Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 478 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P. 688 of 2022

Baby Sheeja N.S. v. State of Kerala & C. Stephen

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition under sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C., challenging a conviction under Section 138 NI Act and the related sentences. The accused, Baby Sheeja N.S., was convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram, for dishonour of a cheque for Rs. 2,00,000 dated 03.09.2015. The Sessions Court, in Crl.Appeal No. 28/2022, modified the default sentence and the compensation payable under Cr.P.C. The revision petition contends that the trial and appellate courts failed to appreciate the evidence of PW1–PW3 and relied on presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act to sustain the conviction, while also challenging the imposition of 9% interest on the cheque amount. The petitioner argues a case of prior transactions (2011) and a possible misutilisation of the cheque, supported by DW1, which the courts allegedly did not properly evaluate. The High Court reiterates that revisional jurisdiction is supervisory and not a second appellate jurisdiction; it does not reweigh evidence absent gross miscarriage of justice. Citing several Supreme Court decisions (Namboodiri, Sanjay-sinh Chavan, Kishan Rao, Rangappa, Bir Singh, Kalamani Tex) and Vijayan’s case (AIR 2012 SC 528), the court upholds the trial and appellate verdicts, finds 9% interest not merited, and dismisses the revision petition. The court grants six months to pay the fine (from today) and defers execution until 24.02.2023, with the interim order vacated.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5898 OF 2024; BAIL APPL. NO. 6223 OF 2024; BAIL APPL. NO. 6225 OF 2024

Bail Applications in Crime No. 471/2024, Karipur Police Station, Malappuram: Rashid M.; K Riyas; Ramees M C v. State of Kerala

These bail applications arise from Crime No. 471/2024 of Karipur Police Station, Malappuram, pending before the Kerala High Court. Three petitioners—Rashid M., Riyas K., and Ramees M C—are accused under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) and Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, for allegedly possessing 4.9 kg of ganja in a hotel room on 19.06.2024, with investigations revealing involvement of others in the case. The petitioners argue innocence, lack of material linking them to the offences, and that they have no criminal antecedents. They highlight that the contraband is of an intermediate quantity, investigation is complete, and recovery has been effected; consequently, continued detention is unnecessary. The State/Public Prosecutor counters that, although there are no antecedents, the nature of narcotics trafficking and the potential for repetition warrant ongoing custody; the charges pertain to import from Thailand with an intended export to the UAE, underscoring the offense’s seriousness. After hearing, the court notes the absence of prior antecedents, the intermediate quantity of contraband, and the completion of investigation, and finds that further detention is unwarranted. It grants bail to all three petitioners on bonds of Rs. 1,00,000 each with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including regular IO appearances, no inducement or tampering with evidence, and surrender of passports if any, citing bail practices and recoveries on bail (Sushila Aggarwal doctrine).

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022

BAIL APPLICATIONS IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM (BA Nos. 7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022)

This judgment consolidates eight connected bail applications filed by Sri Lankan refugees/foreign nationals in two criminal investigations—Crime Nos. 529/2022 (Pallithottam Police Station, Kollam) and 868/2022 (East Police Station, Kollam). Heard by Justice Viju Abraham, the petitioners seek regular bail or interim release while investigations proceed and, in several cases, request continued stay in refugee camps or detention facilities. The court notes the serious nature of the offences, including sections 511 and 370 read with 34 IPC, as well as violations of the Foreigners Act (sections 14A, 14C, and an 14A(b) reference), the Emigration Act (section 10) and the Passport Act (section 12(1)(a)). The court had earlier issued interim bail orders directing that the foreign nationals stay in Open Prison and/or a transit home under government oversight, and recognizing a transit home at Mayyanad, Kollam. The court observed concerns about health, pregnancy, and child welfare, and discussed sending certain petitioners back to refugee camps in Tamil Nadu under orders in a separate Writ Petition, and the need for inter-state guidance (Kerala, Tamil Nadu, and Central Government). On reviewing developments, the court disposed of the bail applications by granting interim bail with detailed conditions, including personal bonds, non-interference with investigations, and restrictions on movement, while directing arrangements for the petitioners to stay at Gandhi Bhavan Pathanapuram or Open Prison Nettukaltheri, with educational facilities for their children, pending further orders.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 19 of 2023

Crl.M.C. No. 19 of 2023

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No.19 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court challenges the validity of FIR No.2067/2022 registered at Nedumangad Police Station, seeking to quash all further proceedings. The petitioners, accused Nos.1 to 3, include an Inspector of Police; respondent No.2 is the defacto complainant who alleges that petitioner No.1 enticed her to his house, sexually assaulted her on multiple occasions, and that petitioners 2 and 3 assaulted her when she visited later. A parallel FIR (2068/2022) against Respondent No.2 and her husband and another FIR (2092/2022) were also launched. The petition rests on the claim that the entire complaint is false, motivated by personal and financial disputes, and that the evidence purportedly shows the allegations are untrue; the defense emphasizes that the parties were in a close relationship, that the alleged acts occurred within a consensual context, and that the matter has been amicably settled. Respondent No.2 contends that the case was filed to avoid criminal jeopardy and highlights the settlement between the parties as justification for quashing. The court cites the Supreme Court’s guidance in Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Lakshmi Narayan, and Kapil Gupta, to balance ends of justice against the seriousness of the alleged crimes. Ultimately, the court finds the allegations unsustainable and declares that continuing proceedings would cause injustice, hence quashing FIR 2067/2022 and related processes.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 8700 OF 2022

Vaisak P.R. v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by Vaisak P.R., the 2nd accused in Crime No. 43/2018 (S.C. No. 73/2020) before the Special Court NDPS, Thodupuzha, challenging the non‑bailable warrant and seeking directions to consider his bail application on surrender. The petitioner, who had been granted bail by this Court in 2019, went abroad due to his father’s cancer treatment. On return readiness to surrender on 9.12.2022, the petitioner sought that the Special Court be directed to consider his bail application on the date of surrender, on merits, and to keep the non‑bailable warrant in abeyance until surrender. The State of Kerala, represented by the Public Prosecutor, conceded the factual events. The report of the Special Judge indicated that the accused had previously absented himself, triggering a forfeiture process; though the bond forfeiture record was not entirely clear, the court discussed the law surrounding bond forfeiture, remission under CrPC 446(3), and the duty to impose penalties on both accused and sureties where default has occurred. The High Court exercises supervisory jurisdiction to ensure a fair, prompt disposition on surrender. It ultimately directs the Special Judge to entertain any bail application on the date of surrender and, on merits, to pass orders and, where appropriate, impose penalties on the sureties and the accused.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2406 OF 2022

Rajesh D and others v. State of Kerala

These eight petitioners approached this Court under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash the final report and proceedings in CC No.525/2017 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Alathur, arising from Crime No.464/2017 of Alathur Police Station. The offences alleged are 143, 147, 148, 323 and 324 read with 149 IPC. The prosecution alleges an unlawful assembly on 29.04.2017 during which respondents 3 and 4 were assaulted. The petition is supported by affidavits A3 and A4 by injured parties stating the dispute is private, having been settled, with no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor confirms that the settlement’s veracity was verified by the SHO, and the injured parties reiterate no grievance. The Court finds the dispute essentially private and that continuing the proceedings would not serve any useful purpose, citing the principle in Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another (2012(4) KLT 108) that the High Court can exercise its inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC in such private-settlement cases. However, the presence of criminal antecedents for petitioners 4 and 8 leads the Court to restrict quashing for them, allowing quashing for petitioners 1–3 and 5–7 while proceedings against 4 and 8 continue.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 12173/2020, 6753/2020, 13816/2020, 13965/2020 and 18492/2020

Common Judgment in W.P.(C) Nos. 12173/2020, 6753/2020, 13816/2020, 13965/2020 and 18492/2020

These connected writ petitions, heard together, challenge a 30.12.2019 order of the Sub Collector, Fort Kochi, which rejected a revenue-entry correction application for about 9.41½ acres in Rameshwaram Village including Sy Nos 613/1, 613/2, 613/3, 663/2, 661/1 and 1499 forming part of Azhakiyakavu Devi Temple land. The petitioners contend the land is Devaswom property (Devaswom Puramboke) with entries showing “Vela Veli” and “puramboke” in basic tax and settlement registers, and that Ext.P6 was passed without providing a copy of the 22.08.2019 Village Officer report, violating natural justice. The Cochin Devaswom Board and allied petitioners seek correction of revenue records to reflect temple ownership and protection of temple rituals and the Sreemoolastanam situated there. The Court underlines temple lands as objects of guardianship under the doctrine of parens patriae and cites decisions stressing protection of Devaswom properties. It finds Ext.P6 vitiated for lack of audi alteram partem and for reliance on a report not furnished to affected parties. The judgment remands with directions to reconsider Ext.P4 afresh, ensuring due process, hearing, and documents, and to decide within four months, while maintaining status quo and allowing reconstruction of a boundary wall subject to necessary permits. It reiterates the duty to safeguard religious and charitable properties and to address encroachment through lawful remedies.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1545 OF 2019

MACA NO. 1545 OF 2019

MACA 1545 of 2019 arises from a motor accident involving Lino M George, who died in 2013 while riding a motorcycle on a public road in Pathanamthitta. The appellants, the deceased’s parents and his brother, challenged the MACT award of Rs. 9,99,000 with interest. The Tribunal recognised the claim with notional income based on a student; the appellants argued for a higher income and for future prospects, and for higher dependency. They relied on Supreme Court authorities: Ramachandrappa for notional income, Pranay Sethi for 40% future prospects, and Sarla Verma for the 18 multiplier. The court increased the notional income to Rs. 10,000 per month, applied 40% future prospects, and deducted 50% for personal expenses; the loss of dependency computes to Rs. 15,12,000 using a multiplier of 18. Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd on filial consortium awards Rs. 40,000 per parent with a 10% increase every three years, totaling Rs. 88,000 for the claimants. The Tribunal’s awards for love and affection (Rs. 50,000) and pain and suffering (Rs. 10,000) were set aside. Loss of future prospects and certain other heads were adjusted, producing a total enhanced compensation of Rs. 16,00,000, with enhanced amounts of Rs. 6,36,000 payable by the insurer. The appeal is allowed; directions for interest and NEFT/RTGS payment were issued.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO.703 OF 2012

Shihabudheen.K.P. v. M/s TV Sundaram Iyengar and Sons Limited; Noor Mohammed; Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd.

This MACA arises from an award of the Principal MACT, Kozhikode, in OP(MV) No.1639/2009 dated 20.09.2011. The appellant, Shihabudheen.K.P., sustained injuries in a motorcycle–jeep collision on 14.08.2009 on the Kondotty–Kozhikode road. The jeep, owned by the first respondent, was insured by the third respondent. The appellant, a construction worker, claimed Rs.8,53,000; the Tribunal awarded Rs.2,28,886 with interest at 7% and Rs.1,000 costs, partially allowing the petition. The appellant appeals for higher compensation, arguing substantial heads such as loss of earnings, disability, pain and suffering, bystander expenses and loss of amenities. The respondents contended that the accident occurred due to the appellant’s own negligence and that the insurer is liable to indemnify only if the policy conditions are satisfied; the third respondent admitted insurance but argued no loss of earning capacity per disability certificate. The High Court undertook a reassessment, relying on Ramachandrappa to set notional income at Rs.6,000/month, and Rajkumar and Sarla Verma to guide medical board reference and multiplier, upgrading disability classification and recalculating totals. Ultimately, the court enhances compensation to Rs.4,86,086, with an additional Rs.2,57,200 payable with 7% interest, and costs. The insurer is required to deposit the enhanced sum before the Tribunal within 60 days for disbursement to the appellant.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C).654/2022

Baby Girija @ Girija S. Nair and S. Sreekandan Nair v. K. Jayaram Nair and Biju

This is an Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India filed by the plaintiffs in OS No.526/2021 before the Munsiff Court, Neyyattinkara, challenging concurrent findings of fact and law recorded by the trial court and the appellate court in a dispute relating to a property and easement along a ramp/pathway. The petitioners contend that the appellate court did not afford them an opportunity to argue the case on merits and dismissed CMA No.14/2021 without hearing, relying on an affidavit (Ext.P9) filed by their counsel. The court examined the chronology of events surrounding CMA No.14/2021 and CMA No.2450/2021, including a Sub Judge’s report stating that the matter was heard on 01.12.2021 and posted for orders, but actual pronouncement was delayed. The petition also questioned whether stay arguments were adequately heard, and Ext.P9 was said to be filed after the impugned judgment. The High Court concluded that the impugned judgment was a detailed merits-based order, that hearing occurred as reported, and that the petitioners’ assertion of lack of hearing could not be sustained, especially in light of the Sub Judge’s report. The court ultimately dismissed the Original Petition, upholding the concurrent findings of the lower courts. The matter also discusses the sufficiency of plaint descriptions in easement claims, citing established principles on dominant/servient heritage.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1123 OF 2022

C Hashim v. Oriental Insurance Co Ltd

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal arising from an award in OP(MV) No.1508/2006 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode, concerning catastrophic injuries to a 13-year-old boy who was rendered bed-ridden with near-total dependence. The MACT originally granted Rs. 6,64,671 as compensation, which the appellant contends is exiguous in light of extensive medical treatment, long hospitalisation (over 330 days), and lifelong functional disability. Counsel for the appellant stressed that Ext. C1 certifies 50% disability, but the functional impact is far greater: the child requires continuous attendant care, catheters and medical articles, and will endure lifelong disability. The insurer argued the award was proper given the 50% disability and the minor’s notional income baseline. The High Court undertook a de novo assessment, noting the child’s loss of childhood, enduring dependency, and the breadth of medical and personal care costs. Relying on Supreme Court precedents cited in Vinod v. Suresh Kumar and others, Kurvan Ansari Alias Kurvan Ali v. Shyam Kishore Murmu, Kishan Gopal v. Lala and others, and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Others, the court held that a minor’s notional income must be at least Rs. 30,000 per annum and that compensation must be substantially enhanced across heads including permanent disability, attendant costs, bystander expenses, loss of amenities, pain and suffering, and loss of studies, while directing 6% interest.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.12829 & 14883 of 2022

WP(C) Nos.12829 & 14883 of 2022

Two writ petitions by quarry leaseholders challenge an environmental clearance condition requiring wildlife clearance for mining activity within 10 km of protected areas. The petitioners contended that Ext.P20 imposed an onerous condition, predicated on an Office Memorandum dated 08.08.2019 (OM 2019) that mandates prior clearance from the Standing Committee of the National Board for Wildlife (SCNBWL) for projects within 10 km of National Parks or Wildlife Sanctuaries. They argued the ESZ notification was not finalised and the 10 km buffer order cannot be used to curb mining beyond a unit kilometre; they relied on Raji Mathew v. Director of Mining and Geology (2018) to contend that delays in finalising draft notifications cannot block environmental clearance. They cited Amit Kumar v. UoI and Goa Foundation (II) to argue that the 1 km rule is not absolute and that strict legal mechanisms are necessary to impose wildlife-related hurdles. The petitioners pressed that ESZ rules and the 2019 OM are not issued under law and cannot override the EIA 2006 framework without proper legislation. The Kerala High Court, applying the Supreme Court’s directions in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. UoI, quashed general condition i of Ext.P20 and Clause 5(6) of Ext.P2, directing authorities to consider mining lease applications without insisting on SCNBWL clearance, thereby permitting mining subject to other statutory checks.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P.Nos.116, 234 and 590 of 2017

Crl.R.P. Nos.116, 234 and 590 of 2017

Three criminal revision petitions (Crl.R.P. Nos.116/2017, 234/2017, and 590/2017) before the Kerala High Court arise from S.C.No.68 of 2016 (Crime No.118/1982 and 65/1983) involving the 1982 murder of Anchery Baby and related offences. The accused-turned-revisions challenge discharge orders passed by the II Addl. District Court/ MACT, Thodupuzha under Sec.239 Cr.P.C. The matter traces a long line of proceedings. In 1982, nine accused were tried in S.C.No.58/1985; the Sessions Court acquitted them; the State’s appeal in Crl.Appeal No.411/1986 was dismissed by the High Court in 1990, a judgment which has since become final. In 2012, a CPI(M) district secretary made a public speech naming persons allegedly involved in past killings, leading to fresh investigations and final reports (2015–2012) in Crime Nos.118/1982 and 65/1983. The present case re-frames conspiracy and murder charges against present accused Nos.2 and 3 (and others) on the basis of new and previously examined witnesses who had earlier been acquitted or became witnesses. The High Court finds serious inconsistencies, reliance on old acquittals, and contradictions in witness testimony, undermining the substratum of the prosecution case. Relying on discharge jurisprudence, it allows the revisions and discharges all accused, setting aside the impugned discharge orders.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2875 OF 2023

Aneesh N.B., Deepak V.M., Abin Bharathan, Abhijith Sunny, Rajeesh S v State of Kerala represented by Public Prosecutor, Joyal Job, Ashwin Santhosh, Vishnu Prasad, Amal PC

This criminal miscellaneous case (CRL.MC 2875/2023) concerns a petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by five accused persons challenging the order in SC 538/2021 from the Addl. Sessions Court, Thalassery. The petitioners—Aneesh N.B., Deepak V.M., Abin Bharathan, Abhijith Sunny, and Rajeesh S—are facing charges arising from an incident on 24 December 2020, in which they allegedly restrained and assaulted the defacto complainant and associates with an iron rod, causing injuries under multiple IPC sections (143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 506(ii), 308, 326) read with 149. They contend that the parties have amicably settled all disputes, and the investigation has been directed to verify the genuineness of that settlement and whether any impediment exists to terminating the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, but acknowledged absence of other transgressions against the petitioners. Relying on State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and a line of decisions including Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Parbatbhai Aahir and others, the court lays down the controlling principles: quashing is permissible where the criminal proceedings have a civil/private character and the disputes are resolved; however, it should not be used for heinous, serious offences or for offences under special statutes. The judge ultimately concludes that, after evaluating the gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the current amicable settlement, quashing under 482 is appropriate; the petition is allowed and all further proceedings in SC 538/2021 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
BA 3980/2020

Rashid Salam T.A. et al. v. Senior Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Kochi Zonal Unit & Sub Regional Unit, Nelloore/Vijayawada

This is a Kerala High Court anticipatory bail matter under Section 438 Cr.P.C. involving three petitioners engaged in importing and trading agricultural products, including spices. The DRI asserts that Arecanuts from Indonesia were misdeclared as coconut expeller cake in four containers, making the goods liable for confiscation under Section 111 of the Customs Act and an offence under Section 135. The petitioners were summoned under Section 108 of the Customs Act, statements were recorded over several days, and the Sessions Court had dismissed their anticipatory bail application. The petitioners contend they have an unblemished industry record, that no offence has been committed by them to date, and that Section 104(1) of the Customs Act empowers arrest by a Customs Gazetted Officer if there are grounds to believe a non-bailable offence has been committed; thus anticipatory bail is warranted, even though they have not yet been charged. The respondents rely on the seriousness of the alleged contraband, the statements recorded, and the ongoing investigation, arguing that arrest is a real possibility. After hearing, the Court notes the investigation is ongoing, the applicants have not yet been accused, and finds the case to be premature for anticipatory bail. The bail application is ultimately dismissed as premature, given the ongoing inquiry and the lack of an accused status at this stage.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1805 of 2012

Mariyamma Varkey Pattathil & others v. Ajinal Azad & The New Indian Assurance Co. Ltd.

This High Court of Kerala appeal arises from an award under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, concerning the death of Chacko Varkey @ Lalichan in a road accident on 09.12.2007. The appellants, the deceased’s mother and siblings, claimed structured compensation of Rs. 4,00,000 in the Motor Accidents Claims Petition (O.P. (MV) No. 415/2008) before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 94,500, with Rs. 90,000 for loss of dependency, Rs. 2,000 for funeral expenses, and Rs. 2,500 for loss of estate; other heads were disallowed. The insurer contended that Section 163A prescribes a fixed, Second Schedule-based formula for compensation in fatal accidents, negating the conventional multiplier and dependency calculations; the claimants argued for a higher income and a better multiplier, accusing the Tribunal of misapplying the rules and relying on outdated principles. The High Court reviewed the statutory scheme, noting Section 163A’s objective of rapid relief and the structure of the Second Schedule, and the line of authorities distinguishing 163A from claims under Section 166. It held that multiplier-based calculations are not applicable under 163A and determined enhanced compensation of Rs. 2,83,350 with a 50:25:25 distribution among claimants, plus interest. The appeal was allowed, directing payment within two months and bearing costs by respective parties, with disbursement aligned to the court’s directives on bank details and timelines.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.15128 OF 2020(M)

HDFC Bank Ltd. v. Sub Registrar, Kothamangalam Sub Registrar Office, Government of Kerala and Village Officer, Pindimana Village

The petitioner, HDFC Bank Ltd., a secured creditor, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ of mandamus to compel respondents 1 and 3 to remove attachments created after the mortgage in a property measuring 10 cents in Sy.No. 477/1A/37/9A, Pindimana Village, registered by documents Nos. 291 of 2000 and 2484 of 2010 in the Kothamangalam Sub Registrar Office. The bank had extended Rs. 13,00,000 to a partnership named Near and Safe Tube N Rods and secured the loan by mortgage through title deeds; an attachment order F172/2016 was filed during the mortgage period. Encumbrance certificates Ext.P3 and Ext.P4 (dated 24.12.2016) show post-mortgage encumbrances. The petitioner contends these attachments are contrary to law and seeks their expunction, as well as a declaration that the property is free from encumbrances. The State respondents submit that the writ petition is not maintainable and that attachments created post-mortgage do not affect the bank’s rights; they contend the Sub Registrar must accept encumbrance orders under the Registration Act. The court relies on Madhan v. Sub Registrar (2014) and Keechery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Sajitha Nizar (2020), and Ali Asharaf M.M. v. Sub Registrar, Thrissur (W.A.612/2015) to uphold that post-mortgage attachments do not defeat the mortgagee’s rights. It directs deletion/effacement of the attachments from records within six weeks, with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1886 OF 2009

Sabu C.S. v. Saju George and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

The appellant, Sabu C.S., filed O.P.(M.V.) No.796/2004 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation for injuries sustained on 27 May 2002 while travelling as a pillion on a motorcycle (KL-8/P 908). The accident occurred on Kuzhikattussery–Ashtamichira road at Kolkunnu when a Maruti car from the opposite direction collided with the motorcycle. The appellant, a police constable, suffered serious injuries including multiple fractures and permanent disability, and claimed Rs.7,66,000 against the rider (first respondent) and the insurer of the motorcycle (second respondent) who admitted coverage. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition, holding that only 50% of the compensation could be recovered from the insurer due to contributory negligence by both the rider and the car driver, and because the car owner/insurer had not been impleaded. The appellant challenged this finding, invoking Supreme Court precedents on composite negligence and joint and several liability, which permit recovery from a single wrongdoer or from multiple if sought. The High Court held that the Tribunal’s 50% limitation was erroneous and that the insurer must indemnify the rider’s liability in full since the motorcycle was insured under a package policy and the pillion rider was covered. On quantum, the court adopted cogent reasons to apply the split multiplier method, re-calcуlating income and disability, and enhanced the award to Rs.2,20,400 with 7% interest and Rs.10,000 costs, directing payment within two months and permitting recovery from the car’s owner/insurer as applicable.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.362 of 2022

South Indian Bank Ltd. v. Medicina Unani Hospital Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

This writ appeal arises from a Kerala High Court order in WP(C) 22686/2021 directing the bank to accept repayment of the overdue amount of Rs. 79.12 lakh in 16 equal installments and to regularise the loan account, with coercive proceedings stayed. The appellants, bank lenders, challenge the notices issued under Section 13(2) and 13(4) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002, and seek quashing of those notices or mandamus to restructure the loan in line with RBI Covid-19 relief measures, or to permit alternative repayment. The court noted that the bank had signalled willingness to accept payment in installments and to regularise the account, and that the earlier order contemplated 16 installments starting February 2022, with continued EMIs and conditions on default. It was observed that the bank had issued communications to remit the overdue amount in installments as directed by the court, which the bench accepted in dismissing the appeal. The judgment emphasizes prudent discretion in recovery matters, citing Supreme Court rulings on the treatment of public money and the need for circumspection in stay orders, while upholding the court-ordered installment plan as a workable remedy in the Covid context.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(KAT).NO.102/2022

Santhosh S. T v. State of Kerala and Others

Santhosh S. T., employed as an Assistant Executive Engineer in the Kerala Water Authority (KWA), filed O.P.(KAT) 102/2022 challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's order dated 21.03.2022 in O.A.443/2022, which dismissed the OA as not maintainable. The petitioner contends that the dispute concerns recruitment and service matters and that exclusion of KWA (an autonomous State PSU) from Stream 2 recruitment to the Kerala Administrative Service (KAS) is unlawful under the Kerala Administrative Service Rules, 2018. He seeks to challenge the KAS Rules 2018 and to obtain consideration for recruitment in KAS as an aspirant; The KAT had dismissed the OA on maintainability grounds under Section 15 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, arguing the dispute did not fall within listed categories. The High Court reviews Section 15, confirming its broad remit over recruitment and service matters in relation to State civil service. It cites Chandrakumar v. Union of India to justify liberal interpretation of the words 'recruitment' and 'matters concerning recruitment' so as to cover recruitment-notice and consideration of applications. It acknowledges the petitioner's status as an aspirant to a KAS post regulated by the KAS Rules 2018 and holds that the Tribunal cannot abdicate its jurisdiction. While acknowledging Sujith v. State of Kerala's policy-based conclusions, the Court proceeds to dispose of the petition by setting aside the Tribunal's order and dismissing the OA on merits in view of the Division Bench decision on policy matters.