This Kerala High Court judgment, in Crl.M.C. No. 1053 of 2023, concerns the State’s challenge under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to an Annexure A2 order that rejected an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. in a murder trial (SC No. 805 of 2017) before the Additional Sessions Court-V, Kollam. The prosecution sought to recall and examine additional witnesses after a court directive to complete the trial by 31 December 2022. It filed Cr.M.P. Nos. 73/2023 and 74/2023; Cr.M.P.74/2023 was allowed to recall PW23 with a two-week deadline, while Cr.M.P.73/2023 was partly allowed by the trial court. The State contends the witnesses are essential to prove crucial aspects, including treatment records (and the signature on Ext.P60 attributed to Smt. Bency) and other facts such as the deceased’s temple visit. The court emphasizes that Section 311 Cr.P.C empowers summoning and recalling witnesses only when essential for a just decision and cites Swapan Kumar Chatterjee v. CBI for the need to exercise this power with caution and not as abuse of process. It also cautions against belated recalls that prejudice the accused and disrupt continuous trial. On evaluation, the court holds Cr.M.P.73/2023: examined in part, allowing PW1’s examination and the recall/examination of PW2 and PW4, with a direction to complete within 30 days. The petition is thus partly allowed.
This suo motu DBP was initiated after news reports about a private helicopter package for Sabarimala pilgrims offered by Enhance Aviation Services LLP. The Kerala High Court noted that the operator advertised two daily Kochi–Nilakkal trips at Rs 45,000 per head, allegedly including darshan, dolly service and car transfer, without DGCA approval for regular operations within the Special Security Zone around Sabarimala and without prior intimation. The court recalled the proceedings from 18–21 November 2022, including undertakings by the operator to suspend the service, but held that such undertakings do not excuse action in accordance with law. It cited DGCA regulations (CAR) and GO(P) No.72/2022/Home, emphasising that helicopter operations, if regular (more than seven times a month), require DGCA-approval and SOPs; the operator allegedly did not possess an Air Operator Permit. The Travancore Devaswom Board asserted ownership of the Nilakkal helipad and relied on CAR for temporary heli-landing areas; the court observed the Nilakkal helipad is temporary and near the Periyar Tiger Reserve, justifying restricted use. It directed compliance with Section 83 of the Kerala Police Act (Special Security Zone) and mandated prior permission from the District Police Chief and prior intimation from the District Collector, plus NOC from the Board. The DBP is disposed of with directions to restrict helicopter operations, ensure security, and protect worship rights, wildlife, and public safety.
This High Court of Kerala appeal concerns the interpretation of sections 15 and 17 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 in a marumakkathayam (Nair) family. After Vijayalekshmi’s death, her mother filed O.S.343/1994 seeking partition, asserting intestate succession under S.17. Defendants, being her brother’s line, resisted under S.15. The Sub Court Thiruvananthapuram decreed the suit as prayed, effectively applying S.17 to entitle the mother to a share in the estate’s partition. An earlier suit (OS 2492/1993) by the second defendant for injunction against trespass involving items 6 and 7 had been decided; the question of whether that injunction judgment operated as res judicata to bar the partition suit was raised and rejected by the Sub Court, which held the injunction judgment could not operate as res judicata. The appellants challenged the Sub Court’s reasoning, arguing that Article 254 of the Constitution read with S.4 of the HSA overrides pre-1956 law and that the res judicata defense should bar the partition suit. The High Court, however, upheld the Sub Court, holding that marumakkathayam would continue to be governed under HSA S.17 (substituting the mother as a class I heir) and rejected the constitutional override and res judicata challenges. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
This is a Kerala High Court appeal (FAO (RO) No.191/2014) from remand order in a suit for fixation of boundary and injunction (OS 622/2004, O.S. 397/1977 antecedent). The suit, originating in the Additional Munsiff’s Court, Alappuzha, sought to fix northern and western boundaries of plaint schedule land, and to grant permanent and mandatory injunction against trespass after defendants allegedly erected slab walls and removed boundary marks on 2 August 2004. The trial court measured the property by the old survey and, relying on Ext.C2(a), decreed the reliefs. The First Appellate Court (A.S. No. 87/2008) remanded for locating the plaintiffs’ property including a UTFL way on the northern side (1.6 m wide, 40.2 m long) and directed inclusion of this way in the plaint schedule, effectively expanding the plaintiffs’ boundary description. The appellants challenged the remand, contending that Section 13 of the Kerala Survey and Boundaries Act requires fixation based on the re-survey, and that a boundary suit cannot substitute for possession, while revenue entries do not confer title. The respondents argued that re-survey does not establish title and urged reliance on the old plan. The High Court held that remand was unwarranted, insisted on fixing boundaries per the old survey/ title deeds, and set aside the remand, restoring the trial court’s decree. It dismissed the FAO and reaffirmed the original boundary findings. The decision navigates the role of re-survey versus title-based boundaries in Kerala land disputes.
The petitioner, K.A. Muraleedhara Menon, a retired Senior Superintendent, challenged an order of the Kerala Lok Ayukta (Exhibit-P6, dated 4 July 2014) in Complaint No.2433/2011, which sought to fix liability for delay in disbursement of retirement benefits and related dues arising out of a disciplinary proceeding in 1992–93. The factual narrative traces suspension in 1992, a Departmental inquiry, and a punishment of barring three increments with cumulative effect in 1993, followed by appeals, multiple court directions for timely pensionary payments, and belated liability certificates. The Lok Ayukta, after hearing, dismissed the complaint, holding that liability was quantified before retirement (3 August 1993) and intimated within one month of retirement, that follow-up actions for collection do not form part of the statutory obligation, and that the bar of limitation under Note 3, Rule 3, Part III KSRS did not render the liability invalid. The petitioner contends that the belated fixation of liability and the withholding of full DCRG violate KSRS and related decisions, and seeks full DCRG with interest. The respondents and Lok Ayukta defend the order, relying on KSRS Rule 3 and decisions such as Mathew and Balan, contending no interference is warranted. The High Court ultimately agrees with the Lok Ayukta and dismisses the petition, upholding the order.
A Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC arises from orders in A.S.6/2022 of the Sub Court, Chavakkad and O.S.1416/2014 of the Munsiff Court, Chavakkad, challenging a sale deed and related declaration. The plaintiffs, legal heirs of Divakaran, claim Ext.A2 (sale deed) executed in 2011 was not a sale but a mortgage/security for a loan, with an understanding of re-transfer upon payment. They seek to declare Ext.A2 null and void. The defense maintains that there was a prior contract for sale with the 3rd defendant and that the sale deed completed title transfer to the vendee. The trial court examined evidence; PW1 admitted Ext.B1; both the trial and first appellate courts dismissed the suit. The appellants argue that there was no passing of consideration and rely on Kewal Krishnan v. Rajesh Kumar etc., AIR 2022 SC 564, to emphasise that sale under Section 54 TP Act requires price. The court discusses that a contract for sale is not itself an interest in property; sale requires price, and a deed executed without price is void. However, the High Court ultimately finds no substantial question of law; the appeal is meritless and is dismissed without admission, with all interlocutory applications also dismissed. The decision reinforces the settled law that second appeals under Section 100 CPC must be grounded on a substantial question of law and not on questions of fact or mere technicality.
This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the fourth accused, Ramachandran, in Crime No.34/2024 of Mannanthala Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, challenging an order in CMP 81/2024 of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class – V, Thiruvananthapuram (Special Court – Mark List Cases) that denied bail in a case involving alleged criminal conspiracy and offences under sections 409, 420, 120(b) and 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 04.11.2023, the first accused, former Branch Manager of the Catholic Syrian Bank, Nalanchira Branch, stole 1727.77 grams of gold ornaments valued at Rs. 96,23,678 from the bank’s strong room and handed them to the second accused, who passed them to the third, with the fourth accused later replacing stones and pearls and melting the gold; the recovered gold was tested and sold to Kerala Jewellery, East Fort, with profit shared among the accused. The applicant contends his innocence, arguing that as a goldsmith he could not have aided the 409/420 IPC offences, and that conspiracy under 120(b) r/w 34 IPC can still be attributed, citing Jose P.T. v. State of Kerala and Shinoj v. State of Kerala. He notes custody since 17.01.2024, claims investigation is complete, and recovery effected, urging bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting ongoing investigation and grave economic offense, and that earlier bail petitions of co-accused were dismissed. The court ultimately dismissed the bail application, citing risk of tampering with evidence and justice being thwarted, consistent with established bail principles and prior orders in B.A. Nos. 809/2024 and 1044/2024.
WA 1689 of 2022 arises from WP(C) 14015/2021, filed against a Single Judge order directing the Kuzhalmannam Block Rural Credit Co-operative Society Ltd. (R3) to disburse matured fixed deposit (FD) proceeds to respondents 4–9 on an out-of-turn basis, subject to verification of deposits. The writ petition filed by the contesting respondents sought expedited payment of FD amounts amid concerns of misappropriation and a broader revival scheme for the cooperative sector. The Division Bench notes that disputes involving banking transactions are predominantly private or commercial in nature and not ordinarily amenable to the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The court emphasizes that the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act provides statutory avenues—Sec.69 for arbitration before an Assistant Registrar and, thereafter, an appeal or revision before the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal—rather than executive orders by the court. It relies on established jurisprudence, including a Full Bench decision in Shanmukha Sundaram Pillai S. v. Meenachil Rubber Marketing & Processing Co-operative Society Ltd. & Ors. (2022) and a Division Bench decision in The Mavelikkara Taluk Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Rajeswari S. Kumar (WA No. 614 of 2022), to argue that the Registrar lacks power to direct release of matured deposits under Sec.66A and that writ jurisdiction should not override statutory remedies. The appeal is disposed with the impugned ad hoc directions set aside and the judgment modified to reflect the available statutory remedies, while preserving liberty to pursue appropriate legal remedies.
CRL.M.C. NO. 7565 OF 2023 This Kerala High Court judgment under Section 482 CrPC deals with quashing of non‑compoundable offences arising from SC 1292/2022 (Crime No. 101/2021, Kothamangalam Police Station). The petitioners (1–4) are accused in offences including sections 341, 323, 447 r/w 34 IPC and sections 3(1)(s), 3(2)(Va) of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The respondents include the State represented by the Public Prosecutor, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, and the injured victims CW2–CW4. The petitioners seek to quash the prosecution on the basis that the parties have settled their dispute, supported by affidavits from the victims; the Public Prosecutor, while cautious, concedes the matter is settled. The court examines landmark authority: State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, and the guiding precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303 and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab (2014) 6 SCC 466. It is held that the power under S.482 CrPC can quash non‑compoundable, private offences where a complete settlement exists and the offences do not have a serious societal impact; however, heinous offences or those under special statutes may be excluded. On these lines, the court allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes SC 1292/2022 proceedings against the petitioners.
The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, hears CRL.A No. 825 of 2009, a criminal appeal by seven accused challenging the judgement of the Fast Track Court No.III (Adhoc), Manjeri, in SC 175/2008. The prosecution alleged that on 24 January 2007, around 7 a.m., the accused, acting in concert, criminally trespassed into PW1’s house and attacked him, his wife PW1’s wife PW2, and others, with MO1 (a sword) and MO2 (an iron rod). The trial court convicted the appellants under multiple IPC sections: 143, 147, 148, 452, 323, 324 and 307 r/w 149 IPC, and, for accused 4, Section 27 of the Arms Act. The accused were sentenced to various terms and fines; some were acquitted of certain counts. The High Court scrutinizes the evidence, including MO1’s non-identification, the lack of bloodstains on Ext.P13, inconsistencies in the First Information Statement (Ext.P1), and the reliance on custodial disclosure statements under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act. Relying on Sujatha v. State of Kerala (2018 KHC 659) and citing Raju Manjhi v. State of Bihar (AIR 2018 SC 3592), the court holds MO1 and MO2 not incriminating and that Section 27 discovery is untenable. It partially reverses the trial court’s findings: accused 2–7 are acquitted; accused 4’s Arms Act conviction is set aside; accused 1 is found guilty only of 323 and 452 IPC, with a short sentence for pre-trial detention. The appeal is allowed accordingly.
MACA No. 1678 of 2015 & Co. 145 of 2015 This is a Kerala High Court judgment in MACA No. 1678 of 2015 and Cross Objection/Co. 145 of 2015, decided by Justice Devan Ramachandran on 13 March 2023. KSRTC challenged a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in OP(MV) 1122/2012 for injuries sustained by Madhusoodanan in a road accident on 22 October 2012, arguing the Tribunal erred in fixating the claimant’s notional income at Rs. 30,000 per month and in the approach to future prospects. The claimant/cross-objector pressed for a higher notional income (Rs. 50,000) and enhanced compensation under heads such as Pain and Sufferings and Extra Nourishment. The Court analyzed the evidence: the cross-objector was a senior advocate with over 30 years’ practice and a panel counsel for National Insurance Company since 2005, but ultimately upheld the Tribunal’s Rs. 30,000 per month notional income, noting that even a 25% disability and long career may justify conservative earning estimates, especially given age (66 at the time of the accident) and the established jurisprudence on future prospects. The Court, however, increased damages under Pain and Suffering from Rs. 20,000 to Rs. 40,000 and Extra Nourishment from Rs. 1,000 to Rs. 5,000, while leaving other heads intact. It dismissed MACA No. 1678/2015 and allowed the cross-objection in part, with a two-month window to deposit enhanced amounts plus 9% interest and costs.
CRL.M.C 5980/2023 & 1345/2023 This is a pair of connected criminal miscellaneous petitions under Section 482 CrPC filed by Abinas K. and by Sufail Rahiman and Marshad seeking to quash the proceedings arising from Hosdurg Police Station Crime No. 99 of 2017 in which the accused faced multiple offences under IPC 143, 147, 148, 448, 341, 323, 324, 308 read with 149 IPC. The petitions were heard along with 5980/2023 and 1345/2023 and the court observed that the parties had resolved their entire dispute by means of settlements, including affidavits by the victims. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged that the matter was settled. The court relied on the three-judge decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan (2019) and the line of cases culminating in Gian Singh and Narinder Singh to articulate the framework under Section 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences when private disputes are resolved and where the offences are not heinous or connected to public interest. The court emphasized that quashing is permissible for private, non-heinous offences, especially in commercial or family disputes after settlement, while cautioning against quashing acts like murder, rape, dacoity, or offences under special statutes. In the present case, it found the dispute to be private in nature and accepted the settlement, quashing all further proceedings in both connected cases. The petitions were allowed.
MACA NO. 2015 OF 2014 & CO NO. 159 OF 2014 This High Court of Kerala disposal concerns a cross-appeal/cross-objection arising from a Motor Accidents Claim Tribunal award in OP(MV) 1288/2008. The original claim petition, filed by Unnikrishnan for injuries sustained in a 23.02.2008 accident, later became a death claim after his demise on 27.10.2008. The insurer, New India Assurance Co. Ltd., challenged the quantum of compensation; claimants sought enhancement through cross-objections. The court re-assesses several heads of compensations following established Supreme Court principles: it fixes the deceased’s monthly income at Rs.5,000 (per Ramachandrappa), adds 25% future prospects and applies a 14-year multiplier (per Pranay Sethi), leading to a substantial uplift in dependency. The tribunal’s lack of future-prospects addition is corrected. Loss of estate is increased from Rs.2,500 to Rs.15,000. The court also revisits the controversial heads of loss of love and affection and loss of consortium, applying the principle that compensation for loss of consortium should be sufficient for all claimants (wife and parents) and that separate love-and-affection awards should be avoided, invoking United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur. Funeral expenses are trimmed from Rs.25,000 to Rs.15,000. The consolidated outcome yields an additional payable amount of Rs.2,30,220, directing deposit within three months with 8% interest and costs.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1395 OF 2023 This is a regular bail application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) filed by Shan. M.S., the first accused in Crime No. 51 of 2022 of the Amaravila Excise Range Office, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner is charged under Sections 22(c) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) for allegedly transporting 75 grams of MDMA along with other items in KA-01-AM-7666. The contraband and related articles were recovered during a vehicle check at Amaravila RTO Check post on 10.11.2022, and the accused has been custody since 10.11.2022. The prosecution contends that the offences involve a commercial quantity of contraband, attracting the non-bailable regime under Section 37 NDPS Act, thereby precluding regular bail unless two conditions are met: (i) there are reasonable grounds for believing the accused is not guilty, and (ii) he is not likely to commit an offence while on bail. The petitioner, through counsel, asserts innocence, minimal involvement, and no prior criminal record, arguing for bail notwithstanding the NDPS charge. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail given the alleged commercial quantity and the gravity of the offences. The court perused the case diary, noted the 75 g MDMA in the petitioner’s possession, and relied on established jurisprudence beginning with Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari to define “reasonable grounds” as requiring more than prima facie sight. After evaluating the materials and the authorities cited, the court concluded there are no such substantial grounds and dismissed the bail application, upholding Section 37 NDPS bail restrictions.
The petitioner, Johny Kulampally, challenged the election initially scheduled for 25.04.2021 for the Idukki Taluk Primary Co-operative Bank, which was postponed due to a District Collector order under the Disaster Management Act and reset for 19.02.2023 without publishing a revised voters list. He contended that the long gap between the original date and the revised date necessitated a thorough verification of the voters list and removal of ineligible voters, including those who had died, to prevent impersonation and bogus voting. The respondents argued that once an election process commences, it must proceed to its conclusion and cannot be undone at intermediate stages; they claimed that the election could be conducted under the existing Rules with safeguards. On 15.02.2023, the court observed the petitioner’s concerns and, recognizing the risks, appointed Advocate Commissioner Deepu Lal Mohan to supervise the process and ensure compliance with procedures. The Advocate Commissioner’s report indicated routine identity checks and no instances of bogus voting, with counting proceeding and results to be declared later under further court orders. Ultimately, the petition was closed, with permission for the Returning Officer to declare the results and with avenues open for aggrieved parties to challenge in accordance with law.
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases The judgment consolidates multiple writ petitions challenging freezing of bank accounts by authorities in cybercrime investigations. It notes that accounts have been frozen on police intimations, with several petitioners from different banks and service cooperatives. On admission, the court issued interim directions restricting freezes to the amounts specified by police requisitions and directed banks to inform police as to the duration of the freeze. The court observed that often, freezes impact the entire account and hinder legitimate transactions, and it emphasized balancing investigation with petitioners’ rights and business continuity. The order ultimately disposed of WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected cases with directions that freezing be confined to the disputed sums, while keeping other contentions open for later consideration. The judgment repeatedly references prior jurisprudence (notably Dr. Sajeer v RBI) and prior Kerala High Court judgments, and provides a framework for subsequent banking and policing actions in cybercrime contexts.
BA 5811/2024 & 5918/2024; Crime No. 491/2024 This common order disposes Bail Applications Nos. 5811/2024 and 5918/2024 arising from Crime No. 491/2024 of Kannur Town Police Station. Petitioners Shiju M.A. and Shobha P. are accused of offences under Section 489B IPC for dealing with counterfeit currency. They were arrested and remanded on 09.05.2024. The prosecution contends the first accused passed counterfeit Rs. 500 notes to a Kannur hotel and, in interrogation, admitted that the second accused supplied the notes. A search of the second accused’s residence recovered counterfeit notes of Rs. 500, Rs. 1000 and Rs. 2000 denominations, along with a laptop and a printer. The petitions contend innocence, false implication, and lack of material tying them to the offence; they note that they have been in custody for about eighty days and that investigation is substantially complete with recoveries effected. The Public Prosecutors oppose bail, arguing the crime is serious and release could lead to repetition. The Court relies on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, Dataram Singh v. State of U.P, State of Kerala v. Raneef and Sushila Aggarwal to reaffirm presumption of innocence, that bail is the rule with detention only as an exception, and Article 21 rights. After careful consideration, the court allows the applications subject to stringent conditions: bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two sureties, weekly appearances before the IO, and other standard conditions including no tampering with witnesses and surrender of passports; failure to comply can lead to cancellation of bail. The matter is disposed accordingly.
WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and connected cases This judgment consolidates multiple writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and connected cases) arising from freezing of bank accounts in the wake of cybercrime investigations across several states. The High Court, led by Justice T.R. Ravi, addresses petitions filed by individual account holders and private entities challenging police-initiated freezes and bank halts on funds, arguing that freezing should be tightly limited to the amount specified by police requisitions and that blanket freezing impairs lawful business and property rights. The Court notes that police authorities inform banks about freezes and the banks implement them, but directs that freezes be confined to the amounts stated in the police notices, to enable petitioners to operate accounts beyond those limits. The judgment references a guiding precedent in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and prior Kerala High Court orders (e.g., W.P.(C) 28155/2023, W.P.(C)15751/2023), to frame directions for proportionate freezing and timely review. The Court emphasizes that if the enquiry disputes the charge, amounts alleged to be proceeds of crime must still be treated with caution, ensuring civil liberties while preserving the integrity of investigations. Ultimately, the petitions are disposed of with directions to restrict freezes to the limited amounts and to monitor continuations or withdrawals in light of evolving evidence.
Mat.Appeal Nos.1301/2015, 5/2016, 233/2016 These consolidated matrimonial appeals arise from the Family Court, Thrissur, where a decree of divorce under the Indian Divorce Act was granted to the husband after a protracted period of discord following the couple’s marriage in 2007 and subsequent separation. Angela, the wife, challenged the divorce in Mat.Appeal No.1301/2015 and was joined by connected appeals in Nos.5/2016 and 233/2016, while Terry Thomas and other family members counter-challenged some of the Family Court’s orders. The Court notes that the parties had been living separately since 2012 with failed efforts at reconciliation, and that emails, complaints, and communications to the husband’s employer and other authorities were placed on record as alleged mental cruelty. The High Court upheld the divorce, finding no sufficient ground to interfere with the opposition to reconciliation, while stressing that the child’s welfare requires attention to both parents’ care and visitation. On cross-claims, the Family Court’s award of Rs.12 Lakh and 60 sovereigns of gold ornaments to the wife, and the child’s 12 sovereigns, was scrutinized; the High Court partly modified the financial relief and confirmed a substantial portion of the ornament order, while preserving custody arrangements. The appeals were disposed of with no costs; the wife’s appeals were dismissed and the husband’s appeal was allowed in part.
The Kerala High Court (Single Judge) hears Crl.M.C. No. 9631 of 2023, challenging the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thiruvananthapuram’s order in CMP 1483/2023 (Vigilance case No. 3/2023/SIU-II). The petitioner, GOPAKUMAR V.G., faces a charge under Section 7(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1983 (Amendment 2018) for allegedly demanding Rs.10,000 from Aswathy (wife of Baiju) to issue a soil-removal pass. A vigilance trap led to the arrest; the defence claims the prosecution’s version is untrue and seeks production of CCTV footage from four nearby shop rooms to establish the sequence of events. The Trial Court had dismissed the Section 91 Cr.P.C. application to summon third-party stores for CCTV material, prompting this challenge. The petitioner cites Nitya Dharamananda v. Gopal Sheelum Reddy and Gokul Raj v. State of Kerala to support broad access to documents under Section 91, while the State counters that Section 91 is an enabling power to be exercised at appropriate stages, not for a roving defence fishing expedition. The court canvasses relevant authorities (State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi) about necessity and desirability, but ultimately holds that the Section 91 application cannot be entertained at the present stage. The Crl.M.C. is dismissed and CCTV production is not ordered.