Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 493 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
I.T.A. No. 10 of 2019

M/S JOYALUKKAS INDIA LTD v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

This Kerala High Court decision concerns ITA 10 of 2019 filed by M/S JOYALUKKAS INDIA LTD (now M/S JOYALUKKAS INDIA PVT LTD) challenging the ITAT Cochin Bench’s 2018 order which upheld a disallowance of Rs. 92,28,405 under the proviso to Section 36(1)(iii) of the Income Tax Act for AY 2010-11. The assessment process began with processing under Section 143(1) and a reference to the Transfer Pricing Officer to determine arm’s length pricing under Section 92CA. A Dispute Resolution Panel draft order dated 25.03.2014 was followed by the final assessment order under Section 143(3) read with 144C, issued after DRP’s decision on 29.12.2014. The central issue is whether interest on working capital loans, claimed by the assessee as a revenue expenditure to fund day‑to‑day business, can be disallowed under the proviso to 36(1)(iii) as an expenditure related to asset acquisition or capital work in progress. The appellant relies on the Full Bench in Indus Motors and the Division Bench in Joy Alukkas to contend that such expenditures are revenue in nature and not subject to the proviso. The Revenue argues the matter hinges on facts; the onus rests on the assessee to prove revenue expenditure. The DRP/ITAT findings—allocating the funds to capital work in progress and finding lack of revenue substantiation—were upheld by the High Court, which dismissed the appeal as the onus on proving revenue nature and factual tiedness remained with the assessee.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2505 OF 2022

Prince v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case, CRL.MC No. 2505 of 2022, arises from an order of the Judicial First Class Magistrate-III, Irinjalakuda in CMP No.7/2022 in ST No.79/2018. The accused, Prince, seeks to quash the order and to direct CMP No.7/2022 to send Ext.P1 cheque for expert analysis (Neutron Activation Analysis) to ascertain the age of the ink and the date entered in the cheque. The complaint relates to an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act). The Magistrate had dismissed the request, noting the lack of available facilities for ink-age analysis and relying on a Kerala High Court dictum. The High Court, per Justice Mary Joseph, examined the maintainability and found the petition lacking. It discussed jurisprudence including Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar (SC) on implied authority to fill cheque entries and the presumption under section 139 NI Act, which shifts the onus to the accused to rebut. It also referred to prior Kerala decisions (Kuriakose C.T. v. Joseph) regarding the non-availability of ink-age analysis facilities, but ultimately held that the petition did not establish a necessary discernible transaction or provide a viable rebuttal. The petition is dismissed, and the impugned order is confirmed, upholding the trial court’s decision.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12545 of 2021

Anand Viswanath v. Mahatma Gandhi University and 2 others

Anand Viswanath, a 56-year-old retired Associate Professor of Government College, Munnar, challenged Exts. P12 and P13 arising from internal and subsequent inquiries concerning alleged misconduct. The petitioner initially reported five female students for examination malpractice; the students later accused him of sexual harassment, triggering an internal inquiry culminating in Ext. P8 and later Exts. P12 (a re-enquiry by two Syndicate members) and P13 (an MG University order relating to the students’ malpractice). The petitioner contends Ext. P12 was prepared behind his back and that Ext. P13 has no bearing on the sexual harassment allegations; he refused to give a statement in the proceedings, alleging illegality. The MG University countered that three reports (Exts. P3, P8, P12) exist and that Ext. P12 is not a statutory enquiry but an internal one, with Ext. P13 primarily concerning student malpractice; no final action has yet been taken and the matter has been referred to the Government for appropriate action. The Government Pleader argued that the POSH Act inquiry is underway, but no final order has been issued. The court, relying on Vijayakumaran CP v. Central University of Kerala (2020) 12 SCC 426, held that an ICC report under the POSH Act cannot by itself impose punishment and a proper enquiry must be completed. It found Ext. P12 cannot by itself cause detriment and dismissed the petition, while granting liberty to authorities to proceed under due process.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No.677 of 2022

Achuth Mohan v. Kerala University of Health Sciences & Ors.

Achuth Mohan, a final BDS student (2012 admission) challenged the Kerala University of Health Sciences’ Board of Adjudication for Students Grievances and related authorities after the May 2021 Final BDS Degree Part II Supplementary Examinations. He alleges anomalies in the valuation of the Paediatric & Preventive Dentistry paper, including that a mark was awarded for a question he did not answer in the first valuation, and that the two valuations (First: 40, Second: 46) produced an average of 43, below the passing threshold of 50. He argues KUHS Regulation Ext. P3 permits double valuation with averaging and, in exceptional cases, a fresh third valuation upon the Board’s recommendation and Governing Council approval; the “Exceptional Cases” are not defined in the Regulation. He sought re-totalling, copies of score sheets, and third/fresh valuation by subject experts, including appointment by this Court at his expense. He relied on M.G. University v. Millu Dandapani to support court intervention for expert review of papers. The High Court examined clause 1.15(9) of Regulation Ext. P3 and related precedents (Board of Secondary Education v. Panda; Sanchit Banzal v. JAB; All India Council of Technical Education v. Dhawan) and found the writ court had erred in denying relief. It held the Board’s approach was discriminatory, set aside the impugned order, and directed KUHS to apply clause 11.5(9) on par with other candidates, issuing a speaking order within 10 days.),

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4815 OF 2021

Nidhish Kumar M.N v. State of Kerala

The petitioner, Nidhish Kumar M.N., seeks to quash FIR No. 495/2021 of Ernakulam Central Police Station and CC 586/2021 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate-II, Ernakulam, under Sections 4(2)(e) and 4(2)(j) of the Epidemic Diseases Ordinance, Section 269 IPC, and Section 3(f) of the Covid-19 Additional Regulations, 2020, as well as Section 482 Cr.P.C. The matter concerns Sunverge Pvt. Ltd., a renewable energy startup allegedly operating in a restricted period during the Covid-19 lockdown. The petitioner argues exemption for renewable energy projects under Annexure-V (Ministry of Home Affairs guidelines) permits operation, and that the complainant’s claims lack material to establish negligence or intent to spread infection. Annexure-V states construction of renewable energy projects is permitted; the petitioner’s office is part of a startup entity registered and recognized as renewable energy work. The court notes the charge-sheet is weak with only two witnesses, and the prosecution has not shown that the petitioner acted negligently or with intent to spread infection. The judge emphasizes the settled law that if the FIR/charge-sheet, even on face value, does not prima facie disclose an offence, Section 482 Cr.P.C. allows quashing to prevent abuse of process. Consequently, the entire proceedings are quashed and the petitioner exonerated.

High Court of Kerala
Ex.F.A.No.20 of 2021

Najmuneesa v. Dileep Kumar, M/S Revathi Apartments Private Ltd., and V.N. Radhakrishnan

Najmuneesa, the appellant, challenged the orders in Execution First Appeal Nos.125/2020 and 345/2020 arising from E.P.150/2016 in O.S.204/2014 before the Principal Sub Court, Palakkad, under Order XXI, Rule 97 CPC. The suit (O.S.204/2014) for recovery of money led to a decree in favour of the 1st respondent, who then sought sale of the petition schedule property (4.64 acres) in E.P.150/2016. In execution, the southern 2.32 acres were sold to the 1st respondent for ₹70 lakhs, and delivery of the property was sought by E.A.356/2019. The appellant claimed possession since 20.05.2002, contending that 4.64 acres had been entrusted to her by the 3rd respondent and that she has openly possessed and lived on the property with her children for about 18 years, thereby perfecting title by adverse possession. The 1st respondent disputed this, and the trial court, after recording oral evidence and marking Exts.A1–A4, dismissed both EA petitions. The High Court examined whether the appellant could prove right, title or interest under Rule 97/101, citing Shamsher Singh v. Col. Nahar Singh (AIR 2019 SC 4840) and Nooruddin v. Dr. K.L. Anand, among others. It held that substantial hostile possession had not been proven, and that the appellant remained a permissive occupier. Despite long occupancy, the absence of a definite start date of hostility and evidence of nec vi, nec clam, nec precario led to dismissal of the claim. The court affirmed the execution court’s findings, dismissing the appeal with no cost order.

High Court of Kerala
Ex.F.A.No.20 of 2014

Shaijan s/o ThottaHIPARAMBIL Kutttan v. Varghese s/o Kannamppuzha Ouseph and Yohannan Stephen s/o Pynadath Ouseph and Dileep s/o ChetTiparambil Kumaran

The appellant, Shaijan s/o Thottahiparambil Kutttan, challenges an order of the Principal Sub Court, Irinjalakuda, in EP 205/2010 in OS 289/2008 arising from an Adalat award dated 29-01-2010. The award created a charge on 10 cents of land in Sy. No. 1238/2 that was attached and brought to sale in execution proceedings. The appellant asserts he is the absolute owner in possession of the 10 cents, supported by Ext.A1, a certified copy of sale deed No. 2336/2008. He contends the compromise decree granting the award is collusive and Ext.A1 was executed before the filing of the suit; the respondents did not substantiate the underlying agreement for sale. He argues Ext.A1 is fraudulent under Section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act, with an inadequate consideration (Rs. 40,000 for 10 cents at Rs. 20,000 per cent) and that the charge on the petition schedule property cannot be saved. The appellant maintains that Order XXI, Rule 58 CPC permits a claim against attachment, but a charge cannot override his title. The respondents submit that the charge arose from the award under Section 55(6)(b) TP Act, and Ext.A1 is tainted by fraud. They invoke Krishnamenon v. Pradeep Kumar to assert that a subsequent bona fide purchaser cannot defeat a statutory charge and that the appeal should fail. The High Court ultimately dismisses the appeal, upholding the attachment and charge.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No. 53 of 2022

Jayalal v. Sugesh and Dharmaputhran Pillai

This is an appeal under Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) and Rule 1A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging an order of the Sub Court, Punalur, in O.S. No.58 of 2016. The suit, filed for realisation of money on a building contract, was rejected for non-payment of balance court fees; the counter-claim was decreed ex parte. The appellant remained absent and did not seek restoration or setting aside in a timely manner, resulting in a default on both plaint and counter-claim. The appellant moved I.A. Nos.1 and 2 of 2020 after a delay of about 1071 days, seeking condonation of delay and restoration of the suit and setting aside the ex parte decree in the counter-claim. The Sub Court rejected the applications, noting lack of credible evidence of illness or compelling cause and finding the documents on record insufficient to prove the claimed injuries or inability to attend court. The appellant contends that both he and his wife were chronic patients needing ongoing treatment, and that the COVID-19 pandemic compounded the delay. The respondents counter that the delay is neither bona fide nor justified. The Kerala High Court, applying the principles from Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee, held that even under liberal exceptions the delay was not condonable given the extended period and lack of verifiable medical evidence. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed and the trial court’s orders stand.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(TAX).NO.9/2016; O.P.(TAX).NO.23/2016; O.T.REV.NOS.97/2017; O.T.REV.NOS.98/2017; W.A.NO.601/2021

Madhavaraja Club v. The Commercial Tax Officer (Luxury Tax) & Ors

The Kerala High Court collectively hears O.P.(TAX).Nos.9 and 23/2016, O.T.Rev.Nos.97 and 98/2017, and W.A.No.601/2021 concerning the applicability of the mutuality principle to the Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 (KTL Act). The petitioner Madhavaraja Club, a members’ club, challenged penalties levied under the KTL Act for various years and questioned the Tribunal’s confirmatory orders. The core issue is whether the mutuality doctrine—where members’ contributions and participation in club activities create an identity between fund contributors and beneficiaries—can shield the club from luxury tax on charges collected from members for rooms, halls, and amenities, except where Section 4(2A) applies. The respondents argue the tax is levied on the “proprietor” for the luxury provided, and that mutuality cannot bar such levy, citing a line of decisions including Asianet, Trivandrum Club, Lotus Club, and Supreme Court/Constitution-based authorities. The court, engaging with Calcutta Club Ltd. (State of West Bengal v. Calcutta Club Ltd., 2019 SCC 107), ultimately holds that the mutuality doctrine applies to insulate the club from the tax on charges to members, except for Section 4(2A) turnover. It distinguishes earlier Kerala Division Bench rulings (Madhavaraja Club 2013 Ker 9816; Lotus Club) and clarifies that the absence of two distinct parties negates a sale-to-self scenario only in contexts where the statute contemplates such incidence. The judgment remands both the KTL and KVAT assessments for fresh adjudication, excluding the mutuality turnover, and directs de novo assessment within three months.

High Court of Kerala
CUS.APPEAL NOS.11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018

Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Willingdon Island, Cochin v. KIMS Health Care Management Ltd.

This is a batch Customs Appeal from the Kerala High Court involving the Revenue (Commissioner of Customs) challenging the order of the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal Bangalore dated 21.08.2017 in seven appeals (Cus.Appeal Nos.11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018). The importer, KIMS Health Care Management Ltd., had imported an MRI scanner (Bill of Entry No.1001 dated 22.05.2006) and claimed exemption under the Served from India Scheme (SFIS) with SFIS credit. The Revenue contends that the importer was not entitled to exemption as the credit available under SFIS was insufficient; it also argues that Education Cess and Special Additional Duty (SAD) were incorrectly treated in the Tribunal’s computations. The Tribunal allowed the importer’s appeals by interpreting Notification No.20/2006 and relevant notifications, following Gujarat Ambuja Exports Ltd. v. UOI and Pasupati Acrylon Ltd., among others. The High Court examined the substantial questions of law and held that the Tribunal’s approach correctly appreciated the duties payable under BCD, CVD and SAD in light of Notifications 20/2006, 6/2006 and 92/2004, and the SFIS framework. It concluded that there is no substantial question of law, and the revenue’s appeals fail. The batch appeals are dismissed, preserving the Tribunal’s order in favor of the importer.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1875 OF 2012

Rukmini and Others v. K.G. Babu and K.K. Nelson and National Insurance Company Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act arising from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam dated 16 February 2011 in O.P.(MV) No.2209/2006, concerning a death in a road accident on 18 May 2006 involving a bus (KL-7 AS 9429). The appellants – Rukmini, RadhaKrishnan, Bindhu and Sindhu – challenge the Tribunal’s quantum of compensation. The Tribunal held negligence by the bus driver and awarded Rs.2,28,646 with 8% interest. The appellants contend that the compensation is inadequate and relies on established legal principles for computation of dependency loss, including higher income, future prospects, and multiplier rules. They invoke Ramachandrappa to fix monthly income at Rs.5,500 (plus 10% future prospects per Pranay Sethi) and Sarla Verma for the correct multiplier (9 rather than 8 given age 57). The appellants also seek damages for loss of estate, funeral expenses, loss of consortium, and reductions in head amounts as directed by later precedents (Satinder Kaur) to be applied. The Respondents/Insurance Company contest the calculations but admit the policy. The High Court allowed the appeal, enhancing the total compensation to Rs.7,13,696 (Rs.4,85,050 as enhanced amount in addition to the Tribunal’s Rs.2,28,646), with the same rate of interest, and directed deposit of the enhanced amount and payment of court fees and balance among the appellants within two months.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal Nos.1406/2017 & 160/2018

Syam R.S. v. Lekshmi Vijaya

These matrimonial appeals involve the same couple, Syam R.S. and Lekshmi Vijaya. The husband sought divorce in O.P. 36/2016 before the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, which was dismissed. The wife had pursued O.P. 1374/2015 for recovery of gold ornaments, maintenance and other relief, which the Family Court partly allowed, including eight sovereigns of gold ornaments and a fixed deposit of Rs. 9,00,000 in joint names, and maintenance of Rs. 5,000 to the wife and minor child. The husband challenged these orders by filing Mat.Appeal Nos. 1406/2017 and 160/2018. Both appeals were heard together on 14.07.2022. The couple married on 26.12.2011; they lived in Sharjah; a daughter was born in 2013; the wife allegedly refused to accompany him to Sharjah. The husband contends the marriage is irretrievably broken due to cruelty and desertion, while the wife alleges the husband refused to take her to Sharjah and misappropriated her ornaments. The court found that the eight sovereigns of gold were withdrawn by the husband from a joint locker (though the evidence was contested) and that the fixed deposit was jointly held. After re-examining the evidence, the High Court reaffirmed the earlier reliefs and, invoking the Beena v. Shino G. Babu doctrine, held that withholding consent for mutual separation constitutes cruelty. It then dissolved the marriage by decree of divorce, dismissing MA 1406/2017 and allowing MA 160/2018.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 626/2004 (C) & RFA No. 628/2004 (C)

Jayadevi v. Narayana Pillai and others (RFA Nos. 626/2004 & 628/2004)

Two connected suits were heard together in the Kerala High Court. The primary dispute in O.S. 88/1997 was a counterclaim to set aside Ext.B15, a sale deed executed by Subhadramma, on the ground that it affected dispositions under Ext.A4, a joint Will executed by Subhadramma and Ramakrishna Pillai. The court analysed whether Ext.A4 was a mutual (reciprocal) Will and whether Ext.B15 could stand against such dispositions. It held that Ext.A4 is not a mutual Will and that, as a joint Will, its operative effect would be limited to the property of the deceased testator and cannot bind the survivor to an alteration of dispositions after the other’s death. In interpreting such wills, the court emphasized that Section 82 and 84 of the Indian Succession Act require a holistic reading of the instrument, and that repugnant clauses follow the rule of construction, with the court applying pertinent authorities (including Ramachandra Shenoy and Suryanarayana) to determine which dispositions prevail and how life interests vs absolute bequests are to be construed. The judgment also cites the maxim cum duo inter se pugnantia reperiuntur in testamento ultimum ratum est and discusses its limited application. Ultimately, the court concluded Ext.B15 is valid against the estate of the deceased testator, while the counter claims relating to the other properties were unsustainable. The connected suit OS 306/1998 was left undisturbed. The RFAs, 628/2004 and 626/2004, were disposed with different outcomes: RFA 628 allowed and RFA 626 dismissed. No costs were awarded.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 230 of 2018 (C)

The Managing Director, Kitex Garments Ltd. v. T.C. Jose and others

This Regular First Appeal arises from OS No.76/2013 of the Sub Court, Perumbavoor, wherein the death of a worker by electrocution occurred during employment with Kitex Garments Ltd. The trial court awarded Rs.10,00,000 to the legal heirs of the victim. The fourth defendant challenged the decree on grounds including bar under Section 75(3) of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (ESI Act), and estoppel/res judicata, arguing that remedies were pursued before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner and the Human Rights Commission and an ESI petition was dismissed. The trial court did not decide the §75(3) bar at the preliminary stage, opting to adjudicate on the merits, which led to CRPs and interim orders. The High Court analyses whether the civil court had inherent jurisdiction or was ousted by the ESI Act’s special scheme, discusses estoppel and election doctrine (Section 35 of the Transfer of Property Act) and cites several precedents. It clarifies that a party cannot prematurely veto an exclusive forum while participating in litigation, and that Section 75(3) does not automatically strip civil courts of all jurisdiction where tort liability could arise, emphasizing equity and fair play. Ultimately, the court concludes that the appellant’s contentions do not deserve acceptance and upholds the trial court’s decree. The Regular First Appeal is dismissed, leaving the Rs.10,00,000 award intact for the plaintiffs.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). No. 13448 of 2022

Jeebinsa v. State of Kerala and Others

Jeebinsa, the petitioner, challenged Ext.P4 which rejected her application under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 and the Rules, 2014 for donating a kidney to Safir T.V., a chronic kidney patient with whom she had a longstanding relationship. The joint Form-3 and Form-11 applications were submitted for donation. The Court had earlier, by Ext.P3, directed the authorities to consider the applications and pass appropriate orders. Ext.P4, however, records a police report stating a commercial transaction between donor and recipient and rejects the application in a single sentence, without addressing the statutory criteria. The petitioner contends Ext.P4 is not a speaking order and fails to apply Section 9 of the Act and Rule 7(3) of the Rules, thereby ignoring the due procedure required for quasi-judicial consideration. The Government Pleader argues that there is a commercial transaction and that the police report supports rejection. The Court emphasizes that the Act and Rules prescribe a detailed, inquiry-based process requiring consideration of multiple factors and a speaking order after hearing. It invokes the Kranti Associates lineage to stress that reasons are essential, and a police report cannot solely defeat an application. The Court quashes Ext.P4 and directs the 2nd respondent to reconsider the applications with opportunity of hearing within one month.

High Court of Kerala
R.F.A. No. 246 of 2004

S Chandradas and others v. Choolayil Finance & Investment Company Pvt. Ltd.

This Regular First Appeal arises from OS 113/1999 in the Subordinate Judge’s Court, Attingal, filed by the plaintiff S. Chandradas and his legal heirs against the Choolayil Finance & Investment Co. Pvt. Ltd. The dispute centers on a fixed deposit of ₹2,00,000 made on 31 December 1997, evidenced by Ext. A1 signed by D2 (a director) along with the company’s manager, bearing 15% interest; interest was paid only up to 31 August 1998. On maturity (01/01/1999), the plaintiff demanded repayment, but the company allegedly closed and the directors absconded. The suit sought ₹2,33,750 with interest at 15% per annum from the date of suit and costs. D1 and D2 were ex parte; D3 contested, claiming she became a director without knowledge, suffers from mental illness since January 1998, resigned on 06/04/1998, and contended non-liability. The trial court dismissed the suit. The High Court held that D3 could not be held liable since she was not a director when the cause of action arose (01/01/1999) and Ext.A1 was not signed by her. D1 and D2 were found liable for the deposit, as the amount was in the name of D1 and Ext.A1 bore D2’s signature. The appeal was partly allowed: the suit against D1 and D2 was decreed for ₹2,33,750 with interest (15% till decree; 6% thereafter) and costs; the claim against D3 was dismissed, and the earlier ex parte decree status was clarified.

High Court of Kerala
MACA.1004/2006

Velayudhan and Janaki v. V. Guruvayoorappan and Ors

This appeal arises from an order of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Palakkad, awarding compensation for the death of Krishnamoorthy in a head-on collision involving a Tata Sumo and a tractor-trolley. The appellants, parents of Krishnamoorthy, contend that the Tribunal erred in exonerating the insurer and the vehicle owner by attributing negligence solely to the tractor driver, despite evidence suggesting joint liability. The tribunal awarded Rs. 2,79,700 with 6% interest and costs. The defence by the insurer admitted the policy but disputed liability and quantum. The High Court, examining related awards in OP(MV) Nos. 1077/2001 et al., notes a prior finding that both drivers contributed to the accident and held that such findings, having attained finality, cannot easily be disregarded. The court proceeds to revise the quantum by reassessing monthly income, applying 50% future prospects, and deducting 50% for personal expenses, leading to a revised loss of dependency calculation. It awards funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium, applying jurisprudence from United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur and New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Somwathi & Ors to justify adjustments. The final order holds joint and several liability between the first two respondents and the third and fourth respondents in equal shares, increases total compensation to Rs. 6,83,223, and raises interest to 7%, with a time-period exclusion for the insurer.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2887 OF 2023

Najeeb v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Misc Case (CRL.MC 2887 of 2023) filed by the 2nd accused Najeeb under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of criminal proceedings arising from Crime No. 519 of 2016 at Panur Police Station, which led to S.C. No. 825 of 2018 before the ASJ Thalassery. The accused faced charges under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 308 read with 34 IPC. The first accused was a juvenile and the trial against him was sent to the Juvenile Justice Court; the 3rd accused proceedings were quashed; the present petitioner’s case proceeds. The court undertook a two-step inquiry: whether a settlement between the parties exists and whether quashing is appropriate under Section 482. The prosecution initially opposed quashing, citing the seriousness of certain offences and the public interest in criminal deterrence. The court, after evaluating the nature of the offences, the gravity of injuries, the absence of prior criminal antecedents, and the amicable settlement between the parties, held that the power under 482 can exercise to quash non-compoundable offences where the civil character predominates and the settlement is complete, subject to scrutiny of evidence and gravity. It relied on a line of Supreme Court decisions to harmonize private settlement with social interest. Ultimately, the court quashed the proceedings against the petitioner, terminating the prosecution in S.C. No. 825/2018.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. Nos. 1544/2021 & 1541/2021

W.A. Nos. 1544/2021 & 1541/2021 (Arshaj S. v. Secretary, Department of Tourism; Anish Thanikkal v. Secretary, Department of Tourism)

These two writ appeals challenge the contract appointment process for the post of Secretary, District Tourism Promotion Council (DTPC) across 14 districts in Kerala. The appellants, Arshaj S. and Anish Thanikkal, participated in the recruitment process but were not shortlisted for interview. They contend that the norms governing the selection were altered midstream: originally, Clause 5 of Part III of the scheme appended to Ext. R-2(a) GO dated 18.08.2021 provided for district-wise units of appointment; before the written examination, Ext. R-2(b) GO dated 22.09.2021 changed the unit to state-wide, supposedly to enable uniform reservation measures. This change occurred after the last date for submitting applications (14.09.2021) and before the written test (25.09.2021). They also challenge the shortlisting cut-off of 24.75 marks, arguing there is no basis for such a cut-off in the notification. The respondents defend the change as essential to implement prime policy norms of community reservation; they contend the modification was issued as a corrigendum/erratum and applied equally to all candidates, with the scheme and notification making no explicit district-wise unit requirement. The court relies on established jurisprudence that midstream changes must be open to all and not prejudicial, citing Bank of India v. Aarya K. Babu and related decisions. Ultimately, the Division Bench dismisses the appeals, upholding the common judgment of the Single Judge and finding no substantial prejudice to the appellants.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. Nos.1112 of 2018 & 710 of 2019

State of Kerala v. Bibin Varghese @ Saippu & Robin David

This is a criminal appeal arising from a double-accused murder case decided by the Kerala High Court. On 12 April 2015, four friends returning from a gathering were waylaid on a road near a petrol bunk following a dispute over an open car dickey. A2 allegedly stabbed the deceased repeatedly with a knife, while A1 played a facilitating role. The four victims were on a bike and scooter; the car occupants confronted them, a scuffle ensued, and the victim succumbed to stab injuries, primarily a left thigh wound with extensive chest injuries observed in the postmortem. The Sessions Court convicted both accused under sections 341, 323, 140, and 324 read with 34 IPC, and specifically sentenced them to life imprisonment for murder under section 302 read with 34 IPC, along with fines for the other offences. The appellants challenge the verdict, contending lack of prior intent, an embellished deposition by PW1, and that A1’s role did not amount to murder; A2 contends fabrication of the incident and delays in FIR, with several witnesses hostile. The prosecution relies on ocular testimony of PW1–PW3, seizure of MO items including a knife (MO1) and vehicle (MO2), and blood-stained garments. The High Court examines the reliability of the FIS, the medical evidence, and the overall conduct, ultimately upholding the trial court’s findings on joint liability under Sec.34 IPC and premeditation, and dismissing the appeals while confirming the sentence.