Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 535 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 4060, 8175, 8130, 8138 & 7515 of 2023

BA Nos. 4060, 8175, 8130, 8138 & 7515 of 2023

These bail applications arise in Crime 1266/2022 (Vanchiyoor Police Station) from the BSNL Engineers Cooperative Society Ltd. The accused, including SOPHYAMMA THOMAS (4th), PRASAD RAJ (7th), K. MANOJ KRISHNAN (8th), ANILKUMAR K.A (9th/10th), and MINIMOLE I (11th), are directors or staff of the society. The prosecution alleges misappropriation of fixed deposits amounting to Rs 44,14,37,950 by maintaining parallel registers and issuing forged fixed deposit receipts during 2019–2020. The depositors were mostly lower‑income BSNL employees and retirees. The cases address pre‑arrest bail, with the petitioners contending they retired and had no active role; some rely on resignation and lack of direct day‑to‑day management; they claim custodial interrogation is unnecessary as they have cooperated. The respondents argue the misappropriation is substantial, involving group A officers, with evidence such as recovered deposit receipts and the presence of a systemic scheme; custodial interrogation is essential to unearth the money trail and to prevent tampering. The court must balance gravity of the offence with rights of the accused. The Kerala Co‑operative Societies Act, BUDS Act 2019 and related Rules are invoked to explain the regulatory regime; the court ultimately refuses anticipatory bail, holding economic offences of this magnitude require custodial interrogation and governance of the society cannot be exonerated by resignation or retirement. The applications are dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
6223/2013; 5143/2015

Pazhayannoor Grama Panchayat Multipurpose Co-operative Society Ltd v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (General), Thrissur; Mini Reji v. Elanadu Multi-Purpose Co-operative Society Ltd & Others

Two writ petitions, WP(C) Nos. 6223 of 2013 and 5143 of 2015, were heard together before a single judge of the Kerala High Court. The first petition, filed by Pazhayannoor Grama Panchayat Multipurpose Co-operative Society Ltd, challenged an order (Ext. P7) of the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies that rescinded a disciplinary penalty imposed on Smt. Mini Reji following a disciplinary inquiry. The Society contends that the Joint Registrar exceeded jurisdiction under Rule 176 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules (KCS Rules) by intervening in a disciplinary process and voiding the punishment, and that Ext. P7 is illegal. In the second petition, Mini Reji seeks to prevent the Elanadu Multi-Purpose Co-operative Society from filling the post of Secretary after her dismissal, and to pursue remedies under the KCS Rules. The court, noting that the Joint Registrar lacks authority to entertain such disciplinary reviews under Rule 176, cites the principle laid down in several precedents (Prakasini v. Joint Registrar; Raveendran v. State of Kerala; Kanjoor Service Co-operative Bank v. Joint Registrar) and declares Ext. P7 impermissible. The judge allows WP(C) No. 6223/2013, sets aside WP(C) No. 5143/2015, and directs consideration of an alternative remedy with appropriate limitation considerations, leaving all contentions open for future proceedings. The decision clarifies the boundaries of official interference in internal disciplinary actions within co‑operative societies.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.2110/2011

MACA No.2110/2011 (OPMV 1690/2006) — Ansar (deceased) represented by Chithu Hameed and others v The New India Insurance Co. Ltd., Perumbavoor

This MACA arises from OP(MV) No.1690/2006 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, seeking compensation for injuries sustained by Ansar in a motor vehicle accident on 22.04.2006. Ansar, aged 25 at the time, later died on 13.01.2017, and his mother Chithu Hameed, along with others, were brought on record as appellants. The Tribunal held that the accident occurred due to the driver’s negligence and that the claimant and driver shared 50% contributory negligence, awarding Rs.8,83,790 with Rs.4,41,895 payable by the insurer (50%). The 3rd respondent insurer contested the findings and quantum. The appellant argued sole negligence by the bus driver, highlighting the driver’s violent turning of the vehicle and resultant head injury to the claimant, supported by Exts. A4 (police charge sheet) and Ext. A3 (vehicle inspection) and challenged the adequacy of compensation. The High Court, applying precedent such as Mammachan v. KSRTC, New India Assurance v. Pazhaniammal, Kajal v. Jagdish, and Pranay Sethi, found the tribunal’s contributory negligence finding unsustainable and held sole negligence by the driver. The Court re-assessed the compensation for long-term disability (100% functional impairment, future prospects) and bystander expenses, arriving at Rs.23,68,190, with the insurer directed to deposit this amount plus interest at 7.5% p.a. The appeal was allowed; delay of 159 days was excluded from interest. The final order clarifies liability and rewards.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.8955/2023

Anil Akkara v. State Co-operative Election Commission & Others

The petitioner, Anil Akkara, a member of the Adat Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd (the 5th respondent), challenged Ext.P1, the election notification for the Managing Committee to be held on 16.04.2023, seeking its quashing, directions to prepare a proper voters list, and a declaration that members possessing Form 6A identity cards issued by the 5th respondent or other cards permitted under Rule 35A(6)(x) should be allowed to vote. He contends that the bank’s bye-laws envisage a ‘representative general body’ under Section 27(2) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, and that Sections 27 and 28 read with Rules 34, 34A and 35A require the elections to the Managing Committee and the Representative General Body to be simultaneous; hence, elections to the Managing Committee alone would be contrary to the Act and Rules. He invokes Nazir Ahmed v. King Emperor to support his view and points to Ext.P5 ministerial statements and Ext.P7 replies to argue that preliminary voters’ lists and identity-card regimes are flawed. The respondents counter that the petition is not maintainable and that post-election remedies exist under the statute; disputes concerning voter lists are to be resolved via an election petition. The court held that the question of simultaneity is examinable in these proceedings but found the provisions directory, not mandatory, and dismissed the petition. It clarified that observations shall not bar a future election petition if warranted, and that disputes may be raised through the statutory channels.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No.3892 of 2023

CRL.M.C No.3892 of 2023

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. challenging the proceedings in Crime No.576 of 2023 of the Cheranelloor Police Station, where the petitioners (Accused Nos. 1 to 4) are alleged to have abducted the complainant and inflicted injuries, with offences including IPC Section 307 and several other sections. The petitioners contend that the parties have settled all disputes, supported by affidavits from the respondents (Annexures A2 and A3). The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the matter has been settled and the parties are living in peace, seeking quashing of proceedings on the basis of compromise. The learned Public Prosecutor opposes quashing, emphasizing that 307 IPC constitutes a heinous offence and that quashing cannot be entertained at the FIR stage; reliance is placed on State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and related decisions, which in turn discuss Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and other precedents. The court reviews the settled line of authority: quashing under Section 482 is permissible primarily for non-compoundable offences with civil character when the dispute is resolved, but not for serious offences affecting society. It notes that final report has not been laid, and, on this ground, is not inclined to quash. The petition is dismissed. The judgment is authored by Raja Vijayaraghavan V, J.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 23028 of 2012; 13853/2013; 14367/2013; 17654/2013; 17780/2013; 21162/2013

WP(C) Nos. 23028 of 2012; 13853/2013; 14367/2013; 17654/2013; 17780/2013; 21162/2013 (Kerala High Court)

This batch of writ petitions, heard together by Justice P. V. Kunhikrishnan, challenges orders directing the petitioners to furnish information under the Right to Information Act, 2005. The petitioners are numerous handloom weavers’ co‑operative societies from Thiruvananthapuram region, who contend they are not “public authorities” and thus RTI obligations do not apply since they are not substantially financed by the government. The respondents include the General Manager, District Industries Centre, PIOs, and several Senior/Junior Co‑operative Inspectors (Handloom) across different circles, with an additional impleaded party JTUC official in some cases. The petitioners rely on the Supreme Court’s Thalappalam SCB Ltd. v. State of Kerala (2013) to argue that cooperative societies, lacking substantial government funding, cannot be compelled to disclose information under RTI. The court, however, aligns with the Apex Court’s reasoning and clearly indicates that the impugned RTI orders cannot stand. It sets aside the orders and directs authorities to act consistent with the Thalappalam dictum, thereby broadening the potential reach of RTI to cooperative societies connected with government schemes where they function as public authorities. The decision clarifies the circumstances under which RTI obligations may extend to non-traditional public bodies.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 16117 OF 2023

KERALA STATE FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES LIMITED v UNION OF INDIA

The petitioner, Kerala State Financial Enterprises Limited, challenges Ext.P12, a directive issued by the 2nd respondent requiring the deposit of 50% of the assessed tax amount as a pre-condition to entertain Ext.P3 appeal under Section 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The underlying dispute arises from the assessment order dated 26.12.2022 under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B for the assessment year 2021-22 and the corresponding demand under Section 156. The petitioner had filed Ext.P3 appeal and a stay petition Ext.P9, but Ext.P12 purportedly conditioned stay on payment of half the demand. The petitioner contends that Ext.P12 is patently wrong and violates settled law, particularly Archana Agencies v. Commercial Tax Officer, which requires reasons for stay orders in taxation matters and cautions against arbitrary financial conditions. The court concludes that Archana Agencies principles are squarely applicable to income tax matters and that Ext.P12 failed to provide any reasons for the deposit condition, rendering it untenable. The judgment sets aside Ext.P12 and directs the 2nd respondent to reconsider Ext.P9 stay petition after hearing, in light of Archana Agencies and other decisions, and to issue notice for a hearing, while keeping coercive actions in abeyance pending the decision. The decision emphasizes fairness, the constitutional mandate under Article 265, and the need for reasons in discretionary tax orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 21811/2024, 21992/2024, 22452/2024, 22878/2024, 22903/2024, 23474/2024, 24566/2024

Batch Writ Petition (Civil) in the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam: WP(C) Nos. 21811/2024, 21992/2024, 22452/2024, 22878/2024, 22903/2024, 23474/2024, 24566/2024

This batch of writ petitions before the High Court of Kerala challenges the academic calendar for the 2024-25 session published by the Director of General Education (Ext. P3) and the accompanying order Ext. P6, which declare 25 Saturdays as working days to make up the minimum 220 instructional/working days. The petitioners contend that Rule 3 of Chapter VII of the Kerala Education Rules (KER) prescribes 220 instructional days and that, while exceptions up to 20 days may be condoned, Sundays, holidays, and other non-working days cannot be treated as working days. They argue this constitutes a policy change in violation of the Kerala Education Act and Rules and that such a change requires the Government’s decision with due process, including stakeholder hearing, and adaptation to the central Right to Education Act, 2009 which sets separate minimums for different classes. The petitioners emphasize the central supremacy of the Right to Education Act over state rules (Article 254 of the Constitution) and rely on Gambhirdan Gadhvi v. State of Gujarat to support central-acts-precedence. The court considers central supremacy, due process, stakeholder consultation, and best interests of the child (UNCRC Article 31) and ultimately quashes Exts. P3 and P6 to the extent they declare 25 Saturdays as working days, directing reconsideration in light of RTE and stakeholder views.

High Court of Kerala
Co.Appl. No.174/2023 in Crl.Compl. No.1/2022 in C.P. No.7/2007

Co.Appl. No. 174/2023 in Crl.Compl. No.1/2022 in C.P. No.7/2007 – M/s Variety Finance & Traders Pvt. Ltd. (In liquidation)

This original jurisdiction High Court of Kerala, sitting as a Company Court, deals with Co. Appl. 174/2023 under Section 227 Cr.P.C. and Rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, seeking discharge of the 7th accused in Criminal Complaint No.1 of 2022 arising from a winding-up of M/s Variety Finance & Traders Pvt. Ltd. (in liquidation). The complaint, under Section 538(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, alleges the ex-directors failed to deliver books and papers to the liquidator and that annexed statements of affairs and lists of suits show non-compliance. The applicant argues discharge on ground of limitation (Section 468 Cr.P.C.) since the last enforcement letter to the ex-directors was 07.07.2014 (Annexure D) and the complaint was filed on 08.08.2022, with Annexure E later issued to circumvent limitation. The respondents contest the discharge, maintaining that delay should not bar the prosecution and that the matter involves non-delivery by officers, continuing violation and abuse of process. The court notes that the complainant’s delay is unexplained, and the complaint is beyond the 3-year period under Section 468 Cr.P.C., as held by the Supreme Court in Sarah Mathew v. Institute of Cardio Vascular Diseases. Consequently, it allows the discharge, holding the criminal proceedings time-barred and ends the case against the 7th accused.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 39299 of 2016

W.P.(C) No. 39299 of 2016

This writ petition challenges Kerala Lok Ayukta Exhibit P9 order dated 18.10.2016, which directed rectification of revenue records and tax for a disputed land in Sy.No.584, Varkala Village. The Lok Ayukta held that the re-survey reduced the original extent of patta land from 11 cents to 2.24 ares (5.53 cents), with the overall adjustment reflecting 3.35 ares (8.274 cents) as the true extent, and directed correction in revenue records to show the total extent and to tax the balance 1.11 ares for the period 2010–2016, giving credit for Rs. 83 already paid. The complainant alleged ownership by him and his siblings and that the original patta remained in the late Gopalakrishnan Nair’s name, with tax receipts supporting their position; the re-survey, however, was said to misrepresent the area and was not aligned with revenue records. The petitioners argued no maladministration and that the Lok Ayukta cannot adjudicate possession or title; they urged remedy by civil suit and rectification through proper channels. The Lok Ayukta concluded there was maladministration in terms of inaction by state authorities and ordered compliance, including rectification of records and tax adjustments. The High Court, while noting the absence of arbitrariness, held that maladministration can include inaction, distinguished a prior Sudha Devi K. decision on facts, and dismissed the petition. The case underscores reconciliation between survey results, revenue records, and timely rectification to ensure accuracy of tax and title.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.1017 of 2023

Vishak K.C. v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Changanacherry Police Station, Kottayam District

Vishak K.C., the first accused in Crime No.3430/2022 of Changanacherry Police Station, approaches the Kerala High Court seeking regular bail under Section 439 CrPC. The prosecution alleges that on 25.12.2022, at about 10:30 p.m., he along with accused Nos. 2 and 3 assaulted the defacto complainant and his friends Lijo and Sony with a common intention, with the first accused using a hand-held axe to strike the complainant, causing serious injuries including a craniofacial fracture, a fracture of the left high parietal bone with minimal pneumocephalus, a nasal septal fracture, and multiple other facial fractures; the second accused is said to have slapped the complainant, while the three accused are claimed to have attacked the complainant with the objective of murder. The prosecution cites offences under Sections 323, 341, 324, 326, and 307 read with Section 34 IPC, with investigation ongoing and a final report likely after custody. The petitioner contends innocence, notes that he sustained serious injuries (e.g., Type II open fracture of the fibula with nerve injury) and points to Annexure A2; he also highlights prolonged custody since 03.01.2023. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing that the main overt act and gravity of the injuries justify keeping him in custody, and cites prior antecedents under Section 15(1) of KAPPA. The court, noting that the final report has been filed and the investigation is near completion, grants bail with stringent conditions mandating bond, two sureties, non-interference, cooperation, regular appearance before the IO, and travel restrictions. The order also refers to the treatment records and the case diary.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(KAT).NO.180 OF 2016

O.P.(KAT).NO.180 OF 2016

This is a Kerala High Court judgment in O.P.(KAT).No.180 of 2016 challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s order dated 25 May 2016 in O.A. No.1644 of 2014. The petitioners, State of Kerala (represented by the Finance Department and General Education Department) and the Directorate of Vocational Higher Secondary Education, contend that the Tamil Tribunal’s directions for pay parity between Laboratory Technical Assistants (LTA) in the Vocational Higher Secondary Education (VHSE) stream and Trade Instructor Grade II in the Technical Education Department are unjustified. The O.A. was filed by the Kerala Vocational Higher Secondary School Lab Technical Assistants’ Union and two LTA members seeking parity with Trade Instructors Grade II, arguing that the LTA post requires higher qualifications and that the duties of the two posts are comparable. The Tribunal held that the two posts are essentially similar in duties and that parity should have been granted, quashing the Government’s revised order and directing fresh consideration. The Government argued that the two posts belong to different streams and that pay fixation is an executive matter. The High Court ultimately agrees that disparate pay scales were unjustified and upholds the Tribunal, while noting that parity decisions are complex and must be grounded in material facts, and directs compliance within four months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 2565 of 2021

V.J. Laly and N.J. Siby v. Vazhapilly Grama Panchayat and Others

The petitioners, residents of Valiyakulam in Vazhapilly Grama Panchayat, challenged the validity of development-related permissions granted to Sowparnika Projects and Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., a private builder, for constructing a flat complex near Chethipuzha Village, Changanassery Taluk, Kottayam district. The dispute traces alleged irregularities in the permit process, including a forged development permit (Ext.P1 vs Ext.P2) and subsequent mining and building permissions (Ext.P3, Ext.P4). By 2017-2018, concerns of illicit sand/earth removal prompted residents to form the Janakeeya Samarasamithi. In response to complaints, the petitioners challenged revised plans increasing units from 74 to 90, leading to directions in a prior judgment (WP No.11135 of 2020, Ext.P28) to grant a hearing and decide within ten days after hearing. The case eventually reached Ext.P39 order (July 2020) issued by the 2nd respondent after a hearing conducted by the Assistant Secretary under Section 183 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, due to the Secretary’s containment in the Covid lockdown. The petitioners alleged violation of natural justice and non-consideration of irregularities. The Kerala High Court, after analyzing the process and relying on precedents on natural justice, held that the delegated hearing and the subsequent order were legally valid; the petition was dismissed, and Ext.P39 and the Tribunal’s Ext.P45 were upheld.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.246 of 2019; R.C.Rev.No.253 of 2019; R.C.Rev.No.268 of 2019

R.C.Rev Nos. 246, 253 & 268 of 2019 (Kizhakke Pulinjoli Rajan v. Cheeram Veettil Santha and others)

This is a common order disposing of three Rent Control Revisions (R.C.Rev. Nos. 246, 253 and 268 of 2019) decided by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The tenants challenged eviction orders under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, which were granted by the Rent Control Court and affirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority on grounds that the landlords bona fide needed the premises for occupation by a dependent family member of a co-owner. The tenants contended that the need was not of a dependent family member of all co-owners; in one case the tenant operated a tuition center, and in another case there were disputes about the suitability of the premises for the contemplated business. The court reaffirmed that bona fide needs must be real, sincere, and not merely a pretext, following decisions of the Supreme Court (e.g., Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath, etc.) and Kerala decisions (Ambika C.; Ammu; Regy V. Edthil; Nalakath Saidali Haji; Kizhakkayil Suhara; Gireeshbabu T.P.; George T.I.). The High Court held the orders valid and disposed of the revisions by dismissing them, but granted time to vacate with conditions: six months for Rev. Nos. 246 and 268, and till March 2023 for Rev. No. 253, subject to affidavits, arrears payment, and compliance with licensing requirements.

High Court of Kerala
R.F.A. No. 509 of 2008

Manojkumar Kalathil v. K. Fousi and K. Fasila

This High Court of Kerala, in Regular First Appeal No. 509 of 2008, concerns a dispute over a specific performance claim arising from an agreement for sale dated 09.08.2005 involving 30 cents in Sy. No. 1281/2 of Valayanad Village and machinery on the plaint schedule property. The plaintiff-appellant Manojkumar Kalathil alleges that Rs.21,00,000 was agreed for the sale, with Rs.10,000 paid upfront and Rs.2,00,000 paid on 15.12.2005, with the balance due by 31.07.2006. The defendants, represented by their mother as Power of Attorney Holder, allegedly failed to provide title documents, permit measurement, and to carry out the sale, and on 22.01.2006 the defendants allegedly attempted to cut trees and remove machinery. On 10.02.2007 the defendants allegedly tried to alienate the property to Sunil Dutt to defeat the sale. The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 73/2007 seeking specific performance; the trial court declined, granting instead a decree for repayment of Rs.10,000 with interest and costs. The appellate court affirmed, emphasizing the plaintiff’s inability to show continuous readiness and willingness to perform, a prerequisite under Section 16 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, as explained by Supreme Court precedents. The court refused to admit additional evidence and dismissed the appeal. The result is a confirmed denial of specific performance.”

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(RC) No. 153 of 2022

O.P.(RC) No. 153 of 2022

This is a supervisory petition under Article 227 challenging orders in R.C.P. No.83 of 2021 before the Rent Control Court (1st Addl. Munsiff), Thrissur, filed by landlords under Section 11(2)(b) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act seeking eviction for arrears of rent. The petitioners-tenants approached this Court to direct expeditious disposal of I.A. Nos. 8 and 9 of 2022 (I.A.8 seeks referral to arbitration under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; I.A.9 seeks appointment of an Advocate Commissioner and civil engineer for measuring area). They also sought to keep in abeyance I.A.3 of 2022 (a landlords’ application under Section 12 to deposit arrears) pending those interlocutory orders. The landlords contended that the eviction petition is not arbitrable and that Section 12 relief cannot be withheld to delay eviction. The Court examined Sections 11 and 12 of the Act, including the proviso to Section 12(2) and Section 12(3), and the arbitration framework under Section 8, aligning with Vidya Drolia to restrict arbitrability in tenancy disputes where exclusive statutory forum exists. It relied on J. Ramkumar v. Ashok Jacob for timelines on deposit and the consequences of non-payment. The petition was dismissed; however, the Rent Control Court was directed to decide I.A.3 within two months, in the light of statutory provisions and case-law discussed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 13018/14

Dr. Shaji Jacob v. Sree Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit & Others

Dr. Shaji Jacob, an Associate Professor in the Malayalam Department of Sree Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit, faced serious allegations of sexually coloured remarks and inappropriate conduct toward female students following an oral complaint by a male student. A Women Complaints Committee (WCC) was formed with a mix of academic and non-academic members, including a technical assistant as chairperson, an Assistant Professor, a court lawyer, an NCC officer, a research scholar, and two other women. The WCC conducted interviews, recorded statements, and issued a notice inviting the petitioner to present his version. The report (Ext.P8) concluded that his conduct fell into categories such as unwelcome sexual remarks, intrusive non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature, interference with work, hostile work environment, humiliating treatment, and violation of professional ethics. Based on the report, the University issued Ext.P9 and later Ext.P11, demoting him from Associate Professor to Assistant Professor and transferring him to another centre, despite the WCC recommending disciplinary action and major penalties only under applicable rules. The petitioner contends that the WCC was not a statutory Internal Complaints Committee and that Ext.P11, which demoted him, was without a proper disciplinary enquiry, rendering it unlawful. The court scrutinizes due process, the status of the WCC, and the need for a proper disciplinary process, citing Vijayakumaran CP to emphasize that a mere ICC report cannot automatically lead to punishment.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl) No. 307 of 2023

Anandhavalli v. State of Kerala & Others

Anandhavalli, mother of the detenu, challenges Ext.P1 detention order dated 10 January 2023 under Section 3(1) KAAPA (Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007), which designates her son as a known goonda. The detenu is in judicial custody in Crime No.625/2022, Kadakkavoor PS, in a NDPS case involving a commercial quantity under Section 22(c) NDPS Act, with Section 37(b) NDPS Act potentially limiting bail. The petitioner contends two grounds: (i) non-application of mind by the detaining authority while passing Ext.P1; and (ii) delay in executing the order. The Government Pleader contends that Ext.P1 sets out reasons and reflects subjective satisfaction lawful under precedent. Relying on decisions such as Dimple Happy Dhakad, Senthamilselvi, and Huidrom Konungajo Singh, the court reiterates that the detaining authority’s satisfaction that the detenu, though in custody, may be released on bail and indulge in prejudicial activity is a matter of subjective assessment grounded in material before it. It is observed that the order, read with the materials, demonstrates application of mind. Regarding delay in execution, the court notes prompt steps to obtain permission and execution within days; a three-day delay is not fatal. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, and the detention order is sustained; the petitioners’ contentions are rejected.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C)NO.16445OF2023

O.K. SAILAJA and Others v KOYILANDY CO-OPERATIVE AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD and Others

Petitioners are six former employees of the Koyilandy Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd (D-2020). They superannuated on dates spanning 2005-2015 after more than three decades of service. They contend that after retirement the Bank secured a Group Insurance Policy with the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) and that LIC’s payout formed the basis for gratuity calculation under Rule 59 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 read with Section 4(2) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The petitioners assert that if LIC has paid only the prescribed ceiling amounts (3.5 Lakhs, 10 Lakhs, 20 Lakhs), the balance gratuity, if any, must be paid in accordance with Sections 4 and 5 of the central Act. They rely on Chandrasekharan Nair G. and Others v. Kerala State Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. and Others (supra), contending that the central provision enables higher gratuity and prevails over the Kerala Rules. The petitioners seek certiorari to quash Exts. P15–P20, a declaration of entitlement to balance gratuity with interest, and a mandamus to effect payment. Respondents contend writ petitions cannot adjudicate higher gratuity under Article 226, that liability to pay beyond the ceiling lies with the employer, and that policy payments may suffice. The court followed Chandrasekharan Nair, held that the central Act prevails, allowed the petition, quashed Exts. P15–P20, directed reconsideration of Exts. P1–P6, and ordered payment of the balance within two months with 6% interest if delayed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 325 of 2020

Badusha v. State of Kerala

Badusha challenges a conviction under Section 22(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) by the Special Judge (NDPS Act Cases), Vadakara, for possession of 35 LSD stamps. The trial court, after examining PWs 1–6 and MOs 1–3, convicted him and sentenced him to 15 years’ rigorous imprisonment, a fine of ₹1,00,000, and an additional six months’ imprisonment in default. The prosecution’s case is that on 19.12.2018, a Sub Inspector of Police, on duty at Mukkam, obtained reliable information about a person supplying intoxicants to KMCT institutions. The officers, with a gazetted officer (DFO PW4) present, conducted a body search with the accused’s body search conducted in the presence of the DFO. 35 LSD stamps were recovered from the accused, sealed and seized; an inventory and later verification by a Magistrate followed, with the contraband sent to the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory where the stamps were confirmed as LSD. The prosecution relied on the seizure and recovery eyewitnesses in addition to Exts.P1–P17. The appellant’s contentions included that no seizure mahazar was drawn at the spot, no sample was drawn from the seized material, the arrest memo lacked the accused’s signature, and discrepancies existed in Exts.P8 and P11 regarding date and place. He also challenged the Section 52A sampling mechanism and asserted inconsistencies in weight. The High Court, applying the Balbir Singh standard of non-mandatory compliance, found no prejudice and upheld the trial court’s reasoning, ultimately dismissing the appeal.