Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 534 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
B.A. No.6431/22

Bava U. v. State of Kerala & Others

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the 10th accused, Bava U, in Crime No.1989/2021 of Palakkad Town South Police Station, alleging a large conspiratorial murder of Sri. Sanjith, an RSS worker. The prosecution charges include sections 120(b), 143, 144, 147, 148, 341, 302, 109, 118, 201, 212, 465, and 471 r/w 149 IPC, and section 27(3) r/w 7(a)(b) of the Arms Act, 1959. The incident reportedly occurred on 15.11.2021 when the deceased and his wife were struck by an unlawful assembly; the accused are said to have hacked the victim to death with dangerous weapons. The 10th accused is alleged to be a conspirator and a district president of SDPI, with prosecution claiming his role as a “king conspirator” and mastermind, supported by call data records (extensive phone calls and messages) and the accused’s absconding for months. The defense contends that the only alleged act is conspiratorial linkage without material tying him to the crime or conspiracy; emphasizes lack of antecedents and role as a school teacher, and urges liberty under Article 21 with possible conditions. The court considers the relevant materials and, citing the seriousness of the charge, risks to witnesses, and potential prejudice to the prosecution, refuses bail, holding that release would impede justice pending trial.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 986 OF 2023, BAIL APPL. NO. 992 OF 2023

Vijilal V v. State of Kerala; Aswin U v. State of Kerala

These bail applications concern accused Nos.6 and 7 in Crime No.1078/2022 of Kayamkulam Police Station. The High Court of Kerala, in a short order dated 21 February 2023, considers whether Vijilal V and Aswin U should be enlarged on anticipatory bail given the serious offences alleged under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 294(b), 324, 326 and 149. The prosecution charges that on 12 November 2022, the petitioners formed a common unlawful assembly armed with deadly weapons, assaulted the complainant and his friend Manu Sebastian, resulting in grave injuries and a depressed skull fracture. The petitioners contend their complicity is less than that of accused Nos.2 to 4, who had already been granted anticipatory bail, and that there is no allegation that they caused specific injuries to the victims. The Public Prosecutor submits that the weapon allegedly used by the first accused was recovered and that the petitioners shared a common intention to assault. On scrutiny of the case diary, the court finds that the petitioners, after sharing common intention, attacked the victims with a sword and sticks, causing serious injuries. However, invoking parity with accused Nos.2–4 and considering prior bail orders, the court allows anticipatory bail subject to conditions: surrender within ten days, interrogation and identification, bond of Rs.30,000 with two sureties, cooperation with investigation, Wednesday appearances for six weeks, and a clause not to intimidate witnesses or commit offences. The order is signed by A. Badharudeen, J.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos.345/2013 & 400/2013

Mangalanandan and others v Hashim and Shameer Muhammed and The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (MACA Nos.345/2013 & 400/2013)

These two Motor Accidents Claims Appeals arise from a common award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha, dated 23 November 2011, in O.P.(MV) Nos.1863/2006 and 1862/2006, granting compensation for the deaths of Manoj and Subhash in a 2006 road accident involving a private bus and an auto-rickshaw. The appellants, legal representatives of the deceased, contended that the Tribunal erred in the quantum of compensation by underestimating earnings, adopting an inadequate monthly income, and applying a low multiplier. They argued that PW3 (Labour Officer) and PW4 (employer) established the deceased as skilled labourers with higher earning capacity; the Tribunal fixed a monthly income of Rs.3,000 and used a multiplier (17). The respondents disputed negligence by the bus driver, challenged the claimed incomes, and argued the award was not excessive. The High Court, after admitting additional evidence (Ext. A16 showing Subhash’s birth date), re-assessed income at Rs.6,250 per month and increased the multiplier to 18, substituting the Tribunal’s calculation. It invoked the Pranay Sethi guidelines (Constitution Bench decision) to award heads neglected by the Tribunal: funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium, while noting that loss of love and affection and pain and suffering were not payable to the legal heirs. The court directed payment of enhanced compensation with interest at 7.5% per annum, within two months, and left liability on the insurer.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 7783 of 2022

M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. v. State of Kerala & Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd., Crl.M.C. No. 7783 of 2022

On 11 January 2023, the Kerala High Court (Single Judge A. Badharudeen) dismissed a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking to quash Annexure-A3 complaint in C.C. No. 2493/2015 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners, accused Nos. 1 and 3 (M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and another), contended that the second petitioner was merely an employee authorized to sign but had no day‑to‑day control, and that even if a legally enforceable debt existed, the loss due to dishonour had been offset by subsequent payments reflected in Annexure A‑4 (Rs. 34,20,000 via RTGS on 15.07.2016). They further argued that since the substrate of the complainant’s case no longer exists, continuing the prosecution would amount to abuse of process and that quashing the entire proceedings would serve ends of justice. The second respondent countered that Annexure A4 did not relate to the specific cheque involved in the 138 NI case, that many cases under Section 138 remain pending (74 cases) and some were withdrawn after mutual discussions, leaving substantial dues. The court applied the Nagawwa principles and related Supreme Court authorities, noting that the complaint must be examined as a whole and that quashing should be sparingly used. It concluded that the petition was meritless, and the prayer to quash was rejected; the criminal proceedings continue.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.1855 OF 2023

Farooq, Saheer, Faasil, Naufal and Shemeer v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by five accused (Farooq, Saheer, Faasil, Naufal and Shemeer) seeking quashing of proceedings in CC No. 624 of 2015 of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Attingal. The accused faced charges under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 341, 294(b), 323, 324 and 427 arising from an incident on 05.03.2015 at around 9 p.m. sparked by prior enmity with the de facto complainant. The petition asserts a complete amicable settlement between the parties, supported by affidavits filed by respondents 2–5 (Annexures A3–A6), and argues that ending the proceedings would promote peace and permit the parties to move forward. The investigating officer’s report was sought to verify the truth of the settlement and whether any impediment to termination exists. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but did not point to any other fault with the petitioners. The judge surveys the legal framework governing relief under Section 482 CrPC, citing State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and a line of precedents including Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and others, to articulate when quashing is appropriate—primarily for non‑compoundable offences with private character and settled disputes, while excluding heinous offences or those under special statutes. Ultimately, considering the gravity of the offences, lack of ongoing grievances, and the settled facts, the court allows the petition, quashing the Final Report (Crime No. 103/2015) and all further proceedings (CC No. 624/2015).

High Court of Kerala
WA 607/2023; WA 629/2023; WA 637/2023; WA 665/2023

WA Nos. 607, 629, 637 and 665 of 2023 (Writ Appeals Nos. 607, 629, 637 and 665 of 2023)

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment in WP(C) Nos. 7070 of 2022 and 9671 of 2022, concerning the appointment of the Principal of an aided Higher Secondary School at Kandamangalam. Two rival claimants, Sangeetha R. Nair and Rajeswari Devi S, both HSSTs, were in contention for the post after the vacancy on 31.03.2019. The Manager initially appointed the petitioner as Principal-in-charge on 29.05.2019, but the Director of Higher Secondary Education later directed that the fifth respondent be accorded seniority and to give effect to an earlier order (Ext. P6). The crux is the inter se seniority of two teachers in the same grade HSST for the Principal’s post. The learned Single Judge held that Rule 37 of Chapter XIVA KER cannot govern inter se seniority in this context and that seniority should be decided by general principles where no express rule exists, including age-based tie-breakers. The Government and other respondents contended Rule 37 cannot apply to such inter se disputes for Principal appointments, and that general principles, including age, can determine seniority. The High Court upheld the single-judge view, holding that Rule 37 cannot govern inter se seniority here, and that in the absence of a specific rule, general principles should apply. Consequently, the writ appeals were dismissed, sustaining the Director’s and RD’s orders and the fifth respondent’s appointment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P Nos.1474 OF 2017 & 200 OF 2018

Criminal Revision Petitions Nos. 1474 of 2017 and 200 of 2018

This is a Kerala High Court judgment in Crl.R.P Nos.1474 of 2017 (accused 1: Aaremsky Sports and Fitness, represented by Mohammed Shafi with managing partner status) and 200 of 2018 (complainant: P.A. Sadanandan) arising from CC 36/2014 (JFCM-VII, Ernakulam) under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The trial court convicted the accused for dishonour of cheques and awarded sentence: to the firm a fine of Rs.60,000 and to the managing partner Rs.6,10,000 with compensation under Cr.P.C. The appellate court upheld the conviction, but converted the 2nd accused’s substantive sentence to simple imprisonment till rising of the court and reduced the compensation to a fine, with a reduced default sentence. The revision petitions were heard together on 15.12.2023. The Court examined whether the amount borrowed was Rs.5,00,000 in three installments and whether Ext.P1 (a cheque for Rs.6,00,000) was given by the 2nd accused in discharge of that loan. It relied on legal authorities on the effect of signed blank cheques, obligation to rebut Section 139 NI Act presumptions, and the security-cheque principle, while emphasizing that the appellate reduction of sentence was disproportionate. The High Court ultimately set aside the appellate modification, reinstating the conviction, and directed enhanced sentence for the 2nd accused and awaiting execution, while preserving the firm’s conviction and returning balance deposited amounts to the complainant.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 27373/2022

Manappuram Finance Ltd v. Assistant Commissioner, Central Tax and Excise, Thrissur Division, and Joint Commissioner (Appeals), Central Revenue Building, Is Press Road, Kochi

The petitioner, a non-banking finance company registered under GST, filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging Ext.P1, an order in appeal that upheld rejection of its claim for a refund of GST paid on notice pay received by its erstwhile employees. The appellate authority confirmed the original authority’s denial of the refund. The petitioner contends that CBDT Circular No.178/10/2022-GST (dated 3 August 2022) clarifies that amounts recovered as notice pay from employees, paid as penalties or bonds in cases of early departure, are not taxable under GST because they are penalties, not consideration for services. The petitioner argues the Circular should apply to past transactions, as supported by Suchitra Components Ltd. and related jurisprudence (Navnit Lal C. Jhaveri, K.P. Varghese, Madhu Silica, etc.), and that Circulars binding on the GST Department justify retroactive application. It further submits that since the GST Appellate Tribunal is not yet constituted, Article 226 remedies are available. The respondents counter that the petition is not maintainable and that the Tribunal’s constitution or retrospective effect of the Circular must be decided by the Tribunal. The Court ultimately allows the petition, holds Ext.P8 retrospective, and quashes Ext.P1 and related orders, directing the refunds to be reconsidered by the authorities.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1035 OF 2023, BA 1131 OF 2023, BA 1146 OF 2023

Rajeev A.R. v. State of Kerala; A.R. Gopinathan v. State of Kerala; Murthy P.R. v. State of Kerala (Bail Applications in Crime No.1266/2022, Vanchiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram)

This judgment consolidates three anticipatory bail applications (BAIL APPL. Nos. 1035/2023, 1131/2023 and 1146/2023) arising from Crime No. 1266/2022 at Vanchiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, involving alleged large-scale misappropriation by the BSNL Engineers Co-operative Society Ltd. Between 01.06.2019 and 16.06.2020, deposits were allegedly siphoned off through parallel registers and forged Fixed Deposit receipts, amounting to Rs. 44.14 crore, with investigators later suggesting the figure could exceed Rs. 300 crore. Petitions seek anticipatory bail for a former president, secretary, and other office-bearers and staff, who contend they either had no role or acted bona fide, with the 6th accused emphasizing he deposited Rs. 1 crore and even lodged a complaint about the alleged scam. The court examines the seriousness of the offence, the alleged conspiracy, the use of forged documents, and the scale of misappropriation, while noting that the investigation has revealed extensive assets allegedly disproportionate to income. The learned ADGP emphasizes custodial interrogation to unearth details of misappropriation and the alleged unity among accused. The court, following principles that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy to be exercised sparingly, especially in economic offences, ultimately dismisses the bail petitions, permitting arrest and ongoing investigation to proceed to ensure meaningful prosecution.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 20963 OF 2021

Rani Sam and others v. Joint Registrar (General), Department of Co-operative Societies; Assistant Director of Co-operative Audit; Director Board of Punukkannoor Desabhivardhini Service Co-Operative Bank Ltd. and Punukkannoor Desabhivardhini Service Co-Operative Bank Ltd. (represented by the President and Secretary)

This writ petition under WP(C) No. 20963 of 2021 challenges audit objections that the petitioners’ salaries are 'banned' because their appointments were not approved. The petitioners—Secretary in charge, a junior clerk, and an attender of the Punukkannoor Desabhivardhini Service Co-Operative Bank Ltd.—contend that vacancies existed since the bank’s inception and that appointments to existing sanctioned posts should not require ex post facto approval or prior authority, citing Elampal Service Co-operative Bank v. Government of Kerala (2000) (3 KLT 389). The respondents counter that audit objections would be tenable where posts were created or filled without prior sanction and urge dismissal. The court acknowledges that the Elampal principle supports the petitioners but declines to set aside the audit objections outright. Instead, it directs the Joint Registrar (General) to hear the petitioners and the bank’s officials and decide the validity of the objections. If the objections are found unsustainable, the registrar must vacate them and direct prompt disbursement of overdue salaries, within prescribed timeframes. The judgment emphasizes functional necessity of vacancies and the need for an expeditious resolution of audit objections.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC Nos. 4196/2022; 4198/2022; 4201/2022; 4212/2022; 4218/2022; 4226/2022; 4232/2022

Cardinal Mar George Alencherry v. Joshi Varghese and others

The Kerala High Court, in CRL.MCs 4196/2022, 4198/2022, 4201/2022, 4212/2022, 4218/2022, 4226/2022, 4232/2022, heard seven petitions filed by Cardinal Mar George Alencherry seeking exemption from personal appearance under section 205 Cr.P.C. in private complaints before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kakkanad. The petitioner, aged 77 and head of the Syro-Malabar Church with global duties, argued that attendance would cause extreme hardship and disrupt his duties, and that he should be allowed to appear through counsel. The Respondents contended that a person has no vested right to exemption; personal attendance may be required to ensure identity, bail, and cooperation with the trial, and that the court must exercise the discretion cautiously. The High Court reviewed a lineage of precedent, including Bhaskar Industries, TGN Kumar, Rameshwar Yadav, Puneet Dalmia, Mathew, and others, to emphasize that section 205 grants discretionary power to dispense with personal attendance but only in rare, exceptional circumstances with safeguards such as identity undertakings, counsel appearance, and appropriate bail conditions. Ultimately, the court held that no exceptional circumstances were established for first-appearance exemption, and declined the relief. It disposed of all CRL.MCs, while directing the magistrate to decide the pending 205 Cr.P.C applications expeditiously after the petitioner appears and is released on bail, and that exemptions should not delay the trial.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.928 of 2023 and connected cases

W.A.No.928 of 2023 and connected writ appeals (Kerala High Court)

These writ appeals are a consolidated challenge to a common judgment by a single judge upholding elections to the Managing Committee of the Thiruvananthapuram Regional Milk Producers Union (a central cooperative society). The core dispute centers on who may vote in the elections where some member societies were under administrators/administrative committees. The petitioners invoked Section 28(8) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, read with Sections 8A and 20–21, and Rule 44A, to argue that societies placed under administrators should be barred from voting and that only those admitted under Section 8A(4) or properly elected committees could participate. The State and election authorities contended that the non-obstante clause in Section 28(8) overrides other provisions and that voting rights are governed by Sections 20–21 and Rule 44A, or by Section 8A(4) for APCOS admitted before 60 days prior to the election, irrespective of administrator status. The court, after considering arguments and several authorities, held that Section 28(8) is to be read harmoniously and that it only prescribes who may attend general body meetings and contest elections, not who may vote. The bench reversed the single judge on issues B and C, holding that votes cast by delegates from administrator-run APCOS are countable and the results must be declared accordingly. The appeals were disposed with directions to count such votes and to declare the results.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.4013OF2023

Ashok G.S. and Shameer MS v State of Kerala and Rocky

This is a criminal miscellaneous petition (CRL.MC No.4013 of 2023) filed under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam by accused Ashok G.S. and Shameer MS in Crime No.558 of 2023 of Museum Police Station. The accused were charged with offences under IPC Sections 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 506 and 308 read with Section 34. The prosecution alleges that on 14 May 2023, at about 6.30 pm, the accused, acting in concert, intercepted the defacto complainant and attacked him with weapons, causing injuries. The petition argues that the parties have amicably settled their disputes (Annexure A2) and seek quashing of the ongoing criminal proceedings to restore peace and normalcy. The court directed investigation to verify the settlement’s genuineness and to ascertain any prior antecedents of the petitioners. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, but acknowledged no prior complaints against the petitioners. Relying on a line of Supreme Court decisions (cited as State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Parbatbhai Aahir, etc.), the court held that Section 482 CrPC power to quash may be exercised in private, non-compoundable/less serious offences where a genuine settlement exists and there is no public interest to be served by continued prosecution. Given the gravity of the offences, the petitioners’ lack of serious criminal antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the High Court ultimately allowed the petition and quashed the FIR (Crime No. 558/2023) and all further proceedings. Annexure A1 (FIR copy) and related records were quashed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8513 OF 2015

Najeeb v. Secretary, Revenue Department, Government of Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram, and Others

The petitioner, Najeeb, a resident of Poruvazhy Village in Kollam District, challenges Exts.P5 and P6, orders cancel­ing an auction sale of 19.12 Ares of land issued to realize sales tax arrears. The auction, held on 28.02.2008, fixed an upset price of 1,33,840 and the highest bid was 1,60,000, deposited by 18.03.2008. On 27.04.2009, the sale was cancelled on the ground that the upset price and sale amount did not match the land’s market value. The petitioner invoked Section 83(1) of the Revenue Recovery Act, 1890. The Revisional Authority allowed the revision petition on 11.06.2012 and directed that the matter be heard again; by Ext.P3 the Revenue Divisional Officer upheld the cancellation. The Commissioner of Land Revenue directed the Village Officer to submit a valuation report; Ext.P4 indicated the report found the sale in consonance with the notification. Ext.P5, dated 12.03.2014, upheld the cancellation, and Ext.P6, a Government Order, rejected the petitioner’s further revision under Section 83(2) on 06.01.2015. The petitioner argued that the fifth respondent’s valuation of 7,874 per are was far below the fair value, which the Village Officer’s Ext.P4 showed as 22,500 per Are. The Government Pleader contended the Village Officer lacked competence to fix market value. The Court noted the fair value and held that the upset value was miscomputed, citing Senthil Kalidas M. v. RDO to emphasize the circumstances under which a Revenue Recovery sale may be cancelled. In the circumstances, the writ petition is dismissed, and the challenged orders are sustained.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C). No.21060 of 2020

G.K. Renukumar and others v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others

The petitioners, occupying shop rooms in the Chakkuvally Devaswom Shopping Complex under the Travancore Devaswom Board, challenge a series of notices dated 25.08.2020 (Exts. P1–P24) demanding enhanced rent and additional security deposits, issued by the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner, as well as Ext. P25 (22.05.2020) issued by the Board directing fresh tenancy agreements and a 10% annual rent revision. They seek quashing of the notices, declaration that the respondents cannot unilaterally re-fix or enhance rent, and a writ of mandamus to consider rent relief for the Covid-19 lockdown period (April–July 2020). The petition asserts that the Board’s redetermination based on the Delhi Schedule of Rates (DSR) is unjustified, arbitrary, and violates existing agreements and fiduciary duties. The respondents contend that under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, the Board must protect Devaswom properties and maximize revenue through rents, with DS R reflecting market rates; they rely on several constitutional and judicial authorities to justify market-based rent fixation. The judgment recognizes the Board’s fiduciary duty as trustee and cites multiple precedents reinforcing protection and enhancement of Devaswom income, while directing refixation of rent at market rates with due process, after hearing, and Board approval, within stipulated timeframes, with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.33771/2023

M/S. SOUTH COAST SPICES EXPORTS PVT LTD v. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax and Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax

This writ petition challenges notices issued under Section 153C of the Income Tax Act for AY 2015-16 to 2020-21 and the corresponding assessment orders for AY 2015-16 to 2021-22. The petitioner contends that the notices were issued without proper jurisdiction, because Section 153C requires a cited satisfaction note by the Assessing Officer before issuing notices to a person other than the searched person, and the notices in Exts P1–P6 did not indicate such a satisfaction note or DIN. It asserts that the DIN requirement from CBDT Circular No.19/2019 applies to communications and that the lack of DIN renders the proceedings invalid. The petitioner also points to a search under Section 132 in 2021 at a related business and contends that the subsequent assessment orders under Section 153C are unwarranted. The respondents dispute the petition, arguing that the Assessing Officer recorded satisfaction and issued valid notices under Section 153C; the satisfaction notes have been supplied (Ext. P18) and show DIN; the CBDT Circular does not apply to satisfaction notes. The High Court, after examining the records and distinguishing the Bombay High Court decision Ashok Commercial Enterprises, held that the proceedings were not without jurisdiction; the petition is dismissed, with liberty to appeal against the assessments. The decision underscores that the remedy in appellate forums remains available and that 153C proceedings were properly carried out.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No.2558 of 2009

SATHEESH KUMAR V.K. VALIYAZHIKATHU VEEDU v. SAJU S. and State of Kerala

The petition concerns a private complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for a dishonoured cheque of Rs. 84,000 issued by the accused in the course of employment at Yamuna Hotel, Thiruvananthapuram. The Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kollam, acquitted the accused after evaluating Exts. D1–D3 (defence documents) and the absence of corroborative independent evidence supporting the complainant’s wage claim and the alleged employer–employee relationship. The appellant contends the acquittal was vitiated by reliance on Ext. D1, which the appellant admits bears the accused’s signature but which purportedly relates to a dispute settlement with DW1 and a lost cheque; Exts. D2 and D3 allegedly corroborate the hotel’s salary records. The State and the accused counter that no cheque was issued in the complainant’s favour and that the cheque in question was a security instrument, issued during a settlement, with Ext. D1 admitting loss of the cheque. The High Court, per single judge, upheld the acquittal, holding the evidence failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt the accused’s guilt, and noting the presumption under NI Act is rebuttable. It relied on Chandrappa to emphasize deference to the trial court’s findings where two views are possible.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 35181/2015; 17964/2016; 701/2017; 19920/2019; 12888/2020; 12446/2022; 3448/2023

WP(C) Nos. 35181/2015 and connected cases (Nicholas P. Dias; Gemma Mercy Simethy; and others) vs. Thrikkakara Municipality and others

This is a consolidated batch of writ petitions concerning construction, use and occupancy of a multistoried building at Edappally, Kochi, and the related planning approvals in Thrikkakara. Petitioners initially obtained a building permit and occupancy certificates for a commercial building; objections were raised when a proposed change of occupancy to a hospital was sought, against the backdrop of road widening plans for the Edappally-Pukkattupady road. The petitions trace a long sequence of approvals, reviews, and judicial directions, including references to Ext.P3 building permit, Ext.P11 and Ext.P13 judgments, and later Division Bench guidance on seeking variation under the Kerala Town and Country Planning Act, 2016 (Section 67). The court’s central concern is whether occupancy for remaining floors can be considered without awaiting a formal variation of the structural plan, given the petitioners’ assertion that the hospital ceased functioning and that two floors have already been numbered. Relying on a Division Bench decision in The Town Planner v. Joseph Jacob, the court directs the Thrikkakara Municipality to consider the petitioners’ requests for commercial occupancy in accordance with law, while ensuring objectors and other violations are heard. The matter is to be decided within three months from the judgment copy, with notices to all parties.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 1248 of 2022

V.K. Vasudevan Namboodiri v. Assistant Educational Officer, Talipparamba North, Kannur; District Educational Officer, Talipparamba, Kannur; M.P. Madhusoodhanan

This writ appeal (WA No.1248 of 2022) arises from a challenge to an order appointing the Manager of Poomangalam AUP School. The petitioner, V.K. Vasudevan Namboodiri, who had been the approved Manager since 2015, applied for renewal of his appointment after his term expired. The first respondent, the Assistant Educational Officer (AEO) of Talipparamba North, Kannur, without prior notice or hearing, appointed the 4th respondent as Manager. The petitioner challenged this order in a prior writ petition, W.P.(C) No.29771/2021, which the High Court disposed with Ext.P1 directing the 1st respondent to pass orders after hearing both parties and after due notice. Pursuant to Ext.P1, Ext.P2 was issued for hearing on 10/03/2022, but the respondent’s counsel alleges that separate notice and hearing dates were fixed for the 4th respondent, contrary to Ext.P1, and the petitioner was not allowed to compare documents or present submissions, showing alleged bias. The learned Single Judge rejected the bias claim, directing both sides to appear for a hearing on 18/08/2022. On appeal, the court found bias substantiated, and disposed of the writ appeal by directing that the hearing be conducted by an AEO in the district other than the second respondent or by another officer who has taken charge, with the District Educational Officer nominating the appropriate AEO to comply with Ext.P1’s directions. The appeal is thus disposed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.36727 OF 2022

M/S Peacock Rock Products v Union of India & Ors.

The petitioner, Peacock Rock Products, engages in quarrying and mining in Wadakkanchery Village, Thrissur District, and challenges Condition 3 of Ext.P1 (Letter of Intent) and Ext.P2 (Environmental Clearance), which mandates Wildlife Clearance from the National Wildlife Board (NCNBWL). The petitioner contends that the quarry lies 9.41 km from Peechi-Vazhani Wildlife Sanctuary and that the buffer zone as demarcated does not encroach upon the quarry area. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India, the petitioner argues that ESZ restrictions should apply only to the proposed area and not be uniformly extended; hence SCNBWL clearance should not be required for lease if the applicant is otherwise eligible. The Special Government Pleader (SGP) maintains that prior clearance from SCNBWL is mandatory for developmental activities within 10 km of protected areas where final notification exists or is pending, and that the ESZ framework requires careful compliance with MOEF&CC directions and the Standing Committee of the National Board of Wildlife. The petition was heard on 19.12.2022 and the court ultimately disposed of the matter by quashing the SCNBWL clearance condition and directing the respondents to consider the mining lease if otherwise eligible, with the judgment guided by Godavarman and the Goa Foundation guidelines to preserve ESZ norms while balancing mining interests.