the Government. The Kerala High Court ultimately sets aside the conviction and sentence, holding that the conviction cannot stand, and relies on Lucca Beltrami’s doctrine that confessions recorded by Forest Range Officers are not sustainable and on other statutory principles, while distinguishing contrary authorities. The revision petition is allowed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C.) No. 14615/2014

W.P.(C.) No. 14615/2014: Dr. C. S. Premavathy v. Divisional Forest Officer Nilambur North, Nilambur, Malappuram District, and Others

This writ petition, filed by Dr. C. S. Premavathy, seeks a mandamus to respondents 1 to 3 to issue a no-objection certificate to pay basic land tax in respect of five acres of land claimed in Vettilappara and Pulippadam Villages, and a mandamus directing respondents to refrain from interfering with possession and to accept the basic land tax for the property shown in Exhibits P1–P4 without requiring any forest NOC. The petitioner asserts she is the owner in possession, evidenced by Ext. P1 (sale deed dated 04.11.2003), Ext. P2 (Land Tribunal certificate), and Ext. P3 (land tax receipt) with Ext. P4 (possession certificate). She contends that, after 2003, she was informed that land tax could not be paid because forest authorities purportedly planned to notify the property under the Kerala Forest (Vesting and Management of Ecologically Fragile Lands) Act, 2003, and that the land tax could be blocked on that ground. RTI disclosures (Exhibits P5–P6) allegedly confirm the petitioner’s land was not listed as ecologically fragile, though verification indicated possible village boundary adjustments placing the land in Vettilappara. The Divisional Forest Officer counters that the land is forest land and not the petitioner’s; the property is surrounded by reserved forest and not located as per Ext. P1–P2. The court relies on established principles that disputes touching property rights with contested facts require a civil suit, not a writ, citing D.L.F. Housing Construction and Roshina T. The petition is dismissed with liberty to approach competent authorities or a civil court to ventilate the grievances.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P No.1338 of 2012

Govindaraj v. State of Kerala

Govindaraj, the first accused, challenges his conviction under Section 55(g) of the Abkari Act for possession of about 20 litres of wash recovered from a plastic pot buried in the plantain garden in the property of his father at Nattukal, Chundapetti, Puthur village, Mannarkkad Taluk. On 22 July 2004, PW2 and a police party, acting on reliable information, found the accused near the garden, opened the soil, and recovered the plastic pot containing wash. A 500 ml sample was taken, sealed, and the balance wash was destroyed; the accused and his father were charged under Section 55(g) and Section 64A Abkari Act. The trial court convicted the accused; the appellate court affirmed. In the revision petition, the High Court scrutinizes whether the prosecution proved possession—actual or constructive—beyond reasonable doubt. The court notes the lack of proof that the property from which the contraband was recovered belonged to the accused’s father, and hence no clear link to him. The court also observes procedural defects: Ext. P1 seizure mahazar lacks a specimen seal, the forwarding note did not name the Excise Guard who despatched the sample, and the Excise Guard and other witnesses were not properly examined; PW3 turned hostile. Relying on Santhosh v. State of Kerala, Gunwantlal v. State of M.P., and other authorities (Moothedath Sivadasan, Kumaran, Narayana Velichappada), the court held that possession was not proved beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed and Govindaraj is acquitted; bail bonds are cancelled and he is set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)No.31729 of 2023

Mattannur Sree Mahadeva Temple v. State of Kerala and Others

Mattannur Sree Mahadeva Temple, a Devaswom-controlled institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board, filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging Ext.P1 declaring the temple as a religious institution and appointing an Executive Officer. The temple sought a Mandamus to the MDB Commissioner to initiate proceedings under the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951 to recover documents relating to letting out temple buildings to respondents 5–20, recover arrears of rent with interest, obtain vacant possession, and conduct a public auction to lease the buildings at market rates under Section 29 and the Rules. It also sought eviction of defaulting tenants and the recovery of rent to enhance temple income, arguing that the temple’s properties must be protected from misappropriation by trustees or other interfering parties (respondent 21, Sree Mahadeva Kshethra Samithi). The petition references Exts.P5–P25 to show notices and representations, and notes a pending suit OS 5/2022 filed by the Samithi challenging Ext.P8. The High Court, citing fiduciary duties of trustees, the guardian role of the deity, and the doctrine of parens patriae, held that the temple cannot obtain the reliefs by writ and that statutory remedies must be pursued. It disposed of the petition and directed the petitioner to submit a proper representation within two weeks to the 3rd respondent, with due process and notice to all parties, leaving open the civil suit rights.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.RP 617 of 2012

Balakrishnan v. State of Kerala

Balakrishnan, the revision petitioner, challenges his conviction for an offence under Section 8(1) of the Kerala Abkari Act arising from SC No. 729/2006 before the Assistant Sessions Court, Vadakara. The High Court of Kerala, in CrL.RP No. 617 of 2012, heard the matter on 12 October 2023. The trial court had convicted him and sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with a further six months’ imprisonment in default; the appellate court reduced the sentence to six months and kept the fine at Rs. 1,00,000 with a further three months’ imprisonment on default. The petitioner challenges two main defects: (i) lack of a label on the sample bottle and the absence of a clear mention of labeling in Ext. P2 mahazar, with questions about whether the signatures on the label were indeed affixed; and (ii) unexplained delay in investigation, with the occurrence on 10.08.2004 and final report filed only on 28.04.2006, despite the chemical analysis report being ready in 02.12.2005. The court applied strict scrutiny of Abkari Act formalities, citing Baburaj, Sathi, Sasidharan, and Sumathy, and various delay-precedent cases. It held that the labeling defect and the delay undermine the prosecution’s case, and consequently set aside the conviction and sentence, acquitting the petitioner. The bail bond is cancelled, and any deposited amount is to be refunded.”

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.190 of 2020

Mooryantakath Muhammed Haris v. M. Rafi

The revision petitioner, a tenant, challenged eviction under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, after the Rent Control Court allowed eviction for bona fide need and the Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal. The petitioner contended that service of process on the respondent through his counsel, under Rule 59 of the Kerala High Court Rules, was not proper, and argued that the landlord’s claimed need to occupy the premises for a fruit business was not bona fide; he urged that the landlord had other suitable premises or that second proviso to Section 11(3) should be applicable, which would bar eviction. The court appointed an Amicus Curiae to address the service issue, referencing authorities such as Manual v. Thomas and Geetha Panicker v. Lagi Easo Mathew, but ultimately held that the question of service need not be deeply urged and proceeded to hear the matter. On merits, the landlord’s bona fides were examined against the backdrop of precedents including Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath, Ammu v. Nafeesa, and later Kerala and Supreme Court authorities (Gireeshbabu T. P.; Francis; Kunhamma; Rukmini Amma Saradamma; Hindustan Petroleum; Thankamony Amma), which support a test of genuine need. The High Court dismissed the revision but granted six months’ time to surrender possession, with conditions such as affidavit of surrender, arrears payment, and continued rent, subject to compliance.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 571 OF 2021

Rajalakshmi v. Sheeja, Mohanan and The State of Kerala

Rajalakshmi filed CRL Rev.Pet 571 of 2021 challenging two concurrent decrees concerning a "shared household" under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. The trial court dismissed her petition under Section 12 and Sections 18(a), (b), (c), (f) and (g) on the ground that the disputed dwelling did not meet the DV Act’s definition of a "shared household" and that she failed to prove co-residence with her husband and children. The appellate court sustained this view. In the High Court revision, the petitioner argued that she and her deceased husband resided in the home as a family unit; the respondents disputed ownership, contending the property originally belonged to the mother of the first respondent and was gifted to her in 2016, with the petitioner allegedly trespassing in 2015. The court noted that the evidence relied upon by the petitioner was primarily her own testimony, with little independent corroboration, and that the two courts below had concurrently found against the petitioner’s claim of a shared household. It also considered evolving jurisprudence on the meaning of “shared household” under Section 2(s) of the DV Act, particularly the shift from S.R. Batra to Satish Chander Ahuja. The High Court reaffirmed that revisional jurisdiction in Cr.P.C. is supervisory and does not permit re‑appreciation of evidence, and dismissed the revision petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.1608/2015 & 3537/2018

Rajeeshkrishna K.R. and Manager, Higher Secondary School, Kandamangalam v. State of Kerala and Others; S. Manju v. State of Kerala and Others

These consolidated writ petitions challenge a Government order directing appointment by transfer for a Lab Assistant vacancy in a Kerala Higher Secondary School and deal with the apportionment of posts between direct recruitment and transfer as mandated by Kerala Educational Rules. Rajeeshkrishna K.R., appointed as Lab Assistant based on a 2013 notification and later approved in 2014, challenges Ext.P12 (01.01.2015), which directed filling the resultant vacancy by transfer to a different category, while the Manager seeks implementation of that order. The second petition by S. Manju seeks to enforce the same transfer-based allocation. The Court examines Rule 4.6 of Chapter XXXII and Rule 6 of Chapter XXXII of the Kerala Educational Rules (KER), which prescribe 25% of Lab Assistant posts by transfer and 75% by direct appointment, with provision for seniority-based transfer and probationary testing. Relying on Sabitha Cherian v. State of Kerala (DB) 2022 (5) KHC 564, the Court clarifies that the method to reconcile conflicting claims is the “percentage of arising vacancies” doctrine, effectively treating vacancies sequentially with direct recruitment dominating in a two-post scenario. The learned Judge holds that the revisional order Ext.P12 is unsustainable and restores Ext.P2 (approval) while quashing Ext.P12; the second writ petition is dismissed. The decision directs immediate payment of consequential benefits to the first petitioner within three months, and the petitions are disposed of accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P. No. 3826 of 2009

Ponnappan v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, in a criminal revision, intervenes in the conviction of Ponnappan under the Abkari Act. The petitioner was convicted by the trial court under Sections 8(1) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of contraband liquor (three litres of arrack) and was sentenced to one year’s simple imprisonment, with a fine of Rs. 1 lakh and a default sentence. The Sessions Court’s judgment, confirmed on appeal in Crl. Appeal No. 104 of 2008, upheld the conviction and sentence. The revision petition challenges the legality and propriety of the concurrent judgments, alleging material irregularities in search and seizure, including a contested arrest on 17.06.2004, and that no contraband was recovered as alleged. The petitioner points to the arrest memo Ext.P4 containing the crime number, the time discrepancy, and the seizure mahazar’s lack of a specimen seal, arguing that the link between the seized sample and the lab analysis is not properly established. He relies on judicial dicta, including Rafeeque, Xavier and other authorities, to contend that the investigation was prejudiced by the involvement of a subordinate officer and possible enmity with police officers. The court scrutinizes these contentions and, considering the evidence and defense submissions, finds deficiencies in proof of the chain of custody and the manner of investigation. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed and the accused is acquitted under Cr.P.C. s.235(1).

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.28049 OF 2022

M/S. Confident Projects India Pvt. Ltd. v The District Collector, Thiruvananthapuram; The Sub Collector, Revenue Divisional Office, Kudapanakunnu, Thiruvananthapuram; The Tahsildar (Land Records), Taluk Office, Thiruvananthapuram; The Village Officer, Kadakampally Village, Thiruvananthapuram

This writ petition challenges Ext. P6, a communication by the Sub Collector directing the petitioner to file Form-7 under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Rules, 2008, to change the nature of land in revenue records. The petitioner, M/S Confident Projects India Pvt. Ltd., claims ownership of about 31.07 ares in Survey Nos. 1285/2-1-1-2-1 and 1285/2-1 in Kadakampally Village, Thiruvananthapuram Taluk. The land is dry in reality, but revenue records classify it as Nilam. The petitioner had, relying on Ext. P2, permission dated 04.12.2015 under Clause 6(2) of the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967, to use the land for non-agricultural purposes. Based on that permission, the petitioner constructed a multi-storey apartment complex and obtained Occupancy Certificates. The petitioner subsequently sought reassessment of land tax under the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961 (Form-A) and entry in the Basic Tax Register. Ext. P6, requiring Form-7 under Paddy Land Rules, is challenged. The Government Pleader contends Ext. P6 accords with Paddy Land Rules; however, the court notes the petitioner invoked LOUO 1967. The court relies on Joseph Uppani and Iype Varghese to permit reassessment when LOUO orders exist and to limit higher charges under amended Paddy Land law. The writ petition is disposed of with directions to the Tahsildar to decide Ext. P4 in Form-A within six weeks, and Ext. P6 is set aside.

High Court of Kerala
RSA NO. 919 OF 2009

John, S/o Chori v. Meenkamma and Others

This Regular Second Appeal concerns a family-property dispute arising from a will and partition among the sons of Kocheri Chori. The plaintiff, John, seeks a declaration that defendants 1–10 have no right, title or possession in the plaint schedule property, a fixity of boundaries, and an injunction to restrain interference. The father’s Will No. 18/1955 allotted 64 cents of land among three brothers, with John receiving 20 cents (C schedule, item No.5), Jacob 22 cents (B schedule, item No.6), and Joseph 22 cents (A schedule, item No.6). After the father’s death, Jacob pressed for an exchange of C schedule No.5 with B schedule No.6, which John allegedly agreed to, and Mathai was permitted to construct a shed. Subsequently, kudikidappu rights allegedly arose under the Land Reforms Act. The plaintiff claims usufructs from the middle 22 cents and seeks to declare the others have no interest. The Trial Court dismissed the suit on the preliminary issue, holding that an oral exchange is not legally permissible and transfer in completion of an exchange must occur by sale through a registered instrument. The First Appellate Court affirmed. The High Court, applying sections of the Transfer of Property Act and Registration Act (notably 118, 54, 17(1)(b) and 49), held that such an exchange cannot be recognized as valid without registration and that the suit is not maintainable. The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed with costs.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1291/2022

C.K. Rajendran Kambakkaram v. State of Kerala and others

This intra-court writ appeal (WA No.1291/2022) challenges a Single Judge’s order dated 21.07.2022 in WP(C) No.19536/2022, which declined police protection for the 86-year-old appellant, a senior member and President of the Aroor Puthuvaranadu Devaswom Trust. The appellant sought police protection for life for himself and his family and to ensure the implementation of Ext. P1, a decree in OS No.198/2017, decreeing rights related to the conduct of elections of the Devaswom Trust and opening the temple to conduct such elections. Respondents 3–8 allegedly obstructed compliance with Ext. P1, with threats to life and property. The District Court proceedings (AS No.54/2022) are pending before the District Court, Alappuzha. The learned Single Judge and now the Division Bench held that civil disputes involving rights to property and civil remedies should not be resolved by police protection under Article 226 of the Constitution; rather, the civil forum, including execution where applicable, is the proper channel. Citing George Mirante v. State of Kerala, Raman and Others v. State of Kerala, and Kallai Abu v. Sub Inspector of Police, the court emphasized that police intervention is a last resort and cannot adjudicate civil rights. The writ appeal is dismissed; the appellant must pursue relief through the civil court and execution channels.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C.8260/2023

null

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C.8260/2023) decided by Justice P. V. Kunhikrishnan. The petitioners, Rajendran Nair, Santosh and Ajith R. Nair, were convicted by the Assistant Sessions Court, Punalur in S.C. No.512/2010 arising from Crime No.92/2010 of the Kunnikode Police Station, Kollam. Their conviction and sentence were the subject of an appeal pending as Crl. Appeal No.115/2020 before the Sessions Court, Kollam. The petitioners sought to quash the proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C. on the basis of a private settlement with the defacto complainant, supported by an affidavit from the victim. The petitioners’ counsel relied on Biju Eappen v. State of Kerala and Another (2010) to justify quashing in light of settlement, and cited Ramgopal and Another v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Another (2021) to bolster the principle. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations but acknowledged settlement. The court, after considering the lexicon of Laxmi Narayan v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019), Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, held that where the dispute is private and non-heinous non-compoundable offences are involved, quashing may be appropriate. The court found the dispute private in nature, accepted the settlement, and allowed the CMP, setting aside the conviction and quashing the proceedings and related appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 23186/2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These writ petitions challenge Government Order G.O.(MS.) No.121/2022 dated 07/07/2022 and the Plus One admission prospectus for 2022-23 in Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools in Kerala. The petitioners, Managers of Private Aided H.S.S. and Vocational H.S.S., contend that the policy reducing the Management Quota to 20% and the requirement that management declare the community to which the school belongs, with 10% reserved for that community on merit, violate Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution and encroach upon the rights of private educational institutions. The State defends the policy as a legitimate executive decision to cure long-standing anomalies and to secure merit-based admissions, especially in a system funded by the state. The Court traces the historical evolution of admission quotas since 1990, reviews precedents on reservation and merit, and examines constitutional validity of community-based quotas for management, secular character of institutions, and the scope of judicial review over policy. The judgment upholds the 20% management quota, but strikes down the 10% community quota as unconstitutional, directing that the corresponding seats be treated as open merit seats and filled through the Centralized Allotment Process (CAP). The petitions are disposed of with these directions, clarifying that admissions already made on declared community grounds remain undisturbed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 6282 OF 2022

AKBAR K.I. v. Union Territory of Lakshadweep

This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by the petitioner-accused Akbar K.I., a retired government employee, in respect of Crime No. 21/2022 registered at Kavaratti Police Station, Lakshadweep. The offences alleged include grave criminal misconduct: criminal breach of trust, forgery, misappropriation, and acquisition of disproportionate assets, under IPC sections 409, 464, 465, 468, 471, 477-A and under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (Sections 13(1)(c), 13(1)(d), 13(1)(e) r/w 13(2)). The petitioner contends that custodial interrogation is not required and seeks anticipatory bail, arguing that his senior medical and pension-related rights would be jeopardized by political rivalry and departmental politics. The respondents, Union Territory of Lakshadweep, through its Standing Counsel, submit that the investigation is at a preliminary stage, that a Section 41A notice was issued but not complied with, and that custodial interrogation is necessary to progress the investigation. The court relies on Sumitha Pradeep v. Arun Kumar C.K (2022) to emphasize that custodial interrogation is only one relevant factor among several for assessing anticipatory bail, including the prima facie case, gravity of the offence, antecedents, risk of tampering with witnesses, and ensuring fair investigation. In the end, the court finds the offences grave and the prima facie case unfavourable to bail, rejects the anticipatory bail, and directs surrender within two weeks, with regular bail possible on same-day disposal if sought.

High Court of Kerala
WP.(C)No.14342 of 2019 & con.cases

Thiruvabharana Patha Samrakshana Samithi v. Travancore Devaswom Board & Others

The case concerns the Thiruvabharana Patha (the ceremonial route for carrying Tiruvabharanam from Pandalam to Sabarimala) and alleged encroachments along its path. The petitioner, Thiruvabharana Patha Samrakshana Samithi, a society dedicated to preserving religious practices, filed WP(C) No. 14342 of 2019 and connected petitions seeking implementation of a 2009 resolution (Ext.P1) directing removal of encroachments on the Thiruvabharana Patha and to ensure the entire encroached stretch is cleared by the end of 2009. The petition asserts encroachments by multiple local residents across several villages and requests the court to order a time-bound survey and eviction, under the guidance of an Advocate Commissioner, and with police protection for the survey team. It also sought the involvement of the Directorate of Survey and Land Records and the Forest Department for surveying the affected forest land. The respondents—State, Travancore Devaswom Board, District Collector and other revenue/road authorities—contend that eviction actions have progressed in some locales under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act and that due process (including mahazar notices and hearings) must be observed, with avenues for statutory appeals. The High Court, after considering the matter on 19.10.2022, disposed of the petitions with directions to issue fresh mahazar-based notices, afford hearing, and complete eviction within fixed timeframes, while safeguarding rights of affected landless SC families in connected cases. The decision emphasizes natural justice, adherence to land and boundary laws, and a time-bound, survey-driven eviction framework to preserve the sacred procession route.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.14103 of 2020

Philip Abraham v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Kochi; Tahsildar, Kanayannur Taluk; Village Officer, Edappally South Village; Sub Registrar, Edappally Sub Registrar; Local Level Monitoring Committee represented by its Convenor; State of Kerala; Corporation of Kochi

The petitioner, Philip Abraham, challenges the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act and Rules made thereunder, contending that two contiguous plots owned by him, purchased via separate deeds before 31 December 2017 and aggregating to more than 25 cents, should qualify for exemption from payment of the fee for changing the land’s revenue nature. The petitioner sought relief by asserting a decision in Sajeev A.V. (Dr.) v. Revenue Divisional Officer/Sub Collector (2023 (5) KHC 245) that, in such circumstances, exemptions may be claimed for contiguous lands despite separate documents. He has submitted Ext.P22 before the Revenue Divisional Officer requesting exemption, and the petition prays for the 1st respondent to consider Ext.P22 in light of the Sajeev A.V. decision. The Special Government Pleader notes a writ appeal against Sajeev A.V. Supra, which was dismissed per Revenue Divisional Officer v Dr. A.V. Sajeev (2023 (4) KLT 331). The court ultimately disposes of the petition by directing the 1st respondent to consider Ext.P22 in light of Sajeev A.V. (Dr.) Supra and pass orders within two months, with any deposited amounts pending final orders.