Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 507 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
L.A.A.No.99 of 2009

Sosa and others v. State of Kerala and Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.

This Land Acquisition Appeal (L.A.A. No.99 of 2009) arises from an acquisition of 55.49 acres of dry land and 62.51 acres of wetland in Thiruvankulam for storage tanks of Indian Oil Corporation, following notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 dated 19.12.1994. The Land Acquisition Officer initially awarded Rs. 33,480 per acre for dry land and Rs. 4,780 per acre for wetland. In reference, LA.R. No.151 of 1997, the Sub Court re-determined at Rs.46,872 per acre (dry) and Rs.7,170 per acre (wetland). The appellants challenged under Order XLI, Rule 1 CPC and Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984. In 2010, this Court enhanced dry land value to Rs.50,000 per acre and wetland to Rs.11,875 per acre. The Apex Court remitted the wetland value for redetermination, noting that while wetland cannot be equated with dry land, uniform compensation for wetlands acquired through the same process is required unless justified by distinct potentiality. The present judgment addresses post-notification evidence and the scope of remand; ultimately, the Wetland value for 62.51 acres is fixed at Rs.31,923 per acre, aligning with the L.A.R. 3 of 1998, with statutory benefits after deducting already paid amounts. The order is rendered by a Division Bench comprising Justices Anil K. Narendran and P.G. Ajithkumar on 14.09.2023.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29656 OF 2021

Krishna Haridas v. State of Kerala and Others

This Kerala High Court writ petition concerns the appointment of the petitioner as a Lower Primary School Assistant (LPSA) at Kathikudam, Thrissur, and the denial of approval for that appointment in a school considered uneconomic. The petitioner, who took up service with effect from 01.06.2015 in the school managed by the fifth respondent, faced rejection of the appointment proposal by the Assistant Educational Officer (AEO) as per Ext P1, a decision subsequently confirmed by Exts P2 and P4. After the Government issued Ext P5 on 01.08.2019, the petitioner approached this Court earlier in W.P.(C) No. 4523/2019; the Court directed reconsideration by the AEO in light of Ext P5. Subsequently, Ext P7 was issued by the AEO, again denying regularization on the ground that the petitioner was a daily-wage employee. The Court, relying on Ext P6 (the Court’s earlier judgment), observed that Ext P5 required reconsideration and directed the 4th respondent to re-examine the issue with notice and a hearing. It noted that Clause (1) in paragraph 2 of Ext P5 should be properly applied and that the matter must be concluded within two months. The judgment ultimately allows the writ petition, sets aside Ext P7, and directs fresh orders with due process; if the appointment is approved, back pay and other monetary benefits should be disbursed promptly.

High Court
OP (CAT) No.85 of 2017

Union of India & others v. P. Balakrishnan

This is an OP (CAT) challenging a CAT Ernakulam Bench order (Ext.P5) dated 20.06.2016 in OA 297 of 2013, which granted the sole respondent, Balakrishnan, notional promotion to Senior Administrative Officer (SAO) and refixation of pay and pension, with arrears limited to three years prior to the OA. The petitioners argued that post-retirement changes in seniority lists (Annexures R1/R2) and the DoPT Office Memoranda (OM) of 27.03.1997 and 08.02.2002, together with pay fixation rules like FR 27, cannot abridge vested rights accrued before retirement, and that equity does not justify retroactive alterations affecting a retired employee. They contended the 1997 OM creates a retroactive engrafting norm and that the common date 18.07.1996 used in Annexure-A3 for multiple incumbents was unwarranted. The Respondent Balakrishnan contends that Annexure-A1 (O.A.1565/1994) and Annexure-A2 (1997) orders had conferred notional benefits and that the Tribunal’s directions were justified; any revision post-retirement cannot erase rights already adjudicated. The Kerala High Court, a Division Bench, held that the relief can be granted in part: notional SAO promotion from 07.08.1992, no monetary arrears, pension refixation, and arrears limited to three years before Ext.P5 (04.04.2013). It also directed timely compliance, clarified that observations about Annexure-A3 apply only to this case, and preserved other incumbents’ rights. The Petitions accordingly stand disposed with these limited modifications.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases

WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The judgment consolidates WP(C) petitions including WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 and connected matters concerning frozen bank accounts in the wake of cybercrime investigations. Appearing before Justice T. R. Ravi on 26 March 2024, the petitioners (bank customers and financial entities across Kerala, Gujarat, Karnataka, Telangana, Delhi, etc.) challenge freezing orders issued by banks and police authorities under cybercrime vigilance. The court notes broadcasted police intimations, bank freezes, and online complaints, and directs that freezes be restricted to the amount specified in the police requisition or communication. It emphasizes that funds beyond the notified amount should be unfrozen to allow ordinary business; banks are to act expeditiously to verify and, where appropriate, de-freeze. The court relies on existing jurisprudence (notably Dr. Sajeer v RBI) to frame interim directions and disposes of the petitions with bindings directions to the respondent banks and police authorities. The decision is framed as a precautionary measure to balance legitimate investigative needs with the right to use bank accounts, ensuring that freezing does not cripple legitimate commerce while investigations proceed. The judgment catalogues several connected petitions dealing with multiple banks, branches, and cybercrime cells across India, all being disposed of with similar directions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A 134/2022

Jaleel v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court single-judge judgment (Gopinath P.) dated 19 October 2023 in Crl.A No.134 of 2022, challenging the January 25, 2023 conviction of the appellant in SC No.798/2020 before the Fast Track Special Court, Kunnamkulam. The trial court had convicted Jaleel for offences under IPC sections 376(1), 376(2)(n) and 450, sentencing him to 10 years, 12 years and 5 years imprisonment with fines, to run concurrently. The appellant’s core submission centers on the relationship with the de facto complainant/victim from 2009 to 2014, alleging a false promise of marriage thereby negating valid consent under Section 90 IPC. The defence asserts that a marriage was solemnized on 10-02-2014, that the couple later lived apart yet resumed cohabitation as husband and wife with a child, and that post-conviction affording the couple the chance to re-unite merits intervention under Section 482 Cr.P.C and Article 142 of the Constitution to quash the proceedings and set aside the judgment. The Public Prosecutor concedes the ongoing settlement and points to Ramgopal, Ramawatar, and Soban as precedents. The judge holds that the settlement and ends of justice justify invoking inherent powers under Article 142/482 Cr.P.C to quash the proceedings, setting aside the conviction and allowing the Criminal Appeal to be disposed of. The decision takes care to note cautions from Ramgopal and Ramawatar regarding misuse, while endorsing the settled proposition that a voluntary compromise can justify quashing non-compoundable offences in appropriate circumstances.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. No. 1540 of 2007

Divakaran v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal arising from a conviction under the Abkari Act for possession of contraband liquor. The appellant, Divakaran, was found on 19.11.1998 at about 5.30 p.m. with four litres of arrack in a bag containing six bottles (five bottles of 750 ml and one of 250 ml). The Excise Inspector (PW1) intercepted him, seized the contraband (Ext.P1 mahazar) and drew samples; the accused was arrested and taken to the station with the contraband, along with reports. PW3 and PW4, independent witnesses, did not support the prosecution and disowned their signatures on Ext.P1 and Ext.P2, the arrest memo, creating material doubt. PW5 supported PW1’s evidence. The main contention of the defense was that Ext.P1 was prepared on the date of occurrence but produced before the court only on 1.6.2000, as was the arrest memo Ext.P2, with no explanation for the delay, challenging the credibility of the arrest and the chain of custody. The court below convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. However, on appeal, the Kerala High Court found long delays in production of crucial documents and the final report (filed 1.6.2000) without satisfactory explanation, along with discrepancies in signatures and lack of immediate production, fatal to the prosecution. Relying on Krishnan H. v. State for the principle that unexplained delay can vitiate the case, the High Court allowed the appeal. The conviction was set aside and the appellant acquitted, with bail bonds discharged.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.272 of 2019

T.K. Chandrakanth v. Wilson Antony and Mary K.J.

This is a revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The revision petitioner, T.K. Chandrakanth, challenged the judgment in R.C.A. No. 85 of 2016 of the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-VII, Ernakulam) which, in turn, affirmed an eviction order dated 30.09.2016 under Section 11(3) of the Act directing the petitioner to surrender vacant possession of the petition schedule shop room within 45 days. The respondents sought eviction from three Rent Control Petitions for four rooms in the first floor of their building to accommodate a readymade tailoring unit by the 2nd respondent, wife of the 1st respondent, who reportedly has tailoring experience. The petitioner contested, asserting lack of bonafide need, arguing that (a) the 2nd respondent does not know tailoring, (b) there exists other vacant rooms in possession of the respondents (ground floor or upstairs) which could be used, and (c) the petitioner’s livelihood depends on the consultancy business run from the petition schedule shop room. The Commissioner’s report (Ext. C5a) suggested a small vacant room but found it unsuitable. The High Court, following well-established revisional principles (including Rukmini Amma Saradamma, T. Sivasubramaniam, Ubaiba, Hindustan Petroleum, and Thankamony Amma), held that the revision court cannot re-appreciate evidence and must examine legality, regularity, and propriety, not substitute its own findings. It concluded that the findings of the Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority were not perverse or illegal and dismissed the revision petition with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
OP(Crl) No.329/2016

Rajan v. State of Kerala and others

Rajan, the petitioner in OP(Crl) No.329/2016, challenges an order of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kottayam, that dismissed Ext.P3, the criminal complaint filed under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against respondents 2 to 8. The complaint alleged that public land (4.50 acres) in RS No. 422/7, Mannar Village, was taken by the first accused with the help of others and that a forged sale deed (document No. 1599/2003, SR0 Mannar) was executed in favour of accused 7, framed through a conspiracy and false survey pattayam numbers. The Special Court dismissed the complaint on the ground that there were no materials to support the allegations and that the property is not shown to be purambokku land; the court suggested the petitioner should have produced documents from Revenue authorities to prove land status. The petitioner challenged this order under Article 227, contending that materials existed and that cognizance should have been taken or that the matter should be investigated under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. The High Court, however, finds no jurisdiction to interfere; it notes that the core issue is whether there is sufficient basis to proceed. It further observes that the law permits rejection of a complaint at the pre-cognizance stage and treats the present dismissal as such, while granting leave to file a fresh complaint with adequate materials. Consequently, the petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No. 4439 of 2017 (D)

Kerala State Beverages (Manufacturing & Marketing) Corporation Limited v. State of Kerala & Others

These two consolidated writ petitions challenge the Kothamangalam Municipality's denial of a D&O license to the Kerala State Beverages (Manufacturing & Marketing) Corporation Ltd. for a foreign liquor shop (FL-1) relocated to a new building within the municipality, following the Supreme Court's distance-rule in State of Tamil Nadu and others v. K. Balu. The petitioner, a state-owned licensee, had operated FL-1 shop No.7054 since 2001 and sought to shift to a new building after a Shifting directive. It obtained sanction from the Excise Department (Ext. P2) and filed an application for a Trade License under Sec. 447 of the Kerala Municipality Act, asserting that re-establishment within the pre-2012 limits did not require fresh formal approval. The Municipality, citing public protest and distance considerations under the Foreign Liquor Rules, 1953, issued Ext. P4 on 07-02-2017 declining the license. A Residents' Association contended the proposed site lies within 100 metres of the SNDP Karingazha Temple, engaging the 2nd proviso to Rule 13(1) of the Foreign Liquor Rules, 1953, and argued insufficient inspection. The court held Ext. P4 arbitrary and not grounded in law, directing the Deputy Commissioner of Excise to verify whether a deity is installed in the temple to determine applicability of the distance rule. It quashed Ext. P4 and directed the Municipality to re-consider the license application within 30 days. The judgment notes the shop opened on 21-07-2017 and emphasizes compliance with Bosco Antony and Sivadasan A. precedents and related statutory provisions. The petitions were disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No.294 of 2009

N.C. Jacob and Others v. T.P. Kishore and N.M. Alley

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit O.S.1208/2003 before the I Additional Munsiff, Ernakulam, concerning a 2.370 cents plaint A schedule property with a 10-link wide pathway to the main road. The plaintiffs claim a right to the north-south common pathway (B schedule) that enters the plaint A schedule property at its north-eastern corner; they allege encroachment by the defendant, who purchased the adjacent eastern property in 1997, extended his wall, and in 2003 encroached upon the pathway, including construction of concrete steps. The trial court dismissed the suit for not pleading the nature of the right. The First Appellate Court held that the plaintiffs acquired a 10-link wide pathway by grant, extending to 14 links at the entrance, and that the defendant had encroached about 25 sq. links (B schedule). It relied on legal authorities to hold that an easement acquired by grant cannot be extinguished merely by non-use, unless there is a release by the granter. The Kerala High Court, after reappreciation, affirmed the First Appellate Court, concluding that the plaintiffs retain subsisting rights over the entire pathway and that the defendant has no exclusive right to the route. The court directed demolition of the encroached portion and affirmed injunction against interference with plaintiffs’ enjoyment under the relevant statutes. The Regular Second Appeal is therefore dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A.No.584 OF 2020

Ajumon and Anitha Kumari v. State of Kerala and Punya Prabha

The Kerala High Court, in CRL.A. No. 584 of 2020, hears an appeal challenging a pre-arrest bail order in Crime No. 2434 of 2020, Pathanamthitta Police Station, under IPC Section 498A read with SC/ST (POA) Act 3(1)(r)(s). The appellants, Ajumon and Anitha Kumari, are accused in a case arising from allegations by the defacto complainant, a member of the Scheduled Caste, that within her matrimonial home she was insulted on account of caste, harassed, and subjected to demands for money. The District Sessions Judge had dismissed their pre-arrest bail application. The appellants contend that their six-year love affair culminated in marriage on 10 June 2019; they reportedly resided together and later separated around July 2019; related Family Court and Munsiff Court proceedings occurred, including a restraining order on the plaint schedule property. They allege a false, vendetta-driven complaint. The Respondents oppose bail, pointing to ongoing investigation and the prima facie case. The High Court analyzes the “public view” requirement of the Act, noting the alleged insult occurred inside the four walls of the home where public access is lacking, making the essential ingredients unlikely at this stage. Citing Prathviraj Chauhan v. Union of India, it holds that the bar under Sections 18/18A of the Act may not apply absent a prima facie case. Consequently, the appeal is allowed and anticipatory bail is granted with conditions: bond, two solvent sureties, appearance, non-tampering with witnesses, and no new offences.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 958 OF 2012

P. D. Sadhanandan v. K. J. Joseph, Unnikrishnan Pillai, S. Suresh Kumar and National Insurance Company Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA 958 of 2012) from the Kerala High Court arising from an award by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur in OP(MV) 3675/2004 for injuries sustained by the appellant in a road accident on 03.10.2004 due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle. The Tribunal awarded a total compensation of Rs. 2,50,000 (restricted to Rs. 2,00,000) for injuries including a fracture of the humerus. The appellant contends that the amount is exiguous because the Tribunal adopted a notional income of Rs. 2,500 per month, which, he argues, undercompensates him under multiple heads. Counsel for the appellant points to the Supreme Court’s Ramachandrappa decision (2011) 13 SCC 236, which prescribes a notional income floor of Rs. 4,500 for individuals with unascertainable income in 2004, and highlights Exts. A5–A7 (medical records) and Ext. A10 (Disability Certificate) showing a 16% disability and significant functional impairment, including shortening of the right hand by half an inch. The Tribunal’s reduction to 3% disability and the modest awards under ‘Pain and Suffering’ and ‘Loss of Amenities’ are alleged to be inconsistent with the evidence. Respondents’ counsel argues the Tribunal’s calculations were correct. On review, the High Court finds the notional income adoption erroneous, applies Ramachandrappa to fix Rs. 4,500 as notional income, and enhances compensation: disability to Rs. 59,400; loss of earnings to Rs. 13,500; pain and suffering to Rs. 20,000; loss of amenities to Rs. 20,000; other heads remain. Interest at 8% and proportionate costs awarded; remuneration recoverable from the Insurance Company for the enhanced amount.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.936 of 2023

Favas K.P v. State of Kerala

This is a regular bail application filed by the sole accused, Favas K.P., in Crime No. 399 of 2022 registered at Kasargod Police Station for alleged possession of contraband (MDMA) in commercial quantity under Section 22(C) of the NDPS Act. The High Court, Kerala, heard arguments on 14 March 2023. The petitioner contends long custody since 28.04.2022, absence of criminal antecedents, and reliance on the Apex Court’s ratio in Dheeraj Kumar Shukla v. State of Uttar Pradesh to dispense with the rigour of Section 37 of the NDPS Act in cases involving commercial quantity when trial is delayed. He also notes the absence of a chemical analysis report and raises the possibility that the contraband could be methamphetamine, which would complicate the quantity classification. The Public Prosecutor counters that the recovery was red-handed, with 130 grams of the contraband, implying strong prima facie complicity, and that reliance on the Dheeraj Kumar Shukla precedent is inappropriate given the facts here (no long custody and the likelihood of an expeditious trial). The Court recalls the statutory framework of Section 37, emphasizing that bail in NDPS cases involving commercial quantity requires two conjunctive conditions: reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty and that he will not commit an offence while on bail. Ultimately the Court concludes that these conditions are not satisfied and dismisses the bail application.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No.470/2017

OP(KAT) No.470/2017

This original petition by the State of Kerala challenges a Kerala Administrative Tribunal order dated 13 January 2017 in TA 2285/2012 directing regularisation of daily-wage sweepers as part-time sweepers under GO(P) 501/2005 and subsequent GO(P) 61/2010. The respondents, five daily-wage sweepers employed since 2001–2003, sought regularisation of their service in the Directorate of Museums & Zoos and related premises, arguing that they sweep areas far exceeding 100 m2 and are covered by the government schemes. The petitioners contend that the GO/GO's do not extend to sweepers engaged in markets, streets, public gardens, etc., and that regularisation is restricted by the terms of the GO. The Tribunal had directed regularisation in line with the GO and the 2010 modifications, leading to the present challenge. The High Court, relying on Mercy v. State of Kerala (2004) and its Division Bench confirmation (2005), held that the benefit of regularisation should extend to those sweeping public places such as markets, streets, bus stands, and gardens, and that no distinction should be drawn between office-sweepers and those sweeping public places. It found no legal reason to upset the Tribunal's directions and modified the order to provide six weeks for compliance, while dismissing the petition with costs.

High Court of Kerala
OP (RC) No. 72 of 2021

I.T. Joy v. Sreelekha T.S.

This Rent Control Original Petition (OP RC 72/2021) stems from a 12(1) order under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, filed by the tenant I.T. Joy against the landlord Sreelekha T.S. for eviction of shop rooms including room 6/279C. The Rent Control Court had directed the tenant to pay arrears of Rs. 90,000 within 30 days and continue to remit rent as it fell due, during the pendency of the petition. The tenant contends that no tenancy exists for 6/279C, which was allegedly made available at the landlord’s request while two other rooms were earmarked for demolition; he argues there is no landlord-tenant relationship or title dispute regarding 6/279C and that the Rs. 6,000 rent for 6/279C is part of a separate use-and-occupation arrangement, not a tenancy. The landlord maintains that a tenancy does exist in respect of 6/279C and that the amendment to the petition schedule to include 6/279C is valid. The court examines maintainability of the petition, whether denial of landlord’s title was bona fide under Section 11(1), and the interplay of Sections 11, 12 and 18, citing case law to interpret interim versus final orders. Ultimately the bench holds there is a tenancy in 6/279C, dismisses the petition, and grants three weeks for deposit of arrears, while upholding the Rent Controller’s order in substance.

High Court of Kerala
M.A.C.A.No.563 of 2014

M.A.C.A.No.563 of 2014

This judgment arose from an appeal by Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (insurer) challenging the Quantum Award in a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal proceeding (O.P.(MV) No.1227/2007) arising from a motor accident on 16-10-2007 that killed Rakhesh, aged 42. The claimants—wife Anupama, and four dependants including two minors Vishnu and Anagha, and Hyma Raghavan (mother/next friend)—sought compensation. The Tribunal awarded Rs.25,13,720, which the insurer and claimants challenged. The High Court scrutinized Exts. A6–A7 pay slips, noting that travel allowance allegedly amounting to about Rs.7,000 per month was shown as part of salary, creating a dispute over the correct monthly income. It accepted that the pay slips were not conclusively proved as salary versus reimbursement, but proceeded with Rs.16,200 monthly income after a 10% tax deduction for computation, and a loss of dependency figure of Rs.25,51,500 (based on Rs.16,200 monthly income, 25% future prospects per Pranay Sethi, 14 years, 12 months, and 3/4 of the family’s dependents). The Court held that the Tribunal erred in applying 30% for future prospects (instead of 25% for a 42-year-old per Pranay Sethi) and found merit in the claimants’ contentions for enhanced compensation under heads such as pain and suffering, love and affection, filial/ parental consortium, and loss of estate. It also relied on Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram to justify higher awards under those heads. Finally, the Court dismissed the insurer’s appeal and allowed the cross-objection in part, increasing the total compensation by Rs.2,37,780, with interest at 7.5% on the enhanced amount and directions for deposit/disbursal to be issued by the Tribunal.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No.3501 of 2020

Crl.M.C.No.3501 of 2020 (G)

This High Court criminal misc. petition, filed by the fifth accused in CC 34/2011 before the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thrissur, challenges the final VACB report under section 482 Cr.P.C. The essential allegation is that accused 1–4, public servants, conspired to purchase cement mill internals from M/s. AIA Engineering Ltd without inviting public tenders, causing a loss to Malabar Cements Ltd. Accused 5 (K. Dileepkumar) and Accused 6 (MD of AIA Engineering Ltd) were said to participate, attracting sections 13(1)(c)/(d) read with 13(2) PC Act, 1988 and sections 409/120B IPC. Accused 6 had already been discharged in a prior order (CRL.R.P.529/2018). The petitioner contends that his role was no different from Accused 6; there is no personal act or pecuniary gain alleged against him, and liability cannot be vicarious without the company being an accused and independent material linking him to the offence. The Public Prosecutor argues that the petitioner signed the offer letter and inspected the cement mill, suggesting misstatement and potential pecuniary advantage. The Court, however, finds no specific allegation of personal acts or conspiracy against the petitioner and cites the necessity of independent material for vicarious liability. It quashes the final report against the petitioner and all proceedings in relation thereto, holding it a fit case under section 482 Cr.P.C. to do so, and closes all interlocutory applications. The judgment underscores the elements of criminal conspiracy and the requirement of independent material for officer liability.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R.Nos. 431, 432 & 433 of 2017

Krishnakumar A.V. v. Hamza Musaliyar

This is a consolidated Rent Control Revision filed as R.C.R. Nos. 431, 432 & 433 of 2017 before the Kerala High Court, challenging a common judgment of the Rent Control Appellate Authority (RCAA) dated 31-03-2017. The revision petitions, filed by Krishna kumar A.V., tenant, challenge eviction under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, on the ground of bona fide need to enable Musthafa (the landlord’s brother’s son) to start a footwear business from the petition schedule shop. The landlord contends Musthafa is a dependent of the landlord for the tenanted premises, despite his affluence and own properties; the tenants argue Musthafa is not a dependent and that the need is not bona fide. The courts below held that Musthafa qualifies as a dependent and eviction is justified under the first proviso to Section 11(3). The High Court scrutinizes the concept of dependency, explaining that the need is that of the landlord, and dependency is for the tenanted building, not merely financial dependence, citing Ismail v. Kesavan (2004) 2 56. It also clarifies that the first proviso to Section 11(3) applies to both landlord and dependent, requiring examination of whether the dependent owns another suitable building in the same city, town or village where the tenanted premises lie. Since the dependent’s other buildings are at Naduvattom and Nadakkavu (not in the same locality as Padinjare Angadi), the proviso does not negate the landlord’s case; hence revisions are dismissed with six months’ time to vacate on conditions, including arrears payment and an undertaking to vacate.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.5 of 2021

Cont.Case (C) No.5 of 2021

This Contempt of Court Case (Cont.Case (C) No.5 of 2021) before the Kerala High Court arises from petitioners who were parties in W.P.(C) No.31850/2016 challenging pension-related directions issued in 2018 and seeking higher pension entitlement under the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) framework. The petitioners, who are numerous individuals enumerated in the application, contend willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure A1 judgment dated 12.10.2018 and related matters. The matter travels through the evolution of the 2014 amendment to the pension scheme via Notification No. G.S.R. 609(E) and its subsequent validation by the Supreme Court in 2022, culminating in a detailed directive in Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO (AIR 2022 SC 5634) that the 2014 amendment is legal and applicable, with time extensions for exercise of options and alignment of pre- and post-amendment provisions with the 1995 Pension Scheme. The High Court, after hearing submissions, notes that the Apex Court’s judgment requires reconsideration of the petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension by the EPFO in light of the 2022 decision. Consequently, the contempt petition is closed, but with a clear caveat that EPFO may revisit entitlements in accordance with controlling law. The order underscores the judiciary’s role in implementing apex-court guidance within the EPF framework and signals ongoing adjustments to pension rights under statutory schemes.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.11251 of 2018

Secretary, Baithul Izza Arts and Science College v. State of Kerala and University of Calicut

This writ petition challenges an order of the University of Calicut denying affiliation for two proposed courses (B.Com Professional and B.Sc Physics) at Baithul Izza Arts and Science College, despite a prior affiliation for existing courses. The petitioner, Secretary of the college, seeks a mandamus directing the University to grant the additional affiliation based on recommendations in Exhibit P5, arguing that no Government No Objection Certificate should be required for these new programs. During the proceedings the University issued Ext.P8 on 14 May 2018 refusing the request without providing any reasons, while noting that the decision is subject to the outcome of a pending writ petition before this Court. The petitioner relies on established jurisprudence stressing the necessity of reasons in administrative orders, and contends that a reasonless decision is arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution. The respondents contend that university discretion governs affiliation and that the decision is appropriately subject to the ongoing WP; however, the Court emphasizes the principle that reasons are essential to avoid arbitrariness and to enable meaningful judicial review. The judgment ultimately sets aside Ext.P8 and directs the University to issue a reasoned order on the requested affiliation, strictly in accordance with law, within 10 days of receiving a certified copy of the judgment, leaving other contentions for further adjudication.