Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 492 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 8404 OF 2022

Muhammed Ajmal v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court Criminal Misc. Case (CrL.MC No. 8404 of 2022) challenges Annexure 4, a 18.10.2022 order extending the detention period beyond 180 days under the NDPS Act, in respect of Crime No. 470/2022 of Kunnamkulam Police Station, Thrissur district. Petitioner Muhammed Ajmal (Accused No.3) argues the extension was granted on a report filed by the Investigating Officer (Annexure 3) rather than on a report by the Public Prosecutor as mandated by Section 36-A(4) NDPS Act, and that the statutory bail application was improperly dismissed as a result. The NDPS case involves accused Nos. 1 and 2 possessing 10.80 grams of MDMA; Ajmal allegedly procured the contraband and handed it to them. The prosecution contends Ajmal was in custody since 04.04.2022 and that Annexure 3 reflects progress of investigation. The petitioner relies on Hitendra Vishnu Thakur, Sanjay Kumar Kedia, Appukuttan, Nayantara Gupta and other decisions to argue for strict adherence to the statutory process, including the necessity of Public Prosecutor’s independent mind, and the requirement of notice to the accused for extensions. The High Court analyzes the statutory text and cited authorities and holds Annexure 4 void ab initio for non-compliance with the proviso to Section 36-A(4). Consequently, Annexure 4 is set aside and the petitioner’s statutory bail is allowed subject to conditions pending further proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos.84/2018; OT.Rev Nos.75/2018; OT.Rev Nos.78/2018; OT.Rev Nos.77/2018; OT.Rev Nos.79/2018; OT.Rev Nos.80/2018; OT.Rev Nos.82/2018; OT.Rev Nos.81/2018; OT.Rev Nos.86/2018; OT.Rev Nos.91/2018; OT.Rev Nos.92/2018; OT.Rev Nos.94/2018

OT.Revision Nos.84 of 2018 & connected cases (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

This batch of OT revisions challenges a common order of the Kerala VAT Appellate Tribunal dated 5 March 2018 in T.A.(VAT) No.564 of 2014 and Cross Objection Nos.2 of 2016, along with several connected cases. The petitions, filed by the State/Revenue, target the scope of reassessment under Section 25 of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003, in contexts where dealers had opted for compounding of tax under Section 8, and where deemed self‑assessment under Section 21 interacts with reassessment under Section 25. The High Court referred the matter to a Full Bench due to divergent opinions in prior decisions such as C.C. Sebastian v State of Kerala and State of Kerala v Muhammed Ali A.M. (2017) 25 KTR 73. On 31 March 2022, the Full Bench held that reassessment under Section 25 is comprehensive and can be invoked in cases of escaped assessment, under‑assessment, under‑or over‑taxed turnovers, or impermissible deductions, and that acceptance of a compounded rate does not immunize against reassessment. The bench clarified that the powers under Sections 25, 56 and 66 are separate and independently exercisable. Consequently, the Tribunal’s impugned order was set aside, and the OT revisions were allowed and remitted to the Tribunal for fresh consideration on merits, expeditiously.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A.No.418/2021

BALU v. STATE OF KERALA

BALU, a migrant laborer from Tamil Nadu, stands before the Kerala High Court in CRL.A. No. 418 of 2021 challenging a trial court judgment convicting him for murder following a chain-snatching incident in Irinjalakuda. The prosecution’s case rests on a chain snatched from a housewife who was found dead in a pond; MO1 (chain) and MO2 (rings) and MO3 (watches) recovered from the accused or his companions, and the accused allegedly fleeing to Tamil Nadu after the incident. The court scrutinizes whether the death amounted to murder under Section 300 IPC or culpable homicide under Section 299 IPC, considering the three limbs of Sec.299 and the four limbs of Sec.300, guided by classic authorities such as Virsa Singh, Rajwant, Kali Ram and others. It discusses the interpretation of mens rea, knowledge, and the proximity of the accused’s acts to the death, while evaluating the reliability of identifications and the circumstantial chain connecting the accused to the crime, including discovery of the ornaments from a pawn shop and subsequent purchases in A2’s name. While noting some procedural and evidentiary concerns, the Bench upholds that the prosecution has established a causal nexus and the requisite intent, leading to a sustained conviction. The appeal is dismissed and the impugned judgment is confirmed in toto.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 38727 OF 2022

Sajith V. S. v. Central Board of Secondary Education & Ors.

Petitioner Sajith V. S., a student of St. Thomas Central School affiliated to CBSE, seeks correction of his date of birth in CBSE records. The school had 26.10.1988 as his DOB, while a birth certificate issued by the Corporation of Thiruvananthapuram shows 23.10.1987, and the CBSE mark sheet bears the same erroneous date. The petitioner submitted Ext.P6 on 20.06.2022 seeking rectification. Counsel for the petitioner contends that the issue of DOB correction has been set at rest by the Supreme Court in Jigya Yadav v CBSE (2021 (3) KLT 711(SC)), though the question of limitation was left open; therefore the CBSE should entertain the application and pass orders in accordance with law. The respondents argue Regulation 69.3 of the CBSE Examination Byelaws prescribes a five-year limitation for entertaining corrections, but do not deny directions in Jigya Yadav about undertakings and affidavits. The Court observes that Byelaw amendments are pending, and that the Ananthu Ashok v. Regional Office, CBSE (W.P. No.29182 of 2021) has guided a remedy by requiring an affidavit, indemnity bond, and public notice in some cases. The court therefore allows the petitioner to pursue a fresh application and directs the Board to consider it in light of Jigya Yadav and Ananthu Ashok, issuing procedural directions: the 3rd respondent to forward the application within one week, and the 2nd respondent to entertain and decide within three months. The writ petition is disposed.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O. No.72 of 2020

K. P. Ahmed Kunji v. Sheela Pradeepan and others

In FAO No.72 of 2020, filed against an order dated 07.11.2017 in I.A. Nos. 3861 and 3862 of 2017 in O.S. No. 461 of 2013 of the Principal Sub Court, Ernakulam, the appellant K. P. Ahmed Kunji challenges the dismissal of his appeal for restoration of the suit and condonation of delay. The suit sought a decree directing respondents to convey a proportionate undivided share in the suit property under a 2006 agreement, and to execute a required conveyance deed for a constructed apartment complex. The trial court dismissed the suit for default on 23.05.2017 after the appellant’s non-appearance; a counter-claim was decreed ex parte. The applications to restore the suit on file and to condone the delay were denied in a common order. The appellant argued that his age (71), chronic ailments, and a stroke, corroborated by a certificate dated 01.03.2017, prevented attendance on the trial date; thus there was sufficient cause. The respondents argued there was persistent inaction. The High Court, after summarizing the relevant CPC provisions (Order IX, Rules 8 and 9) and surveying leading precedents—Robin Thapa, Esha Bhattacharjee, State (NCT of Delhi) v. Ahmed Jaaan, Sangeetha v. Shibu, Raj Kishore Pandey, Plantation Corp. Kerala v. Hussain, O. P. Kathpalia—concludes that the delay and non-appearance do not warrant restoration. The appeal is devoid of merit and is dismissed, with no costs. Observing that repeated defaults and lack of evidence to prove “sufficient cause” undermine the appellant’s case, the court refused to disturb the trial court’s order and affirmed dismissal.

High Court of Kerala
DBP NO.56 OF 2022

Suo Motu v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others (DBP No. 56 of 2022)

This High Court of Kerala, in DBP No. 56 of 2022, exercises suo motu jurisdiction to examine complaints about Sabarimala darshan and crowd management during Mandala-Makaravilakku season. The petition references the Travancore Devaswom Board’s (TD Board) administration of Sabarimala and related temples, and the use of a Virtual-Q system for crowd control. The court outlines the statutory framework: the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, particularly Sections 15A (duties of the Board to ensure rites, monitor staff, and maintain facilities), 24 (maintenance and administration of Devaswoms from the Devaswom Fund), and 31 (management of Devaswoms). It recalls prior jurisprudence, notably Suo Motu v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Others (2022 Ker) 20737/2022 SCC OnLine Ker 2185, and SSCR No.23 of 2022, concerning the Virtual-Q system and crowd management at Sabarimala, including authorities’ roles and privacy considerations under IT Rules. The Court stresses that crowd management must balance worshippers’ rights with safe access, and lays down concrete directions: the 3rd row as a buffer zone, CCTV, police vigilance at Pathinettampadi and Sopanam, and the transfer of Virtual-Q ownership and responsibility to the Board with IT-safety compliance, while preserving Kerala Police access for security. The matter is disposed of with these directions, subject to ongoing SSCR No.23/2022.

High Court of Kerala
FAO Nos.120 and 156 of 2016

Col. Josy Joseph v. Ouseph and Litty Joseph

This is a Division Bench judgment of the Kerala High Court arising from two connected first appeals (FAO Nos.120 and 156 of 2016) challenging a common order dated 10.03.2016 of the Sub Court, Perumbavoor, in O.S.189 of 2011. The suit, filed for partition by the plaintiff (father of the appellant) against the appellant (the 1st defendant) and the 2nd defendant, culminated in ex parte decrees against the appellant on two occasions (30.10.2013 and 03.09.2015), and an accompanying ex parte preliminary decree on 03.09.2015 with the counter claim dismissed. The appellant invoked Order IX Rules 9, 13 and related provisions seeking to set aside the ex parte decree and restore the counter claim (I.A.Nos.1087, 1088, 1085 and 1086 of 2015). The High Court considered whether the delay (about 35 days) and the appellant’s circumstances, including a fracture and hospitalisation on 03.09.2015, constituted sufficient cause for condonation under Section 5 of the Limitation Act and liberal interpretation under precedents such as Katiji, G.P. Srivastava, and Esha Bhattacharjee. Relying on these authorities and subsequent Kerala decisions (Peeves Enterprises; M. Shivananda; Rafeek v. Kamarudeen), the court held that a liberal, justice-oriented approach is warranted where there is no mala fide intent. Consequently, the appeals were allowed: the ex parte preliminary decree was set aside, the counter claim restored, and the matter directed to be disposed of by the Sub Court within four months of receiving a certified copy. The decision emphasizes balancing timely justice with substantive rights, and endorses a pragmatic approach to condonation of delay.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 69 of 2023

M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. v. State of Kerala and Asianet Satellite Communication Ltd.

This is a Kerala High Court judgment by Justice A. Badharudeen, rendered on 11 January 2023, in Crl.M.C. No.69 of 2023, arising from CC 159/2017 in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court XII, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner, Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd., seeks to quash a criminal complaint under Section 482 CrPC filed by Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. The complainant alleges that the first accused, through the second and third accused as authorised signatories, executed three cheques for Rs. 5,05,620 each, in discharge of a debt related to channel carriage and placement, which were dishonoured in 2014. The petitioner contends that, even assuming a legally enforceable debt existed, the liability was discharged by payments reflected in Annexure A6, including a Rs.40 lakh payment by demand draft on 08.06.2015; thus the substratum of the case allegedly no longer exists. The respondents contend that mere bank statements do not prove discharge of liability without evidence and that the matter should be left for trial. The court cites Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi and a string of Supreme Court decisions detailing when a complaint may be quashed, emphasizing the sparing nature of the power and that quashing is warranted only when the complaint fails to disclose essential elements or constitutes abuse of process. The High Court ultimately holds that the prayer to quash is meritless, dismisses the petition, and leaves the prosecution to proceed to trial, noting that discharge questions require evidence at trial rather than pre-trial determination.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 30861 of 2010

Pushpalatha v. State of Kerala & ors (KuttiKol Service Co-operative Bank Ltd and Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies as respondents)

Pushpalatha, a candidate in Kasaragod district, filed WP(C) No. 30861 of 2010 seeking a mandamus to be appointed as Junior Clerk in the KuttiKol Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. She argued she stood second in the Ext.P1 rank list prepared after a Kerala Co-operative Service Examination Board test conducted under the Kerala Cooperative Societies Act, 1969, with Section 80B. The first rank holder was appointed in March 2009 but resigned on 30 September 2009. Despite vacancies, the bank, facing sustained losses, decided on 30 September 2010 to run with existing staff and not fill vacancies. The petitioner invoked Ext.P3, a judgment in W.A.1461/08 (dated 25 January 2010), asserting she was similarly situated and entitled to appointment. The respondents contended financial difficulties justify non-appointment and argued that mere inclusion of a name in a ranked list does not create an indefeasible right to appointment, citing Dr. K. Ramulu and others (1997) and Director, SCTI for Medical Science & Technology and another v. Pushkaran (2008) to support this position. The court observed the bank had initially decided to fill two Junior Clerk posts in 2007, paid salary to the first rank holder for six months, and that a blanket refusal based on finances cannot defeat the appointment rights of the next eligible candidate. It granted an interim order directing provisional appointment to the petitioner by 5 February 2011, noting the validity of the ranked list would expire on 6 February 2011, and closed the writ petition after the interim relief. The judgment underscores that financial considerations cannot permanently bar a pending rightful claim where a vacancy exists and a prima facie case is made.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 853 of 2021

Laxman Kappacheri v. Padmini, Kamala, Sarojini, Prasanna and Pushpavall

This regular second appeal arises from a partition dispute O.S.244 of 2010 in the Subordinate Court, Thalassery. A preliminary decree dated 28.01.2015 ordered partition of the properties among the co-owners, and a Commissioner prepared reports (C1–C6) including share lists and accounts. A final decree (FDIA 1000/2015) was passed, distributing the residential house to the appellant’s share and directing owelty payments for equalization. The appellant challenged the final decree in A.S.No.15/2019; the District Court/did, on 25.03.2021, dismiss the appeal, holding there was no illegality in the allotment and that the final decree complied with the Commissioner’s report. The appellant filed RSA 853/2021 before the Kerala High Court. The High Court underscored that a Second Appeal is maintainable only if a substantial question of law is involved, citing the test from Sir Chunilal V. Mehta and Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal. On merits, it found that the Commissioner’s report (Exts. C1–C6) was accepted by all parties, no objections were raised, and the final decree was framed accordingly. It concluded there was no substantial question of law, and dismissed the appeal as not admitted with no costs. The decision emphasizes the narrow scope of appellate review in partition cases where the lower decree reflects the parties’ agreement.

High Court of Kerala
RCR No.156 of 2022

Subair and others v Abdul Jaleel and others

This is a Rent Control Revision (RCR No.156 of 2022) filed by five tenants challenging an eviction order under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court (Principal Munsiff-I, Kozhikode) allowed eviction on the ground of bona fide need by the landlords to start a readymade and fancy shop in the petition schedule shop and an adjacent unit, while denying eviction under Section 11(2)(b). The Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-IV, Kozhikode) affirmed the eviction on 23.12.2021. The tenants approached the High Court under Section 20, arguing the finding of bona fide need was perverse and illegal. The High Court, after considering arguments and a string of precedents, held that bona fide need must be genuine, real, and not a mere pretext; it acknowledged that even a well-off landlord can have a genuine need for own occupation, provided the need is shown to be natural, sincere and honest. The Court found no perversity in the findings of the lower authorities. Consequently, the revision petition was dismissed, but six months’ time to surrender possession was granted with conditions: unconditional affidavit of vacating within six months, deposit of arrears, continued rent payments, prohibition on third-party induction, and operation of business only with proper licenses. The decision upholds eviction while moderating the timeline due to Covid-19 considerations.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 2446 OF 2021

K.K.SAROJINI v. C.K.RUGMAGADAN and others

This High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) review concerns OP(C) No. 2446 of 2021, challenging Ext.P4 in IA 2 of 2021 in FDIA 1493 of 2009 in OS 11 of 2007 before the Munsiff Court, Vatakara. The petitioner, K.K. Sarojini, a final decree holder, sought a supplementary final decree in a partition suit concerning a property that had seen encroachment by the 1st respondent and adjustments arising from a National Highway acquisition. The original suit, O.S. 11/2007, led to a preliminary decree and a final decree in 2011; subsequent commission reports (Exhibit P3) and revised owelty values were prepared, with Ext.P1 seeking a supplementary final decree and Ext.P4 dismissing it. The respondents contended that the preliminary decree had attained finality (citing RSA No. 1359/2013) and that passing a supplementary final decree was not permissible. The petitioner argued for relief under exceptional circumstances, emphasizing the commission report, encroachment findings, and the possibility of proportionate adjustments to owelty. The High Court, relying on the doctrine articulated in Thomas K.T. v. Anna @ Accamma John and others (2018) and the settled position that supplementary decrees are extraordinary, declined to interfere under Article 227 and dismissed the original petition, while leaving avenues for legal remedies open to the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
AR NO. 85 OF 2021

Galaxy Auto Fuels and Shiju John v Indian Oil Corporation Limited and Others

This Arbitration Request (AR 85 of 2021) before the Kerala High Court arises from a Retail Outlet Dealership Agreement (Annexure A1) dated 16.04.2004 between M/s Galaxy Auto Fuels (and its Managing Partner Shiju John) and Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOC). With the dealership term expired, disputes regarding the “Machinery and Apparatus” installed at the petroleum outlet, alleged demurrage, and related rights arose. The petition contends that these disputes are arbitrable under Section 11(the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996) and that Clause 62 of Annexure A1 provides for arbitration by the Director (Marketing) of IOC. Respondents assert that Annexure A1, though styled as a Dealership Agreement, creates land rights in IOC’s favor and involves tenancy, tenancy arrears and land-ownership issues that cannot be referred to arbitration under the Act; hence the AR should be dismissed. The judge examines Annexure A1, notes it is a Retail Outlet Dealership Agreement with the land owned by the petitioners and IOC providing only the machinery. He cites Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd. (AIR 2020 SC 59) and Tulsi Developers India Pvt. Ltd. v. Dr. Appu Benny Thomas (2021(5) KLT 339) to emphasize that no party to the agreement can arbitrarily appoint an arbitrator and that the law supports arbitration only within proper bounds. Ultimately, the court disregards the clause 62 provision to the extent necessary and refers the disputes to arbitration, nominating Sri S. Jagadees as the sole arbitrator, with disclosure, cost-sharing, and a fixed appearance date. The court expressly states it has not decided merits and leaves all questions to the arbitrator under the Act.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 1971/2022

Anil Kumar S and Sheeja S.S v Axis Bank Ltd (W.A. No. 1971/2022)

Petitioners Anil Kumar S and Sheeja S.S challenged the Axis Bank’s recovery actions, seeking a writ of mandamus to direct the respondent bank to grant 50 equal monthly installments for repayment of the entire defaulted arrears. The petitioners availed a loan of Rs. 1,37,00,000 and a credit facility of Rs. 24,99,999, mortgaging 20 cents of property in Kanjiramkulam, Thiruvananthapuram, as security. Though they paid installments, financial difficulties led to defaults and a notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 demanding Rs. 1,56,473.45, failing which possession could be taken. They sought time to settle the overdue arrears in 50 installments; the writ petition was disposed of by the Writ Court directing repayment of the overdue amount Rs. 10,25,754 in ten equated installments with a set schedule, while continuing regular EMI payments and keeping coercive proceedings in abeyance. On appeal, the Division Bench, noting the settled legal position that writs against SARFAESI recovery are not ordinarily maintainable where statutory remedies exist, dismissed the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C). No. 41950 of 2018

Beena S. v. State of Kerala & Others

Beena S., a widow, challenged the grant of ARD 217 (ration shop) at Kattachira, Bharanikavu Gram Panchayat, Alappuzha, under Ext.P1 (notification dated 01-03-2007) which required applicants to attach a solvency certificate issued within two months prior to submission. Beena and the 6th respondent applied; Beena contends the 6th respondent submitted on 09-04-2007 without the original solvency certificate, relying instead on a solvency certificate dated 22-07-2006 allegedly held by the District Supply Officer. Ext.P1’s two-month requirement would bar acceptance if the certificate is not produced within that window, and Beena argues that even if the original certificate were produced, it would contravene Ext.P1; hence the 6th respondent’s application should have been dismissed in limine. Beena secured Ext.P2 appointing her as licensee; however Exts.P3 and P4 show appeals and revisions against her, which were reversed by Ext.P6 (Go) and then disturbed by Ext.P7 upon Government review. The petitioner challenged Ext.P6; the Government contended the 6th respondent’s site lies within the notified area, supported by Ext.P9 and a report from the Taluk Supply Officer, which found the proposed site beyond the notified boundary (about 0.99 km away). The Court reviewed prior judgments (WP(C) Nos. 30960/2006 and 29746/2004) and the Varkey precedent (1984 KLT 567), noting contradictions, and ultimately held that Ext.P6 was improperly issued. Ext.P6 was set aside, and the Government was directed to reconsider the matter afresh after hearing, with ARD 217 remaining in status quo until final decision, to be made within four months.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.39931/2018

Thrissur District Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Mustaffa T.A. and others; Kerala Lok Ayukta

This writ petition (W.P.(C) No.39931/2018) filed by The Thrissur District Co-operative Bank Ltd challenges the Kerala Lok Ayukta’s Complaint No.982/2018 and the interim orders (Exhibits P7 and P8) staying SARFAESI recovery proceedings against borrowers Mustaffa T.A., Kadeeja and Suharath. The Bank commenced recovery under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act) by issuing Section 13(2) notices for three loans of Rs.40 lakh each, secured by mortgaged property of the borrowers. The borrowers approached Lok Ayukta alleging mal-administration by the Bank and sought stay of recovery, investigation under the Kerala Lok Ayukta Act, 1999, and related reliefs. Lok Ayukta admitted the complaint for regular investigation and stayed further proceedings for two months upon deposit requirements of Rs.1,00,000 per borrower, with possible extension upon further deposits. The Bank contends that Lok Ayukta has no jurisdiction to entertain complaints affecting SARFAESI proceedings and that interim orders exceed its powers, relying on decisions including Punjab National Bank v. O.C.Krishnan and State Bank of India v. Mathew K.C. The Kerala High Court ultimately held Lok Ayukta had no jurisdiction to entertain such complaints and set aside the interim order (Exhibit P8), thereby allowing the writ petition and permitting SARFAESI proceedings to proceed under the Act.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C NO. 62 OF 2023

M/S JEEVAN TELECASTING CORPORATION LTD. THROUGH ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE MRS. SHEEJA SUNNY vs STATE OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM & ASIANET SATELLITE COMMUNICATION LTD.

This is a criminal miscellaneous case under section 482 CrPC to quash Annexure-A1 complaint in C.C. No. 3891/2017 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram, filed by Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. (complainant) against the first accused, M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd., and the second and third accused as authorised signatories. The dispute arises from a debt allegedly owed to the complainant in the context of a channel carriage agreement. The cheque for Rs. 5,89,890 issued by the second and third accused on behalf of the first accused was dishonoured. The petitioner contends that, even if a debt existed, the liability was extinguished by subsequent payments reflected in Annexure-A3 and the complainant’s own records (Annexure-A2A/A3A). Hence, continuing criminal proceedings would be an abuse of process since the substrate of the offence no longer exists. The respondents counter that the payment evidence does not conclusively discharge the liability toward the specific cheque, and the matter requires trial evidence rather than quashing. The High Court relies on the Nagawwa framework and subsequent precedents, concluding that quashing is an exceptional remedy to be exercised with caution and only when the complaint fails to disclose an offence or is an abuse of process. Ultimately, the petition is dismissed and the prosecution proceeds.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2817 OF 2023

BAIL APPL. NO. 2817 OF 2023

This is a bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C. filed by the accused in Crime No. 914/2022 of Aryanad police station, Thiruvananthapuram. The offences alleged include IPC sections 376(2)(f) and 376(3) and also sections 3(b) read with 4(2), and 9(1)(n) read with 10 of the POCSO Act, 2012. The FIR was lodged on the information furnished by a 13-year-old daughter of the petitioner, who described repeated sexual assaults beginning in December 2021 and continuing into 2022, including grabbing, kissing, touching, and other acts of sexual violence in the family home. The petitioner contends innocence and points to ongoing matrimonial disputes and a protective order under the Domestic Violence Act since 2019; he argues that there was no cohabitation at the relevant times and casts doubt on the credibility of the allegations. The Public Prosecutor opposes anticipatory bail, arguing that Section 438(4) Cr.P.C. bars entry where offences under 376(3) exist, and that the victim’s statements, including her First Information Statement and statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C., along with an expert-panel report, support a prima facie case. The court considers maintainability of 438(4) but ultimately notes the alleged acts relate to severe sexual offences against a minor and distinguishes a cited case to exercise caution. Ultimately the court dismisses the anticipatory bail application, while noting the petitioner may surrender and seek regular bail later.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 2748 of 2023

Ajnas M v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.M.C No.2748 of 2023) before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, arising from Crime No.552/2021 of Nadapuram Police Station, Calicut District, and challenging a CMP order in SC No.403/2022 before the Fast Track Special Judge, Nadapuram. The sole accused, Ajnas M, contends that the trial process was flawed because the statement of the victim recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C was not made available to him to confront the witness, which he argues violated his right to a fair trial. Although the victim reportedly attained 18 years, the counsel for the petitioner contends that Section 33(5) of the POCSO Act is not an absolute bar to recalling a witness for further examination. The Public Prosecutor maintains that the 164 Cr.P.C statement was forwarded with the final report and served to the accused in terms of Section 207 Cr.P.C., and that Section 33(5) of the POCSO Act does not bar recall where necessary for a just decision. The High Court, applying the discretion under Section 311 Cr.P.C., holds that the accused must have an opportunity to confront the 164 statement and recalls PW1 for further examination, directing the trial court to complete examination on the appearance date. The court ultimately allows the criminal miscellaneous petition and set aside the earlier recall order, ensuring a fair trial process.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7909 OF 2018

Preesa Foods and Spices (India) Private Limited v. State of Kerala and Sreejith A.S., Kunnath Rafeeque

This Kerala High Court judgment deals with a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by Preesa Foods and Spices (India) Private Limited (Petitioner/Accused No.2) seeking to quash a prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (S.T. No.986/2017) initiated in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Ottapalam. The 2nd accused contends that the complaint is defective because the drawer of the dishonoured cheque was the company, not the individuals, and crucial statutory requirements under the NI Act were not satisfied; notably, the company had ceased operating in 2016, the 3rd respondent (Managing Director) allegedly misused authority, and the company itself was not arraigned as an accused. The court examines the ingredients of an offence under Section 138 (the five acts leading to the offence) and discusses the necessity of a valid notice to the drawer, and whether directors or ex-directors can be liable where the company is not properly arraigned. Relying on multiple precedents, including decisions on vicarious liability, notice requirements, and cognizance, the court ultimately holds that the Annexure A1 complaint is not maintainable, quashes the complaint against the petitioner, and sets aside the registration of the case against the 2nd accused, while leaving the broader proceedings against others potentially open.