Crl.Appeal No.497 of 2019 This High Court of Kerala, in Crl. Appeal No.497 of 2019, heard on 23 August 2023, relates to the brutal murder of Shihab, an activist of the CPM, on 01 March 2015 in the Pavaratty area of Thrissur district. The trial court (Court of Sessions) had 11 accused; accused nos. 8 to 11 were acquitted, while accused nos. 1 to 7 were convicted of several offences including murder under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 506(ii), 326, 120B, 109, 212 and 302 read with 149 IPC, and under Section 27 of the Arms Act. The appellants challenge this conviction on grounds that the investigation was flawed, several inconsistencies plagued the eyewitness accounts, and the identification of the seven accused was unreliable. The prosecution relied heavily on ocular evidence provided by two main witnesses, PW1 (Baiju) and PW2, both linked to political affiliations, and on certain recoveries said to be supported by the statements of the accused under Section 27 IPC. The Kerala High Court undertook a thorough examination of the evidence, including the police diary, and found grave deficiencies in the investigation, substantial contradictions in PW1’s and PW2’s depositions, and a lack of independent corroboration to connect the seven appellants to the crime beyond reasonable doubt. Accordingly, the court allowed the appeal and acquitted the accused, releasing them from custody.
This writ petition challenges the State Government and Kollam Corporation’s plan to establish a comprehensive solid waste-to-energy (WTE) plant on a 2.85-hectare plot at Sakthikulangara, Kollam. The petitioner contends that the Kollam Corporation owns sufficient land at Kureepuzha and that earlier attempts to site a plant there were halted by a committee’s report (Ext.P1), which recommended identifying an alternate site. The matter has traversed multiple fora: Writ petitions in 2011 and 2018; National Green Tribunal (NGT) orders directing site identification; and a propensity of orders and counter-orders concerning land acquisition, CRZ considerations, and the status of legacy waste removal. The petition asserts that the present proposed site at Sakthikulangara is unsuitable, that the exact site details have not been transparently disclosed, and that the CRZ and Devaswom land questions complicate the project. Respondents insist that the government’s policy aims at a modern, state-of-the-art WTE facility and that there is no embargo on using Kollam Corporation’s land; NGT directives and policy analysis justify moving forward, and an alternate site has not been found. The court, emphasizing that Ext.P1 is a court-ordered expert report rather than an adjudicatory finding, ultimately held that the petition lacks merit and dismissed the writ petition.
This CrL MC 2736/2023 concerns a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by accused Nos. 1 to 6 in CC No.206/2017 of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-I, Changanacherry. The petition arises from Crime No. 3069/2016 of Changanacherry Police Station, involving offences punishable under IPC sections 143, 147, 149, 323 and 294(b) for allegedly restraining the de facto complainant and others and causing injuries on 11.11.2016 around 4.30 p.m. The petitioners submit that the disputes between the parties have been amicably settled, supported by affidavits from respondents 1 to 4 stating they have no grievance and do not wish to proceed. The court directed the investigating officer to verify the genuineness of the settlement and to report on any criminal antecedents or impediments to termination of proceedings. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, but acknowledged no other complaints against the petitioners. Relying on a line of Supreme Court precedents culminating in State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and related decisions, the court outlined the constitutional framework for exercising Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences when the civil character predominates and a genuine settlement exists, while excluding heinous or public interest offences. After weighing gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the settlement’s genuineness, the court held that quashing would promote ends of justice and would not adversely affect society. Annexure A records the Final Report and quashes all further proceedings in CC 206/2017.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 2842 of 2023) decided by a Single Judge of the High Court of Kerala (Hon. Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V.) on 29 May 2023. The petitioner-accused challenges the continuation of CC No. 989/2019 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-II, Hosdurg, alleging offences under Sections 341, 324 and 506(ii) IPC. The prosecution’s case is that on 15 October 2019 the petitioner restrained the second respondent and attacked him with a stone, causing injuries. The petitioner invokes Section 482 CrPC to quash the proceedings on the ground that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by an affidavit from the injured stating no grievance. The court directed the investigating officer to record the de facto complainant’s statement and to report whether the settlement is genuine and whether there are any antecedents or impediments to terminating the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, but acknowledged no other impediments. After examining the records and considering the gravity of the allegations, injuries, and the parties’ reconciled relations, the judge relied on authorities such as Gian Singh and Narinder Singh to hold that Section 482 CrPC can quash non-compoundable offences with a predominantly civil character when disputes are fully resolved. Given the private nature of the dispute and lack of societal impact, the court allowed the petition and quashed Annexure- AII Final Report and all further proceedings in CC 989/2019.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India concerns the loan account of BINOY PAULOSE, proprietor of Darshana Cinema Complex, Piravom. The petitioner borrowed from South Indian Bank in 2015 for theatre renovation and mortgaged lands and buildings. After default, the bank classified the loan as NPA on 29 December 2020 and initiated SARFAESI proceedings, obtaining symbolic possession. In a prior order in W.P.(C) 25727/2021 (30 November 2022), this Court directed the bank to consider restructuring or One Time Settlement (OTS) and to decide within two weeks, while suspending further SARFAESI actions pending decision; the bank invited Ext.P13 for restructuring and issued Ext.P14 denying relief. The petitioner submitted Ext.P13, proposing a restructuring plan with reworked repayment and exploiting cash flows from agriculture and sale of property, but the bank rejected it, citing lack of commercial viability, nil credit turnover in KCC accounts since 2018, and a net loss of Rs 1.17 crore. The bank argued that, under RBI Circulars of 6 August 2020 and 5 May 2021, agricultural loans were not eligible for restructuring; the COVID-19 relief window had closed, and viability lies with the lender. The High Court held that lending decisions are commercial, deferential to the lender’s discretion, and cannot substitute its judgment absent compelling reasons; thus the petition was dismissed. The Court also cites that RBI guidelines provide broad reliefs but lending remains the lender’s prerogative.
W.P.(C) No. 16457 of 2023 The petitioners, devotees of Goddess Bhadrakali at Pattazhy Devi Temple (under Travancore Devaswom Board), files this writ petition under Article 226 seeking mandamus to direct the Additional District Magistrate, Kollam to consider Ext.P15 (dated 05.04.2022) under Rule 150 of the Kerala Petroleum Rules, 2002, and to order the Kerala State Pollution Control Board (KSPCB) to undertake a fresh hearing on revocation of consent and to examine the existence of four other residential buildings within the prohibited 30-meter distance from the proposed Nayara Energy petrol retail outlet. They also seek restraining orders against Nayara Energy Limited (9th respondent) and other related parties. The matter traces to a prior writ petition (WP(C) No.24300 of 2021) disposed by Ext.P13 (23.03.2022) with a direction that the Travancore Devaswom Board or any person interested may challenge the proceedings before the appropriate forum, and costs imposed on Subhash R. Ext.P15 attempts to cancel a No Objection Certificate under Rule 150, which, the Court notes, is beyond Rule 150’s scope as Rule 150 concerns cancellation only if the licensee ceases to have the right to store petroleum and requires due process. The Court cites mandamus jurisprudence to emphasize that mandamus issues only to enforce a legal duty, not to contravene statutory provisions. It ultimately disposes of the petition by directing the KSPCB’s Environmental Engineer to decide the revocation matter with due notices, in accordance with law, and deprecates the petitioners’ conduct (costs already paid) while noting pending PSC Board proceedings. The judgment closes with directions rather than granting relief sought in Ext.P15.
CRL.M.C. NO. 8420 OF 2023 This High Court of Kerala, in a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC, quashes the prosecution against the petitioner, Sayed Shebeeb V.P., in Crime No.1431/2023 of Kodungallur Police Station, registering offences under Sections 365, 342, 323, 324 and 506 r/w 34 IPC. The petitioner contends that the dispute with the victim has been settled, and the victim has filed an affidavit supporting the settlement; hence, the prosecution should be quashed. The Public Prosecutor, while expressing reservations about quashing non‑compoundable offences solely on the basis of settlement, concedes that the matter is settled. The court carefully reviews the records and cites Supreme Court jurisprudence including State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), which holds that the power under Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences can be exercised where there is a civil/private dispute and the entire dispute has been resolved, with exceptions for heinous crimes and offences under special statutes. It also references Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab and others for the legal framework. The court notes the private nature of the dispute and accepts the settlement, holding that quashing is appropriate after evidence is gathered, and thereby allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes all further proceedings against the petitioner.
OP (CAT) Nos. 188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015 This batch of four Original Petitions under OP (CAT) arises from challenges to orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal granting financial upgradation of Grade Pay in the promotion hierarchy to employees belonging to the Naval Armament Depot and related civil services, as well as to personnel in All India Radio and Central Public Works Department, Kerala. The CAT had allowed the petitioners’ prayers in several OA Nos., directing upgradation of Grade Pay. The Union of India and the other petitioners contended that such financial upgradation is not permissible under the governing pay rules and DoPT/O.M. guidelines, and that the matter is squarely covered by the Supreme Court’s decision in Union of India v. M V Mohanan Nair (2020), which restrained upgradation in the promotion ladder. The respondents in the original applications (employees) argued that the CAT orders followed a longstanding practice and that DoPT memoranda, together with the Central Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008, permit progression by upgradation in certain circumstances. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, references Mohanan Nair, noting the similarity of issues, and ultimately allows the petitions, setting aside the CAT orders in light of the Mohanan Nair decision.
CRL.M.C Nos. 3965 of 2023; 3977 of 2023; 3979 of 2023; 3986 of 2023; 3991 of 2023; 4003 of 2023; 4005 of 2023; 4017 of 2023 (connected matters) These petitions challenge multiple orders issued under Section 111 CrPC read with Section 107 CrPC by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Fort Kochi, directing the petitioners to attend and show cause why they should not execute cash bonds for keeping peace for up to one year. The orders are identically worded and anchored to information from the North Paravur Police Station, yet the petitioners argue there was no material establishing an imminent breach of peace; the Magistrate’s mind was not applied, and the police dictates appeared to drive the process. The court scrutinises the procedure under Section 107 CrPC, emphasizing that the jurisdiction to proceed is conditioned on the Magistrate’s independent satisfaction of sufficient grounds, with the grounds then recorded in the 111 CrPC order. Relying on classic authorities such as Moidu v. State of Kerala, Peethambaran v. State of Kerala, Madhu Limaye v. SDM Monghyr, and more recent Kerala decisions (Santhosh M.V. and Others; Bejoy K.V.), the court cautions against automatic actions or vague, generic information. The object is preventive, not punitive; hence cogent materials are essential. In the absence of material demonstrating probable breach of peace, the orders lack foundation and are liable to be quashed. Consequently, the court quashes all proceedings against the petitioners in the connected CrMCs and directs Annexure A orders to be set aside.
Reshma Divakaran, an applicant for the post of Munsiff-Magistrate in the Kerala Judicial Service, approached the Kerala High Court with a writ petition challenging a notification that provided relaxation of marks for Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidates only at the viva-voce stage, and not for the preliminary or main examinations. The petitioner contends that such relaxation should extend to the preliminary and main examinations to prevent unjust exclusions of SC/ST candidates who secure lower marks in written tests. She had applied for both NCA vacancies (Serial Nos. 8 and 9) and 47 regular vacancies. Ext.P1 notification (dated 30.06.2020) stated that relaxation would be applicable only for viva-voce, with shortlisting to follow the preliminary examination in a 1:10 ratio for the notified vacancies. The petitioner asserts that the relaxation in the viva-voce alone is illegal and demands re-fixation of the ratio to include candidates who would be eligible if preliminary and main examinations were relaxed as well. The respondent argues the notification explicitly limits relaxation to viva-voce, and that the shortlisting already applied the 1:10 ratio, with the last shortlisted candidate having 87 marks in the SC category and 82 marks in a regular vacancy; the petitioner had 70 marks. The court, citing Apex Court decisions on acquiescence, held that the petitioner’s challenge after participating in the selection process is impermissible, and that the notification’s terms were not violated. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed.
This public interest writ petition (WP(C).No.12073 of 2021) concerns Lakshadweep island residents amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Nasih K.K. seeks urgent relief including mandamus to ensure food kits (rice and provisions) and direct cash transfers under the National Food Security Act to enable residents to purchase food during the lockdown and curfews. He argues that, with a population largely dependent on daily wage livelihoods (fishing, coconut cultivation, coir twisting) and restricted movement due to curfews, the right to life under Article 21 includes access to basic necessities. He relies on Ashok v. Union of India (AIR 1997 SC 2298) to support the claim that life encompasses dignity and sustenance. The UT Lakshadweep administration and Union Government respond that there is no starvation or shortage of essentials; they claim adequate stock of rice and supplies, extensive NFSA implementation, PM-GKAY distributions, and subsidized provisioning across the islands. They contend that Section 34 of the Disaster Management Act, 2005 and other regulatory measures empower district authorities to act according to ground realities, and that mandamus cannot compel all actions. The Division Bench noted ongoing measures and after hearing, disposed of the petition, denying the requested reliefs while acknowledging the authorities’ actions during the lockdown.
This Regular First Appeal challenges a trial court decree for specific performance of a contract for sale. The trial court refixed the sale consideration at Rs. 11,000 per cent, deviating from the Rs. 8,750 per cent agreed in the contract, relying on Supreme Court precedents. The High Court examines whether a court trying a suit for specific performance can dictate terms and conditions of the contract, or modify the price, under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. It concludes that a court cannot alter the terms or substitute the contract while enforcing it, though it may exercise equity to compensate the plaintiff by ordering an additional sum if warranted. The decision traces several apex court authorities—Pratap Lakshman Muchandi; Her Highness Maharani Shantidevi Gaikwad; A.C. Arulappan; Antony K.O.; Tejram; Kanshi Ram; S. Rangaraju Naidu; Azhar Sultana; Gobind Ram; and Damacherla Anjaneyulu—emphasizing that discretion under Section 20 is negative (not to grant specific performance) and can be used to strike a balance by awarding damages or a supplemental sum, sometimes via conditional decrees. Ultimately, the court holds that the contract terms cannot be varied for specific performance; instead, equity may be achieved through a monetary compensation. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed in part, and a monetary decree of Rs.3,10,000 is awarded against the defendants.
This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal arising from a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, filed by Girish, the appellant-pillion rider, for injuries sustained in a road collision on 07.12.2003 involving a car driven by the 1st respondent and a scooter insured by the 4th respondent. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Muvattupuzha, partly allowed the petition, awarding Rs 87,000 but holding contributory negligence by both drivers at 50%, resulting in a net award of Rs 43,500 with interest. The appellant challenged both the finding of contributory negligence and the quantum of compensation. The High Court relies on Ext A5 charge sheet and precedents such as Mohammed Siddique, Pazhaniammal, and Ramachandrappa to reject the Tribunal’s finding of contributory negligence against the appellant and to assess notional income as Rs 4,000 per month for the year 2003. The court recalculates heads of compensation: loss of earnings Rs 16,000; disability 5% Rs 40,800; loss of amenities Rs 15,000; bystander expenses Rs 3,500, etc., totaling Rs 1,24,650. The appeal is allowed in part, enhancing compensation by Rs 81,150; the insurer is to deposit this sum with interest at 8.5% p.a. within 60 days, and the Tribunal to disburse the enhanced amount with costs.
This writ appeal, brought by Palakkad Municipality and its Secretary, challenges a learned Single Judge’s order in WP(C)133/2021 (dated 18 January 2021) quashing Exhibit P2, a building-permit rejection for Devadas’ property. The Single Judge found the permit impermissible since the site lay within the Ayyapuram–Ramanathapuram Approved DTP Scheme and appeared in the data bank as paddy land, with a road-widening proposal. He directed the Municipality to consider the application untrammelled by the DTP Scheme and to pass orders within three weeks after hearing the writ petitioner. The Municipality contends Exhibit P2 was based on a mistaken scheme designation and that the site is actually outside the scheme area, supported by Revenue Divisional Officer order (Exhibit P4) removing the property from the Paddy land data bank. It argues that there is no approved DTP Scheme for the area; even if a scheme exists, provisions of the Kerala Town and Country Planning Act, 2016, and master plans must be reconciled with the building rules. The writ petitioner contends there is no operative scheme and that deprivation of permit is arbitrary. The Division Bench holds that a valid Town Planning Scheme in force prevails over building rules, and the Municipality must decide the permit taking into account any existing scheme and the purchaser notice under Section 67 of Act 2016; the appeal is partly allowed.
This is an OP (LC) filed by the management of ID No. 31/2009 before the Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court (Ernakulam) challenging a preliminary order (Ext.P12) dated 24/08/2012 issued by the 2nd respondent. The dispute relates to a reference under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, concerning the justifiability of the discharge of a workman after disciplinary proceedings that began in 1999. The disciplinary process involved ex parte proceedings against the workman; a de novo enquiry was ordered after the disciplinary authority found the charges proved but believed natural justice required further opportunity. The workman objected that the disciplinary authority lacked plenary power to order a de novo enquiry. The Labour Court held that the disciplinary authority could not order a fresh enquiry unless empowered by statute, rule, award, or settlement, and therefore the de novo enquiry was invalid. The petitioner contended that de novo enquiry could be justified where an order violates natural justice. The Labour Court’s approach was supported by authorities, but the High Court ultimately did not interfere, noting that the petitioner had not shown patent perversity. While acknowledging several precedents (Chelamattom; St. Thomas Mission Hospital; SBI-related cases), the Court dismissed the petition, while reserving the petitioner’s right to challenge the preliminary order along with the final order as per Chelamattom.
This Regular Second Appeal, filed under Section 100 read with Order XIV Rule 1 CPC, arises from OS 796/2012 (Parts of the property partition suit) and AS 196/2015 in which the trial court and the Additional District Court, Irinjalakkuda, passed a preliminary decree of partition in favour of 1/5th shares to the plaintiffs and the legal heirs of Lonappan and Devassy. The appellants (defendants 1–4 and 6–8 in OS 796/2012) challenged the preliminary partition decree and the related appellate judgment, contending that an oral partition had already taken place about 36 years ago, with possession and construction evidencing separate shares. The trial court rejected the oral-partition contention, holding the properties partitionable and directing division into five equal shares with respective shares allotted. The appellate court agreed, noting lack of clear delineation in the commission report and the absence of definitive boundaries supporting oral partition. The High Court closed on the position that no substantial question of law was formulated and that the second appeal could not be entertained merely on grounds of misapprehension of evidence or questions of fact. It cited leading authorities on the requirement of a substantial question of law for admit/further adjudication. Ultimately, the High Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the concurrent decrees and allowing the partition to stand as decided by the courts below.
B.A.No.5327/2021; B.A.No.5527/2021 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Rahul R.U., the first accused in Crime No. 240/2021 of Museum Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The case concerns a scheme to siphon funds allotted for Scheduled Caste welfare through forged applications and bank accounts, allegedly masterminded by the petitioner who served as Senior Clerk in the SCD office. By forging applications and incorporating bank account details of accused persons, he is claimed to have transferred Rs. 79,52,693 to their accounts and, with their connivance, withdrew the amount, misappropriating public funds meant for the poor. Accused Nos. 2–11 are said to be relatives or close associates; the fourth accused was a clerk; the fifth and eleventh accused were SC Promoters. The investigation is at a nascent stage, and the court noted the petitioner absconded and was later remanded; the prosecution contends a deep-rooted conspiracy and serious offences. The court discussed bail principles, citing Supreme Court guidance on non-bailable offences, the gravity of economic offences, and the need to balance fair investigation against detention. Although some co-accused received anticipatory or regular bail, the court held parity does not favor the petitioner due to his role as mastermind. Ultimately, the bail application was dismissed to safeguard investigations and prevent witness tampering and further loss to the State.
R.C.R.No.94 of 2021 is a Kerala High Court rent control revision challenging an eviction order under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The landlords sought eviction of tenant Raghavan from a building originally owned by late Dr. George A. Mathew to start a Multi-Specialty Hospital. The Rent Control Court at Karunagapalli passed eviction on 19.07.2019, holding that the denial of landlord-tenant relationship by the tenant was not bona fide, and that the landlords had a genuine need and that the tenant defaulted in rent. The Rent Control Appellate Authority, Kollam, confirmed the eviction on 27.02.2021. The tenant filed this revision under Section 20 of the Act. On 21.10.2021, a Division Bench heard arguments and analyzed the locus of the dispute, considering whether there exists a landlord-tenant relationship and whether the eviction grounds and limitations (provisos) were satisfied. The court relied on jurisprudence such as Parthakumar v. Ajith Viswanathan to confine Section 11 jurisdiction to bona fide denial, while treating registered lease Ext. A1 as valid per Prem Singh, and applying fiduciary-duty principles from Krishna Mohan Kul. The High Court affirmed the concurrent factual findings and dismissed the revision, holding no interference with the eviction order. The decision underscores the need for genuine, present occupancy needs and preserves the landlord’s recourse through eviction where legally warranted.
This is a habeas corpus petition challenging a COFEPOSA detention order (Section 3(1)) of a person named Sunil Kumar Mohanakumaran Thambi, detained after a gold-smuggling case in which 25 gold bars totaling 24.998 kg were seized at Thiruvananthapuram airport. The detenu was arrested in May 2019 and ultimately detained on 27 September 2019, with execution of the order only on 21 January 2021. The Advisory Board met on 23 March 2021 and recommended confirmation; the Central Government confirmed the detention on 13 April 2021. The petitioner contends that several procedural and substantive defects vitiate the detention: (i) representations dated 18 December 2019 (made prior to execution) and 10 April 2021 were not properly considered; (ii) requests for CCTV footage (Exts. P4–P6) were not placed before the Advisory Board; (iii) statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act were not voluntary; (iv) the detaining authority did not adequately consider the bail order and conditions granted by the Kerala High Court on 2 July 2019; (v) there was a substantial delay between passing and executing the detention order, breaking the live link between the grounds of detention and its objective. The respondents argued the detenu’s role in the smuggling network and justified the delay. The Kerala High Court ultimately held that the delay in execution, combined with the detenu’s absconding, severed the live link between the grounds and the detention, and quashed the detention order, ordering the detenu’s release forthwith.
W.P.(C) Nos. 9241/2021; 25720/2021; 35870/2022 The batch of writ petitions concerns the Temple Advisory Committee of Sree Krishna Swamy Temple, Neyyattinkara, under the Travancore Devaswom Board. The central issues are: (i) the vigilance inquiry into the 2016-18 procurement of Anjili wood for temple renovation and the proper disposition of the timber in possession of the Board; (ii) the statutory framework governing Temple Advisory Committees formed under Section 31A of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, and the related Rules governing committee formation, membership, term, duties and financial governance; and (iii) challenges to electoral and administrative actions affecting Committee membership, including Ext.P1 circulars and Ext.P10 orders. The petitioners in different slices sought mandamus to ensure due procedures, quash Enquiry Ext.P9, or challenge elections and removals from voters lists. The respondents contended that there were procedural lapses in wood procurement, and that the vigilance inquiry and election-related actions were within statutory power and proper safeguards. The High Court, after considering statutory provisions, precedents on writs versus statutory remedies, and the factual matrix, held that Ext.P9 could not be quashed in a writ petition given an efficacious alternative remedy, declined to interfere with election-related orders, and dismissed the certiorari challenge in the 2021 petition, disposing of the connected matters with directions.