Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 511 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.13664/2021

Shaji K.C. et al. v. University of Calicut and Vice Chancellor, University of Calicut

This writ petition, WP(C) No. 13664 of 2021, has been filed by seven drivers challenging the University of Calicut’s plan to terminate their services and replace them with new drivers engaged on daily wages or contracts. The petitioners allege that they were engaged in 2013-2014 on ad hoc, daily wage, or contract terms following a selection process, and that they have continued in service with periodic memos and extensions (e.g., Exhibit P1). They argue that their uninterrupted service since 2013-14, coupled with ongoing engagement, entitles them to continued work through a legally compliant appointment process. The respondents counter that a 2012 press release initiated a panel for daily-wage drivers and that subsequent selection led to 24 appointees, with engagements renewed under daily wage arrangements until a formal contract appointment system was introduced. They rely on Government orders mandating that daily-wage engagements be limited to 179 days and not extended beyond two years, and point to a 2018 notification and a 2020 driving-test-based selection for contract posts (67 candidates participated). They cite a statement that petitioners who participated in the selection cannot challenge the process. The High Court ultimately held the petition not maintainable to challenge the notification, but directed that petitioners may continue on daily wage until the ongoing selection process is completed, balancing interim employment with the legality of the recruitment framework.

High Court of Kerala
RP 503/2021 in W.A.133/2021

Mahatma Gandhi University v. Union Christian College, Aluva, University Grants Commission and Dr. David Saj Mathew P.

This Review Petition (RP 503/2021 in W.A.133/2021) before the Kerala High Court challenges the intra-court judgment dated 8.4.2021 in W.A.133/2021, which concerned the University’s evaluation of a candidate for the post of Principal of the Union Christian College, Aluva, and remanded the matter for appropriate action. The petitioners are Mahatma Gandhi University and its Vice Chancellor; the respondents include Union Christian College, Aluva, the University Grants Commission (UGC), and Dr. David Saj Mathew P. The Supreme Court had earlier dismissed Special Leave Petitions against the High Court’s decision (SLP Nos. 7049/2020 and 7394/2021) and did not grant liberty to file a review petition. The High Court, relying on Khoday Distilleries and Kunhayammed principles, examined whether the petition for review was maintainable and whether the earlier decision merited reconsideration. It emphasized that dismissal of a Special Leave Petition may not merge with the underlying judgment and that any observations in the Supreme Court’s order carry judicial discipline and bind parties in subsequent proceedings. The court ultimately dismissed the review petition, holding that the grounds for interference were largely the same as those already argued before the Supreme Court, and clarified that its own findings were based on material available at hearing. It also stated that the decision should not be treated as a binding precedent in future cases and expressed a desire to conclude the litigation, directing appropriate orders to finalize the writ petitioner’s appointment as Principal.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 1210 OF 2021

Ettumanoor Development Council v. Edassery Towers Pvt. Ltd and Kumarakom Grama Panchayath

The Ettumanoor Development Council filed OP(C) No. 1210 of 2021 challenging an interim injunction and the appellate order in OS 211 of 2020 of the Additional Munsiff Court, Kottayam, which restrained construction near the Vembanad Lake. The suit alleges violation of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Lands Act and the Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 2011, for constructing a commercial building within 50 metres of the High Tide Line of the Vembanad lake on land described as Re-Sy.Nos. 172/3-2 and 172/8-2 in Kumarakom Village. The trial court granted an ex parte injunction, later made absolute. The first respondent (Edassery Towers) appealed, and the appellate court vacated the injunction, directing further proceedings. The petitioner contends that the disputed portion is private land and not Kayal Nilam, and relies on Ext.P14 (the court’s own prior judgement) and government records cancelling a Thandaper in a private name; it also argues that the CRZ regime does not apply since Kumarakom Panchayath is not within the CZMP, relying on Ext.R1(j)–(n). The respondents argue the Panchayat issued a building permit; CRZ requires CZMA concurrence; the Panchayat’s non-appearance in court is a matter of concern. The High Court ultimately holds that the questions are primarily factual, requires evidence, and disposes of the petition by dismissing it, while directing the trial court to proceed within eight months and to base construction on any Panchayat permission, uninfluenced by interim orders or appellate observations.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 11 of 2012

Kuttiappu and others v. ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. and others

The case arises from a motor accident that killed Udaya Bhanu on 07.09.2008, with the claim petition filed in O.P(M.V) No. 175/2009 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode. The Tribunal held that the accident occurred due to negligence of the lorry driver (2nd respondent) and that the insurer (3rd respondent) was liable to pay compensation, directing Rs. 1,55,000 with interest and Rs. 1,500 costs. The appellants, as the deceased’s parents and siblings, challenged the quantum of compensation. The High Court, applying jurisprudence from Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq for determining the deceased’s income and Pranay Sethi for future prospects, fixed the monthly income at Rs. 6,500 (for a 2008 accident) and added 40% towards future prospects, with a 50% deduction for personal expenses given the deceased’s bachelor status. Recalculation yielded loss of dependency of Rs. 9,82,800, with additional amounts for funeral expenses (Rs. 12,000), loss of estate (Rs. 15,000), and loss of consortium (Rs. 75,000). A prior Rs. 5,000 awarded for love and affection was to be deducted, following Satinder Kaur. The aggregate compensation was fixed at Rs. 9,49,800. The appeal was allowed; the insurer was directed to deposit the enhanced amount with interest within three months, with the court noting that the delay could be excluded for interest calculations.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal Nos.353 and 406 of 2015

Prakash Kamapalan v. Priya (Mat.Appeal Nos.353 and 406 of 2015), High Court of Kerala

These matrimonial appeals arise from O.S.245 of 2007 filed by the respondent-daughter against the appellant-father in the Family Court, Kollam. The Family Court decreed the suit ex parte on 30.01.2008, directing the defendant (father) to pay Rs.10,00,000 towards marriage expenses, with the option to realise from the plaint schedule property if paid late. The appellant filed I.A.No.2124 of 2012 under Order IX Rule 13 CPC to set aside the ex parte decree, along with I.A.No.2125 of 2012 under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay; both applications were dismissed by a common order dated 19.02.2015. The grounds included serious defects in Ext.A1, the power of attorney, such as lack of proper attestation, inconsistent signatures, and lack of knowledge by the attorney holder about the plaint averments. The respondent contended that challenging the ex parte decree was a belated attempt and that the delay was not sufficiently explained. The High Court found that the ex parte judgment was rendered without considering the proof affidavit and the defects in the power of attorney, which could not be sustained in law. Consequently, the appeals are allowed: ex parte judgment and the 2015 common order are set aside, the suit is restored to file, and the Family Court is to proceed on merits with opportunity to file a written statement and adduce evidence. A hearing is fixed for 08.01.2024.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2070 OF 2023

Bail Application No. 2070 of 2023 (Kaipamangalam Police Station Case No. 86/2023)

This is a Kerala High Court anticipatory bail petition (Bail App. No. 2070 of 2023) by accused nos. 1 and 2 in Kaipamangalam Police Station Case No. 86/2023. The prosecution alleges offences under IPC sections 341, 324, 326, 307 and 308 read with 34. The case record shows that a previous crime, No. 376/2022, was registered on 22.05.2022, based on a First Information Statement by the second accused, with allegations of assault on the bar owner and staff after disputes over alcohol billing. The petition argues that the earlier crime lacked legal sustenance, the defacto complainant did not timely file a complaint, and the present case is built on a private complaint that was mechanically forwarded for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. The learned counsel for the petitioners contends the allegations are false, and that the applicants are entitled to pre-arrest bail and will cooperate with investigation, including weapon recovery during custody. The Public Prosecutor opposes anticipatory bail, noting prima facie credibility of the prosecution case and the necessity of custodial interrogation and weapon recovery. The court, after considering the diary and submissions, grants anticipatory bail with conditions directed at surrender within ten days, two days of interrogation in a specified window, production before the court on arrest, a bond of Rs.30,000 with two sureties, ongoing cooperation, and non-interference with witnesses.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P.No.416/2021

K.G Stephena v. State of Kerala and The Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau, Kollam Unit

This is a criminal revision petition filed by the first accused, K.G. Stephena, challenging the order dated 29.04.2021 passed by the Special Court (Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thiruvananthapuram) dismissing his discharge application under Section 239 Cr.P.C. in CC 6/2015, which relates to alleged malpractices in distributing educational concessions for 35 SC and other eligible students. The prosecution contends that the first accused, while serving as the Chavara Block SC Development Officer, along with the second accused (a clerk) and the third accused (principal of Axis Parallel College), conspired to disburse Rs. 1,55,515 without proper verification, thereby causing undue pecuniary advantage and committing offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and IPC sections 420, 468, 471 and 120B. The petitioner argues that the trial court erred in denying discharge by not properly considering defence materials and by not adequately weighing prosecution materials for a prima facie case. The Kerala High Court, in a detailed examination of established precedents on framing and discharge, holds that while defence materials are generally not to be weighed at charge-framing, rare exceptional cases may allow their consideration. It sets aside the discharge order, directs fresh adjudication of the discharge petition, and emphasizes that the court must perform judicial scrutiny to determine the existence of a prima facie case without conducting a mini-trial, reiterating the boundaries between discharge and frame-of-charge standards.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No.159 of 2015

Saju v. Raveendran and others

This High Court of Kerala, in FAO No.159 of 2015, heard an appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(d) CPC challenging an ex parte decree in O.S. No.46 of 2009 (Kochi) and two related I.As (939/2014 and 940/2014). The appellant, Saju, the 4th defendant, contends that his non-appearance at a trial date resulted from the death of his counsel, which led to an ex parte decree on 27.03.2014. He further argues that a notice regarding attachment was only learned of after the decree and thus there was a sufficient cause for delay in filing I.A.s and in filing the appeal, which should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The plaintiff-responder contends that the appellant’s conduct shows lack of bonafides and that prior ex parte decrees had been set aside on different grounds, implying protraction of litigation. The court relies on Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee to emphasize that “sufficient cause” is elastic and must be interpreted in a manner that promotes substantial justice, while distinguishing between inordinate delays and short delays. It ultimately holds that the delay can be condoned and the ex parte decree set aside, subject to a cost of Rs. 5,000 to the plaintiff, and directs restoration of the suit on file against the appellant in accordance with law, thereby allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Appeal No.538 of 2023

Crl.Appeal No. 538 of 2023: Shameem v. State of Kerala & Neethu P. Mani

This High Court of Kerala, in a criminal appeal, scrutinizes the grant of anticipatory bail under the SC/ST (PoA) Act, after the Special Court's order to delete several offences and continue only with Section 3(1)(r). The appellant, CH Shameem, is a senior LP school teacher and faces accusations under IPC Sections 354B and 294B and under the SC/ST (PoA) Act 2015. The prosecution contends that the second respondent, a member of a Scheduled Caste, was humiliated and an attempt was made to disrobe her in the presence of students, triggering heavy statutory penalties and the prohibition under Section 18A. The appellant's counsel contends the allegations are false and motivated; the second respondent allegedly shifted positions over time, with Annexure I complaint on 16.02.2023 not pleading the requisite caste-based motive, casting doubt on the reliability of the complaint. Drawing on Arul P. Sugathan and Others v. State of Kerala (2021) and a Supreme Court reference in Hitesh Verma, the court notes that Section 18A is not an absolute bar, particularly where prima facie case is weak or mala fide allegations appear. The prosecution argues that serious gravity and the status of the appellant as a teacher warrant caution. The High Court ultimately allows pre-arrest bail to Shameem, with conditions, despite the 18A prohibition, reflecting a careful balancing of evidentiary and policy concerns.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.16098/2023

Navaneeth Mohanan K.P. and others v. State of Kerala and KSBCDC and Kerala Public Service Commission

The petitioners, Navaneeth Mohanan K.P., Noorjahaan S., and Alexy Elizabeth Chandy, three engineers with B.Tech degrees and MBAs, challenge a Kerala Public Service Commission (PSC) recruitment notification for the post of Assistant Manager in the Kerala State Backward Classes Development Corporation (KSBCDC). They allege that the PSC notification Ext.P14 requires PGDCA as a qualification, even though their higher qualifications are superior and encompass skills taught in PGDCA. Having been selected as Project Assistants on contract, the petitioners argue that their B.Tech degrees, supported by Exts.P7 and P8, are or should be treated as equivalent to PGDCA and thus sufficient for appointment to the Manager post. They rely on KS&SSR Rule 10(a)(ii), which contemplates recognition of equivalent qualifications, and on judgments suggesting that higher qualifications can suffice for lower posts if not arbitrary. They also highlight inconsistencies: in other PSC recruitments, such as HSST (Junior) and Computer Programmer, PGDCA is not insisted for engineers, suggesting discrimination. The respondents contend that Rule 10(a)(ii) is not satisfied here, lacking an executive order recognizing equivalence, and that courts should not second-guess employer qualification prescriptions. The High Court ultimately held the triple-test under Rule 10(a)(ii) unmet, distinguished Jyoti K.K. as inapplicable to these facts, and dismissed the petition, upholding the employer’s qualification standards and the PSC’s recruitment framework.

High Court of Kerala
OP (MAC) NO. 60 OF 2021

Midhun Shaji v. Anil Kumar and The Oriental Insurance Company Limited

This is an OP(MAC) challenging a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) order at Attingal that dismissed a claim for compensation on the ground of delay in filing. The petitioner, Midhun Shaji, sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident and sought compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act. The MACT dismissed the application as time-barred, taking the view that Section 166(3) as amended by the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 had come into force and required filing within six months from the date of occurrence, with COVID-19 extensions not extending this period. The petitioner contended that Section 166(3) was not in force because the Amendment Act’s notification did not bring that provision into effect; hence the original Section 166 should apply. The High Court examined the enactment and the notification regime, noting that while some provisions of the 2019 Amendment Act were brought into force from 1 September 2019, Section 53 (which introduced 166(3)) was not notified as in force. Relying on a decision from the Allahabad High Court (Shailendra Tripathi v. Dharmendra Yadav), the court held that the amended provision did not apply in the absence of force of Section 53. Consequently, the Tribunal’s order was set aside, and the petition was allowed, with directions to proceed under law.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.3298 of 2021

Jubair and others v. State of Kerala and Asya d/o Ismail

This is a criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. No. 3298 of 2021) before the High Court of Kerala, Krala. The petitioners, accused 1 to 4, sought to quash Crime No.161/2019 registered at Tirurangadi police station for offences under Sections 498A and 406 read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution case asserts that the first petitioner, the husband of the de facto complainant, along with co-accused, subjected the de facto complainant to cruelty and misappropriated her valuables in pursuance of a common intention. On hearing, the petitioners’ counsel argued that the dispute between the petitioners and the de facto complainant had been amicably settled, and the complainant has no grievance or objection to quashing, supported by Annexure A3 (an affidavit) stating the misunderstanding and that the FIR was lodged due to a misapprehension. The Public Prosecutor supported the settlement and argued that continuing proceedings would amount to abuse of process and waste of time. The High Court invoked Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) to recognize that quashing is permissible in cases with a civil/private flavour where settlement exists, provided ends of justice require it and continued proceedings would be unjust or oppressive. Given that the entire dispute is resolved, no public interest is involved, and continuation would be oppressive, the court quashed the proceedings. The order thus allows the Crl.M.C. and directs quashing of Crime No.161/2019.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 630/2016 & 780/2016

RFA Nos. 630/2016 & 780/2016: Meena and others v. Bhaskaran and others (Partition suits) - High Court of Kerala

Two regular first appeals, RFA 630/2016 and RFA 780/2016, arise from two suits for partition in Palakkad (OS 168/2010 and OS 124/2011). The appellants, Meena and her children, contend that the property is a coparcenary ancestral property and that the 1973 partition between Ramankutty and his two sons (Bhaskaran and Chenthamara @ Kannann) was not binding on Gopi, Ramankutty’s deceased son, or his estate, so Gopi’s heirs should obtain a share by birth. The trial court had dismissed the first suit and decreed the second. The High Court held that Ext. A1 (1965 partition) shows the property was not coparcenary but self-acquired by Kandan and Ramankutty, hence Viswanathan v. Ramankutty does not assist the plaintiffs. On Ramankutty’s death in 2007, devolution occurs under the Hindu Succession Act to his legal heirs and to Gopi’s heirs. The court held the plaintiffs are entitled to a 1/7th share in the schedule properties, with the defendants retaining the remainder. A preliminary decree to that effect was passed, with a 90-day window for final decree; suits adjourned sine die; costs borne out of the estate; receiver discharged after final decree; equity to be settled at final decree. Both appeals were allowed in terms of the modified decree.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 42 of 2021

Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) & Regional Officer, CBSE v. Dr. Kalyani A. & The Principal, Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Model School

This High Court of Kerala Writ Appeal arises from a challenge to a single-judge order directing CBSE to correct the date of birth in the CBSE certificate of the first respondent, Dr. Kalyani A. The writ petition (W.P.(C) No.26270/2019) alleged erroneous DOB entries and sought correction in CBSE certificates based on the local Birth Certificate. CBSE contended that byelaws 69.2 and 69.3 govern DOB corrections, restricting changes to typographical errors and alignment with school records, especially for certificates issued prior to 2005 and from 2015 onwards, and that such corrections require genuineness and timely action. The respondent argued that delays in correction can ruin future prospects and that the Birth Certificate from the local authority should be given substantive weight, potentially overriding byelaw restrictions. The Kerala High Court, relying on Subin Mohammed S. v. Union of India and various precedents, held that CBSE’s corrections are subject to reasonableness and that the bye-laws, though not statutory, bind candidates. The appellate court ultimately dismissed the writ appeal, but directed CBSE to consider corrections where genuineness is established, with a cost and fee framework, reinforcing judicial discipline and the primacy of statutory records in DOB determinations. The judgment is delivered by Chief Justice S. Manikumar and Judge Shaji P. Chaly on 01-02-2021.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.3165 of 2009

Omana and Others v. Shaibu P.S. and Others (MACA No.3165 of 2009)

This appeal arises from OP(MV) 362/2005 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakkuda, seeking compensation for the death of Vasu, a construction worker, in a road accident on 14.12.2004 involving a tempo van and a minilorry. The tribunal awarded Rs. 3,32,800 with 7% interest and costs. The appellants contended that the compensation was inadequately calculated and argued for higher notional income, future prospects, and a correct multiplier, citing standard precedents on “just compensation.” The High Court re-evaluated quantum: fixing notional income at Rs. 4,500 per month (instead of Rs. 2,250), applying a 13-year multiplier (per Sarla Verma) and adding 25% future prospects. It recalculated loss of dependency, replaced pain and suffering and love & affection awards with amounts dictated by Pranay Sethi and related cases, and allowed enhancement of total compensation to Rs. 5,31,625, with 7% interest on the enhanced amount from the date of admission (30.3.2021) to deposit. The judgment also directed deposit and distribution through the Tribunal after deducting court-fee. The Court held that a statute-based “just compensation” framework permits enhancement beyond the petitioned amount, and clarified liability of insurer under the MV Act.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 763 OF 2022

Saleena Nazar v. K.B. Bhadran and The State of Kerala

Saleena Nazar, the revision petitioner, challenges concurrent convictions under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, arising from a cheque dishonor case. The Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Karunagappally, found that the cheque dated 22 July 2013 for Rs. 13,00,000 issued by the accused to the complainant was in discharge of a debt arising from a purported loan, and sentenced the accused to two months of simple imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 13 lakh, with default imprisonment for two more months. The Appellate Court (Sessions Court-V, Kollam) dismissed the appeal in Cr.A. No. 115/2018, affirming the conviction and sentence. The revision petition contends lack of credible proof of the borrowal or the source of funds, and disputes the alleged transaction involving a relative of the accused, including a property deal in 2011 associated with a signed blank cheque. The High Court discusses that the evidence of PW1 and PW2 supported the transaction and that the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act are rebuttable by preponderance of probabilities. In a partial intervener, the High Court modifies the sentence to a day’s simple imprisonment till rising of the court and a fine of Rs. 13 lakh, with time to pay and an execution deferment until 24.04.2023.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.11859/2021

Biju P v. District Collector, Palakkad District and others

The petitioner, Biju P, seeks permission to reclaim a paddy land (Nilam) in Puduppariyaram-II Village, Palakkad, under Exts. P11 to P15, for constructing a residential house. The land is described as Revenue land and is part of the Data Bank; petitioner argues there is no nearby paddy cultivation and that he has no other land to build a home. The LLMC previously refused due to concerns that conversion would adversely affect paddy cultivation; the Principal Agricultural Officer and the District Collector also rejected the application. The petitioner challenged those orders in earlier WP(C) 16227/2020, which this Court remitted to LLMC by Ext.P9, holding that the grounds of rejection were untenable. The Government Pleader argued that the land remains paddy land per Data Bank, Thandaper Register, and possession certificates, and that fragmentation would impair drainage in the Padasekharam; the LLMC’s adverse view was based on preservation of paddy cultivation. The Court noted that Ext.P9 is an inter partes judgment binding on the respondents, even if later law declarations exist, and held that the earlier grounds cannot justify rejection now. It allowed the petition in part and directed the respondents to reconsider the Ext.P15/Ext.P10 application in light of Ext.P9, and to pass fresh orders within two months, with a minor postscript correcting numbering in the final order.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 15703 OF 2021

Sethu Sivan Pillai v. Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and others

The petitioner, Sethu Sivan Pillai, seeks correction of CBSE records to reflect his correct name, date of birth, and parental details in CBSE-issued certificates and related records. He asserts misentries in the CBSE record, supported by Exts. P1–P5 (birth certificates, a gazette change of name, SSLC book, Aadhaar, and gazette notification). The Board reportedly refused to entertain the correction/change. The petitioner relies on the Supreme Court’s Jigya Yadav v. CBSE decision (2021) which delineates two categories of corrections: (i) ‘correction’ to align CBSE certificates with school/public documents, and (ii) ‘change’ when CBSE records differ from public documents or reflect a later acquired name. The Court frames the issue in terms of ‘change’ of particulars and acknowledges the legal presumption in favor of public documents under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, allowing corrections with conditions. The petitioner, aged around 23, explains the delay as due to preparations for further studies abroad. The Court notes the change of name via Gazette (Ext. P5) and contends the petition merits afresh consideration in light of Jigya Yadav. It disposes the petition with a direction that, on a fresh application through the fifth respondent school and compliance with noted conditions, the Additional seventh respondent CBSE officer shall consider the request in light of the Apex Court’s ruling."

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.4592 OF 2018(Y)

WP(C).No.4592 OF 2018(Y) and connected cases

This common judgment—delivered by Justice Amit Rawal on 31 March 2021—addresses identical questions of fact and law arising from multiple writ petitions challenging university-level reservations in teaching posts. The core issue is whether the University of Kerala could reserve professorship posts across teaching departments by treating all departments as a single unit, thereby enabling category-wise rotation that, in effect, amounts to 100% reservation for certain communities. The petitions contend that such a unitary approach violates Articles 14, 16(1), 16(4) and 16(4A) of the Constitution and contravenes precedents requiring cadre-specific consideration. The court examines statutory amendments (Kerala University Act, 1974 as amended by Act 26 of 2014), Rules 14-17 of KS & SSR 1958, Rule 15 on reservation by rotation, and UGC Regulations 2010 (and amendments), along with several Indian Supreme Court authorities on reservation in single-post cadres. The court ultimately holds that reservation by treating all departments as one unit for posts such as Professor, Assistant Professor, or Associate Professor is impermissible in the absence of plurality of posts and would breach constitutional guarantees. The impugned notifications and related amendments are quashed, with directions that appointments already made are subject to the final outcome of the writ petitions.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.161 of 2023

Rashin Rajan v. Biju K. Mathew

This Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges Ext.P2, a custody order passed in E.P.69 of 2022 in G.O.P. No.2034 of 2017 by the Family Court, Thrissur. The petitioner, Rashin Rajan, seeks to set aside Ext.P2 and to stay Ext.P1 (the 2019 decree) while IA 2/2022 in G.O.P. No.2034 of 2017 is considered and disposed. The two minor daughters, aged 12 and 10, were produced before the court for counselling, and the matter was heard after interactions with the parties. The decree had awarded permanent custody to the father with visitation rights for the mother. The court noted the estrangement between the spouses and a long gap in executing the decree, and took into account the welfare principle, including the children’s safety, stability, and the children’s own expressions during counselling. A key reference is Rohith Thammana Gowda v. State of Karnataka & others (AIR 2022 SC 3511), which clarifies that the welfare of the child remains the paramount consideration and that the wishes of a child, while relevant, do not automatically determine custody. Consequently, Ext.P2 was modified to an ad hoc arrangement, reducing the duration of custody to five days and setting a timetable for return, with the Family Court directed to decide IA 2/2022 within two months.