Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 539 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29143 OF 2010

Harrisons Malayalam Ltd. v. K.K. Ahamed & Industrial Tribunal, Palakkad

This writ petition (WP(C) No. 29143 of 2010) challenges Ext.P4 award of the Industrial Tribunal, Palakkad in ID No. 13/2008, which held that the dismissal of K.K. Ahamed (employee of Harrisons Malayalam Ltd.) was not justifiable and granted reinstatement with 25% back wages. The matter arose after Government GO (Rt.) No. 1065/2008/LBR referred issues whether the dismissal for alleged theft of fuel cards (FC) by the workman was justified and what relief he deserved. The Tribunal, after scrutinizing the domestic enquiry, found the enquiry perverse (not properly conducted) and, upon evaluating the evidence, held that the Management failed to prove the charge. It concluded that the punishment of dismissal was unjustified and ordered reinstatement with 25% back wages. The petitioner-management contended that the Tribunal ignored credible evidence, admitted admissions by the respondent, and should not have ordered reinstatement for a serious misconduct like theft. The respondent supported the award, arguing Article 226 powers should not re‑appreciate evidence and that the Tribunal correctly assessed the facts. The High Court, after thorough perusal of Ext.P4, acknowledged that the enquiry’s findings were perverse but maintained that it cannot re‑evaluate the evidence under Article 226 and, noting that the management had already reinstated the employee, dismissed the petition. The court underscored the principle that interference in departmental matters is limited and cited Phulpari Kumari and Om Pal Singh as authorities cited by counsel. Ultimately, the writ petition was dismissed and the Tribunal’s award stood.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No.216 of 2019

Don Paul v. Tisa Don

The appellant, Don Paul, challenged a Family Court judgment (O.P. No.810 of 2015) from Kottayam at Ettumanoor that dismissed his custody petition but granted the respondent custody of Elena Maria Don, then seven years old, with visitation rights for the father. The Family Court's common judgment, dated 30 January 2019, followed a joint trial in three petitions: OP 810/2015 (custody), OP 1281/2015 (return of gold ornaments and money), and OP 1032/2015 (dissolution of marriage). Evidence included testimony of PW1 and PW2 and documentary Exts; RW1 and Exts B1-B2. The respondent, a dental practitioner, had left the marital home after allegations of cruelty, and now resides with the child at her parental home. The appellant contended that the respondent neglected the child and that he, with the help of his mother, could provide a stable environment; he is unemployed, but asserts his care would be adequate. The respondent argued that cruelty and an unsuitable atmosphere in the home rendered custody with the appellant inappropriate. The High Court, citing Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan and Vasudha Sethi, upheld the Family Court’s welfare-based decision that the mother should retain custody of the child, while granting the father structured visitation and holiday custody to maintain contact. The order also specifies custody exchanges at St. George Church, Thalayolaparambu, with defined timings.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.11398/2012

T.K. Mathew and others v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition challenges alleged unauthorised land acquisition and possession for the Kaippattoor–Pathanamthitta road widening project in Omalloor, Pathanamthitta. The petitioners claim their properties were taken possession by respondents for road construction without following the due process of law and without proper acquisition under the Land Acquisition Act. They seek measures to confirm the present status of the road project, ascertain whether any portions of their land were used for construction without formal acquisition, and, if so, secure compensation. They pray for mandamus relief to ensure fair procedures and to restrain forcible possession until compliance with legal norms. The respondents contend that the road work is already completed and that no properties have been taken for the project. They propose measurement of disputed properties by the District Collector’s office, after which details will be shared with petitioners and they will be afforded an opportunity of hearing. If any property has indeed been acquired, compensation would be paid under the law. The court, after hearing, disposed of the petition by directing measurement, hearing, and expeditious subsequent action, clarifying that compensation will be paid if acquisition is proven.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 5052/2020 & WP(C) 2676/2020

CRL.MC No. 5052 of 2020 & WP(C) No. 2676 of 2020, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

Two connected matters arising from Crime No.1785/2015 at Kottayam West Police Station were heard together: CRL.M.C. No.5052/2020 filed by accused Nos.1,2 and 5 seeking to quash further proceedings, and WP(C) No.2676/2020 brought by the defacto complainant seeking expeditious investigation and submission of a final report. The crux was whether Section 212(6) of the Companies Act, 2013 (read with Section 447) and related provisions bar or impede police investigation into alleged fraud and forgery connected with M/s Roshini Sea Foods, involving forged documents, transfer of shares and properties in the name of relatives of the 1st accused, with IPC offences (120B, 406, 465, 467, 468 r/w 34). The petitioners contended that the 2013 Act creates a special investigation regime and cannot apply to pre-Act acts, and requested quashing. The respondents argued that IPC offences touching company affairs can be investigated by police and that the private complaint cannot be retroactively barred by the Companies Act, especially since the alleged acts occurred prior to 2013. The court held that the acts were pre-2013 and not within the retroactive reach of Section 212(6); it rejected the plea to bar police investigation, distinguished contrary Telangana cases, and emphasized that concurrent offences under IPC and company affairs are permissible. Consequently, CRL.M.C. was dismissed, the investigation was directed to be expedited, and a final report was to be submitted within six months. WP(C)2676/2020 was disposed with a similar direction to expedite investigation.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 896 OF 2023

Iddeenkunhi v. State of Kerala and Chandera Police Station, Kasaragod

Iddeenkunhi, the accused in crime No. 782/2022 of Chandera Police Station, Kasaragod, applies for regular bail under Section 439 CrPC in a NDPS case involving 23.46 grams of MDMA recovered from a car and the accused’s person after a road accident. The prosecution under Section 22(c) NDPS Act contends invocation of a commercial quantity, attracting stringent bail conditions under Section 37. The petitioner argues non‑compliance with Section 50 NDPS Act since the recovery occurred by chance and not on prior information, and asserts a prolonged custody since 07.09.2022 entitles him to bail. The Public Prosecutor disputes the applicability of Section 50, asserting the recovery did not derive from prior information. The case diary shows the discovery followed an accident and the accused was restrained by bystanders; the court notes the recovery was not a result of prior information, i.e., not a “information‑based” search, and therefore Section 50 would not apply. The petitioner’s extensive NDPS antecedents are highlighted, including multiple prior offences and two cases in 2022 involving NDPS. The court reiterates that for bail in offences involving commercial quantity under Section 37, two conditions must be satisfied: reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty and that he will not commit an offence while on bail. Relying on Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and a line of Supreme Court precedents (Paulsamy, Nodira, Abdulla, Mon, Rattan Malik, Niyazuddin, Rajesh), the court finds no such grounds and dismisses the petition. Hence the bail application is denied and the petition stands dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 3243 of 2023

Kannur University v. Kerala State Information Commission and Muhammed Athif.K.K.

This writ petition, filed by Kannur University under the Kannur University Act, 1996, challenges Ext.P7, an order of the Kerala State Information Commission directing the University to furnish information sought by the 2nd respondent, including copies of answer scripts for exams conducted in 2019. The University contends that disclosure under RTI Act would burden its functioning and that Ext.P11, a government circular, plus Ext.P12 interim order, reflect government direction to limit dissemination unless fees are paid; it asserts that RTI-enabled disclosure cannot override university regulations governing revaluation, photocopying, and scrutiny. The 2nd respondent maintains the information is within RTI rights and that the University cannot evade disclosure by constitutional or regulatory shields. The State Information Commission and the government argue that RTI principles apply and that information must be supplied at nominal RTI fees, with no undue burden. The petitioner relies on Kerala Public Service Commission v. State Information Commission (2011) 2 KLT 88 and its affirmation in 2016 SCC, Paras Jain, and related authorities, to contend that RTI cannot be used to compel unfettered or gratuitous disclosure. The court ultimately holds that RTI and University rules are not mutually exclusive, that information must be disclosed under the avenue chosen (RTI or university guidelines), and interim orders are tentative. The writ petition is dismissed with no costs; the information issue requires compliance under applicable law.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.9260 of 2022

K.A. Fanshas v. State of Kerala

This is a regular bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the third accused, K.A. Fanshas, in NDPS Act Case No. 544/2022 of Pantheerankave Police Station, Kozhikode. The prosecution alleges the accused, along with others, were found in possession of a large, commercial quantity of contraband at Oceanic Apartment, Athani Junction, including 31.130 g MDMA, 0.450 g LSD stamps, 0.780 g MDMA ecstasy pills, 2.980 g hashish oil and 11.050 g ganja. The offence is framed under Sections 8 r/w 20(b)(II)(A), 22(b) and 22(c) r/w 29 of NDPS Act. The petitioner contends innocence, asserting he was detained at the apartment only because he could not reach Atholi after attending class; he claims no contraband was recovered from him, and therefore Section 37 NDPS does not bar bail. The Public Prosecutor argues that the scale of the seizure and petitioner’s presence with co-accused indicate complicity, invoking Section 37’s bar on bail for commercial quantities. The court notes the contraband constitutes a commercial quantity and that the recovery details and statements prima facie establish the petitioner’s involvement. It evaluates the twin conditions under Section 37(1)(b): (i) reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty, and (ii) likelihood of not committing an offence while on bail. Relying on Kesari and subsequent authorities, the court finds no such reasonable grounds and dismisses the bail application. The petition is therefore denied.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos.1165 & 1239 of 2023

Bail Applications Nos. 1165/2023 and 1239/2023 (Shibu C.S. v. State of Kerala; Sanoop & Shebeer v. State of Kerala)

Two bail petitions under Section 439 CrPC were heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court on 24 February 2023 arising from Crime No. 48/2023 of Perumbavoor Police Station, Ernakulam, alleging NDPS offences involving MDMA. Accused No.1 Shibu C.S. seeks bail in BA 1165/2023; accused Nos.2 and 3 Sanoop and Shebeer seek bail in BA 1239/2023. The prosecution alleges the transport of 6.95 grams of MDMA in a Mahindra Thar on 12 January 2023. The petitioners contend innocence, argue that the quantity constitutes an intermediate amount not requiring strict custody, and point to lack of involvement in other NDPS offences, making bail appropriate given ongoing investigation. The Public Prosecutor counters by stressing the seriousness of the allegation, the narcotics nature of the offence, and each accused’s criminal antecedents. The court, after perusing the case diary and IO report, notes that the investigation requiring custody has largely concluded and the extra-criminal records are not extremely serious. It concludes that, with stringent conditions, bail is warranted to safeguard personal liberty while ensuring investigation proceeds. The order grants bail to all petitioners subject to conditions including bond, two solvent sureties, no witness tampering, ongoing cooperation, weekly appearances before the IO, no inducement or intimidation, and passport surrender if applicable, with breach risking cancellation of bail.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1197 OF 2023

Satheesan v. State of Kerala

Satheesan, the sole accused in Crime No. 911/2022 of Pudukkad Police Station, Thrissur, seeks regular bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C. in a Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) case, alleging possession of contraband in commercial quantity (21.05 kg of ganja) seized from a car. The car was intercepted at night, following a secret information dump and subsequent search under Section 50 of the NDPS Act; the search occurred between sunset and sunrise, and the petitioner contends that the second proviso to Section 42(1) of the NDPS Act requires the detecting officer to record grounds for belief and convey information to a superior before any such nocturnal search. The Public Prosecutor argues that Section 42 has no application to searches in public places or conveyances, and that Section 43 governs seizures in such contexts. The judge surveys authorities, including Karnail Singh, Sukdev Singh, and Boota Singh, to discuss the evolving jurisprudence on compliance with NDPS provisions, especially in emergencies, where strict writing-down of information may be delayed but not wholly absent. The Court notes the vehicle was a private one, not a public conveyance, and concludes that the case primarily engages Section 42 and 43 interplay. After evaluating the materials and the requirements under Section 37 for commercial quantities (two conjunctive conditions for bail), the court holds that there are no reasonable grounds to believe the petitioner is not guilty or to prevent re-offending, and therefore declines regular bail. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No.6682 of 2023

Ali and others v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under section 482 CrPC, challenging the continuation of prosecution in CC No.1208/2016 arising from Crime No.1046/2012 at Kunnathunadu Police Station. The petition seeks quashing of proceedings against petitioners Ali, Shaheer E.P., and Abdulrahman, who are charged with offences including section 506(1) of the IPC and sections 118(d) and 120(o) of the Kerala Police Act. The prosecution case asserts that the accused, by a conference call, threatened the second respondent to return a golden necklace, creating fear of death. The record shows the parties have arrived at a settlement, with the victim filing an affidavit in support and expressing no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor, while expressing reservations about quashing solely based on a settlement, concedes that the matter is settled between the parties. Relying on the Supreme Court’s decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and the earlier Gian Singh and Narinder Singh line of authorities, the court considered whether quashing non‑compoundable offences is appropriate where the dispute is private and settled. The court found the dispute to be private, accepted the settlement, and allowed the M.C. to quash the proceedings. Consequently, all further proceedings in CC No.1208/2016 are quashed, disposing of the case.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO.391 OF 2022; MAT.APPEAL NO.370 OF 2022; MAT.APPEAL NO.709 OF 2022; R.P.(FC)NO.221 OF 2022; R.P.(FC)NO.54 OF 2023

Mat. Appeal No.370 of 2022 and connected cases; Mat. Appeal No.391 of 2022; Mat. Appeal No.709 of 2022; R.P.(FC)Nos. 221 of 2022; R.P.(FC)Nos. 54 of 2023

These are connected matrimonial appeals arising from orders of the Family Court, Kottayam at Ettumanoor concerning custody of marriage disputes between Bivin John and Minnu Joseph. Mat. Appeal No.370/2022 concerns a challenge to a Family Court order that dismissed a petition for dissolution or nullity and the linked O.P.(Div) No.1022/2018 seeking dissolution; Mat. Appeal No.391/2022 challenges an order granting restitution of conjugal rights on an O.P. filed by the wife Minnu Joseph. Mat. Appeal No.709/2022 involves a cross-appeal by the wife seeking recovery of Rs.15 lakh and jewelry, with the Family Court having allowed partial relief. RP(FC) Nos.221/2022 and 54/2023 revisit maintenance and related orders under the Family Courts Act. On 07.02.2023, during common hearing, the court noted mediation between the parties and recorded a settlement dated 19.01.2023. The court then permitted I.A. Nos. 1 and 2 of 2023 to grant a decree of mutual divorce under Section 10A of the Divorce Act, waiving the statutory six-month cooling-off period, and directed the Family Court to implement the settlement and lift attachments. The matters were disposed of in terms of the settlement, resolving all issues purportedly through mutual consent.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos.62/2018 & 65/2018

M/s Kinfra Export Promotion Industrial Parks Ltd. v. The Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (OSD) Circle-1(2), Kochi; The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-1(2), Kochi

These Kerala High Court appeals arise from a common order of the ITAT Cochin Bench (dated 19 April 2018) in ITA Nos. 354/CoCH/2014 and 338/CoCH/2014, involving assessment years 2008-09 and 2009-10. The assessee, a wholly‑owned subsidiary of Kinfra, received financial assistance under the ASIDE scheme from the Government of India to develop an Export Promotion Industrial Park at Kakkanad, Kochi. The central dispute concerns whether subsidies received under ASIDE and other schemes should be deducted from the asset cost under Section 43(1) and Explanation 10 for computing depreciation under Section 32, or whether they are general grants that should not reduce asset costs. The assessment authorities treated subsidies as amounts met directly or indirectly to asset costs, while the assessee argued the subsidies were general grants for infrastructure, not asset-specific. The court surveys pre‑ and post‑1999 jurisprudence, including PJ Chemicals (1994) and subsequent amendments introducing Explanation 10 and the proviso, and the principle that provisos may modify, qualify, or even be treated as independent provisions. It holds that ASIDE subsidies without asset specificity are generally not deductible from asset cost, but the proviso may permit apportionment across assets if subsidy cannot be tied to a particular asset. Ultimately, the court partially allows the appeals, remitting the matters to the AO to recalculate actual cost, excluding pre‑1999 subsidies, and directed fresh orders for 2009-10, with part in Revenue’s favour and part in the assessee’s favour. The final disposition is “Appeals allowed in part; remitted to Assessing Officer.”

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos. 37/2012, 38/2012, 39/2012, 40/2012, 42/2012

Kerala Cricket Association v. Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax, Range 2, Thiruvananthapuram (ITA Nos. 37/2012, 38/2012, 39/2012, 40/2012, 42/2012)

Kerala Cricket Association (KCA) challenged orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal concerning exemptions under Sections 11 and 12 of the Income Tax Act for a batch of assessment years (2001-02 to 2002-03 on various years). The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench comprising S. V. Bhatti, J. and Bechu Kurian Thomas, J., deliberated ITA Nos. 37/2012, 38/2012, 39/2012, 40/2012 and 42/2012 on 7 December 2022. The core issue was whether KCA’s activities qualify as a charitable purpose under Section 2(15) and thus are eligible for exemption under Sections 11 and 12, in the light of the proviso to Section 12A(1) and the amendments effective from 1 April 2009, as well as the registration regime under Section 12AA. The court notes the change in statutory interpretation of charitable purpose and emphasizes that registration is not automatically conclusive; the assessment must be conducted anew under the revised framework. The judges analogize the dispute to a multi-test series, referencing the Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority decision, Sahney Steel, and Ponni Sugars to illustrate the criteria for income classification (revenue vs. capital) and the need for a fresh, law-compliant evaluation by the Assessing Officer. The judgment ultimately remits the matters for fresh decision, while allowing the appeals in part, guided by the cited authorities.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NOS.797/2022, 824/2022, 430/2022, 431/2022

Mat.Appeal Nos.797/2022, 824/2022, 430/2022 & 431/2022 - Rajan.R v. Bindu Chandra; Rajan R v. Rekhi Raj; Binduchandra v. Rajan R

These four matrimonial appeals arise from orders of the Family Court Kollam dealing with the dissolution of marriage between Rajan.R and Binduchandra and related claims by the wife and daughter for maintenance, return of gold ornaments, and marriage expenses. The trial court’s O.P.1556/2018 directed the return of 35 sovereigns of gold and Rs.1,00,000 cash (plus Rs.15,000) and ordered certain maintenance in other petitions (OP(HM)A/1288/2013 and OP 306/2019). The High Court, in a consolidated hearing on 02.11.2023 and delivered on 07.12.2023, examined the evidence and the Family Court’s findings. It upheld the Family Court’s partial award—return of 10 sovereigns of gold and Rs.15,000 with interest at 6% and Rs.3 lakhs toward marriage expenses to the daughter—to be paid within six months, and rejected larger claims for more gold or higher maintenance. It observed the parties’ ongoing litigation, the husband’s asserted income/assets, and the wife’s evidence, including cross-examination.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 21489 of 2021

DR. ANITHA GOPINATHAN v. STATE OF KERALA & ORS

This Kerala High Court writ petition challenges the in-service quota admission criteria for the NEET MDS 2021 in Kerala. The petitioner, Dr. Anitha Gopinathan, seeks to quash clause 11.7 of Ext. P6 Prospectus, which provides inter-se seniority in service as the criterion for selection and the basis on which the rank list will be prepared. She also challenges Exts. P12 and P13 relating to service-quota candidates. The petitioner asks to be considered in the in-service quota based on her NEET MDS rank (1974) rather than length of service, and for the provisional allotment list to reflect merit according to the NEET MDS 2021 results. The court notes the Apex Court’s decision in Sudheer N. v. State of Kerala (Civil Appeal Nos. 297-298/2015) that merit alone should govern admission within a category, and prima facie finds Clause 11.7 to be inconsistent with that ruling. The State argues, relying on Tamil Nadu Medical Officers’ Association v. Union of India (2021) 6 SCC 568, that Regulation 9(1) of PG Medical Education Regulations, 2000 may permit a separate in-service entry within the State Quota. An interim order staying Clause 11.7 has been in place since 27.10.2021, and the court disposes of the petition by retaining the interim order while keeping other contentions open.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R.No.95 of 2020

Kunhayamu alias Kunhappu (Mahmood Ahammed) v. K. Jayalakshmi and others

Kunhayamu alias Kunhappu (Mahmood Ahammed) challenged a Rent Control revision arising from eviction proceedings under Section 11(4)(ii) of the Kerala Buildings Lease and Rent Control Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Manjeri, had directed the tenant to deposit admitted arrears at Rs. 572 per day from 06.10.2015, after Rs. 2,61,404 had already been deposited, while the landlords sought eviction under the petition schedule shop. The tenant contested the rent figure, arguing Rs. 572 per day rather than Rs. 750, and claimed deposit of arrears was already made. The Rent Control Appellate Authority (District Judge), Manjeri, on 02.06.2020, dismissed the revision petition by rejecting the delay-condonation application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act (619 days) and upheld that the review petition under Section 12(1) had been improperly entertained. The tenant had, in the meantime, sought relief under Section 18(1)(b) of the Act. The High Court stayed E.P. proceedings and heard submissions on the merits and the relevant law of limitation. It examined whether condonation of delay can be entertained by an appellate authority and whether an order under Section 12(1) is appealable. Relying on Katiji, Esha Bhattacharjee and subsequent case law, the court held that the Appellate Authority’s approach was correct and that the challenged order was not appealable. Consequently, the Rent Control Revision is dismissed, upholding the appellate order.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 11488 of 2022

Simon V.J. and Daya.D. v State of Kerala and Others

The petitioners, Simon V.J. and Daya.D., two individuals who served as Upper Primary School Teachers (UPST) at Nellimoodu’s New Higher Secondary School between 2008 and 2011, challenged administrative actions affecting their appointments. They argued that their posts were valid additional posts fixed by student strength and staffing norms and that their appointments (as per Exts. P1 and P3) should have been approved, with related monetary benefits for the service rendered. The State had barred fresh appointments by G.O. (P) 317/05/G.Edn (2005), but the ban was later lifted subject to conditions, notably the execution of a bond by the Manager to appoint teachers from the protected-teachers list in a 1:1 ratio (G.O. (P) No. 10/10, 2010). By the time the petition proceeded, the petitioners had resigned to join government service, leaving their hoped-for approval unresolved and their salaries unpaid. They rely on Moosakutty v. DEO Wandoor (2009) and WA No. 2592/2015 to illustrate instances where approvals prior to 01.06.2011 were accepted and salaries paid. Respondents argued based on Ext. P12 that approval could not be granted absent a bond and that the petition must be dismissed. The Court references WA 2592/2015 and connected cases, and ultimately sets aside Ext. P12, directing reconsideration as if the Manager had executed the bond (GO 10/10) within three months. The decision underscores a purposive interpretation of GO orders and seeks to align past practice with available schemes for approval.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 3866 of 2023

Riyas v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application (B.A. No. 3866 of 2023) by Riyas, the sole accused in Crime No. 747/2022 of Bekal Police Station, Kasaragod, under NDPS Act, seeking regular bail under Section 439 CrPC. The High Court of Kerala, in a 13 November 2023 order by Justice A. Badharudeen, reviewed the earlier dismissal of a prior bail application (B.A. No. 939 of 2023) and the underlying narcotics seizure: 25.33 g MDMA and 6.38 g Hashish Oil from a resort room, plus 49.430 g MDMA on body search. The court examined the validity of search procedures under NDPS Sections 42(1) and 50, noting that information recorded in the General Diary can satisfy Section 42(1), and that body searches, though not shown to comply with Section 50(5)/(6), fall to be considered at trial. The court held that non‑compliance with Section 50 is not mandatory for non-body searches and may be addressed during evidence, but the possession of a commercial quantity gives rise to Section 37 constraints. It adhered to the settled test of “reasonable grounds” for bail under NDPS 37(1)(b), citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and other authorities, and concluded that no such reasonable grounds were demonstrated, especially since the trial is envisaged to be expedited. Ultimately, the court dismissed the bail application, noting that the Special Court intends to complete the trial within five months and that the ratio from Fasil v. State of Kerala does not apply here given the lack of favourable prognosis for bail.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 10612 of 2024 & connected cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a consolidated judgment of the Kerala High Court delivering directions in a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and connected cases) challenging freezing orders imposed by banks and cybercrime authorities under the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal regime. The petitions involve freeze notices/injunctions placed on various bank accounts in the context of alleged online financial fraud and related cyber-crime investigations across multiple states and banks (e.g., Federal Bank, ICICI Bank, South Indian Bank, Canara Bank, Axis Bank, etc.). The court opens by noting the common thread: accounts frozen on intimation from police authorities, with the petitioners seeking relief to unfreeze or limit the freeze to the disputed amount. The bench, under Justice T.R. Ravi, grants interim directions and ultimately disposes of the writ petitions with a uniform set of directions aimed at proportionate relief. The core directive is to confine the freeze to the amount in dispute as indicated in police requisitions, while banks must inform the police if further freezing is required for extended periods, with a proviso that, if no information is received, petitioners may approach the court again. The judgment cites Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC OnLine 661) for the principle of proportional freezing and leaves open rights for further motion if information arises. The decision thereby creates a balanced framework between banking/freezing powers and due process protections for account-holders.

High Court of Kerala
OP(Crl.) No. 217 of 2023

Riyas T.V., Muhammed Salih P.K. and Jaffer Rahman N.V. v. State of Kerala and Sub Divisional Magistrate, Kozhikode (OP(Crl.) No. 217 of 2023)

This original petition challenges Exts. P5 and P6 proceedings initiated by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Kozhikode under sections 107 read with 111 CrPC, seeking to compel a bond or imprisonment for alleged breach of peace and related actions in Crime Nos. 131/2022 and 396/2022. The petitioners contend that Ext. P6 is illegal and arbitrary, and that Ext. P5 fails to disclose the substance of information and the basis for action, rendering the orders unsustainable. The Kerala High Court assesses whether the SDM’s order complied with the mandatory requirements of 107 CrPC and 111 CrPC, noting that an order under 111 CrPC must set forth the substance of the information received, the bond amount, its duration, and the specifics of any required sureties. Citing existing precedents such as Girish P. and others v. State of Kerala (2009) and Bejoy K.V v. State of Kerala (2015), the court reiterates that the information must be disclosed and the decision must reflect an evaluation of truth and necessity to preserve peace. It also references the principle from Moidu’s Full Bench regarding imminent breach of peace. The court concludes that Exts. P5 and P6 do not meet these criteria and quashes the proceedings, allowing the petition and directing quashing of further actions in Exts. P5 and P6. The judgment is delivered by a Single Judge, P.V. Kunhikrishnan, J.