Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 521 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 2792 OF 2010

George s/o Joseph Kodakattu House Pathiriyambam Nadavayal Sulthan Bathery Wayanad District v. State of Kerala (Excise Range Officer, Sulthan Bathery) represented by Public Prosecutor, High Court of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition filed under section 397/401 against the conviction of the revision petitioner for an offence punishable under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The trial court had sentenced George to rigorous imprisonment for two years and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 with a default sentence of six months’ simple imprisonment. The appellate court dismissed the appeal. The petitioner contends that crucial irregularities tainted the process: (i) Ext P1 seizure mahazar lacked a specimen seal or proper description of seals affixed on samples, compromising link evidence between the seized contraband and the sample analyzed; (ii) delays in production of contraband and in investigative steps, including the chemical analysis report prepared on 20.07.1999 but filed only on 21.06.2000; (iii) unexplained custody and dispatch delays of samples (Ext P6/Ext P7) and non-examination of key officials responsible for safekeeping; (iv) lack of proof that the sample reaching the laboratory was the same sample seized. The court cites multiple precedents emphasizing strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities, tamper-proof chain-of-custody, and the fatal consequence of unexplained delays. On such grounds, the High Court allows the revision, sets aside the conviction and sentence, acquits the petitioner, and cancels bail, with refund of any deposit if ordered.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1314 OF 2012

Chinnamma and Others v. K. Mohan and Others

This is a Kerala High Court appeal under MACA No. 1314 of 2012 against a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal Ottapalam award dated 20 July 2011 in O.P.(M.V.) No. 827/2008. The appellants are legal representatives of C. D. Anto, who died in a motorcycle-lorry crash on 05 June 2008. The Tribunal determined 60:40 liability in favor of the driver and awarded ₹2,96,000 as compensation against the owner-insurer. The appellants challenged the Tribunal’s reliance on the presence of alcohol smell and on the scene Mahazar to fix contributory negligence, citing Balan v. Abhiraj, Jose v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd, Vineetha Nair, and Jiju Kuruvila as persuasive authorities that such evidence cannot alone determine negligence; they also pressed for enhanced compensation under Pranay Sethi guidelines. The respondents contended that the driver was primarily liable and challenged the quantum of compensation, including income and dependency heads. The High Court held that alcohol smell alone cannot establish negligence, and that the driver was solely responsible for the accident. Reassessing income at ₹6,500 per month (with future prospects) and applying Pranay Sethi principles, the court increased heads for loss of consortium, estate, and funeral expenses, awarding an additional ₹6,23,850 as part of the revised relief, with interest at 7.5% and directions to pay within two months, subject to any excess court fee.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.No.2679 of 2010

Bhuvanachandran Smitha Bhavan v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Revision Petition challenging an order of conviction under the Abkari Act. The accused were found in possession of 13 litres of arrack at Silk Farm, Anad Village, Nedumangad, which led to a conviction by the trial court under Section 8(1) and (2) of the Abkari Act, with rigorous imprisonment for two years and a fine of Rs 1,00,000. The Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track (Adhoc-II), Thiruvananthapuram, on appeal, sustained the conviction but modified the sentence to one year’s imprisonment and Rs 1 lakh fine, with default imprisonment. The revision petition contends serious procedural flaws: nonproduction of the search memo under Section 31 of the Abkari Act, a hostile independent witness, lack of credible evidence of search and seizure, absence of a specimen seal in the forwarding note, and unexplained delays in investigation contrary to Section 50. The High Court, citing decisions like Ramankutty, Baburaj, Sathi, Vijayan, Nadarajan, Sasidharan, and Daulat Ram, scrutinizes these lapses as potentially vitiating the prosecution case. It ultimately holds that due to nonproduction of the search memo, hostile witnesses, absence of specimen seal, and unexplained delays, the prosecution fails to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed and the accused is acquitted, with bail bonds cancelled and any deposited amounts to be refunded.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.113 of 2012

Sajeev and Bhavani Amma v. The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and others

The appellants, petitioners 3 and 5 in OP(MV) No.1639/2001 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Mavelikkara, sought enhanced compensation for the death of Vijayakumaran Pillai in a motor-vehicle collision on 29 March 2005. The accident occurred when the deceased’s bicycle was struck by an autorickshaw driven rashly by the first respondent; the vehicle belonged to the second respondent and was insured with the third respondent. During pendency, the 1st and 4th petitioners died; the appellants sought to record the legal heirs. The Tribunal held the insurer liable and awarded Rs.5,17,000, deducting 10% for the abated claim of the 4th petitioner and directing the insurer to deposit Rs.4,65,300 plus costs. The appellants challenged the quantum, contending that the tribunal erred in applying a split multiplier and ignoring future prospects, and failing to apply the 30% addition for future prospects as per Pranay Sethi. They argued the deceased, aged 48 and in regular employment, warranted higher dependency compensation, with 1/4 deduction for personal expenses instead of 1/3. The High Court allowed the appeal in part, recalculating loss of dependency to Rs.7,60,500, adding funeral, estate, and loss of consortium heads, and awarding an additional Rs.4,40,500. It directed 90% of the total to be paid by the insurer, with recovery rights against the owner and others preserved; 4th petitioner’s share abated.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1386 of 2020

Arun Cherian v. The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

Arun Cherian, the appellant, was injured in a road accident on 16 March 2018 and sought higher compensation in OP MV No. 517/2018 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Taliparamba. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 5,42,585, which the appellant challenged in MACA No. 1386 of 2020. The appellant claimed he was an electrician earning about Rs. 30,000 per month and that the Tribunal’s notional income of Rs. 9,000 per month under-compensated him. Exts. A5 and A6 (salary certificates) and the testimony of PW1 were relied upon to show his occupation, but the evidence did not conclusively establish Rs. 30,000 per month. The High Court, while not accepting the higher claim, acknowledged that the appellant’s technical avocation warranted a higher notional income than the Ramachandrappa baseline of Rs. 11,500. Citing Rajani (2022) for a robust approach to technical avocation, the court fixed a notional income of Rs. 12,500 per month, and added that seven months would be a reasonable period for loss of earnings due to serious injuries. The appellant suffered a compound fracture of the right femur and other injuries; Ext.X1 shows 1% disability. The court increased compensation significantly under several heads: permanent disability Rs. 25,500; loss of earnings Rs. 87,500; extra nourishment Rs. 9,200; pain and suffering Rs. 50,000; loss of amenities Rs. 30,000, while bystander expenses remained Rs. 600 per day for 46 days. Interest was fixed at 8% (reducing from 9%), with costs on the enhanced amount and a two-month deposit period for payment from the insurer.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos.2985, 2989, 11867 & 13263 of 2023

W.P.(C) Nos.2985, 2989, 11867 & 13263 of 2023

This judgment consolidates four writ petitions challenging the statutory pre-requisites for starting a new B.Pharm college in Kerala. The petitions, filed by two applicant institutions (Sirajul Huda Educational Complex and Ma’Dinussaquafathil Islamiya), question the mandatory nature of obtaining a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the State Government and the consent of affiliation from the University/State authorities as pre-conditions for approval to run a Bachelor of Pharmacy course. The issues revolve around Exts.P12, P8, and P7, which required NOC and affiliation consent, and the central regulatory framework under the B.Pharm Course Regulation, 2014 (Regulation 9) and the Pharmacy Act’s Section 12. The Court, presided by Justice Basant Balaji, recounts prior Kerala High Court decisions and Supreme Court rulings, including W.P.(C) No.15525 of 2018 (which held NOC prerequisites could be struck down) and the Pharmacy Council of India v. Rajeev College of Pharmacy (2022 AIR SC 4321) regarding the mandatory nature of NOC per SC guidance. Ultimately, the High Court allows the petitions, holding that NOC from the State Government is not a pre-requisite for approval of a B.Pharm course, and quashes Ext.P12 (in 2985/2989) and Exts.P7/P8 (in 11867/13263).

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.770 of 2012

Sunitha M.R. and Others v. Abdul Jaleel M.K. and Others

This Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA No. 770 of 2012) arises from a claim filed under the Motor Vehicles Act on the death of Girish in a road accident attributed to a private bus driver. The Kerala High Court, presided over by a single judge, re-examines the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, which had awarded Rs. 16,17,970 with 8% interest. The appellants—Sunitha M.R. and three minor children represented by Sunitha as guardian, and Radha E.—challenge the adequacy of compensation, the income assessment, and the computation heads. The respondents (insurers and the bus owner) contested liability and quantum. The Tribunal was silent on several disputes; the High Court first clarifies income and future prospects, endorsing the 50% enhancement for future prospects per Pranay Sethi and correcting the multiplier to 16 (age group 31–35) while applying a 1/4 deduction for four dependants. It also approves adjustments to funeral, loss of consortium, and loss of estate in light of Pranay Sethi, while striking down heads of pain and suffering and love and affection as impermissible per a later Supreme Court decision. The result is an enhanced compensation of Rs. 7,31,870, to be deposited by the insurers in specified proportions within two months, with liability on the third respondent. The appeal is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
MACA.1265/2012

Raja J. v. Sakthivel, Perumal Nadar & The National Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA No.1265 of 2012) arising from a petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, filed by Raja J., the appellant-petitioner, seeking compensation for injuries sustained in a motor accident on 24 January 2004 near Kundanoor Junction, Ernakulam. The bicycle-rider claimant was hospitalized for about 48 days with multiple surgeries, disrupting his education as a college student. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, awarded Rs. 2,67,880 with 9% interest, finding the respondents liable, with the 3rd respondent (the insurer) contesting the claim. In appeal, the appellant’s counsel urged a higher monthly income, arguing he was 18 at the time and earned through tutoring; he relied on Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd., to argue for Rs.4,500 as monthly income for a similar class of labour; he claimed 15% permanent disability justifying a higher multiplier (18) and recalculated compensation for loss of earnings, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and future treatment. The insurer argued against inflated sums and for keeping Tribunal findings. The High Court allowed the appeal in part, enhancing several heads, and directed an overall enhanced award of Rs.1,08,000 with 8% interest, while confirming other Tribunal findings. The order also prescribed NEFT/RTGS transfer and set-off for any already-paid amounts, with conditions on deposit and court-fee if necessary.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(C) No.391 of 2017 & F.A.O.No.134 of 2017

O.P.(C) No.391 of 2017 & F.A.O.No.134 of 2017

This Kerala High Court (Division Bench) judgment arises from two related proceedings: O.P.(C) 391/2017 (a challenge under Article 227 to an order of the Sub Court, Katappana, regarding impleadment of the petitioner as the second defendant in O.S. No.51 of 2011) and FAO No.134 of 2017 (an appeal from an ex parte decree dated 17.11.2014 in the same suit and related delay condonation). The petitioner, Sreenivasan, claims to have purchased land subject to the suit and hopes to defend the case as a pendente lite transferee and later as a possessor with independent rights under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act and related provisions. The first respondent, Ummer Ali, and the second respondent, E. Jayachithra, oppose the impleadment contending bad faith and contumacious conduct, citing that the impugned injunction and decree were compliance-based, and that the petitioner acted with knowledge of the suit. The court surveys a long line of precedents on impleadment of pendente lite purchasers, liberal construction of Section 146 CPC, and the rights of strangers to come on record, ultimately allowing both the original petition and the FAO, setting aside earlier Sub Court orders, and restoring the suit subject to payment of Rs.15,000 as costs. The judgment clarifies the balance between permitting necessary party participation and preserving the rights of the plaintiff, while imposing cost to compensate the other party for delays caused by the petitions.”

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.848 of 2012

Antony v. V.K. Suresh and The New India Assurance Company Limited and Sreenivasan

This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No.848 of 2012, hears Antony's appeal against a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Perumbavoor) award dated 25.10.2011 arising from a motor accident on 02.04.2005. Antony, the appellant, claimed compensation for personal injuries and total loss of his car, registered KL-7/AK-5683, when a mini lorry driven by the 4th respondent collided with his vehicle on the Aluva–Munnar road. He had already received Rs.3,36,651 from his own insurer (the second respondent) and sought the balance Rs.1,84,015 from the third respondent, insurer of the offending vehicle, arguing that subrogation allowed recovery from the third party. The Tribunal jointly tried O.P. (MV) Nos.1825 of 2005 and 1824 of 2005 and dismissed the MV claim while allowing the personal injury claim. The insurer contends that no further payment is due and that the insurer’s rights under subrogation permit recovery only to the extent of the amount actually paid, while the appellant insists on a double recovery from the third party. The High Court examines the law of subrogation under Section 69 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act, cross-checks precedents (Jacob Joseph v. Devassy; New India Assurance Co. v. Jaya; National Insurance Co. v. M.S. Mohan; Economic Transport Organisation v. Charan Spinning Mills), and agrees that once the insurer has indemnified the insured, the insurer steps into the insured’s shoes and the insured cannot claim again. Result: appeal dismissed; Tribunal’s decision upheld, with costs.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 1698/2021

W.A. No. 1698/2021

This writ appeal challenges the judgment of a learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 26975 of 2021, which dismissed the petition seeking certiorari to quash Ext. P5 and quo warranto to question the authority of the 4th respondent as Vice-Chancellor of Kannur University. The appellants (1) Dr. Premachandran Keezhoth and (2) Dr. Shino P. Jose, members of Kannur University’s Senate and Academic Council respectively, contend that the reappointment of the existing Vice-Chancellor (Dr. Gopinath Ravindran) in 2021 was illegal for not following the statutory and regulatory prerequisites. They argue that Section 10 of the Kannur University Act, 1996 prescribes a detailed appointment procedure and requires compliance with eligibility criteria, including age limits (60 years) and qualifications, and that UGC Regulations 2018 (Regulation 7.3) guided the selection process; Ext. P2/Ext. P5 and the state’s notification purportedly bypassed these requirements. The respondents contend that reappointment is expressly permissible under Section 10(10) of the Act and does not require a fresh selection committee for a second term, citing related case law and UGC regulations. The High Court’s analysis concludes that the reappointment was in accordance with the statute and regulations, and dismissed the writ appeal, maintaining the single judge’s ruling. The court refused to grant quo warranto or certiorari.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2476 OF 2022

Premadasan v. State of Kerala

Premadasan's bail application under Section 438 CrPC was heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitioner, aged 42, was named in FIR No. 79/2022 of Chalissery Police Station, registered for offences under IPC sections 447 (criminal trespass), 324 (hurt), and later 308 (attempt to murder) with the latter added subsequently. The alleged incident occurred on 26.02.2022 at about 9 PM when the accused trespassed into the defacto complainant's house and assaulted him with a steel pipe, causing injuries. The petitioner contends that even if the facts are true, the offense under Sec. 308 IPC is not established; the addition of that section was to facilitate arrest, and there is a family dispute about burial ground. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, but suggested that if bail is granted, stringent conditions may be imposed. The judge acknowledged that the offences are serious; however, delay in lodging the First Information Statement cannot by itself justify denial of bail. Relying on Supreme Court authorities—Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement and Siddharth v. State of UP—the court reaffirmed that bail is the rule and that custodial interrogation should be avoided if not necessary. On that basis, the application was allowed with conditions: appearance before the IO within two weeks; bond Rs. 50,000 with two sureties; weekly appearances; not leave the country; not commit similar offences; and biweekly interrogations on Mondays for 30 days, with potential cancellation if violated.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 828 OF 2022; CRL.MC NO. 1321 OF 2022; CRL.MC NO. 5713 OF 2022

Crl.M.C Nos. 828, 1321 & 5713 of 2022, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These three criminal miscellaneous petitions arise from a dispute that culminated in a Final Report in Crime No. 650/2019 of the Erattupettah Police Station and subsequent proceedings in CC No. 290/2019 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Erattupettah. The petitioners—accused nos. 6 in Cr.MC 828/2022 and accused nos. 1,3,4,5,7 in Cr.MC 1321/2022, along with accused no. 2 in Cr.MC 5713/2022 (Dona Bijo)—seek to quash the Final Report and the CC on the ground that the parties have amicably settled the subject matter. The offences are punishable under Sections 341 and 323 IPC; the common respondent 3 appeared and an affidavit was placed. The Public Prosecutor reported that the dispute has been settled voluntarily and amicably, and the victim agrees to the settlement. The Court relied on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and Lakshmi Narayan v. State of Madhya Pradesh, to reiterate that under Section 482 Cr.P.C. a High Court can quash non-serious offences where there is a genuine settlement to serve ends of justice and prevent abuse of process. The court found the settlement to be voluntary, fair, and satisfying the conscience of the Court, with no public interest impediment. Consequently, the petitions were allowed and the Final Report and subsequent proceedings were quashed against the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.4574 OF 2023

Kalesan B., Anilkumar S. and Jose K. Baby v. Chairman and Managing Director, Kerala State Beverages (Manufacturing and Marketing) Corporation Ltd., and General Manager (Administration), Kerala State Beverages (Manufacturing and Marketing) Corporation Ltd.

This writ petition challenges Ext.P1, a transfer order issued to three KSBC clerks from the Adoor Outlet to Pandalam/Kodumon as part of a disciplinary proceeding. The petitioners argue the transfer is punitive and stigmatic, and thus unsustainable, since Ext.P1 expressly frames the transfer as disciplinary. Respondents counter that the District Audit Team’s Ext.R1(a) report found operational shortcomings at the Adoor Outlet, including a non-functioning local counter due to staff negligence, and contend the transfers are administrative exigencies rather than punishments; Ext.P1 is therefore not punitive. The court notes Ext.R1(a) does not name the petitioners and that no charge sheet or show-cause notice has been issued, suggesting no departmental proceeding has been initiated against them. While Ext.P1 mentions disciplinary context, the court finds the transfer from Adoor to nearby centres within the same district does not inherently stigmatize the petitioners. Relying on Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner and State of Kerala v. Balakrishnan, the court emphasizes that orders must be judged on the reasons stated and cannot be supplemented by extraneous materials, and that a transfer in administrative exigencies may be permissible absent legal malafide. The writ petition is dismissed, upholding Ext.P1.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C 4079 of 2016; CRL.M.C 4148 of 2016

CRL.M.C Nos. 4079 of 2016 and 4148 of 2016, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These two criminal miscellaneous matters challenge orders taking cognizance in CMP 6264/2008 and CC 34/2012 arising from a private complaint by the first respondent Gayathri against police officers. The petitioners, accused Nos. 1–3 in CC 34/2012, seek quashing on grounds that cognizance was taken under Section 343 IPC read with Section 34 IPC without sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C. The thrust is whether the acts alleged – including illegal detention and alleged assault in custody – fall within the discharge of official duties, such that prosecution would require sanction under 197 Cr.P.C. The petitioners place reliance on a commission report and human rights inquiries to argue illegal detention occurred between 11.11.2008 and 15.11.2008, with arrest recorded only on 15.11.2008. The respondents argue cognizance for the offences is valid and sanction is not a prerequisite if the act is connected with official duties. The court surveys Supreme Court precedents on Section 197 protection, the 24-hour detention rule under Section 57 Cr.P.C, and the need for sanction when duties are involved. It ultimately dismisses the petitions, clarifying that observations pertain to the inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and do not decide the merits.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.7123/21

Babu K.P. v. State of Kerala & Others

The petitioner, Babu K.P., a physical education teacher, seeks correction of his date of birth in his service book and related records. According to the service records and the SSLC book, his date of birth is 20.05.1966, but he contends that his actual date of birth is 17.04.1968 and should have been recorded accordingly. He joined service on 28.02.2001 and was approved on 28.01.2003. He discovered the discrepancy in 2004 and filed an application for correction on 20.12.2004, which after an initial rejection was allowed by Ext.P5 on 02.02.2021. The Government argues that the correction of date of birth in the service book is governed by G.O.(P) No.45/91 (1991) and a five-year window from entry in service, and that a mere correction in the school records does not automatically entitle correction in the service records. The State also contends that delaying for nearly two decades cannot be condoned, and that the petitioner’s petition is meritless. The court examines Ext.P8 (the 1991 Government Order), Rule 3 of Chapter VI KER, and Rule 143 of Part III KSR, noting the earlier Annamma decision but ultimately upholding Muhammed K.B.’s view that the time spent correcting the SSLC DOB cannot be excluded. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, with no relief granted for correction in the service records.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 8769 of 2021

Ganga Devi C v Regional Cancer Centre and Government of Kerala Health and Family Welfare (J) Department

Ganga Devi C., a Laboratory Technician at the Regional Cancer Centre, challenged a sequence of pay revisions and a post-retirement recovery of funds following the three-men committee recommendations. She joined RCC in 1983 and received early assessment promotions in 1988 and 1992. The TBGP scheme introduced in 1994 allowed her to be promoted to Senior Lab Technician, and the FCP and LP scheme in 2000 continued to grant promotions in a three-step ladder. The pay scales were aligned with SCTIMST and later with the 6th Central Pay Scale; notional fixation and monetary adjustments were made, culminating in a revised scale around 2007 and subsequent government orders in 2009 and 2014. A Three Men Committee examined anomalies, recommended rectification of certain assessment-grade promotions, and suggested fixed pay scales to align with revised pay structures. Although the RCC prepared a report implementing some changes, it did not implement them during the petitioner’s service. After superannuation in 2019, provisional pension was issued and a final pay-fixation order issued in Ext.P15 fixed a lower pay scale and reversed TBGP; recoveries were effected from gratuity and leave surrender. The petitioner challenged these orders, arguing lack of notice and contrary to the policy on pay fixations and recoveries. The State urged that government directives and prior permission were required. The High Court held in her favour, quashing the recovery orders and directing refunds while permitting future refixation with due process.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 9 of 2018

Sheena K. v. State of Kerala and Director, Directorate of Soil Conservation Department

Sheena K., appointed as a Lower Division Clerk in the Soil Conservation Department under a disability quota, challenged her dismissal from service following a finding that her 45% disability certificate was bogus. An initial disability certificate (Annexure A1) had been relied upon for appointment, but a Medical Board examination concluded that the disability was feigned and that the first certificate was not genuine. After the petitioner replied to a show-cause notice, her services were terminated by Annexure A5 and she unsuccessfully challenged the order in Annexure A8 before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT). The Tribunal accepted the Medical Board certificate and held that in cases where fraud is used to obtain employment, the procedure under the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1960 (KCS&A Rules) need not be followed. It relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in R. Viswanatha Pillai v. State of Kerala (2004) 2 SCC 105 to justify termination. The petitioner contended there was no finding that the original certificate was forged and argued that a later reduction in disability cannot invalidate the initial certificate, citing OP(KAT) 66 of 2021, WA No.1265 of 2011, and OP(KAT) 336 of 2015 as authorities. The High Court distinguished those authorities on facts, upheld the dismissal, and held fraud in obtaining employment justifies termination without KCS&A procedure. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.431 of 2022

Prasannakumari P.R. v. State of Kerala and others

This Writ Appeal challenges an order directing finalisation of disciplinary proceedings against the appellant, a headmistress of an aided school, following suspensions and an enquiry conducted by an officer unfamiliar with the prescribed procedure. The Kerala Government and education authorities had sought to proceed under Rule 75 of Chapter XIVA of the Kerala Education Rules (KER), appointing the Additional Director of Public Instruction (ADPI) as the enquiry officer. The appellant contended that such appointment violated Rule 75(1)(b) and that the ADPI’s report (Ext. P36) did not constitute a proper enquiry report, since it did not record charges, evidence, or findings as required, and Ext. P37 directed the manager to finalise disciplinary action based on an invalid report. The Government’s later order, Ext. P37, is attacked as illegal and arbitrary. The Single Judge dismissed the petition, holding that the challenge to the competence of the enquiry officer was premature since the appellant had participated in the enquiry. On appeal, the Division Bench scrutinises the legality of Ext. P35 (appointment of an enquiry officer), Ext. P36 (the report), and Ext. P37 (the Government’s direction). It holds that the appointment was effectively waived by participation and lack of prejudice, relying on H.V. Nirmala and other authorities, but ultimately sets aside Ext. P37 due to non-compliance with Rule 75, and allows the writ petition in part, noting that continuing disciplinary action post-retirement is improper in current circumstances. The matter is thus resolved with a partial win for the appellant and a remnant of the disciplinary proceedings remaining subject to proper compliance.

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO.2252 OF 2019

Contempt of Court Case (C) No.2252 of 2019

Contempt Case (Civil) No.2252/2019 is filed by petitioners who were arrayed as petitioners 1, 3, 5 and 8 in W.P.(C) No.39355/2016 against alleged willful disobedience of the directions in Annexure A to the Kerala High Court’s 12.10.2018 judgment in W.P.(C) No.39355/2016 and connected matters. The petitioners contend that the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) did not implement the directions regarding pension entitlements as interpreted by the Supreme Court in SLPs and connected matters, particularly relying on the judgment dated 4 November 2022 in Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-44 of 2022 (Sunil Kumar B.). The respondents urge reconsideration of higher pension entitlement in light of the Apex Court’s 2022 decision and argue that the authorities should undertake the exercise in accordance with law. The High Court notes that the 2022 Supreme Court judgment read down certain provisions of the pension scheme and extended the amended scheme to exempted establishments, directing a further option and time for exercise under the scheme. Ultimately, the court closes the contempt petition, while reserving the right of EPFO to reconsider the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension consistent with the 2022 Apex Court directives. The decision underscores that the exercise must be undertaken in accordance with law and Article 142 of the Constitution.