Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 479 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C Nos. 5784/2022, 5759/2022, 5816/2022

CRL.M.C Nos. 5784/2022, 5759/2022 and 5816/2022 v. State of Kerala

This is a consolidated order of a single-judge bench (Honourable Dr. Justice Kauser Edappagath) of the Kerala High Court dealing with three connected Criminal Miscellaneous Cases (Crl.M.C. Nos. 5784/2022, 5759/2022 and 5816/2022) arising from Thiruvalla Police Station offenses. The accused and the victim in all three cases are married persons who reportedly had a consensual relationship over a period, including visits to lodges and two rented houses, followed by tribulations in the marriage. The prosecutions allege offenses including rape and related crimes under IPC sections such as 366, 376(2)(n), 403, and 420 (in Crime 314/2022) and 376(2)(n), 323, 506 (in Crime 907/2022), and 376(2)(n) (in Crime 2353/2021). All three cases have been amicably settled between the parties, with the victim stating she does not wish to press the matter further. The Public Prosecutor and the investigating officer corroborate the amicable settlement. Relying on a recent Kerala High Court decision (XXX v State of Kerala, 2022 KHC 296), the court holds that the alleged promise of marriage to a married woman is unenforceable in law and cannot sustain a conviction under Section 376 IPC. Consequently, the court allows the three Crl.M.Cs and quashes all further proceedings in the connected crimes.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.1133 of 2022

SANTHOSH KUMAR NAIR v. SURESH P. SREEDHARAN and Others

This is a divisional-Bench appeal from a writ petition (WP(C) No.21186/2022) filed by the tenant (1st respondent in the writ petition) challenging actions by his landlord (5th respondent) and seeking police protection for life and property, as well as a direction to register a criminal case against the landlord. The tenancy related to building no. 39/1687/1, with Ext.P1 a consent from the landlord, and Ext.P2 a Thrissur Corporation license. Ext.P3 is a Pollution Control Board consent; Ext.P4 and P4(a) evidence the restaurant’s inauguration. Beginning June 2022, the landlord allegedly trespassed, entered with a duplicate key, removed fittings, and caused damage, while the petitioner was ill. He reported Exts.P5 and P8 to police. The learned Single Judge held that a landlord cannot evade the statutory eviction process under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, and directed police protection and restraint on license cancellation without due process. The Division Bench reversed, emphasizing that Article 226 powers are discretionary and not to resolve disputed questions of title or civil rights; such disputes require civil or Rent Control Court proceedings. The court advised pursuing remedies in civil court, or Rent Control, and set aside the impugned order, while reserving costs to the parties.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 153 of 2015

Jayaseelan v. M.K. Prakasan and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

This MACA challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thalassery award arising from a 19.06.2005 accident in which the appellant-driver of a motor cycle and the pillion were injured when their vehicle collided with a tipper lorry. The pillion’s claim was settled; the appellant’s O.P.(M.V).No.463/2006 resulted in an award that is attacked on grounds of insufficient compensation. The Kerala High Court, hearing MACA 153/2015, re-evaluates several heads of compensation. It accepts that the appellant was an autorickshaw driver and, supported by Ext.A17 driving license, determines the notional monthly income at Rs.6,000 (overruling the Tribunal’s Rs.4,000) and notes hospitalization for 37 days, with a claim of about a year out of work; the court fixes six months for loss of income. Pain and suffering is increased from Rs.25,000 to Rs.35,000, with an additional Rs.25,000 for loss of amenities after considering the disability certificate showing 8% impairment. The court declines future prospects but awards enhanced amounts across various heads, totaling Rs.2,09,860, with separate instructions for interest and NEFT/RTGS transfer. The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated, adjusting the compensation payable by the insurance company."

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No. 242 of 2012 (with connected cases Nos. 243/2012 and 317/2012)

C.C. Joy v C.D. Mini

This is a matrimonial appeal involving C.C. Joy (appellant) and C.D. Mini (respondent) with Milan (minor) as a party, arising from Family Court Thrissur O.P. Nos. 559/2006 and 775/2006 and connected cases, decided by a Kerala High Court Division Bench on 13 June 2022. The central issue is whether a series of properties acquired during the marriage were benami transactions—i.e., purchases made in the name of Mini (and Milan) but funded by Joy’s money and for his benefit—and, if so, who is the real owner. The court undertook a focused benami analysis, applying the six tests enunciated in Java Dayal Peddar v. Bibi Hazra (AIR 1974 SC 171) and reaffirmed in Valliammal v. Subramanian (AIR 2004 SC 4187). It also considered statutory provisions of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (as amended by Act 43 of 2016) including sections 3(1), 3(2), and 2(a), and the presumption under Section 3(2) regarding purchases in the name of a wife/unmarried daughter. The Family Court had dissolved a divorce case and partly granted relief on property disputes; the High Court, after examining evidence and bank transactions, concluded most properties were benami, with Joy as the beneficial owner, and Mini as the name lender. The judgment upholds some findings, reverses others, and partially allows the appeals, notably declaring Joy as the beneficial owner of item 17 (O.P. No.559/2006) and injuncting Mini from alienating that property, while ordering that other immovable properties be treated as Joy’s beneficial property and directing movables to Mini. The bench is Division Bench; neutral citation is not provided in the document.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 119 of 2015

Saramma Chacko and Sanal M.O. v. Aby Johnson and The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.

MACA No.119 of 2015 arises from an appeal against an award of Rs 6,64,200 with 9% interest in the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta, in OP(MV) No.83/2008, concerning the death of Chacko, a 48-year-old mason, who died in a motor vehicle accident on 13 November 2007 while travelling in an autorickshaw. The petitioners, the wife and son, claimed compensation of Rs 9,95,000 for loss of dependency and other heads. The Tribunal held the first respondent negligent and assessed Rs 6,64,200, distributing the amount across heads such as loss of dependency (Rs 4,73,200), funeral expenses (Rs 25,000), loss of love and affection (Rs 50,000), loss of consortium (Rs 1,00,000), and loss of estate (Rs 5,000), with the balance under other heads and 9% interest from the date of filing till realization. The 2nd respondent Insurance Company contended the amount was excessive. The High Court re-examines the evidence, aligning with Supreme Court principles on MV Act awards, including notional income, future prospects, and deductions for personal living expenses, as well as the relationship between loss of love/affection and loss of consortium. It fixes the notional income at Rs 6,000 per month for 2007, applies 25% future prospects, and uses Ramachandappa, Pushkar Mehra, and Satinder Kaur to refine the heads. The result is a revised total of Rs 2,31,800. The appeal is allowed, directing deposit of the enhanced amount at 9% interest within two months, with proportionate costs, and noting a 102-day exclusion for interest.

High Court of Kerala
DBAR No.4 of 2022

Joint Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Travancore Devaswom Board Audit v. Secretary, Travancore Devaswom Board

This Division Bench of the Kerala High Court adjudicates a Devawsom Board audit report (DBAR No.4 of 2022) brought by the Joint Director, Kerala State Audit Department, seeking action on the Travancore Devaswom Board’s failure to furnish Annual Financial Statements for 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21, and breach of the time schedules under the Devaswom Fund Accounts Rules. The petition details that the Board implemented a Double Entry System of Accounting with retrospective effect from 01.04.2010 and that audits are to be conducted by High Court-appointed auditors under Section 32 of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950. It traces the procedural history, including repeated reminders to furnish accounts, delays in collecting data from subordinate offices, and the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on office functioning and staff strength. The respondent Secretary contends that delays are largely due to administrative and logistical challenges, including inter-departmental coordination and the necessity to reconcile records from numerous units, and cites particular extensions already granted in earlier DBAR proceedings. The court emphasizes statutory duties—regular accounting, annual audits, and accountability for mismanagement—and cites precedents stressing public accountability. It ultimately disposes of the DBAR by directing the Board to file proper applications seeking extension of time for the specified years and to report back, while preserving the court’s authority to act against those responsible for delays.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos.161 & 3363 of 2015

MACA Nos.161 & 3363 of 2015 (Rini Joy & Ors vs National Insurance Company Ltd)

This is a motor accident claims appeal arising from OPMV 653/2011 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pala, involving the death of Joy, S/o Abraham, in a road accident on 17-3-2011. The National Insurance Company Ltd (NIC) appeals MACA 161/2015 against the Tribunal’s compensation award, while the claimants (Rini Joy and family) cross-appeal in MACA 3363/2015 seeking higher damages. The Kerala High Court, C. Jayachandran, heard both appeals on 28 October 2022. The Tribunal had fixed the deceased’s monthly income at Rs 10,000 and calculated future prospects at 30 percent. NIC contended that Rs 8,000 would be more appropriate in light of Ramachandrappa; the claimants argued for Rs 15,000, supported by Exts A8-A10 showing business activity in real estate and a chitty, and by a shop income. After considering the evidence, the court held that Rs 15,000 was justified, noting Ext.A9 (a KSFE chitty passbook) indicating substantial regular remittance and Ext.A10 (sale agreements) showing real estate involvement. The court also held that future prospects should be 25 percent (not 30 percent) due to unorganized sector work. Relying on Pranay Sethi, it revised heads of damages: funeral expenses reduced to Rs 15,000; loss of estate increased to Rs 15,000; love and affection eliminated; consortium increased to Rs 1,20,000; loss of dependency enlarged to Rs 17,55,000, producing a total enhanced award of Rs 19,15,000. The insurer must pay the enhanced sum with 5% interest from the petition date; payment by NEFT/RTGS within a month, with set-off for any pre-paid amounts and consequences for non-compliance.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R.No.95 of 2018

T.K. Rahmathulla and T.K. Sihabudheen v. Charles C. Andrews

This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, heard by the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, in R.C.R.No.95 of 2018. The revision petition was filed by landlords T.K. Rahmathulla and T.K. Sihabudheen (represented by power of attorney) challenging the Rent Control Appellate Authority, Kozhikode’s reversal of eviction under Section 11(3) of the Act. The Rent Control Court, Kozhikode, had originally ordered eviction in R.C.P.238/2014 on 20/10/2016, finding the landlords’ need bona fide to start a medical centre in the scheduled shop. The RCAA allowed the landlords’ appeal on 28/09/2017, holding the need not bona fide, and thus evictions could not proceed. The High Court, hearing the revision, re-evaluated the evidence under its revisional jurisdiction and found the RCAA’s conclusions erroneous, concluding the need was bona fide and the proposed medical centre could be established in the premises. The court examined evidence including PW1’s income, Exts. B1–B3, and the broader purpose of the lease, while noting liberal pleadings and avoiding pedantic rigidity. It ultimately allowed the revision, granting the respondent six months to vacate with an undertaking and arrears payment by 27/12/2022, and continuing rent thereafter until vacatur.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 & MACA NO.2000 OF 2022

MACA Nos. 45 of 2021 & 2000 of 2022

These appeals concern quantum of compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act for the death of a minor in a road accident (Yasin Hydar A.P., aged 15). The Tribunal fixed the deceased’s notional income at Rs. 18,000 per month, with half deducted for personal expenses, awarding Rs. 17,47,000. The insurer challenged the quantum, while the claimants urged liberal assessment and questioned the continuing relevance of the Second Schedule to S.163A after its omission by Parliament. The Court surveys a line of precedents (Assainar, Kajal, Meena Devi, Kishan Gopal, Master Ayush, Angad Tiwari, Kusmi Devi, etc.), noting divergent approaches to notional income, global compensation and future prospects. The central issue is whether the pre-existing Assainar framework remains applicable after the Second Schedule’s omission and, if not, what method should fix notional income for a minor’s death. The Court ultimately holds that the Second Schedule is no longer applicable; notional income should be determined with reference to State minimum wages for a skilled worker, applying a multiplier approach. It partially allows the insurer’s appeal, while recalibrating future prospects, and wholly allows the claimant’s appeal in the 2022 matter, fixing notional income at Rs. 18,900 and determining enhanced compensation totaling Rs. 7,83,400 along with interest and costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 10612 of 2024 and connected cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected cases, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam (Pursuant to the Judgment by The Honourable Mr. Justice T.R. Ravi dated 26 March 2024)

This is a consolidated judgment of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, delivered by Justice T.R.Ravi on 26 March 2024, addressing a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and several connected matters) concerning freezing of bank accounts by various police authorities in cybercrime and related financial offences. The petitions challenge police-initiated freezes imposed on account funds as potentially proceeds of crime, arguing that freezes should be limited to the exact amounts specified in police requisitions and that the blanket immobilization of customer accounts is disproportionate and harmful to livelihoods. The court surveys the contemporaneous practice across multiple banks and states and observes that while police enforcement to curb crime is legitimate, order of freezing must be proportionate to the claimed misappropriation and constrained to the amount indicated in the police requisition. The judgment extracts and relies on a precedent from Dr. Sajeer v. RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) to guide interim measures and directs banks and police to follow a harmonized procedure. In its operative directions, the court directs: (a) confining freeze to the specified amounts, (b) police to inform banks whether further continued freezing is necessary and for how long (up to eight months from the judgment copy), (c) banks to comply or withdraw freezes based on police information, and (d) petitioners to approach the court again if information is not provided. The orders are said to dispose of the petitions with these directions, thereby balancing crime control with the protection of bank customers’ rights.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.2958 OF 2023

Jafar and others v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC 2958 of 2023) is a Kerala High Court petition under Section 482 CrPC by five accused persons challenging the order in SC No. 1408 of 2022 of the Assistant Sessions Court, Tirur. The petition seeks quashing of the criminal proceedings on the basis that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, and continuing prosecution would thwart peace and ends of justice. The accused—Jafar, Sharafudheen, Faizal, Vinu, and Gangadharan—are accused in an alleged unlawful assembly with a common object, trespass into the de facto complainant’s house, and injuries to the complainant, under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 452, 341, 323, 324, 308 read with 149. The prosecution alleged the offence on 10.07.2022. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing purely on settlement, noting prior criminal antecedents of some petitioners. The court directed the IO to record the defacto complainant’s statement and verify the genuineness of the settlement and any impediments to termination. Relying on State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and related Supreme Court authorities, the court held that Section 482 CrPC quashing is permissible for non-compoundable offences when disputes are civil/private and resolved, subject to exceptions for serious crimes. On analysis, the court concluded the present offences fall under Abkari Act 15(c) and IPC 279; the proceedings and the final report are quashed, thus bringing peace and ends of justice.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.2924 OF 2023

CRL.MC NO.2924 OF 2023

This is a Kerala High Court criminal misc case (CRL.MC 2924 of 2023) concerning accused nos. 1 to 8 in CC No.1271 of 2022 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-II, Alappuzha. The petition, invoked under Section 482 CrPC, challenges the continuation of proceedings for offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 323 and 324 IPC arising from an incident on 09 March 2018, when the petitioners allegedly formed an unlawful assembly and assaulted respondents 3–9, causing injuries. The petitioners contend that the disputes between the parties have been amicably settled and that, as a result, the entire prosecution should be quashed. Annexures A3–A9 affidavits from respondents 3–9 are relied upon in support of settlement. The investigating officer was directed to verify the genuineness of the settlement and whether the petitioners have any criminal antecedents, and the Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing mere settlement. The court then canvassed the settled-law framework from decisions including State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, among others, laying down when 482 CrPC power may be exercised and when it should not, particularly in heinous or public-offence or private-right contexts. The court emphasised weighing gravity of offence, injuries, and antecedents, and the civil nature of the dispute. On these considerations, the court allowed the petition and quashed Annexure-A2 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC 1271/2022.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1061 OF 2012

Devasia Xavier @ K.S. Jose and Soni Jose v. Manager, Marymatha Public School, Benny Varghese and United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (MACA No. 1061 of 2012)

This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, presided over by Justice Mary Joseph, heard MACA No. 1061 of 2012, challenging a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, award dated 16 February 2012 in O.P.(M.V.) No. 1589 of 2008. The deceased, Jose Sebastian (Saji Jose), was a motorcyclist who died in a road accident caused when a bus, KL 3/P-0958, driven rashly, struck him near Konni. The appellants, father and brother of the deceased, sought compensation of ₹8,58,000. The tribunal held the bus driver liable, awarded ₹3,62,900, and directed the insurer to deposit with 7.5% interest. The appellants contended the tribunal erred in applying the wrong multiplier (using the father’s age instead of the victim’s), under-valued the monthly income (₹7,500), and failed to consider loss of future prospects. The respondents contested that the award was just and claimed deductions for non-pecuniary heads. The court found omission to account for future prospects and adopted the appropriate multiplier (17) for a 28-year-old, unmarried victim, with 50% deduction for personal expenses. It reassessed the dependency loss to ₹10,71,000, adjusting for 40% future prospects, and deducted ₹35,000 from the extra heads to reflect Pranay Sethi principles. The tribunal’s total was recalibrated to ₹7,43,000 plus 7.5% interest, with directions for payment within two months and proportional court fee. The appeal is allowed with modified compensation."

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1697 of 2021

State Bank of Travancore (Now State Bank of India) v. Abraham T.V.

Abraham T.V., a retired employee of the State Bank of Travancore, challenged a bank decision denying him pension after voluntary retirement. He had 19 years, 6 months and 28 days of service and had sought pension under Regulation 29 on completion of 20 years of qualifying service. The bank had granted voluntary retirement effective 31.01.2014 but rejected the pension in Ext.P4 dated 20.06.2014 on the ground that he lacked the 20 years of qualifying service. The Single Judge held that the last fragment of service (6 months 27 days) could be treated as one year under Regulation 18, and when added to 19 years, yielded 20 years, making him eligible for pension with arrears and interest. The bank contended that Regulation 18 applies only to broken or interrupted service and that after 19 years 6 months 28 days the employer–employee relationship ceased; relying on Regulation 2(w) read with ejusdem generis and United Bank of India v. Nandy, it argued for a restricted interpretation. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, rejected this challenge, holding that Regulation 18 is a liberal, beneficial measurement rule that can treat interrupted or final uninterrupted spells for determining qualifying service. Relying on Indian Bank v. Venkatramani and Pritam Singh Bedi, the court distinguished United Bank of India, and upheld the writ petition. WA dismissed; pension must be paid within two months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.RP No.1683 of 2016

Asokan v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, in a criminal revision, examined Asokan, the accused in a 2012 Abkari case, challenging a conviction under Sections 8(1) and 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act. The trial court had held him guilty and sentenced one year’s simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with possible further imprisonment on default. The III Additional Sessions Court, Kozhikode, in Crl.Appeal No. 466 of 2015, maintained the conviction. The revision petitioner argued that Ext. P5 forwarding note did not name the Excise Guard who sent the sample for chemical analysis and that Ext. P7 does not show the date of despatch; the chemical analysis report showed the sample was received only on 27.03.2014 though the occurrence occurred on 31.10.2012, casting doubt on tamper-proof handling. He relied on Viswanadhan and Majeedkutty and urged that due process requires proof of proper custody and chain of custody. The court, citing Viswanadhan, Kumaran, Jayakumar, Gnanaprakasham, Viayan, Sathi and Baburaj, held that due to the lack of vital despatch details and failure to examine the thondy clerk or guard, the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed; conviction and sentence are set aside; the accused is acquitted, bail cancelled, and any deposited amount will be refunded.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 750 OF 2025

P. M. Mathew v. The Station House Officer, Changanacherry Police Station; State of Kerala represented by the Public Prosecutor; Arya Baiju

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case filed before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam by the petitioner-accused, P. M. Mathew, challenging an order in CC No. 4891/2019 pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Changanacherry, arising from Crime No. 2014/2019. The petitioner seeks to exercise the inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the First Information Report and all further proceedings on the ground that a settlement between the parties has been reached and that continuing the criminal process would be futile and amount to abuse of process. The defacto complainant, Arya Baiju, has provided an affidavit stating that she does not intend to pursue the case, and she has no grievance against the petitioner. She has even tendered an apology; her statements, coupled with the settlement, persuade the court that the settlement is genuine and bonafide. The respondent-State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, aligns with the relief, and the defacto complainant supports quashing. The court references established principles from Kulwinder Singh (Punjab & Haryana High Court), Gian Singh, Narinder Singh and Madan Mohan Abbot to assess quashment when a settlement is genuine and ends of justice demand. Ultimately, the court holds that the quashing would conserve resources and prevent abuse of process, and accordingly allows the Criminal Misc Case, quashing the F.I.R. and the final report, and all related proceedings in CC 4891/2019.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.5817 of 2024

SHAJI v. STATE OF KERALA

Shaji, petitioner/accused No.9 in Crime No. 444/2022 of Kuthuparamba Police Station, Kannur, moved Bail Application No. 5817/2024 under Sec. 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhitha, 2023, seeking bail in respect of offences including 406, 420, 201, and 204 read with Sec. 34 IPC; offences under the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act (3,4,5), Sec. 66D of the Information Technology Act, and Sec. 3 read with Sec. 21(1) of the BUDS Act. Arrested on 17 May 2024, the petitioner contends innocence, alleging false implication, and asserts he was merely an employee of the company named ‘My Club Trading,’ in which the 1st to 3rd accused were directors. The prosecution alleges a scheme to collect deposits from 8.7.2020 onwards, totalling about Rs. 2.086 crore, promising profits but failing to pay or return capital. The accused allegedly operated together; the 5th accused was granted bail in Annexure A IV. Counsel for the petitioner argued lack of criminal antecedents, 69 days in custody, and completion of the investigation in the petitioner’s portion, with recovery effected. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, citing ongoing investigation and risk of reoffending. Citing Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. and Article 21, the Kerala High Court finds a presumption of innocence and that bail is the general rule, with bail granted on stringent conditions: Rs.50,000 bond, two sureties, weekly appearances, no tampering, passport surrender or affidavit, and standard safeguards, including the possibility of early recoveries per Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi).

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.2624 of 2021

Anoop.K v. Sreevalsan.T.E and United India Insurance Company Limited

The Kerala High Court hears MACA No.2624 of 2021, a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thalassery award in O.P.(MV) No.124/2017. The appellant, Anoop.K, a mason injured in a road traffic collision on 19.11.2016, was hospitalised until 25.11.2016 and claimed loss of income based on a Rs.30,000 monthly wage, plus implant surgery costs and future implant removal. The Tribunal accepted the appellant’s evidence for injuries but fixed a notional income at Rs.8,000 and awarded total compensation of Rs.1,71,500 with no permanent disability compensation. The appeal contends that the notional income is understated and that additional expenses for implant removal and other non-conventional heads require enhancement. On hearing, this Court finds merit in the appeal and, aligning with the principle laid down in Angad Tiwari and Another v. National Insurance Company Ltd. and Another, 2024 KHC 8590, holds that the notional income should be fixed at the State of Kerala’s minimum wage Rs.16,200 as notified by G.O.(P) No.28/2016/Fin. dated 26.02.2016. The Court further awards enhanced compensation on non-conventional heads and allows Rs.60,000 for implant removal (rejecting Rs.1,00,000 as excessive) after considering the elapsed time since the accident. The final order provides a total enhanced compensation of Rs.1,45,200 over the Tribunal’s award, with interest at 8% p.a. on the enhanced Rs.85,200 and two months’ time for deposit, with a condition that Rs.60,000 be released only upon production of an implant removal certificate.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 6109 OF 2024

Gino Babu v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under section 439 CrPC filed by Gino Babu, the first accused in Crime No. 458/2024 at Kuravilangadu Police Station, Kottayam, challenging the allegations under multiple IPC sections. The prosecution contends that on 09.05.2024, the accused, in furtherance of common intention, abused the father of the de facto complainant, assaulted him with a wooden stick causing injuries, restrained him, snatched his mobile phone, and that the second accused misappropriated the scooter key, with additional offences under sections including 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 325, 326, 308 and 392 r/w 34 IPC. The petitioner surrendered on 09.07.2024 and has been in judicial custody for about 28 days; investigation is complete and the final report was laid on 15.07.2024. He has no prior criminal antecedents. The defense argues innocence and contends that adding aggravated sections appears designed to keep him incarcerated; the petitioner had earlier sought anticipatory bail under Section 438, which was dismissed. The prosecution submits risk of witness intimidation and tampering but does not dispute that the investigation has concluded. The court invokes Sanjay Chandra and Dataram Singh to reaffirm presumption of innocence and bail as the rule, and cites Sushila Aggarwal for recoveries on bail. The order ultimately allows bail on stringent conditions including a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, and periodic IO appearances, with other safeguards.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 32228 OF 2019

M. Muraleedharan Vibhanjika v. Kozhikode District Co-Operative Bank Ltd

This writ petition challenges the decision of the Kozhikode District Co-operative Bank Limited to withhold the petitioner’s retiral benefits on the basis that a liability of Rs. 1,53,32,339/- has been fixed against him. The Bank quantified the liability through Ext.P4, and the petitioner contends that Ext.P4 is illegal and cannot be used to withhold retirement benefits, particularly since Ext.P3 granted by this Court provided liberty to the Bank to consider his claim and issue an appropriate order, not to permit unilateral quantification. The Bank’s stand relies on Rule 198(8) of the Kerala Cooperative Societies Rules to withhold the Non-liability Certificate, arguing that large amounts due justify retention of benefits. The sole question before the Court is whether the Bank was justified in withholding the retiral benefits on the basis that only a Liability Certificate can be issued, having already found amounts due under the statutory framework. The Court relies on its own decision in Mohanan Nair P.G v. Omallur Service Co-operative Bank Ltd and others (W.A.No.297/2020), which answered this issue against the Bank and is binding. Ext.P4 is treated as an internal assessment, not a formal quantification under Section 69 of the KCS Act. The Court directs the Bank to release all retiral benefits within three months, while permitting the Bank to pursue Section 69 remedies through the competent authority if desired, subject to any interdictory orders. This order aims to balance statutory due process with timely disbursement of retirement benefits.