Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 520 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C No.2757 of 2023

Criminal Misc. Case No. 2757 of 2023, High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam)

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC, filed to quash Crime No.393/2023 of Kadakkal Police Station, Kollam, in which seven petitioners (Anoop U, Vipin Jith R.S, Akash R.S, Rahul C.S, Vishnu Raj R, Athul R.S, Anand U.B.S) stand charged under IPC sections 143, 147, 294(b), 341, 323, and 149. The prosecution alleges that on 02.03.2023, around 11:30 pm, the petitioners formed an unlawful assembly, restrained the informant and his friend, and inflicted injuries. The petitioners contend that the disputes among them have been amicably settled, supported by affidavits (Annexures 2 and 3), and seek quashing to enable peaceful coexistence. The State/Prosecution opposes quashing, noting some petitioners were deleted from the array and warning against quashing based solely on private settlement, given the serious nature of the offences. The court surveys established law on exercising its inherent power under Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences where private disputes have been settled, citing a lineage of Supreme Court decisions. It holds that quashing is permissible when the dispute is private, the offence is not heinous, and the settlement is genuine, while reserving scrutiny for cases involving serious offences such as Section 307 IPC or offences under special statutes. Applying these tests to the present facts, the court determines that quashing the proceedings would promote ends of justice and reduce waste of judicial time, and accordingly quashes the FIR and all further proceedings against the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 2718 of 2018 & MACA 4060 of 2018

MACA No. 2718 of 2018 & MACA No. 4060 of 2018, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These MACA nos. arise from O.P. (MV) No. 690/2017 before the II Addl. Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode. The claimant Jamshid sustained injuries in a motor-vehicle collision on 10 May 2014 on the Kozhikode–Kannur road, when his motorcycle KL-11 AR 1596 reportedly collided with another bike ridden by the 2nd respondent. The Tribunal found the 2nd respondent negligent and, as insurer of the vehicle, the National Insurance Company Ltd. was held liable, directing payment of Rs 1,90,800 with 8% interest and costs. MACA 2718 challenged the negligence finding; MACA 4060 challenged quantum. The insurer contends that the Tribunal relied on Ext. A1 (a private complaint) and Ext. A7 (conviction) and on Pazhaniammal (supra) to infer fault, while there was no police report or independent corroboration. The High Court noted that a private complaint and a criminal conviction do not by themselves prove causation, and that Pazhaniammal’s observations were not applicable here, given the absence of a police investigation report containing independent witness statements. Consequently, the court held that the Tribunal’s negligence finding could not be sustained and remanded the matter for fresh evidence, with liberty to adduce proof. The appeals were disposed of with directions to appear before the Tribunal on 29 January 2024, for re-adjudication in accordance with law. The quantum aspect will also be readjudicated on remand.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC No. 23 of 2023

THARIK ALI v. ISHAAN A. THARIK

This is a revision petition under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act filed in the Kerala High Court against a Family Court order granting maintenance to a minor child. The petitioner, Tharik Ali (the father), challenges the Family Court’s maintenance quantum of Rs. 15,000 per month for ISHAAN A. THARIK, represented by his mother Rinusa P.A., who filed a maintenance petition under Section 125 CrPC. The Family Court relied on the earlier mutual settlement in O.P. Nos. 2452/2011 and 2447/2011, observed a father’s financial potential, and noted the child’s learning disability, concluding that the father did not fully disclose his finances and that he could meet a higher maintenance figure; accordingly, it fixed Rs. 15,000 per month and recognized the need for care, tuition, and transport. The revision petitioner contends inadequate and seeks reduction, asserting limited income and highlighting the mother’s profession and past abroad employment. The High Court, after hearing both sides and reviewing the evidence, observed that the respondent father possesses substantial income history and financial activities, but also that his financial status has changed. It ultimately modified the quantum to Rs. 13,000 per month from the date of petition, allowing the revision petition in part.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 8287 of 2022

Razak Mether v. State of Kerala & Sarath Kumar

Razak Mether, aged 70, petitioner-accused, challenges a magistrate’s order and a complaint under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, pending in the Special Judicial First Class Magistrate (N.I. Act Cases), Kozhikode. The Cr.M.C. seeks to quash Annexure A4 (order dismissing CMP 3534/2022) and Annexure A1, the complaint in S.T.879/2021. The core dispute is whether a complaint under Section 138 NI Act filed through a Power of Attorney (POA) is valid when the body of the complaint does not explicitly record the POA holder’s knowledge or witness to the transaction, and whether cognizance was validly taken. The petitioner leans on A.C Narayanan v. State of Maharashtra & anr. (first case), which permits POA filings, with the POA holder able to depose and verify if he witnessed the transaction or had due knowledge, while emphasizing explicit assertion of the POA holder’s knowledge. The court also cites Narayanan A.C & anr v State of Maharashtra & Ors. (second case), which lays stringent requirements that the complaint’s body and verification must reflect POA details; Shibu v. Neelakantan and In Re: Expeditious Trial of NI Act cases are cited to explain practice and evidence directions. On balance, the High Court finds cognizance illegal for lack of explicit POA knowledge/witness in the complaint, and allows the Cr.M.C., returning the matter to pre-cognizance, with liberty to file an affidavit under Section 145 NI Act and to proceed with fresh cognizance in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 8270 OF 2023 & 9741 OF 2023

B.A.NOS.8270 & 9741 OF 2023

In B.A. Nos. 8270 and 9741 of 2023, the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam addressed two anticipatory bail petitions under Section 438 CrPC by accused Nos. 1 and 2 in Crime No. 607/2023 of Vidyanagar Police Station, Kasaragod. Accused Nos. 1 and 2, Ismail M.D. and Mahfoose M.D., allegedly conspired with the 3rd accused, the bank manager, to facilitate an illicit loan by forging the defacto complainant's documents and mortgaging property belonging to the complainant, resulting in a loan of Rs. 3,55,23,444 from South Indian Bank, Cherkala Branch. The allegations state collusion with the bank and misappropriation of documents. The petitioners argued that custodial interrogation was unnecessary since the matter involved prior recovery proceedings and the defacto complainant was, by some accounts, aware of the loan; they sought anticipatory bail. The State opposed bail, contending investigation was essential. After hearing both sides, the judge found no necessity for custodial detention but imposed standard conditions: surrender within ten days, bond of Rs. 25,000 with two solvent sureties each, cooperation with investigation, no intimidation of witnesses, and non-commission of further offences while on bail. The court also noted the Apex Court’s principle enabling police to continue investigation even on bail, citing Sushila Aggarwal (2021) 1 KHC 663.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.2831OF2023

Sumesh and Arun v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC challenging CC No. 260/2020 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-II, Palakkad, in which accused Sumesh and Arun are charged with offences under IPC Sections 457, 511 and 380 r/w 34. The prosecution alleges that between 5 January 2020 and 10 January 2020 the petitioners trespassed into the de facto complainant’s unoccupied house, attempted theft, damaged CCTV and bedroom windows, and acted with common intent. The petition argues that the dispute has been amicably settled as evidenced by Annexure-4 and seeks quashing to allow the parties to move forward in peace. The court directed the Investigating Officer to record the victim’s statement, verify the genuineness of the settlement, and assess any impediments to quashing. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing on settlement alone but conceded no other active complaints against the petitioners. Citing Supreme Court jurisprudence beginning with State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and including Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and others, the Court reiterates that Section 482 powers may be invoked where the matter is private in character and the parties have resolved their disputes, while excluding heinous offences or certain public-interest crimes. On weighing the gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the settled posture, the High Court quashes the proceedings: CC No. 260/2020 and all further proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 665 of 2012

H. Aslam v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No. 665 of 2012, heard an appeal by the claimant H. Aslam challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kasaragod award under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, for injuries sustained in a 27.04.2006 accident while riding as a pillion on a motorcycle. The Tribunal held the 1st and 2nd respondents liable, with the insurer (3rd respondent) admitted coverage; the claimant’s plea for enhanced compensation was rejected to some extent. The appeal, heard on 22.02.2022, proceeded largely on fixing income for a young claimant and recalibrating heads of damages. The court noted that the accident occurred in 2004 and that the claimant was a 19-year-old pre-university student. It relied on jurisprudence fixing notional incomes for young claimants (e.g., engineering student/graduate benchmarks) and the established bifurcation of damages into pecuniary and non-pecuniary heads. After assessing medical evidence showing permanent disability (14% whole body, per board), the court applied the 18-year multiplier (as per Sarla Verma and approved in Pranay Sethi) and recalculated compensation for permanent disability, loss of amenities, extra nourishment, and bystander expenses, ultimately awarding an enhanced sum. The insurer was directed to pay within two months, with 7.5% interest from the petition date and excluding interest for 168 days due to earlier condonation. No further relief was granted for delay.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.506 of 2021

W.A.No.506 of 2021 (State of Kerala v. Watchmen in the Kerala High Court Service and others)

This writ appeal challenges pay-parity in the Kerala High Court Service for Watchmen vis-a-vis Watchmen in the Secretariat, wired to the recommendations of the 9th and 10th Pay Revision Commissions. The State sanctioned only the lower scale (Rs. 8500–13210) for High Court Watchmen while granting the higher scale (Rs. 9940–16580) to Secretariat Watchmen, despite an anomaly highlighted by the Chief Justice and subsequent directions. Earlier, the Division Bench had driven parity for Librarians after a chain of contempt and court orders; the 9th Pay Revision recommended parity to the Watchmen, and the 10th Pay Revision reshaped several scales. The Government’s actions, including GO(MS) No. 196/2012 (parity denial) and later GO(MS) Nos. 315/2016 and 215/2017 (framed around Librarians and related posts), were examined against the court’s prior directives. The learned Single Judge held that the parity must reflect the Chief Justice’s original recommendation—i.e., the pay scales applicable before the restructuring under the 9th and 10th revisions—and that the Government could not automatically apply the Secretariat’s restructured scale to the High Court Watchmen. On appeal, the Division Bench affirmed, holding the State must extend the 9th Pay Revision benefits for 01.07.2009–30.06.2014 and the 10th Revision benefits from 01.07.2014 onward. The appeal is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO. 549 OF 2015

Alli v. Babu @ Abraham

Alli, the appellant wife, challenges the Family Court's dismissal of her petition for dissolution of marriage on grounds of cruelty and constructive desertion under Section 10(1)(IX) and (X) of the Divorce Act, 1869. Married on 23 February 2003 under Christian rites, they had a child and lived together until 2008. Alli left the matrimonial home in 2005 and again in 2008 claiming danger to her safety, while she obtained a maintenance decree in 2007 (MC No. 52/2007). In OP No. 165/2010 before the Family Court, Kalpetta, she contended that her husband subjected her to cruel treatment from day one and neglected and misbehaved; she argued the cruelty and desertion were continuing and irretrievably broken the marriage. The respondent denied cruelty and asserted that Alli left of her own accord due to incompatibility and lack of amenities; the Family Court recorded evidence from PW1, PW2, RW1, and Exts A–B; it ultimately dismissed the petition, holding no proved cruelty or desertion. The appellant appealed to this Court. The Kerala High Court, after hearing arguments, allowed the appeal, holding that the marriage had irretrievably broken down, and directed dissolution of the marriage with no costs. The decision relies on Supreme Court dicta recognizing irretrievable breakdown and the possibility of dissolution where cruelty may be on both sides.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.4674/2022

Sajad M.Y v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition, WP(C) No.4674 of 2022, filed by Sajad M.Y., a part-time Lower Grade Arabic Teacher at St. Ambrose LPS, Edavanakkad, challenges the denial of arrears for service from 01.06.2018 to 30.09.2021 and the related Ext.P7 order. The petitioner seeks (i) quashing of Ext.P7 and (ii) mandamus directing arrears to be sanctioned and disbursed, arguing that non-approval and delayed salary contravene statutory duties and constitutional rights, and that exempted status under Ext.P9 for Part-Time Teachers should permit release of arrears without Provident Fund deposit. The petition traces the appointment history, noting the predecessor’s delay in approval and the 2018 approval retroactive to 01.06.2018, followed by a salary freeze until 2021. The Court examines GO Nos. 29/2016 (G.O.(P) 29/2016) and 2011-2016 amendments, the role of Circulars (Ext.P9, Ext.P12, Circular 6/2018/Fin) and the limitations of executive orders to alter statutory pay regimes. It cites precedents emphasizing that salary and pension constitute property and livelihood protected by Article 21 and Article 300-A, and that deference to policy cannot override constitutional guarantees or statutory mandates absent lawful authority. The court ultimately holds in the petitioner’s favor, directing bill resubmission and timely disbursement of arrears, with ongoing compliance to orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 9638/2021

Blue Roots Tech Services LLP v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition (WP(C) 9638/2021) challenges non-payment and alleged balance works in the Rectification of damaged slipway at Ayittikadavu, Payyannur under Ext.P1 dated 05.12.2018, with a contract value of Rs. 27,79,894 and a contractual period of 45 days. After site inspection on 27.11.2019 (Ext.P4) and ensuing communications (Exts.P5, P8, P14), the petitioner submitted bill Ext.P3 for Rs. 29,48,892 and an additional Rs. 4,25,502 (Ext.P2). The 2nd respondent claimed the works were not complete and that Rs.13 lakhs had already been released. The petitioner sought (i) a mandamus to inspect, issue a completion certificate, process bills and release funds; (ii) a mandamus for a work experience certificate; and (iii) other reliefs, including costs. The respondents argued that the dispute is contractual/private in nature and not suitable for writ relief, citing Bridge & Roof Co. (India) Ltd, Jain Plastics, and Kalathil. The court held the dispute arises from a private contract, not a statutory one, and writ under Article 226 is not the proper remedy for adjudicating such contractual disputes; the matter involves factual disputes requiring evidence, to be resolved by civil court or arbitration. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, reaffirming settled law on writ jurisdiction and contractual disputes, with the parties to pursue appropriate remedies.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1163 OF 2017

Pavithran K.V v. Nalinkshan M.V and State of Kerala

Pavithran K.V., the sole accused in S.T.C. No. 274/2006 and the appellant in Crl.A. No. 398/2006, challenges his conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) and the concurrent appellate affirmations by the trial court and Sessions Court. The High Court of Kerala, in a criminal revision under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C., scrutinizes whether the prosecution successfully established a legally enforceable debt and whether the prosecution’s reliance on presumptions under S.139 NI Act was properly rebutted by the defense. A key issue is whether documents purporting to prove the source of funds for the cheque amount should have been admitted; the accused contends that bank details and other evidence showing source are essential, citing M.S. Narayana Memon. The court reviews the scope of revisional power, emphasizing that it is supervisory and not an ordinary appellate review, and that reappreciation of evidence is generally impermissible absent gross miscarriage of justice (citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and later cases like Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan, Kishan Rao, Rangappa, Bir Singh, Kalamani Tex). The court reiterates that once signatures on a cheque are established, presumptions under S.118 and S.139 NI Act operate in favor of the complainant and are rebuttable. It ultimately parts with the conviction, but modifies the sentence: one day simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,30,000, the latter to be paid as compensation under Cr.P.C. with a default imprisonment of three months, and time granted for payment and surrender. The conviction is maintained otherwise, and the filing of the revision petition is partially allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRP(UTY) No.626 of 2017

Dr. R. Janardhanan v. Board of Trustees, Padiyar Homoeopathic College & Others

Dr. R. Janardhanan, a long-serving teacher and former Principal of the Padiyar Homeopathic College, faced suspension in 2013 on charges of misconduct and unauthorised absence. An Enquiry Officer found multiple charges proved (11 proved, 2 not sustainable) and the college dismissed him in February 2016, holding the dismissal would be a disqualification for future employment in University-affiliated institutions. He challenged the dismissal by filing CRP(UTY) No.626 of 2017, which the Kerala Health University Appellate Tribunal dismissed in its order dated 21.10.2017. In the revision petition, counsel for the petitioner confined submissions to proportionality of the punishment, not the findings themselves, arguing that after 24 years of unblemished service, dismissal would inflict undue hardship and forfeit pension rights. The College and Government Pleader defended the punishment as proportionate and necessary to uphold institutional standards. The High Court, recognizing the long service and pensionary interests, relied on established principles limiting punishment and maintaining public ethos. It held that the institution’s objective could be achieved by keeping the delinquent employee out of service beyond the final order, and thus modified the punishment to compulsory retirement from 03.02.2016, with pensionary benefits payable only from 01.04.2022 and with the interregnum not counting towards service. The revision petition was allowed to that limited extent.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.NO.337 OF 2016

Shanavas v. State of Kerala

Shanavas, aged 40, challenges a conviction under Section 379 IPC for theft of a telephone coin-box from Kodampuzha–Thottungal, Kozhikode, in July 2000. The trial court convicted him, sentencing two years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs.10,000, with default imprisonment and an order that Rs.9,000 be paid to the Telephone Department; MO1 (the coin box) was to be handed to the department. On appeal, the Sessions Court affirmed the conviction and reduced the sentence to six months. The revision questions the reliance on recovery under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, contending that the recovered MO1 box (yellow) did not match the stolen item (red). Prosecution evidence includes PW1 and PW3 identifying MO1 as the stolen box, with PW6 (IO), PW4 (an independent witness), and PW7 supporting the recovery and its mahazar Ext. P2. The defense contends the color discrepancy devoid of corroboration undermines the recovery. The High Court scrutinizes Ext. P2, the witnesses, and the color description, noting that the recovered article aligns with the stolen object’s description in essential aspects and is corroborated by other evidence. Citing Muhammed Yousaf @ Sajid, Boby, Suresh Chandra Bahri, and State of Karnataka v. David Rozario, the court discusses the Section 27 requirements and admissibility consequences. Ultimately, the revision is dismissed; the conviction and sentence stand, and MO1 is to be handed to the Telephone Department.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case(C)No.2177 of 2019

K.P. Bhaskaran and others v. Umesh Kumar, Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Sub Regional Office, Kannur

This Contempt of Court Case arises from a petition by the petitioners (retired employees associated with Keltron Component Complex Limited) alleging willful disobedience of directions contained in the Kerala High Court’s judgment dated 12 October 2018 in WP(C) No. 15895 of 2015 and connected matters. The key backdrop is the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) pension scheme dispute, which the Supreme Court addressed in Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO (2022) culminating in a detailed judgment (AIR 2022 SC 5634) that upheld the validity of the 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E)) to the pension scheme and laid out extensions and guidance regarding pension options under paragraphs 11(3) and 11(4) of the pre/post-amendment schemes. The Kerala High Court, noting the 2022 apex court directive, held that petitioners’ claim to higher pension required reconsideration by EPFO consistent with the 2022 decision, and directed the EPFO to undertake this exercise in accordance with law. On 29 September 2023, the court closed the Contempt Case, however preserving EPFO’s right to reconsider petitioners’ entitlement under the apex court’s 2022 directions. The decision sits on a framework of statutory regimes (1965-1990s pension scheme provisions) and constitutional tool (Article 142) to achieve lawful redress.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 667 of 2023; WP(C) 4216/2023

Dhanya R.C v. Board of Directors of ITTIVA Agricultural Improvement Co-Operative Society Ltd and ITTIVA Agricultural Improvement Co-Operative Society Ltd

This appeal arises from a writ petition filed by the appellant challenging the non-reinstatement in service following a suspension connected to a memo of charges in a cooperative society. The petitioner Dhanya R.C., who joined service in 2014 and was promoted to Secretary in 2016, was suspended on 11 July 2022 and faced a memo of charges dated 11 August 2022 (Ext.P3) after which she submitted a reply. An inquiry was conducted and a show-cause notice contemplated punishment of compulsory retirement. The memo of charges was challenged in W.P.(C) No.123 of 2023 on the ground that it was issued by an incompetent authority, resulting in withdrawal of the memo of charges with liberty to proceed afresh. Pending the petition, the respondents withdrew Ext.P3 and sought to reinstate or proceed anew. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petition for reinstatement, allowing only subsistence benefits for the period of suspension. The Appellant contends that withdrawal of the memo renders the suspension void and mandates immediate reinstatement with back wages. The Division Bench distinguishes theMathew joseph case (Mathew (supra)) but ultimately upholds the dismissal of reinstatement, directing completion of disciplinary proceedings within four weeks from the judgment copy, and leaves the door open to fresh action.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1023 OF 2012

Girish Kumar v. Thangal Kunju and National Insurance Co. Ltd. and Reliance General Co. Ltd.

This Kerala High Court motor-accident claims appeal arises from MACA No. 1023 of 2012 challenging an award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kollam, relating to an accident on 12.03.2008. The appellant, Girish Kumar, contends that the respondent 1, Thangal Kunju, rode ahead and applied a sudden brake, causing a rear-end collision for which the insurer respondents were liable for compensation. The Tribunal held the appellant negligent and dismissed the claim, awarding Rs. 72,500 only, on the premise that the appellant contributed to the accident. The High Court, however, scrutinizes the evidence, including Ext. A1 FIR and Ext. A5 wound certificate, and rejects the Tribunal’s conclusion that the appellant was intoxicated merely on the wound certificate’s mention of alcohol smell. It holds that there is no evidence of intoxication within permissible limits and that the Tribunal erred in placing sole liability on the appellant. The Court fixes contributory negligence at 50% by the appellant and revises quantum by adopting a higher monthly income benchmark, following Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq, along with Minu Rout’s authority. The recalculated compensation totals Rs 1,28,100, of which the appellant would receive Rs 64,050. The insurer is directed to deposit the amount with interest at 8% per annum. The appeal is allowed, and the Tribunal’s findings are partly reversed.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(Crl.) No.288/23

N. P. Abdul Nazer v Union Bank of India (erstwhile Corporation Bank) and State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court heard O.P.(Crl.) No.288/23, challenging Ext.P3 dated 16.05.2022, by which the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Manjeri, appointed an Advocate Commissioner to take possession of secured assets under the SARFAESI Act. The petitioner, N. P. Abdul Nazer, contends that Panakkad Agencies is MSME and thus its account could be treated under the MSME Act (notably the 2015 Framework notified under Section 9 of the MSME Act), which would preclude recovery under SARFAESI, RDBA, or IBC, and that the action was vitiated by misrepresentation in Ext.P3. The amended petition sought eleven reliefs including declaring MSME status, voiding the SARFAESI proceedings, and a perpetual injunction against further recovery actions. The respondents countered that the petition is not maintainable, as the Bank had recourse to a Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) for SARFAESI-related remedies; the MSME Act reliefs arose only after registration (02.04.2023) and cannot override the statutory SARFAESI regime. The court examined two issues: maintainability and the MSME framework’s applicability. It relied on Supreme Court rulings that writ petitions challenging SARFAESI are generally to be deprecated in favor of alternate remedies, and held that the MSME Framework is optional and not mandatory to derail SARFAESI. The petition was dismissed, with the court noting that the MSME Act cannot trump SARFAESI and that the remedy before DRT remains appropriate.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.2327/2022

HaneeFa v. State

This is a regular bail application (B.A. No.2327/2022) filed by HANEEFA, the 1st accused in Crime No.105/2022 of Perinthalmanna Police Station, Malappuram, under Section 439 CrPC, challenging an order/judgment in the Special Court (ATROCITIES AGAINST SC/ST), Manjeri. The prosecution alleges that, on 28.01.2022, the accused along with co-accused transported 45.900 kg of ganja in an ambulance (Registration KL 42 H 3673) after hatching a conspiracy, constituting offences punishable under NDPS Act, sections 20(b)(ii)C r/w 29. The applicant argues innocence, absence of criminal antecedents, and prolonged custody without trial (custody since 28.01.2022; over a year and two months). Medical illness is claimed—kidney disease—with supportive isotope renogram evidence. The Public Prosecutor opposes regular bail, citing commercial quantity and the stringent twin conditions of Section 37 NDPS Act. The court cites unreported apex court decisions (Dheeraj Kumar Shukla v. State of Uttar Pradesh, SLP(Crl.) No.6690/2022) indicating that Section 37’s rigour can be diluted where the accused has no antecedents and has spent substantial custody without trial, and references Rajuram v. State of Bihar and Mohd Muslim @ Hussain v. State (NCT of Delhi) to justify dilution under certain circumstances. The judgment also notes the necessity of a broad, non-meticulous assessment (Union of India v. Rattan Malik; Satender Kumar Antil supra). Ultimately, the judge concludes that the petitioner satisfies criteria for diluting Section 37, given the quantity involved and the lack of antecedents, and grants regular bail with conditions such as bond, sureties, witness protection, non-travel, passport surrender, and continuing cooperation with investigators.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.1608 of 2023 and 4048 of 2023

W.P.(C) Nos.1608 of 2023 and 4048 of 2023 (Chettikulangara Devi Temple)

These connected writ petitions challenge Travancore Devaswom Board’s actions relating to Chettikulangara Devi Temple, including Ext.P3 proceedings (board’s order), Ext.P4 bye-laws of Chettikulangara Sree Devi Vilasam Hindu Matha Convention Trust, and Ext.P5 amendments. The petitioners, devotees of the temple, contend that Ext.P3, Ext.P4/Ext.P5 are contrary to the statutory framework under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 and Ext.P1 bye-laws framed under Section 31A(3). They seek quashing, mandamus to constitute a Temple Advisory Committee (Upadesaka Samithi) through the Board’s election process from the registered electorate across 13 karas, and a declaration that the 7th respondent cannot act in the temple’s name. The respondents, led by the Travancore Devaswom Board, contend that Temple Advisory Committees are statutory under Section 31A, to be formed per Ext.P1 bye-laws, and that the 7th respondent may be treated as the apex body for the 13 karas, with safeguards for temple management and finances. The Court, dividing on technicalities, held that the Temple Advisory Committee must be constituted in accordance with Ext.P1, and Clause 3 needs modification to protect the rights of devotees across karas. Ext.P3 and Ext.P5 approvals are set aside; the Board is directed to finalize the new bye-laws and an election plan within three months. The 7th respondent’s bank accounts may be operated with the Administrator’s concurrence and accounting controls, and audit/wealth enquiries remain open. The decision cites several precedents and reserves certain reliefs for later consideration.