Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 508 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 14553 OF 2021

Reetha v. Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO), Fort Kochi & Others

This writ petition challenges the Revenue authorities’ treatment of 12.33 acres (12.33 Ares) of land in 34/1C, Alangad Village, North Parur Taluk, Ernakulam, classifying it as Nilam while the petitioner seeks to record it as Purayidam (garden land/dry land). The petitioner relied on directions from this Court and subsequent orders to alter the basic tax register (BTR) and reclassify the property under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order (KLU). Exhibit P3 shows an order under Clause 6(2) of the KLU; Exhibit P4 and P5 record a proactive attempt to reassess land tax and classify the property as Purayidam/Dry land/Garden land, per Court directions. The petitioner contends that the Land Tax Act, and the KLU, along with relevant judgments (Renji K Paul v. RDO; Iype Varghese v. RDO) require the property’s nature to be updated in revenue records; however, the Tahsildar (LR) allegedly retained the Nilam classification and allowed non-agricultural use by an order of 11.03.2020. The Government Pleader notes the 2nd respondent is not the proper authority to pass such orders, leading to suo motu impleading of the 4th respondent. The Court ultimately finds the impugned orders unsustainable, allowing the petition and directing the Tahsildar (LR) to amend the Basic Tax Register to reflect Dry land/Garden land/Purayidam and to take follow-up action within a month, guided by prior judgments and KLU provisions.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 15868/2021 & 16609/2021

WP(C) Nos. 15868 of 2021 & 16609 of 2021 (Renju @ Renjith; Jaseentha George @ Jyothi; Thomas Kutty @ Aji; Thomas @ Thomachan v. State of Kerala & Others)

Two life-convict petitions challenged a 06.08.2021 Government order extending ordinary leave for prisoners up to 23.08.2021, arguing that it violated Supreme Court directions to release certain categories of prisoners by a High Powered Committee (HPC) and the related orders in Suo Motu Writ Petition No. 1/2020. The petitions note that parole was granted in pursuance of Supreme Court directions (23.03.2020) directing HPCs to determine categories of prisoners eligible for release, with further guidance in 07.05.2021. The applicants contend that HPC-driven releases, and the consequential non-interference by the State Government, must govern them because it is the Court’s policy to identify class-wide releases; they were instead on ordinary leave extended due to the pandemic. The Special Prosecutor counters that the petitioners were not released by HPC but were on ordinary leave, and the Government retains discretion to extend or restrict such leave, especially for life convicts not covered by HPC’s release category. The court examines the HPC 09.05.2021 order and notes that the directive covered certain categories (NDPS, POCSO, highway offenses, etc.) but that those directions pertain to releases by HPC, not parole-based leave. It distinguishes a 2020 ruling (W.P(C) No.23595/2020) as non-applicable to the present case. Ultimately, the court refuses to interfere with the Government’s extension, while keeping open the possibility of future extensions in pandemic conditions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.Rev.Pet No.2902 of 2011

Fazil Trading Company & K.K. Shihab v. P.P. Rasheed & State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala decision deals with a criminal revision petition filed by Fazil Trading Company (represented by its managing partner K.K. Shihab) challenging judgments in a criminal appeal and a trial where the accused were convicted under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The Trial Court had convicted all accused, with the first accused fined Rs. 1,00,000 and the second and third accused imprisoned for five months and fined Rs. 65,500 each, to be paid as compensation under Cr.P.C. The Appellate Court partly allowed the appeal, acquitting the third accused for not being in charge of the firm, while upholding the conviction of the first two accused and imposing fines and imprisonment. In the revision petition, the petitioners attacked the evidence and the presumption framework, contending there was no reliable proof that they borrowed Rs. 2,31,000 from the complainant, and that the second petitioner was not in charge of the firm. The High Court, invoking the reverse onus doctrine under Sections 118/139 NI Act and relying on ancillary authorities (Rangappa, Kalamani Tex, Rohitbhai Jivanlal Patel, Ramrao Chavan), held that there is a prima facie legally enforceable debt and that the accused failed to rebut the presumption. The revision petition was dismissed, with the conviction and sentence confirmed, and directions issued to pay the fines by a specified date; execution was deferred to 27.11.2023.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.27219 of 2019

St. Mary's Orthodox Syrian Church, Poothrikka v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition, filed by St. Mary’s Orthodox Syrian Church, Poothrikka, and its vicar and trustees, seeks protection to conduct religious services in the church, cemetery, and chapels and to allow parishioners to participate without obstruction by members of the Jacobite/Patriarch faction (respondents 7–12). The petition relies on the Malankara Church Constitution of 1934 and the Supreme Court’s decision in K.S. Varghese v. St. Peter’s & Paul Syrian Orthodox Church (2017) to require that sacraments be conducted only by priests appointed under the 1934 constitution by the Diocesan Metropolitan. It recounts earlier civil suits (O.S. 52/2003 and O.S. 17/2002) and their decrees recognizing the 1934 constitution as governing the church and restraining others from interfering. It further asserts that after Ext. P3 judgment, the respondents obstruct the 2nd petitioner’s entry and performance of duties; police assistance was sought but not provided. The petition emphasizes that the 2nd petitioner is the legally appointed vicar and that the Supreme Court Varghese decision governs the church and its properties. The court, after considering submissions, holds that Varghese applies to the church and its properties; however, a bona fide dispute exists over certain property (Exhibit R14(a)) and cannot be decided in this petition. Consequently, the petition is disposed of, leaving the contentions on R14(a) open and preserving the interim order from 24.11.2021, while directing compliance with the Varghese judgment.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.2854 OF 2018(F)

MANAGER, S.P.S.S.U.P.SCHOOL, THODIYOOR, KARUNAGAPALLY, KOLLAM-690 518 v. STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 001; DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 001; ASSISTANT EDUCATION OFFICER, SUB DISTRICT, KARUNAGAPPALLY-690 518; K.PADMAKUMAR, S/O KUNJU KRISHNAN KRISHNAVENI, THODIYOOR P.O, KARUNAGAPPALLY, PIN-690 518

Petitioner, the Manager of S.P.S.S.U.P.School, Thodiyoor, Karunagappally (Kollam district), challenges Ext.P5, the Assistant Educational Officer’s 17.01.2018 order directing the reinstatement of the fourth respondent, the school’s Headmaster, who had been kept under suspension. The central issue is whether suspension beyond the statutory limit of 15 days, ordered by the Manager, could continue without the concurrence of the competent Educational Authority under the Kerala Education Act and Kerala Education Rules (KER). The Manager contends that the gravest charges against the fourth respondent—alleged possession of materials not appropriate for a headmaster—necessitated concurrence and due process, and that Ext.P5 is illegal; he had sought to set aside Ext.P5 and to take action against the fourth respondent. Respondents argue that continuation beyond 15 days without such concurrence is impermissible and Ext.P5 should operate. The fourth respondent’s counsel asserts innocence and seeks retirement benefits, urging regularization of the suspension period. The court notes the settled principle that concurrence is required, but given lack of enquiry and the fourth respondent’s retirement, it declines to re-open proceedings. It disposes by directing retirement with suspension treated as duty and mandates payment of all service and retirement benefits, while confirming Ext.P5 and safeguarding the Manager from action under the Kerala Education Rules.

High Court of Kerala
WPC 10487/2019

Nisha T.S. v. Mahatma Gandhi University and Others

The petitioner, Nisha T.S., challenged the selection process of Mahatma Gandhi University for the post of Assistant Professor in Behavioral Sciences, alleging that the Selection Committee misawarded marks to her and that she was unfairly deprioritized relative to the 4th respondent. She claimed she was allotted only 20.43 marks while the 4th respondent received 36.5, creating a substantial merit gap that, in her view, should have yielded appointment. Her primary contentions were that she deserved additional marks under the heads PhD, UGC Scholarship (including UGC-BSR), Publications, and Teaching Experience; she urged that six marks for PhD and five marks for the funded UGC scholarship should be awarded, following the court’s earlier decision in Nisha Vellapan Nair (supra). She also argued that her publications, including national and UGC-listed works, warranted more marks, and that teaching experience acquired after PhD should count for some marks, although the committee restricted Teaching Experience to permanent posts. The University contended that the committee followed its own yardsticks and that only JRF-based scholarships were eligible for marks; it also rejected several publications as ineligible or predatory. The court acknowledged six marks for PhD per the cited decision but held that even with such recalibration, the petitioner could not surpass the 4th respondent, and declining to interfere, dismissed the writ petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.3910 OF 2023

CRL.MC No. 3910 of 2023 (Against the order/judgment in CC 270/2020 of Judicial Magistrate of First Class-I, Nedumangadu)

This Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC 3910 of 2023) challenges the order in CC No. 270/2020 of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-I, Nedumangadu, concerning forest-offence proceedings. Petitioners Amal alias Rakendhu, Arunlal, and Kiranlal, accused under IPC sections 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 326, and 506(ii) r/w Section 34, are sought to be quashed under Section 482 CrPC. The prosecution alleges that on 08.02.2020, the petitioners, in furtherance of common intention, restrained and assaulted the complainant, causing grievous injuries. The petition contends amicable settlement between the parties, supported by an affidavit (Annexure-B), and requests termination of the proceedings so the parties may move forward in peace. The State, through the Public Prosecutor, expresses reservations about quashing solely on settlement, while noting no other registered criminal antecedents. The court surveys established authority, citing State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and several related decisions, to set out the governing principles in paras 15.1–15.5: quashing under 482 is permissible where the non-compoundable offence has a civil character and disputes are fully resolved; not for heinous offences or those under special statutes or involving public servants; for offences like Section 307 IPC, the court must assess evidence post-investigation. Considering the gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the settled relationship, the court concludes quashing would serve ends of justice. Consequently, the petition is allowed, and Annexure-A Final Report in Crime No. 121/2020 (Palode Police Station) and all further proceedings in CC 270/2020 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 658 of 2016

Ganga Devi G. @ Ganga v. Dr. Lathakumari K.

This Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 658 of 2016) arises from a money-decree based on a cheque in OS 26/2015 of the Sub Court, Karunagappally, Kollam. The appellant-defendant, Ganga Devi G. @ Ganga, challenges the trial court’s decree on the ground that it admitted an additional proof affidavit and three documents (Exts. A3–A5) without granting an opportunity for cross-examination. The court below relied on these materials, allegedly in contravention of Sections 137 and 138 of the Indian Evidence Act, which vest a crucial right of cross-examination in the opposing party and the documents tendered. The judgment canvasses a well-established line of Supreme Court authorities—State of U.P. v. Nahar Singh, Dahyabhai Chhaganbhai Thakker, and Satnam Singh v. Sadhu Singh—emphasizing that cross-examination is not a mere formality, that the right to test veracity is expansive, and that death of a witness before cross-examination necessitates corroboration rather than wholesale exclusion of testimony. It also discusses the proper handling of documents marked as exhibits, noting that marking does not automatically confer admissibility of contents unless admitted or proven (citing State of Karnataka v. State of A.P.; Narbada Devi Gupta; Ramji Dayawala). The High Court ultimately sets aside the decree, remanding the matter to the trial court to afford cross-examination on Exts. A3–A5 and permitting additional evidence within four months, with the appeal being allowed in part.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 3098 OF 2010

JANU MATTUMMAL LAKSHAMVEETTIL v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition arising from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The petitioner, an elderly female, was found with a 5-liter can of arrack on 24.05.2003 and was convicted by the trial court, upheld by the Fast Track Adhoc Kozhikode District Court, leading to this revision before Justice Sophy Thomas. The core issues concern delays in the chain of evidence: delay in producing seized articles before the magistrate (seizure on 24.05.2003, produced 26.05.2003), a protracted chemical analysis timeline (FSL report dated 19.11.2003 with sample forwarded notes lacking dates), and the long gap between seizure and witnesses’ examination. The court noted the absence of arrest at the scene, reliance on official witnesses without independent corroboration, and incongruities in the link between the seized sample and laboratory analysis. Citing decisions emphasizing the need for prompt investigation and reliable link evidence (including Moothedath Sivadasan v. State of Kerala), the court held that the prosecution failed to establish the link evidence and explained why the delay undermines the case. The revision petition was allowed, resulting in acquittal and cancellation of bail bonds."

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1314 of 2021

George Sebastian & K.V. George v. Administrator, Vaikom Taluk Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. & Others

This writ appeal challenges a Single Judge’s order interdicting the Vaikom Taluk Co-operative Bank election and directing a de novo election. The petitioners, members of the bank, contend that after the Election Commission’s Ext.P4 order postponed the election, the court should have directed resumption of the process from the stage at which it was halted, not a fresh de novo election. The bank’s term had expired, and Ext.P1 set out a draft of the electoral process with dates; Ext.P4 halted the process on grounds of ineligible membership. The Administrator superseded the Managing Committee; subsequent actions involved requiring funds for notices to allegedly ineligible voters. The learned Single Judge in WP(C) 5491/2021 allowed the writ petition in part, directing de novo election, and rejected resumption from the halted stage. The appeal challenges this, arguing that there is no statutory bar to resuming from the stopped stage and that lapse of time cannot justify de novo elections. The High Court, citing Shri Sant Sadguru Janardan Swami and approving a Division Benches’ decision (W.A.No.68 of 2014), holds that where an election process has been unjustifiably interfered with, it should be resumed from the point it was stopped; lapse of time cannot necessitate a de novo process. The appeal is allowed and the election should be resumed from the halted stage forthwith.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2907 OF 2009

MACA NO. 2907 OF 2009

This Motor Accident Claims Appeal arises from a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, registered as OP(MV) No.1219/2006 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottapalam, alleging death of Neeli (the mother of the appellants) after a road accident on 05.11.2006 involving motor cycle KL-48 941 driven rashly by the 1st respondent. The appellants, as legal heirs/dependents, claimed compensation for loss of dependency, funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium. The Tribunal awarded Rs 2,63,050 with 7% interest and costs, fixing the deceased’s notional income at Rs 3,000 per month and relying on policy indemnity by the 2nd respondent. The 1st respondent admitted negligence; the insurer contested the quantum as excessive. The High Court, invoking Supreme Court jurisprudence on “just compensation” (Pranay Sethi, Ramachandrappa, Sarala Varma), re-evaluates the head of damages: fixes notional income at Rs 4,000 (consistent with the petition), adopts a higher multiplier in light of age, and awards future-prospect-based enhancements. Conventional heads are revised: funeral/estate to Rs 15,000 each; loss of consortium to Rs 80,000 for minors; loss of dependency recalculated to Rs 4,35,600. The appeal is allowed in part, increasing total compensation to Rs 5,55,650 with 7% interest from the petition date, and a two-month window for deposit of the enhanced amount by the insurer, with the Tribunal disbursing accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No.2086/2015

Vimal Arackal v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. 2086/2015) concerns Vimal Arackal, who purchased a parcel of land from the 2nd respondent and relatives (11 co-owners) and sought to quash a final report in Crime No. 857/2012 of Kannamali Police Station under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. The 2nd respondent alleged that on 29.9.2012 the petitioner trespassed into her residence, caused damages, and insulted her by using caste-based slurs. The sale deed, dated 17.9.2012 (Nos. 4155/2012 and 4157/2012 referenced in the record), transferred possession to the petitioner on the same day. The Magistrate’s final report annexed to CP 1/2015 was challenged as lacking essential elements of the offence. The High Court noted that the alleged trespass occurred inside a private residence, not in public view, and that the complainant is one of eleven co-owners; possession had passed to the petitioner upon sale, undermining the trespass claim. It concluded that there was no prima facie case under 3(1)(x), and to prevent abuse of process, quashed the final report and FIR under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The decision emphasizes that Section 482 powers are to be exercised judiciously to prevent frivolous prosecutions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 24666/2021 and 2144/2020

W.P.(C) Nos. 24666/2021 and 2144/2020

This joint judgment of a single-judge bench of the Kerala High Court deals with two connected writ petitions challenging a Labour Court award and subsequent recovery steps. The leading petition (W.P.(C) No. 24666/2021) is filed by Unnitheri, a toddy tapper, seeking enforcement of an award in I.D.No.18/2014 (dated 7.9.2016) that held no denial of employment but granted notice wages and retrenchment compensation under the Industrial Disputes Act (I.D. Act) and directed payment. A Revenue Recovery notice under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act (RR Act) was issued to recover amounts from the employer’s heirs. W.P.(C) No.2144/2020, filed by Babumon Joseph (son of the original employer), challenges the same award and the RR notice, contending that the Kerala Agricultural Workers Act should apply, not the I.D. Act, and arguing lack of awareness of the proceedings by the respondent. The court examines jurisdictional questions, including whether the I.D. Act or the Kerala Agricultural Workers Act applies, and whether Article 227 (revisional jurisdiction) justifies interference. It ultimately holds that the 2144/2020 petition is liable to be dismissed, while allowing 24666/2021 and directing completion of revenue recovery within six months from receipt of the judgment copy. The decision relies on preexisting authority (e.g., Abraham Thomas) to uphold the I.D. Act framework, while Article 227 arguments are treated as probing the nature of appellate versus revisional review.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O.No.283 of 2016

Abdurahiman and Rukhiya v. Sathi

This appeal arises from FAO No. 283 of 2016 challenging an order dated 10 August 2015 in I.A. No. 2211 of 2014 in O.S. No. 325 of 2010 on the file of the Sub Court, Tirur. The suit, a specific performance action concerning an immovable property, was decreed ex parte on 2 July 2013. The appellants sought to set aside the ex parte decree, filing I.A. No. 2211/2014 after a delay of 482 days, which the Sub Court refused. The delay in filing the appeal itself (398 days) was later condoned under C.M. Appl. No. 1 of 2016. The appellants argued that their inability to appear stemmed from their son’s serious road accident and subsequent medical treatment, which required them to remain away from home, including at Mukkam. The Sub Court, after accepting some evidence (PW1 and Exts. A1–A5), found that the illness was not sufficient to justify such extended absence, and thus decreed the suit ex parte. On appeal, the Division Bench relied on liberal interpretations of “sufficient cause” and the need to avoid injustice, citing Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee, and also Rafeek v. Kamarudeen for support. The court ultimately allowed the appeal, set aside the impugned order, condoned delay, and directed restoration of O.S. No. 325/2010 with costs, directing the Sub Court to proceed in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.No.3184 of 2010

James, S/O Thomas v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition by James, accused No.1, challenging his conviction under Section 55(A) of the Abkari Act for illegally transporting 450 litres of spirit from Karnataka. The trial court convicted James and another accused, sentencing three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1,00,000 each, with default imprisonment. The appellate court upheld the conviction against accused No.1 but interfered with accused No.2. The revision petition contends grave procedural non-compliance with statutory formalities under the Abkari Act and challenges the chain of custody for seized contraband, including the absence of a specimen seal on the seizure mahazar and the delay in production of the contraband, its forwarding for chemical analysis, and the lack of evidence on safe custody. The High Court emphasizes the stringent nature of Abkari Act provisions and cites Baburaj, Sathi, Vijayan, Nadarajan, Moothedath Sivadasan, Sasidharan and other precedents to stress that strict compliance and clear link evidence are essential. It finds lacunae in the chain of custody, unexplained delays, and lack of corroborative evidence between seizure and laboratory analysis, ultimately determining that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The revision petition is allowed; conviction and sentence are set aside, and the petitioner is acquitted, with bail bonds cancelled and possible refunds of deposited amounts.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.14955 OF 2020(T)

Manager Sankaran Nair Upper Primary School, Kodunthirappully, Palakkad-678 004 v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition (WP(C).No.14955 of 2020) challenges Ext.P8, an order by the government denying the transfer of Smt. Aparna from the post of UPSA to LPSA so as to fill a vacancy in the UPSA and admit a fresh appointee to the UPSA vacancy. The management contends that the UPSA is fully qualified to hold the LPSA and that the government’s amendment to Kerala Education Rules Chapter XXXI (Rule 4A) and the government’s Circulars were misinterpreted in Ext.P8, which relied on a Full Bench judgment in Thresia M.L v. Preethy M.P and others (2014 (4) KLT 837) to bar such transfer. The government and its counsel argued that the transfer is irregular, not approved by the office, and contrary to policy prohibiting routing shifts to accommodate B.Ed holders in the U.P. section; Ext.P9 clarifies the intended constraint. The court, after examining the issue, found that Thresia M.L did not squarely address UPSA→LPSA transfers where the UPSA is otherwise eligible for LPSA, and that the amendment to Chapter XXXI supports reconsideration rather than outright prohibition in this context. It allowed the petition, set aside Ext.P8, and directed the Government to reconsider the matter under Chapter XXXI, Rule 4A, after hearing Aparna and the Manager, with a decision within three months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 10954/2023 and 11333/2023

N. Prakash v. Bar Council of India and Ors.

These writ petitions, WP(C) Nos. 10954/2023 and 11333/2023, arise from a law student N. Prakash challenging the non-adherence of Sree Narayana Law College and Mahatma Gandhi University to the Bar Council of India's Rules of Legal Education, 2008. The core grievance is that the minimum hours of lectures, tutorials, moot courts, seminars and other essential components are not being satisfied before examinations for the 8th and 9th semesters, thereby compromising the quality and credibility of legal education. In 11333/2023, the challenge extends to the 8th semester examination, while 10954/2023 concerns the 9th semester practicals/internals. The court recalls authoritative pronouncements, notably Satheesh Kumar N. v. Mahatma Gandhi University (AIR 2016 Ker 93), which requires scrupulous adherence to regulatory hours and suggests verification by the Registrar/Controller of Examinations based on inputs from college authorities. The University notified 8th semester examinations (notification dated 23.03.2023) but dates were not fixed, and concerns persisted about 9th semester activities. The respondents contend that affirmative steps are being taken to meet the hours. On disposal, the court directs that (1) mandatory study hours must precede 9th semester practicals; (2) by 05.05.2023, 8th semester hours must be completed and reported; and (3) the University shall verify and act in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 1858 OF 2016

M.N. Chandran v. K.M. Muhammed

Petitioner M.N. Chandran, the judgment-debtor in EP 60/2015 of OS 115/1999 before the Sub Court, Perumbavoor, challenges an order dated 20 July 2016 directing the sale of the scheduled property. He maintains that he is an agriculturist and entitled to the protection of Section 60(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure, and that the execution court misapplied the provision by treating the property as a residential plot and by not considering the value of improvements, including a two-storey building. He argues the entire property was proclaimed for sale even though only part of the property would suffice to satisfy the decree, and that Rule 330 of the Civil Rules of Practice was not complied with, as no encumbrance certificate or affidavit by the decree holder was produced. The respondent/decree holder contends all objections were answered and that no payment has been made on the decree since 2016, so the petition lacks merit. The court reviews Sec.60(c) and recalls that the term agriculturist, though not defined in the CPC, connotes a person dependent on tilling soil for maintenance. It cites authorities including Mathew v. Bank of Cochin, Pathmavathi v. Sheeja, Narasayya v. Subba Rao, Sukumaran K.A., K.V.Thomas, Chandradas K.P., and Raman alias Raman Kunju to scrutinize the valuation, description, and scope of sale. Finding fault with the impugned order, the High Court sets it aside and directs a fresh enquiry by the Execution Court with notice to both sides within three months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 20235 of 2022

Prabhakar Alva v. The District Collector Kasaragod and others

Prabhakar Alva filed W.P.(C) No. 20235 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court seeking a mandamus to direct the fourth respondent Panchayat to act under Section 235X of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 to stop construction of a place of worship in Re Survey No.163/3, Kayyar Village, Kasaragod district, on the ground that no building permit from the fourth respondent and no objection certificate from the first respondent were obtained, as required by law. The petitioner also sought expeditious consideration of representations (Exhibits P1 and P2) submitted to the first and fourth respondents. The fifth respondent, Sree Dhoomavathy Malaraya Dharma Chavadi Seva Samithi, contends that construction has been halted in light of a notice from the fourth respondent and has moved for regularization; it relies on Mohanan and another v. District Collector and others (2022 (1) KHC 441) to contend that no permission from the first respondent is necessary. The petitioner’s counsel argues that the first respondent’s permission is necessary, and the court notes the conflict between positions but does not decide that issue. The matter is disposed of with directions: the fourth respondent is to proceed in accordance with law on any regularization application after giving notice to the petitioner and the fifth respondent; construction will not proceed without appropriate permission pending final orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.15182/21

Thadevoose Sebastian v. Regional Passport Office, Trivandrum & The Regional Passport Officer, Regional Passport Office, Trivandrum

Thadevoose Sebastian, the petitioner, approached the Kerala High Court challenging a communication from the Regional Passport Office that flagged shortcomings in his fresh passport application. He previously held passport No. Z1969747 issued from Dubai, valid till 11-12-2020, and claims to have lost it in April 2012 at Nedumbassery Airport, prompting police verification and a police certificate dated 20-11-2012 indicating no information about the missing passport. On the same day, an FIR No.1480 of 2012 was registered against him alleging offences under IPC sections 406, 419, 420 and Passports Act sections 12(1)(a),(d) for impersonating the complainant’s identity while travelling with the complainant’s passport in Sharjah. He applied for a fresh passport on 26-11-2012, but the file was closed in 2014 due to the adverse report of pendency in the crime. Five years later he applied anew, claiming police closure and police clearance (dated 19-02-2020), yet the passport authority again raised shortcomings. The petition argues that pendency cannot automatically bar travel rights and seeks issuance of a passport under Government circulars and the GSR 570(E) notification. The High Court reviews the right to travel under Article 21, balanced against pendency of criminal proceedings, and lays down parameters to govern criminal courts’ grant of no-objection certificates; the Court directs a magistrate-based remedy and retains passportprocessing discretion in certain scenarios.