Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 512 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.1097 OF 2023

Muhammed Ali P v. State of Kerala and Others

This High Court of Kerala bail application concerns Muhammed Ali P, the accused in Melattur Police Station Crime No. 640/2022, charged under Section 420 IPC. The petition seeks bail under Section 438 CrPC. The prosecution’s case is that in August 2021, the defacto complainant and his friend entered into a sale agreement with the accused for property in Survey No. 232, Edapatta Village, for Rs. 45,00,000, paying Rs. 35,00,000 as advance. Subsequently, on encumbrance verification, it emerged that the accused pledged the property with Perinthalmanna Co-operative Bank for a loan of Rs. 20,00,000 and that the sale agreement was executed with the defacto complainant while suppressing this loan. The petitioner contends that the offence under Section 420 IPC is not made out and that even if true, the matter is civil in nature; OS No.114/2022 is pending before the Sub-Court, Manjeri. The petitioner also claims willingness to cooperate; the defense notes prior directions for interrogation but asserts lack of co-operation and that the civil suit undercuts the criminal claim. The court, after hearing both sides, determines custodial interrogation may not be necessary and relies on the bail principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, citing Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement. Bail is allowed on stringent conditions: appearance before IO within two weeks for interrogation; if arrest is proposed, bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties; no leaving jurisdiction; no inducement; no similar offences; continued cooperation. The order bears the judge’s signature as a Single Judge decision.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No.49 of 2023

M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. v. State of Kerala & Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd.

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. No.49 of 2023) challenging Annexure-A1 complaint in C.C.No.2317/2016 filed before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-XII, Thiruvananthapuram. The petition seeks to quash the complaint under Section 482 CrPC against accused nos.1 and 3: the corporate entity M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and an employee/authorized signatory. The petitioners contend that the second petitioner is merely an employee with no control over day‑to‑day affairs, and that even if a legally enforceable debt existed, the alleged liabilities evidenced by cheques 197119 (Rs.3,42,000), 197120 (Rs.3,42,000) and 197118 (Rs.3,42,000) were discharged by payments totaling Rs.40,00,000 via RTGS on 14.07.2017, erasing the substratum of the case. They also argue that continued prosecution would amount to abuse of process and that quashing the entire proceedings would serve the ends of justice. The respondent states dispute that liability has been discharged and contend that bank remittances do not conclusively prove payment of the exact cheque amounts; evidence is required. The court frames the issue through Nagawwa’s principles on when quashing is appropriate and notes that the power to quash must be used sparingly. Ultimately, the court holds that the complaint cannot be quashed at this pre-trial stage, finds the petition meritless, and dismisses the Cr.M.C., allowing the proceedings in C.C.No.2317/2016 to continue.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1122 OF 2022

Arun J v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal under Section 14A(2) of the SC/ST Act challenging an order dated 17.10.2022 of the Special Judge (in Crl.M.C.2199/2022) that rejected the anticipatory bail petition filed by Arun J., the sole accused. The prosecution accuses the appellant of offences under IPC sections 376(2)(j)(n), 506, 328, 377, 417, along with SC/ST Act Section 3(2)(v)(va) and IT Act Section 66E, arising from alleged intimate relations with a defacto complainant belonging to the Scheduled Caste. The sequence spans 2019 to 2021, including alleged rape, coercion, and use of nude visuals to threaten, with a claimed false marriage in October 2021 and subsequent separation. The defense contends that the intimate relationship matured into a genuine marriage, that the alleged offences are not made out since the first complaint (Annexure-2) does not allege cheating or rape, and that the FIS contains date discrepancies; the marriage is argued to be non-consummated or a ruse to evade consequences. The prosecution argues that the complainant’s caste and the offences alleged create a prima facie case under the SC/ST Act, making anticipatory bail barred by Sections 18 and 18-A. The High Court ultimately holds that the materials show the complainant’s Scheduled Caste status and offences under the SC/ST Act so as to bar anticipatory bail, and dismisses the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC No. 50 of 2022

RPFC No. 50 of 2022

This is a Kerala High Court revision petition under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, challenging the Family Court, Mavelikkara’s order in MC No. 80/2018 which directed maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. The respondents—Shyam Sasidharan’s wife, Reshma Raj, and their minor son Kasinath (Ryan)—had claimed maintenance of Rs.10,000 each per month, alleging the wife’s mental illness, lack of livelihood, and the husband’s desertion. The petitioner contested, arguing the 1st respondent suffers from serious mental illness and that their consent to marriage was obtained by fraud; he also asserted his income was lower than claimed and that the 1st respondent had distanced herself and kept away the 2nd respondent. After disclosures and evidence, the Family Court held that the husband’s notional income should be used and ordered maintenance of Rs.5,000 to the wife and Rs.2,500 to the child from 05.06.2018. Following guidelines in Rajnesh v. Neha and Aditi alias Miti v. Jitesh Sharma, the court directed the parties to file asset disclosures. The Kerala High Court, noting the maintenance scheme as a social justice mechanism and finding no illegality in the order, dismissed the revision petition, while clarifying that the petitioner may seek modification or cancellation in accordance with law. It also instructed adjustment of any deposited amount if applicable.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 14221 of 2021

Deputy General Manager (B&O), State Bank of India, LHO Ernakulam; Chief General Manager, State Bank of India, Local Head Office, Rotary Junction, Poojappura, Trivandrum; Assistant General Manager (HR), State Bank of India, HR Department, Local Head Office, Rotary Junction, Poojappura, Trivandrum; Chief Manager, State Bank of India, MG Road Branch, Ernakulam v. K.V Joy Kollamolath House, Karukapilly, P.O., Kolenchery, Ernakulam-682 311

The petitioners, four officers of the State Bank of India, challenge Ext. P1 – the award of the Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Ernakulam in I.D. No. 17 of 2014 – which directed payment of Rs. 4,50,000 in lieu of reinstatement to a respondent who had served the bank from 7.10.2005 until 3.1.2013. The tribunal found the respondent to be in continuous service and held that his termination violated Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, warranting monetary compensation instead of reinstatement. The petitioners had argued that the respondent was over 45 years old and thus ineligible for permanent appointment, a position grounded on earlier writ petitions that this court had dismissed; they relied on Supreme Court precedents in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi and State of Kerala v. G.V. Chandrashekar to argue that permanent posts should not be granted and that the Administrative Labour Court cannot intervene in bank recruitment. The respondent contends that the termination was illegal and without due process, seeking reinstatement with back wages. The High Court, exercising limited supervisory jurisdiction, rejected a reappreciation of the evidence, upheld the tribunal’s finding of continuous service, and concluded that the compensation awarded was not excessive given the employee’s age and service. The petition is dismissed, leaving the award intact.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12142 of 2021

Indu Memorial Teachers Training Centre v. National Council for Teacher Education & Ors.

Indu Memorial Teachers Training Centre, a National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) recognised institution to run the Secondary (B.Ed) course at Nemmeni, Palakkad, approached the Kerala High Court challenging withdrawal of recognition for conducting B.Ed from the next academic session by Ext. P9, and the related Ext. P1 appellate order. The institution was granted recognition in 2006 to run a one-year B.Ed course in rented premises with a condition to shift to its own building within three years. Despite shifting to Kuzhalmannam and obtaining provisional University affiliation for 2007-2008, the NCTE later issued a 2015 revised recognition under the 2014 Regulations, permitting two units of 50 students each, contingent upon proof of land, building plans and related documents and compliance with norms. In 2019–2020, after show-cause proceedings, the NCTE withdrew recognition by December 2020 on grounds including non-shift of premises, incomplete documents, and non-compliance with norms, despite the Institute asserting it had shifted and provided many documents. The petition contends withdrawal is a drastic, punitive measure taken after a long interval and without proper inspection under Section 13. The judgment surveys the NCTE Act, 1993 provisions (Sections 2, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 32) and the 2014 Regulations, and ultimately quashes the withdrawal, directing inspection and processing of the shifting request under due process.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.9477 OF 2022

Soniya S and Karthika Sreekumar v State of Kerala through its Planning and Economic Affairs Department, Kerala Public Service Commission, and Kerala State Electricity Board Ltd.

This writ petition challenges Ext.P3 GO 2007/PLG order and related provisions governing compassionate appointments in the Kerala State Electricity Board Limited (KSEBL), arguing they violate citizens’ equality rights under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and undermine the petitioners’ right to direct recruitment. The petitioners, who are included in Ext.P2 rank list for posts such as Junior Assistant, Cashier and Assistant Grade II in KSEBL, contend that Ext.P3 allocates 50% of direct recruitment vacancies for compassionate appointments, resulting in appointments of dependents of deceased or disabled employees and thereby defeating fair opportunity for those in the ranked list. They also point to 248 vacancies filled by working arrangements, as per Ext.P14, and assert that higher posts are being sought to be filled by compassionate appointment. The respondents deny that Ext.P3 prescribes any fixed 50% reservation and contend that compassionate appointment is a social security measure permissible as an exception to unbiased selection; KSEBL alleges no vacancies were reported to KPSC. The court clarifies the language of Ext.P3, notes lack of vacancies reported, and holds that the petitioners lack locus standi to challenge the provisions. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed. The judgment recognizes compassionate appointment as a policy tool but rejects the petition’s challenges where no vacancies were reported.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO. 815 OF 2022; MAT.APPEAL NO. 252 OF 2023

Neethu B. v. Rajeshkumar and Rajeshkumar v. Neethu

Two matrimonial appeals (MAT AP 815 of 2022 and MAT AP 252 of 2023) arise from a Family Court, Ottappalam, in OP 129/2020 concerning guardianship and custody of a minor child. The couple, Neethu B. and Rajeshkumar, married in 2011 and a son was born in 2012. They separated and entered into a decree of divorce in 2015 based on a mutual agreement of 2014 which granted the mother permanent custody with the father’s right to meet the child on two Saturdays each month until majority. The mother remarried in 2016 and a second child was born; disputes intensified when she sought to take the child to Malaysia for education and visa purposes, prompting transfer of OP(G&W) 2353/2019 to OP 129/2020 in Ottappalam. The Family Court allowed the petition in part, appointing the mother as guardian but denying permanent custody to her, and permitting limited visitation and travel constraints. The High Court, via a joint judgment by Justice Amit Rawal and Justice C.S. Sudha, held that relocation to Malaysia would not be in the minor’s welfare, criticized the mother’s conduct, and reversed the trial court. It granted permanent custody to the father with specified visitation for the mother (including video calls on alternate days and holiday visits), while restricting overseas travel. The appeals were disposed of with these observations, emphasizing the child’s best interests and stability.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2421 OF 2022

Sivasankarapillai and RadhaKrishnapillai v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 2421 of 2022) filed in the Kerala High Court challenging the cognizance order in ST 277/2021 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kollam. The petitioners, accused nos. 1 and 2, contend that the Magistrate’s order taking cognizance and issuing summons was not properly grounded in material before him, and that there is ambiguity whether cognizance was based on the final police report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C. or on materials produced during inquiry under Section 200 Cr.P.C. Annexure A1 FIR, lodged in 2016 for demolition of a boundary wall, led to a closure report, followed by a protest complaint. Annexure A6 reveals the order sheet that the court took cognizance on 11.06.2021, but the order is silent about the basis of cognizance. The High Court relies on the principles in Parameswaran Nair v. Surendran and Another (2009) to insist that the Magistrate must consider all materials and record proper reasons before taking cognizance and issuing process, and that a second complaint is permissible only for manifest error or miscarriage of justice. The Court finds procedural lacuna and allows the petition, setting aside the cognizance and directing remand for fresh consideration under Section 173(2), in light of the cited principles.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.116 of 2020

Haridasan; C. Asokan; Dinesan N.K. v. Chandran; N. Vinu; Sajith Kumar; Nigeesh Kumar; Poovathil Thottathil Sarojini; Babitha; Jubina; Kuniyil Suseela; P.K. Suneesh Kumar; P.K. Sudheesh Kumar

The petitioners-tenants challenged the order of the Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Vatakara, dismissing their application under the 3rd proviso to Section 11(4)(iv) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 for re-induction into a reconstructed building owned by the respondents-landlords. The Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge, Vatakara) affirmed that dismissal. This Rent Control Revision was heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court on 28 October 2021. Material facts show that cracks developed in 2013 following heavy rainfall; the Tahasildar evicted the tenants and the building was demolished. The landlords reconstructed the first floor and promised to re-induct the tenants. The petitioners invoked the 3rd proviso to Section 11(4)(iv) seeking re-induction, but both the Trial Court and the Appellate Authority held that the proviso applies only to tenants evicted under Section 11(4)(iv) and not to evictions arising from other statutory procedures such as Section 133 CrPC or municipal actions to avert danger. The High Court reviewed the statutory text and relevant precedents, including Thankamma Mathew, George, Narayana Pillai, Porinchu, and later Supreme Court decisions on revisional jurisdiction, and held there is no reason to interfere with the concurrent findings. Consequently, the revision petition was dismissed, upholding the existing orders.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2526 OF 2023

Ramar and others v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court bail matter concerns eight petitioners/accused in Crime No.266/2023 of Munnar Police Station, Idukki, under Section 438 CrPC. The prosecution allege that on 14 March 2023 the accused formed an unlawful assembly with knowledge of its nature and attacked the de facto complainant and his cousin, using a knife and an iron rod; the de facto complainant sustained serious injuries including fractures, and one accused allegedly handed over the knife to another for the assault. The petitioners face multiple IPC charges: 143, 144, 147, 148, 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 326 read with 149. The defense contends that there is also Annexure 2 crime (Crime No.257/2023) with separate injuries, and that truth will emerge during evidence; they assert readiness to cooperate and seek anticipatory bail. The State opposes bail—arguing that the accused used weapons, that the knife was supplied by the 8th accused, and that arrest, custodial interrogation, and weapon recovery are necessary, citing the CT scan evidence of serious injuries. The court, after reviewing records, held that anticipatory bail should be dismissed for accused Nos.1, 2, and 8, while granting anticipatory bail to accused Nos.3 to 7 under strict conditions, including surrender within ten days, bonds of Rs.30,000 with two sureties, cooperation, and non-interference with witnesses. The decision reflects a partial relief disposition.

High Court of Kerala
RFA 194/2008

AFRO ASISAN AGRO PRODUCTS (SINGAPORE) LTD. v. LEKSHMI ENTERPRISES KILIKOLLUR, KOLLAM and others

This Kerala High Court Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 194/2008) arises from a suit for recovery of Rs. 72,40,392.68 with future interest (6%) after a partial counter-claim, linked to eight import contracts for raw cashew nuts sourced from Singapore. The plaintiff Lekshmi Enterprises, a partnership exporting processed cashews, engaged with Afro Asian Agro Products (Singapore) Ltd. for supply of cashew nuts; shipments originated from Abidjan, Ivory Coast. The contracts were CAD terms with 5–10% advance, and Lloyd’s Certification was repeatedly invoked as a condition ensuring quality, quantity, and seaworthiness. The defendant contended Lloyd’s Certification was not mandatory and claimed losses from demurrage and freight; it relied on the waiver of certain production terms, the re-sale of goods, and various contractual clauses to justify repudiation. The trial court granted the plaintiff substantial relief, deducting a counter-claim, and the High Court, in a division bench, held that Lloyd’s Certification is a condition for indemnity, and that severable contracts must be treated individually. It upheld breach findings against the defendant in four contracts, but found no independent legal injury to sustain forfeiture of advance payments except where waiver occurred (Ext.A7). The court held that time-limits and forfeiture must be understood in light of Section 73 and 74 of the Contract Act and related cases, ultimately dismissing the appeal while upholding the trial court’s decree with partial regard to the counter-claim.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No.802 of 2022

Thomas Koshy v. Susamma Thomas

The appellant-husband, Thomas Koshy, challenges ex parte divorce decreed against him by the Family Court, Pathanamthitta, in O.P.(Div) No.218 of 2017 under Section 10(1)(x) of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869. The respondent-wife, Susamma Thomas, had filed I.A.No.1/2021 to set aside the ex parte decree; this was renumbered as R.P.No.12 of 2021, with I.A.No.2/2021 filed for condonation of delay of 814 days. The Family Court, by orders dated 21.07.2022 and 17.08.2022, allowed the delay and restored the petition, ultimately allowing R.P.No.12/2021. The appellant filed this MAT.APPEAL under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, contending the orders are cryptic and contrary to law. The High Court stayed further proceedings on 24.11.2022. The judgment surveys principles from Abdul Kareem v State of Kerala, Balakrishnan v Geetha N.G., G.P. Srivastava v R.K. Raizada, Peeves Enterprises v Muhammed Ashraf, Breen v Amalgamated Engineering Union, Alexander Machinery, Chairman and Managing Director, United Commercial Bank v R.C. Kakkar, and Assistant Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department v Shukla and Brothers, emphasizing liberal interpretation of ‘sufficient cause,’ the necessity of reasons, and the right to a reasoned order. The Court holds the cryptic order untenable and allows the appeal, directing a fresh, reasoned Order IX Rule 13 order within two weeks, with the interim stay intact.

High Court of Kerala
MFA (RCT) No. 71 of 2016

Ramla Beevi and others v. Union of India

This is an appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, by the appellants (legal heirs of Jahangir) challenging the Railway Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench’s order dated 5 February 2016 dismissing OA No. 82/2014. Jahangir, aged 47, died on 30 October 2013 while travelling by Parasuram Express from Aluva to Parandode; the appellant contends the death was an untoward incident under Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, and that the Tribunal erred by attributing the death to self-inflicted injuries. The Tribunal’s adverse finding rested on a defence argument that Jahangir might have leaned out of the moving train and struck a bridge, a possibility extrapolated from the DRM report and the absence of a recovered ticket. PW1’s testimony, the DRM report Ext. R1, and the lack of direct evidence left the appellants with scant corroboration beyond the claim that the incident occurred near Peruman bridge. The respondents argued there was no justification to interfere with the Tribunal’s finding. The Kerala High Court recognizes the untoward-incident framework, noting precedents that a passenger is prima facie presumed to be bona fide and that absence of a ticket does not automatically negate eligibility for compensation. Relying on cited decisions, the Court concludes the death was an accidental fall from a moving train and grants compensation of Rs. 8,00,000 with 6% interest, directing deposit within two months. The appeal is disposed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
R.S.A.No.613 of 2019

T. D. Radhakrishnan Nair v. Chandravathy Amma and others

R.S.A.No.613 of 2019 arises from a partition suit over the plaint schedule property left by late C.R. Divakaran Nair. The trial court held the parties as co-owners and by a preliminary decree allotted 1/7th share to each plaintiff, 1/7th to the first defendant, and 1/7th to defendants 2 to 4 jointly. The first appellate court affirmed these findings. The appellant, the first defendant, challenged the decision on the ground of a purported family settlement allegedly made before the death of the father, claiming the plaint schedule properties were settled in his favour by a 1993 oral family arrangement, with the rest receiving patrimony at marriage. The respondents contended that the plaint schedule property is divisible and that no bona fide family settlement binding on all co-owners exists. The High Court examined the evidence and found that the family settlement pleaded lacks bona fides: it was oral, four days before the father’s death, not reduced to writing, and not all sharers were party to it. It relied on M.N.Aryamurthi and another v. M.L.Subbaraya Setty (dead) by his legal Representatives and Others to hold that such family settlements are not binding on other co-owners. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed in limine, reaffirming co-ownership and partition rights, and with no order as to costs.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 1053/2010

Thengath Saidh S/O Muhammed v. Chirakkal Kareem Muhammed

The plaintiff filed O.S.212/1999 in the Munsiff Court, Kalpetta, claiming Rs 35,000 with future interest, alleging that on 25 May 1995 the defendant received the amount to arrange a visa for employment in Muscat and promised repayment if the visa was not arranged. On 15 October 1998, the defendant executed Exhibit A1, undertakings to repay by 30 April 1999, with interest at 20% per annum if not paid timely. The defendant denied the transaction and contended that the suit was barred by limitation. During trial, PWs 1 and 2 testified and Exhibits A1–A8 were marked for the plaintiff; DW1 and Exhibits B1–B5 were marked for the defendant. The Trial Court held Exhibit A1 was not an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act but a fresh agreement based on past consideration and thus not barred by limitation; it decreed Rs 35,000 with interest at 20% per annum from 25.05.1995 till realization. The First Appellate Court confirmed the decree. The defendant challenged the decree under Section 100 CPC before this Court. On admission, two substantial questions of law were framed: (i) whether awarding 20% interest post-decree is sustainable under Section 34 CPC, and (ii) whether the suit was barred by limitation. The appellant argued A1 was an acknowledgment of a past liability under Sec.18 Limitation Act; the respondent argued A1 is a written promise to pay a debt barred by limitation under Sec.25(3) (novations). The High Court ultimately held A1 is a valid written promise to pay a debt barred by limitation, not barred by limitation, and modified the decree by fixing interest at 12% from the institution of the suit to decree and 6% from decree to realization, while confirming the decree and disposing of the Regular Second Appeal; pending applications closed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) NO. 37 OF 2014

A. Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala and Others

This OP(KAT) arises from a challenge to the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s (KAT) final order dismissing a transferred application seeking counting of military service towards time-bound higher grades in the State Excise service. The petitioner, a retired Excise Manager, contends that his prior military service, counted along with civil service, should qualify him for higher grades (10, 18 and 25-year marks) from specified dates, and that para 3(iii) of Ext.P1 and G.O.(P) No.622/2003/Fin should not bar such counting for pre-1992 entrants. The Tribunal held that war/military service counts for civil pension only for one higher grade (per the extant government norms) and thus dismissed the Transferred Application. The petitioner invoked Articles 226/227 of the Constitution and pointed to Ext.P2 (GO No.644/2003/TD), Ext.P1 (G.O.(P) No.622/2003/Fin), and related circulars clarifying counting of military service only for the first higher grade. The court, after detailed discussion of several Government orders and prior judgments, including a Full Bench decision in V.J. Philomina, held that the earlier dicta in Sreedharan’s case are overruled and that the government’s position mandating counting for only a single higher grade remains valid. The petition is ultimately dismissed; the court declines to grant the requested reliefs.

High Court of Kerala
Arb.Appeal No.18 of 2013

Asha Rajan v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.

This arbitration appeal arises from an award under an LPG distributorship agreement with the Indian Oil Corporation (IOC). The appellant, Asha Rajan, challenged an arbitration award upholding the termination of her IOC-distributorship after a committee found that her financial year 1999-2000 income exceeded Rs. 2,00,000, a threshold for eligibility. The appellant had entered into a distributorship agreement in 2002, and a complaint by a rival applicant led IOC to terminate the dealership following the committee’s finding. The dispute was referred to arbitration under Clause 37(a) of the agreement, since the contract provided for arbitration before an IOC officer acting as arbitrator. The appellant sought relief under Section 34(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, alleging (i) bias because the arbitrator was an IOC employee, (ii) that the income issue was outside the scope of submission to arbitration, and (iii) that the arbitrator did not scrutinize the enquiry report’s validity. The Kerala High Court rejected these challenges: the arbitrator’s status as an IOC employee does not ipso facto prove bias; the income issue fell within the arbitration’s terms; and the court cannot reweigh evidence under Section 34 except for patent illegality. The appeal was dismissed with no costs. The court emphasized that challenges to arbitral awards must respect the narrow scope of Section 34 and the precepts of natural justice and reasonable doubt about impartiality must be justified and substantiated.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.2917 of 2021

Abdul Razak @ Abu Ahmed v Union of India represented by National Investigation Agency, Midhilaj @ Abu Mis'ab, and Hamsa U.K.

Abdul Razak @ Abu Ahmed, the second accused in SC No. 2/2018/NIA, challenges Annexure E, an order of the Special Court allowing the NIA to examine Shajahan V.K. as an additional witness in the same proceedings. Shajahan, who was convicted by a Delhi NIA court in connection with the same conspiracy to wage jihad with ISIS, was sought to be examined as an additional witness in the Kerala trial. The petitioner contends that Shajahan is a co-accused and that permitting his examination as a witness would violate the constitutional protection against self-incrimination (Article 20(3)) and would contravene Section 315 CrPC, which limits when an accused may testify for his defence, not as a prosecution witness against co-accused. The Asg argues maintainability of the petition under Section 482 CrPC and that Section 311 CrPC authorizes examination of a witness in appropriate circumstances, irrespective of status. The Kerala High Court undertakes a thorough analysis of the interaction between CrPC sections 306, 307, 308 (pardons and approvers), 315 (accused as defence witness), and Section 132 of the Indian Evidence Act, as well as the inherent powers under 482 CrPC. It highlights the danger of prejudice to the defence in permitting a convicted co-accused to testify against a co-accused, especially in a case involving terrorism and same transaction. Ultimately, it holds that the impugned order is not legally sustainable, sets aside Annexure E, and allows the Crl.M.C., while dismissing Annexure B (the prosecution’s application). The court emphasizes the need to protect the rights of the accused and to secure ends of justice, resisting misuse of cross-accusation dynamics in a “split-up” prosecution.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). No.16120 of 2020

Roshi.V.Ravi v. District Collector, Ernakulam & Others

The petitioner, Roshi V. Ravi, a resident of Kunnathunadu Taluk, challenged Ext. P3 pattayam (dated 15.12.1969) acquiring 2.09 acres of temple land in Pattimattom village, once belonging to Kandangakkavu Chandika Devi Temple. He seeks quashing and annulment of the pattayam, removal of encroachments by respondents 5 and 6, and protection of temple assets under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act, 1957, in light of the Apex Court’s directions in W.P.(C) No. 649 of 2018 dated 05.07.2018, while requesting reinstatement of deities removed from the property. The petitioner points to prior disputes (O.S. Nos. 420 of 2016; 14 of 2020) and contends that pattays were obtained by respondents 5 and 6 through questionable means, including alleged obstruction of devotees and misappropriation of temple property. Ext.P6, a petition dated 30.11.2021, has been filed before the District Judge in terms of Apex Court directions; Ext.P5 is the apex order. The court notes that Krishna-like guardianship of temple property lies with Devaswom authorities and the court has a parens patriae obligation to protect sacrosanct assets. The High Court, exercising its jurisdiction, disposed of the matter by directing the Additional District Judge to consider Ext. P6 and report back within four months, while not deciding on the merits of Ext. P6. The court’s focus is protective, interim, and procedural rather than final determination of ownership as between the parties.